Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/10
GAHC040007912023
2026:GAU-AP:742
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP/26/2023
Kadum Apang
S/o Rokom Apang,
R/o Ramsing Village, PO/PS Jengging, Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
VERSUS
Momang Apang
D/o Tani Apang,
R/o Ramsing Village, PO/PS Jengging, Upper Siang District, Arunachal Pradesh.
Advocate for the Petitioner
Gammi
: Nalo Pada, Tanur Gao,Adam Tatak,Tsering Gyatso,Amy Talom,Tonni
Advocate for the Respondent : Ninnong Ratan, Pura Khongkhung,Orin Modi
-BEFOREHON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
Advocate for the petitioner
: Mr. Nalo Pada, Adv.
Advocate for the respondent
: Mr. O. Modi, Adv.
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
27.07.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
:
07.08.2026
:
N/A
Page No.# 2/10
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. N. Pada, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr.
O. Modi, learned counsel for the respondent.
2.
The instant revision has been preferred by the petitioner
namely, Kadum Apang, under section 115 CPC, 1908, assailing the
judgment and order dated 17-03-2023 passed by the Court of the
learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Yingkiong, Arunachal Pradesh
in Title Suit No. 01/2021, whereby the preliminary objection to the
suit by the petitioner as defendant No. 1 was rejected and it was
held that the suit is not hit by the doctrine of res judicata and that it
can proceed.
3.
The facts in brief are that the respondent herein, namely
Momang Apang, instituted the title suit registered as Title Suit No. 1
of 2021, for declaration of title and rights of Resing Arik area at
Ramsing village and consequential relief of permanent injunction
against the petitioner. In the suit, the petitioner was arrayed as
defendant No. 1, along with other defendants and on being
authorized by the other defendants, he filed a joint written
statement on various grounds including preliminary objections. The
petitioner as defendant No. 1 raised a preliminary objection on the
ground that the subject matter of the dispute pertaining to the
property was already decided by the Kebang on 14-03-2021, in favor
of the petitioner and therefore, the subsequent suit instituted by the
Page No.# 3/10
respondent as plaintiff is barred by the doctrine of res judicata.
4.
However, the learned Trial Court was not impressed by the
contentions of the petitioner and it held by the impugned order
dated 17-03-2023 that the earlier decision was not by a competent
forum and therefore, one of the essential ingredients of the doctrine
of res judicata being missing, the present suit was not barred by the
said doctrine and decided to proceed with the suit.
5.
It may be mentioned here that initially by the order dated 19-
06-2023, this Court was pleased to direct stay of the suit
proceedings; however, by subsequent order dated 12-07-2023, after
hearing the parties, was pleased to vacate the said interim order.
Pursuant thereof, the suit has proceeded, witnesses have been
examined and final hearing was stated to have been fixed on 28-072026.
6.
This Court while reserving the judgment on 27-07-2026
observed that the learned Trial court may proceed with the
arguments, but judgment shall not be pronounced until disposal of
the instant revision petition.
7.
The sole respondent has filed affidavit-in-opposition to the
revision petition and the petitioner has also filed an affidavit-in-reply
to the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent. The petitioner also
filed an additional affidavit in the revision bringing on record certain
documents.
8.
The primary contentions of the petitioner are that the revision
petition is maintainable and that the impugned order dated 17-032023 is not an interlocutory order and that it satisfies the ingredients
Page No.# 4/10
of proviso to sub section 1 of section 115 CPC. Another contention of
the petitioner is that the village authority by way of Kebang, which
had passed the order dated 14-03-2021 was a competent forum to
do so and that the Kebang decision was passed in compliance with
the provisions of law mandated under section 5 and section 44 of
the Assam Frontier Regulation, 1945 (hereinafter AFR). It is
contended that Alo Pangkam, Gaon bura and signatory No. 17 of the
Kebang decision dated 14-03-2021 was the lone Gaon bura of
Ramsing village, and he was duly appointed by the Deputy
Commissioner, Upper Siang district, Yingkiong. It is also contended
that in terms of the stipulations, the Kebang proceeding dated 1403-2021 was conducted in open darbar in the community hall of
Ramsing village. It is contended by the petitioner that the
respondent was aware of the Kebang proceedings and he even
requested to postpone it to 21-03-2021.
9.
The petitioner also contends that the provisions of AFR or
Arunachal Pradesh Civil Courts Act does not stipulate as to how
many Gaon Buras should be present in the Kebang proceeding and
as to whether Gaon Buras should stamp their seal after they sign on
such Kebang decision.
10. The contentions of the respondent side that have emerged
from their affidavit-in-opposition is that the civil revision is barred by
the proviso to sub section 1 of section 115 CPC and that the
impugned order dated 17-03-2023, being an interlocutory order, civil
revision would not lie against it. Another contention of the
respondent is that the plaint cannot be rejected on the plea of res
Page No.# 5/10
judicata. The most important contention of the respondent is that
the Kebang decision is not by a competent authority and therefore,
the principle of res judicata contended by the petitioner as
defendant in the suit would not hold.
11. Mr. N. Pada, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
the order dated 14-03-2021 passed by the Kebang was valid and
legal order and it fulfilled the requirements of section 44 of the AFR.
He further submits that at the time of filing of the proceeding, the
provisions of the Arunachal Pradesh Civil Courts Act had not come
into being. It is submitted that the impugned order dated 17-032023, amounts to deciding the title suit on merits. He contends that
the civil revision is maintainable in terms of the proviso to sub
section 1 of section 115 CPC. It is submitted that the Kebang vide
order dated 14-03-2021 had validly decided the title of the property
in favour of the petitioner.
12. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for the
petitioner cites the following decisions:-
(i)K. D. Sharma Vs. Steel Authority of India Ltd and Ors, Civil Appeal
No. 4270 of 2008;
(ii) Pawan Kumar Gupta Vs. Rochiram Nagdeo reported in 1994 (4)
SCC 243;
(iii) Sitaram @ Mahendra Ghosh and Ors Vs. Sri Antaryami
Mohapatra and 18 Ors reported in 2003 (II) OLR 409.
13. On the other hand, Mr. O. Modi, the learned counsel for the
sole respondent submits that the Kebang decision dated 14-03-2021
is not by a valid forum and therefore, the principle of res judicata
Page No.# 6/10
would not apply. It is submitted that in terms of section 5 of the
AFR, village authority should be appointed by the Deputy
Commissioner. It is submitted by the respondent counsel that the
order dated 14-03-2021 declaring title in favour of the petitioner
having being passed by an incompetent forum would not act as res
judicata and therefore, the suit is maintainable and rightly it was
allowed to proceed and is on the verge of completion.
14. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for the
respondent cites the following decisions:(i)
Srihari Hanumandas Totala Vs. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors
reported in 2021 AIR (SC) 3802;
(ii)
Tek Singh Vs. Shashi Verma and Anr reported in 2019 Supreme
(SC) 320.
15. I have perused the revision petition, the additional affidavit,
the
affidavit-in-opposition
and
the
affidavit-in-reply.
I
have
considered the submissions of the learned counsels on both the
sides and perused the relevant documents annexed. I have also
perused the decisions cited at the Bar.
16. As already mentioned above in para 3, the petitioner as
defendant No. 1, raised a preliminary objection that the suit
preferred by the respondent plaintiff was barred by the doctrine of
res judicata ; however, the learned Trial court did not agree with the
same and dismissed the said plea. If the said plea that the suit was
barred by res judicata was accepted by the learned Trial court in
favour of the petitioner as defendant No. 1, then, the suit would
have come to an end. In other words, the proceedings would have
Page No.# 7/10
ended. Therefore, the aforesaid situation fulfils the criteria laid down
in proviso to section 115 (1) of the Civil Procedure Code, 1908,
regarding maintainability of a civil revision under section 115 (1)
CPC, 1908. The aforementioned section 115 (1) along with the
proviso may be reproduced herein below:
“115. Revision.— [(1)] The High Court may call for the record of any
case which has been decided by any Court subordinate to such High
Court and in which no appeal lies thereto, and if such subordinate Court
appears—
(a) to have exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it by law, or
(b) to have failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, or
(c) to have acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with
material irregularity,
the High Court may make such order in the case as it thinks fit:
[Provided that the High Court shall not, under this section, vary
or reverse any order made, or any order deciding an issue, in the
course of a suit or other proceeding, except where the order, if it had
been made in favour of the party applying for revision would have
finally disposed of the suit or other proceedings.]
(2) The High Court shall not, under this section, vary or reverse
any decree or order against which an appeal lies either to the High
Court or to any Court subordinate thereto.
(3) A revision shall not operate as a stay of suit or other
proceeding before the Court except where such suit or other proceeding
is stayed by the High Court.]”
17. In the aforesaid facts and circumstances, I am of the view that
the revision against the impugned order would be maintainable
under section 115 Code of Civil Procedure, 1908.
18. It is well settled that the issue of res judicata cannot be a
ground for rejection of plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC as
determination of the doctrine involves looking beyond the pleadings
of the plaintiff and would not be permissible under Order 7 Rule 11
CPC.
19.
In this context, reference can be made to the case of Srihari
Hanumandas Totala Vs. Hemant Vithal Kamat & Ors reported
Page No.# 8/10
in 2021 Supreme (SC) 432 and the relevant paragraph 25.4, is
reproduced herein below:
“25.4. Since an adjudication of the plea of res judicata requires
consideration of the pleadings, issues and decision in the “previous suit”,
such a plea will be beyond the scope of Order 7 Rule 11(d), where only
the statements in the plaint will have to be perused.”
20. The decision in Tek Singh (supra) relied upon by the
respondent side would not come to the aid of the respondent side.
21. Upon perusing the impugned order dated 17-03-2023, passed
by the learned Court below, it appears that question of res judicata
has been framed and answered as a preliminary issue.The court on
the basis of the materials and submissions held that the earlier
court was not a competent court to decide the matter at hand and
therefore, the principle of res judicata would not apply. It is well
settled that a mixed question of law and fact cannot be framed as a
preliminary issue and that, only a question of law can be so framed
as a preliminary issue.
22. In the instant case, the question of res judicata could not have
been framed as a preliminary issue in any case, as it involved looking
into some disputed facts as well regarding the competency of
the customary court which had passed the earlier order.
23. From perusal of the materials and the submissions made by
the learned counsels on both the sides, it is clear that one of the
important questions which would determine whether the doctrine of
res judicata would apply - is whether the former forum i.e, the
Customary court was competent vis-a-vis the subsequent litigation.
The Learned Trial Court merely held on perusing the materials before
Page No.# 9/10
commencement of trial that res judicata would not apply as the
former forum was not a competent court.
24. However, it has transpired from the materials and submissions
that the competency or otherwise of the previous forum was a
disputed question and therefore, the said question can be
determined only by framing it as an issue in the trial, allowing the
parties to adduce evidence on the same and adjudicate the issue on
the basis of such evidence and materials.
25. Therefore, the impugned order dated 17-03-2023 is interfered
with, to the extent that the learned Trial Court shall frame a specific
issue regarding applicability of the doctrine of res judicata and
enable the plaintiff and the defendants to lead evidence upon the
same. Upon undertaking that exercise, the said issue of applicability
or otherwise of the doctrine of res judicata to the suit will be
decided as part of the adjudication of the title suit as a whole.
26. It has been submitted by the learned counsels at the Bar that
evidence is completed and the case was posted for final hearing on
28-07-2026. And in that context, while reserving the instant revision
for judgment vide order dated 27-07-2026, it was observed that
while the learned Trial Court can proceed with the arguments, but
the judgment shall not be pronounced, until the disposal of the
instant revision petition.
27. In view of the direction vide this judgment, regarding framing
of the additional issue and adjudication, the learned Trial Court may
now proceed with the trial and bring it to conclusion, after
undertaking the aforesaid exercise, as directed.
Page No.# 10/10
28. The civil revision stands disposed of on the aforesaid terms.
29. Return back the case records received from the learned Trial
Court.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review