Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY,THE SIXTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTIGE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ANI)
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APP EAL NO: 473OF 2025
AppealUnderorder43-RulelofC.P.C.againstorderdated06.10-2025
passed in l.A.No. 1,194 ot 2025 in O.S.No. 145 ot 2025 on the file of the Court of
ih" vt Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy District at Kukatpally
Between:
of Tanla Platforms Limited, a company
Karix lvlobile Pnvate Limited, A subsidiary
-ie56
at Tanla
having .its resistered
;;;;h;;;dJ ,"J"i1r,E Comfanies Act.
^offi*
Telangana
C"niie, Hitech City Road, Madh-apur Hyderabad- 500081,
nepreseni6O by its authorized signatory lvlrs Seshanuradha Chava'
i".f,i"i"i,
...APPELLANT/ Petitioner
AND
OneXtel Limited, Having its registered office at C 80-2' ATS Bouquet, Sector
1 32. Noida, 201308. Represented by its lrilanaging Director
Mr. Amit Kumar Jha, S/o Suresh Chander Jha, Aged lMaior, O-c^c:-Priv.ate
empnyee at Onextel Limited, C 802, ATS Bouquet, Sector 132' Norda'
201308.
Mr. Prakash Badoni, S/o Roshan Lal Badoni, Aged about 37Years, Occ
Fiiuri" erpfoyee ai OneXtet Limited, C 802, ATS Bouquet, Sector 132'
Noida, 201308.
tvlr Raohu Raia Marwaha, S/o KK Marwaha, Aged Major, Occ: Private
Erpfoi.e, Rl6 Horse No. 2320A, Sector 42C, ehandigarh - 160036'
...RESPONDENTS/ ResPondents
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Application Under Order 39 Ryle 1 and 2 of CPC praying that in the
circumsiances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court
maynepleasedtoinjuncttheRespondentsNo.2-4hereinfromdisclosing
proilriet"iy and confidential information which exclusively belongs to the Appellant
utilizing
lr iis group companies and simultaneously restrain all Respondents from
confidintial information of the Appellant in any manner whatsoever and to pass
.u"h oth"1 oider or orders as deemed fit and proper in the interest of justice.
Counsel for the Appellants: SRI A. VENKATESH, Senior Cc r nsel
SRI. D. NARENDAR NAIK
Counsel for the Respondents: SRI M.V. PRATAP KUMAR
The Court delivered the following Judgment:
-
IIIGH COURT FORTTIE STATE OF TEIIINGANA
AT IfYDERABAI)
I
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHTIMI BIIATTACHARYA
AND
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE GADI PRAVEEN KUMAR
1'
CTVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL.No.473 OF 20.25
6th February, 2O26
Between
Karix Mobile Private Limited
...Appellant
AND
OneXtel Limitecl and 3 Othcrs
...Respondents
Mr. A.Venkzrtesh, Iearned Scnior Counsel representing IvIr'Narcndar- Naik,
learned counseI appearing for- the appellant.
Mr.M.V.Pratap Kumar, learned counsel appearing for the respondcnrs.
JUDGMENT: Qter Hon'ble Justtce Moushumt Bhattacharyu)
l.
The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal arises out of an order dated
06.1O.2O25 passed by the learned VI Additional Drstri('t atld
Sessions Judge, Ranga Reddy District at Kukatpalll' ("irial Cor'rrt')
whereby the Trial Court rejected the appellant,i pltrintil['s
Application for temporary injunction restraining the respondent
Nos.2 - 4 from disclosing confidential information belonging to the
appellant/ plaintiff to the respondent No.l and from utilizing the
confidential information of the plaintiff'
lIIrEt
2.
MB,J & GPK,.T
CIt't .No.473 of 2O2s
The appellant's I.A. was rejected on the g ( Llnd. that the
appellant had failed to make olut a pima facie ca,e or that the
appellant witl suffer irreparable loss if injunction is r r lused.
3.
The appellant had filed the Suit seeking perpct -ral injunction,
delivery up, rendition of accounts of profits, and I sclosure, etc.,
against the respondents/defendants. The appellant rlso prayed for
perpetual injunction restraining the defendants frcr r soliciting the
appellant's existing clients and for a direction on t L , defendants to
deliver up all cor-rficlential information belonging l( the appellant
rvhich is in the possession of the respondents/defr'r r :rnts.
4.
The Trial Court granted ex parte ad inter i r injunction in
favour of the appellant on 18.07.2025 restraining -l-re respondent
Nos.2, 3 and 4 from disclosing or using i r v confidential
information of the appellant. The respondents ent: -ed appearance
on 22.O8.2O25 and filed a counter affidavit o the interim
application along u'ith an application under Ordcr Vll Rule I0 of
the CPC for retnrn of the plaint to the appropr i te Court. The
appellant hled an application seeking leave to fiL, rejoinder along
rvith counter afhdavit to the respondents' Otc r r VII Rule 10
application. 'fhe respondents' Order VII Rule lC application was
dismissed by the Trial Court on 12.09.2025. The mpugned order
/"
,-w
--
MB,J & GPK,J
cMA.No.473 of 2025
dismissing the appellant's I.A., for temporary injunctron' i\ras
passed on 06.10.2025.
Arquments otr behalf of the Parties
5.
Senior Counsel appearing for the appellant submits that the
Trial Court erred in refusing to consider and mark the rclevant
documents including a mail dated 17 'O7 '2025 which was crucial
to
the appellant's case of breach of conhdential information' Counsel
urges that the conhdential information divulged b1' tlle
respondents, particularly by the respondent No 4 to the responclent
No.1, rrr,as information whiCh was exclusive to the appellant arld
not
available in the public domain' Counsel submits that the
respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4 were in senior positions in the appeilarlt
and left their employment in April 2025 tojoin the respondent
No
immediatelv after u'hich, the appellant lost a major client'
6.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents submits that
the appellant has failed to Iile any document to shor'v that the
to give
information was exclusive to the appellant and also failed
specifrc details with regard to the alleged breach of confidence
on
the part of the respondents' It is also submitted that the appellant
has not placed any material to show the specihc nature of
the
confidential information or that the breach complained of is in
G.EI
v&:.4
\G-
\,
\.
4.
,'r,. .*n:i"1r":{;!
respect of informzrtion which is only present in thr: 1r'ivate domain
of the appeilant.
7.
The case of the appellant is that t r -' respondent
No. 1/defendant No. 1 u2., OneXtel Limited is a dire -- competitor of
the appellant an<l operates in a line of u,ork ir-lvc tving within a
similar consumer - work prohle. The appellant -- aLims that the
respondent No. 1 placed its employees (the respor-r .1 :nt Nos.2 - 4)
u,ithin the appellant and its other group compani:; including its
parent compan\ for corporate espionage and t r cause severe
business losses to the appellant b1, identifi,ing tht rnployees who
u,ould have access to sensitive information and irr ucing them to
leave tl-re appellant and join the respondent No. 1.
Decision
B.
We have consiclered the competing submi:,r ions made on
behalf of the parties. The decision is divided into ; recihc captions
rt,hich are relevant for the conclusion
9.
The appellan t / plaintiff, Karix Mobile, is - '.r'l.ro11y-owned
subsidiary of Tanla Platforms Limited which clainr ; to tre a leading
provider of enterprise communication ald engag€ rrent solutions
offering businesses a unified platform to inl c I rct with their
,/
E?
i-
.-,,v
customers across multiple digital channels.
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.N0.473 o! 2025
The appellant
specializes in mobile messaging services (MMS) and facilitates
large-scaie communication through SMS, Whatsapp, RCS, Voicc
and Email for the purpose of enabling timely and personalized
customer outreach. The appellant's services include advanced
Application Programming Interface (API) integrations, campaign
management tools and real-time analytics supporting a wide range
of use cases such as marketing, notihcations, alerts and
transactional messaging. The appeilant further claims to work rvith
global tech-giants and with leading domestic e-commerce
platforms, fantasy sports companies, food and grocery deliverv
platforms, hnaucial service providers, etc.,
10. The dates relevant to the dispute are as follou's
(i) Thc respondent No.4 joined the appeilant on
07.12.')015 in the field of telecommunications
and tcch sales and received training at the
appellant for several years' The respondent No'4
submitted his resignation on 12.03.2025 and
joined the respondent No. I on 3O.O4.2O25 i'e',
after about a month of leaving the appellant'
EE!!
E'it
R.
t-
MB,J & GPK,J
CII t.No.473 of 2O2S
(ii) The respondent Nos.3 and 2 joinec the
appellant on O2.O5.2017 and 05.07. I )23
respectively and held senior positions h: ving
access to confidential information. 'lhe
respondent Nos.2 and 3 resigned in Decc r ber,
2024 and I',-ebruary, 2025, respectivell' ancl
joined the respondent No.1
(iii) The appellanl subsequently conducu r arr
internal inquiry and found that the respor ient
Nos.2 - :l had joined the respondent No.l.
(iv) Around .June, 2O25, the appellant n: jced
that its business '"vith a major client had <:r rre to
a star-rdstill and the procurement head r' the
said client indirectly conf,rrmed that h, had
received a call lrom the respondent Nr;. I for
drverting the business. The appellan \\ras
furtl-rer informed that the sender IDs I the
appellar-rt were being registered in
aggregator's account and that
,.r ' rther
onh thc
respondent No.4 had access to all sur.l r dala
rvhich rvould enable redirecting all the s.nck:r
IDs.
( l.
w
(")
MB,J & GPK,J
cMA.No.473 ol 2025
On 17.O7.2025, one Mr.Jayant from the
respondent No. 1, issued a mail to the
respondent No.4 disclosing details regarding the
release date for Phase - 1 of the International
Long - Distance Operator ('ILDO). The appellant
came to know of this mail since the respondent
No.4, w'l-rile replving to Mr.Jayant's mail, marked
the mail to one of the appellant's employees viz.,
Mr.Sarthak Nanda, on his Karix email lD. The
appellant discovered that Mr-Sarthak Nanda '*'as
involvcd in
misappropriating conhdential
information from the appellant while still in
employment and was passing on the said
information to the respondent No.1 and its
employees including the respondent No.4.
("i) The appellant filed the Suit on 18.07.2025 aiong
rvith an application (t.A.No. i 194 of 2025\ for
temporary injunction against the respondent
Nos.2, 3 and 4 to restrain them from disclosing
confidential information belonging to
appellant to the respondent No. l.
the
w
\i#I.rJ
\6i . l'
\'i
MB,J & GPK,J
C'It\ .No.4Z3 oj 2O2S
Action lbr lSreach of Confidence
11. Breach ol confidence is recognized n5 q 6li; inct tort and
embodies the equitable doctrine that the person v,.lr r hzrs received
information in confidence shall nct take unlair ar1 . rntage of it or
proht from the ',r.rongful use or publication of it. The L(rtion requires
that the person u,ho received the information rn r st not use it
t'ithout the consent of the confider or use thr nlbrmation to
his/her advant:rge inclucling for monetary gain.
l'2. An action for breach of confidenc.t. is
generally
straightforward as it prohibits use of information <:..,rmunicateci in
conildence. In most cases, the plaintiff claims that 1 re irrformation
u,as shared in confidence thereby imposing a cot-rc;ponding duty
cn the defendan t to prevent the information from I rr i I g cl isclosed to
others. The disclosure of information by a defen,j r rt can only be
restrained if the ir-rformation possesses the tlecc:,r .rrJ, quality of
conhdence. Thc information shared must also r ot l>e public
property or bc in thc realm of public knou I ,rlge ancl the
information should havc been disclosed in circumslr rces which the
plaintiff and the defendant both believed to be cc r fidential. The
action further presupposes that the defendant tlisclosed the
information lo anolher lor gain.
-,
t/
{\\
\",
w
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 of 2025
13. The obligation of confidence may arise from an express or
implied term in a conl"ract of employment and also in a noncontractual fiduciarv situation. The obligation is breached by the
confidant u,ho had notice of its confidential characterr
14. The essential characteristics of a breach of conhdence may be
summarised as:
(i)
The informtrtion must have the necessa{r
quali[-r, ol coufirlence i.e., it must not be public
property or be in the realm o[ public
knon4edge2.
(i1) Equitable intervention is grounded on the iarger
ethical consideration that it is unconscionable
for a person to reveal inlbrmation knowing fully
well that the information is not to be revealed'
An action for breach of conlidence has moral
underpinnings; the person who receives
information is bound b1' conscience to keep the
information secret.
I Satmqnd & tleuston on The Lalv ofTorts, Twent)' First Editi()n, iatt*airg"gi"eering Coy. Ltd-, Ferotec Ltd and Monarch Engincering Coj'
(1948) 65 R P C 203
(frntt.t r*), Ltii. v. Campbelt Engineering Co)''' Ltd ;
FEI
\; ''
\.
\
l0
MB,J & GPK,J
a4 l.No.4Z3 ol 2O2S
(iii) The larv of confidence protects u,ritten oi orai
conhdcntial comm unication and olx r ate s
against those u,ho receive information or- ileas
in confidence. 'lhe application of conlr,l ,:r<.e
usuall.y ceases when the informatiorr or i leas
become public knowledge. In
e ss ( ncr,,.
confidcnce should be respected in t, rblic
interest even u,here the confider can poitlt I ) ro
specilic hnalcial detriment to himselF.
(iv) '[]re ol;ligation of conhdence rests not on I on
the original recipient but also on an-\, il son
ri,ho received the inlbrmation q,ith knou I .dgc
accluired at the time or subsequentlv tlr; i thr.
information was originalty impartec in
confidence.
(r')
The information may qualify as conhdential
,VC TI
il it is based upon information that is i r tht.
public sphere provided the creator shar.,l th(.
information in confrdence, expendecl [-i; ,her.
intellectuai effort and produced a uniquc :., sull
rvhich could oniy be reproduced bv the : rmt.
I C'oprrrgr:r ancl Skonr: James on Copyright
(l3ihDdn-)
rt\
'v
IiIIT
tl
MB,J & GPK'J
CMA.No.473 ol 2025
process. In other words' the recipient
of the
information cannot take a short-cut
to the same
resuit without putting any effort
for reaching
there. Courts will not permit someone
who has
come into possession of information
to steal a
march on his/her competitors from
whom that
person obtained the information
in confidence2'
(vi) A defer-rdarrt cannot use the piaintiffs
idea (even
'the germ of the idea') as a 'springboard'
for the
defenclant's Producta'
(vii) A claim of breach of confidence is
defeated simply on the ground
others u'ho know the facts in
not to be
that there are
question' besides
the person accused of breaching
confidence and
i
I
those he tolds.
be clearlv
(viii) The infbrmation must
I
i
identifred' be ot
to havc
a conhclcntial nature and be shown
of
been handed over in circumstances
aseaser v. CoPYdex l'rd lt96712 AII ER
5 Reports of Patent and Design and
5i,
ir'l
tisizf
s f'ra-nchv v. Franch] textenslon
Trade Mark Cases 1'19
i
I
I
w
\.
\
t2
MB,J & GPK,J
C)4 r.No.473 of 2025
confidence and then used without a licers - or
that therc was a threat of such use6.
(i*) An obligation of confidence may accl.Ll,t '\ren
rvhere there is no contractual relation be, ,,'en
the parties 7.
(x)
Commonplace information may have the
trappings of conhdence u,here it is suffici ntlr-
rler.elopecl so
as to have comrn c rcial
attractiveness and be capable of
I c ing
translr,.ecl into a profitable ventures. T1,r irlea
must have a significant element of orillir irlitv
which is not already in the realm of p rlrlic
knorvlcdge and may consist of a significant ;lanr
to a q,eli known concepte.
oCN,ll Clcnter s lor l\le<iical Innovation
GMBH v. phytophann pl,C,
Reports 235
i Tirllrot r,. (leneral Televisron Corporation p!,t. Ltd-, (l9g 1) RpC
3 Lloirrrlman r'. Phipps. (1966) All ER72l at759
,, Fr,rser r,.'fhanres l\rlevision Ltrl., (19g3)
2 All L.R. 101
I q()9J Flcet Street
. :.?
-!-!7
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.N,.473 of 2025
Trade Secrets
15. A Trade Secret may be in the form of a formula, patent,
device, plan or compilation of information w'hich is used in and
benehcial to one's business and gives the owner an edge over
competitors q,ho do not have the Trade Secret
16. Black's La',v Dictionay l2tn Edition defines Trade Secret' as a
formula, process, device, or other business information that is kept
confidential to maintain an advantage over competitors' The
information may include a formula, patterns, cornpilations,
programmes, devices, method, technique or process that has
actual or potential economic value because it is not generaliy
known or easily discoverable and that it is protected by reasonable
efforts to keep it secret.
17. Pollock & Mulla on Indian Contract Act, 13Lh Edition sets out
the essentials of Trade Secrets and Confidential lnformation'
According to the text, the extent of protection available extends to
the employee carrying the information in his/her tread and using
the information after expiry of the employment contract' However,
confrdential information including lists of customers r'r'hich cannot
verb-dtim be copied by the employee cannot be used by him/her to
the detriment of the employer. This is founded on the principle
,/
t4
MB,J & GPK,J
C.u 1.No.473 of 2025
thal the ernplo\.ee owes a duty of hdelity to his/her ( mplover not to
disclose to oth('rs lor his own profit the trade secre.l - or confidential
information rr hich he/she learns during the <,o i sle of his/her
emplo-\ mentlc).
18. Thus, thr. defining features of a Trade Secret r, ruld include:
(i)
The extent to which the information is i. r ovr,n
outsLcia rhe specific business.
(ii)
The extcnr to 'r,hich it is known to those i, .sjde
the btrsiness e.g., by the employees of th,- : uing
en(rt\
(iii) Thc precautions taken by the holder r, rhe
Tra<le Secret to guard against dissemineLli ,n of'
the in lormation.
(iv) 'lhe eflort or money expended in obtainins and
de veloping the Trade Secret.
iu)
The value of the Trade Secret to the hol,l ,r as
agarnst competitors. In other u,ords, ri.t ,ther
ro Bornba\ f)veing arrrl Manufacturing
Onlin( Bom l2 t3
Co. Ltd. v. Mehar Kararr : r r11h, 201O SCC
-
the information amounts to a
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 of 2025
property
right/ intellectual property right of the owner.
("i) The amount of time and expense it would take
for others to acquire and duplicate the Trade
Secret I I .
The Undis uted Facts in the Present Case
19. The appellant/piaintiff (Karix Mobile) specialises in mobile
messaging serr.ices and facilitates large scale commul-rication
through SMS, WhatsApp, RCS (Rich Communication Services),
Voice and Email, enabling personalised customer outreach. The
respondent No. 1 (OneXtel) is a competitor of the plaintiff, being
engaged in the same line of work and having a similar business
prohle. The respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4 joined the appellant in
2023,2017 and 2015, respectively. The respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4
submittecl their respective resignations in 2O24-2O2 5 ar-rd joined
the respondent No. 1/OneXtel n'ithin a short period of timc
thereafter. The respondent No.4 admittedly quit the appellant and
joined the respondent No.1 within a month'
Lrcolorado Suppl1'Co. v. Stewart,797 P-2d t303 (Colo- App. 1990)
WT
\1'i
MB,J & GPK,J
Cl4 r.No.473 of 2025
Thc Causal Chain
20. Thc tu o signihcant events in the caus;r chain of the
appellant's case iire givcn below
. First, the appellant lost one of its bigges clients u.ithin
t\^,o/three months of the respondent Nos.2, 3 ar < 4 leaving the
appellant ancl .ioining the respondent No.1. An : rployee of the
appellant receir,'.'cl :r mail datecl 1 1.06.2025 fror. L Mr'.Ritesh P.
Kapadia, Director Global Carrier Relations ii Sales of the
appellant. statirrg that the respondent No.4 (r.r.lr , br, then had
resigned frorn tlre appellant) had been girren ar.r, ss to sensitive
information about the appellant's business. The m r l further stated
that one of the appellant's biggest clients, Tu,iii I had sucldenly
stoppt:d its trerf tlc' on the appellant's platforn r and that the
procuremcnt hcad of Twilio had indirectly conli med of having
reccived a cali lrom the respondent No.4. The m r I further stated
thilt one ol the appellant's close aides had also c:tfirmed that all
the appellant.'s sender IDs were being regist,' ed in another
Aggregators' ac(ount ancl that only one person h I i access to that
data.
22. Second, a letter was sent by Mr.Jayant Junekar of the
respondent Nc- I to the respondent No.4 on 17.O / 2.025 disclosing
@,{
/
l7
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 of 2O25
details of the release date for the respondent No.1's ILDO Phase - I
The respondent No.4, in his reply to Mr.Jayant Junekar, marked
the mail to an cmploree of the appellant, Mr.Sarthal< Nanda, on his
Karix email lD
Infelencq ald PI€EU rruflq1
23. The above sequence of events would give rise to an
unshakablc inlerencc that the exit of the respondent Nos-2, 3 ancl
4 from the appellant's employment had a nexus u,itl-r thc immediate
loss of the appellant's biggest client. Further, the back-to-back
events of all three respondents quitting the appellant and joining
the respondent No.1 within a short span of time and Trvilio (the
appellant's erstu,hile client) abruptly stopping business n'ith the
appellant u,ould lre rnore than a mere coincidence.
24. The proximitv of the events would itself give rise to the
presumption that the respondent Nos.2,3 and 4 had a part to pla.)'
in the appellant's immediate loss of business.
25. It is also undisputed that the respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4
u,orked in the same Division of the appellant before they joined the
respondent No. 1. The respondent No.4 r.t'as a senior emplovee
heading a Division in the appellant, responsible for generating
Iu
MB,J & GPK,J
Ctt r. No.473 oj 2O2S
revenue of thorrsands of crores. lt is also r_rndispr lrd that all the
three responclcr-rts rvere priw to and had aCCeSS o information
pertainirrg lo trilrls, codes, data, techr-rologr., inforn-r r io, relating to
the appellant's pricing policies, routing logic, retrirr ogrc, technical
architecture erc., which were not in the public clt,r tain and u,ere
made avaiiable only to a specific set of emplovees ir he appellant,s
core team. Thc information included price _ sensir r,e data u,hich
u'as nol. in pr rblic knorvledge ever-r u.ithin the i r rpellant,s own
Company. The intbrmation rvhich ,a,as macle a,, tilal-lle to the
re spondent Nos.2. 3 and 4 u.as to give the appell:rrr
a c-ompetitive
edge over its rir als.
Em Jovrnent Contract
26.
Moreovcr. the respondent Nos.2,3 and 4 u,erI also bound bv
the tcrms of t}'rerr emplo,r,ment \\ ith the appellar t_, r'ramely, an
'Emplovee Non- I)isclosure ancl Invention Assigntr r rrt Agreement,
"r'hich
inclu<lecl a clause on "Trade secrets a, r crnfidentiar
Information". l'he rele'a,t ltart tl.rereof me,.rir.s. inter alia,
supplier names. aclciresses, pricing policies, inforr; tion regarding
the skills, abilitv and compensation of other emploi. res, marketing
plans antl strategies, research projects or der.,eloprn
r n ts ancl future
plans relating 1rl any aspect of the present or antrci rated
business
.FE
*:
1!
l9
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 ol 2025
of the Company '...hereinafier collectiuelA the "Confidential
Informatiort"' (u ords used in the Agreement).
.
'l'herefore, apart from the unwritten implied code of conduct
or call of conscicnce, w'hichever way one may put it, the respondent
Nos.2, 3 artd 4 $'ere bound by the terms of their employment lt'ith
the appellant to holcl the information acquired during the course of
their employment in strict confidence and not to misuse, disclose,
divulgc or communicate such conhdential informalion directly or
indirectiy to an\ PL'rson, corporation, or entity, except as required
in connection s'ith their work for the Company as weil as not to Llse
or acquire confirlcntial information for their own purposes or for
that of others includ ing any future employers rvithout the prior
n,ritten approvai of a cluly authorised officer of the appellant'
(referring to thc :spc'cific terms of the Agreement)'
2a. Notabl-v, thc Dmployee Non-Disclosure and Inven(ion
Assignment Agreement, in Clause 1 pertains to Trade Secrets atrd
Confidentiai lLrti:rmation and mentions 'future entployers or
companies'toemphasizethattheobligationofnon-disclosureof
confidential information lr'ould be carried o\rer to future
employment anil that the information acquired while in the
employment of the appellant cannot be divulged u'ithout the prior
written approval of a duly authorised officer of the appellant'
w
MB,J & GPK,J
C,V, 1.No.473
ol 2025
The Need for Infcrential Assumptiorts iu a Breach ol lonljdence
Action
29. An action for breach of conficlence operate-(.. rr:rforce , on anr
inferential assumption unlike, lor instance, r lt action for
infringement of ir-rtellectual property rights such
trade marks,
copyrights, etc., rvhere the Court has the benefit r I a side - by -
side comparisor to verif), the allegation of mi:.r se. Breach of
conhdence does not necessarilv permit or
lil ) rsage obvious
evidence of '.urongful exploitation save and exc,. )r: surrounding
circumstances. causality and inference. The proxiu i:y of facts and
immediacv of the damage caused to the conr riainant would
constitute the mainstay of a claim of breach of con'i lenr:e
30. The inlernal mail circulated b1. Mr-Rit.;h lo another
employee of the appellant with regard to Tn'ilio':; i lrrupt departue
and the confirmation given bf, the proc'urement lii, rl of Tr.vilio that
he had receivt:d a call from the resltondent No.4 (r :o had recentiy
quit the appellant and joined the respondent iilo :t lbilou.ed by the
rcspondent No.4 rnarking a reply to an emplovee oi the appellant in
respect of thi: r-elease date for ILDO Phase I c[ the respondent
No.1 are incidents u,hich are too closel-v connecteri l the cause and
effect of the chain. The incidents assume signif.,:rnce in light of
the fact that the appellant had successfully de, ,ioped its ILDO
!F7'-I
.*.dt
/
2l
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 ol 2025
platform as opposed to the respondent No 1 who was still at Phase
- I of its ILDO se rviccs
31. Consiclerirrg the above set of events, it is inconceivable that
the Trial court failed to notice the obvious cause-effect chain of
circumstances and see beneath the surface of the admitted facts.
We accordinglv hold that the Trial Court erred in ignoring the
inferential valuc of these facts. The Trial Court also failed to
appreciate that lhe appellant's claim related to information u'hich
was original, spet;ialisecl, scnsitive and was accessible to the
respondent Nos.2. 3 ancl 4 during the course of their employment
with the appellant.
Section 27 of The lndian Contract Act. tB72 is not ap plicable to the
present case
32. Section 27 of Tine lndian Contract Act, lB72 ('the 7a72 Act'l
provides that evet'u' agrecment, b-y vt'hich any one is restrained from
exercising a lau'ful profession, trade or business of anv kind, is void
to that extent
33. Section 27 embodies the principle that where the restraint of
a party from carn'ing on a trade is u'ider than the protection that
the party rvith u,hom the contract is made can possibly require,
MB,J & GPK,J
Ci| lNo.473 ol 2025
such restraint must be considered unreasonable I lau,, and the
corltract u,hich u'ould enforce it must therelbre be ' ,id t'. Niranjon
Sltonkar Golikrtri u. Cenhtrg Spinning and Mctrrrtfc't r r.htq Co. Ltd.I3
provides contextual relevance to this discussior Tl're Supreme
Court drew a distinction betvveen good and bad n,enants (noncompete agreements) and protected the authorit-v : the Courts to
ISS1lC
injunctions lvhich were reasonable anrl ne<:essary for
protecting the interest of the employer/ rcspr) rient Company
r,r'here the appellant rvas said to have divulgecl inlt,r r r;ltion to a rival
entltv
34.
Learned <:ounsel appearing for the responcir': r s; h:rs relied on
sectior-r 27 of thc 1872 Act to urge that thc, appr'l
lr1
)ras put the
respondents in an unreasonable contracrlu.rl :i trl-,;g)ehold. We
hou,ever find the argumellt to be untenahlc i r
the following
reasons:
The Sr-rit and the I.A. are for the prot,- ioi-r of
cor-rfidential information and to prevcnt rl s rl rsuse
and exploitation bv the respondents. 'l'l-rt Siuit is
nol for restrarning the respondent Nos.2. lr and 4
rr Ilitchcock r., Cokt'r. (1837) 6 Ad. & U. 438
'r I 967 SCC Onlirrc Sc 72
G-rr'
*,',il
I
t'
/1
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 oJ 2O25
from joining the respondent No.l or any other
entity
Sectiorr 27 of the 7872 Act bars agreemen[s rn
restraint of trade but does not impose any embargo
on the protection of trade secrets and confidential
information , u,hich even as per the Employment
Agreemelrt in the present case, survives the
termination of em plo,ymen t.
The respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4 were well arvare of
the terms of their emplovment u'ith the appellant
including the "Emplol'ee Non-Disclosure and
Invention Assignment Agreement" u'hich
specificail]' mentions a u'ide array of information
clescribed as 'confidential information'. The
respondents rvere therefore bound by contract not
to disclose such information during the course of
their employment with the appellant and 'at all
times thereafle/ includin g 'any future employer or
companies...'.
iv.
None of the respondents have challenged the
Non-Disciosure/Non-Compete Agreement being
24.
MB,J & GPK,J
cMt .No.473 of 2025
urlreasonahle or contrary to section 27 of tltt 187 2
Act. The llombay F{igh Court in V.M.Desht)t t (le t).
The Aruind Mills Co. Ltd., Ahmedabacllr ct'rt-si l::rerl
a plethora of cases in relation to section 12 a ,l thc
7872 AcI but proceeded to grant an iniL I (rtiorl
against the defendant/ appellant frorr treing
employed as a weaving master or dis( i i lgrLtg
substantially the same duties as a u'eavinl :- rrster
in the concerned Company for a certairt p.'riocl.
'l'he Cour'l also restrained the clefendir t
divr,rlging any trade secrets, proces:.i i
l-rom
or
infonnation relatect to the affairs of the ( { ] r l)arr\'
for ivhom the defendant had rvorked as a r.' ';n inq
mastcr under an Agreement.
The Trial Clourt fell into Error in co14t11g I r lhc lmpugned
Con clu sion
35. The irnpr,rgned order records that the uro 'llarrt and the
responclent No. i are in the same bttsiness ancl th; tht' appellant's
former employees (the respondent Nos.2, 3 and 41, : ticr holding key
positions, resigned from the appellant and joitrt'r thc respondent
rl Lll? l9-l(r Born 423
:.,--'w
*,
/':'
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 oJ 2025
No.l to divulge the conhdentia-I information of the appellant to the
respondent No. I . Hou,ever, the Trial Court found that the details of
the said confidential information as well as the manner in which
the respondents misused the information rvere not mentioned by
the appellant. The Trial Court also held that 'list of clients',
'business operations, event types, etc., cannot be termed as
confidentiai since they are readily available through public sources.
The Trial Court also failed to give due weightage to the mail dated
17.O7.2025 .,r'hich expressly reflected the respondent No.4
communicating u,ith an employee of tire respondent No.1 regarding
technical routing data and also marking the mail to an existing
employee of the appellant. The Trial Court concluded that the
appellant had failed to make o:ut a primo facie case or show balance
of convenience rvas in its favour.
36. We hnd the reasons given by the Trial Court to be contrary to
the records placed before us. The rejoinder hled by the appellant
contains specilic and sufhcient details ol the sensitive information
including click through rate (CTR optimisation), technical
architecture, routing logic and retrial logic which n'as original and
exclusive to the appellant. The rejoinder given particulars of
sensitive and proprietary information developed by the appellant
through skill, expertise and extensive research including creating of
)
r-
t-'.):
\
'26
MB,J & GPK,J
Ct A.No.473 of 2O25
a proprietary platform named International ,ong Distance
Operator. Tl-re Trial Court should have takcn intc, : :count the fact
of the respondent No.1 releasing its ILDO platlorrr rencl informing
the respondenl No.4 of the date for the release rvith el'erence to the
I
i-DO piatforrn created and developed bl
1r. petitioner.
Signihcantly, this mail was sent to the respondeir No.4 after he
exited the appellant and joined the respond: rt No.1 thus
reinforcing thc inference of breach of information ;-elating to the
appellant's ILDO piatform.
37. It is seltlecl lau, that information consisting ol' rice - sensitive
;
cletails, pricing policy, codes, databases I ludir-rg ciient
i
conhderetialit_v ciata and prior analytics cannot simpl be reduced to
"list of clients". [n the present day and age. r:r r rorate entities
compete with one another not only for large
:
minute, rruanced data signif-ving individual
c
ale data but
preferen ces,
predilections. hehavioural patterns and life choic,:r; <lf consumers.
l'heretbre, rhe value of information to businesscs lr Ls evolved u,el1
be-i,ond mere lists of clients to encapsulate F,( r ;onalised and
customised consumer databases. Vieu,eci in the albt :said light, the
Trial Court's reduction of the entire case of the a.; rellant onlv to
that of a "llst of clients" not only trivialises the is; re but fails to
.-.,
\
MB,J 6L GPK,J
CMA.No.473 of 2025
recognisethatmoderndaybusinessgoalsalerootedincalibrated,
fine - tuned, nuanced information.
38. The Trial Court also failed to appreciate that it $rould t)e
virtually impossible for the plaintiff in a breach of conltdence case
to provide specilic evidence of wrongdoing' In such cases' the
threshold of a pina facie case must be lowered to a case of
inference and causality. A plaintiff cannot be expected to obtain a
..confessional statement,, from the wrongdoer r'r.itlr rcgard to tlre
disclosure of conhdential information . As stated abovt', the Cor-trt
must proceed on the probability of a breach on ttre happening of
certain sequential events which i't'ould invariabl.v give rise to the
presumption that the injury could only have been caused bY reason
of revelation of secret information.
39. It is also important to bear in mind that tl-re right to protect
sensitive information created and developed through skill, effort
and irrvestment needs to be balalced against the fr-eedorn to scek
employment of one's choice. An individual's right to enhance
his/her prospects cannot trample upon the right of the erstu'hiie
employer to preserve arrd protect confidential information
the employer has a proprietary interest'
in u'hich
-lEE,'?
Yl
MB,J & GPK,J
( I 'A.No.473 of 2025
40. lnterim protection against the revelation ot rnlormation is
r,r'arrantecl even more u,here the plaintiff seeks t r .Jrevellt ln-lury
u,hich can reasonably be expected if the resi rr.rricnt is not
rcstrained from continuing the wrongful acts. pending trial.
Interim protection may entail freezing of the existn
{
state of affairs
to prevent the respondent from disseminating fur rcr information
and cause lurther injury to the plaintiff.
41. In r.hc present case, the appellant/pl;ri riitf filed the
application lor tc'mporary injunction restrainirr r: r he individual
respondents ithe respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4) I.r)m clisclosing
conlidential r,tfonnation belonging to the :rrrl :llirnt to the
respondent No. 1. The Triai Court should have tz,l, r n ilto a(.cour1t
the irnmircnt thrcat of future disclosure and t]-r. rresumption of
culpahilitr or1 rhe part of the respondent No.2, 3 , i rl 4. The Trial
Court hou.errer overlooked the urgency and dis I isst,d the I.A.
primarily on the ground of the plaintiff failing to rn; i<e out a prima
facic case. l'he Trial Court iguorecl the obvious r:d llags
in the
seqlrence ol m:rils referred to in the paragraph abov ,
42. The remaining tr.l,o of the triad for interim pr.,, (.cti(,n namel-y,
bal:rnce of convenience and irreparable injury, rs
par$/ whose pral,er for interim prott:ction
1( elrsure that a
is der.ried ., oulri not suffer
greater loss i[ rhat partv were to ultirnately succccrl j
I thc Suit. We
?^.:q
,\.!'
MB,J & GPK,J
CMA.No.473 of 2025
are of the firm view that given the impossibility of bringing actual
proof to the table ir-r actions for breach of conhdence ' the Trial
Court should have minimised the potential harm to the appellant
by restraining the respondents from continuing rvith their:rlleged
wrongful acts, namely, revealing confidential information belonging
to the appellzrnt to the respondent No' 1 (the new emplol'er of the
respondent Nos.2, 3 arrd 4).
43. The cases relicd on by counsel appearing for the respotrdents
are distinguishable on facts. Manipal Business Soltrrlorrs Priuate
Limited u. Auigoin Consultants Priuate Limitedl ' Arneicart Express
s
Bank l-td- u. tvls.Prigo Pun16 and Cigma Euents Priuate Lintited
Vs'
Deepak Guptat; rvere Single Bench decisions of the Delhi I{igh
Court in relation to Agreements in restraint of tracle' Iv[atipal
Business Solutions (supra) involved a Non-Disclosure Agreemcnt
and a claim lbr breach of conhdentiality. The Delhi High cottrt
foundthattheplaintiffspleaofconfidentialitv\\'asullsllsliiilral;lc'
as the plaint trnd the pleadings did not disclose thc naturc
o[ thc
information / data of which confidentiality u'as claimecl Arnericart
Express Bank (supra) dealt u'ith a Suit flled by the plaintiff
seeking
a permanent and mandatory injunction to restrain the dct-endant
from using or disclosing any information and trade secrets
tlzozz scc ont-inc Dct 2480
16 2606 sCC onlinc Del 638
11 2024 SCC Online Del 9 140
relating
E\
MB,J & GPK,J
C.u r.No.473 of 2025
to the busir-ress ancl operations of the plaintiff. ! I-re t)elhi High
Court lound that the plea that the defendant r: I ;llc.gallr, and
unlart,fulll' obtained confidential information abou the plaintiff s
customers \\.as made as an afterthought tc tressurize the
defendant to continue her employment with th(. rlain tiff and to
curtail her ftrture prospects.
44. Cigrna Et.tt'r'Lls Pnuate Limited (supra) sougl- I to distinguish
betu'ecn trade scr:rcts or confidential information as opposed to the
business knort'ledge acquired bl, an employee I t'rrugh ordinary
experience su<:h as u.avs of dealing with clients. I i:e Court noted
that the tiisclostrre of the knowledge would not l.]: m the plaintiff
unless it was rlemonstrated that the defendarr itaci access to
specifrc trade s(,crets or proprietarv information. ihe H igl-r Court
found that the details of customers gained in that r rse could easily
have beer.r acqr-rired through observation indepen<l,.. I (ianvassing or
minimal efforr anrl u,ould not qualify as proprie: n' or protected
tracie secrets. irr Star India Priuate Limited Vs. Ler rriraj Seetharam
Nattal;ts, a Single .Judge of the Bombav High Cor.t rcstrained the
defendant No. 1 therein from disclosing or divuig I g tl.;e plaintiffs
business plans ancl franchisee agreements, t'hi,. L the defendant
'$ N,tAN U/ \,1tI / 04 oir,/ 20o3
/
3t
MB,J AL GPK,J
CMA.No.473 oJ 2025
No. 1 therein had come to know during his employment with the
plaintiff.
45. Wander Limited u. Antox India Priuate Limitecil1 u'as cited
I>-1'
the respondents for the proposition that the Appellate Court should
not interfere w'ith the exercise of discretion of the Court of first
instance and substitute its own discretion except \r'here the
discretion has been shown to have been exercised arbitraril-1',
capriciously or '"r.here the Court has ignored the settled principlcs
of larv, regulating grant or refusal of interlocutory inj unction s'
There cannot be any divergent vieu' on this proposition. We havt'.
however, stated our reasons for holding that the'lrial Court errc'd
in refusing to exercise its discretion in favour of the injunction
sought for despite a compelling case for doing so. Hence, we tlnd
that the cases citcci on behalf of the respondents are not persuasive
enough to tilt the balance against grant of an injunction in thvour
of the appcllant / plaintiff.
Le 1990 (Supp) sCC 7 27
r
\
MB,J & GPK,J
(\ tA.No.473 of ZO2S
fhe trtelestr.4_1irilerl to Mark the Cruc ial Mail dzrr e r 17.O7.2025
46. Thc marrl clittecl 17.O2.2O25 from the responrl ,nt
ernplovee of the rcspondent No. I
No.4 (as an
) to Mr..1a1,6nt (a .t )ther employee
of the respondent No.1) as rvell as to an
existinll r n-rplovee of the
appellant *.as a crucial piece of evidence
whicli ,r,rs filed by the
appellant in its r<joinder. The Trial Court
hou,eve r lailecl to mark
this clocumen t in violatior-r of the direction passecl
Berrch of this Corrrt on 21.O7.2017 in
lr a Co_ordinate
CMA.r.r-os.5,. , 564 and 60Z
ol 2017 *,herein it *.as obsen,e<i that Courts
rvill ,,r bc justified in
failing to mark documents s,hich arc
reltt,rl Lrpon at the
intcrlocutorl' stage. Circ:ular R.O.C.No.275O/OI,
issued clirecting the District Courts
icll/2021 was
to ensure str_i _ 2dhslsnc.g 16
Rules 51 ancl 6O of The Telangana
Civil Rules r . practice and
Circular Order.s, 19g0, primarily.
in respect r f marking of
documents in rnterlocutor v* applications
before leciding such
appiir: ation s.
\
47. 'fhus, u,e find substance in the submissions
of the appeilanr rhat rhe Triar court
mail dated IZ.OT.2O2S in violation
I ade on behalf
errecr in fairi r 1 to mark the
of the dire<:tion issued bv the
High Court to all District Courts.
ri
it
t44f
MB,J & GPK,J
cMA.No.473 oJ 2025
Conclusion
48. The a<imittecl facts of this case ltt squarelv into the Brcacl-r of
Conhdence paracligm. The facts satisfy the three essential
ingredients required to mount an action for a claim of conltdence,
these are
(a) The information is conhdential and exclusive to the
appellirni. 'lhe inlormation pertains to customer
preferctrce databases, pricing policies, routing and
retrial logic, click through rate (CTR) optimisation
and technical architecture - '*'hich is not in the
public clomain. The information is specialised and
uniqut' arrrl translates to an asset of the plaintiff'
(b) The in lortrtation u'as shared with the respondent
Nos.2. 3 zurd 4 ill circumstances of confidence l>Y
virtue of the said respondents being in kev
positions in the appellant Company' Tl-rc
respondents rvere also bound by the confidentiality
obligations in their contract with the appellant'
(c) A competling inference can be drawn in respect of
the confidential information being disclosed by the
MB,J & GPK,J
cvt No.473 oj 2025
respondenl Nos.2, 3 and 4 to the responrl:,ri I'lo.l
u ithout thc permission
or authorisation r the
appellant. resulting in grave monetarv los.. t ; thr:
appeliar-rt/ plaintiff. Notably, the Trial Co,,rr i irilerl
to see the obvious red [lags in the causal r:ll Lin of
clrcumstances.
49. Contrary to the argument made on
. 'l-rall' of the
del'en danl s/ r'el;pon dent Nos.2,3 and 4, the inform;rl r rr disclosed by
the appellant in its rejoinder reflects that tht
nfr-.rrmation is
calibrated, spe<:ialised, exclusive and extends ie,r lrevond 'client
lists'. [n oth<'r' .,i'ords, the information amoulrts , ar proprietary
asset or an intellcctual propert.l, right of the app,'iit:-rl, the use of
u.hrch is u,ilhin the appellant's exclusive <lomain. l':r, information
plzrced belbre r-rs is not of the nature u.hich can r':rs h' tre acquired
by others throrrqh observation or hl minimal effor r
appellarit has tleveloped the intbrmation by usr
Further, the
,1' considerable
skiil, effolt arrd expertise. Hence, rve do not gree t'ith the
submtssion thaL the protection sought by tl're ii I tellant \rras on
vague and unrlefined terrns
50. Apart fr-r'rm satisSring the essential featurr s lf a Breach of
Confidence action, the back-to-back incidents, .:.. (i) all three
\r(sltottdents (tire responcient Nos.2, 3 anrl 4) beit'|_ ir-om the same
-4r, {
MB,J & GPK,J
cMA.No.473 oJ 2025
Division in the appellant, and (ii) their leaving the appellant and to
join the responclent No.1 and (iii) the appellant losing a major client
soon therealter, lcacls to the irrefutable presumption of rvrongdoing
on the part of the respondent Nos.2, 3 and 4. The tell-tale mail
d.ated 17.O7.2025 which the respondent No.4 marked to an existing
employee of the appellant, is not a mere coincidence but appea-rs to
be part of a pre-me<lltated design to misuse the proprietary
information ol the appellant. We are thus compelled to agree u'ith
the appeltant anci hotd that the 'lrial Court erred in refusing
interim protection to the appellant.
51. The reasorrs given in the above paragraphs persuade us to
allow the Appeal and set aside the impugned order dated
06.ro.2025.
52. CMA.No.473 of 2025, along with all connected applications,
is accordinglv allorrr,ed and disposed of in terms of the above'
S . K.SRINIVASA RAO
JOINT REGISTRAR
/,TRUE COPY//
ECTION OFFICER
B
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Justice MOUSHUMI
( For Her LordshiPs Kind Perusal)
T ACHARYA
GAOI PRAVEEN KUMAR
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice
( For His LordshiPs Kind Perusal)
To
The Vl Additional District Judge, Ranga Reddy
1{ . L.R. CoPies
The Under Secretary, Union of lndia, Ministry
Affairs, New Delhi.
District at Kukatpally
of Law' Justice and Company
4. The Secretary, Advocate s Association
_ Hyderabad.
5.
-
One CC to SRt. D. NARENDAR
6. One CC to SRt. M.V. pRATAp
7. Two C.D. Copies
Library, High cou r Buildings
NAIK, Advocate
[OptI )
KUMAR Advocate
[OplJ ]l
kul/PSL
)
i
;
i
I
I
HIGH COURT
I
I
II
I
DATED:06t02t2026
i
;
i
I
!
Notc :L.R. COPY TO BE MARKEI)
-:*
.rt t)cMl.tNT
I
a
)
q :1126
CMA.No.473 ot 2025
I
Or{; I r rr,vr r''
==t'
AI.t.OU'IN(; fut-. Applln L \\,lTIloLr.f (.os.ts
oq
,-t
*
j'C
Jlr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review