The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
8. In the instant case, the suit is for permanent injunction and admittedly, interim injunction has been granted on 19.11.2003 and nearly after 1 year and 7 months, the petitioners have taken out an application for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. Even as per the averments made in the petition, the respondent/plaintiff has stated that the petitioners/defendants are making arrangements to obliterate her cart-track or land and also proposed to encroach a further extent of 0.09 cents. Whereas, there is no averment in the plaint that there is an encroachment of land. It is a well accepted principle of law that an Advocate Commissioner should not be appointed to find out the possession of the property, which has to be adjudicated only by oral and documentary evidence. Under such circumstances, the order of the Lower Court suffers from material irregularity and it is not in accordance with the principles laid down in the above decisions. In the result, the order of the Lower Court is set aside. The Civil Revision Petition is allowed.”
8. In view of the reasons stated above and in light of the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble High Court of Madras as referred above, the order passed by the trial Court does not warrant any interference, as there is no material defect, bias, or perversity, and the same is in accordance with law.
9. Accordingly, the present Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs. As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010674772025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3329]
TUESDAY,THE TENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 117/2026
Between:
1. KARUMURI
@
KARUMUDI
VENKATARATNAM
@
VENKATARATNAMMA, W/O. SRINIVASA RAO, AGED ABOUT 48
YEARS,
OCC AGRICULTURE, R/O. GUNDLAPALLI VILLAGE,
MADDIPADU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. KOTA VENKATA RAO, S/O. KODANDARAMAIAH, AGED ABOUT 54
YEARS, OCC AGRICULTURE, R/O KURRAVANIPALEM VILLAGE,
KORLSAPADU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT.
2. JARLAMUDI KOTESWARAMMA, , W/O. RAMAJANEYULU. AGED
ABOUT 51 YEARS, OCC HOUSE WIFE, R/O. KURRAVANIPALEM
VILLAGE, KORISAPADU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT.
3. JAGARLAMUDI RAMANJANEYULU, S/O. RAMULU, AGED ABOUT
61 YEARS, OCC AGRICULTURE, R/B. KURRAVANIPALEM VILLAGE,
KORISAPADU MANDAL, BAPATLA DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,praying that in the
circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be
pleased topleased to allow the Civil Revision Petition by setting aside the
order dated 12/08/2025 in I.A. No. 531 of 2025 in O.S. No. 201 of 2024 on the
file of the Honble Principal Junior Civil Judge Court, Addanki, whereunder
dismissed the petition filed for appointment of Advocate Commissioner, and
pass
IA NO: 1 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased
pleased to stay of all further proceedings in O.S. No. 201 of 2024 on the file
of the Hon'ble Principal junior Civil Judge court, Addanki, pending the. Civil
Revision Petition and pass
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. KOTI REDDY IDAMAKANTI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. PENUMAKA VENKATA RAO
The Court made the following:
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION No.117 of 2026
ORDER:The revision petition is filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India
aggrieved by the order dated 12.08.2025 passed in I.A.No.531 of 2025 in
O.S.No.201 of 2024 on the file of Hon’ble Principal Junior Civil Judge, Addanki.
2.
The petitioner herein is the plaintiff and the respondents herein are
defendants in the Suit. For the sake of convenience of this Court, the parties are
referred herein as arrayed in the Suit.
3.
The petitioner herein/ plaintiff instituted a suit vide O.S.No.201 of 2024
seeking permanent injunction restraining the defendants, their men and agents
from interfering in any manner with plaintiff’s peaceful possession and enjoyment
of the suit schedule property. While so, the plaintiff herself filed I.A.No.531 of
2025 under Order 26 Rule 9 read with Sections 94 and 151 of CPC, seeking to
appoint an advocate commissioner to inspect the suit schedule property, to
observe existing physical features including boundaries for the suit schedule
property and to get schedule property measured with metes and bounds by the
mandal surveyor and to note down the other existing features if any that may be
brought to his notice and to file his report with plan to the court by answering the
work memos if any given at the time of his inspection.
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner/ plaintiff was
granted ad-interim injunction and the respondents filed vacate petition and
insisting for hearing the matter. He further submits that the petitioner acquired the
subject property through a registered Will deed dated 30.12.1995 duly executed
by her maternal grandmother in favour of the petitioner and her mother.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner/ plaintiff further submits that the
plaintiff acquired the D-schedule property under a registered Will dated
28.07.1993 covering part of the suit schedule property i.e., Ac.0.73½ cents in
Sy.No.896 of Ravunuthala Village duly executed by her maternal grandfather. He
also contended that there is another registered Will executed on 30.12.1995 by
maternal grandmother in favour of the petitioner and her mother with regard to the
rest of the land in Sy.No.896 of Ravinuthala Village. By which, she became
absolute owner and possessor of Ac.1.46½ cents in Sy.No.896/2 i.e., the suit
schedule property. Pursuant to same, the petitioner has been in peaceful
possession and enjoyment of the subject property. He further submits that after
considering the mode of acquisition by the petitioner, the trial Court was pleased
to grant ad-interim injunction in her favour. Since the defendants also claiming
rights over the property stating that they were in possession of the property, it is
most appropriate to note down the physical features of the suit schedule property
along with measurements to identify the property. Therefore, the petitioner herein
filed I.A. seeking for appointment of an advocate commissioner to mark and
measure the boundaries. But the trial Court, erroneously dismissed the said
application on the ground that the present application is filed in order to drag the
matter and to avoid the enquiry and hearing in respect of I.A.No.1321/2024,
where ad-interim injunction was granted. Therefore, the reasons assailed by the
trial court are contrary to the law and liable to be set aside.
6.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents submits that
since the petitioner claiming as the absolute owner and possessor of the subject
property filing the interlocutory application for appointment of an advocate
commissioner to note down the physical features and measurements is contrary
to her own pleading of possession over the subject property. He further submits
that the subject Suit is filed for bare injunction restraining the respondents from
interfering with the peaceful possession of the subject property of the petitioner.
Therefore, when a bare injunction was pleaded by the petitioner, it should be
decided basing upon the evidence and documents filed along with IA but cannot
be permitted to gather the evidence by way of commissioner report. He further
submits that having obtained an ad-interim injunction even after the filing of the
counter and after insisting on a hearing, the petitioner is now avoiding the hearing
of the said application. Only with a view to drag on the proceedings, the petitioner
has filed the present revision petition, contrary to her own admission before the
Court that she was in possession of the subject property. Therefore finding of the
trial court that the present application is filed only to drag the matter is rightly held
and the order of the trial court does not warrants any interference.
7.
Heard the submissions made by the learned counsel for both the parties,
admittedly, the suit itself is filed for bare injunction in respect of the suit schedule
property. It is settled law that once a Suit is filed for bare injunction, claiming as
absolute owner and possessor of the subject property, the petitioner cannot
sought for assistance of advocate commissioner for identification of the property
which itself indicates the validity of statement of her possession over the subject
property. It is settled principle that the party who has evidence claiming absolute
ownership
cannot
sought
for
collection
of
evidence
through
advocate
commissioner. In a suit for bare injunction, appointment of advocate
commissioner for physical identification of property cannot be allowed as held by
the Hon’ble High Court of Madras in Chandrasekaran and Ors. Vs. V.Doss
Naidu1, wherein, Paragraph Nos. 11, 17, 18, 21 and 22 of the said order are
extracted hereunder:
“11.
Whether the defendants are entitled to seek for
appointment of Advocate Commissioner to report about the physical
features and age of the house and the trees thereon is the main point
that arises for consideration in this civil revision petition.
17.
The Commissioner is sought for to note down the
existence of the house, age of the house, Guava trees and Coconut
trees and their age. Though the appointment of Advocate
Commissioner is sought for under the pretext of noting down the
physical features, indirectly it only seeks to find out the factum of
possession. The material issue in the suit is relating to the nature of
possession and lawful right of the defendants (if any). That material
issue of determining the possession cannot be left to the Advocate
Commissioner. The Appointment of Advocate Commissioner for
making enquiry about be adjudicated upon framing issues and
recording the evidence.
18.
Advocate Commissioner could be appointed only when
the Court is satisfied that on the materials available on record, the
party is not able to produce the desired evidence, the Court may
C.R.P.(PD) No.1968 of 2002, dt. 29.06.2005
assist the party to appoint the Advocate Commissioner to obtain the
evidence. If really, the defendants are in possession of the Suit
Property, the possession could not be proved by producing House
Tax Receipts, Adangal and such other desired oral evidence. When
the concurrent findings in the earlier litigation in O.S.No.6 of 1972
and A.S.No.164 of 1977 are against the Defendants, it would not be
appropriate to Appoint the Advocate Commissioner to note down the
existence of the house trees, so as to bring out the possession of the
Defendants. In the facts and circumstances of the case, particularly
in the light of earlier judgment in O.S.No.6 of 1972 and A.S.No.164 of
1977, there cannot be mechanical and indiscriminate appointment of
Advocate Commissioner. The contention that the defendants would
pay the remuneration and that the plaintiff may not prejudiced by
appointment of advocate commissioner has no force.
21.
The power under Article 227 of the Constitution is to be
exercised by the Court in its discretion and cannot be claimed as of
right by any party. Under Article227 of the Constriction of India, the
well settled position is:i)
The High Court’s power of revision under Article 227
of the Constitution would be restricted to interference in
cases of grave dereliction of duty flagrant violation of law,
and would be exercised most sparingly, in cases where
grave injustice would be done unless the High Court
interferes. It cannot be used as appellate or revisional power.
ii)
The power would not be exercised to correct and error
of fact or of law, not being an “error of law apparent on the
face of the record”, of an “irregularity or illegality of
procedure” unless such error affects the jurisdiction, or
involves
breach of the principles of natural justice; or to
reappraise the evidence.
iii)
Nor will the High Court, in exercise of this power,
substitute its own judgment for that of the inferior Court,
whether on a question of fact, or of law or interfere with the
intra vires exercise of a discretionary power, unless it is
“arbitrary or capricious” or unless there was no evidence at
all on which the finding on a “jurisdictional fact”. Where the
high court found fault with appellate court in declining to take
into consideration certain documents and took them on
record, instead of substituting its opinion on the merits of the
case, it should have remanded the matter back for the
opinion of the appellate court, it being the final court of fact.
iv)
Nor can the High Court, not being a appellate court,
pass an order of remand.
In short, as regards findings of fact of the inferior Courts, the
jurisdiction under Article 227 is limited to only examining whether the
subordinate court kept itself within the bounds of its authority in
reaching the findings of fact. Consequently, the High Court cannot
quash the judgment of Subordinate Court merely in the ground that
its findings of fact were erroneous, but could do so only if the
subordinate court came to its conclusion without any evidence or
upon a misreading of the evidence, or if its conclusions were
perverse.
There is nothing to suggest that the impugned order is perverse or
in violation of law warranting interference under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
22.
Upon consideration of the facts and circumstances of the
case, learned district Munsif has rightly declined to appoint Advocate
Commissioner to note down the physical features and there by
elucidating the factum of possession,. The impugned order does not
suffer from any material irregularity. This revision petition has no
remits and is bound to fail.”
In addition, Chinnathambi and Ors. Vs. Anjalai,2 the Hon’ble High Court of
Madras held as follows:
“We shall now consider some of the decisions rendered by
various Courts in this regard.
(i) In a decision reported in Puttappa vs. Ramappa (AIR 1996
Karnataka 257), in paragraph 3, the Court held as follows :
"3. …. a Commissioner cannot be appointed to find out
as to who is in possession of the property. Under Order
26, C.P.C., a Commissioner can be appointed to make
local investigation to investigate the facts or other
materials which are found in the property and to make a
report in regard to that matter to the Court. In a suit for
injunction the question as to who is in possession of the
property, is a matter to be decided by the Court on the
basis of the evidence, either oral or documentary, to be
adduced by the parties. That function cannot be
delegated to a Commissioner who cannot find out as to
who is in possession of the property. Accordingly, the
Lower Court was right in rejecting the application…”
(ii) In a decision reported in Union of India and another vs. M/s.Kripal
Industries (AIR 1998 Rajasthan 224), the Court in paragraph 18 has
held as follows :
“18. …power of appointment of Commissioner for local
investigation cannot be exercised by the Court to assist
party to collect evidence where it can get evidence itself.
In the case on hand the written statement has already
been filed, therefore, the disputed question of fact can be
adjudicated upon by the Court after framing the issues
CPR (PD) No.1721 of 2005 & CMP No.19371 of 2005, dt.22.09.2026
and recording the evidence of the parties. For such
purpose
assistance
of
Commissioner
is
neither
necessary nor justified…”
(iii) In a decision reported in Penta Urmila and others vs. Karukola
Kumarasamy (2005 (2) ALD 130), the Court in paragraph 6 has held
as follows:
“….6. In a suit for permanent injunction, the vital and
important issue is whether the plaintiffs are in possession
of the suit schedule land and whether there was attempt
by the defendant/s to interfere with such possession of
plaintiffs. The burden is entirely on the plaintiffs to bring
convincing and cogent evidence on record and for so
doing, it is not permissible for them to invoke Order XXVI
Rule 9, which is intended for difference purpose. Further,
if at this stage, Advocate Commissioner files a report, as
directed by Appellate Court with the assistance of the
Mandal Surveyor it would certainly amount to introducing
additional evidence which is ordinarily not permissible
unless proper application is made under Order XLI Rule
27 satisfying the conditions therein….”
In a matter relating to investigation in to the disputed question
of fact of possession, the power of appointment of Commissioner for
local investigation cannot be exercised by the Court to assist the
party to collect evidence, where the party can collect evidence by
himself. Thus in a case, where the claim of the plaintiff that, she is in
possession of the disputed property is denied by the defendants by
filing written statement, the disputed question of fact can be
adjudicated upon by the Court, after framing of issues and recording
evidence of the parties.
8. In the instant case, the suit is for permanent injunction and
admittedly, interim injunction has been granted on 19.11.2003 and
nearly after 1 year and 7 months, the petitioners have taken out an
application for appointment of an Advocate Commissioner. Even as
per the averments made in the petition, the respondent/plaintiff has
stated that the petitioners/defendants are making arrangements to
obliterate her cart-track or land and also proposed to encroach a
further extent of 0.09 cents. Whereas, there is no averment in the
plaint that there is an encroachment of land.
It is a well accepted principle of law that an Advocate
Commissioner should not be appointed to find out the possession of
the property, which has to be adjudicated only by oral and
documentary evidence. Under such circumstances, the order of the
Lower Court suffers from material irregularity and it is not in
accordance with the principles laid down in the above decisions.
In the result, the order of the Lower Court is set aside. The Civil
Revision Petition is allowed.”
8.
In view of the reasons stated above and in light of the ratio laid down by
the Hon’ble High Court of Madras as referred above, the order passed by the trial
Court does not warrant any interference, as there is no material defect, bias, or
perversity, and the same is in accordance with law.
9.
Accordingly, the present Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. No costs.
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall stand
closed.
___________________________________
VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA, J
Date:10.03.2026
BSP
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Civil Revision Petition NO.117 OF 2026
DATED:10.03.2026
Date:10.03.2026
BSP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review