Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.37056 of 2023
Sri Karan Karal
…….
Petitioner
-VersusThe learned District and
Sessions Judge, Jharsuguda
…….
Opp. Party
For the Petitioner : Mr. Umakant Sahoo, Advocate
For the Opp. Party : Mr. Jayant Kumar Bal, Addl. Govt. Advocate
CORAM:
THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE MANASH RANJAN PATHAK
AND
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SIBO SANKAR MISHRA
Date of Hearing & Judgment: 11.03.2026
S.S. Mishra, J. The petitioner’s late father Saroj Kumar Karal, who
was working as Sheristadar in the Civil Court, Jharsuguda and he
expired on 27.01.2016. The present petitioner filed an application
seeking appointment under the Rehabilitation Assistance Scheme on
21.08.2018. The committee constituted under the Odisha Civil
Service
(Rehabilitation
Assistance)
Amendment
Rules,
examined the case of the petitioner and on evaluation, awarded 55
points out of 100 points. The committee was of the view that the
application filed by the petitioner suffers a delay of 2 years, 7 months
of the death of his father. As per sub-rule (6) of Rule-9 of the Orissa
Civil Service (Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, 1990, the application
ought to have been filed within one year from the date of death of the
Government servant. In the exceptional cases, the limitation
prescribed under sub-rule may be condoned by the Government in the
concerned administrative department. Eventually, vide order dated
07.03.2020 passed by the District & Sessions Judge, Jharsuguda, the
application of the petitioner has been turned down on two grounds,
which is found mentioned in the penultimate paragraph of the order
itself. For convenience of ready reference, the grounds of rejection
read thus:
“(i) The application has not been filed on the
stipulated period as per Rule-9 of sub-rule (6). Further
in this case, there is a delay of more than 12 months.
(ii) The applicant has not passed the test in Oriya
equivalent to any standard as per Rule-6(4)(d) of the
Orissa District and Sub-ordinate Courts Non-judicial
Staff Services (Method of Recruitment and Condition
of Service), Rules, 2008 as amended in 2010.”
The Petitioner is aggrieved by the aforesaid order of the learned
District Judge. Hence, he has invoked the writ jurisdiction of this
Court seeking following reliefs:
i)
To quash the impugned order dtd. 07.03.2020 (Annexure-6) of
the learned District & Sessions Judge, Jharsuguda.
ii)
To direct the Opp. Parties to appoint the petitioner under
Rehabilitation Assistance Scheme in accordance with Odisha
Civil Services (Rehabilitation Assistance) Rule 1990 in any
post on compassionate ground within a time limit considering
his application.
2.
Heard Mr. Umakant Sahoo, learned Counsel for the petitioner
and Mr. Jayant Kumar Bal, learned Additional Government Advocate
for the opposite party.
3.
The principal issue highlighted by learned counsel for the
petitioner at the Bar is that two reasons for which his application has
been turned down by the opposite party are completely misplaced.
However, at this stage, he prefers not to embark upon those issues in
view of the recent amendment brought in the Rule.
He further submitted that the petitioner was a minor at the time
of the death of his father and as per Rule-9(7) of the Odisha District
and Subordinate Court's Non Judicial Staff Services (Method of
Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2008 (Amendment
Rules, 2010), which stipulates that:
"If at the time of death of the Government servant,
there is ward who is minor and who alone is available
in the family of the deceased Government servant for
employment, he/she shall apply for job under these
rules on attaining the age of eighteen years and in no
case beyond three years from the date of attaining the
age of eighteen years."
The father of the Petitioner, namely, Saroj Kumar Karal, who
was Ex-Sheristadar of the Court of learned Senior Civil Judge,
Jharsuguda, died on 27th January, 2016, and the application of the
Petitioner was filed on 21st August, 2018. Hence, it is contended that
the application was filed within the extendable time.
Further, it is submitted that the Petitioner passed Odia as a single
subject from the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha. Certificate to
that effect is available at Annexure-5 to the writ petition. According
to the petitioner, these materials were not taken into consideration by
the learned District and Sessions Judge, Jharsuguda while considering
his application for rehabilitation appointment.
4.
On perusal of the certificate at Annexure-5, it appears that the
said certificate, which discloses that the Petitioner passed Odia as a
single subject, was issued on 8th December, 2020, which is much
after rejection of his application for appointment under the Rule. Mr.
Sahoo, learned counsel for the Petitioner, however, submits that the
Petitioner had already passed M.E. standard in Odia subject, as
required under Rule 6(4)(d) of the Odisha District and Subordinate
Court's Non Judicial Staff Services (Method of Recruitment and
Conditions of Service) Rules, 2008. The learned counsel for the
petitioner has also apprised this Court of the same, and such
submission has been recorded in the order dated 09.10.2025.
5.
Be that as it may, learned counsel for the petitioner has also
drawn our attention to this Court’s order dated 23.06.2025 in W.P.(C)
No.15193 of 2022 and submits that the present writ petition is
squarely covered by the aforementioned order and therefore the same
may also be disposed of on similar terms, granting a fresh opportunity
to the petitioner for consideration of his application under the new
legal regime.
By virtue of notification dated 4th April, 2025, a suitable
amendment has been effected to the provisions of Rule 2 of the
Odisha Civil Services (Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, 2020. The
amended provision to Rule 6 of the said Rules has the following text:
"2. In the Odisha Civil Services (Rehabilitation
Assistance) Rules, 2020 (hereinafter referred to as the
"said rules"), in rule 6,- (i) for sub-rule (9), the
following sub-rule shall be substituted, namely:- "(9)
(a) All pending applications, relating to death of
Government employee prior to the date of
commencement of the Odisha Civil Services
(Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, 2020 shall be dealt
in accordance with the rules prevailing on the date of
death of Government employee for appointment under
Rehabilitation Assistance Scheme: Provided that in
case the death of Government employee occurred on
or after commencement of the Odisha Civil Service
(Rehabilitation Assistance) Amendment Rules, 2016
and before commencement of the Odisha Civil Services
(Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, 2020, shall be
governed by the provisions of the Odisha Civil Service
(Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, 1990."
6.
The moot question arises for consideration is that in the factual
scenario of the present case whether the amended Rule, 2020 is
applicable in the case of the petitioner or the earlier Rule of 1990 is
applicable. This question came for consideration in many other
occasions by way of writ petition. In one of such case, i.e., in the case
of Malaya Nanda Sethi vs. State of Odisha and others, arising out of
W.A. No.367 of 2021, the question arose, if an application for
rehabilitation assistance was filed before amendment of 2020 while
1990 Rule was prevailing, “whether the benefit of amendment can be
extended to such applicant merely because their application has been
pending and during pendency, 1990 Rule suffered amendment”. This
was negatively answered by this Court in the said Writ Appeal
Malaya Nananda Sethi (supra). The matter was taken to the Hon’ble
Supreme Court by filing Special Leave Petition [Civil Appeal No.
4103 of 2022 (Arising out of S.L.P.(Civil) No. 936/2022)]. The
Hon’ble Supreme Court has set aside the order vide judgment dated
26.10.2021 passed in W.A. No.367 of 2021 (Malaya Nanda Sethisupra) and held the appointment of the petitioner under the scheme
should not be refused in the guise of non-applicability of the amended
rule, 2020 merely because the petitioner had applied for rehabilitation
appointment under the erstwhile OCS Rehabilitation Assistance Rule,
1990. It is because of the lethargic and bureaucratic approach the
application remained pending for a longer time and in the meantime,
the amendment has taken place, the benefit of amendment must be
given to the petitioner. The prevailing Rule at the time of
consideration of the application shall only be applied.
7.
Learned Additional Government Advocate for the Opposite
Party submits that he has no objection to the contentions advanced on
behalf of the petitioner. In view of the amended provision, the case of
the petitioner may be considered afresh.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and upon perusal
of the materials on record, this Court finds that the petitioner would
be satisfied if his case is considered under the amended legal regime
brought into force by notification dated 4th April, 2025. Learned
Additional Government Advocate fairly submits that the case of the
petitioner can be considered under the amended provisions of the
Odisha Civil Services (Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules within a
reasonable time frame. Both sides further agreed that while
undertaking such consideration, all contentions of the parties shall
remain open to be examined by the competent authority in accordance
with law. Such a course, in the opinion of this Court, would meet the
ends of justice. Since the matter is to be reconsidered afresh, the
earlier rejection of the petitioner’s claim shall not stand in the way of
such fresh consideration.
9.
We expect the competent authority to strictly comply with the
direction of this Court and decide the fresh application to be filed by
the petitioner within the time frame fixed by this Court without any
further delay, particularly because of the reason that the petitioner has
applied for the benefit of Rehabilitation Assistance Scheme as on
21.08.2018 and aggrieved by the rejection order, he approached this
Court by filing a writ petition in the year 2023.
10.
In view of the above, the writ petition stands disposed of with a
direction to the competent authority to reconsider the case of the
petitioner under the amended provisions of the Odisha Civil Services
(Rehabilitation Assistance) Rules, as referred to above, and to pass
and decide the same on or before 30th of June 2026 in accordance
with law subject to filing of a fresh application by the petitioner on or
before 30.03.2026 before the appropriate/concerned authority along
with a certified copy of this order.
11.
The Writ Petition stands succeeded.
(Sibo Sankar Mishra)
Judge
I agree
(Manash Ranjan Pathak)
Judge
The High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Dated the 11th of March, 2026/Subhasis Mohanty
Digitally Signed
Signed by: SUBHASIS MOHANTY
Designation: Personal Assistant
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack.
Date: 20-Mar-2026 13:41:45
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review