Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
%
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
+
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Judgment reserved on: 22.12.2025
Judgment delivered on: 23.01.2026
KARAN SINGH
.....Petitioner
versus
STATE NCT OF DELHI
Memo of Appearance
For the Petitioner:
For the Respondent:
.....Respondent
Mr. Chetan and Ms. Madhu Sharma, Advocates
Mr. Sanjay Lao, St. Counsel (Crl.) with Ms.
Priyam Agarwal and Mr. Aryan Sachdeva,
Advocates
Insp. Gianender Singh and SI Vikram Singh, PS
Welcome
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIVEK CHAUDHARY
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ JAIN
JUDGMENT
1.
Present petition has been filed under Articles 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India read with Section 528 of Bharatiya Nagrik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 whereby petitioner, inter alia, prays that his
arrest be declared unconstitutional, being in gross violation of Article 21,
22 (1) & Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
2.
Petitioner, who was arrested on 07.02.2024 in FIR No. 126/2024
registered at Police Station Welcome under Sections 302/307/34 of
Indian Penal Code, 1860, filed an application seeking grant of regular
bail before the learned Trial Court. Such application was dismissed on
03.12.2025 and he also assails such order in the present proceedings.
3.
However, the primary argument raised before us is that since the
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
grounds of arrest were never communicated to the petitioner, till the
filing of the chargesheet, in view of the specific pronouncements of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court, the arrest is illegal. He relies upon Pankaj
Bansal v. Union of India (2024) 7 SCC 576 (decided on 03.10.2023),
Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT of Delhi) (2024) 8 SCC 254 (decided
on 15.05.2024), Vihaan Kumar v. State of Haryana (2025) 5 SCC 799
(decided on 07.02.2025) and Mihir Rajesh Shah v. State of
Maharashtra 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2356 (decided on 06.11.2025).
4.
The petitioner also submits that his co-accused Sajjan @ Manish
had also moved an application seeking bail before the learned Trial Court
and while declaring his arrest as illegal, he was enlarged on bail vide
order dated 11.11.2025. He, thus, seeks relief on the ground of parity as
well.
5.
Mr. Sanjay Lao, learned Standing Counsel for the State submits
that the present petition is completely misconceived. He further contends
that writ petition would not lie for grant of bail.
6.
We also feel that the questions whether the accused has been
falsely implicated or, for that matter, whether invocation of Section 34
IPC was justifiable or not, cannot be pressed here.
7.
However, since petitioner has raised a ‘question mark’ about
legality of his arrest, we have looked into the matter from that limited
angle.
8.
Article 22(1) of Constitution stipulates that no person who is
arrested shall be detained in custody without being informed, as soon as
may be, of the grounds for such arrest. Such constitutional safeguard was
further strengthened by procedural law i.e. Section 50 of CrPC 1973
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
(now Section 47 of BNSS 2023) which reiterates the same by casting
duty upon police officer who is arresting any person (without warrant) to
forthwith communicate to arrestee, full particulars of the offence for
which he is arrested or other grounds for such arrest. Section 48 of BNSS
2023 further provides that arresting police officer shall forthwith give
information regarding such arrest and place, where the arrested person is
being held, to any of his relatives, friends or such other persons as may
be disclosed or nominated by the arrested person for the purpose of
giving such information and also to the designated police officer in the
district. It also, inter alia, provides requisite vigil over compliance by
making it obligatory for the concerned Magistrate to satisfy himself that
such requirements have been complied with.
9.
There cannot be any qualm with respect the evolution of law on
the aspect of furnishing of ‘grounds of arrest’.
10.
In Pankaj Bansal (supra), the question was that of the requirement
of written grounds of arrest being provided in an arrest under Section 19
of Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA), 2002 and Supreme
Court, in order to give true meaning and purpose to the constitutional and
the statutory mandate of Section 19(1) PMLA of informing the arrested
person of the grounds of arrest, held that it would be necessary,
henceforth, that a copy of such written grounds of arrest is furnished to
the arrested person as a matter of course and without exception.
11.
In Prabir Purkayastha (supra), the Apex court, while dealing with
a case under Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA),
reiterated the abovesaid constitutional requirement in context of arrest
under said Act also and observed that there was no doubt that any person
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
arrested for allegation of commission of offences under the provisions of
UAPA or for that matter any other offence(s) has a fundamental and a
statutory right to be informed about the grounds of arrest in writing and a
copy of such written grounds of arrest have to be furnished to the
arrested person as a matter of course and without exception at the
earliest.
12.
In Vihaan Kumar (supra), the accused had been arrested for a case
of cheating. It was pleaded that grounds of arrest were never
communicated and moreover the accused was handcuffed and chained,
when after arrest, he was hospitalized. Supreme Court, while reiterating
that the requirement of informing a person arrested of grounds of arrest
was mandatory one, supplemented that the mode and method of
communication must be such that the object of the constitutional
safeguard is achieved. It also held that any infraction thereof would not
vitiate the investigation, charge sheet and trial but, at the same time,
filing of chargesheet would not validate breach of constitutional mandate
provided under Article 22(1), either. It, however, also observed that
although there is no requirement to communicate the grounds of arrest in
writing, what is stated in paragraphs 42 and 43 of the decision in the case
of Pankaj Bansal (supra) were suggestions which merited consideration.
It was also observed that, in every case, it may not be practicable to
implement what is suggested above, supplementing that if the course, as
suggested, is followed, the controversy about the non- compliance will
not arise at all.
13.
In Mihir Rajesh Shah (supra), Supreme Court, while reiterating
the compliance of abovesaid mandatory requirement, went on to hold
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
that, in cases where the police is already in possession of documentary
material furnishing a cogent basis for the arrest, the written grounds of
arrest must be furnished to the arrestee on his arrest.
14.
At this juncture, it is apposite to notice the consolidated
jurisprudence crystallised by the Supreme Court in Mihir Rajesh Shah
(supra), while taking into consideration all the aforesaid decisions, as
under:
“21. After having discussed the constitutional mandate and
statutory provisions giving effect to the constitutional mandate in
Article 22 of the Constitution of India, let us now consider the
jurisprudence developed by this Court with respect to furnishing of
grounds of arrest through its decisions.
22. In Pankaj Bansal (supra), this Court while dealing with the
issue of furnishing grounds of arrest under Section 19(1) of PMLA
has underscored that Article 22(1) of the Constitution mandates
that no arrested person shall be detained without being informed
of the grounds of such arrest at the earliest opportunity. The
manner in which such grounds are to be communicated must be
efficacious and substantive which must fulfil the essential objective
and mandate of the constitutional provisions. It was further held
that there exists no plausible justification as to why a written copy
of the grounds of arrest ought not be provided to the arrestee as a
standard procedural requirement without any exception.
23. This Court has reached the above conclusion based on the
proposition that mere oral communication of such grounds, in the
absence of any written document, renders the compliance
susceptible to factual disputes which often result into conflicting
claims between the arrested person and the investigating agency.
This conflict results in jeopardizing the integrity of the arrest
process and thereby giving an opportunity to the accused person to
claim an immediate release. This situation may be obviated by
furnishing the grounds of arrest in writing. Apart from the
practical difficulties, furnishing grounds of arrest in writing also
results into effective compliance of the mandate provided under
Article 22 of the Constitution of India.
********
24. In Prabir Purkayastha (supra), of which, one of us was a
member (B.R. Gavai, J., as he then was), this Court reiterated the
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
principle laid down in the above judgment, while dealing with
offences under UAPA and held that any individual arrested for
alleged commission of offences under the UAPA or any other
offence for that matter, has both a fundamental and a statutory
right to be informed in writing such grounds of arrest. The Court
further held that a copy of such written grounds must be
furnished to the arrested person at the earliest without any
exception observing that the communication provided under
Article
and
Section 50 of CrPC 1973
(now
Section 47 of BNSS 2023) is not a mere procedural formality but
a vital safeguard with the ultimate objective to enable the
arrested person to effectively consult legal aid and be prepared to
raise objections in remand hearing and apply for his/her bail.
The right to life and personal liberty, safeguarded under
Articles 20, 21 and 22 of the Constitution, stands as the
paramount fundamental right. Accordingly, infringement of
these constitutional protections commands rigorous judicial
scrutiny and strict enforcement.
25. It was said that any breach of the constitutional
safeguards provided under Article 22 would vitiate the lawfulness
of arrest and subsequent remand and entitle the arrested person
to be set at liberty.
********
26. Subsequently, in Vihaan Kumar (supra), this Court
underscored that a failure to comply with the requirement of
informing the grounds of arrest soon after the arrest would render
the arrest illegal. The Court referred to the above-mentioned
decisions of this Court and observed that although the ideal mode
of communication of grounds of arrest is to provide such grounds
in writing, there is no such statutory requirement to provide such
grounds in writing. The Court noted that it may not be practical to
communicate grounds of arrest in writing in every situation, but if
such a course is followed, the controversy about non-compliance
will not arise at all.
27. It was further observed that to ensure the effective
implementation of the constitutional mandate in Article 22, the
law further requires such grounds to be effectively
communicated not only to the detainee/arrestee but also to their
friends, relatives or any other nominated person as envisaged in
Section 50A of CrPC 1973 (now Section 48 of BNSS 2023). The
legislative
intent
behind
the
incorporation
of
Section 50A of CrPC 1973 is to ensure that those in a position to
act, i.e. secure legal representation, initiate the process for bail,
are empowered to do so without any delay, thereby safeguarding
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
the fundamental rights of the arrested person as enshrined in
Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
********
28. Before we delve into analysing the provisions of law and
jurisprudential developments by this Court, we find it
quintessential to discuss the impact of arrest on an individual. The
arrest of an individual invariably impacts not only the person
arrested himself, but also the persons associated with him, i.e.
family, friends, relatives, etc., affecting their psychological balance
and overall social well-being. This Court has on several occasions
underscored that there is a stigma attached to arrest which impairs
the reputation and the standing of an individual in society. The
stigma attached to arrest undermines a person's social dignity and
results into consequences that reverberate beyond the individual
but also extend to their social circle.
29. The impacts of arrest are multidimensional and are not
only limited to societal impact but also extend to the physical and
mental health of the person. Mental health issues like depression
due to custodial confinement can be aggravated by inadequate and
overcrowded conditions prevalent in prisons. Such conditions
severely impinge upon the fundamental rights of the arrested
person and curtail his dignity and personal liberty.
30. This Court in Arnesh Kumar v. State of Bihar4, observed
that arrest results in embarrassment, restricts freedom, and leaves
permanent scars. Lawmakers and the police are aware of this. The
police and lawmakers are at odds, and it appears that the police
have not learned the lesson that is implied in and reflected in
the CrPC 1973 (now BNSS 2023). Despite long years of
independence, it still maintains its colonial image and is primarily
viewed as an instrument of oppression and harassment, and it is
undoubtedly not regarded as a friend of the public.
31. In Joginder Kumar v. State of U.P.5, this Court while
framing guidelines regarding the rights of an arrested person has
observed that the existence of a power to arrest and the
justification to use such power are two different aspects. The
person making arrest must be able to justify the arrest with
reasons apart from his power to do so. Arrest of a person can
cause irreversible damage to his reputation in the society as well
as his self-esteem, therefore, arrest cannot be made in a routine
manner. The Police Officer making an arrest must be cautious
while arresting a person and ought to satisfy himself after a
reasonable investigation to justify the person's complicity and also
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
the effect as well as the need of arrest. This Court has further
observed that except in heinous offences, arrest must be avoided.
32. Having perused the jurisprudential developments and
impact of arrest on a person, let us now consider the issues at
hand.
33. The mandate contained in Article 22(1) of the Constitution
of India is unambiguous and clear in nature, it provides that the
arrested person must be informed of the grounds of arrest as soon
as they can be. It further provides that the arrested person has the
right to defend himself by consulting a legal practitioner of his
choice. This constitutional mandate has been effectuated by the
legislature in Section 50 of CrPC 1973 (now Section 47 of BNSS
2023) which provides that an arrested person shall be forthwith
communicated with the grounds of his arrest.
34. The objective enshrined in Article 22(1) of the Constitution
of India for furnishing grounds of arrest stems from the
fundamental principle of providing opportunity to a person to
allow him to defend himself from the accusations that are levelled
against him leading to his arrest. The salutary purpose of
informing the grounds of arrest is to enable the person to
understand the basis of his arrest and engage legal counsel to
challenge his arrest, remand or seek bail and/or avail of any other
remedy as may be available to him/her under law.
35. It is pertinent to note that the arrested person must be
given early access to legal assistance to enable him to defend
himself and oppose the remand. The early access to legal counsel
becomes a quintessential object to ensure that the personal
liberty of the arrested person is protected. This Court in Suhas
Chakma v. Union of India while emphasizing on the need of prelitigation assistance has directed that the “Guidelines on Early
Access to Justice at Pre-arrest, Arrest and Remand Stage
Framework” as framed by the National Legal Services Authority,
are to be diligently pursued. The guidelines provide for legal
assistance to the arrested person at the stage before remand. The
remand advocate shall interact with the arrestee with the
objective to inform him about the allegations against him and the
grounds being put by the prosecution for seeking remand. The
guidelines also provide for making available the translated copy
of documents to the arrested person in the language he/she
understands. The purpose of securing legal assistance before
remand is not merely symbolic, but it is to ensure that the
accused is afforded an effective opportunity to oppose the prayer
for police custody and to place before the magistrate any
circumstances that may warrant refusal or limitation of such
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
custody. If the accused is not represented through a Counsel,
he/she should be made aware that he/she is entitled for legal aid.
As far as possible, it shall be ensured that every accused person is
represented by an advocate, if he is not able to avail such
assistance, he should be given free legal aid. A three-judge Bench
of this Court in Ashok v. State of Uttar Pradesh7 held that an
accused who is not represented by an advocate is entitled for free
legal aid at all material stages starting from remand.”
(emphasis supplied)
15.
What emerges from the above is that the legislative intent behind
serving the grounds of arrest is to enable the arrested person to
effectively secure legal representation and to promptly seek any
appropriate legal remedies available, so that such remedies may be
exercised without any delay. This requirement is designed to empower
not only the arrestee but also those in a position to act on his behalf,
thereby safeguarding the right to life and personal liberty guaranteed
under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.
16.
It was further observed by the Apex Court in the judgment of
Mihir Rajesh Shah (supra) that in exceptional circumstances such as
offences against body or property committed in flagrante delicto, where
informing the grounds of arrest in writing on arrest is rendered
impractical, it shall be sufficient for the police officer or other person
making the arrest to orally convey the same to the person at the time of
arrest. Later, a written copy of grounds of arrest must be supplied to the
arrested person within a reasonable time and in no event later than two
hours prior to production of the arrestee before the magistrate for remand
proceedings. The conclusion was summed up as under:“56. In conclusion, it is held that:
i) The constitutional mandate of informing the arrestee the grounds
of arrest is mandatory in all offences under all statutes including
offences under IPC 1860 (now BNS 2023);
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
ii) The grounds of arrest must be communicated in writing to the
arrestee in the language he/she understands;
iii) In case(s) where, the arresting officer/person is unable to
communicate the grounds of arrest in writing on or soon after arrest,
it be so done orally. The said grounds be communicated in writing
within a reasonable time and in any case at least two hours prior to
production of the arrestee for remand proceedings before the
magistrate.
iv) In case of non-compliance of the above, the arrest and
subsequent remand would be rendered illegal and the person will be
at liberty to be set free.
xxx xxx xxx
58. We are cognizant that there existed no consistent or binding
requirement mandating written communication of the grounds of
arrest for all the offences. Holding as above, in our view, would
ensure implementation of the constitutional rights provided to an
arrestee as engrafted under Article 22 of the Constitution of India in
an effective manner. Such clarity on obligation would avoid
uncertainty in the administration of criminal justice. The ends of
fairness and legal discipline therefore demand that this procedure as
affirmed above shall govern arrests henceforth.”
(emphasis supplied)
17.
The date of decision of Mihir Rajesh Shah (supra) is 06.11.2025
and admittedly, the petitioner herein had been arrested much earlier i.e.
on 07.02.2024 and, therefore, he cannot be permitted to raise any
grievance.
18.
Mr. Sanjay Lao also divulges that petitioner has tried to
misrepresent that he was not aware about reason of his arrest till filing of
the chargesheet. The police had sought police custody of all the three
accused including petitioner herein, who had allegedly committed
murder, and the prosecution version was clearly specified in remand
papers also. He contends that all the three accused were duly represented
by their advocates when they were produced before the concerned
magisterial Court and that their advocates had even opposed grant of
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
‘police custody’, by contending that accused had been falsely implicated.
He submits that in view of above, it is quite evident that the petitioner
has not come up with complete and true facts. He also submits that the
application seeking cancellation of bail of his co-accused is already
pending adjudication before learned Single Judge of this Court and,
therefore, petitioner cannot seek any parity, either.
19.
There is one more aspect of the case. The grievance about the
alleged procedural lapse has been raised very belatedly i.e. after more
than one year and nine months of the arrest and there is no whisper of
any prejudice being caused to the petitioner, who was represented by
counsel from day one. Supreme Court in State of Karnataka v. Sri
Darshan: 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1702 has held that while compliance of
Section 50 Cr.P.C is mandatory, the consistent judicial approach has
been to adopt a ‘prejudice-oriented test’ when examining alleged
procedural lapses and, further held that mere absence of written grounds
does not ipso facto render the arrest illegal, unless it results in
demonstrable prejudice by denial of a fair opportunity to the accused to
defend themselves.
20.
In conspectus of the facts and circumstances, this Court finds that
the challenge to the arrest of the petitioner fails on three counts:
i.
The law laid down in Mihir Rajesh Shah (supra), insofar as it
mandates uniform written communication of grounds of arrest,
operates prospectively;
ii.
The petitioner’s clear and evident contemporaneous awareness
of the substance and basis of his arrest from the inception; and
iii.
Absence of any demonstrated prejudice, coupled with the
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
inordinate delay in raising the grievance.
21.
Consequently, we find no merit in the present petition and the
same is, accordingly, dismissed.
(VIVEK CHAUDHARY)
JUDGE
(MANOJ JAIN)
JUDGE
JANUARY 23, 2026/dr/pb/kp
W.P.(CRL) 4203/2025
Signed By:PRATIBHA
KUMARI
04:02:09
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review