Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
SA No. 83 of 2020
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 26-02-2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE T.V.THAMILSELVI
SA Nos. 83 and 91 of 2020
1. KAMALAM(died)
W/o.Murugesan, D.No.2/58, East
Street, Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal
Taluk And District.
2. P.Madheshwari
w/o palanivel,no.1/345,VIP
Nagar,mudhalaipatti post,namakkal
district -637003
3.M. Chandra
W/o. Neelakrishnan, 4/325-1, Kaatoor
Rasipuram Road, Kumaramangalm
Post, Thiruchengodu Taluk, Namakkal
4.M. Duraimurugan
S/o. Murugesan, 283/1, Sarvasree illam,
Sindicate Bank Colony, Ayyan
Thirumaligai, Kannagkurichi,
Thiruchengodu Taluk, Namakkal
District
5.M. Ponmani
W/o. Manivannan, 1/361-1, VIP Nagar,
Mudhalipatti Post, Namakkal District
-637 003
6.Murugesan
S/o. Rakkiyannan, D.No.2/58, East
Street, Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal
Taluk and District
(A1 died, A2 to 6 are brought on record
as lrs of the deceased A1 vide court
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
order dated 17/04/2025 made in
CMP.Nos.15068 of 2023 and
21299,21301 and 21302 of 2022 in
S.A.No.83 of 2020(AANJ) and order
dated 17.04.2025 made in
CMP.Nos.15065,293, 289 & 292 of
2023 in S.A.No.91 of 2020 (AANJ)
Appellant(s) in both SAs
Vs
1. Durai Raj
S/o.Subbaiya Kangani, D.No.2/59, East
Street, Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal
Taluk And District.
1st Respondent in SA.No.91 of 2020
3rd Respondent In SA.NO.83 of 2020
2.SAROJA(died)
W/o.Palnisamy, D.No.10, Bharathi St,
Pattabiraman Nehru Nagar, Chennai-72
3.Lakshmi
W/o.Balakrishnan, D.No.2/38, East
Street, Nallipalayam Village,
Namakkal Taluk And District.
4.Vasanthi
W/o.Palaniyappan,
Veppamarathuthottam, Namakkal
Taluk And District.
5.Kalivani
W/o.Balakrishnan, E.B.Colony,
Paramathi Road, Namakkal Taluk And
District.
6.Ganesan
S/o.Balakrishnan, D.No.2/38, East
Street, Nallipalayam Village,
Namakkal Taluk And District.
7.P.Mohan
S/o.Ponnusamy, D.No.5, Veerappan
St, Ramapuram Pudur, Namakkal
Town And Dist.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
7th Respondent in SA.No.91 of 2020
1st Respondent In SA.NO.83 of 2020
SA No. 83 of 2020
8.Manogari
W/o.Ramu, D.No.6/87, 2/38, East St,
Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal Taluk
And District.
9.Mahalakshmi
W/o.Karuppannan, Nallipalayam
Village, Namakkal Taluk And District.
10.INDIRANI(died)
W/o.Muthusamy, D.No.6/87,
Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal Taluk
And District.
11.Gowri
W/o.Matheshwaran, D.No.6/87,
Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal Taluk
And District.
12.Thirunavukkarasu
S/o.Subramanian, D.No.6/87,
Nallipalayam Village, Namakkal Taluk
And District.
13.S. Palaniswamy
S/o Late Subraya Gounder, Res At
No.15, Bharathi Street Nehru Nagar,
Pattabiram, Chennai - 600072.
14.K.P. Sendilkumar
S/o S. Palaniswamy, Res At No.15,
Bharathi Street Nehru Nagar,
Pattabiram, Chennai - 600072.
15.N. Sumathi
W/O R.K. NATARAJAN, RES AT
NO.15, BHARATHI STREET NEHRU
NAGAR, PATTABIRAM, CHENNAI –
600072.
(R2 died, RR13 to 15 brought on record
as legal heirs of the deceased R2 vide
court order dated 25/08/2022 made in
CMP.Nos.152 and 155 of 2022 made in
SA.No.83 and 91 of 2020(ptaj)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
16.M.Dayalan
s/o late muthusamy,1/260,mariyamman
kovil street, ayyasamy naidu
street,perur chettipalayam,coimbatore
641010.
(R10 died, R16 is brought on record as
lr of the deceased R10 vide court order
dated 17.04.2025 made in CMP.Nos.
21302 of 2022 in SA no 83 of
2020(AANJ) and CMP. Nos.35065,
293, 289 & 292 of 2023 in S.A.No.91
of 2020 (AANJ).
Respondent(s) in both
SAs
PRAYER in SA No. 83 of 2020:
Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, prays to set
aside the decree and judgement of the Additional District Judge, Namakkal, in
AS No.47/2013 dated 16/12/2017 reversing the Decree and judgement of the
Sub Judge Namakkal in OS No.182/2005 dated 31/07/2013.
PRAYER in SA No. 91 of 2020:
Second Appeal filed under Section 100 of Code of Civil Procedure, prays to set
aside the decree and judgement of the Additional District Judge, Namakkal, in
AS No.44/2014 dated 16/12/2017 reversing the Decree and judgement of the
Sub Judge Namakkal in OS No.182/2005 dated 31/07/2013.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Appellant(s):
Mr.S.Muthukrishnan
For Respondent(s):
Mr.S.Senthil For Rr1 And 9
V.Rajesh- For Rr13 To 16
Mr.N.Narayanaswamy For R4
And R5
R2,r5 And R10 – Died
R3,r6 To R8,r11 And R12 – No
appearance
SA No. 83 of 2020
COMMON ORDER
The appellant has filed these second appeals to set aside the judgement
and Decree dated 16.12.2017 passed in AS Nos 47 of 2013 &.44 of 2014,
respectively on the file of the Additional District Judge, Namakkal, reversing
the Judgment and Decree dated 31.07.2013 passed in OS No. 182 of 2005 on
the file of the Subordinate Judge, Namakkal.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties herein are referred to as they
were ranked in the suit.
3. Challenging the reversing findings of the First Appellate Court, the
plaintiff has preferred the present Second Appeals.
4. Before the Trial Court, the original plaintiff, Kamalam, filed a suit for
partition against her sisters, brother, and the legal heirs of her predeceased
brother, claiming a 1/5th share in the suit property. According to the plaintiff,
the suit property absolutely belonged to her mother, Pavayee Ammal, who died
intestate on 28.11.2004, leaving behind the plaintiff and defendants 1 to 7 as her
legal heirs. He further alleged that the third defendant, her brother, was not
inclined to give her rightful share and had collusively sold the suit property to
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
the eighth defendant with an intention to defeat her rights. Therefore, she filed
the suit for partition against the defendants. During the pendency of the suit, the
first defendant died and her legal heirs were impleaded as defendants 9 to 13.
The purchaser of the property was arrayed as the eighth defendant.
5. The third defendant, who is the brother of the plaintiff, filed a written
statement disputing the plaintiff's claim for a 1/5th share in the suit property. He
contended that their mother, Pavayee Ammal, had executed a registered Will
during her lifetime. Under the terms of the Will, he was directed to sell the suit
property within six months of her death and distribute the sale proceeds by
paying a sum of Rs.75,000/- each to his sisters and another sum of Rs.75,000/to the legal heirs of his deceased brother, Balakrishnan. According to him, the
Will represented the last testament of Pavayee Ammal. After her demise in the
year 2004, he acted in accordance with the recitals contained in the Will.
6. The third defendant further stated in his written statement and
additional written statement that he sold the suit property to the eighth
defendant for a sum of Rs.4,00,000/-. Thereafter, he obtained four Demand
Drafts, each for a sum of Rs.75,000/-, in favour of the female heirs. Since they
refused to receive the amounts, he filed O.P. Nos.6 to 9 of 2005 under Section
83 of the Transfer of Property Act before the District Munsif Court, Namakkal,
and deposited the amounts before the Court. The third defendant also contended
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
that, after the death of Pavayee Ammal, a Panchayat was convened at TKS Oil
Mill, Nallipalayam, in the presence of Panchayatdars, namely Madeswaran and
Kuppusamy. According to him, the plaintiff, her husband, defendants 1 and 2,
and the legal heirs of the deceased brother participated in the Panchayat and
demanded Rs.75,000/- each towards their share. In accordance with the terms of
the Will, he sold the property to the eighth defendant and obtained Demand
Drafts for Rs.75,000/- each in favour of the female heirs, but they refused to
receive the same. Suppressing these facts, the plaintiff has come forward with
the present suit. Hence, he prayed for dismissal of the suit.
7. The eighth defendant, the purchaser of the suit property, also contested
the suit. He contended that he is a bona fide purchaser for valuable
consideration. He purchased the suit property for a sum of Rs.4,00,000/- on
15.05.2005 and also discharged certain loans incurred by the third defendant.
According to him, the purchase was made for valid consideration and he has
been in possession and enjoyment of the property ever since the date of
purchase as its absolute owner.
8. By way of a reply statement, the plaintiff disputed the alleged Will
relied upon by the third defendant. She also denied the alleged Panchayat said to
have been conducted at TKS Oil Mill and contended that no such Panchayat had
ever taken place. He further contended that the alleged Will dated 04.07.1997 is
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
not genuine and that the burden squarely lies upon the third defendant to prove
the same in the manner known to law. The plaintiff further claimed that she was
not aware of the existence of the said Will. According to her, the additional
written statement was filed only to fill up the lacunae in the defence. Therefore,
she prayed for a decree as sought for in the suit.
9. Before the Trial Court, both parties adduced oral and documentary
evidence in support of their respective cases. On the side of the plaintiff, PW.1
was examined and Ex.A1 and Ex.A4 were marked. On the side of the
defendants D.W.1 to D.W.4 were examined and Ex.B1 to Ex.B12 were marked.
10. Upon consideration of the oral and documentary evidence and the
submissions advanced on either side, the learned Trial Judge doubted the
genuineness of the Will. The Trial Court compared the signature found in the
partition deed relied upon by all the parties, marked as Ex.B8, wherein the
testatrix had signed as "Pavayee Ammal" in the year 1996. On the other hand, in
the alleged Will, marked as Ex.B9, the testatrix had signed only as "Pavayee".
The Trial Court observed that no evidence had been adduced by the third
defendant to establish that, in her later years, Pavayee Ammal was accustomed
to signing merely as "Pavayee" instead of "Pavayee Ammal".
11. On the basis of the said discrepancy, the Trial Court held that the Will
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
was surrounded by suspicious circumstances and that the signature of the
testatrix had not been satisfactorily proved. Consequently, the Court concluded
that the Will had not been proved in accordance with law. The Trial Court
further held that, although the eighth defendant may be a bona fide purchaser,
he would be entitled to work out his remedies against his vendor, namely the
third defendant, during the final decree proceedings. Accordingly, the suit was
decreed as prayed for, and a preliminary decree was passed allotting 1/5th share
in favour of the plaintiff.
12. Aggrieved by the said findings, the third defendant preferred an
appeal before the Subordinate Court, Namakkal. The learned First Appellate
Judge independently re-appreciated the entire evidence on record by framing
separate points for consideration.
13. Before the First Appellate Court, it was argued on behalf of the third
defendant/appellant that the plaintiff had only generally disputed the
genuineness of the Will and had not specifically pleaded that her mother used to
sign only as "Pavayee Ammal" and never as "Pavayee". In the absence of such a
specific pleading, it was contended that the plaintiff was not entitled to raise
such a defence during trial.
14. Considering the said submission, the First Appellate Court observed
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
that the thumb impression of Pavayee Ammal found in the disputed Will had
been sent for forensic examination in I.A. No.1403 of 2005. The thumb
impression found in the Will was compared with the admitted thumb impression
of Pavayee Ammal, and the expert opined that both impressions belonged to one
and the same person. Based on the said opinion, the First Appellate Court held
that the thumb impression found in the Will had been proved to be that of
Pavayee Ammal. Though the expert's report had not been formally marked as an
exhibit, the First Appellate Court nevertheless took the same into consideration.
15. The First Appellate Court further relied upon the evidence of D.W.2,
Kaliannan, one of the attesting witnesses to the Will, and ultimately concluded
that the Will had been duly proved by the third defendant. The Court also held
that, under the Will, the third defendant had been directed to sell the property
and distribute the sale proceeds among the female heirs. In pursuance of the said
direction, the property had been sold to the eighth defendant, who was a bona
fide purchaser for value.
16. Since the property had already been sold in the year 2005, the First
Appellate Court held that no property remained available for partition as
claimed by the plaintiff. Consequently, the findings of the Trial Court were set
aside and the suit was dismissed. Aggrieved by the judgment and decree of the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
First Appellate Court, the plaintiff, Kamalam, preferred the present Second
Appeals. During the pendency of the proceedings, she died and her legal heirs
were brought on record as appellants.
17. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant contended that the
First Appellate Court committed a error in upholding the Will as genuine and
valid without properly considering the fact that the signature found in the
alleged Will and the admitted signature found in the partition deed, Ex.B8, are
entirely different. According to the learned counsel, the testatrix had
consistently signed only as "Pavayee Ammal" and never as "Pavayee".
Therefore, the Trial Court had rightly concluded that the Will had not been
proved. He further argued that the First Appellate Court erroneously relied upon
the forensic opinion relating to the thumb impression of Pavayee Ammal even
though the said report had not been marked as evidence. Such reliance,
according to the appellants, is legally unsustainable.
18. The learned counsel also submitted that D.W.2, the attesting witness
to the Will, was a close associate of the third defendant, who was the principal
beneficiary under the Will. He argued that her evidence contained material
contradictions and did not satisfactorily establish the due execution and
attestation of the Will. According to the appellants, the First Appellate Court
failed to consider these material discrepancies while holding the Will to be
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
genuine.
19. The learned counsel further contended that D.W.3, the alleged
Panchayatdar, was also a close friend of the third defendant. He argued that the
plea regarding the alleged Panchayat conducted at TKS Oil Mill was introduced
only through the additional written statement in order to fill up the lacunae in
the defence. Even the date of the alleged Panchayat had not been specified. The
Trial Court had rightly rejected the said plea. However, the First Appellate
Court, without properly appreciating these deficiencies, erroneously concluded
that the Will had been proved and that the plaintiff had no right in the suit
property. Hence, the judgment and decree of the First Appellate Court are liable
to be set aside.
20. By way of reply, the learned counsel appearing for the contesting
defendants submitted that the Will had been duly proved before the Trial Court
through the evidence of D.W.2, one of the attesting witnesses, and the
circumstances surrounding the execution of the Will were further corroborated
by the evidence of D.W.3 regarding the Panchayat held in the family. According
to the learned counsel, the First Appellate Court had rightly appreciated the
evidence on record and arrived at a correct conclusion, which requires no
interference by this Court.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
21. The learned counsel further submitted that, after the demise of
Pavayee Ammal, a Panchayat was convened wherein the contents of the Will
were made known to the family members. The said fact was established through
the independent testimony of D.W.3. He also contended that the third defendant
had taken steps to implement the recitals of the Will within six months of the
death of his mother by selling the property and distributing the sale proceeds
among the female heirs. Though Demand Drafts were obtained for Rs.75,000/each in favour of the female heirs, they refused to receive the same for ulterior
reasons. According to the learned counsel, these aspects were rightly considered
by the First Appellate Court, which correctly concluded that the property had
been sold in accordance with the Will executed by Pavayee Ammal and that no
property remained available for partition. Hence, the dismissal of the suit was
justified and requires no interference. Accordingly, he prayed for dismissal of
the appeal on the ground that no substantial question of law arises for
consideration.
22. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant, on the other hand,
contended that even assuming the Will to be genuine, the First Appellate Court
failed to properly interpret its recitals. According to him, the Will merely
directed the third defendant to sell the property within six months and distribute
the sale proceeds among the female heirs. Such a document, according to the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
appellants, does not amount to a testamentary disposition of property but is
more in the nature of an authority or direction. The First Appellate Court failed
to properly appreciate this aspect. On that ground also, the impugned judgment
is liable to be set aside.
23. The Second Appeals are admitted on 13.02.2020, on the following
substantial questions of law:
(i). Whether the Will executed in favour of D3 is proved in the
manner known to law?
(ii). Whether the recital of the Will executed in favour of D3 is
amounted to a Will as per the law?
24. This Court has carefully considered the submissions made on either
side and perused the materials available on record.
25. It is an undisputed fact that the original plaintiff Kamalam, defendants
1 to 3, and the deceased Balakrishnan are the children of one Pavayee Ammal. It
is also undisputed that the suit property originally belonged to Pavayee Ammal.
The title of Pavayee Ammal to the suit property has been established through
the settlement deed marked as Ex.A1, executed in the year 1943. Thus, the suit
property is admittedly the absolute property of Pavayee Ammal.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
26. According to the plaintiff, Pavayee Ammal died intestate on
28.11.2004, leaving behind five children as her legal heirs. Therefore, being one
of the legal heirs, the plaintiff claims entitlement to 1/5th share in the suit
property. Since the third defendant, instead of allotting her share, sold the
property in favour of the eighth defendant, the plaintiff was constrained to
institute the present suit seeking partition and separate possession of her lawful
share.
27. The third defendant, while admitting the relationship between the
parties and the fact that the property absolutely belonged to Pavayee Ammal,
denied that she died intestate. According to him, during her lifetime, Pavayee
Ammal executed a registered Will dated 04.07.1997, marked as Ex.B9. The said
Will has been specifically disputed by the plaintiff as not genuine and valid.
Since the third defendant relies upon the Will, the burden lies upon him to prove
its due execution and attestation in the manner known to law, particularly in
accordance with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act. In order to discharge
the said burden, the third defendant examined D.W.2, Kaliannan, one of the
attesting witnesses to the Will.
28. Relying upon the evidence of D.W.2, the learned counsel for the third
defendant contended that the Will had been proved in accordance with law and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
that the First Appellate Court rightly appreciated the evidence. However, the
learned counsel for the appellants submitted that the evidence of D.W.2 is
neither cogent nor reliable and contains several contradictions, which were not
properly appreciated by the First Appellate Court.
29. A careful examination of the evidence of D.W.2 reveals that he is
closely acquainted with Mahadevan, the son of the third defendant. According
to her evidence, he was called by Pavayee Ammal and accompanied her to the
house of the document writer, where the Will was prepared in accordance with
the instructions allegedly given by Pavayee Ammal. He further deposed that
after the Will was prepared, Pavayee Ammal signed the document in his
presence and in the presence of another attesting witness, Hyder Ali. Thereafter,
the Will was registered, and he identified Pavayee Ammal before the registering
authority.
30. D.W.2 further stated that, under the Will, the entire property had been
given to the third defendant and that Pavayee Ammal had signed only as
"Pavayee". However, as rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the
appellant, the property was not absolutely bequeathed to the third defendant.
Even according to the recitals contained in the Will, the third defendant was
merely directed to sell the property and distribute the sale proceeds among the
beneficiaries. This material aspect was not even known to D.W.2, who simply
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
stated that the property had been given absolutely to the third defendant.
31. Further, Ex.B8, the partition deed executed in the year 1996, which
has been admitted by all parties, contains the signature of the testatrix as
"Pavayee Ammal". Relying upon the said document, the plaintiff contended that
her mother consistently signed as "Pavayee Ammal" and not merely as
"Pavayee". Once such a specific dispute has been raised regarding the signature,
the burden lies heavily upon the propounder of the Will to establish that
Pavayee Ammal was accustomed to signing only as "Pavayee" at the relevant
point of time.
32. It is pertinent to note that neither party took steps to obtain an expert
opinion regarding the disputed signature. Though the thumb impression found
in the Will was subjected to forensic examination, the forensic report was never
marked as an exhibit. Nevertheless, the First Appellate Court relied upon the
contents of the unmarked report and concluded that the thumb impression found
in Ex.B9 belonged to Pavayee Ammal. Such a conclusion, based upon an
unmarked document, cannot be sustained in law.
33. Further, the third defendant has not offered any satisfactory
explanation as to why the testatrix signed as "Pavayee" in Ex.B9, whereas she
had signed as "Pavayee Ammal" in Ex.B8. The evidence of D.W.2 also reveals
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
material inconsistencies. While D.W.2 deposed that the property had been given
absolutely to the third defendant, the recitals of the Will merely authorize him to
sell the property and distribute specified amounts among the female heirs.
Therefore, the testimony of D.W.2 cannot be said to be wholly reliable and free
from contradictions.
34. The propounder of a Will is required to dispel all legitimate
suspicions surrounding its execution. In the present case, the discrepancy in the
signatures, the contradictions in the evidence of the attesting witness, and the
active role played by the beneficiary in the execution and custody of the
document create serious suspicious circumstances.
35. It is significant that in Ex.B8, executed only a year prior to the alleged
Will, the testatrix signed as "Pavayee Ammal", whereas in Ex.B9 she is shown
to have signed merely as "Pavayee". Though the plaintiff specifically
questioned this discrepancy, no convincing explanation has been forthcoming
from the third defendant.
36. Moreover, the evidence of D.W.2 does not inspire the confidence of
the Court. His evidence clearly indicates that he was not fully aware of the
contents and recitals of the Will. Even assuming that the Will is genuine, its
recitals indicate that the property was to be sold and the proceeds distributed.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
However, D.W.2 categorically stated that the property had been absolutely given
to the third defendant. This contradiction strikes at the very root of the defence
case.
37. Further, D.W.2 is closely associated with the beneficiary under the
Will. The custody of the Will remained with the third defendant throughout. The
surrounding circumstances indicate that the third defendant had actively
participated in the execution and registration of the Will. These circumstances
give rise to legitimate suspicion, which has not been satisfactorily removed by
the evidence adduced on behalf of the defendants.
38. The First Appellate Court, without properly appreciating these
suspicious circumstances, proceeded to hold that the Will had been duly proved.
Such a finding is legally unsustainable and liable to be interfered with.
Accordingly, the first substantial question of law is answered in favour of the
appellant.
39. In view of the finding rendered on the first substantial question of law,
the second substantial question of law need not detain this Court for long. Since
the Will itself has not been proved in accordance with law and remains
shrouded in suspicious circumstances, the question of interpreting its recitals
does not arise for consideration. Accordingly, the second substantial question of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
law is answered.
40. During the course of arguments, the appellant produced a typewritten
copy of the alleged Will and contended that the Will had been registered both in
handwritten and typewritten forms and that the original typewritten copy had
not been produced. However, this contention does not merit acceptance in the
facts and circumstances of the present case as such new plea raised without
pleadings.
41. The third defendant further contended that a Panchayat had been
convened at TKS Oil Mill before the sale of the property and that the family
members were informed about the contents of the Will. In order to substantiate
this plea, D.W.3, one of the alleged Panchayatdars, was examined.
42. However, as rightly pointed out by the learned counsel for the
appellants, the third defendant had not specifically pleaded in his original
written statement either the date or the particulars of the alleged Panchayat. It
was only by way of an additional written statement that the plea regarding the
Panchayat was introduced. Even then, neither the date nor the year of the
alleged Panchayat was disclosed.
43. The evidence of D.W.3 also reveals that he was unaware of the date
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
on which the alleged Panchayat was conducted. Consequently, the third
defendant has failed to establish that any such Panchayat was held after the
death of Pavayee Ammal. The evidence of D.W.3 does not support the defence
case in any meaningful manner.
44. Therefore, there is no acceptable evidence to show that the female
heirs were informed about the recitals of the Will or the proposed alienation of
the property before its sale in favour of the eighth defendant. On the contrary,
the evidence indicates that notices were issued to the female heirs only after the
property had already been sold. Thus, the third defendant has failed to establish
that the beneficiaries had prior knowledge of the alleged Will and its
implementation.
45. Ordinarily, this Court would be slow to interfere with concurrent
findings of fact. However, where material evidence has been improperly
appreciated or relevant circumstances have been ignored, interference is not
only permissible but necessary to prevent miscarriage of justice.
46. In the present case, the First Appellate Court has failed to properly
appreciate the evidence on record and has arrived at conclusions unsupported by
the materials available. Consequently, the judgment and decree of the First
Appellate Court are set aside. The judgment and preliminary decree passed by
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
the Trial Court are restored. The plaintiff is entitled to 1/5th share in the suit
property. In respect of the share allotted to the third defendant, the eighth
defendant/purchaser shall be entitled to work out his remedies in the final
decree proceedings in accordance with law.
47. Accordingly, the Second Appeals are allowed. If any final decree
application is pending or is filed hereafter, the Trial Court is directed to dispose
of the same as expeditiously as possible, preferably within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. No costs.
26-02-2026
Index:Yes/No
Speaking/Non-speaking order
Internet:Yes
rri
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
To
1. The Additional District Judge,
Namakkal.
2. The Subordinate Judge, Namakkal.
3. The Section Officer, VR Section,
High Court of Madras.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
SA No. 83 of 2020
T.V.THAMILSELVI J.
rri
SA Nos. 83 & 91 of 2020
26-02-2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review