Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC040001332025
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
(ITANAGAR BENCH)
Case No. : WP(C)/39/2025
Kadum Jamoh
Son of Shri Naloko Jamoh, Rani Village, PO and PS Pasighat, East Siang District,
Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
The State of AP and 3 Ors
represented by the Secretary (Home Affair), Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
2:The Director General of Police (PHQ)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
3:The Deputy Inspector General of Police (PHQ)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar.
4:The Assistant Inspector General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Tabit Tapak, T Taki,T Tabing,Aso Dalbong
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
Page No.# 2/15
Before
Hon’ble Mr. Justice ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
25.05.2026
Heard Mr. T. Taki, learned counsel for the petitioner and also heard Mr. Y. Riram,
learned Junior Government Advocate, appearing for the State respondents.
2.
In this petition, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, the petitioner has
challenged the order dated 23.07.2024, vide No.PHQ/PER-128/2016 (PART-I), issued
by the Assistant Inspector General of Police (E), Police Headquarter, Itanagar,
Arunachal Pradesh and also prayed for reinstating the petitioner in service, to the post
of Constable (Civil Police) in terms of the appointment order, dated 22.04.2024, vide
No.PHQ/PER-21/2024. It is to be noted here that vide impugned order, dated
23.07.2024, the petitioner was dismissed from service.
3.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present writ petition, are briefly
stated as under:“Pursuant an advertisement dated 03.05.2023, vide No.APSSB-13/6/2023,
issued by the Secretary cum CoE (APSSB), Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, the
petitioner had applied for the post of Constable. The petitioner was selected and
appointed to the post of Constable, vide common appointment order, dated
22.04.2024. Thereafter, he served as Constable under Arunachal Pradesh Police,
for 5 months and undergone departmental training at Banderdewa, and he
received salary for 5 months. But, during the course of service training, an
objection has been raised by the respondent department to the effect that he
has concealed his criminal antecedents in terms of the application form, filled up
by him. Whereas, at the time of filling up of the form, he was not properly
aware of the language contained in the form, as he was never been convicted in
Page No.# 3/15
any Court of law. However, a technical objection has been raised by the
respondent department, and he has been terminated from the service illegally
and arbitrarily without any departmental enquiry/proceedings in violation of the
principle of natural justice.
The specific allegation against the petitioner was that in Clause 11(a) of the
application form, it has been asked, have you ever been arrested, prosecuted,
kept under detention or bind down/fined, convicted by a Court of law for any
offence, or debarred/disqualified by any public service examination from
appearing at its examination/selection or debarred from taking any examination
restricted by any university or any other education authority/institution, as
contained in the language of the form, which was a complex question and
therefore, he has mistakenly filled as ‘No’ and even if there was a mistake, it
was corrigible as he was never been convicted in any Court of law and despite
the fact that the respondent authority mechanically and technically raised the
issue and in violation of the principle of natural justice by issuing the impugned
termination order, dated 23.07.2024 mechanically and arbitrarily.
It is, however, the case of the petitioner that a case was registered against
him, being S/Oyan P.S. Case No.26/2019, under Section 419/506/34 IPC,
corresponding G.R. Case No.321/2019, and investigation of the said case
culminated in submission of charge-sheet. But, the petitioner has been
discharged from the case on 06.06.2024, by the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Pasighat and police has also given a report over the criminal
antecedents of the petitioner, in which no criminal records have been found
against him in terms of the certificate, dated 26.07.2024 issued by the Deputy
Superintendent of Police, Pasighat. Being aggrieved, the petitioner approached
this Court by filing the present petition seeking the relief as aforesaid.”
4.
The respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 have filed their affidavit-in-opposition, wherein
Page No.# 4/15
a stand has been taken that while appointing the petitioner, vide appointment letter
dated 16.02.2024, under Memo No.PHQ/PER-213/2024, the petitioner was directed to
report at Police Training Centre on 05.03.2024 subject to the condition at Sl.No.2 of
the offer of appointment that “A Comprehensive Character and Antecedent
verification of the candidate to the fullest satisfaction of the
department, if any adverse remarks received about the Character and
antecedents,
the
service
will
be
terminated
forthwith”. The said
condition was also mentioned in the appointment order dated 22.04.2024. Thereafter,
the Character and antecedent report has been received by the office, which clearly
reveals that the petitioner is involved in one criminal case, being S/Oyan P.S. Case
No.26/2019, under Section 384/506/34 IPC and charge-sheet has been submitted in
the said case, and the case is currently on trial and the same has been reported in the
letter by the Officer-in-Charge, Sille-Oyan Police Station, Pasighat.
4.1.
It is also stated that in the character and antecedent form at Clause Nos. 11 (a)
and 11(b), it is clearly mentioned as under:(i) 11(a):- Have you ever been arrested, prosecuted, kept under
detention or bound down/fined, convicted by a Court of
law for any offences or debarred/disqualified by any
public
service
commission
from
appearing
at
its
examinations /selections or debarred from taking any
examination restricted by any University or any other
Education authority/Institution?
(ii) 11(b):- Is any case pending against you in any Court of law,
University or any other Education authority; Institution
at the time of filling up this attestation form?
(If the answer to (a) & (b) is ‘Yes’ full particulars of the
case, arrest, detention, fine, conviction sentence etc.
and
the
nature
of
the
case
pending
in
the
Court/University/ Educational authority etc. at the time
of filling of this Attestation form, should be given. If
bailed out date and type of bail be mentioned.)
Page No.# 5/15
4.2.
It is further stated that in the instant case, the petitioner has concealed the
abovementioned fact and filled the point at Clause Nos.11(a) and 11(b) as ‘No’ and as
such, the impugned termination order has been issued.
4.3.
It is also stated that the department has issued termination order on
23.07.2024, based on the report received from the Officer-in-Charge, Sille-Oyan Police
Station, Pasighat and the petitioner has filled his character and antecedent form on
18.02.2024, and as such, he has concealed the fact in the attestation form by
responding ‘No’ against Clause 11(a) signed on 18.02.2024, whereas, the judgment of
learned C.J.M., Pasighat is of dated 06.06.2024, and it is apparent that when the
petitioner has filled up the form on 18.02.2024, the case was pending against him.
And as such there is no merit in this petition and that the petitioner was rightly
terminated from service and therefore, it is contended to dismiss the petition.
5.
The petitioner has filed his reply, denying the statement and averment made in
the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondents and he has enclosed the acquittal
order as Annexure-I in his reply affidavit and he has also filed one additional affidavit,
by placing on record the charge-sheet in connection with G.R. Case No.321/2019.
6.
Mr. Taki, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned order, so
passed by the respondent authorities, is illegal and arbitrary for being issued without
giving any opportunity of being heard to the petitioner. He also submits that the
question at Clause 11(a) of the application form, is of a complex nature, and the
petitioner could not understood the same properly, and therefore, he answered the
same as ‘No’ and that there is no suppression of fact and he further submits that the
petitioner was acquitted by the learned C.J.M., Pasighat, vide order dated 06.06.2024,
and despite the termination order was issued on 23.07.2024, and as such, the
impugned order is illegal and arbitrary and therefore, it is contended to set it aside.
7.
In support of his submission, he has referred to a decision of Hon’ble Supreme
Page No.# 6/15
Court in the case of
(i)
Sandeep Kumar v. GB Pant Institute of Engineering and
Technology Ghurdauri & Ors. [Civil Appeal No(s)./2024, arising out
of SLP(C) No(s). 8788-8789/2023]
(ii)
Pawan Kumar vs. Union of India & Anr. [Civil Appeal No(s).3574
of 2022 [Arrising out of SLP(C) No(s). 8788-8789/2023]
(iii)
Shri Dejo Karga v. State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors.
[WP(C) No.25(AP)/2025] and in the case of Shri Gumluk Karbak v.
State of Arunachal Pradesh & Ors. [WP(C) No.612(AP)/2024],
and also a decision of a Coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of to
bolster his submission.
8.
Per contra, Mr. Riram, learned Junior Government Advocate, appearing for the
State respondents, has supported the impugned order dated 23.07.2024. He submits
that the petitioner has suppressed the material fact, while answering the questions at
Clause Nos.11(a) and 11(b) as ‘No’ and that he has filled up the form on 18.02.2024
and he was acquitted by the learned C.J.M., Pasighat on 06.06.2024 and as such, on
18.02.2024 the case was pending against the petitioner before the Court of learned
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Pasighat. He also submits that in the character and
antecedent verification report, the Officer-in-Charge of Sille-Oyan Police Station has
indicated the pendency of the case against the present petitioner and since the
petitioner has suppressed the material facts, while filling up the clauses of the form at
Sl.Nos.11(a) and 11(b), the impugned order suffers from no infirmity or illegality
requiring any interference of this Court. He also submits that the case was originally
registered under Section 384/506/34 IPC, which relates to extortion, threat and
intimidation. He further submits that though, the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Pasighat vide order dated 24.05.2024, has dropped the charge under Section 384 and
only offence under Section 419 and 506 IPC is found to be established and that the
Page No.# 7/15
petitioner is appointed as Constable in the Police Department and he was involved in
the case of extortion and under such circumstances, the impugned order, so passed by
the respondent authorities, suffers from no infirmity requiring any interference of this
Court.
8.1.
In support of his submission, he has also referred to following decision of
Hon’ble Supreme Court in support of his submission:(i)
Daya Shankar Yadav vs. Union of India and Others reported in
(2010) 14 SCC 103.
(ii)
Devendra Kumar v. State of Uttaranchal & Ors., reported in
(2013) 9 SCC 363.
(iii) Avatar Singh vs. Union of India and Others reported in (2016) 8
SCC 471.
(iv) Rajasthans Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited and Another
vs. Anil Kanwariya, reported in (2021) 10 SCC 136.
9.
Having heard the submission of learned counsel for both the parties, this Court
has carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on record and also
gone through the decisions referred by the learned counsel for both the parties.
10.
The basic facts here in this case are not in dispute. Pursuant to an
advertisement dated 03.05.2023 issued by the Secretary cum CoE (APSSB),
Government of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar, the petitioner had applied for the post of
Constable. He appeared in the written test and he got selection on merit and he was
appointed vide order dated 22.04.2024. Thereafter, he had undergone 5 months’
departmental training at Banderdewa Police Training College and while he was
undergoing training, he was served with the termination order dated 23.07.2024. The
ground for termination was that he has violated the condition, as contained at Sl.No.4
of the appointment order and also in Clauses 11(a) and 11(b) of the form filled up by
him for being appointed as Constable.
11.
It is a fact that before passing the termination order no show-cause notice was
Page No.# 8/15
issued to the petitioner and no opportunity of being heard was also granted to him.
But, it is not in dispute that at that time he was under the probation. Further, at
Sl.No.4 of the common appointment order, it is stated that a comprehensive Character
and Antecedent verification of the candidate to the fullest satisfaction of the
department, and if any adverse remarks received about the character and
antecedents, the service will be terminated forthwith.
12.
It also appears that before the service of the petitioner being terminated on
23.07.2024, the Sille-Oyan P.S. Case No.26/2019, registered against the petitioner, has
been charge-sheeted and it was pending before the Court of learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Pasighat and the charge-sheet was filed under Section 384/506/34 IPC.
However, the learned C.J.M., vide order dated 24.05.2024, has held that only offence
under Section 419 and 506 IPC is attracted and thereby dropped the offence under
Section 384 IPC vide order dated 06.06.2024, as the informant on that day do not
want to pursue the case further and thereafter, the learned C.J.M. had acquitted him.
13.
However, the issue before this Court is not the nature and gravity of the charge
and also not of the acquittal or conviction. It is the suppression of fact in the
application form. It is also not in dispute that in the offer of appointment, dated
16.02.2024, being Annexure-II of the petition, at Sl.No.4 it is stated that the petitioner
will be on probation for period of two years. And further from the Annexure-III of the
petition i.e. the common appointment order dated 22.04.2024, specially in condition
No.4 indicates that a comprehensive Character and Antecedent verification of the
candidate to the fullest satisfaction of the department, if any adverse remarks received
about the character and antecedents, the service will be terminated forthwith and
further, from the Annexure-III of the affidavit-in-opposition, in Clauses 11(a) and
11(b) of the attestation form, it is stated that (a) have you ever been arrested,
prosecuted, kept under detention or bound down/fined, convicted by a Court of law
for any offences or debarred/disqualified by any public service commission from
Page No.# 9/15
appearing at its examinations/selections or debarred from taking any examination
restricted by any University or any other Education authority/Institution? And (b) Is
any case pending against you in any Court of law, University or any other Education
authority; Institution at the time of filling up this attestation form? (If the answer to
(a) & (b) is ‘Yes’ full particulars of the case, arrest, detention, fine, conviction sentence
etc. and the nature of the case pending in the Court/University/Educational authority
etc. at the time of filling of this Attestation form, should be given. If bailed out date
and type of bail be mentioned.)
14.
And in the said form, the petitioner herein has answered both the points as ‘No’.
However, from the verification report of the Officer-in-Charge, Special Branch,
Pasighat, which is enclosed with the petition at page No.92 indicates that no any
adverse or criminal records found against the petitioner as per Special Branch records.
But, the report furnished by the Officer-in-Charge, Sille-Oyan Police Station, Pasighat
indicates that as per available P.S. record, it is found that the petitioner has previous
criminal record with respect to S/Oyan P.S. Case No.26/2019, under Section
384/506/34 IPC and the same has been charge-sheeted and pending before the Court
for trial. Thus, Annexure-III of the petition and the report of the Officer-in-Charge,
Sille-Oyan Police Station, which is placed at page No.93 of the petition, indicates that
despite pendency of the Sille-Oyan P.S. Case No.26/2019, under Section 384/506/34
IPC, the petitioner while filling up the form on 18.02.2024, has failed to mention the
same in respect of Clauses 11(a) and 11(b).
15.
Thus, there appears to be suppression of material facts by the petitioner in the
attestation form and in view of the condition No.4 in the common appointment order
dated 22.04.2024, Annexure III of the petition, which stipulates that a comprehensive
character and antecedent verification of the candidate to the fullest satisfaction of the
department. If any adverse remarks received about the character and antecedents,
the service will be terminated forthwith. And accordingly, in view of the said clause,
Page No.# 10/15
the respondent authorities herein have terminated the petitioner from service during
his probation period.
16.
Now, the issue to be addressed by this court is :- what would the consequence
of giving such false information in the application form. According to Mr. Riram,
learned Junior Government Advocate, the impugned order suffers from no infirmity or
illegality as in view of the condition No.4 of the appointment letter, the service of the
petitioner was terminated on receipt of adverse remark. There appears to be
substance in his submission and the decisions referred by him in Devendra Kumar
(supra), Avtar Singh (supra) and Parmod Kumar (supra), also fortified his
submission.
17.
It is to be noted here that a three judge bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of Avtar Singh(supra), while dealing with the issue in question and also taking
note of various decisions summarize the conclusion as under:38.1.
Information given to the employer by a candidate as to
conviction, acquittal or arrest, or pendency of a
criminal case, whether before or after entering into
service must be true and there should be no suppression
or false mention of required information.
38.2.
While passing order of termination of services or
cancellation of candidature for giving false information,
the employer may take notice of special circumstances of
the case, if any, while giving such information.
38.3.
The employer shall take into consideration the Government
orders/instructions/rules, applicable to the employee, at
the time of taking the decision.
38.4.
In case there is suppression or false information of
involvement in a criminal case where conviction or
acquittal had already been recorded before filling of the
application/verification form and such fact later comes
to knowledge of employer, any of the following recourse
appropriate to the case may be adopted:
38.4.1. In a case trivial in nature in which conviction had been
recorded, such as shouting slogans at young age or for a
Page No.# 11/15
petty offence which if disclosed would not have rendered
an incumbent unfit for post in question, the employer
may, in its discretion, ignore such suppression of fact
or false information by condoning the lapse.
38.4.2. Where conviction has been recorded in case which is not
trivial in nature, employer may cancel candidature or
terminate services of the employee.
38.4.3. If acquittal had already been recorded in a case
involving moral turpitude or offence of heinous/serious
nature, on technical ground and it is not a case of clean
acquittal, or benefit of reasonable doubt has been given,
the employer may consider all relevant facts available as
to antecedents, and may take appropriate decision as to
the continuance of the employee.
38.5.
In a case where the employee has made declaration
truthfully of a concluded criminal case, the employer
still has the right to consider antecedents, and cannot
be compelled to appoint the candidate.
38.6.
In case when fact has been truthfully declared in
character verification form regarding pendency of a
criminal case of trivial nature, employer, in facts and
circumstances of the case, in its discretion may appoint
the candidate subject to decision of such case.
38.7.
In a case of deliberate suppression of fact with respect
to multiple pending cases such false information by
itself will assume significance and an employer may pass
appropriate order cancelling candidature or terminating
services as appointment of a person against whom multiple
criminal cases were pending may not be proper.
38.8.
If criminal case was pending but not known to the
candidate at the time of filling the form, still it may
have adverse impact and the appointing authority would
take decision after considering the seriousness of the
crime.
38.9.
In case the employee is confirmed in service, holding
Departmental enquiry would be necessary before passing
order of termination/removal or dismissal on the ground
of suppression or submitting false information in
verification form.
38.10.
For
determining
suppression
or
false
information
Page No.# 12/15
attestation/verification form has to be specific, not
vague. Only such information which was required to be
specifically
mentioned
has
to
be
disclosed.
If
information not asked for but is relevant comes to
knowledge of the employer the same can be considered in
an objective manner while addressing the question of
fitness. However, in such cases action cannot be taken on
basis of suppression or submitting false information as
to a fact which was not even asked for.
38.11.
18.
Before a person is held guilty of suppressio veri or
suggestio falsi, knowledge of the fact must be
attributable to him.
Subsequently, in the case of Anil Kanwariya,(supra) Hon’ble Supreme
Court, taking note of the ratio laid down in the case of Avtar Singh (supra), and
also in other cases held as under:“9. Applying
the law laid down by this Court in the
aforesaid decisions to the facts of the case on hand, the
impugned order [Rajasthan Rajya Vidyut Prasaran Nigam
Ltd. v. Anil Kanwariya, 2019 SCC OnLine Raj 7819] passed
by the Division Bench dismissing the appeal and
confirming the order [Anil Kanwariya v. Rajasthan Rajya
Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Ltd., 2019 SCC OnLine Raj 5082]
passed by the learned Single Judge quashing and setting
aside the order of termination terminating the services
of
the
employee
on
the
ground
of
nondisclosure/suppression of material fact and filing a
false declaration and directing the appellants to
reinstate the respondent employee is unsustainable.”
19.
In the case of Devendra Kumar (supra), the fact of the case was that - while
joining the training, the employee was asked to submit an affidavit giving certain
information, particularly, whether he had ever been involved in any criminal case. The
employee submitted an affidavit stating that he had never been involved in any
criminal case. The employee completed his training satisfactorily and it was at this
Page No.# 13/15
time that the employer in pursuance of the process of character verification came to
know that the employee was in fact involved in a criminal case. It was found that the
final report in that case had been submitted by the prosecution and accepted by the
Judicial Magistrate concerned. On the basis of the same, the employee was discharged
abruptly on the ground that since he was a temporary government servant, he could
be removed from service without holding an enquiry. The said order was challenged
by the employee by filing a writ petition before a Single Judge of the High Court which
was dismissed. The Division Bench upheld that order, which was the subject-matter of
appeal before Hon’ble Supreme Court.
19.1. Dismissing the appeal, Hon’ble Supreme Court observed and held that the
question is not whether the employee is suitable for the post. The
pendency of a criminal case/proceeding is different from suppressing
the information of such pendency. The case pending against a person
might not involve moral turpitude but suppressing of this information
itself amounts to moral turpitude. It is further observed that the information
sought by the employer if not disclosed as required, would definitely amount to
suppression of material information and in that eventuality, the service becomes liable
to be terminated, even if there had been no further trial or the person concerned
stood acquitted/discharged.
20.
In the case of Daya Shankar Yadav (supra) Hon’ble Supreme Court has held
as under:“23. The fact that a criminal case was registered against the
appellant is not disputed. The fact that no criminal case was
pending against him, when he gave the verification
declaration in the year 2004, or the fact that he was not
convicted or fined or bound down in any case, loses
relevance, when he clearly suppressed the material fact that
he was prosecuted and thereby made a false statement. Though
the English version of the questions could have used a little
more clarity, we cannot agree with the contention that he was
misled into answering the question wrongly, as the Hindi
Page No.# 14/15
version of the questions which were answered by the appellant
did not suffer from any vagueness or ambiguity.
24. We are satisfied that the appellant had knowingly made a
false statement that he was not prosecuted in any criminal
case. Therefore, the employer (CRPF) was justified in
dispensing with his services for not being truthful in giving
material information regarding his antecedents which were
relevant for employment in a uniformed service, and that
itself justified his discharge from service. Consequently, we
dismiss this appeal as having no merit.”
21.
The proposition of law, as laid down in the cases discussed here in above, and
application of the same to the given factual matrix of the case would indicates that the
impugned order of termination dated 23.07.2024, terminating the services of the
petitioner on the ground of non-disclosure/suppression of material fact and filing a
false declaration is entitled to an appointment as a matter of right. The question,
however, is not about whether an employee was involved in a dispute of trivial nature
and whether he has been subsequently acquitted or not. The question is about the
credibility and/or trustworthiness of such an employee who at the initial stage of the
employment i.e. while submitting the declaration/verification and/or applying for a
post made false declaration and/or not disclosing and/or suppressing material fact of
having involved in a criminal case.
22.
This Court has carefully considered the submission of the learned counsel for
the petitioner and also carefully gone through the decisions referred by Mr. Taki,
learned counsel for the petitioner in
WP(C)
No.25(AP)/2025 and in WP(C)
No.612(AP)/2024, and find that the facts of the present case is clearly
distinguishable from the fact of the said cases. In the said cases the petitioners were
juvenile at the time of commission of the offence.
22.1. The facts in other two decisions referred by him in Sandeep Kumar (supra)
and Pawan Kumar (supra) also, appears to be distinguishable from the case in hand.
Page No.# 15/15
In the case of Sandeep Kumar (supra), the petitioner was a Registrar of an
University and his service was terminated without holding a disciplinary proceeding
despite his service deemed to have been regularized. Under such circumstances
Supreme Court has interfered with the order of termination. And in the case of Pawan
Kumar (supra), the petitioner was holding the post of Constable in Railway
Protection Force and the criminal matter against him was of trivial nature, not
involving moral turpitude and the nature of post and nature of duties to be discharged
by the recruit has never been looked into by the competent authority while examining
the overall suitability of the incumbent keeping in view Rule 52 of the Rules 1987 to
become a member of the force.
22.2. In the case of Devendra Kumar (supra) it has been held that the case
pending against a person might not involve moral turpitude but suppressing of this
information itself amounts to moral turpitude. In that view of the matter the decision
referred by Mr. Taki, learned counsel for the petitioner, in Sandeep Kumar (supra)
and Pawan Kumar (supra), which are pronounced much later than the case of
Devendra Kumar (supra) would not come into his assistance. Further, the decision
in Avtar Singh (supra), is a decision of three judge bench of Hon’ble Supreme
Court.
23.
In the result, this Court find no merit in this petition and accordingly, the same
stands dismissed, leaving the parties to bear their own cost.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review