Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR
ALI
Digitally signed
by SYED
ROSHAN
ZAMIR ALI
Date:
2026.06.22
19:41:00 +0530
2026:CGHC:25555
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Order Reserved on 20/04/2026
Order Pronounced on 22/06/2026
Order uploaded on 22/06/2026
WPC No. 4557 of 2019
1. Kamlesh Rajpuria S/o Late Shri N.D. Rajpuria Aged About 59
Years R/o Chhattisgarh Heights, B- 301, Daldalseoni, Mova,
Raipur , District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
... Petitioner
versus
1. Government of India Through Its Secretary, Ministry Of Mines,
Department of Mines, Shashtri Bhavan , Dr. Rajendra
Prashad Road, New Delhi.
2. State of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary , Mineral
Resources Department Mahanadi Bhavan , Village Rakhi ,
New Raipur , District Raipur Chhattisgarh.
3. The Collector Jagdalpur, District Bastar, Chhattisgarh.
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Yogesh Chandra Pandey, Advocate
For Respondents
:
Mr. Suyash Dhar Badgaiyan, Govt. Advocate
SB: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Parth Prateem Sahu
CAV Order
1. By this petition, petitioner has questioned the legality and
sustainability of the order dated 11.9.2019 passed in revision
No.12/(07)/2016/RC(II) filed under Section 30 of the Mines
and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957 (for
short ‘the Act of 1957’) read with Rule 36 of the Minerals
(Other than Atomic and Hydro Carbons Energy Minerals)
Concession Rules, 2016 (for short ‘the Rules of 2016’) by
which revision petition filed by petitioner was dismissed and
order No.F-3-28/2011-12 dated 10.3.2016 passed by the
State Government dismissing application of petitioner filed
under Rule 28-A (1) of the Rules of 2016 was affirmed.
2. Facts relevant for disposal of this petition are that the State
Government has granted mining lease of lime stone (major
mineral) to the petitioner over land bearing Khasra No.452
area
3.36
hectare
situate
in
village
Bandagi
Tehsil
Lohandiguda District Bastar for a period of 30 years w.e.f.
30.8.2003 to 29.8.2033. Lease deed was executed on
30.8.2003. The State Government thereafter had issued
notice dated 20.8.2014 to petitioner to show-cause as to why
lease granted to him be not declared lapsed.
Petitioner
submitted reply to show-cause notice contending that,
petitioner wrote letter dated 12.2.2004 to the concerned
authority seeking permission to enter into the land to work
and further explained the reasons as pleaded therein. It is
case of petitioner that respondent State without considering
reply submitted by petitioner in appropriate manner had
passed the order dated 21.5.2015 (Annexure P-12) declaring
the lease granted in favour of petitioner to have lapsed.
Petitioner thereafter submitted an application under Section
4-A (4) of the Act of 1957 read with Rule 28-A(1) of the Rules
of 1960 for revival of lease. The State Government
considered and dismissed application for revival vide order
dated 10.3.2016 only on the ground that application was
submitted with inordinate delay of 10 years, observing that
lease was lapsed on 30.8.2005, therefore, application for
revival could have been filed within a period of six months
thereafter. Order dated 10.3.2016 was put to challenge in a
revision before respondent No.1 which was also dismissed by
impugned order.
3. Learned counsel for petitioner would submit that respondent
No.2 as also respondent No.1 fell into error in dismissing
application submitted by petitioner for revival of lease only on
the ground of delay and not considering application on merits.
He contended that the State Government has not passed any
order declaring the lease to have lapsed prior to 21.5.2015.
Respondent No.2 and 3 have taken 30.8.2005, as the date of
lapse of lease which according to provision under Rule 28-A
of the Rules of 1960, is erroneous. He further contended that
lapse of lease is not automatic after expiry of period of two
years but when the competent authority finds that lessee has
not commenced mining work within prescribed period or has
discontinued mining operations for a period exceeding two
years, the concerned authority has to issue notice seeking
reply and thereafter to pass appropriate order. In this case,
the competent authority had issued show-cause notice to
petitioner, which was replied, and thereafter respondent No.2
had passed the order on 21.5.2015. Hence, the observation
made by respondent No.2 that application submitted by
petitioner after lapse of 10 years is not sustainable. He also
contended
that
the
demarcation,
pursuant
to
the
letter/direction issued by the office of the Collector (Mines
Branch) on 09.7.2007, and demarcation was conducted by
the revenue officer on 13.6.2007 and report was submitted
before the Tahsildar. Thus, it is clear that land which was
granted on lease to petitioner, was not demarcated and
boundaries of lands for mining purpose was not handed over
to petitioner on the date which is considered that lease lapsed
on 30.8.2005 and therefore, finding recorded by respondent
No.1 and 2 that lease granted to petitioner lapsed in the
month of August 2005 is erroneous. He also contended that
vested right of a lease holder cannot be curtailed without
affording him opportunity to repudiate the impression of the
competent authority. According to provision under the Act of
1957 and the Rules of 1960, mining lease would not be
deemed to have lapsed till the State Government passes an
order declaring the mining lease to have lapsed and further
communicating the same to the lease holder. In support of his
contention, he placed reliance upon the decision of Hon’ble
Supreme Court in case of Common Cause vs Union of
India & ors, reported in (2016) 11 SCC 455.
4. On the other hand, learned Government Advocate appearing
on behalf of respondents would oppose submissions of
learned counsel for petitioner and submit that respondent
No.2 has passed the order strictly in accordance with
provisions under the Act of 1957 and the Rules of 1960.
Petitioner was awarded lease for a period of 30 years, starting
from 30.8.2003 to 29.8.2033. According to provisions, the
petitioner has to commence mining operations within a period
of two years from the date of execution of lease deed.
However, petitioner could not able to commence mining
operation within specified period, therefore, lease has
automatically lapsed after expiry of period of two years from
the date of execution of lease deed according to provision
under Section 4-A (4) of the Act of 1957. He also submits that
petitioner was given show-cause notice to which, he
submitted reply and thereafter case was registered, petitioner
appeared through his counsel and the matter was heard on
several dates.
Petitioner has not submitted any mining
closure plan approved by the Indian Bureau of Mines (IBM).
Referring to provisions under Rule 28-A (1) and (2) of the
Rules of 1960, it is submitted that application for revival is to
be filed within six months from the date of lapsing of lease i.e.
30.8.2005, whereas application for revival is submitted by
petitioner after almost 10 years.
5. Heard learned counsel for respective parties and perused the
documents available in record of writ petition.
6. Pleadings made in writ petition with regard to demarcation of
land allotted to petitioner on lease for mining purpose on
30.6.2007 is not in dispute.
In the order dated 10.3.2016
passed by the State Government on the application for revival
of lease, there is mention that the Collector got executed
supplementary agreement on 7.9.2009. There is further
mention that petitioner had submitted/deposited the dead rent
till 2014.
7. From the documents enclosed along with writ petition, in
particular order dated 21.5.2015, Annexure P-12, it is
mentioned that vide letter dated 2.4.2011, the proceedings
have been forwarded by the Collector for declaring the lease
lapsed, based upon which show-cause notice was issued to
petitioner and the matter was fixed for hearing on 9.9.2014,
30.10.2014, 19.1.2015, 13.2.2015, 16.3.2015 and 23.3.2015.
It is also mentioned that on the date fixed, petitioner was
represented through his advocate and Mining Officer
Jagdalpur also appeared.
8. From the aforementioned facts, as mentioned in the order
dated 21.5.2015, Annexure P-12, it is apparent that the
Mining Officer had forwarded the proceeding for declaring the
lease to have lapsed referring to provision under Section 4-A
(4) of the Act of 1957 and Rule 28A of the Rules of 1960.
9. Respondent No.2 has passed the order declaring the lease
awarded to the petitioner of land bearing Khasra No.452 area
3.36 hectare situated in village Badanji to have lapsed only on
21.5.2015. There is no order or proceeding drawn in this
regard prior to 21.5.2015.
10.Sub-section (4) of Section 4-A is relevant and therefore, the
same is extracted herein below:“(4) Where the holder of a mining lease fails to undertake
production and dispatch for a period of two years after the
date of execution of the lease or, having commenced
production and dispatch, has discontinued the same for a
period of two year, the lease shall lapse on the expiry of
the period of two years from the date of execution of lease
or, as the case may be, discontinuance of the production
and dispatch.
Provided that the State Government may, on an
application made by the holder of such lease before it
lapses and on being satisfied that it shall not be possible
for the holder of the lease to undertake production and
dispatch or to continue such production and dispatch for
reasons beyond his control, make an order, within a
period of three months from the date of receipt of such
application, to extend the period of two years by a further
period not exceeding one year and such extension shall
not be granted for more than once during the entire period
of lease:
Provided further that such lease shall lapse on
failure to undertake production and dispatch or having
commenced the production and dispatch fails to continue
the same before the end of such extended period.”
11. Perusal of order dated 21.5.2015, Annexure P-12, would
show that the State Government has passed an order on
21.5.2015
declaring
lapse
of
lease
w.e.f.
30.8.2005.
Application submitted under Rule 28A of the Rules of 1960
was considered and dismissed observing that application was
submitted after 10 years from the date of lapse of lease i.e.
30.8.2005, without considering the fact that the land was
demarcated by revenue officer only on 13.06.2007.
Land
awarded on lease was identified by demarcation proceeding
only on 13.6.2007 and further that the order declaring the
lease lapsed was passed only on 21.5.2015.
12. In case of Common Cause (supra), Hon’ble Supreme Court
considering the operation of Section 4A(4) of the Act of 1957
and automatic lapse of lease, has observed thus:“35.It is not possible for us to accept, that vital vested
rights in a leaseholder can be curtailed without
affording
him
an
opportunity
to
repudiate
the
impression(s) of the competent authority, namely, that
the leaseholder could not have (or had actually not)
carried out mining operations, for a continuous period
of two years. Our instant contemplation stands
affirmed through Rule 28 of the Mineral Concession
Rules. The same is reproduced below:
“28. Lapsing of leases – (1) Subject to the other
conditions of this rule where mining operations
are not commenced within a period of one year
(sic. two years) from the date of execution of the
lease, or is discontinued for a continuous period
of one year (sic. two years) after commencement
of such operations, the State Government shall,
by an order, declare the mining lease as lapsed
and communicate the declaration to the lessee.
(2) Where a lessee is unable to commence the
mining operation within a period of one year (sic.
two years) from the date of execution of the
mining lease, or discontinues mining operations
for a period exceeding one year (sic. two years)
for reasons beyond his control, he may submit
an application to the State Government,
explaining the reasons for the same, at least
three months before the expiry of such period.
(3) Every application under sub-rule (2) shall be
accompanied by a fee of Rs.200.
(4) The State Government may on receipt of an
application made under sub- rule (2) and on
being satisfied about the adequacy and
genuineness of the reasons for the noncommencement of mining operations or
discontinuance thereof, pass an order before the
date on which the lease would have otherwise
lapsed, extending or refusing to extend the
period of the lease:
Provided that where the State Government
on receipt of an application under sub-rule (2)
does not pass an order before the expiry of the
date on which the lease would have otherwise
lapsed, the lease shall be deemed to have been
extended until the order is passed by the State
Government or until a period of two years,
whichever is earlier.
Explanation 1. - Where the non-commencement
of the mining operations within a period of two
years from the date of execution of mining lease
is on account of –
(a) delay in acquisition of surface rights; or
(b) delay in getting the possession of the leased
area; or
(c) delay in supply or installation of machinery; or
(d) delay in getting financial assistance from
banks, or any financial institutions; or
(e) ensuring supply of the mineral in an industry
of which the lessee is the owner or in which he
holds not less than 50% of the controlling
interest, and the lessee is able to furnish
documentary evidence supported by a duly
sworn affidavit, the State Government may
consider if there are sufficient reasons for noncommencement of operations for a continuous
period of more than one year (sic. two years).
Explanation 2. - Where the discontinuance of
mining operations for a continuous period of two
years after the commencement of such
operations is on account of –
(a) orders passed by any statutory or judicial
authority; or
(b) operations becoming highly uneconomical; or
(c) strike or lock out, and the lessee is able to
furnish documentary evidence supported by a
duly sworn affidavit, the State Government may
consider if there are sufficient reasons for
discontinuance of operations for a continuous
period of more than one year (sic. two years).
Explanation 3. - In case of mining lessee who has
undertaken reconnaissance operations or in case
of mining lessee whose capital investment in
mine development is planned to be in excess of
Rs. 200 crores and where the mine development
is likely to take more than two years, the State
Government shall consider it to be sufficient
reason for non-commencement of mining
operations for a continuous period of more than
two years.”
(emphasis supplied)
It is apparent from a perusal of sub-rule (1)
extracted above, that the State Government is
mandated to pass an order, and thereby, declare
that a mining lease had lapsed. It is also the
mandate of sub-rule (1) aforesaid, that such an
order passed by the State Government, must be
communicated to the leaseholder. On a conjoint
reading of Section 4A(4) and Rule 28(1), we are
satisfied to hold, that a mining lease under
Section 4A(4) would not be deemed to have
lapsed, till the State Government passes an
order, declaring the mining lease to have lapsed,
and further communicates the same to the
leaseholder.”
13. In aforementioned decision, Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
in categorical terms that a mining lease under Section 4A (4)
would not deemed to have lapsed till the State Government
passes an order declaring mining lease to have lapsed and
further communicates the same to the lease holder. Lapse of
mining lease is not automatic. Respondent No.2 as also
respondent No.1 has not taken into consideration this aspect
that lapsing of lease would be from the date of order passed
by the State Government and fell into error in taking into
consideration two years period from the date of execution of
lease deed only without there being any order of the
competent authority and dismissing the application submitted
by the petitioner under Rule 28A of the Rules of 1960 only on
the ground of delay without considering the merits. Therefore,
in the opinion of this Court, the impugned order dated
11.9.2019 (Annexure P-16) is not sustainable and liable to be
set aside.
14. Accordingly, writ petition is allowed. Impugned order dated
11.9.2019 (Annexure P-16) is hereby set aside. Matter is
remanded back to the respondent No.2 to consider the
application submitted by petitioner under Section 4A (4) of the
Act of 1957 read with Rule 28A of the Rules of 1960 afresh on
merits keeping in mind relevant provisions and the decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Common Cause (supra).
15. Considering the fact that order declaring the lease lapsed is
dated on 21.5.2015 (Annexure P-12), respondent No.2 is
directed to consider and decide the application submitted by
petitioner expeditiously within outer limit of three months from
the date of recept of copy of order.
Sd/(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
roshan/-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review