Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKAYARA
SECOND APPEAL NO:598 OF 2025
Appeal Under Section 100 of CPC aggrieved by the Judgment and
Decree passed in A.S. No. 83 ot2022dated25-11-2025 on the file ofthe Gourt
of the I Additional District Judge at Kamareddy preferred against the judgment
and decree dated 17-10-2022 in O.S.No.24 ol 2015 on the file of the Court of
the Senior Civil Judge, Kamareddy
Between:
Kasarla Lingama @ Lingaiah, S/o. Late. Agamaiah Agaiah, Age. 70 Years, Occ.
Agriculture, R/o. H. No. 7-130, Lingapoor Village, Kamareddy Mandal and District.
...APPELLANT/ RespondenU Plaintiff
AND
1. Mohd. Lateef, S/o. Syed Razak (Died). (The suit againstthis respondent was
not pressed and was withdrawn .)
2. Mohd. Abid Hussain, S/o. Mohd. Hussain, Age. 49 Years, Occ. Private
Employee, Ri/ o. H. No. 5-8-52, Sri Ramnagar Colony, Kamareddy Town and
Djstrict, at present R/o. Opp. New Bus Stand, Near Raja Xerox, Kamareddy
Mandal and District.
3. Kasarla Rajender, S/o. Narayana, Age.47 Y.ears, Occ. Agriculture, FUo. H.
No. 5-52, Lingapoor Village, Tadwai Mandal, Kamareddy District.
4. Nimanala Linga Reddy, S/o. Rajireddy, Age. 45 Years, Occ. Agriculture, Rl/o.
Chandapoor Village, Tadwai Mandal, Kamareddy District.
...RESPONDENTS/ Appellants / Defendant No's. I to 4
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
restrain the respondents and their men from interfering with peaceful possession
and enjoyment of the petitiorer over the schedule property annexed to the petition.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRl. K. VENUMADHAV
Gounsel for the Respondents:
The Court at the stage of admission delivered the following Judgment :
)
IN THE
E'OR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUI(A YARA
No.598 of 2O25
- 2026
6TH DAY OF
Between:
I(a.sarla Lingama (@ Lingarah
..
.Appellant/ respondent/ plaintiff
and
Mohcl. Lateef and 3 others
...Respondents/appellants/defendant Nos. I to 4
JUDGMEN'f:
Heard Sri K. Venumadhav, learned counsel for the
appellant, {rn the question of admission. Perused the record.
2. This St:cond Appeal is preferred aggrieved by the judgment
ancl decret: in A.S.No.B3 of 20'22 passed by the learned
I Additional District Jr-rdge at l(amareddy (for short the learned
F-irst Appe[ate Court') dated 25.11.2025 setting aside the
judgment arrd decree in O.S.No.24 of 2O15 passed by the learned
Senior Civil Judge at Kamareddy (for short the learned Trial
Court') dat.ed 17.1O.2022, vvherein, in First appeal filed
-\
-/
challenging the judgment and decree passed in favour of the
appetlant herein granting perpetual injunction has been allou'ed,
consequently dismissing the suit for perpetual injunction.
3. The background facts of the case are that the
appellant/plaintiff herein claimed to be absolute owner and
possessor of agricultural land in Sy.No .2ll119 to an extent of
Ac.0.11 Gts., bounded on North: Agricultural land of Kasarla
Bhumawa, South: Agricultural land of Bhumaiah, East:
Agricultural land of Timakkapally Rajaiah and West: Agricultural
tandofKasar1aBhumavVasituatedatDevanpa11yVillage
of Kamareddy Mandal, Kamareddy District. The appellant's
father was the original owner and possessor of the suit schedule
property and after his death, said land was inherited by the
appetlant. UpoR inheritance, thq suit schedule property was
mutated in the narne of the appellant and he obtained loan from
PACCS by mortgaging the suit schedule property. The pahanies
for the years 1999 to 2015 show the ownership and possession
of the appellant over the suit schedule land. While SO, the
respondents who have no right over the suit schedule property
\_
.t
a
J
caused jnterference on OL.O7.2015 by creating fake documents
and therefore, a suit for perpetual injunction has been filed.
4. The respondents 2 to 4 filed written statements in sum and
substanc:e stating t.hat the agricultural land of Sy.No.2rl has
been converted into plots in the year r98T through Gp.Lp No.6/
1987 issrued by Grama Panchayat, Devanpally Village. The
respondent No.1 and respondent.No. 2 have purchased plot No.1
to an ext(lnt of 133.3 sq.yds. under the registered document No.
617 of 1{)89, dated 23.03.1989. Likewise, the respondent No.2
purchase,l plot No.2. Therefore, respondent No.1 and respondent
No.2 are in possession of the plots. The respondent No.2 left the
plots unconstructed. The appellant is not in possession and not
cultivatingl the said plots. Therefore, according to respondents
No.2, there is no can-rse of action for filing the suit. on similar
lines, resllondent Nos.3 and 4 filed vrrritten statement stating
that land in sy.No.211 was converted into plots and the
purchaserrs of plots are in possession and enjoyment. The layout
was issuecl vide GP LP No.o6/ lgST . The respondent Nos.3 and 4
purchased the plots under document Nos.3,1og of 2o1o and
31o9 of 2c'10, dated:31.05.2010 and are in possession. In fact,
respondent Nos.3 and 4 have constructed a house
bearing
H.No.5-82byavailingbankloan.Itisthecaseofrespondent
Nos.3 and 4 that the appellant is not in possession and
the suit
is to be dismissed.
5. The learned Trial court upon assessing the evidence
adduced by the appellant and the respondents has decreed
the
suit.TheappellantgothimselfexaminedaSPwlandthe
The
respondents got themselves examined as DWs 1 to 4'
appellant got marked Exs.Al to A19 and the respondents
got
in
exhibited Exs.Bl to B 17 J perusal of the documents_marked
.A', series on behalf of the appellant show that there are certified
copies of pahanies under Exs.Al to A6 for the years 1954-55
to
2012_13. Further there is a certified copy of Bhubharathi
certificate und.er Ex.A7. Ex.Ag is certified copy of Pahani
record, Ex.Ag is certified copy of
of RoR
pahani containing property
declaration certificate vide document No.2455 0f 1992
Ex.A12 is-the Release Deed vide document No.105 0f
Further, Ex.A13 is Rectification of release deed document
and
2015'
No'412
of 2015, Exs.Al4 and A15 are original title deed and
patta
passbook, Ex.A16 is certified copy of pahani for the year
2013,
o
IV
1l
Exs.A17 and A18 are certified copies of pahanis for the years
2Ol4 and 2015 and Ex.A19 is the valuation certificate. The
documents filed by the appellant primarily show existence of suit
schedule land and the Exs.Al2, A14 and A15 show title deed
and passbook in proof of ownership of the appellant. Pahanies
up to the year 2015 allegedly show the possession of the
appellant c,n account of mutation of his name in the revenue
records.
6. In resp,onse to the evidence adduced by the appellant, the
respondentr; got marked Ex.B1 attested copy of death certificate
of respondent No.1, Exs.B2 and 83 certified copies of pahanres
for the years 1986-87 and 1987-88, Exs.B4 to BlO sale deeds,
Ex.B11 Agr,:ement of sale-cum-GPA dated O9.O9.2O09, Exs.Bl2
to B 16 registered sale deeds and 'Ex.B17 Encumbrance
certificate. T'he documents marked by the respondents are meant
for demonstrating that the land in Sy.No.211 has been converted
into plots and sold to various individuals under Exs.B4 to 816.
7. Upon ccnsidering this evidence, the learned Trial Cotrrt
decreed the suit on two grounds. one is that Exs.Al4 and A15
show ownership of the suit schedule property by the appellant
and Exs. A2 toA6, A16 to A18 show possession. Further, there is
a.n inference made about probable interference by the
respondents. On account of proof of ownership in the form of
Exs.A14 and A15 and Pahanies showing possession, the suit has
been decreed. Aggrieved by said judgment and decree, the
respondents preferred . First Appeal before the learned First
Appellate Court vide A.S.No.83 of 2022-
8. The learned First Appellate Court examined the entire oral
and documentary evidence adduced by_ both the parties and
made observation with respect to admission by the appellant as
PWl that the respondents are claiming their plots to be situated
in his agricultural land. Further, an important point rvhich was
ignored by thq learned Trial Court is that respondent No.1 died
in the year 2OO9 whereas the suit for perpetual injunction
against him was filed in the year 2015 with an allegation that
responden-t No.1 along with respondent Nos.2 to 4 has interfered
with the possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule land
belonging to the appellant. Since there was categorical plea that
rqspondent No.l was actively involved in interference rvhen he
\
\V
\
,l
died six Jr€?rs prior to fiting of the suit, the learned First
Appellate 'lourt entertained a doubt about the interference, if
any, by tht-' respondents as not being proven. It is observed that
a suit is filed against a dead person alleging interference on his
behalf. Likewise, it is observed that there may not be any
interferenct: from the remaining respondents, but a false
allegation about causing interference is made against them. tt is
held that th ourgh there are documents in proof of possession and
ow,nership on behalf of the appellant, the consistent plea of the
respondents; in the r,r,ritten statements has been that the suit
schedule prcperty as mentioned in the plaint schedule does not
exist on gror-lnd. It is the consistent case of respondents that the
land in Sy.No.211 was converted into plots way back in the year
1987 and that the land of the appellant as per boundaries given
in plaint schedule is n.ot in existence. when such a plea was
taken, according to the learned First Appeltate court, heavy
burden lies cn the appellant to prove that his land as mentioned
in the plaint schedule exists. whereas, except the evidence of the
j
appellant as PWl, there is no other documentary evidence to
I
show the exir;tence of suit land as per boundaries given in the
I
1/
\
I
l
plaint schedule. In view of the admission by the appellant as
PWl that his tand is claimed by the respondents as part of their
plots, according to the learned First Appellate Court, there is
serious dispute with respect to title and therefore, a suit for mere
injunction simpticiter is not maintainable. Upon examining the
documentary evidence, it is held that the appellant is claiming
Ac.O.l 1 Gts. of land adjacent to the plots covered by Grama
Panchayat Layout vide GP.LP No.6/ lg87 and therefore, it is the
burden of appellant to establish his case but he cannot rely on
the weakness of the case of respondents. Irrespective of the fact
that the respond.ents have admitted that they are not concerned
with land in Sy.No.2Ll/19, but that their plots are situated in
Sy. Nos.2 7l I 13, 2lL /15, 2ll lL6 and 2Il l2l, the learned
Appellate Court set aside the judgment and decree passed by the
learned Trial iourt. Aggrieved by said judgment and decree, the
present Second Appeal has been preferred-
g. In the Second Appeal, the appellant has raised the following
substantial questions of law:
1) Whether the findings of the first appellate court are
perverse to that of the lindings of the Trial Court?
\I
\
I
;
t.
/
lv
{r
2) \Vhen the Trial Court framed 3 issues and had given
c:ategorical findings that, the plaintiff established his
case for granting the relief of injunction, the first
appellate cotrrt as against the said 3 issues framed 2
i:;sues contrary to the issues framed by the Trial
C)ourt and g,iving its own findings contrary to the
findings of the Trial Court, is it valid in Law?
3) Urhen the Plaintiff claimed the suit schedule land by
v;rtue of a title succeeded from his father, he proved
his title and possession and considering the said
d,rcumentary eviclence, the Trial Court decreed the
suit, granting perpetual injunction in his favour and
tkLe lirst ap;tellate court also observed that the
a<lmission of the D.W's.1 to 5 that they are no way
ccrrlce rned u'ith the land in Sy.No.2lL lg of
/
D,-.vanpally and they are concerned with only with the
land in Sy.No.2ll/13, 15, 16 and 21, giving a finding
that rhe plaintiff is not entitled for injunction by
sirnply obsen.ing that the defendant No.l was no
m()re and cannot believe the interference of the
defenclant Nos.2 to 4, is valid in Law when the specific
clzrim is against all the defendants including the
delendants no.2 to 4?
4) Wtren the plaintiff got knowledge about the death of
thr: defenclanl No. 1 after filing the suit, had
withdrawn the suit against the defendant No.1, the
sarne \rras perrnitted b_v the Trial Court and the suit
was contested by the defendant Nos.2 to 4, in such a
case u,hether the finding of the first appellate court
that, the alleged interference of the defendant No.l
whrr already died and the plaintiff is not entitled for
the injunction is valid in Law?
5) Wh:n the Plaintiff has specifically pleaded about the
inte rference of the def'endant No's. 2 to 4 also and the
l0
same is not disputed by them, on the other hand the
said defendants claimed that, the plaintiff in the guise
of land claimed by him in Sy.No.2ILl19, interfering
with their plots of land in Sy.No.2lIl13, 15, 16 and
21, is it not suflicient to say that, the defendants are
interfering with peaceful possession and enjoyment of
the plaintiff schedule land and the finding of the first
appellate court contrary to the same, is valid in Law?
6) When the First Appellate court failed to frame the
issue as provided under Section 39 of the Specific
Relief Act and without answering the same, when the
trial court framed the said issue and answered in
favour of the plaintiff by giving findings, granting the
relief of injunction, the same is set aside, is valid in
Law?
7) Whether the non consideration of material documents
placed by the plaintiff by First Appellate court is valid
in Law?
10. The above alleged substantial questions of law are about the
factual findings given by the Trial Court and validity of
contradictory findings given by the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court. The above questions do not raise any issue of
Iaw. The substantial questions of law at Sl.Nos.3 to 7 are not in
the nature of substantial questions of law, but rather in the form
of questions related to factual lindings given by the Trial Court
and the First Appellate Court. It is to be noted that for grant of
relie(of perpetual injunction, the appellant has to prove prima
\
lY
A
{
ll
facie case of legal possession, balance of convenience and
irreparable loss. In that regard, the documentar5r evidence
marked in 'A' series on behalf of the appellant does show prima
facie case of ownership and possession of the land by the
appellant from the year 2000 on paper. However, when there is a
counter plt:a by the respondents that land in Sy.No.2l 1 is
converted i.eto plots, there is a need to establish that the suit
sched.ule la:rd exists in the form of agricultural land and that the
same is in possession rtf the appellant. When there is a plea that
the land in Sy.No.2l 1 is converted into plots, the person who
approached the court i.e. the appellant has to prove that the
defence take'n by the respondents is false.
1. In the instant case, the admission by the appellant that the
respcindents are claiming land in suit schedule land as part of
i
their plots, shovgs that there is a dispute between the rival
parties about identity of land on ground. Such being the case,
the burden is on the appellant to prove his possession and
existence of suit schedule land on ground with the boundaries
shown in the plaint schedule. However, such evidence is not
adduced bef,:re the Trial court. The second important point
I
t2
observed by the learned Appellate Court is filing a suit for
perpetual injunction against a dead person alleging that a dead
person has interfered with the suit schedule land. Since a false
statement is made against a dead person about interference, a
genuine doubt is entertained about whether or not there was
interference by the remaining respondents. When the
respondents have filed documents in
'B' series showing
conversion of certain part of land in Sy.No.21 1 into plots and
construction of houses in said plots, production of pahanies will
in itself not prove the case of the appellant about being in
possession of land in S_y.No.2lLl19. Therefore, this Court is of
the considered view that there was no infirmity in the findings
given by the First Appellate Court while assessing the evidence
adduced by the appellant and the respondents before the Trial
Court. There are absolutely no questions of law to be considered,
much less substantial questions of law in the Second Appeal.
Therefore, the Second Appeal lacks merits and is liable to be
dismissed
12. In the result, the Second Appeal is dismissed at the stage of
admission. No costs.
R
lY
'i
/
/
s
li
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
SD/. A.V.S. PRASAD
TY REGISTRAR
DE
//TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The I Additional District Judge, at Kamareddy , Kamareddy Dist
2. The senior civil Judge at Kamareddy , Kamireddy Dist.
3. One CC to SRt. K. VENUMADHAV, Advocate tOpUCI
4. Two CD Copies
kul/Sa
w
a
I
/
HIGH COURT
DATED:06101t2026
<t:zi,
\rr['$
oL.
JUDGMENT
i
SECOND APPHAL No.598 ot 2025
I
i 2 Jfr|l A[?[
*
r'-.--^' r':1)
''J"
-,
.".'.;t---
a
DISMISSING TEIE SECOND APPEAL AT THE STAGE OF
ADMISSION WI'THOUT COSTS
G dReb
5{"'"
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review