Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
DATED : 3rd December, 2021
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH : THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
WP(C) No.44 of 2021
:
Petitioners
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim of Sikkim and Others
and
WP(C) No.45 of 2021
:
Petitioners
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
versus
Respondents
:
State of Sikkim of Sikkim and Others
Petitions under Articles 226 and 227
of the Constitution of India
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate with Mr. S. P. Mukherjee, Mr. S.
K. Pandey, Mr. Norden Tshering Bhutia and Ms. Rachana Shilal,
Advocates for the Petitioners.
Mr. Yadev Sharma, Government Advocate for the Respondents
No.1 and 2.
Mr. Anmole Prasad and Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocates with Ms.
Yangchen D. Gyatso, Mr. Sagar Chettri and Ms. Anita Pariyar,
Advocates for the Respondent No.3.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ORDER
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
WP(C) No.44 of 2021 and WP(C) No.45 of 2021 are
being disposed of by this common Order.
WP(C) No.44 of 2021
2.
The Learned Trial Court in Title Suit No.01 of 2017
vide its Order dated 21-07-2021, allowed 4 (four) witnesses of the
Defendant No.3, Respondent No.3 herein, to be examined through
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Video Conferencing (for short, “VC”). Assailing the Order in WP(C)
No.44 of 2021, Learned Counsel for the Petitioners advanced the
argument that the only ground raised by the Learned Senior
Counsel for the Respondent No.3 for examination of the 4 (four)
witnesses by VC was the prevalence of the Covid-19 Pandemic and
that it would not be possible for the witnesses, who are aged
between 60 and 82 years, to travel to Gangtok in the said
circumstances. Attention of this Court was drawn to the provision
of Rule 2 Clause (viii) of the VC Rules, 2020, which provides for
exceptional circumstances in which VC is to be held which includes
Pandemic, Natural Calamities and circumstances implicating Law
and Order and matters relating to the safety of the accused and
witnesses.
That, no exceptional circumstance has been made out
by the Respondent No.3 as required by the provision and it is now
an accepted position that the Covid-19 Pandemic has substantially
gone down in the country and travelling anywhere in the country is
not a risk factor.
That apart, one of the witnesses has left
Himachal Pradesh where he was living and travelled to the Tibetan
Settlement in Bylakuppe, Mysore, Karnataka, where the number of
Covid-19 cases was at the highest till recently.
If such a
circumstance did not restrain the witness from traveling there is no
reason for him or the other witnesses not to come to Sikkim for the
purpose of adducing evidence.
Walking this Court through the
Order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court dated 06-04-2020 in Suo Motu
Writ (Civil) No.05 of 2020 (In Re : Guidelines for Court Functioning
through Video Conferencing During Covid-19 Pandemic) it was
contended that the Hon’ble Supreme Court specified inter alia that
in no case shall evidence be recorded by VC without the “mutual
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
consent” of both the parties.
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
That, the “Rules for Video
Conferencing for Court, 2020”, notified by the High Court of Sikkim
on 12-05-2021, duly published in the Sikkim Government Gazette
No.102 dated 15-05-2020 (for short, “VC Rules, 2020”), at Rule 6
Clause 6.2 specifies that any proposal to move a request for video
conferencing should be preceded by a discussion with the other
party or parties to the proceeding, except where it is not possible
or inappropriate. That, no such discussions took place between the
parties. That apart, summons are to be issued to the witness who
is to be examined through VC which has not been done nor are the
Petitioners aware of it.
The provisions of Rules 7, 8, 12 and
Clauses 8.5, 10.2, 12.4 of the VC Rules, 2020, were also relied
upon while urging that it was essential to have the witnesses
physically present for their cross-examination.
It was further
contended that the witnesses speak only in the Tibetan language
and the translation process is time consuming as it is difficult for
the Advocates and the Learned Commissioner to understand the
answers of the witnesses. That, this difficulty to a large extent can
be mitigated by the physical presence of the witnesses and would
also safeguard against prompting by any interested person.
Besides, technical glitches cannot be ruled out.
That, 6 (six)
witnesses who were all senior citizens were physically present for
their evidence in April, 2021 when the second wave of Covid-19
Pandemic was at its peak and the Learned Commissioner had
effectively recorded their evidence duly complying with all Covid-19
protocols and this should have been duly considered by the
Learned Trial Court. That, as the Learned Trial Court allowed the
cross-examination of the 4 (four) witnesses of the Respondent
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
No.3 without the consent of the parties contrary to the orders of
the Hon’ble Supreme Court and the Rules framed by this Court, the
impugned Order deserves to be set aside and the physical presence
of the witnesses ordered for their cross-examination.
3.
Repudiating the submissions of Learned Counsel for the
Petitioners, Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.3
canvassed the contentions that the Respondent No.3 before the
Learned Trial Court while seeking to examine his witnesses via VC
had in accordance with the prescribed Rules and for propriety
consulted the Counsel on record for the Plaintiffs (Petitioners
herein). The Petitioners however indicated their insistence upon a
direct, personal cross-examination of the witnesses. That, this is
borne out by their response to the Petition of the Defendant No.3,
before the Learned Trial Court wherein the circumstance of such a
discussion was not denied by the Petitioners and it was specifically
averred that the Petitioners had not consented to the examination
of the witnesses through VC.
That, Rule 6 Clause 6.2 of the VC
Rules, 2020, no doubt requires that there has to be a discussion
with the other party or parties before a proposal is moved to
request for VC.
However, Rule 6 Clause 6.3 lays down that the
Court is the ultimate arbiter and should a request for VC be
received, upon hearing the concerned persons the Court will
exercise its discretion. Consequently, the Learned Trial Court after
hearing the parties on the application moved by Learned Senior
Counsel for the Respondent No.3 before it duly considered the
Petition and allowed it.
It was further urged that the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in its Order has categorically laid down that “until
appropriate Rules are framed by the High Court”, VC shall be
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
mainly employed for hearing arguments whether at the trial stage
or at the appellate stage.
Pursuant thereto, the VC Rules, 2020
have been framed by this High Court on 12-05-2020 and are
applicable to the present matter. That apart, the Supreme Court
vide its Order dated 26-10-2020 in IA No.48252 of 2020 in Suo
Motu Writ (Civil) No.05 of 2020 has while substituting sub-para
(vii) of Paragraph 6 of Order dated 06-04-2020 supra, held that the
VC in every High Court and within the jurisdiction of every High
Court shall be conducted according to the rules framed for that
purpose by that High Court.
Consequently, the VC Rules, 2020
now govern, Video Conferencing in all Courts within the jurisdiction
of this High Court. That, no applicable Rules have been bypassed
by the Respondent No.3 and consequent upon the refusal of the
Learned Counsel for the Petitioners for VC, the Defendant No.3
invoked the provisions of Rule 6 Clause 6.2 of the VC Rules, 2020.
Hence, the Order of the Learned Trial Court brooks no interference.
WP(C) No.45 of 2021
4.
In WP(C) No.45 of 2021, the Petitioners assail the
Order of the Learned District Judge dated 11-11-2021 in Title Suit
No.01 of 2017 vide which the Learned Trial Court rejected an
application filed by the Petitioners, under Section 151 of the Code
of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking to examine 15 (fifteen) local
witnesses of the Defendant No.3 before the examination of his 4
(four) witnesses through VC.
A second prayer related to
rectification of the address of the witness of Defendant No.3,
Respondent No.3 herein.
5.
After hearing the Learned Counsel for the parties, the
Learned Trial Court while allowing the second prayer supra, for the
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
first prayer observed that ordinarily it is for the concerned party to
decide the order of production and examination of his witnesses.
That,
it
is
only
in
special
circumstances
that
warrant
the
interference of the Court that the Court would exercise its
discretion to direct the examination of the witnesses in a particular
order and thereby rejected the prayer of the Petitioners.
6.
Before this Court, it is urged by Learned Counsel for
the Petitioner that should the said 15 (fifteen) witnesses be
examined before the 4 (four) witnesses are cross-examined it
would assist in expediting the trial.
7.
Resisting this argument, Learned Senior Counsel for
the Respondent No.3 relied on the ratio in Md. Sanjoy and Md.
Mahtab vs. The State of West Bengal
and Cagetan Rosaria Alveres vs.
Hakul , and put forth the contention that Section 135 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 (for short “the Evidence Act”) lays down the
law on the subject which entitles a party to present its witnesses
for examination according to its discretion. That, the Court ought
to be slow to interfere with this discretion of the party. Hence, this
prayer of the Petitioner requires no consideration.
8.
Having heard the Learned Counsel for the parties at
length, I have also perused the Orders dated 06-04-2020 and 2610-2020 of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Suo Motu Writ (Civil)
No.05 of 2020 as also the Rules for Video Conferencing for Courts,
2020, published in the Sikkim Government Gazette dated 15-052020 enforced from 03-06-2020 vide Notification No.87/HCS of the
same date and the impugned Orders dated 21-07-2021 and 11-112021.
1999 SCC OnLine Cal 371 : (2000) 1 Cal LT 230
1957 0 Supreme (Raj) 28 : 1957 0 RLW(RJ) 126
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
9.
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
Taking up the prayers made in WP(C) No.44 of 2021,
from the submissions put forth before this Court and also on
careful perusal of the Petitions filed before the Learned Trial Court
by the Defendant No.3 in Title Suit No.01 of 2017 it is apparent
that a discussion had indeed emanated between the Counsel for
the Defendant No.3 and the Counsel for the Petitioners.
This is
fortified by the averments made in the Petition filed by the
Defendant No.3 on 22-04-2021 before the Learned Trial Court
which is reproduced hereinbelow;
“17.
That in accordance with the prescribed rules,
the Defendant No.3 had in all propriety
consulted the counsel for the plaintiffs through
his own counsel. However, the plaintiffs have
indicated their insistence upon a direct,
personal cross examination of the witnesses
aforesaid putting not only the witness into peril
but themselves as well.
The petitioner
respectfully submits that it is neither feasible
nor fair to the said witnesses to be subjected to
such a hazardous method of examination
during the current pandemic.”
In response, the Petitioners filed their reply dated 30-062021, the relevant portion of which is as follows;
“18.
10.
That in reply to paragraph 17 it is submitted
that in view of the submission made in
paragraphs 8 & 15 above, the plaintiffs would
not consent for examination of witness through
video conferencing.”
Pursuant to this refusal, the Defendant No.3 has
correctly taken refuge of the provision of Clause 6.3 of Rule 6 of
the VC Rules, 2020 and the Court has correctly exercised its
jurisdiction in considering the matter and passing the impugned
Order.
While examining the correctness of the Order of the
Learned Trial Court it is necessary to notice that the Supreme
Court in Suo Motu Writ (Civil) No.05 of 2020 dated 06-04-2020
ordered as follows;
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
“6.
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
…………………………………………………………
……………………………………………………………….
vii.
Until appropriate rules are framed by the High
Courts, video conferencing shall be mainly
employed for hearing arguments whether at the
trial stage or at the appellate stage. In no case
shall evidence be recorded without the mutual
consent of both the parties by video
conferencing.
If it is necessary to record
evidence in a Court room the presiding officer
shall ensure that appropriate distance is
maintained between any two individuals in the
Court.
……………………………………………………………….”
Vide its Order dated 26-10-2020, the Supreme Court was
pleased to substitute sub-para (vii) of Paragraph 6 of the Order
dated 06-04-2020 as follows;
“……………………………………………………………….
“We propose to substitute sub-para (vii) of
Paragraph 6 with the following;
The Video Conferencing in every High Court
and within the jurisdiction of every High Court shall be
conducted according to the Rules for that purpose
framed by that High Court. The Rules will govern
Video conferencing in the High Court and in the
district courts and shall cover appellate proceedings
as well as trials.
……………………………………………………………….”
Thus, on the anvil of the Order extracted supra, we need
not be concerned any further with the Orders of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court on Video Conferencing considering that in the
interregnum VC Rules, 2020, were notified by this High Court in
compliance of the direction in the Orders supra.
11.
This
Court
is
aware
that
Notification
bearing
No.55/Judl./HCS and Circular bearing No.20/Confdl./HCS, both
dated 28-10-2021, were issued whereby physical hearing in this
Court and in the Subordinate Courts of Sikkim, respectively,
resumed w.e.f. 15-11-2021, but at the same time it is relevant to
notice
that
Covid-19
Pandemic
is
still
prevalent
although
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
undoubtedly the cases have abated considerably. This Court is also
seized of the news that a new variant of the virus has emerged and
precautions are being taken worldwide against it including in our
country. The Learned Trial Courts and this High Court from April
2020 up to 14-11-2021 were consistently conducting matters
through VC, minor glitches may not have allowed seamless
proceedings yet we have successfully traversed through a variety
of matters placed before us and dispensed justice.
The Learned
Trial Courts have also examined nth number of witnesses through
VC. In the circumstances enunciated above, it would be regressive
to speculate that the witnesses of the Respondent No.3 cannot be
examined by VC and that their physical appearance is imperative to
ensure fairness and resolve any issues that may arise during the
recording of evidence.
The language barrier and difficulties in
translation will persist even if the witnesses physically appear
because the Tibetan language is unknown and unfamiliar to the
Counsel for the parties, this was indeed the specific reason why the
Translators were required and have been appointed, it is no one’s
case that they have failed to execute the task that they have been
entrusted with or that they have impeded justice in any manner.
12.
Coming to the question of technical glitches, the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra vs. Dr. Praful B.
Desai
relied on by Learned Counsel for the Respondent No.3 has
dealt in detail with VC and examining of witness by VC. Although it
was pronounced years before the Covid-19 Pandemic struck and
relates to a criminal matter, undoubtedly the principles thereof will
(2003) 4 SCC 602
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
also apply with equal vigour to a civil dispute. It is thus beneficial
to extract the following paragraphs;
“19. At this stage we must deal with a
submission made by Mr Sundaram. It was submitted
that video-conferencing could not be allowed as the
rights of an accused, under Article 21 of the
Constitution of India, cannot be subjected to a
procedure involving “virtual reality”. Such an
argument displays ignorance of the concept of virtual
reality and also of video-conferencing. Virtual reality
is a state where one is made to feel, hear or imagine
what does not really exist. In virtual reality, one can
be made to feel cold when one is sitting in a hot
room, one can be made to hear the sound of the
ocean when one is sitting in the mountains, one can
be made to imagine that he is taking part in a Grand
Prix race whilst one is relaxing on one's sofa etc.
Video-conferencing has nothing to do with virtual
reality. Advances in science and technology have now,
so to say, shrunk the world. They now enable one to
see and hear events, taking place far away, as they
are actually taking place. To take an example, today
one does not need to go to South Africa to watch
World Cup matches. One can watch the game, live as
it is going on, on one's TV. If a person is sitting in the
stadium and watching the match, the match is being
played in his sight/presence and he/she is in the
presence of the players. When a person is sitting in
his drawing room and watching the match on TV, it
cannot be said that he is in the presence of the
players but at the same time, in a broad sense, it can
be said that the match is being played in his
presence. Both, the person sitting in the stadium and
the person in the drawing room, are watching what is
actually happening as it is happening. This is not
virtual reality, it is actual reality. One is actually
seeing and hearing what is happening. Videoconferencing is an advancement in science and
technology which permits one to see, hear and talk
with someone far away, with the same facility and
ease as if he is present before you i.e. in your
presence. In fact he/she is present before you on a
screen. Except for touching, one can see, hear and
observe as if the party is in the same room. In videoconferencing both parties are in the presence of each
other. The submissions of the respondents' counsel
are akin to an argument that a person seeing through
binoculars or telescope is not actually seeing what is
happening. It is akin to submitting that a person seen
through binoculars or telescope is not in the
“presence” of the person observing. Thus it is clear
that so long as the accused and/or his pleader are
present when evidence is recorded by videoconferencing that evidence is being recorded in the
“presence” of the accused and would thus fully meet
the requirements of Section 273 of the Criminal
Procedure Code. Recording of such evidence would be
as per “procedure established by law”.
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
20. Recording
of
evidence
by
videoconferencing also satisfies the object of providing, in
Section 273, that evidence be recorded in the
presence of the accused. The accused and his pleader
can see the witness as clearly as if the witness was
actually sitting before them. In fact the accused may
be able to see the witness better than he may have
been able to if he was sitting in the dock in a crowded
courtroom. They can observe his or her demeanour.
In fact the facility to playback would enable better
observation of demeanour. They can hear and rehear
the deposition of the witness. The accused would be
able to instruct his pleader immediately and thus
cross-examination of the witness is as effective, if not
better. The facility of playback would give an added
advantage whilst cross-examining the witness. The
witness can be confronted with documents or other
material or statement in the same manner as if
he/she was in court. All these objects would be fully
met when evidence is recorded by video-conferencing.
Thus no prejudice, of whatsoever nature, is caused to
the accused. Of course, as set out hereinafter,
evidence by video-conferencing has to be on some
conditions.”
[emphasis supplied]
13.
In light of the above detailed discussions, in my
considered opinion, nothing erroneous emanates in the assailed
Order dated 21-07-2021 of the Learned Trial Court which is
accordingly upheld.
14.
So far as WP(C) No.45 of 2021 is concerned, Sections
135 and 138 of the Evidence Act provide as follows;
135. Order of production and examination of
witnesses.—The order in which witnesses are
produced and examined shall be regulated by the law
and practice for the time being relating to civil and
criminal procedure respectively, and, in the absence
of any such law, by the discretion of the Court.
138. Order of examinations.—Witnesses shall
be first examined-in-chief, then (if the adverse party
so desires) cross-examined, then (if the party calling
him so desires) re-examined. ……………………………
15.
Undoubtedly, if any exigency or circumstances so
require the law provides that the Court shall exercise its discretion,
otherwise it shall be for the party concerned to decide which
witness he seeks to examine first and cannot be based on the
dictates of the opposing party or for their convenience.
In this
WP(C) Nos.44 of 2021 and 45 of 2021
The Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others
vs.
The State of Sikkim and Others
regard also I have to agree with the finding of the Learned Trial
Court and hence the impugned Order dated 11-11-2021 warrants
no interference.
16.
Parties shall comply with the directions in the impugned
Orders dated 21-07-2021 and 11-11-2021.
17.
Resultant, WP(C) No.44 of 2021 and WP(C) No.45 of
2021 stand dismissed and disposed of accordingly. Pending
application(s), if any, stand also disposed of.
( Justice Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
03-12-2021
Approved for reporting : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review