The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Thus, in light of the submissions of learned Counsel for the Petitioners and the Respondent No.3 and in consideration of the peculiar circumstances of the instant matter, although the prayer of learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners seeking ten days for further cross-examination cannot be allowed, however in the interest of justice, I am of the considered opinion that a total period of ten days can be allowed for cross-examination which includes the four days in which the witness has already been examined. Hence, the Petitioners are allowed an additional six days time for further cross-examination of the Respondent No.3 inclusive of the day it commences and concludes. The dates shall be fixed as deemed fit by the learned trial Court duly taking into consideration the prevailing Covid-19 pandemic and the precautions necessarily to be observed. It is expected and trusted that the Petitioners will not venture into irrelevant, Page 6 Virtual Court No. 2 Record of Proceedings random and manifestly vexatious questions during cross- examination.
14. The impugned Order dated 12.02.2020 passed by the learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Title Suit No.01 of 2017 (Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others) is modified to the extent above.
15. Writ Petition disposed of accordingly as also all other pending applications.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
W.P.(C) No. 04 of 2020
KARMAPA CHARITABLE
TRUST & OTHERS
PETITIONERS
VERSUS
STATE OF SIKKIM & OTHERS
RESPONDENTS
Date: 15.06.2020
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
For Petitioners
For Respondents
R-1 & R-2
R-3
Mr. B. Sharma, Senior Advocate.
Mr. K.K. Rai, Senior Advocate.
Mr.
Shiv
Kumar
Pandey,
Advocate.
Mr. N.T. Bhutia, Advocate.
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional
Advocate General.
Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen, Assistant
Government Advocate.
Mr. N. Rai, Senior Advocate.
Mr.
Anmole
Prasad,
Senior
Advocate.
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, Advocate.
Ms.
Yangchen
D.
Gyatso,
Advocate.
Mr. Sagar Chettri, Advocate.
O R D E R (ORAL)
1.
Pursuant to the Order of this Court dated 24.03.2020,
copy of the Petition has been served upon the CaveatorRespondent No.3 who had filed Caveat Petition No.02 of 2020.
Page 1
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
2.
All Respondents are represented by their respective
learned Counsel today. They waive formal Notice.
3.
I.A. No.01 of 2020, a stay application, has also been
filed by the Petitioners along with the Writ Petition seeking stay
of the impugned Order, dated 12.02.2020.
4.
Heard learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners and
Respondent No.3.
5.
Learned Additional Advocate General for Respondents
No.1 and 2 had no submissions to make.
6.
The Petitioners herein are aggrieved by the Order
dated 12.02.2020, passed by the learned District Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok, in Title Suit No.01 of 2017 (Karmapa
Charitable Trust and Others vs. State of Sikkim and Others) inter
alia on grounds that it was ordered as follows;
“Given the facts and circumstances, it would
suffice if the Plaintiffs are given three(03) days time
for the cross-examination of the Defendant No.3.”
7.
Learned Senior Counsel Mr. K.K. Rai, while assailing
the Order, canvassed the contention that the evidence of
Respondent No.3 (Defendant No.3 in Title Suit No.01 of 2017
supra) is being recorded before the learned Commissioner, a
retired District Judge. The witness is only conversant in the
Tibetan vernacular and the cross-examination is being conducted
with the aid of two Interpreters viz. Mr. Jigmee Wangchuk
Bhutia, Post Graduate Teacher, Enchey Senior Secondary School,
Gangtok
and
Mr.
Ugen
Tsewang,
Ex-Translator,
Namgyal
Institute of Tibetology, Gangtok. Consequently, the recording of
the evidence of Respondent No.3 in the said circumstances
becomes protracted as it has to be translated from the Tibetan
vernacular to English and then only recorded thereby requiring
substantial amount of time. The learned Commissioner, during
cross-examination of the Respondent No.3, has never observed
Page 2
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
that the Petitioners had asked any irrelevant questions. However,
the impugned Order came to be passed and the curtailment of
time for cross-examination of Respondent No.3 to three days
would lead to miscarriage of justice and is contrary to the basic
tenets of fair trial, hence the instant application praying that the
impugned Order be set aside and ten days’ time be granted to
the Petitioners to cross-examine the Respondent No.3.
8.
Learned Senior Counsel for the Respondent No.3, for
his part, advanced the argument that the witness was being
subjected to harassment by prolonged cross-examination and
irrelevant questions being put to him. The cross-examination is
sought to be continued only for the purpose of badgering the
witness by asking pointless and arbitrary questions when, in fact,
the cross-examination has covered the main aspects of the case
and the Petitioners do not require more than a day for recording
further evidence. Such dilatory tactics has humiliated and
traumatized the Respondent No.3 as scant consideration is paid
to the fact that he is a senior citizen and in frail health. In fact,
the learned trial Court has correctly considered that the witness
has already been examined for four days and therefore permitted
three days further time for his cross-examination. That, the
learned trial Court is clothed with powers to control the time limit
for the cross-examination for which reliance was placed on the
ratiocinations of R.K. Chandolia vs. CBI & Ors.1, D.P. Sinha vs. Brig.
E.T. Sen (Retired)2, Dineshbhai Zaverbhai Vora vs. State of Gujarat 3
and Yeshpal Jashbhai Parikh vs. Rasiklal Umedchand Parikh 4. That,
in consideration of the above submissions, the petition deserves
a dismissal.
2012 SCC Online Del 2047
1969 SCC Online Del 201
2018 Cri.LJ 1588
AIR 1955 Bombay 318
Page 3
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
9.
I have carefully considered the rival submissions of
learned Counsel at length. I have also perused the orders of the
learned Commissioner, cross-examination of the Respondent
No.3 and the impugned Order, for the instant purpose, including
the citations made at the Bar.
10.
It may relevantly be noticed that the essence of cross-
examination is that it is the interrogation by the Advocate of one
party, of a witness called by his adversary, either with the object
of obtaining admissions favourable to his cause or to discredit
the witness. All questions which are asked with a view to assail
the evidence-in-chief are permissible and no provision of law
requires cross-examination to be confined to what is only
volunteered by the witness. The objective of cross-examination is
thus to elicit the truth and also detect the falsehood in the
evidence-in-chief. It thus becomes the bounden duty of the
Counsel towards his client to take necessary steps in this context
to uphold what is right and just and to expose a dishonest
witness. At this juncture, reference may be made to Section 151
of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (“Evidence Act”) which provides
that the Court may forbid any questions or inquiries which it
regards as indecent or scandalous, although such questions or
inquiries may have some bearing on the questions before the
Court, unless they relate to facts in issue or to matters necessary
to be known in order to determine whether or not the facts in
issue existed. Thus, Section 151 of the Evidence Act prohibits
questions to elicit indecent or scandalous imputations from the
witnesses in the guise of shaking the credibility of any witness
and every trial Court is empowered to forbid such questions.
Section 152 of the Evidence Act requires that the Court shall
forbid any questions which appears to be intended to insult or
annoy, or which, though proper in itself, appears to the Court
needlessly offensive in form. This Section is self-explanatory and
Page 4
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
the learned trial Court can forbid questions which tend to offend
public decency and are intended to insult or annoy the witness.
11.
It is not the case of the Respondent No.3 that
scandalous or indecent questions were put to the witness nor has
there been any intention to insult the witness although the crossexamination being conducted may be cumbersome to him. The
allegation against the Petitioners is that the witness is being
badgered
and
the
cross-examination
being
prolonged
unnecessarily. This allegation evidently has no legs to stand. The
object of cross-examination has already been elucidated supra. It
is not denied that the witness is only familiar with the Tibetan
vernacular as a result of which the evidence deposed by him is
required to be translated for the benefit of the parties and then
only recorded. It is obvious that this process would be longwinded and would involve a substantial amount of time.
Admittedly, the evidence is being recorded before the learned
Commissioner, a retired District Judge. As pointed out by learned
Senior Counsel for the Petitioners, the learned Commissioner has
made no remark that the Petitioners have asked irrelevant
questions during the cross-examination of the Respondent No.3.
In fact, at this juncture, it would be relevant to extract the Order
of the learned Commissioner, dated 23.11.2019, which inter alia
reveals as follows;
“Date is fixed for further evidence of the
defendant No.3. However, the same could not be
taken up for the reason that as the defendant No.3
who has to attend some important religious
conference at Dharamsala, he will not be able to
attend for his cross-examination till March, 2020.
Shri Chezung Bhutia, the Constituted Attorney
of the defendant No.3 filed an application for
adjournment with a copy to the learned Counsel for
the plaintiffs.
In the adjournment petition, it is stated under
para 1 that the matter has been fixed for evidence of
the defendant No.3 at Siliguri commencing from
19.11.2019 till 22.11.2019 as mutually settled
between
the
respective
Counsels
with
the
Page 5
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
Commissioner. This statement is not correct as I
was not told that the evidence of the defendant No.3
would be held only from 19.11.2019 till 22.11.2019.
It is fact that I was informed that the evidence
would commenced (sic) from 19.11.2019 at Siliguri
but no date was fixed or decided that same should
be completed by 22.11.2019.”
(Emphasis supplied)
This is being extracted to indicate the conduct of the Respondent
No.3 which is not above board.
12.
The
records
reveal
that
the
evidence
of
the
Respondent No.3 commenced from 19.11.2019, the crossexamination commenced on the same day and continued for four
days till 22.11.2019. This Court is conscious and aware that the
learned trial Court is clothed with powers to limit the time frame
for cross-examination. Nevertheless the peculiar facts and
circumstances of the instant matter and the stakes involved have
to be taken into consideration which therefore dictates that
parties do not get the impression of being short-changed.
13.
Thus, in light of the submissions of learned Counsel
for the Petitioners and the Respondent No.3 and in consideration
of the peculiar circumstances of the instant matter, although the
prayer of learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners seeking ten
days for further cross-examination cannot be allowed, however in
the interest of justice, I am of the considered opinion that a total
period of ten days can be allowed for cross-examination which
includes the four days in which the witness has already been
examined. Hence, the Petitioners are allowed an additional six
days time for further cross-examination of the Respondent No.3
inclusive of the day it commences and concludes. The dates shall
be fixed as deemed fit by the learned trial Court duly taking into
consideration
the
prevailing
Covid-19
pandemic
and
the
precautions necessarily to be observed. It is expected and
trusted that the Petitioners will not venture into irrelevant,
Page 6
Virtual Court No. 2
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings
random
and
manifestly
vexatious
questions
during
cross-
examination.
14.
The impugned Order dated 12.02.2020 passed by the
learned District Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Title Suit No.01
of 2017 (Karmapa Charitable Trust and Others vs. State of
Sikkim and Others) is modified to the extent above.
15.
Writ Petition disposed of accordingly as also all other
pending applications.
16.
Copy of this Order be forwarded to the learned trial
Court for information and compliance.
Judge
15.06.2020
ml
Approved for reporting: Yes
Page 7
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review