Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED :
24.03.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE R.KALAIMATHI
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
1.Kailash Doulat Bhojwani
2.Chanchal Doulat Bhojwani
.. Appellants
Vs.
1.T.Chitra
2. The New India Assurance Company Ltd.,
No.232, 6th Floor, Bombay Mutual Buildings,
NSC Bose Road, Chennai-1.
... Respondents
PRAYER: Civil Miscellaneous Appeal is filed under Section 173 of Motor
Vehicles Act, to enhance the Award dated 10.09.2025 passed in
M.C.O.P.No.819 of 2023 on the file of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal / II
Special Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
1/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For appellants
: Ms.Ramya V.Rao
For R1
: No Appearance
For R2
: Mr.J.Chandran
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
JUDGMENT
Against the denial of compensation towards loss of dependency, the
elder and younger brothers of the deceased, Hero Doulat Bhojwani, have
preferred this Civil Miscellaneous Appeal against the Award dated
10.09.2025 passed in M.C.O.P.No.819 of 2023 on the file of the Motor
Accident Claims Tribunal/II Special Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
2. The parties are indicated herein as per their litigative status and
ranking before the Tribunal.
3. According to the appellants/claimants, on 14.01.2023 at about 6.30
a.m., while the claimant’s brother was walking along the Aadams Road from
east to north, a Tempo Traveller Ambulance bearing Registration No.TN 87
1864 came at a high speed and in a rash and negligent manner hit from
behind.
He sustained head injuries and while being taken to Kilpauk
Medical Hospital, succumbed to the injuries. The claimants approached the
Tribunal claiming compensation of Rs.48,00,000/- for the death of their
brother on account of the road traffic accident as mentioned supra.
2/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
4. The second respondent/Insurance Company denied the manner in
which the accident occurred. The claimants were put to strict proof of the
age, avocation and income of the deceased.
It was contended that the
claimants, being class II legal heirs, were not dependent upon the deceased
and therefore, the second respondent is not liable to pay compensation to
the claimants. At trial, on the claimants’ side, two witnesses have been
examined and twenty one documents have been marked. On the side of the
second respondent, no oral or documentary evidence was led in.
5. P.W.2 is the ocular witness, has deposed that the manner in which
the
accident
occurred.
During
his
cross
examination,
no
details
advantageous to the Insurance Company was elicited. On the side of the
Insurance
Company,
no
ocular
witness
was
examined.
Upon
comprehensive analysis of the oral and documentary evidence, it has been
concluded that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of
the driver of the tempo traveller vehicle, and the said finding cannot be
found fault with. As per Ex.P6 – legal heirs certificate, father and mother of
the deceased had predeceased him, and the claimants, being his brothers,
fall under the category of class II legal heirs.
3/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
6. It is relevant to refer to the observation made by the Apex Court in a
similar matter in
Smt.Manjuri Bera vs. Oriental Insurance Company
Limited, reported in AIR 2007 SCW 1962, wherein the Apex Court, while
considering the claim under Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act, it has
been held as follows:
"12. According to Section 2(11) of CPC, "legal representative"
means a person who in law represents the estate of a
deceased person, and includes any person who intermeddles
with the estate of the deceased and where a party sues or is
sued in a representative character the person on whom the
estate devolves on the death of the party so suing or sued.
Almost in similar terms is the definition of legal representative
under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, i.e. under
Section 2(1)(g)
13. As observed by this Court in Custodian of Branches
of BANCO National Ultramarino v. Nalini Bai Naique [1989] 2
SCR810 the definition contained in Section 2(11) CPC is
inclusive in character and its scope is wide, it is not confined to
legal heirs only. Instead it stipulates that a person who may or
may not be legal heir competent to inherit the property of the
deceased can represent the estate of the deceased person. It
includes heirs as well as persons who represent the estate
even without title either as executors or administrators in
possession of the estate of the deceased. All such persons
would be covered by the expression legal representative'. As
observed in Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v.
Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai [1987] 3 SCR 404 a legal
representative is one who suffers on account of death of a
person due to a motor vehicle accident and need not
necessarily be a wife, husband, parent and child.
14. There are several factors which have to be noted.
The liability under Section 140 of the Act does not cease
4/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
because there is absence of dependency. The right to file a
claim application has to be considered in the background of
right to entitlement While assessing the quantum, the
multiplier system is applied because of deprivation of
dependency. In other words, multiplier is a measure. There are
three stages while assessing the question of entitlement.
Firstly, the liability of the person who is liable and the person
who is to indemnify the liability, if any. Next is the quantification
and Section 166 is primarily in the nature of recovery
proceedings. As noted above, liability in terms of Section 140
of the Act does not cease because of absence of dependency
16. Judged in that background where a legal
representative who is not dependant files an application for
compensation, the quantum cannot be less than the liability
referable to Section 140 of the Act. Therefore, even if there is
no loss of dependency the claimant if he or she is a legal
representative will be entitled to compensation, the quantum of
which shall be not less than the liability flowing from Section
140 of the Act. The appeal is allowed to the aforesaid extent.
There will be no order as to costs. We record our appreciation
for the able assistance rendered by Shri Jayant Bhushan, the
learned Amicus Curiae."
7. In Deep Shikha and another vs. National Insurance Co., Ltd.,
and Others, 2025(1) TN MAC 689(SC), the death claim was made by the
married daughter and mother of the deceased. The Tribunal partly allowed
the claim petition granting compensation to both the claimants. The same
was challenged, and the High Court modified the Award by reducing the
compensation awarded to the daughter of the deceased and setting aside
the award passed in favour of the mother, holding that they cannot be
considered as dependents of the deceased and this Order was put to
challenge before the Hon’ble Apex Court and the Apex Court held that the
5/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
married daughter of the deceased is not entitled to compensation as she
failed to prove that she was financially supported by her father postmarriage,
but granted enhanced compensation to the mother of the
deceased.
8. In Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation, Ahmedabad vs.
Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai and Another, 1987 (3) SCC 234 wherein, it has
been held as follows :-
"Brother of a person, who dies in a Motor Vehicle accident is
entitled to maintain a Petition under Section 110-A of the Act if
he is a Legal Representative of the deceased. In an Indian
family. Brothers, sisters and Brothers' children and sometimes
foster children live together and they are dependent upon the
bread-winner of the family and if the bread-winner is killed on
account of a Motor Vehicle Accident, there is no justification to
deny them Compensation relying upon the provisions of the
Fatal Accidents Act, 1855 which has been substantially
modified by the provisions of the Motor Vehicles Act in relation
to cases arising out of Motor Vehicles accidents. (Ed.: Though
in the present case it may be that the deceased, who was only
a 14 year old boy, was not the bread-winner of the family at
the present moment, but legally his Brothers would be entitled
to claim Compensation)
Chapter VIII of the Motor Vehicles Act provides for a forum
alternative to that provided under the provisions of the Fatal
Accidents Act for realisation of Compensation payable on
account of Motor Vehicles accidents and its provisions are
substantive and not merely procedural in nature. They
substantively affect the rights of the parties. As the right of
action created by the Fatal Accidents Act was "new in its
species, new in its quality, new in its principles, in every way
new" the right given to the Legal Representatives under the
Act to file an Application for Compensation for death due to a
6/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
motor vehicle accident is equally new and an enlarged one.
This new right cannot be hedged in by all the limitations of an
action under the Fatal Accidents Act. New situations and new
dangers require new strategies and new remedies. Contrary
observation made by the Supreme Court in Minu B. Mehta
case were in the nature of obiter dicta."
9. In National Insurance Company Limited vs. Birender and Others,
2020 (1) TN MAC 182(SC), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has observed that
all or any of the legal representatives of the deceased can move application
for compensation. In Branch Manager, TATA AIG General Insurance Co.,
Ltd., North Block, 3rd Floor, AA Tower, 4 & 5 Bypass Road, Madurai vs.
Muthamil Sagayam and two others, 2025(2) TN MAC 446, it has been
held as follows:-
“12. As observed by this Court in Custodian of Branches of
BANCO National Ultramarino v. Nalini Bai Naique, 1989 Supp
(2) SCC 275. the definition contained in Section 2(11). C.P.C. is
inclusive in character and its scope is wide, it is not confined to
Legal Heirs only. Instead it stipulates that a person who may or
may not be Legal Heir competent to inherit the property of the
deceased can represent the estate of the deceased person. It
includes heirs as well as persons, who represent the estate even
without title either as executors or administrators in possession of
the estate of the deceased. All such persons would be covered by
the expression "Legal Representative". As observed in Gujarat
SRTC v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai, 1987 (3) SCC 234, a Legal
Representative is one who suffers on account of death of a
person due to a Motor Vehicle accident and need not necessarily
be a wife, husband. parent and child."
7/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
10. Law is well settled that a legal representative can very well
maintain the claim. This principle has been reiterated by the Apex Court in
Jitender Kukmar and another vs. Sanjay Prasad and Another, 2025(2)
TN MAC 433(SC), wherein it was observed that the legal representatives,
including married and earning sons and daughters are entitled to claim
compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act irrespective of financial
dependency on the deceased .It is
relevant to refer the said order is
extracted hereunder :-
“13. In our considered opinion, the view on this issue cannot be
faulted. The exposition of law in Birender (Supra) is clear,
wherein it was observed as under:
"14. It is thus settled by now that the Legal Representatives of
the deceased have a right to apply for Compensation. Having
said that, it must necessarily follow that even the major married
and earning sons of the deceased being Legal Representatives
have a right to apply for Compensation and it would be the
bounden duty of the Tribunal to consider the Application
irrespective of the fact whether the Legal Representative
concerned was fully dependent on the deceased and not to limit
the claim towards Conventional Heads only."
11. It is relevant to refer to the evidence of P.W.1,who is the brother of
the deceased. The relevant portion is extracted and given hereunder :
8/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
“ vd;
jhahh;
,we;j
gpwF
tUlq;fs;
fopj;J
jw;NghJ jhd; te;Njd;. ,we;j vd; rNfhjuUk; ehDk;
xd;whf trpf;ftpy;iy.
,we;j vd; rNfhjuh; vdf;F
ve;jtpjkhd nghUshjhu cjtpAk; nra;jJ ,y;iy.
2k;
kDjhuUk;
cwhq;fhq;fpy;
trpj;J
tUfpwhh;.
mtUk; 1996-y; ,Ue;J cwhq;fhq;fpy; trpj;J tUfpwhh;.
2k; kDjhuUf;Fk; ,we;j vd; rNfhjuh; ve;j tpjkhd
nghUshjhu cjtpAk; nra;jJ ,y;it. ,we;j vd;
rNfhjuUf;Fk;
vdf;Fkhd
cwT
Kiw
rhd;wpjo;
jhf;fy; nra;Js;Nsdh vd;why; k.rh.M.6> 7> 9 Mfpa
Mtzq;fs;
jhf;fy;
nra;Js;Nsd;.
,we;j
vd;
rNfhjuiu rhhe;J ,uz;L kDjhuh;fSk; thotpy;iy
vd;why; rhpjhd;” vd;W rhl;rpak; mspj;Js;shh;.
12. Admittedly, the claimants are the brothers of the deceased and
fall under Class II legal heirs. Though they are competent to represent the
estate of the deceased, the moot question is whether they are entitled to be
compensated for loss of dependency.
The evidence of P.W.1 clearly
establishes that they were not fully dependent upon the deceased. In the
9/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
absence of dependency, Class II legal heirs, who are financially independent
are not entitled to be compensated for loss of dependency.
13. In such circumstances, the Tribunal has granted for loss of
consortium, loss of estate and for funeral expenses, quantified at
Rs.1,21,000/- which is perfectly in order.
This Court does not find any
perversity or infirmity in the findings of the Tribunal. No other ground has
been put forth by the appellants with regard to the quantum of compensation
awarded. Based on the aforesaid observations and discussions, this Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal is devoid of merits and is liable to be dismissed and
thereby dismissed.
Sequel to this, Award dated 10.09.2025 passed in
MCOP.No.819 of 2023 on the file of the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/II
Special Court of Small Causes, Chennai, stands confirmed. No costs.
24.03.2026
Index
: Yes / No
Internet : Yes / No
kkd
10/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
R.KALAIMATHI , J.
kkd
To
The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
II Court of Small Causes, Chennai.
C.M.A.No.3770 of 2025
24.03.2026
11/11
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review