Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Date of reserved for Judgment :17.12.2025
Date of Pronouncement
:24.03.2026
Date of uploading
:24.03.2026
APHC010627682013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3520]
TUESDAY,THE TWENTY FOURTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 866/2013
Between:
1. K.PARVATHI, W/O. LATE ANNAIAH NAIDU, OCC: HOUSEWIFE, R/O.
CHOWDEPALLE VILLAGE, PUTHALAPAT MANDAL, CHITTOOR
DISTRICT.
...APPELLANT
AND
1. SMT K JYOTHI BHUVANESWARI 3 OTHERS, W/O. K.ANNAIAH NAIDU,
OCC: HOUSEWIFE, R/O. N.KATTAKINDAPALLE VILLAGE, E.KOTHURU
POST, IRALA MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
2. K RAGHUNADHA NAIDU, S/O. CHINNA AKKAIAH NAIDU, OCC:
CULTIVATION R/O. N.KATTAKINDAPALLE VILLAGE, E.KOTHURU
POST, IRALA MANDAL, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
3. SMT M NIRMALA, W/O. CHENGALPATHI NAIDU, OWNER OF TEMPO
MINI LORRY, NO. AP 03 V 4167, R/O. SIVA JYOTHI NAGAR, D.NO. 203-53E, (ERRA MITTA), TIRUPATHI, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
4. THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, REP. BY ITS
BRANCH MANAGER, TIRUPATI, CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant:
1. SURESH KUMAR REDDY KALAVA
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. K SITA RAM
2. GUDI SRINIVASU
3. A V NARAYANA RAO
The Court made the following:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.866 of 2013
JUDGMENT:
Introductory:
The 3rd respondent in M.V.O.P. No. 358 of 2005 on the file of the IX
Additional District Judge-cum-Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal (FTC), Chittoor
(for short “the learned MACT”), filed the present appeal. Her status as wife of
one K. Annaiah Naidu (deceased) is in dispute.
2.
The 1st and 2nd respondents herein are the claimants. The 3rd respondent
herein is the owner of the tempo mini Lorry bearing No.AP 03 V 4167 [hereinafter
referred as ‘the offending vehicle’] and the 4
th
respondent herein is the Insurance
Company with which the offending vehicle was insured.
3.
Claim was made by the 1st and 2nd respondents herein for awarding a
compensation of Rs.4,00,000/-
for the death of one K. Annaiah Naidu
[hereinafter referred as ‘the deceased’] in motor vehicle accident, contending
that the 1st respondent is the wife, the 2nd respondent is the father of the
deceased, and disputing the status of appellant that she is not the wife of the
deceased.
4.
Learned MACT awarded a compensation of Rs.2,60,000/- in total with
interest 7.5%p.a., out of which, apportioned the amount of Rs.90,000/- each to
the appellant and the 1st respondent herein, being wives, and Rs.80,000/- to the
2nd respondent, father of the deceased.
5.
Appeal is filed contending that the appellant alone is entitled for entire
compensation and that the quantum of compensation awarded is not just and
reasonable.
6.
For the sake of convenience, parties will be herein after referred as the
claimants and the respondents as and how they are arrayed before the learned
MACT.
Case of the claimants, in brief, is that:7.
[i]
On 18.8.2002 at about 5.30 p.m., the deceased left Tirupati in the
offending vehicle, for getting the load of papaya fruits from Koduru, when the
vehicle was near the hotel of Maravaripalle cross, the driver of the said lorry
drove the same in a rash and negligent manner, and hit the backside of the oil
tanker bearing No.AP 03 U 1440, causing accident.
In the said accident,
K.Annamaya Naidu/deceased sustained severe and multiple injuries and
succumbed to the injuries while shifting to the hospital.
[ii]
A case in Crime No.100 of 2002 was registered for the offences
under Section 337-304A IPC, and charge sheet was laid against the driver of the
offending vehicle.
[iii]
The deceased was aged about 38years; hale and healthy, working
as a Manager under 1st respondent, getting a salary of Rs.2000/- per month, and
batta of Rs.50/- per day. He has agricultural lands in an extent of Ac.1.80 cents
of wet land and Ac.0.60 cents of dry land, raising the crops and was earning
Rs.33,000/- by way of agricultural income per annum. He was contributing his all
income to the family and the petitioners lost all valuable support. Hence, the
claim.
[iv]
The 3rd respondent filed Petition vide OP No.15 of 2003 for grant of
Succession Certificate, claiming that she is wife of the deceased. Hence, she is
made as a party, although she is not entitled.
[v]
The 1st respondent is the owner of the offending vehicle. 2nd
respondent is the authorized insurer, with whom the vehicle was insured.
Therefore, the first and second respondents are liable to pay.
Case of the first respondent, owner of the offending vehicle.
8.
[i]
Claimants shall prove the age, occupation and income of the
deceased.
[ii]
Compensation claimed is excessive.
[iii]
Offending vehicle was insured with the 2nd respondent. In the event
of any liability, the 2nd respondent is accountable.
Case of the 2nd respondent/Insurance Company:9.
[i]
Claimants shall prove the pleaded accident, negligence of the driver
of the offending vehicle, age, occupation, and income of the deceased, loss of
dependency, etc.
[ii]
Further, the Insurance Policy, compliance of Policy conditions, etc.,
shall be proved.
[iii]
Negligence of the driver of the Oil Tanker is the cause for the
accident, the petition is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties.
[iv]
The deceased is a gratuitous passenger. Therefore, the 2nd
respondent is not liable to pay any compensation.
Case of the 3rd respondent:10.
[i]
The 3rd respondent is the legitimate wife of the deceased.
[ii]
She has filed OP No.15 of 2003 for grant of Succession Certificate
and the same is pending.
[iii]
Subject matter of the Succession Certificate is in respect of the
amount lying in the Primary Agricultural Co-operative Society (PACS), Nampalli.
[iv]
The 1st and 2nd petitioners have colluded and filed the present case.
The 3rd respondent alone is entitled to the compensation. The 1 st petitioner was
planted by the 2nd petitioner to knock away the compensation amount; the 3rd
respondent and the 2nd petitioner are the only legal heirs under law. There were
misunderstandings between the 3rd respondent and her husband. However, they
have been settled.
11.
Considering the pleadings, learned MACT settled issues touching the
points - 1) Accident and negligence 2) Entitlement of 1st petitioner and the 3rd
respondent for compensation and entitlement of the 2 nd petitioner as well as the
liability of the respondents.
Findings of the learned MACT:12.
[i]
Admittedly, the 2nd petitioner is the father of the deceased.
[ii]
Relationship of the 1st petitioner and the 3rd respondent with the
deceased is in dispute.
[iii]
Ex.B3 is disclosing the marriage of the 1st petitioner with the
deceased.
[Iv]
Ex.B4 is disclosing the marriage of the 3rd respondent with the
deceased and also the 3rd respondent and the deceased living in a house prior to
3.9.1981 whereas the marriage of the 1st petitioner with the deceased taken
place on 19.06.1995.
[v]
As against the Succession Certificate granted to the 3rd respondent,
appeal is pending vide AS No.21 of 2012 on the file of the Principal District
Judge, Chittoor.
[vi]
The evidence is indicating that the deceased married 3rd respondent,
lived with her for some time, later married the 1st petitioner and lived with her until
his death.
[vii]
Inquest report indicating participation of both wives. Therefore, it
can be said that the deceased died in an accident, leaving behind him, the 1 st
petitioner as his second wife and the 3rd respondent as his first wife and 2nd
petitioner is his father. All the three can be considered as legal representatives
of the deceased.
[viii]
The income of the deceased can be accepted @Rs.24,000/- per
annum. ‘15’ multiplier is applicable.
[ix]
Upon deducting 1/3rd towards personal expenditure, the entitlement
for claimants comes to Rs.2,40,000/-, and Rs.5,000/- towards funeral
expenditure and Rs.5,000/- each to the 1st petitioner and the 3rd respondent
towards loss of consortium and Rs.5,000/- towards loss of estate. In all claimants
are a compensation of Rs.2,60,000/-, with apportionment @Rs.90,000/- each to
the 1st petitioner and the 3rd respondent and Rs.80,000/- for the 2nd
petitioner/father of the deceased.
Arguments in the appeal:
For the appellant/3rd respondent:13.
[i]
The appellant/3rd respondent has obtained a Succession Certificate.
[ii]
According to the observations of the learned MACT, since she is the
wife of the deceased, total compensation ought to have been awarded to her.
[iii]
Taking income @Rs.24,000/- per annum is not correct.
[iv]
There is no rationality in quantification and apportionment of
compensation. Claimants are entitled for more compensation.
For the 2nd respondent- Insurance Company :14.
[i]
Compensation awarded is excessive.
[ii]
The deceased is a gratuitous passenger.
[iii]
Insurance Company is not liable to pay any compensation for the
claimants.
[iv]
The appellant is not entitled for any compensation since she has
been living separately and the propriety of Succession Certificate obtained by her
is questioned and the subject matter is subjudise before the appellate court. The
appeal is liable to be dismissed.
Scope of the appeal:15.
[i]
There is no appeal by the Insurance Company, therefore, the issue
relating to the liability of the Insurance Company is out of the dispute.
[ii]
There is no appeal by the claimants. Therefore, the entitlement of
the 3rd respondent for the compensation is out of dispute.
[iii]
The appeal is filed by the 3rd respondent, therefore, exclusive
entitlement of the 3rd respondent for the compensation and the quantification of
compensation done by the learned MACT alone are the subject matters of the
present appeal.
16.
The points that arose for determination in this appeal are –
1) Whether the 3rd respondent/appellant alone is entitled for the
compensation and the 1st petitioner in M.V.O.P.No.358 of 2005 before
the learned MACT is not entitled for any compensation?
2) Whether the compensation of Rs.2,60,000/- awarded by the land MACT
in M.V.O.P.No.358 of 2005 under the impugned Award and Decree
dated 21.12.2012 is just, adequate and reasonable? Or require any
enhancement?
3)
What is the result of the appeal?
Point No.1:17.
The 3rd respondent as RW1 relied on the Succession Certificate granted in
her favor on 09.08.2010. Subject matter in that case is amount lying in a PACS
Nampally.
She has applied for Succession Certificate.
During her cross-
examination, it is elicited that, as per Ex.B3/ the 1st petitioner is the wife of the
deceased, and their marriage was performed on 19.06.1995. She did not file any
record to show that she was residing with the deceased at Kattakindapalli
Village. The decree of Succession Certificate is challenged in the appeal Vide
A.S.No.21 of 2011 on the file of the Court of District Judge, Chittoor and the said
appeal is pending.
18.
The 1st petitioner was examined as P.W.1, and her evidence as to the
relationship of the 3rd respondent with the deceased is concerned, she is claiming
that 3rd respondent (appellant) is not the wife of the deceased and the
Succession Certificate was obtained with false allegations. During the crossexamination done for the 3rd respondent/appellant, PW.1 stated that her marriage
with the deceased took place on 19.06.1995 in a in a temple Vinayakaswamy
temple of Somala village. She further stated that she do not know that by the
date of her marriage whether her husband/ deceased married to 3 rd respondent
and do not know about the 3rd respondent filing SOP No. 15 of 2002. She further
stated that she stayed at Kuwait for a period of one year, after the death of her
husband.
19.
The 2nd petitioner was examined as PW2 he stated that the 3rd respondent
is not the wife of his son/deceased and she never stayed with the deceased.
During his cross-examination done for the 3rd respondent, he has stated that
photographs shown to him is that of his son, late K. Annaiah Naidu’s. Said
photograph is marked as Ex.B1. He further stated that in Ex.B1, the other female
person is standing before the court (3rd respondent) and he did not know whether
Ex.B1 was taken when the marriage of the deceased and the 3rd respondent is
performed. He do not know whether his son married the 3 rd respondent on
03.09.1981 and he cannot say whether 3rd respondent is his daughter-in-law.
20.
Further, the evidence of other witness, RW2 would show that there was
marriage between the 3rd respondent and the deceased. Nothing important could
be elicited from RW2. RW3 also stated about the marriage between the
deceased and the 3rd respondent, except suggesting that the deceased married
1st petitioner nothing is elicited from RW3.
21.
RW4 is sister of the 3rd respondent stated about the marriage between the
deceased and the 3rd respondent.
22.
Oral and documentary evidence placed by the parties is indicating the
relationship of the deceased with the 3rd respondent/appellant. Inquest report is
indicating the presence of both, the 1st petitioner and the third respondent as
blood relatives at serial numbers 2 and 3 and they were shown as first and
second wives in the inquest report. Therefore, the entitlement of both the 1 st
petitioner and the 3rd respondent for compensation need not be doubted.
However, the findings herein shall be confined only to the present claim petition.
The respective contentions of the parties regarding their legal status as the wife
of the deceased, as well as the validity of the marriage between the deceased
and either the 1st petitioner or the 3rd respondent, shall remain subject matter for
adjudication in any pending litigations between the parties. The scope of the
inquiry in this claim petition is limited solely to the determination of entitlement to
compensation on the ground of dependency. Therefore, this Court is of the view
that the conclusions drawn herein are limited to entitlement of both the 1 st
petitioner and the 3rd respondent for compensation.
23.
In a similar situation, where the claim of the second wife was disputed
considering aspect that the dependency is the criteria for awarding the
compensation in a claim under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, the
Honourable High Court of Karnataka, in a case between Smt.Lalita Vs. MFA
no.24165 of 2012 (MV) and Bach considered the entitlement of the second wife
on the ground of dependency, referring to the judgments of the Honourable Apex
Court vide Rameshwari Devi Vs. State of Bihar and Ors.1.
Further, the High
Court of Madras in C.M.A.(MD) 681 of 2019, observed that the though second
wife cannot be considered as a legal representative, certainly she is a dependent
while referring to other judgments of the Honourable Apex Court, Honourable
AIR 200 SC 735
High Court of Karnataka and other High Courts interpreting the expression ‘legal
representative’, and held that the second wife is also entitled for compensation.
24.
In the light of the evidence and in view of the observations made in the
above cited authorities, this Court finds that the first petitioner is also entitled for
compensation and findings of the learned MACT as to her entitlement does not
warrant any interference. Therefore, this Court finds that 1st and 2 nd petitioners
as well as the 3rd respondent are entitled for the compensation. Point No.1 is
answered accordingly.
Point No.2:25.
Learned MACT has considered the income of the deceased at Rs.24,000/-
per annum. To show the income of the deceased, there is no documentary
evidence. Further, it is claimed that the deceased was having landed property
and also he was engaged in agricultural operations also.
26.
Upon considering socio-economic circumstances of the year 2002, when
the accident took place, this Court finds that the income taken by the learned
MACT @Rs.24,000/- per annum is reasonable. But upon considering the age of
the deceased, this Court finds that there should have been at least 30% addition
to the income of the deceased towards future prospects, whereby the income
comes to Rs.31,200/- per annum. 1/3rd is deducted towards personal expenditure
contribution of income of the deceased to the family comes Rs.20,800/- per
annum.
Upon application of multiplier ‘15’, the entitlement of compensation
comes to Rs.3,12,000/- under the head of loss of dependency. Both the wives
are entitled together Rs.40,000/- @Rs.20,000/- each towards loss of consortium
and all the claimants together are entitled Rs.15,000/- towards funeral expenses,
Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate.
27.
In view of the reasons and evidence referred above, the entitlement of the
claimants and the 3rd respondent for reasonable compensation in comparison to
the compensation awarded by the learned MACT is found as follows:
Head
(i)
Loss of dependency
(ii)
Loss of estate
(iii)
Loss of Consortium
(iv)
Funeral expenses
Total compensation
awarded
Interest (per annum)
Compensation awarded
by the learned MACT
[@Rs.5000/No.1 and R3]
Fixed by this Court
Rs. 2,40,000/-
Rs. 3,12,000/-
Rs.5,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.10,000/-
Rs.80,000/-
Rs.5,000/-
Rs.15,000/-
Rs.2,60,000/-
Rs.4,22,000/-
7.5%
6%
each
to
claimant [@ Rs.40,000/- to the 2nd
claimant and @Rs.20,000/- each
to 1st- claimant and the 3rd
respondent]
{{{{
Granting of more compensation than what claimed, if the claimants are
otherwise entitled:28.
The legal position with regard to awarding more compensation than what is
claimed has been considered and settled by the Hon’ble Supreme Court holding
that there is no bar for awarding more compensation than what is claimed. For
the said proposition of law, this Court finds it proper to refer the following
observations of the Hon’ble Supreme Court made in:
(1)
Nagappa vs. Gurudayal Singh and Others 2, at para 21 of the judgment,
that –
“..there is no restriction that the Tribunal/Court cannot award compensation
amount exceeding the claimed amount. The function of the Tribunal/Court is
to award “just” compensation, which is reasonable on the basis of evidence
produced on record.”
(2)
Kajal vs. Jagadish Chand and Ors.3 at para 33 of the judgment, as
follows:“33. We are aware that the amount awarded by us is more than the amount
claimed. However, it is well settled law that in the motor accident claim
petitions, the Court must award the just compensation and, in case, the just
compensation is more than the amount claimed, that must be awarded
especially where the claimant is a minor.”
(2003) 2 SCC 274
2020 (04) SCC 413
(3) Ramla and Others
vs. National Insurance Company Limited and
Others4 at para 5 of the judgment, as follows:“5. Though the claimants had claimed a total compensation of Rs 25,00,000
in their claim petition filed before the Tribunal, we feel that the compensation
which the claimants are entitled to is higher than the same as mentioned
supra. There is no restriction that the Court cannot award compensation
exceeding the claimed amount, since the function of the Tribunal or Court
under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 is to award “just
compensation”. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial and welfare legislation.
A “just compensation” is one which is reasonable on the basis of evidence
produced on record. It cannot be said to have become time-barred. Further,
there is no need for a new cause of action to claim an enhanced amount. The
courts are duty-bound to award just compensation.”
29.
For the aforestated reasons and in view of the discussion made above, the
point No.2 is answered concluding that the claimants are entitled for
compensation of Rs.4,22,000/- with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the
date of petition till the date of realization and the Award and decree dated
21.12.2012 passed by the learned MACT in M.V.O.P.No.358 of 2005 require
modification accordingly.
Point No.3:
30.
In the result, the appeal is partly allowed as follows:(i) the compensation awarded under the award and decree dated
21.12.2012 passed by the IX Additional District Judge-cum-Motor
Accidents Claims Tribunal (FTC), Chittoor (MACT ) in M.V.O.P.No.358
(2019) 2 SCC 192
of 2005 at Rs.2,60,000/- with interest at the rate of 7.5% per annum is
modified and enhanced to Rs.4,22,000/- with interest at the rate of
7.5% per annum from the date of petition till the date of realization.
(ii)
Claimants/petitioners are liable to pay the Court fee for the enhanced
part of the compensation, before the learned MACT.
(iii)
Apportionment:
(a) Petitioner No.1 and the 3rd respondent / wives of the deceased
are entitled for Rs.1,50,000/- each with proportionate interest and
costs.
(b) 2nd petitioner / father of the deceased are entitled for Rs.1,22,000/each with proportionate interest.
(iv)
Respondents 1 and 2 before the learned MACT are liable to pay the
compensation. However, Respondent No.2 is liable in view of the
Insurance Policy.
(v)
Time for payment /deposit of balance amount is two (2) months.
(a) If the petitioners/claimants furnish the bank account number within
15 days from today, the 2nd respondent shall deposit the amount
directly into the bank account of the claimants and file the
necessary proof before the learned MACT.
(b) If the petitioners fail to comply with clause (v)(a) above, the 2 nd
respondent shall deposit the amount before the learned MACT and
the claimants are entitled to withdraw the amount at once on
deposit.
(vi)
There shall be no order as to costs, in the appeal.
(vii)
As a sequel, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the appeal
shall stand closed.
Date: 24 .03.2026
Pnr
____________________________
A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA, J
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE A. HARI HARANADHA SARMA
M.A.C.M.A.No.866 of 2013
24.03.2026
Pnr
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review