Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
$
!
"
!
%%
& '
*
!!
Digitally signed
by
SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
"
!!
#
!
$
"
(& )
-2-
%
$
!!
$
&&
'
!!
$
!
!!
!
!!
!!
!
&"
!
!
(
"
!!
#
"
!!
"
-3-
!!
$
"
$
"
#
"
%
(
"
'
!!
"
"
$
$
"
!
!
!!
!!
#
-4-
!!
$
!
(
!!
$
"
!!
"
#
#
"
!!
"
%
(
!
!!
"
#
'
(
"
-5-
$
"
!!
#
!
!
"
"
#
!
$
!!
#
#
!!
!
-6-
%
!
!!
"
'
$
(
"
!!
!!
"
%
"
!
#
"
-7-
"
!!
%
!!
#
!
!
%
(
"
!!
'
"
$
"
'
!!
!
-8-
"
"
$
"
!!
#
!
$
!!
$
#
!!
"
!!
#
%
"
!
!
! !
#
!!
"
-9-
'
"
#
#$
"
!!
#
"
"
$
!!
#
#
"
!!
!!
"
!!
!!
#
) !!
*"
!
"
"
*
+
&
!!
&
"
#
!
+
- 10 -
!!
$
&
)
*"
!
!
!&
,
+
&
* +
&
*! +
!
$
$
!
$
"
-"
&
+
!!
#
!
$
"
&
!
% * +*.+
'* +
'* +
* +
* +
$'* +
$* +
* +*0+
* +*1+*.+
$
!
%
#
#
!
&
' * +
&
&&
!
"
' * +
* +
* +
* +
* +
$'* +
(
'$
* +*2+
&
&
&
& "
* +*/+
*! +
-"
&
!!
(
"
&
- 11 -
4"
!
5.0
677869
.0
:.98;
>58;<98
60?8
6=;
?/@>.?.80+
>?
<=;8/
8>?.@=
* +
@:
/.A8
*!/828=?.@=
@:
6=;
*!
+
@
$
@: </2.569
>58;<98
' ' *:@/ 05@/? B
D/6=? @: 6=?.>.76?@/E A6.9 .=
!@9.>8
$
/.F8
?6?.@= :@/ ?58 @::8=>80 7<=.056A98 <=;8/
% * +*.+
'* +
' * +
* +
* +
$'* +
$* +
' * +
%
/86; 1.?5
8>?.@=
* +*/+
6=;
*!
F8=;F8=?
?58 :.98 @:
* +*0+
>?
;;.?.@=69
6.>5</ 0.??.=D 6?
8>?.@=
8>?.@=0
* +
'* +
* +
* +
'$ @: "
6=;
$'* +
<=;8/
+
* +
>?C+ :@/
* +*1+*.+
* +*2+ @:
7/808=?9E 78=;.=D @=
$
.0?/.>? 6=;
800.@=0
<;D8
.=;56=</
58 :6>?<69 F6?/.G @: ?58 >608 .0 ?56? @=8
F6/8056
@
.;;6776
699. . 8
?58 >@F796.=? A8:@/8 /807@=;8=?
@=8
6=D6FF6
56=?6FF6
</D6776
./F696
/807@=;8=?
@
@
9@;D8;
7@9.>8 6998D.=D ?56?
6=H<=6?5
6/.E6FF6 6=;
./<76==6
6F805 6/8
- 12 -
A89@=D0 ?@
>58;<98;
60?8 6=; ?58E 6/8 ?58 /80.;8=?0 @:
6??.D<;;6 2.996D8 .=
.=;56=</
69<I
58 6778996=?0
6>><08; 6/8 690@ ?58 /80.;8=?0 @: 06F8 2.996D8 6=; ?58E
6/8 =@? ?58 F8FA8/0 @:
/.A8
>58;<98;
60?8 @/
58/8 160 6 ;.07<?8 A8?188=
:6?58/ .= 961
@:
>@F796.=6=?
F6/8056776 0@= @:
</D6776 15@ .0 ?58
6=;
6>><08;
5.FF6/6;;8776 .=
76?516E 986;.=D ?@ ?58./ 96=;0
>58;<98;
@'
/8078>? @:
58 89;8/0 @: ?58 :6F.9E
6=; 2.996D8/0 5628 08??98; ?58 06.; ;.07<?8
@1828/ ?58
6>><08; 18/8 =@</.05.=D .99 1.99 6=; 6=.F@0.?E 6D6.=0? ?58
2.>?.F0 >@F796.=6=? 6=; 5.0 :6F.9E F8FA8/0
5.=D0 0?@@; ?5<0
@= $%
$
6? 6A@<?
6 F ?58 6>><08; <08; >/.F.=69 :@/>8 6D6.=0?
3 $
6=D6FF6
1.?5 6= .=?8=?.@= ?@ @<?/6D8 58/ F@;80?E 6=; 058 160
F6=56=;98;
58 06.; :6>? 160 A/@<D5? ?@ ?58 =@?.>8 @:
89;8/0 6=; ?58E 5628 /80@928; ?58./ ;.07<?8
58/86:?8/
?58 6>><08; AE 056/.=D ?58 06.; F8006D80 .= 0@>.69 F8;.6
?5/@<D5 ?58./ >@FF<=.?E AE ?6/D8?.=D ?58 >60?8 @: ?58
2.>?.F0 @=
$
6? 6A@<?
$$ 7 F
6=6I6/8;;E
- 13 -
6=H<=6?5
@F608I56/
6=; "606=6D@<;6 5628 690@
:@/>8; 08G<69 :62@</ :/@F
./F696 6=; 56/6008; 58/
>>@/;.=D ?@ ?58 >@F796.=6=? ?58E F.0A85628; 1.?5 ?58
06.;
./F696 6=; 5@1828/ 058 80>678; :/@F ?58 >9<?>580
@: ?58 6>><08;
58/86:?8/ @=
%
$
@=>8 6D6.= ?58
!6=>56E6?5 160 >@=28E8; ?@ 08??98 ?58 ;.07<?8 A8?188=
?58 ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80
@1828/ ?58 2.>?.F0 ;.; =@? 6??8=;
?58 06.; 76=>56E6?
0 0<>5
$%3
7F
@=
$
6? 6A@<?
699 ?58 6>><08; 5628 :@/F8; 6= <=961:<9
6008FA9E AE 5@9;.=D 1867@=0 9.I8 >9<A0 /@; 0?@=8 I=.:8
6=; >5.99. 7@1;8/ 6=; ?/8076008; ?58 5@<08 @: ?58 2.>?.F0
58/86:?8/ ?58E 6006<9?8; ?58 2.>?.F0 AE F8=?.@=.=D ?58./
>60?8
;./8
58 6>><08; 5628 690@ ?5/86?8=8; ?58 2.>?.F0 1.?5
>@=08J<8=>80
&</?58/
6F@=D
?58
6>><08;
@F6058I56/
"606=6D@<;6
5.FF6/8;;E
./<76I056
F6/6D@<;6
6=<F6=?56
8;;E 6=; @=8
F/8056776
5628 F6;8 6= 6??8F7? ?@ >@FF.? /678 @: @=8
./F696
58E 690@ <08; >/.F.=69 :@/>8 6D6.=0? 58/ 1.?5 6= .=?8=?.@=
?@ @<?/6D8 58/ F@;80?E
58/86:?8/
?58E 6006<9?8; ?58
- 14 -
2.>?.F0 6=; >6<08; .=H</.80 AE ?6/D8?.=D ?58 >60?8 @: ?58
>@F796.=6=?
>>@/;.=D ?@ ?58 >@F796.=6=?
.=>.;8=? ?58 D@9;8= >56.= 18.D5.=D
.= ?58 06.;
?@960 160 9@0? 6=;
?58E 690@ ;6F6D8; ?58 5@<08 @: ?58 2.>?.F0
6?8/ ?58
2.>?.F0
@07.?69
18/8
05.:?8;
?@
?58
@28/=F8=?
.=;56=</ 6=; 6>>@/;.=D9E ?58E 9@;D8; ?58 >@F796.=? @=
'
$
@
?58
6? $ 3$$ 7 F 15.>5 160 /8D.0?8/8; .=
$
;6?8;
'
6:@/8F8=?.@=8;
$
AE ?58
@::8=>80
/.F8
</2.569 !@9.>8 :@/
>>@/;.=D
?@
?58
6>><08; 6778996=?0 828/ 0.=>8 ?58 ;6?8 @: /8D.0?/6?.@= @:
&
/807@=;8=?
@
7@9.>8 6/8 F6I.=D 58>?.> 6??8F7?0
?@ 6//80? ?58 6778996=?0
0 0<>5
677/858=0.@= @: ?58./ 6//80?
;;.?.@=69
6?
/9
.0?/.>? 6=;
?58E 6/8 <=;8/ ?58
8=>8 ?58E 677/@6>58; ?58
800.@=0 <;D8
.=;56=</
:@/
D/6=?
.0>
$
6=; ?58 06F8 160 /8H8>?8; 2.;8
@
@/;8/ ;6?8;
$
$
@:
6.>5</ 0.??.=D
6=?.>.76?@/E
A6.9
.=
8=>8 ?5.0 677869
86/; ?58 986/=8; >@<=089 :@/ ?58 6778996=?0
6=;
986/=8;
.D5
@</?
@28/=F8=?
!986;8/
:@/
- 15 -
/807@=;8=?
@
?6?8
7/808=? A8:@/8 ?58
807@=;8=?
@
.0 78/0@=699E
@</?
76/? :/@F </D.=D 0828/69 >@=?8=?.@=0 986/=8;
>@<=089 :@/ ?58 6778996=?0 7/.F6/.9E >@=?8=;8; ?56? ?58
:6908 >608 560 A88= :@.0?8; AE ?58 >@F796.=6=? 0.=>8 ?58/8
160 6 76?516E ;.07<?8 A8?188= ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80
8 690@
>@=?8=?8; ?56? 6 >@<=?8/ >@F796.=? 560 A88= /8D.0?8/8; .=
/.F8
@
'
$
;6?8;
'
$
.= /8078>? ?@ ?58
06F8 .=>.;8=? :@/ ?58 @::8=>80 7<=.056A98 <=;8/
'* +
' * +
* + / 1
' * +
8>?.@=
* + %
'$ @: "
$
8>?.@=0
* +
$'* +
6D6.=0? #
78/0@=0
.=>9<;.=D ?58 >@F796.=6=? 6=; ?58 2.>?.F0 .= ?5.0 >608
8 :</?58/ >@=?8=;8; ?56?
@= 78/<069 @: ?58
>@F796.=? 628/F8=?0 ?58 06F8 ;87.>?0 @F=.A<0 6998D6?.@=0
6D6.=0? 699 ?58 6>><08; 1.?5@<? 796>.=D 6=E
F6?8/.69 ?@ 6??/6>? ?58 7/@2.0.@= <=;8/ ?58 "
?58
7/@2.0.@=
@:
*!
+
>?
@/ <=;8/
;;.?.@=699E
>@=?8=?8; ?56? ;</.=D ?58 >@</08 @: .=280?.D6?.@= .? 160
/828698; ?56? ?58 2.>?.F0 5628 =@? 0<0?6.=8; 6=E .=H</.80
- 16 -
60 6998D8; .= ?58 >@F796.=? 6=; ?58E 5628 0<0?6.=8; @=9E
6A/60.@=0 6=; ?58 7@9.>8 5628 =@? 08.K8; ?58 D@9;8=
6/?.>980 15.>5 18/8 6998D8;9E 9@0? .= ?58 .=>.;8=?
56? .?089:
05@10
AE
:6908
>@F796.=6=?
>@F796.=?
A88=
:@.0?8;
?58
8 0<AF.?0 ?56? ?5.0 .0 6 ;.07<?8 A8?188= ?58
?1@ >@FF<=.?.80 60 0<>5 ?58/8 .0 =@ 0<>5 .=>.;8=? 560
>6<08;
>>@/;.=D9E 58 7/6E0 ?@ 699@1 ?58 677869
986/=8;
.D5
@</?
@28/=F8=?
2858F8=?9E @77@08; ?58 7/6E8/ 6=; >@=?8=?8; ?56? ?58
6778996=?0 6/8 =@? 8=?.?98; :@/ 6=?.>.76?@/E A6.9 .= 2.81 @:
?58 A6/ <=;8/
8>?.@=
* + @:
*!
+
>? &</?58/
58 690@ >@=?8=;8; ?56? ?58 >@F796.=6=? .= ?5.0 >608 560
9@;D8; ?5.0 >@F796.=? 6=; 0<A08J<8=?9E 6 :6908 >@F796.=?
560 A88= 9@;D8; AE ?58 6778996=?0
= 0<>5 >./><F0?6=>8
>608 F6;8 @<? 6D6.=0? ?5808 6778996=?0
>>@/;.=D9E 58 7/6E0 ?@ ;.0F.00 ?58 677869
#
807@=;8=?
@
.0 7/808=? A8:@/8 ?5.0
@</?
6=; 796>8; ?58 75@?@D/6750 @: ?58 .=H</.80 0<0?6.=8; AE
- 17 -
5.F 6=; @?58/ :6F.9E F8FA8/0 6=; 7/6E0 ?@ ;.0F.00 ?58
677869
%
5628 D.28= FE 6=G.@<0 >@=0.;8/6?.@= A@?5 @=
?58 0<AF.00.@= F6;8 AE ?58 986/=8; >@<=089 :@/ ?58
/8078>?.28 76/?.80 6=; /807@=;8=?
@
0@ 690@ 78/<08;
?58 ;@><F8=?0 F6;8 626.96A98 A8:@/8 ?5.0
>@F796.=6=?
>@<9;
A8
D6?58/8;
2.>?.F0
6=;
/80.;.=D .= ?58 06F8 2.996D8
?58
:/@F
@</?
/8>@/;0
?58
6>><08; 6778996=?0
6/8
58/8 .0 6 ;.07<?8 78=;.=D
A8?188= ?58F .= /8078>? @: 6 76?516E &</?58/ @= >6/8:<9
78/<069 @: ?58 >@F796.=? 628/F8=?0 .? .0 0?6?8; ?56? @=
0828/69 @>>60.@=0 !6=>56E6?5 18/8 589; ?@ /80@928 ?58
;.07<?8 A8?188= ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80
>@F796.=6=?
?58 6778996=?0 . 8
#
>>@/;.=D ?@ ?58
78/0@=0 6? 6 ?.F8
8=?8/8; ?58./ 5@<08 6=; F6;8 6= 6??8F7? ?@ @<?/6D8 ?58
F@;80?E @: @=8
./F696 6=; 690@ 6006<9?8; ?58F 1.?5
;86;9E 1867@=0
@1828/ ?58 1@<=; >8/?.:.>6?8 ;.0>9@080
?56?
0<0?6.=8;
?58E
@=9E
0.F798
.=H</.80
.8
- 18 -
6A/60.@=0 6=; .FF8;.6?89E ;.0>56/D8; :/@F ?58
@07.?69
6:?8/ ?6I.=D :./0? 6.;
'
0 /.D5?9E >@=?8=?8; AE ?58 986/=8; >@<=089 :@/
?58 6778996=?0 ?58 .=280?.D6?.@= @::.>8/ 560 =@? 08.K8; 6=E
D@9;8= 6/?.>980
8>?.@=
@ ;@<A? ?58/8 .0 6 A6/ 7/@2.;8; <=;8/
* + @: ?58
6=?.>.76?@/E A6.9
*!
@1828/ ?58
+
@=4A98
>? :@/ D/6=? @:
78G
@</? .= ?58
>608 @:
/87@/?8;
.=
.? .0 589; ?56? 699 .=0<9?0 @/
.=?.F.;6?.@=0 ?@ 6 78/0@= 1.99 =@? A8 6= @::8=>8 <=;8/ ?58
>? <=9800 0<>5 .=0<9? @/ .=?.F.;6?.@= .0 @= 6>>@<=? @:
2.>?.F A89@=D0 ?@
&</?58/
?58
@=4A98
/87@/?8; .=
% 60 <=;8/3
>58;<98;
78G
60?8 @/
>58;<98;
/.A8
@</? .= ?58 >608 @:
!
560 589; .= 76/6
- 19 -
!
#
"
$
%
'
&
"
%
&
$
#
"
%
"
&
"
%
"
$
#
%
"
(
$
)
= ?58 .=0?6=? >608
6;F.??8;9E ?58/8 .0 6
>@<=?8/ >@F796.=? :.98; AE ?58 6>><08;
>@F796.=6=? 6=; 2.>?.F0 6/8 6>><08;
?58 /.269 >@F796.=?0 6=; &
.= 15.>5
?58
= >6/8:<9 78/<069 @:
.? >@<9; A8 D6?58/8; ?56? ?58
>608 6=; 6 >@<=?8/ >608 160 :@.0?8; .= 2.81 @: ?58 D/@<7
>9605 .= A8?188= ?1@ >@FF<=.?.80 1.?5 /8078>? ?@ ?58
76?516E
- 20 -
=
0<>5
.=?8//@D6?.@=
@:
?58
>./><F0?6=>80
?58
><0?@;.69
6778996=?0
=@?
>699
;@80
:@/
>>@/;.=D9E 1.?5@<? 8G7/800.=D 6=E @7.=.@= @= ?58 F8/.?0
@: ?58 >608 0<::.>8 ?@ 5@9; ?56? ?58 6778996=?0 6>><08; >6=
8=>8 ?58 :@99@1.=D,
A8 8=96/D8; @= 6=?.>.76?@/E A6.9
.
/.F.=69
77869 .0
"" #
..
@/;8/
;6?8;
$
/9
.0>
@
$
AE ?58
6=;
800.@=0 <;D8
$
76008;
;;9
6.>5</ 0.??.=D 6?
.=
.0?/.>?
.=;56=</
.0 58/8AE 08? 60.;8
...
58 6778996=?0 6>><08;
@0
#
?@ #
6/8 ;./8>?8; ?@ A8 8=96/D8; @= A6.9 .=
/.F8
@
$
/8D.0?8/8;
?6?.@=
:@/
?58
@::8=>80
8>?.@=0
% * +*.+
'* +
* +
* +
$'* +
AE
'* +
* +
?@ #
</2.569
!@9.>8
7<=.056A98
<=;8/
' * +
' * +
* +
* +
* +
$'* +
$* +
- 21 -
%
/86; 1.?5
8>?.@=
8>?.@=0
* +*/+
6=;
*!
'$ @: "
* +*0+
+
$
* +*1+*.+
F8=;F8=?
>?
6=;
* +*2+ @:
$
0<AH8>?
8G8><?8
0<F
@:
?@ ?58 :@99@1.=D >@=;.?.@=03
6+
78/0@=69
6778996=?0
A@=;
05699
:@/
$$ $$$
86>5 1.?5 ?1@ 0</8?.80 :@/
?58 9.I80<F
?@ ?58 06?.0:6>?.@= @: ?58
H</.0;.>?.@=69
@</?,
A+
58 6778996=?0 05699 67786/ /8D<96/9E
@= 699 ?58 ;6?80 @: 586/.=D A8:@/8 ?58
/.69
@</?
8G8F7?0
<=9800
?58./
?58
67786/6=>8
/.69
@</?
:@/
269.;
/860@=0,
>+
58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? ;./8>?9E @/
.=;./8>?9E ?5/86?8= @/ ?6F78/ 1.?5 ?58
7/@08><?.@= 1.?=80080,
- 22 -
;+
58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? .=2@928 .=
0.F.96/ @::8=>80 .= :<?</8,
8+
58 6778996=?0 05699 =@? 98628 ?58
H</.0;.>?.@= @: ?58
/.69
@</? 1.?5@<?
78/F.00.@= @: ?58 06.;
@</? <=?.9 ?58
>608 /8D.0?8/8; 6D6.=0? ?58F .0 ;.07@08;
@::
:+
6778996=?0
05699
6??8=;6=>8 A8:@/8 ?58
::.>8/
</2.569 !@9.>8
F6/I
?58./
?6?.@=
@<08
?6?.@=
@= :./0?
<=;6E @: 828/E F@=?5 A8?188=
$ $$
6F
>608
6=;
$
$$
7F
?.99
?58
/8D.0?8/8; 6D6.=0? ?58F .0 ;.07@08; @::
A8:@/8 ?58 /.69
@</?
+'
&
!
)
!
.0?
@3
@3
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review