The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
31. With the aforesaid observations C.O. 4047 of 2025 stands disposed of. There shall be no order as to costs. ( Om Narayan Rai, J. )
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
10.06.2026
Sl. No.: 6
Court No.6
BM
C.O. 4047 of 2025
KASHINATH MONDAL @ KASHINATH MANDAL AND
ORS.
VS
SRI UNNATI PATRA
Mr. Haradhan Banerjee, Ld. Sr. Adv.
Mr. Subrata Ghosh
Mr. Tanmay Chowdhury
Mr. Suresh Kumar Sahoo
... for the petitioners
Mr. Arindam Kundu
Mr. Aniket Nanda
Mr. Ashoke Nandy
Mr. Prasanta Sen
... for the opposite party
1.
This revisional application assails an order dated
April 22, 2024 and an order dated August 30, 2025
passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 1st
Court, South 24 Parganas at Alipore in Revocation Case
(O.S) No.03 of 2024. By the order dated April 22, 2024,
the learned Court has stayed the further proceeding of
letters of administration and by the order dated August
30, 2025, the petitioners’ application challenging the
maintainability of the revocation petition instituted by
the opposite party has been rejected.
2.
The opposite parties have filed Revocation Case
No.3 of 2024 seeking revocation of the letters of
administration issued by the learned Additional District
Judge, 4th Court at Alipore in favour of the petitioner in
Letter of Administration Case No.22 of 1967. In the said
case, the petitioners filed an application challenging
maintainability of the revocation case, inter alia, on the
ground that the said case was barred by limitation.
3.
Learned Trial Court has rejected the petitioners’
application challenging maintainability of the revocation
case by holding that the revocation case is maintainable
and that the same shall proceed for adjudication in
accordance with law.
4.
One Nirmal Kumar Mandal had applied grant of
Probate in respect of a Will executed by his father Sital
Chandra Mondal, since deceased. The said proceeding
for grant of probate became contentious and was
therefore registered as O.S Suit No.22 of 1967. The said
application for grant of probate was ultimately allowed
on contest by an order dated September 7, 1986 passed
by the learned Additional District Judge, 4th Court at
Alipore.
5.
It is the petitioners’ case that after the order
granting probate was passed the Executor of the will
died and as such the petitioners applied for grant of
letters of administration in the same O.S. Case No. 22 of
1967.
6.
Upon such application being made letters of
administration was ultimately granted to the petitioner
on August 8, 2018. Subsequently, the opposite party
filed an application for revocation of the said letters of
administration which was registered as Revocation Case
No.3 of 2024. The said case alleges that the Will in
respect
whereof
the
probate
and
letters
of
administration had been granted was a forged one.
7.
In the said case the petitioner took out an
application challenging maintainability of the revocation
case on two principal grounds. The first ground is that
the grant of Probate, which was the main grant was
never assailed and that being so, the challenge thrown
to the ancillary and consequential grant could not have
been entertained by the learned Court.
The second
ground is that the revocation proceeding is barred by
limitation.
Such application has been rejected by the
learned Trial Court.
Hence the present revisional
application.
8.
Mr. Banerjee learned Senior Advocate appearing
for the petitioners submits that the opposite party could
not have filed and maintained an application laying
challenge to the grant of letters of administration
inasmuch as the same was an ancillary grant tethered
to the principal grant of probate. In support of his
contention Mr. Banerjee relies on a Judgement of the
Hon’ble High Court at Bombay in Ramesh Nivrutti
Bhagwat vs. Dr. Surendra Manohar Parakhe, reported in
2001 SCC ONLine Bom 178.
9.
He next cites a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Ramesh Nivrutti Bhagwat vs. Dr.
Surendra Manohar Parakhe, reported in (2020) 17
Supreme Court Cases 284 to demonstrate that the
aforesaid judgement passed by the Hon’ble Bombay
High Court was upheld by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
10.
He further relies on a judgement of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of Manjula and Others vs. D.
A. Srinivas reported in 2026 SCC OnLine SC 831 to
contend that for the purpose of deciding as to whether a
plaint should be rejected under Order 7 Rule 11 of the
Code or not, along with the averments of the plaint the
documents referred to in the plaint which form the basis
of the plaint are required to be looked into by the
learned Trial Court.
11.
The next point which is urged by Mr. Banerjee is
that the application for revocation is hopelessly barred
by limitation. Mr. Banerjee contends that the application
is one to which the period of limitation prescribed under
Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963 will apply.
He
submits that in such view of the matter, even if it is
assumed that a challenge to the letters of administration
is otherwise maintainable, then also the opposite party
ought to have filed the application for revocation within
a period of three years from the date of accrual of cause
of action that is from the date of grant. It is submitted
that in this case the letters of administration was
granted in the year 2018 and as such the proceeding
initiated in the year 2024 is barred by limitation.
12.
In support of his above contention he relies on
the judgements of the Hon’ble Bombay High Court and
the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ramesh
Nivrutti
(supra).
Bhagwat
He
additionally
cites
a
judgement of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
Kunvarjeet Singh Khandpur vs. Kirandeep Kaur &
Ors. reported in (2008) 8 SCC 463 to assert that in
such proceedings Article 137 of the Limitation Act, 1963
applies.
13.
It is further submitted by Mr. Banerjee that the
learned Trial Court has committed a serious error in
rejecting the petitioners’ application challenging the
maintainability of the revocation case without deciding
the aforesaid issues.
14.
Mr. Kundu, learned advocate appearing for the
opposite party submits that the bar of limitation to the
revocation case filed by the opposite party would not
apply inasmuch as the probate case was concluded only
in the year 2018 and not prior thereto and the opposite
party got knowledge about the Will much later upon
summons of Title Suit No.928 of 2021 instituted by the
petitioner
before
the
learned
Civil
Judge,
Senior
Division, 10th Court at Alipore, being served on the
opposite party.
15.
He further relies on a judgement of a Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in the case of The Estate of Kalpana
Das Neogi represented by Ashoke Kumar Das vs. Dipali
Das Neogi & Ors. reported in 2012 SCC ONLine Cal
12647; in support of his contention that a probate case
would remain pending till such time the stamp duty is
fully put in/ paid.
16.
He further submits that the petitioners have
themselves put in the stamp duty in the year 2014
which is more than two decades after the grant of
probate. It is submitted that the revocation case is not
barred by limitation since the opposite party’s case is
based on fraud and the period of limitation in cases of
fraud begins to run from the date of knowledge.
17.
Mr. Banerjee learned senior advocate appearing
for the petitioner in reply submits that the opposite
party’s contention that he got knowledge about the Will
only from the suit instituted in the year 2021 is not
correct inasmuch as the opposite party duly appeared in
another suit being Title Suit No.93 of 2024 that had
been instituted by the petitioners before the learned
Civil Judge, Senior Division, 10th Court at Alipore
arraying the opposite party herein as a defendant no.8
in the said suit.
18.
Mr.
Banerjee
further
submits
that
during
pendency of the revisional application the opposite party
has filed another case being Revocation Case No.7 of
2025 seeking revocation of the grant of probate that was
done in the year 1986. He submits that such revocation
case would not be maintainable on the ground of
limitation as also on the ground that the appropriate
remedy thereagainst would be in the form of an appeal
under Section 299 of the Indian Succession Act
inasmuch as the grant was one on contest.
19.
Heard
Learned
Advocate
appearing
for
the
respective parties and considered the material on record.
20.
Having gone through the order impugned, this
court finds that the learned Trial Court has not adverted
to the aspect as to whether the proceeding for revocation
of letters of administration initiated by the opposite
party is barred by limitation or not. The aspect as to
whether in the facts of the case the issue of limitation
would be a pure question of law that can be decided
without adduction of evidence or a mixed question of
law and facts requiring evidence can be determined only
if the learned Trial Court refers to such issue. If upon a
meaningful
reading
of
the
plaint
along
with
the
documents which have been referred to in the plaint and
which form the basis of the plaint a conclusion can be
reached then the issue need not wait till the stage of
evidence as held by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
paragraph 29 (vi) of the judgment in the case of Manjula
&
Others
(supra)
after
discussing
several
other
judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court on the point.
21.
The other point urged that without challenging
the principal grant no challenge to ancillary grant would
be maintainable also does not appear to have been
answered by the learned Trial Court while dealing with
the petitioner’s application challenging maintainability
of the revocation case.
22.
It is noted that a challenge has also been
mounted to the grant of probate by filing Revocation
Case No. 07 of 2025. The learned Trial Court would be
required to take into consideration the effect of the said
Revocation Case No. 07 of 2025 while deciding the
challenge to the case for revocation of letters of
administration on the point that ancillary grant has
been challenged without challenging the principal grant.
23.
The judgement of the Hon’ble Bombay High
Court in the case of Ramesh Nivrutti Bhagwat (supra)
which was affirmed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court is a
clear authority on both the points that a proceeding
would not be maintainable if the principal grant is not
challenged and if the same is barred limitation under
Section 137 of the 1963 Act.
24.
the
While there is substance in the submission of
opposite
party
that
the
probate
proceeding
continued till such time that the stamp duty was paid
yet, the question as to whether the proceeding is barred
by limitation or not would still require to be answered
since the probate proceeding ultimately concluded in the
year 2018.
25.
Since the learned Trial Court has not adverted to
the aforesaid issues at all, it would not be proper for this
Court to decide the same at the first instance in exercise
of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution
of India. The same must be decided by the learned Trial
Court only at the first instance. As the said issues have
been left undecided, the order impugned deserves
interference.
26.
For all the reasons aforesaid, the order impugned
dated August 30, 2025 is set aside and the matter is
remitted to the file of the learned Trial Court to
reconsider the petitioner’s application challenging the
maintainability of Revocation Case (O.S.) 3 of 2024
afresh in accordance with law.
27.
It is made clear that this Court has not gone into
merits of the matter and that no opinion has been
expressed by this Court either on the maintainability of
any of the two revocation cases or on the merits of the
application
challenging
the
maintainability
of
the
Revocation Case No. (O.S) 3 of 2024. All points are left
open to be urged by the parties and to be decided by the
learned Trial Court in the light of the law governing the
field.
28.
It is further pointed out by Mr. Banerjee that by
an ex-parte order dated April 22, 2024 passed on an
application under Section 151 of the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 filed by the opposite party, the learned
Trial Court has stayed the further proceeding of letters
of administration.
29.
Since, the said application is still pending before
the learned Trial Court, this Court requests the learned
Additional District Judge, 1st Court, at Alipore to dispose
of the said application as expeditiously as possible and
preferably within a period of one month from the next
date fixed without granting unnecessary adjournment to
either of the parties.
30.
The parties shall be at liberty to pray for
preponment of the hearing of the said application which
prayer
may
be
considered
by
the
learned
Court
according to the convenience of the learned Court.
31.
With the aforesaid observations C.O. 4047 of
2025 stands disposed of. There shall be no order as to
costs.
( Om Narayan Rai, J. )
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review