Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010493332025
2026:CGHC:32783
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
AVINASH
SHARMA
Digitally signed
by AVINASH
SHARMA
Date: 2026.08.03
10:09:18 +0530
WPC No. 6259 of 2025
Judgment Reserved On : 01.07.2026.
Judgment Delivered On : 30.07.2026.
Kamal Narayan Sahu S/o Late Rajau Ram Sahu, Aged About 66 Years R/o House
No. 38, Vip Road, Village- Temri, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - Rajesh Dani S/o Late Bala Saheb Dani, R/o Dani Bada, Budhapara, Raipur,
District Raipur (C.G.)
2 - Board Of Revenue, Chhattisgarh, Bilaspur (C.G.) Circuit Court At Raipur, District
Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Commissioner, Raipur Division, Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Sub Divisional Officer (R), Abhanpur, District Raipur (C.G.)
5 - Tahsildar, Abhanpur, Tahsil Abhanpur, District Raipur (C.G.)
... Respondent(s)
For Petitioner(s)
:
For Respondent No.1 :
For State
:
Shri Malay Shrivastava, Advocate.
Shri Ankur Agrawal, Advocate.
Dr. Arham Siddiqui, Panel Lawyer.
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
C A V Order
1. This Writ Petition has been filed challenging the legality and validity of the
impugned order dated 17/10/2025 (Annexure P/1) passed by the Respondent
No.2 i.e. Board of Revenue in Revenue Revision Case No.R.N./14/R/A-
6/299/2024 arising out of order dated 14/10/2024 (Annexure P/2) passed by
the Respondent No.3/Commissioner, Raipur Division in Appeal Case
No.202310970100022/22/A-06/2023-24
arising
out
of
order
dated
11/10/2023 (Annexure P/3) passed by the Respondent No.4 in Revenue
Appeal Case No.202303111100110 A/6/2022-23 arising out of order dated
13/03/2023 (Annexure P/4) passed by the Respondent No.5 in Revenue
Case No. 202302114000003A/6/2022-23.
2. Necessary facts of the case are that grand-father of Respondent No.1 has
purchased a property in the name of minor son-in-law namely Shailesh from
one Sulochana Bai vide registered sale deed dated 18/01/1969 by which the
property situated at Village-Kolar, Tahsil & District- Raipur (the then P.H. No.
124), R.I. Circle & Block Abhanpur, bearing Khasra No.132/11, 156/11,
156/12 and 156/13, total area of 49.35 decimal. Thereafter, vide registered
sale deed 09/12/1970, the land bearing Khasra No. 156/12 and 156/13 has
been sold by minor Shailesh to his brother minor Rajesh. On 20/05/1981,
Respondent No.1 through his father has sold part of Khasra No.156/12 area
2.50 acres to the petitioner and minor sons of the petitioner Rekhram and
Ghanshyam who died issueless and after sale of the property, the Khasra
Number was recorded in the revenue records and Rinpustika in the name of
the petitioner. Against the father of the respondent no. 1, a Ceiling Case
No.07/B-90(3)/1977-78 has been registered in which orders have been
passed against and in favour of the father of Respondent No.1, but neither
the lands have been recorded in the name of the State Government nor the
possession has been taken by the State Government under the provisions of
the Chhattisgarh Ceiling of Agricultural Holding Act, 1960 (which will be
referred herein after as "the Ceiling Act, 1960" for brevity). During the
pendency of the proceedings under the Ceiling Act, 1960 on 19/04/2021, the
original holder of the land i.e. Bala Saheb Dani who is the father of the
Respondent No.1 died, therefore, the Respondent No.1 along with his
brother i.e. Shailesh Dani and other holder of the land has filed an application
before the competent authority in the pending ceiling case in which, on
09/11/2022, an order was passed in favour of Rajesh Dani, Shailesh Dani
and other holder of the land that as per the provisions of the Ceiling Act,
1960, Rajesh Dani, Shailesh Dani and other holder of the land are entitled to
hold 30-30 acres of the land. Therefore, the proceeding under the Ceiling
Act, 1960 has been closed and the land has been recorded in the name of
Rajesh Dani, Shailesh Dani and other holder of the land in the revenue
record. Against the order dated 09/11/2022, Bharti Sahu and others have
preferred a revision before the respondent no.2 which was registered as
Revision Case No. R.N./8/12/5-90(3)/238/2024 in which respondent no.2 vide
order dated 13/10/2025 has set aside the order dated 09/11/2022 and
remanded back the matter to the Competent Authority, Raipur Division,
Raipur to comply with the provisions of Section 4, 11 and 12 of the Ceiling
Act, 1960 after giving the opportunity of hearing to all the interested persons
of the land. As the petitioner has purchased the land vide registered sale
deed and on account of the ceiling proceeding, the name of the petitioner has
been struck off from the revenue records. Therefore, the petitioner has filed
an application under Section 110 of the Chhattisgarh Land Revenue Code,
1959 before the Respondent No. 5 for mutation on the basis of sale-deed
and possession of the land. Tahsildar vide order dated 13/03/2023 has
rejected the application of the petitioner on the ground that since the land
was not recorded in the name of the petitioner, therefore, the provisions of
Section 109 & 110 of the Code, 1959 is not attracted and therefore, the
application was rejected. Against the order dated 13/03/2023, the petitioner
has preferred an appeal under Section 44 (1) of the Code, 1959 before the
Respondent
No.
which
was
registered
as
Revenue
Case
No.202303111100110A/6/2022-23 and the Respondent No.4 vide order
dated 11/10/2023 has allowed the appeal of the petitioner and directed for
mutation of the land of the petitioner on the ground that there was a
registered deed in favour of the petitioner which has neither been challenged
nor cancelled by any competent authority. Therefore, the petitioner was
entitled for mutation. Being aggrieved of the order dated 11/01/2023, the
Respondent No.1 has preferred an appeal under Section 44 (2) of the Code,
1959 before the Respondent No.3 which was registered as Appeal Case
No.202310970100022/22/A-06/2023-24 and the Commissioner vide order
dated 14/10/2024 has allowed the appeal of the Respondent No.1 on the
ground that there was an order dated 09/11/2022 by which, it was directed by
the Respondent No.3 in ceiling case that the land be recorded in the name of
the Respondent No. 1. Therefore, complying with the order dated
09/11/2022, the land will be recorded in the name of Respondent No.1. Being
aggrieved of the order 14/10/2024, the petitioner and other land holders who
have purchased the land from the Respondent No.1 has preferred a revision
under Section 50 of the Code, 1959 before the Respondent No.2 along with
an application under Section 52 of the Code, 1959 for grant of interim relief.
Respondent No. 2 vide order dated 14/10/2024 has rejected the application
filed under Section 52 of the Code, 1959 against which, the petitioner has
preferred a writ petition bearing Writ Petition (C) No.66/2025 before this
Court and vide order dated 08/01/2025, this Court was pleased to grant
interim relief in favour of the petitioner. Vide order dated 17/10/2025, the
Board of Revenue along with other revisions has decided the revision of the
petitioner also on the ground that the facts and laws of the case of one
Ramadhar Sahu and Anr. are similar, therefore, the revision of the petitioner
has also been dismissed upholding the order passed by the Respondent No.
5 and set aside the order passed by the Respondents No. 3 and 4. The
finding recorded by the Respondents No.2 while setting-aside the order of
Respondent No.3 dated 14/10/2024 is that the order dated 09/11/2022 has
been challenged before the Respondent No.2 and the same has been
allowed vide order dated 13/10/2025 and order dated 09/11/2022 has been
set-aside and the matter has been remanded back to the competent Court
under the Ceiling Act, 1960. Hence this Petition.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the sale deed which was
executed in favor of the petitioner on 09/12/1970 by Rajesh Dani- respondent
no.1 is still in existence, therefore, the order passed by the respondent no.4
on 11/10/2023 is a well-reasoned order and the petitioner is entitled for the
mutation of the land. He submits that respondent no.2 has passed a cryptic
order without assigning any reason that as to why the mutation cannot be
done in favor of the petitioner. Respondent No.2 failed to see the reason
assigned by the respondent no.4 that there was a registered sale deed in
favor of the petitioner and the same was not challenged nor has been
cancelled by any competent court having such jurisdiction, as such,
entitlement of the petitioner for mutation of the land cannot be denied.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel for Respondent No.1 submits that real
owner of part of khasra no.156/12 area admeasuring about 2.50 acres
hectare is Rajesh Dani. As the suit property was purchased in the name of
minor by Bala Saheb Dani and further the ceiling case was registered against
Bala Saheb Dani which also includes the suit land and the sale deed was
executed by the Bala Saheb Dani after initiation of the ceiling case and the
said sale deed was executed without taking appropriate permission from
Collector, therefore, any sale deed if executed for any land under ceiling act
then permission from Collector as per Section 5 of Ceiling on Agricultural
Holding Act, is necessary and if any sale is made without permission, then
that sale deed becomes void-ab initio itself. Further, it is submitted that sale
deed executed after initiation of ceiling proceedings were verified by the
competent ceiling officer and by the order dated 05.12.1985, the sale deeds
executed by the Bala Saheb Dani was declared illegal and void and
thereafter, the excess land was vested with the government. It was
specifically stated that the Bala Saheb Dani had sold the land after appointed
date just to defend the provisions of Ceiling Act. It is further submitted, for the
sake of argument, if it is to be believed that sale deed executed by the
respondent no.1 through Bala Saheb Dani is correct then also it is necessary
to take permission before executing sale deed in behalf of the minor which is
also not complied in the present case. Therefore, the petitioner's ownership
and contention cannot be accepted in any level as the sale deed executed in
favour of petitioner is illegal and void from the very beginning as suit land
was purchased in name of minor but the sale deed was executed in favour of
petitioner by Bala Saheb Dani, further no prior permission was taken from
appropriate authority before execution of sale deed in favour of petitioner and
the said sale deed is already declared illegal and void by the order dated
05.12.1985. Therefore, the petitioner is not having any case in his favour.
Further, the competent authority by order dated 09.11.2022 mutated the
name of respondent no.1 along with his brother i.e. Shailesh Dani in the suit
property and ended the ceiling case no. 07/B-90(3) year 1977-78. It is
submitted that the father of the respondent no.1 along with suit land sold
other lands during pendency of ceiling case. One of the parties challenged
the order dated 09.11.2022 before the Board of Revenue and by the order
dated 13.10.2025 Board of Revenue set aside the order dated 09.11.2022
and directed the competent authority to decide again after hearing all
interested party. The competent authority on 30.04.2026 again passed the
order in favour of the respondent no.1 and mutated the name of respondent
no.1 along with his brother in the revenue records. The present writ petition is
only an attempt to get a things done indirectly which cannot be achieved
directly. It is respectfully submitted that adjudication regarding entitlement is
already been done and name of respondent no.1 along with Shailesh Dani
had already been mutated in some of the properties. The petitioner ought to
have challenged the order dated 05.12.1985, 30.04.2026 or to file civil suit
regarding their claim as owner through their sale deed, the petitioner is not
entitled to get any property which were held to be entitled by respondent
under the Ceiling on Agricultural Holding, Act.
5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the material
available with the petition carefully.
6. It appears that the petitioner has filed an application for mutation under
Sections 110 of the Chhattisgarh Land Revenue Code, 1959 on the basis of
the registered sale deed dated 20.05.1981 in respect of 2.50 acre, 1.013
hectare, part of Khasra No.156/12 (new Khasra No.156/70) situated at village
Kolar, PHN 124 (new PHN 4) Tehsil Abhanpur District Raipur C.G., stating it
to be purchased from Respondent No.1 and other respective owners. It was
also stated that proceedings were initiated under the Ceiling of Agricultural
Holding Act, 1960 and the subject land was declared to be additional land
and the same was vested with the State Government and was recorded in
the name of State in revenue records.
7. The Tehsildar vide its order dated 13.03.2023 (Annexure P/4) rejected the
application of the petitioner for mutation on the ground that the subject land is
recorded in the name of State of Madhya Pradesh which was acquired under
the ceiling Act and it is not recorded in the name of seller of the land, as
such, name of petitioner cannot be mutated in respect of the subject land.
8. Thereafter, the petitioner against the order dated 13.03.2023 of Tehsildar,
moved before Sub-Divisional Officer (Revenue), Abhanpur, District Raipur
C.G by filing Revenue Appeal No.202303111100110, A/6, year 2022-2023,
which was allowed on 11.10.2023 (Annexure P/3) by the SDO who directed
for mutation of the land in the name of the petitioner in respect of Khasra
No.156/70, rakba 1.013 hectare on the ground that there was registered
deed in favour of the petitioner which has neither been challenged nor
cancelled by any competent authority.
9. Assailing the order dated 11.10.2023 of SDO (Revenue ), Respondent No.1
moved before Commissioner, Raipur Division, Raipur C.G. by filing Appeal
case No.202310970100022/22, A-06, year 2023-24 which was allowed by
the Commissioner on 14.10.2024 (Annexure P/2) and order dated
11.10.2023 of SDO was set aside as vide order dated 09.11.2022 passed by
the Commissioner in ceiling case, it was directed that the subject land be
recorded in name of Respondent No.1. The Commissioner has also held that
the subordinate court, Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil), Abhanpur did not
consider Section 8(2) of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956
under which transfer cannot be made without permission. Similarly, in Ceiling
Case No. 7/B-90 (3) / 1977-78, the order dated 05.12.1985 of the Additional
Commissioner, Raipur Division, Raipur, regarding declaring the sale as void
as it was benami, contrary to the provisions of the Agricultural Holding Ceiling
Act, 1960, was also not considered by the subordinate court.
10. Thereafter,
the
petitioner
against
the
order
dated
14.10.2024
of
Commissioner, moved before the Board of Revenue, Chhattisgarh by filing
Revenue Revision case No.RN/14/R/A-6/299/2024 which was rejected on
17.10.2025 and the Board of Revenue upheld the order passed by Tehsildar
dated 13.03.2023, and has set aside the orders dated 14.10.2024,
11.10.2023 passed by Commissioner, Raipur and SDO Abhanpur,
respectively, leading to the present writ petition.
11. From the perusal of impugned order dated 17.10.2025, it appears that the
questioned sale deed was executed by the Rajesh Dani, Respondent No.1,
who was minor at that time, inspite of the fact that in earlier ceiling
proceedings bearing No.7/B-90(3)/1977-78 vide order dated 23.03.1979,
excess land of father of Respondent No.1 which includes suit land has been
vested with the State Government. In the aforesaid ceiling case, final order
was passed on 09.11.2022 by the Competent Authority-cum-Commissioner
Raipur Division, Raipur wherein, excess land of father of Respondent No.1
was released from ceiling proceedings and name of Respondent No.1 and
his brother namely Shailesh Dani was directed to be recorded in the revenue
records.
12. It is also evident that due to continuation of ceiling proceedings, the transfer
made in the favour of the petitioner was not declared valid as said ceiling
case was pending for consideration, in which, final order was passed on
09.11.2022, as such, contention of the petitioner that they have purchased
the land earlier would not entitle them to seek mutation on the basis of sale
deed, in which, the sellers were not entitled to execute sale deed due to
pendency of ceiling proceedings under the ceiling act before the competent
authority. The land in question was never released from the ceiling
proceedings, as such, even if any sale deed was executed prior to that, it will
not give any benefit to the petitioner. The land in question was recorded in
the name of Rajesh son of Balasaheb Dani. It is undisputed that Rajesh was
minor at the time of execution of sale deed and his guardian has sold the
property, as such, the entitlement of the seller to execute sale deed in
respect of property during the concurrency of ceiling proceedings was not
decided, as such, even if any sale deed got executed, the petitioner will not
derive any right on the basis of such a sale deed. The pendency of ceiling
proceedings would disentitle the petitioner from the fruits of sale deed as
seller was not having competency to execute such sale deed due to
pendency of ceiling case.
13. In this matter, it would be apt to refer the judgment of MP High Court in the
case of Kalibai & Another vs. Government of M.P. & Another reported in
1987 Revenue Nirnay 315, wherein it has been held that before culmination
of ceiling proceedings and before final decision in accordance with Section
11 of the Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings Act, 1960, any transfer in
contravention of the provisions of Section 5 is illegal and void.
14. The aforesaid view has further been reiterated by the High Court of MP at
Indore in the matter of Madanlal and Ors vs. Laxminarayan and Others,
reported in 2022 Lawsuit (MP) 1858, paragraph 18 of which reads as under:-
“18. A perusal of the aforesaid provision makes it clear that
land which is effected by the provisions of the Act, 1960
cannot be sold, sub divided, gifted, exchanged, leased or
otherwise be transferred until a final order is passed under
Section 11 except with the permission in writing of the
Collector. The same also includes an award or order of any
lawful authority. The section thus provides for restriction on
transfer of land which is effected by the Ceiling
proceedings. As per plaintiff, he and defendants entered
into an agreement for the purpose of defeating the aforesaid
provision by entering into agreement to the effect that they
would institute a suit in the Civil Court and get declaration in
respect of the lands done in such a manner that the lands
would fall outside the purview of the provisions of the Act.
They thus intended to do indirectly what they were
specifically prohibited to do under the Act and decided to
misuse the process of the Court for fulfilling their objective.
The agreement between plaintiff and defendants, which
plaintiff intends to enforce in this suit, was thus clearly
aimed to defeat the provisions of Section 5 of the Act, 1960
and the object or consideration for the same was not
lawful…”
15. It is also evident that final order dated 30.04.2026 has been passed by the
Competent Authority-cum-Commissioner Raipur Division Raipur, C.G. which
was remanded to him by the Board of Revenue, Bilaspur, Circuit Court,
Raipur C.G. vide order dated 13.10.2025 as the Board of Revenue set aside
the order dated 9.11.2022. Vide order dated 30.04.2026, the Competent
Authority-cum-Commissioner Raipur Division Raipur has held that under
Section 5 of the Act of 1960 any transfer without permission of Collector
would be invalid and if any subsequent transfer is made, the same will also
be invalid and void ab initio. Under Section 4 of the Act of 1960, the onus is
upon the transferor to give evidence that the transfer was in accordance with
law. The land in dispute was directed to be recorded in the name of Rajesh
Dani and Shailesh Dani.
16. Since the order passed under the ceiling act has never been challenged by
the present petitioner and further, the competent authority under the Ceiling
Act, 1960 i.e. Commissioner Raipur Division has passed orders for mutation
vide order dated 30.04.2026. Accordingly, unless and until the said order is
annulled by the competent court of law, no order for mutation can be passed
in favour of the petitioner in light of the provisions contained under Section 5
and 11 of Ceiling Act, 1960 .
17. The petitioner relies upon the registered sale deed. Mere existence of a
registered sale deed, however, does not automatically entitle a person to
mutation where the transfer itself is alleged to be void under a statutory
enactment and has been so treated by the competent authority exercising
jurisdiction under the Ceiling Act.
18. In view of the aforesaid legal position, unless the orders passed under the
Ceiling Act are set aside by a competent forum, the petitioner cannot claim
mutation solely on the strength of the sale deed.
19. The dispute raised by the petitioner essentially concerns the validity of the
sale deed, competency of the transferor to execute the transfer, and
correctness of the orders passed under the Ceiling Act. These issues require
adjudication before the appropriate competent forum and cannot be
conclusively determined in mutation proceedings.
20. The Board of Revenue has therefore committed no jurisdictional error in
affirming the rejection of the mutation application.
21. In the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is of the considered
opinion that where the execution of the sale deed, the competency of the
transferor, and the validity of the transfer under the Ceiling on Agricultural
Holdings Act, 1960 are themselves under dispute and stand governed by
subsisting orders passed by the competent authority, no direction for
mutation can be issued in favour of the holder of such sale deed until those
orders are set aside in accordance with law.
22. Accordingly, the Writ Petition being bereft of merit deserves to be and is
hereby dismissed.
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
Judge
The date when the
The date when the
The date when the judgment is
judgment is reserved
judgment is
uploaded on the website
pronounced
01.07.2026
30.07.2026
Operative
Full
------
03.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review