The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
15. Accordingly, the findings that the plaintiff and defendant No.1 are coowners of the suit property and that the plaintiff is entitled to half share therein are findings of fact based on proper appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence on record. The said findings have been concurrently recorded and do not suffer from perversity or any misapplication of law so as to give rise to any substantial question of law.
16. Consequently, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in the present appeals. The appeals are, therefore, dismissed at the admission stage itself. Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru) Judge Rahul/Gowri
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:12057
NAFR
RAHUL
JHA
Digitally signed
by RAHUL JHA
Date: 2026.03.16
17:56:20 +0530
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SA No. 631 of 2024
Kamlesh S/o Anupchand Jain Aged About 31 Years R/o Village Arjunda,
Tahsil Gundardehi, Present R/o Devri, Tahsil Daondilohara, District Balod,
Chhattisgarh. (Defendant No. 1)
Appellant(s)
versus
1 - Pankaj Kumar S/o Anupchand Jain Aged About 29 Years R/o Village
Singarpur, Tahsil Daondilohara, District Balod, Chhattisgarh. (Plaintiff)
2 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through District Magistrate, Balod, District Balod,
Chhattisgarh. (Defendant No. 2)
Respondent(s)
And
SA No. 8 of 2025
Kamlesh S/o Anupchand Jain Aged About 31 Years R/o Village Arjunda,
Tahsil Gundardehi, Present R/o Devri, Tahsil Daondilohara, District- Balod
( C.G.)
Appellant(s)
Versus
1 - Pankaj Kumar S/o Anupchand Jain Aged About 29 Years R/o Village
Singarpur, Tahsil Daondilohara, District- Balod ( C.G. ).
2 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- District- Magistrate, Balod, Distt- Balod
( C.G. ).
Respondent(s)
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Rajkumar Pali, Advocate
For Resp No.1
:
Mr. Shikhar Bhaktiyar, Advocate on caveat
For Resp. No.2.
:
Mr. Malay Jain, PL
Hon'ble Shri Justice Bibhu Datta Guru
Judgment on Board
13/03/2026
1.
Since both the Second Appeals arise out of the same civil suit and
involve common facts, they were heard analogously and are being
decided by this common judgment. Second Appeal No. 631/2024 arises
out of the judgment and decree affirming the preliminary decree,
whereas Second Appeal No. 08/2025 arises out of the judgment and
decree affirming the final decree passed in the same suit.
2.
The present Second Appeals have been preferred under Section 100 of
the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 by the defendant, who is the
appellant herein, challenging the common judgment and decree dated
19/11/2024 passed in Civil Appeal No. 40A/2019 and Civil Appeal No.
8A/2020 (Kamlesh Kumar v. Pankaj Kumar & Others) by the learned
Principal District Judge, Balod. By the impugned judgment and decree,
the First Appellate Court dismissed the appeals preferred by the
defendant/appellant and affirmed the preliminary judgment and decree
dated 12/09/2019 as well as the final decree dated 12/02/2020 passed by
the learned Trial Court in Civil Suit No. 9A/2016 (Pankaj Kumar v.
Kamlesh Kumar & Others).
3.
For the sake of convenience, the parties shall hereinafter be referred to
as per their status before the Trial Court.
4.
(a)
Brief facts of the case are that the plaintiffs instituted Civil Suit
No. 9A/2016 before the learned Trial Court seeking partition and
separate possession of their half share in the suit land bearing Khasra
No. 985/4 admeasuring 0.02 hectare situated at Village Arjunda, Tahsil
Gundardehi, District Balod. It was pleaded that the respective fathers of
the plaintiff and defendant No.1, namely Anupchand and Gulabchand,
are real brothers. The suit property was purchased by their grandfather
Bhanwarlal Jain from one Prakash S/o Surajmal Jain in the names of the
plaintiff and defendant No.1 when they were minors. According to the
plaintiffs, the property was purchased for the benefit of both parties so
that they may carry on business in future and the same constituted their
joint property.
(b)
It was further pleaded that the respective fathers of the parties
later started residing separately and the plaintiff has been residing with
his father at Village Singarpur, whereas defendant No.1 has been
residing with his father at Village Arjunda. It was alleged that defendant
No.1, without the consent of the plaintiff, constructed a house over the
suit land and started carrying on business therefrom. When the plaintiff
demanded partition of the suit property, defendant No.1 refused to do so.
The plaintiff thereafter approached the Tahsildar, Gundardehi for
partition; however, it was orally informed that since a house had already
been constructed over the suit land, the revenue authorities had no
jurisdiction to adjudicate the dispute. On these grounds, the plaintiff
sought partition of the suit property and delivery of vacant possession of
his half share.
(c)
Defendant No.1 filed a written statement denying the plaint
allegations. It was contended that the suit land was purchased when the
respective fathers of the parties had separated due to family disputes and
that the house constructed over the land was built by the father of
defendant No.1 from his own funds. It was further pleaded that the
plaintiff and his father had taken goods worth about Rs. 8,00,000/- from
the shop of defendant No.1 and his father between the years 2005 to
2008 for their business at Village Singarpur and had not returned the
said amount. According to the defendant, it was mutually agreed
between the elders of the family that the share of the plaintiff in the suit
land would be adjusted towards the said amount, and therefore the
plaintiff had no subsisting right or share over the suit property. On these
grounds, dismissal of the suit was prayed for.
(c)
After considering the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial
Court framed as many as five issues for determination. The learned Trial
Court, after appreciating the oral and documentary evidence available
on record, decreed the suit holding that the plaintiff has successfully
established that the suit land bearing Khasra No. 985/6 admeasuring
0.02 hectare situated at Village Arjunda is jointly owned by the plaintiff
and defendant No.1 and that the plaintiff is entitled to ½ share in the suit
property. The Trial Court further held that the plaintiff is entitled to
obtain separate possession of his half share from defendant No.1. It was
also held that although the suit was not properly valued, the defect was
curable in nature, and the suit was found to be within limitation.
Accordingly, by judgment and decree dated 12/09/2019, the Trial Court
passed a preliminary decree declaring the half share of the plaintiff in
the suit property. Thereafter, in the final decree proceedings, the learned
Trial Court, by judgment and decree dated 12/02/2020, proceeded to
effectuate the preliminary decree and passed the final decree by
directing partition of the suit property in accordance with the shares
already declared, thereby granting consequential relief to the plaintiff.
5.
Aggrieved by the aforesaid judgment and decree passed by the learned
Trial Court, defendant No.1 preferred Civil Appeal No. 40A/2019
against the preliminary judgment and decree dated 12/09/2019 and Civil
Appeal No. 8A/2020 against the final judgment and decree dated
12/02/2020 before the learned Principal District Judge, Balod. The
learned First Appellate Court, by the common judgment and decree
dated 19/11/2024, dismissed both the appeals and affirmed the judgment
and decrees passed by the learned Trial Court. Hence, these Second
Appeals have been preferred by the defendant/appellant.
6.
Learned counsel for the appellant/defendant No.1 would submit that the
judgments and decrees passed by the learned both the Courts are
contrary to law and the evidence available on record. It is contended that
the learned First Appellate Court committed an error in treating the
preliminary decree and final decree as separate judgments despite the
final decree having been passed during the pendency of the appeal. It is
further submitted that the application filed by the appellant under Order
VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure was wrongly rejected.
Learned counsel would also contend that both the Courts failed to
properly appreciate the pleadings and evidence on record, particularly
the documents (Ex.P/51 to Ex.P/55) and the alleged family settlement,
and erred in holding that only the plaintiff and defendant No.1 are
entitled to share in the suit property. It is further argued that the suit was
not maintainable as other family members were not impleaded as parties
and that the Courts have erroneously held the suit to be within
limitation. On these grounds, it is submitted that the impugned
judgments and decrees suffer from serious legal infirmities and are
liable to be set aside.
7.
I have heard learned counsel for the appellant on the question of
admission and have carefully perused the impugned judgments and
decrees passed by both the Courts as well as the material available on
record.
8.
At the outset, it is to be noted that the jurisdiction of this Court under
Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure is confined to the
examination of substantial questions of law. Interference with
concurrent findings of fact recorded by both the Courts is permissible
only where such findings are shown to be perverse, based on no
evidence, or founded on an erroneous application of law. Upon
consideration of the submissions advanced, this Court does not find that
the present appeal satisfies the aforesaid parameters.
9.
A careful perusal of the record would show that the plaintiff has
produced the registered sale deed dated 11/05/1994 (Ex.P/1), which
demonstrates that the suit land was purchased in the joint names of the
plaintiff and defendant No.1 during their minority through their
guardians. The documentary evidence further indicates that the property
stood recorded in their names in the revenue records. Both parties, in
their cross-examination, have admitted that the property was purchased
when they were minors and that the transaction was executed through
their guardians.
10.
The defence set up by the defendant was that the plaintiff and his father
had taken grocery goods worth about Rs.8,00,000/- from the shop of the
defendant and his father between the years 2005 and 2008, and that the
share of the plaintiff in the suit property was later adjusted towards the
said alleged dues. However, the material placed on record does not
substantiate such plea. The documents relied upon by the defendant
(Ex.D/51 to Ex.D/55) are merely entries in private account papers
without signatures of the plaintiff or his father and do not constitute
reliable proof of the alleged liability. In view of Section 34 of the Indian
Evidence Act, such entries in books of account by themselves are
insufficient to fasten liability in the absence of independent
corroboration.
11.
Further, no written acknowledgment or registered document has been
produced to show that the plaintiff had relinquished or agreed to adjust
his share in the suit property in lieu of the alleged dues. In absence of
any registered instrument evidencing relinquishment of rights in
immovable property, the plea raised by the defendant cannot be
accepted in law. The evidence of the witnesses examined on behalf of
the defendant also does not satisfactorily establish the alleged settlement
or adjustment.
12.
Upon appreciation of the oral and documentary evidence, the Trial Court
recorded a finding that the plaintiff and defendant No.1 are co-owners of
the suit property and that the plaintiff is entitled to half share therein.
The First Appellate Court re-examined the entire evidence on record and
concurred with the said findings.
13.
These findings are essentially findings of fact based on appreciation of
evidence. Nothing has been pointed out to demonstrate that such
findings are perverse, based on no evidence, or have been recorded in
disregard of settled principles of law so as to warrant interference in
exercise of jurisdiction under Section 100 of the Code of Civil
Procedure.
14.
It is well settled, as reiterated by the Supreme Court in State of
Rajasthan and Others v. Shiv Dayal and Another, (2019) 8 SCC 637,
that interference in second appeal with concurrent findings of fact is
permissible only when such findings are shown to be based on
misreading of material evidence, contrary to pleadings, or such as no
reasonable judicial mind could have arrived at. The appellant has failed
to demonstrate that the findings recorded by the Trial Court and the First
Appellate Court suffer from any such infirmity.
15.
Accordingly, the findings that the plaintiff and defendant No.1 are coowners of the suit property and that the plaintiff is entitled to half share
therein are findings of fact based on proper appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence on record. The said findings have been
concurrently recorded and do not suffer from perversity or any
misapplication of law so as to give rise to any substantial question of
law.
16.
Consequently, no substantial question of law arises for consideration in
the present appeals. The appeals are, therefore, dismissed at the
admission stage itself.
Sd/(Bibhu Datta Guru)
Judge
Rahul/Gowri
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review