Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
WP(C) No. 55/2018
KARMA TENZING AND ORS.
PETITIONER (S)
VERSUS
THE CHIEF OF THE ARMY STAFF AND ORS.
RESPONDENT (S)
For petitioners
:
Mr. Jorgay Namka, Advocate.
For respondents no.
R-1, R-2 and R-6
:
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Govt. Counsel.
For respondents no.
R-3 and R-4
:
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Addl. Advocate General.
Mr. Hissey Gyaltsen, Asst. Govt. Advocate.
Ms. Karma Yangchen Bhutia, Legal Officer, Land
Revenue and Disaster Management Department.
Date: 19/03/2021
CORAM :
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE JITENDRA KUMAR MAHESHWARI, CJ.
…
Invoking the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India,
the Petitioners have filed this petition seeking following reliefs:“Under the above facts and circumstance, it is therefore, prayed that this
Hon’ble Court may be pleased to admit this petition, call for records and issue
rule calling upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a Writ of Certiorari
and/or appropriate Writ/Order or Direction should not be issued directing
Respondent No. 3 and 4 to complete the process of acquisition of the Petitioners
land and/or pass any other order/s /directions as your Lordships deem fit and
proper for the ends of Justice.
In the alternative direct the Respondents to compensate the Petitioners.”
2.
On perusal, it is found some facts are not in-disputed in the case. The
Notification for compulsory acquisition of the lands belonging to the
Petitioners was issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (in
short, Old Act) on 05.10.2013. On account of commencement of the Right to
Fair Compensation to Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
1|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter referred as New Act) w.e.f. 01.01.2014,
the old Notification of Section 4 of the old Act was came to be lapsed in view
of Section 24 of the New Act.
3.
It is also not in dispute that after commencement of the New Act a
fresh Notification for compulsory acquisition of petitioners’ land was issued
on 25.11.2016 under Section 11 of the New Act. The acquisition of the said
land was for the purpose of “Creation of Logistic Infrastructure for Troops”.
Later correspondence reflects that vide letter No. 7379/Rab/123/AC/QM
dated 04.01.2017, a request was made by Lt. Col., OIC, ASW for CO, 17th
Mtn.
Div.
Ord
Unit,
Pin-909417,
C/o
APO
to
the
Deputy
Secretary/Acquisition, Land and Revenue Disaster Management Department,
Government of Sikkim for de-acquisition of the land. As per Annexure R-7
dated 04.05.2019, the Deputy Secretary, Land and Revenue Department
informed Lt. Colonel SA Kalam, OIC ASW for CO, 17th Mtn Div Ord Unit, C/0
99 APO, Pin-909417 that the procedure of de-acquisition is under process
and the District Collector, South is in the process of assessment of the
damage by way of compensation payable to the land owners as per Section
93 of the New Act and same shall be conveyed on finalization. Thereafter,
vide letter dated 01.11.2017, the amount of compensation has been
calculated to the tune of Rs. 1,89,09,777/- and informed to the respondents
no. 1 and 2. It is not in dispute that the said amount has not been paid by
them, in lieu of responding the letter of the Collector dated 24.05.2017 vide
reply letter dated 27.06.2017.
4.
It is also a fact that the Order of determination of the compensation as
passed by the Government of Sikkim through the Land Revenue and
Disaster
Management
Department
dated
01.11.2017
has
not
been
represented or assailed by the respondents no. 1 and 2 taking recourse of
2|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
law, therefore, it has become final. In the said context, it is clear that the
relief No. 1 as prayed in the Writ Petition seeking direction against
respondents no. 3 and 4 to complete the process of acquisition has outlived
its utility on account of the letter referred by respondents no. 1 and 2 dated
22.04.2017 for de-acquisition and due to further correspondence made on
24.05.2017 and 01.11.2017 of the State Authorities, therefore, the first
relief as prayed for in the Writ Petition has now rendered infructuous.
5.
So far as the second relief prayed in alternative to first relief directing
respondents to compensate the petitioners in the opinion of the Court is
surviving because after initiating the proceedings under Section 11 of the
New Act, it was not completed and the process of de-acquisition has been
initiated on the request of respondents no. 1 and 2. In regard to applicability
of Section 93 of the New Act, the person whose land was required to be
acquisitioned, a preliminary Notification taking recourse of Section 11 of the
New Act ought to be issued and the possession thereof should not be taken
over, then only the compensation may be determined and paid.
6.
In the said context, Section 93 is relevant which is reproduced as thus.
“93. Completion of acquisition not compulsory, but compensation
to be awarded when not completed.-(1) The appropriate Government shall
be at liberty to withdraw from the acquisition of any land of which possession
has not been taken.
(2)
Whenever
the
appropriate
Government
withdraws
from
any
such
acquisition, the Collector shall determine the amount of compensation due for
the damage suffered by the owner in consequence of the notice or of any
proceedings thereunder, and shall pay such amount to the person interested,
together with all costs reasonably incurred by him in the prosecution of the
proceedings under this Act relating to the said land.”
3|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
7.
On perusal of the aforesaid, the Legislative intent is clear that
completion of compulsory acquisition by the appropriate Government is not
necessary, they may have liberty to withdraw the said acquisition of which
the possession of land has not been taken over after initiating the process of
acquisition. In the present case also after issuance of the Notification under
Section 4 of the Old Act and on to commencement of the New Act, the
preliminary Notification under Section 11 was issued but the possession of
land was not taken from the petitioners. As per Sub-Section 2 above, it is
clear that when appropriate Government wants to withdraw any such
acquisitions, prior to its completion, the Collector is duty bound to determine
the amount of compensation due for the damages suffered by the owner in
consequence of the Notice or of any proceedings thereunder and such
amount shall be paid to the persons interested together with the cost
reasonably incurred by him in the prosecution of the proceedings under this
Act relating to the said land.
8.
Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of respondents no. 1 and 2 has
made an attempt to satisfy this Court that as per letter dated 01.11.2017
the compensation which was determined by the Collector is of the damages
of crops yield involved in the process of acquisition of the land. The SubSection 2 of Section 93 of the New Act do not confer any power to the
Collector to determine the damages of the crops yield involved, therefore,
the respondents no. 1 and 2 is not liable to pay the amount of compensation
as determined by the Collector under the provisions of Section 93 (2) of the
New Act. It is contended that in response to the previous letter dated
24.05.2017, the objections have already been submitted by the respondents
no. 1 and 2 on 27.06.2017 which has not been duly considered by the
Collector while issuing the letter dated 01.11.2017, therefore, the amount of
4|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
compensation is not required to be paid by them and the present petition
may be dismissed.
9.
On the other hand, the learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioners as well learned
Additional Advocate General representing
respondents no. 3 and 4 contends that after issuance of preliminary
Notification under Section 11, as per Section 93(2) of the New Act, in case
the acquisition is not completed and possession of the land has not been
taken, the Government can withdraw the said acquisition proceedings. In the
said contingencies, the Collector is require to determine the amount of
compensation for the damages suffered by the owner in consequence of the
Notice or any of the proceedings thereunder. The said amount is liable to be
paid by the person to whom the land is being compulsorily acquisitioned,
therefore, the arguments as advanced by the Counsel for the respondents
no. 1 and 2 is contrary to the spirit of Section 93 of the New Act.
10.
After having heard learned Counsel appearing on behalf of both the
parties and to advert the arguments as advanced by the parties, the
intention of the Legislature while enacting Section 93 has to be seen. On
perusal thereto and as discussed above, sub-Section (1) confers a power to
the State Government for withdrawal of the compulsory acquisition of any
land in case it is not completed and the possession of the said land has not
been taken. Sub-Section (2) comes into play when the appropriate
Government withdraws the acquisition, at that stage, it is the duty of the
Collector to determine the amount of compensation due “for damages
suffered by the owner in consequence of a Notice or any Proceedings and
any cost incurred”. Thus, under the New Act special provisions have enacted
by which even at any stage the Government may have liberty or can decide
to withdraw from the said acquisition if not completed subject to payment of
5|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
compensation for the damages suffered by the owner on account of notice
and other proceedings brought against him.
11.
The Legislative intent is clear that the determination of the amount of
compensation shall be based upon or for the damages suffered by the owner
in consequence of the Notice or any proceedings alongwith the cost as
specified. However, the determination of the compensation made by the
Collector vide letter dated 01.11.2017 inter alia stating that the said
compensation is for damages of crops yield involved due to cancellation of
acquisition after Notice of Section 11 of the New Act is squarely fall within
the connotation “in consequence of the Notice”. The arguments as advanced
by the Counsel for respondents no. 1 and 2 is completely misplaced and
contrary to the Legislative intent as discussed hereinabove, therefore, such
arguments cannot be countenanced.
12.
In view of the foregoing discussion, petitioner is entitled to, the
alternative relief, prayed in this petition, and the direction of the said relief
can be issued. It is to observe here that the Order dated 01.11.2017 passed
by the District Collector determining the compensation conveyed to the
Department has not been assailed by respondents No. 1 and 2 though the
period of more than three and half year has already been elapsed, therefore,
in consequence of the provision of Sub-Section (2) of Section 93 of the New
Act, the direction for payment of compensation as determined by the District
Collector can be issued against the respondents no. 1 and 2.
13.
As per discussion made hereinabove, the first part of the relief is
declared infructuous while for the second part of relief petitioners are
entitled to the directions as sought against the respondents to compensate
them. In the present case, after issuance of preliminary Notification for
compulsory acquisition, it has been withdrawn prior to its completion by the
6|Page
HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM
Record of Proceedings through Video Conferencing
WP (C) No. 55 of 2018
respondents no. 3 and 4 on the request of respondents no. 1 and 2. In
consequence the respondents no. 3 and 4 has determined the amount of
compensation as per Section 93(2) of the New Act and the said amount of
compensation is payable by the respondents no. 1 and 2 to the petitioners.
14.
Accordingly, this petition is allowed with a direction that the
compensation determined by respondents no. 3 and 4 vide letter dated
01.11.2017 shall be deposited by respondents no. 1 and 2 within a period of
three months from the date of communication of this Order. Failure to
deposit the said amount within the time limit shall entail deposit with
interest at the rate of 6 % per annum. It is further directed that on receipt
of the said amount of compensation, the respondent nos.3 and 4 shall pay
the same to the petitioners, as per law within a further period of one month
or may keep in fixed deposit till its disbursement. On failure to pay by
respondents No. 3 & 4 within the stipulated time, the interest as per the
rates of fixed deposits prevalent on the date of deposit be payable to
petitioners.
Chief Justice
jk/avi
7|Page
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review