The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Accordingly, the appeal suit is partly allowed and the judgment of the Trial Court in O.S.No.329 of 2022 granting preliminary decree declaring that the plaintiff is entitled to 3/8 share and declaring the settlement deed dated
27. 01.2012 in entirety as null and void is hereby set aside and the judgment and decree of the Trial Court is modified as hereunder:The preliminary decree is passed as follows:(i) the plaintiff is entitled to 1/8th share and the Trial Court shall divide the properties into eight equal shares and allot 1/8 th share to the plaintiff and the remaining share go to the first defendant on payment of necessary court fees. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis AS No. 1263 of 2025 Accordingly, this appeal suit is allowed as indicated above. Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition stands closed. Considering the relationship between the parties, there is no order as to costs. (N.SATHISH KUMAR J.)(R.SAKTHIVEL J.) 17-02-2026 dhk Index:Yes/No Internet:Yes To
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:MHC:710
AS No. 1263 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 17-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE R.SAKTHIVEL
AS No. 1263 of 2025 and CMP.No.32919 of 2025
1. Karuppannan
2. Gomathi
Priya Alias Saranya
Pavayee (Died)
Vs
Appellant(s)
Respondent(s)
PRAYER: Appeal Suit filed under Section 96 of Code of Civil Procedure, to
against the Judgement and Decree Dated 26.09.2025 passed in OS.No.329 of
2022 on the file of Additional District Court, Kallakurichi
For Appellant(s):
Mr.S.Kaithamalai Kumaran
For Respondent(s):
Mr.R.Raj Prasanna
JUDGMENT
(Judgment was delivered by N.Sathish Kumar J.)
Challenging the decree and judgment of the Trial Court granting
preliminary decree declaring that the plaintiff is entitled to 3/8 th share in the suit
schedule properties and separate possession and also declaring that the
settlement deed dated 27.01.2012 executed by Raja Gounder and third
defendant in favour of the first defendant is null and void, the present appeal has
been filed.
2.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
The parties herein are arrayed to as per their own ranking before
AS No. 1263 of 2025
the Trial Court. It is the case of the plaintiff that the plaintiff is the daughter of
the first defendant. The second defendant is another daughter of the first
defendant born through second marriage of the first defendant during the
subsistence of the first marriage. The second defendant was having a brother
named Raja had died intestate as bachelor. According to the plaintiff, the suit
properties are ancestral properties of the plaintiff and the first defendant. The
family geneology is as follows:Rasigounder
│────────────────────│
Karuppannagounder
Sengodagounder
│
Rajagounder --- Pavayee (Died) (D3)
│
Karuppannann (D1)
┌──────┴──────────┐
Thangamani (W1)
Sivagami (W2)
│
/
\
Priya (Plaintiff)
Gomathi (D2) Raja (Died)
3.
According to the plaintiff, the first defendant's great grandfather
Rasi Gounder has two sons namely Karuppagounder(first defendant grand
father) and Sengodagounder. They jointly sold their ancestral property in the
Namakkal district and purchased the suit properties through various sale deeds
in the year 1965 & 1968 and they were put into common hotchpot of the
ancestral nucleus and thereafter, on 11.09.1970, the said Sengoda Gounder and
Raja Gounder partitioned the ancestral joint family between themselves through
a registered partition deed. Hence, the plaintiff’s grandfather Raja Gounder
through the income derived from the ancestral property has purchased various
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
properties through three sale deeds of the year 1986 and the plaintiff’s father
Karuppannan purchased some properties through sale deeds dated 1988 and
1991. The said Raja Gounder and Karuppannan i.e. the 1st defendant has no
individual source of income to purchase any property. The said properties were
purchased from the income derived from the ancestral property. The said Raja
Gounder and his wife Pavayee Ammal has executed a settlement deed
pertaining to the suit property in the name of 1st defendant through a registered
settlement deed dated 27.01.2012. The said settlement deed is void as the
settlement mentioned properties are ancestral joint family properties and the
executors are not the sole owners to execute settlement deed. Hence, settlement
deed does not bind of affect the right of the plaintiff in any way. Hence, the
plaintiff being the daughter of the first defendant seeks allotment of 3/8th share
in the suit property and thus, the suit for partition and declaring the settlement
deed dated 27.01.2012 as null and void.
4.
The defendants admitting the relationship denied that the properties
are not ancestral properties and contended that the properties are self acquired
properties of the first defendant. The first defendant's father Raja Gounder and
his wife Pavayee, third defendant have jointly executed a settlement deed on
27.01.2012 in favour of the first defendant in respect of the first defendant's
father self acquired properties. Thus, the suit properties are separate properties
of the first defendant and the plaintiff has no right to claim any share in the suit
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
properties.
5.
On the basis of pleadings and evidence, the Trial Court framed the
following issues:
1) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for the relief of declaration to declare that she
has 3/8th share in the suit properties as prayed for?
2) Whether the plaintiff is entitled to declare the settlement deed executed by
the 3rd defendant in favour of the 1st defendant on 27.01.2012 vide
Doc.No.270/2012 is null and void?
3) To what other relief?
6.
On the side of the plaintiff, the plaintiff was examined as PW1 and
one Gurusamy was examined as PW2 and Ex.A1 to A13 were marked. Neither
oral nor documents were marked on the defendants side.
7.
After appreciation of evidence, the Trial Court decreed the suit
granting preliminary decree by declaring that the plaintiff is entitled to get 3/8
share in the suit schedule properties and separate possession of the suit schedule
properties and also declared that the settlement deed dated 27.01.2012 executed
by Raja Gounder and 3rd defendant in favour of the 1st defendant is null and
void. Aggrieved over the same, the present appeal suit has been filed by the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
defendants.
9.
The learned counsel for the defendants submitted that even
assuming that the properties are ancestral properties, the shares declared by the
Trial Court is not proper. Though, there is no evidence to show that the suit
properties are purchased out of the joint family nucleus, even assuming that the
properties are held to be joint family property, the plaintiff is at the most entitled
to 1/8th share in the property, not 3/8th share as declared by the Trial Court.
According to the learned counsel, Karuppanagounder/great grandfather and his
son Raju Gounder each are entitled to ½ share of the property. After the death of
Karuppanagounder, his half share devolves upon the Raja gounder and that half
share of Karuppanagounder will not be a coparcenery property, it will be a
separate property of the Raja Gounder, whereas, the plaintiff's father becomes a
coparcener in respect of the half share of Raja Gounder in the property, i.e., 1/4 th
share. In such case, the plaintiff will be coparcener only in respect of 1/8 th share
and not in entirety and other property is already dealt by Raja Gounder,
therefore, would submit that the Trial Court granting 3/8th share is not correct.
10.
The learned counsel for the plaintiff submitted that the character of
the properties is not disputed, however, with regard to the ratio of the share, the
plaintiff will abide by the order of the Court. According to him, though he has
calculated shares in different aspect, he would submit that as pointed out by the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
Court and the appellant, the plaintiff is entitled to 1/8th share.
11.
In light of the above submissions, now the following points arise
for consideration:
(i) Whether the Trial Court is right in granting preliminary decree of 3/8 share in
favour of the plaintiff?
(ii)Whether the Trial Court is right in declaring the settlement deed dated
27.01.2012 executed by Raja Gounder and 3rd defendant in favour of the first
defendant as null and void?
Points (i) & (ii)
12.
The relationship of the parties are not disputed. The plaintiff is the
daughter of the first defendant. The second defendant is another daughter of the
first defendant born through the second marriage of the first defendant.
Admittedly, there is a marital discord between the first wife and the father of the
plaintiff. The plaintiff and her mother left long back and they are residing
separately. The evidence of PW1 itself indicates that that they are residing
separately for more than 40 years. Be that as it may, now, she has sued his father
for partition claiming that the properties are ancestral properties.
13.
Though it is the contention that vide Ex.A13, sale deed dated
18.04.1966, the ancestral property has been sold by Karuppana Gounder and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
Sengoda gounder, later the said sale consideration has been used for purchase of
property under Exs.A1 and A2. Similarly, other properties were purchased out
of joint family nucleus. On perusal of Exs.A1, A2 and A13, we are not in
position to comprehend the submission of the plaintiff that only the ancestral
properties has been dealt, however, the evidence of PW1 in this regard that the
properties are ancestral properties were all along treated as joint family
properties and other properties purchased by Raja Gounder is also out of joint
family nucleus is not even denied in the cross examination. Therefore, once the
evidence of parties is not denied in the cross examination, the facts spoken in
the chief examination is deemed to have been admitted. Therefore, we have no
other go except to hold that the properties are ancestral properties. Further, it is
also to be noted that the defendants having taken a plea that properties are not
ancestral properties, they have not chosen to examine themselves. No oral or
documentary evidence adduced, therefore, when the plaintiff has clearly spoken
that all the properties are ancestral in character and when the same has not been
disputed, it has to be held that the properties are ancestral properties.
14.
In light of the above admitted facts, now, it has to be seen what is
the nature of share plaintiff is entitled for. Admittedly, even as per the plaint,
coparceners are one Rasigounder, Karuppannagounder, Raja Gounder and
Karuppannan, therefore, Karuppannagounder, grandfather of the first defendant
and Raju Gounder, father of the first defendant are equally entitled to half share.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
Though no exact date of death of Karuppannagounder is stated, the fact remains
that Karuppannagounder also died only later. His only son is Raja Gounder.
After the death of Karuppa gounder, his half share devolved upon his son Raja
Gounder, i.e., in half share of the property, the first defendant has become
coparcener along with his father. The Raja Gounder and Karuppanna Gounder
equally entitled to 1/4th share in the ancestral property. Now, the plaintiff in view
of The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 No. 39 of 2005, as there was
no partition effected by way of registered instrument, she will become a
coparcener along with her father only in respect of 1/4 th share in ancestral
property, accordingly, she is entitled to 1/8th share as co-parcener, whereas,
Karuppugounder's ½ share devolved on Raja Gounder remained as separate
property of Raju Gounder as per Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act. In fact,
he has dealt the property along with the third defendant in favour of the first
defendant by executing a settlement deed dated 27.01.2012 under Ex.A9. As
long as the property devolved on Raja Gounder from Karuppa Gounder as per
Section 8 of Hindu Succession Act, such property will be treated only as the
separate property and he has already dealt the property by executing a
settlement deed under Ex.A9.
15.
As far as the ancestral property is concerned, pursuant to the
settlement deed though possession may not be possible to the defendant, the fact
remains that the said document cannot be read as settlement, atleast it can be
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
taken as some transfer or alienation. The grandfather of the plaintiff dealt the
property which devolved on him as per Section 8 of the Act in favour of the first
defendant by way of registered settlement deed. Therefore, the plaintiff as
coparcener and be entitled to only 1/8th share in the coparcenery not beyond
that.
16.
In view thereof, the Trial Court is wrong in passing preliminary
decree declaring the rights of the plaintiff for 3/8 th share and setting aside the
entire document namely the settlement deed dated 27.01.2012 executed by Raja
Gounder and third defendant in favour of the first defendant as null and void.
17.
Accordingly, the appeal suit is partly allowed and the judgment of
the Trial Court in O.S.No.329 of 2022 granting preliminary decree declaring
that the plaintiff is entitled to 3/8 share and declaring the settlement deed dated
27.01.2012 in entirety as null and void is hereby set aside and the judgment and
decree of the Trial Court is modified as hereunder:The preliminary decree is passed as follows:(i) the plaintiff is entitled to 1/8th share and the Trial Court shall
divide the properties into eight equal shares and allot 1/8 th share to
the plaintiff and the remaining share go to the first defendant on
payment of necessary court fees.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
Accordingly, this appeal suit is allowed as indicated above.
Consequently, connected miscellaneous petition stands closed. Considering the
relationship between the parties, there is no order as to costs.
(N.SATHISH KUMAR J.)(R.SAKTHIVEL J.)
17-02-2026
dhk
Index:Yes/No
Internet:Yes
To
1.The Additional District Judge
Additional District Court, Kallakurichi
2. The Section Officer
VR Section
Madras High Court
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
AS No. 1263 of 2025
N.SATHISH KUMAR J.
AND
R.SAKTHIVEL J.
dhk
AS No. 1263 of 2025
17-02-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review