The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. The only limited question which has been raised by the petitioner in the instant petition being the aforesaid issue, the instant petition is allowed, and respondents are directed to provided an adequate opportunity to the petitioner by making effective representation before imposing the penalty which if be done will be in conformity with Rules 35 Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956.
17. Let the entire exercise shall be done by the respondents within a period of four weeks from the date opportunity is given by the respondents to the petitioner to make a effective representation in tune with the aforesaid Rule 35 Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956. Subject to providing an opportunity to petitioner to make an effective representation, to the respondents, the respondents shall pass the final order in consonance with the Rules. As a necessary corollary, the impugned order dated 08.09.2023 is hereby set-aside/quashed.
18. The writ petition is accordingly, disposed of in the aforesaid manner. (Wasim Sadiq Nargal) Judge Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes/No Whether the judgment is speaking Yes/No Jammu:
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Sr. No. 12
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
Pronounced on 03.09.2026
Uploaded on 08.09.2026
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
Kamni Kesar, Age 62 years.
S/o Late Sh. Raghunath
Sharma
R/o H. No. 224, Lane No. 3
Hazuri-Bagh, Raod, Bhori,
Talab Tillor, Jammu.
Through:-
…. Petitioner(s)
Mr. Sachin Gupta, Advocate.
V/s
1. Union Territory of Jammu
and Kashmir through
Commissioner Secretary
Housing and Urban
Development Department Civil
Secretariat Jammu.
2. Commissioner, Jammu
Municipal Corporation,
Townhall, Jammu.
3. Joint Commissioner (Adm),
Jammu Municipal Corporation.
4. Joint Commissioner (R&E)
Jammu Municipal corporation.
5. Chief Accounts Officer,
Municipal Corporation Jammu.
Through:-
…..Respondent(s)
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, GA
Mr. Mayank Gupta, Advocate.
CORAM: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE WASIM SADIQ NARGAL, JUDGE
JUDGMENT (ORAL)
03.09.2026
1.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the only grievance
which has been raised by the petitioner in the instant petition is that
respondent No. 1 before imposing the penalty by way of a fine
equivalent to one month salary in terms of Jammu and Kashmir
Civil Service (Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956, has
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
not issued show-cause notice to the petitioner, which according to
learned counsel was mandatory in terms of Rule 35 of Jammu and
Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules,
1956 for facility of reference, the same is reproduced as under:Adequate opportunity of making any representation be given
to the officer concerned before issuing order imposing
penalty.
Without prejudice to the provisions of rule 33, no order
imposing the penalty {specified in clause (i), (ii), (iii), ad (v)
of rule 30 (other than an order based on facts which have
led to his convictions in a criminal court or by a courtmartial, or an order superseding him for promotion to a
higher post on the ground of his unfitness for that post} on
any government servant to whom these rules are applicable
shall be passed unless he has been given an adequate
opportunity of making any representation that he may desire
to make any such representation, if any, has been taken into
consideration before the order is passed.
Provided that the requirements of this rule may, for
sufficient reasons to be recorded in writing, be waived where
there is difficulty in observing them and where they can be
waived without injustice to the officer concerned.
2.
With a view to appreciate the aforesaid statutory provision it would
also be apt to refer to Rule 33 of CCA Rules as well. The same is
reproduce under:33. Issue of an order of dismissal, removal or reduction in
rank
33 (1) Without- prejudice to provisions of the Public Servants
Inquiries Act, 1977, no order (other than an order based on
facts which had led to his conviction in a criminal court or
by a court-martial) of dismissal, removal, or reduction in
rank 1 [which includes reduction to a lower post and/or
lower timescale - and/or to a lower stage in time-scale] but
excludes the reversion to a lower post of a person who is
holding a higher post temporarily shall be passed on a
person who is a member of a Civil service, or holds a Civil
post under the State unless he has been informed in writing
of the grounds on which it is proposed to take action and has
been afforded and adequate opportunity of defending
himself. The ground s on which it is proposed to take action
shall be reduced in the form of a definite charge or charges
which shall be communicated to the person charged,
together with a statement of tile allegations on which each
charge is based and of any other circumstances which it is
proposed to take into consideration in passing orders on the
case. He shall be required, within a reasonable time, to put
in a written statement of his defence and to state whether he
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
desires to be head in person. If he so desires, or if the
authority concerned so directs, an oral inquiry shall be held
in respect of such of the allegations as are not admitted. At
that inquiry such oral evidence will be heard, as the
inquiring officer considers necessary. The person charged
shall be entitled to cross-examine the witnesses, to give
evidence in person and to have such witnesses called as he
may wish; provided that the officer conducting the inquiry
may for sufficient reason to be recorded in writing refuse to
call a witness. The proceedings shall contain a sufficient
record of the evidence and statement of the findings and the
grounds thereof.
(2) The rule shall not apply where the person concerned has
absconded, or where it is for other reasons impracticable to
communicate with him, or where in the interest of the
security of the State, it is considered not expedient to give to
that person an opportunity of showing cause against the
action proposed to be taken against him. All or any of the
provisions of the rule may for sufficient reasons to be
recorded in writing be waived, where there is difficulty in
observing exactly the requirements of the rule and those
requirements can in the opinion of the inquiring officer be
waived without injustice to the person charged.
(3) this shall also not apply where it is proposed to terminate the
employment of a probationer whether during or at the end of
the period of probation, or to dismiss, remove or reduce in
rank a temporary government servant, for any specific fault
or on account of his unsuitability for the service.
(4) the competent authority may inquire into the charges itself or
if it considers it necessary so to do, it may appoint an inquiry
officer for the purpose.
3.
From a conjoint reading
of
Rule 33 read with Rule 35, it is
apparently clear that, without prejudice to the provisions of Rule 33,
no order imposing the penalty in Clauses (i), (ii), (iii), and (v) of
Rule 30 (other than this) on any Government servant to whom these
rules are applicable shall be passed unless he has been given an
adequate opportunity of making any representation that he may
desire to make before the order is passed.
4.
It is specific case of the petitioner that no adequate opportunity was
provided in terms of Rules 35 of Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services
Rule, (Control Classification and Appeal) Rules, 1956, and before
imposing the punishment which is subject matter of the instant
petition.
5.
The learned counsel, with a view to fortify his claim, has placed
reliance upon the judgment passed by this Court in case titled as N.
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
C Prabhakar V/S State of J&K and Ors. being SWP No.
293/2001 C/w connected matter decided on 06.02.2009 & LPASW
No. 138 of 2009; decided on 19.04.2010, wherein, in the aforesaid
judgment, the Hon’ble Division Bench has already affirmed the order
of the learned Single Judge, whereby the Division Bench concurred
with the view that no adequate opportunity of hearing was provided
before imposing the punishment in consonance with the provisions
of the Rule 35 of Jammu and Kashmir Civil Services Rule, (Control,
Classification and Appeal) Rules, 1956. For non-compliance of the
same, the order/judgment was passed by the learned Writ Court,
which order was affirmed by the learned Division Bench in case
titled State of J&K V/s N. C Prabhakar decided on 19.04.2010
being LPASW No. 138/2009.
6.
Another judgment which has been relied upon by the learned counsel
for the petitioner in which it has been held that competent authority
was not empowered to inflict any other penalties envisaged under
Rule 30 of the Rules of 1956 upon a person who has ceased to be a
member of service. In WP(C) No. 2027/2024 decided on
11.09.2025 in case titled Sudershan Mehta V/s UT of J&K, it is
held that the petitioner cannot be subjected to the Departmental
proceedings for the misconduct committed during the period he was
in service as the rule do not envisage the conduct of disciplinarily
enquiry into the misconduct of delinquent employee after his
superannuation and relaying upon aforesaid principle, the impugned
judgment before the Hon’ble Division Bench, to the extent it upheld
the action of respondents for recovery of remuneration received by
the petitioner from JKCA from his pension, was quashed and setaside.
7.
Relying upon aforesaid judgment passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench in the similar facts and circumstance of the case, the learned
counsel for the petitioner submits that admittedly, in the instant
matter, no opportunity of being heard has been provided to the
petitioner in terms of the aforesaid Rules and therefore, the order
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
which is impugned in the instant petition is vitiated and cannot
sustain in the eyes of law and is liable to be se-aside.
8.
Learned counsel for the petitioner has confined his argument only to
the aforesaid legal issue.
9.
Mr. Mayank Gupta learned appearing counsel for the respondent
Nos. 2 to 5, on the other hand, submits that the instant writ petition
is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed for the reasons that
the petitioner has alternate remedy of filing an appeal against the
impugned order before the competent authority in terms of Rules 36
of Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service (Classification, Control, and
Appeal) Rules, 1956 for facility of reference, the same is reproduced
as under :“Appeals every member of a service shall be entitled to
appeal, as hereinafter provided, from an order passed by
any authority imposing upon him any of the penalties
specified in rule 30;provided that no appeal shall lie
against the order made by the Government.”
10. Admittedly, according to the learned counsel for the respondents, the
petitioner has not availed the said efficacious and alternate remedy
by way of an appeal before the competent authority and has bypassed
the statute by filing the instant writ, petition, which, according to the
learned counsel for the respondents, is not maintainable. In addition,
it has also been submitted that the petitioner has also a remedy of
filing a review in terms of Rules 55 of the aforesaid Rules and,
therefore, bypassing the
aforesaid
provision, the petitioner has
straightaway filed the instant petition, which is not maintainable.
11. Mr. Mayank Gupta, Advocate, further clarifies that the petitioner is
not aggrieved of the enquiry being conducted against the petitioner;
rather, the grievance which has been projected by the petitioner in
the instant petition is that, before imposing the punishment, the
show-cause notice has not been issued. Therefore, the relief of the
petitioner must confine to the issuance of the show-cause notice,
which according to the learned counsel for the respondents has not
been issued.
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
12.
Mr. Suneel Malhotra, learned GA appearing counsel on behalf of the
respondent No.1 also adopts the reply alredy filed by the respondent
Nos. 2 to 5 and well as the arguments advanced by the learned
counsel appearing on behalf of Nos. 2 to 5.
13.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and also learned counsel for
appearing for the respondents at length and perused the record.
14.
Since the only grievance which has been projected in the instant writ
petition by the learned counsel for the petitioner is that no showcause notice has been issued to the petitioner in terms of the Rules 35
of CCA Rules before imposing the punishment, thus, this Court,
without venturing into the maintainability of the instant petition,
deems it proper to dispose of the instant writ petition at this stage
with the consent of the learned counsel for the respondents, as the
relief which has been projected in the instant writ petition is
restricted only to the extent of non-issuance of the show-cause notice
in terms of the aforesaid rules
15.
The respondents have also admitted the non-compliance of the
aforesaid statutory provision, which led to the passing of the order
impugned. Therefore, this Court without wasting the time in the
instant matter or venturing in to maintainability of the instant
petition, deems it appropriate to dispose of the instant writ petition
at this stage by directing the respondent Nos. 2 to 5 to proceed
strictly in consonance with the Rules 35 of Jammu and Kashmir
Civil Service (Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956, by
providing an adequate opportunity to the petitioner to make a
representation before imposing the penalty if permissible under
Rules and the respondents deems it appropriate to impose the same
as the petitioner is not aggrieved of the conduct of the enquiry
proceedings but the only grievance raised in the instant petition is
that adequate opportunity in terms of the aforesaid Rules has not
been provide to the petitioner.
16.
The only limited question which has been raised by the petitioner in
the instant petition being the aforesaid issue, the instant petition is
allowed, and respondents are directed to provided an adequate
WP(C) No. 2472/2023
opportunity to the petitioner by making effective representation
before imposing the penalty which if be done will be in conformity
with Rules 35 Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service (Classification,
Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956.
17. Let the entire exercise shall be done by the respondents within a
period of four weeks from the date opportunity is given by the
respondents to the petitioner to make a effective representation in
tune with the aforesaid Rule 35 Jammu and Kashmir Civil Service
(Classification, Control, and Appeal) Rules, 1956. Subject to
providing an opportunity to petitioner to make an effective
representation, to the respondents, the respondents shall pass the
final order in consonance with the Rules. As a necessary corollary,
the impugned order dated 08.09.2023 is hereby set-aside/quashed.
18. The writ petition is accordingly, disposed of in the aforesaid manner.
(Wasim Sadiq Nargal)
Judge
Whether the judgment is reportable: Yes/No
Whether the judgment is speaking Yes/No
Jammu:
03.09.2026.
Javid Iqbal
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review