Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2910712026
( o3
COMMON JUDGMENT
WA.Nos.748,749 AND 767 OF 2026
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT APPEALS
WITHOUT COSTS.
3l
1HE s14 14:
e
J
o
o
3, JUt zm[
* D6:
S.'r,;33(rc
t
Regulation 8.4(b) of the Regulations have to conform tr the exposition
ofthe Rule Position in this regard, as held herein above'
11. Accordingly, rhe Writ Appeals are disposed of There shall be
no order as to costs.
Miscellaneous applications pending, if any, shall r;tand closed'
SD/. V.KAVITHA
DERUTY REGTSTRAE, --
//TRUE COPYII
,,.!:----'-
,-
oFFrcER
To
;Srron
1. The Registrar, Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences' Nagarjuna
Reddy S/o Komalla fni.iotf i Reddy Bhadrakali Temple Road' Warangal'
Telangana.
Medical a.nd Family Welfare Department Dr'
2. The P-rincipal Secretary, Health
-secretanat'
Hyderabad' State of Telangana
B.R. Ambedkar tetangana
ONE CC tO SRITSHAi;iH, SC FOR KNRUHS [OPUC]
OPUC]
4. ONC CC tO SRI UDAY KUMAR KUKKADAPU, AdVOCAIE(lourt
for the State of
S Two CCs to Gp FOR M-E|;CAL HEALTH & FW, High
Telangana, at Hyderabad [OUTI
6. Two CD Copies
^
nsffid
PSK.
---
10. In the aforesaid view of things, the expression used after the first
paragraph of Clause Vl of the Minutes of Meeting i'e',"Average of
three evaluations is to be taken." appears to be unnecessary and gives
rise to a confusion, which does not fit in with the interpretation of the
first paragraph. Therefore, in respect of a candidate whose evaluations
by two original evaluators have more than 15% discrepancy, the
average of the third evaluation and the original evaluation, which is
nearer to the third evaluation has to be taken into consideration.
Though the two courses i.e., Post-Graduate and ljnder-Graduate are
separate independent courses, Regulation 8.a@) of the Regulations,
which govern the Post-Graduate Medical Education would show that
the method for evaluation of a paper of a candidate having more than
15%discrepancyamongsttwooriginalevaluationsistotakethe
average of best two total marks awarded by the three evaluators
for the
paper, rounded off to the nearest integer (whole number), for final
computation of the results' As such, in the ultimate analysis' the
impugneddirectionsissuedbythelearnedwritCourttotheappellant-
Universitytorecalculatethemarksofthewritpetitionersinthe
-
respective papers taking average of the best two evaluations in terms
of
fair evaluation of marks of a candidate, in case, the rrarks arvarded by
the trvo original evaluators have a discrepancy of mor() than 15%. The
interpretation accorded on behalf of the appellant-Uni',ersity would not
give an obj ective and fairer assessment of the perlbrmance of such a
candidate. It is only on account ofa large discrepancy in marking that
the scheme of evaluation provides for a third evaluatron. As such, a
rvide discrepancy creates a doubt as to the objectiveness ln the
evaluation process of the evaluators. The evaluation by the third
evaluator, if found closer to any one of the original trvo evaluators,
removes this doubt and makes it more fair and objective in the
assessment of the performance of the student
9.
As per the illustration given hereinabove, both scenarios could
emerge upon third evaluation. The third evaluator's rnarks vvould bc
closer to marks aw,arded by either of the tr,vo evaluatc rs. Therefore. an
a\rerage of two would provide proper assessment of the perfbrmance of
the candidate, whether it is on the lou,er side or or the higher side
depending upon the computation of the average of the two marks, one
awarded by the third evaluator and the other by the original evaluator,
rvhich is nearer to it
marks, that has to be taken out for preparation of the marks of that
particular subject.
.
Upon hearing leamed counsel for the parties and on
consideration of the rival submissions, we are of the considered view
that the instant scheme of evaluation under Clause-Vl of Minutes of the
Meeting, on a composite and harmonious reading, accords to the view
that in cases where there is discrepancy of more than 15% in two
evaluations ofany paper, the marks awarded by the third evaluator and
those awarded by the original evaluator, which is nearer to the third
evaluator's marks, should be taken into consideration for preparation of
the marks of that student in that particular subject. For example, if a
candidate in Human Anatomy has scored 70% marks in the first
evaluation and 8l%o marks in the second evaluation, his paper would be
subjected to third evaluation. In case, the third evaluator's marking
is 90%, the average of 90% and 87oh has to be taken into consideration.
In case, the third evaluator's marking is 74%, which is nearer to the
first evaluator's marking i.e.,'10oh, the average of 14%o and 70% has to
be taken for preparation ofthe marks
8.
Such interpretation of Clause-Vl of the Minutes of Meeting is
found to be in consonance with the objective ofproviding a scheme for
"8..1 Va lLration:
a.
All thc teaclters ol'thc orltcr. collegcs ol tlte corrcerncd [.rnirersitr
or other Uni!ersrtie.,. uho are cliqihlc to bc post gradUale c\arriners. can
pcrtorrrr thc \alllati,,r.,,l tlre arr.rrr-...rilrrr
b
\ll thc arsrrer :eripts.,lrrll he rrrhiecred lirr lrrrr ralrra itrns br the
concerned Lrnirelsitr llte arera-sc (,l 1lrc tolal ntarks a\\xtdL,d b\ the
tu'o laluators lbr thc paper. uhich rs r.ounded otf to the nearest intcuer
luhole nLrnrber). shall bc consirlcred lbr corrrputatiorr of tltc ,.esults. AII
the arrsrrer scripts- ultcrc tlte diflclcnce lletwcen t$o r,alrrations is l504
and nt,.rre ofthc totaJ ntar.ks pr.cscrrbccl firr tltc- papcr. sha Ihe srrbicctcd
to third valuation. llte arcraqc oi'tltc hesl t\\() total ntarks. tuardeti br
the three evaluators lor. {ltc papcr.. roLrndcd off to thc ncarest intcgcr
(lrholc nLrrrrbcr)- shall be consirier.crl lirr final colnpLrtation of :he resLrlts.
c.
Aficr tllc c()DtpLtratron and clcclaration of the resLrlt,,. Lrndel Io
circunlstances. rer alrration s pcrrlittcd.
d.
,Ail thc llcaltlr Llrrclsilics lrrstitLrlions in.tpartinq
l)(,st-sraduate
cclurscs shalI intplcntcnt clisital r alLriltron.--
5.
[.ear,cd counsel lbr the appellant-University has expr.essed that
thc interpretation of thc rclcr anI clausc-VI oI thc N4in,tcs of' thc
Meeting should be that i. case oI disc.epancr of rro.c ;han r 5oz in tr.vo
evalLrations of au,v papcr. tltc ar,cr.aec ol'the thl.ec evaluations i.e..
two
o1'the original trvo cr aluators and that ol' thc tlrird e\ irluator has to be
taken lbr preparation o1- thc nrarks.
6.
[.earncd counsel l'or t]rc ,,r rit pctitioners has acl'unced a contraru
vierv that it is the avcra_qc ot'thc tltircl cvaluator.s rnarks and
that of thc
original e'alualor's l.,arks, \\hich is ncarcr to the third evaluator,s
"Vt. IN-fRODLlC'llON ()F S(llll,\'1li OIr L-VAl.UAl'lOtr- .l ppnttad
It is resolred that [)rgital raluatirttr ol'the clLrestion papr--rs is
approvcd. Double raluatiol'r is lrlllrdator). I)iscrepancy in tuo
valuations of nrore than l5o,o is scnt lbr third raltration. lf no
discrepar.rcl then thc average rlarks obtained in doublc valuation is
taken as tinal. ln casc ol'ntot.c thatt l5u,b lariation tlie third
evaluator's nrark ncarct to the original cYalltator is taken into
consideration and an averagc ol thc original and the third
evaluations is done.
A'"erage ol'Three valuations is to bc 1aken. It is apprcr'ed b1 the
Members of Comnron MBBS llOS."
3.
I-earned wril Court has not qrVcn anr vic,"r' on interpretation of
Minutes of the Meeting. Ho\\'e\cr. it dircctcd the appe Ilant-U niversity
to recalculate the rnarks o1' thc pctitiottcrs in all thcse three Writ
Petitionsi appeals in the subjccts o1'ilr"rnran Anatotnl' and Physiology by
taking the average of tlle best tr,r'o evaluations in terms of
Regulation 8.4(b) of
the Post-Graduate Medical llducation
Regulations. 2023 ( tbr short 'thc Rcgulations') and thereafter, declare
their revised results within a period o1'ortc tnonth
4.
'l'he present dispute is not irr rclation to evaluation o1'
answerscripts of Post-Graduate \lcdical Studcnts 1br u'hich the
Regulations plescribed a rncthod of e'r'aluation at Regulation 8.4'
Clause (b) tn particular. Iror acadetrtic purpose. the said Regulation IS
extracted hereunder
t
W.A.No.767 of 2026
Betw'een:
Kaloji Naravana llao Lniversity of Ilealth Scienccs
Through its I n-chargc Rcgistrar,
Nagarjuna Redd1,, S/o. Komalla'l hirupathi Rcddy.
Bhadrakali Temple lload, Warangal,'l'clangana
... Appellant
,,\\l)
Mandagondi Dincsh (lhandra,
Aged about 20 years, S/o. Sivu Ranrakrishna,
Occ: studen t and another
.. Respondents
COMMON JUDCMT,N'I':
IIeard Mr.
.1
. Shalath. lcarned counscl fbr the appellant-
Universitl; Mr. Raja Sripathi l{ao. learned Senior Counscl representing
Mr. Lldai, Kurnar Kr-rkkadapu. learrrcd counsel fbr respondent No.l/w,rit
petitioncrs and Mr. Iandla [tanresh. learned Assislant Governntent
Pleader lbr tlealth. Medical arld |arnily Wellale Department.
appearing 1br respondent No.2
2.
The shorr issLre in all these three appeals
l:i
regarding the
interpretation of' thc scl'rcntc o1' cr aliration conceived lx, the Board of
Studies o1'('ornrron N,lllllS o1' thc appellanl-Unir crsitr in its rneeting
held on 22.01.2020. -l hc rclcr anr (-lausc-VI of thc Minutes o1' the
Meeting is crtlacted lrcrcunclct
tN THE l{lcll cotiRl' t-ol{ l'uE sTAl u ol'-[ELAN(;ANA
AT ll\',Dt,]l{Alt,\t)
The Hon'ble'[he Chicf Justicc Sri Anaresh Kumar Sinsh
and
The tlon'ble Sri .lusticc G.l\I.Mohiuddin
Writ Ann cal Nos.7{8. 7-19 and 767 of 2026
l)atcd:29.07.2026
W.A.No.748 of 2026
Betwecn:
Kalo.ji Narayanzr Rao University of I lexlth Scienccs
1'hrough its I n-cha rgc Rcgistrar,
Nagarjuna Reddy, S/o. Komalla 1'hirupathi Rcddy,
Bhadrakali I'emple Road, Warangal, 1'clangana
... Appellant
A\t)
Varikuti Su rya 1'cj,
Age 20 years, S/o. Naga Raju,
Occ: sludent and anothcr
... Respondents
W.A.No.749 of 2026
Between:
Kaloji Narayana Rao University'ot llclrlth Scicnccs
Through its In-cha rgc Rcgistrar,
Nagarjuna Reddy, S/o. Komalla 'l'hirupathi Rcddy',
Bhadrakali Temple Road, Warangal. 1'clangana
\\ l)
... Appcllant
Putti Vaibhav,
Age 20 years, S/o. Putti Srinivas,
Occ: studcn t and anothcr
... Respondents
WA NO: 767 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause '15 of the Letters Patent preferred against the order
dated 06-05-2026 in WP. No. 1 2305 OF 2026 and pass on the fite of the High Court.
Between:
Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences, Th-ough its ln-charge
Registrar, Nagarjuna Reddy S/o Komalla Thirupathi Rcddy Bhadrakali Temple
Road, Warangal, Telangana.
...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT No.2
AND
1. Mandagondi Dinesh Chandra, Age about 20 years S/o Siva Ramakrishna Occ
Student MBBS-1, R/o. Flat No 283, Sagar Complex, Vanastatipuram,
Hayathnagar, Ranga Reddy District
2. The State of Telangana, represented by its principal Secretary, to
Government, Medical Health and Family Welfare Department, Dr. B. R.
Ambedkar Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENTS
LA. NO: 2OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleaseci to suspend
the operation of the order passed on 0610512026 in Wp.No. l2ii05 of 2026 pending
consideration of the writ appeal.
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRt RAJA SRIPATHI RAO, SENIOR
COUNSEL FOR SRI UDAY KUMAR KUKKADAPU
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI TANDRA RAMESH,
AGP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FW
The Court made the following: COMMON JUDMENT
Counsel for the Appeltant: SRt T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI RAJA SRIPATHI RAO, SENIOR
COUNSEL FOR SRI UDAY KUMAR KUKKADAPU
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI TANDRA RAMESH,
AGP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FW
WA NO:7 49 0F 2026
writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters patent preferred against the order
dated 06/05i2026 in wP.No. r2332 oF 2026 on the fire of the High court.
Between:
Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences, Through its rn-charge
Registrar, Nagarjuna Reddy s/o Komaila Thirupathi Reddy Bh-adrakari rempie
Road,Warangal, Telangana
...APPELLANT/RESpONDENT No.2
AND
Putti Vaibhav, Aged about 20 years, S/o putti Srinivas, Occ: Student, R/o g_
100, Ramayampet Mandal, Medak District.
Ihe State of Telangana, rep by its principal Secretary, Health, Medical
Family Welfare Department Secretariat Building Hyderabad'
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2 026
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of the order passed on o6tost2o26 in wp No. 12332 of 2026 pending
consideration of the writ appeal
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI T.SHARATH, SC FOR KNRUHS
Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI RAJA SRIPATHI RAO, SENIOR
COUNSEL FOR SRI UDAY KUMAR KUKKADAPU
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SRI TANDRA RAMESH,
AGP FOR MEDICAL HEALTH & FW
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
[ 3488 ]
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF -ULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE SRI APARESH KUMAR SINGH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
WA.Nos.748 749 AND 767 0F 2026
WA NO: 748 OF 2026
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of the Letters Patenl preferred against the order
dated 06/05/2026 in W.P.No 12263 ol 2026. on the fite of the High Court.
Between:
Kaloji Narayana Rao University of Health Sciences, Through its ln-charge
Registrar, Nagarjuna Reddy S/o Komalla Thirupathi Reddy Bhadrakali Temfle
Road, Warangal, Telangana
...APPELLANT/RESPONDENT No.2
AND
1 Varikutr Surya Tej, Age 20 years S/o Naga Raju, Occ Student, R/o. H. No. 34, Almasguda, Near Hanuman Temple, Badangpet, Ranga Reddy Drstrict.
2. fhe State of Telangana, rep. by its Principal Secretary, Health, Medical and
Family Welfare Department Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Telangana Secretariat,
Hyderabad
...RESPONDENTS
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2026
Petition under Section 151 cPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the
affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to suspend
the operation of the order passed on 0610st2026 in wp No 12263 of 2026 pending
consideration of the writ appeal.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review