The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Admittedly, the suit properties are joint family properties in which the plaintiffs and the defendant equally entitled to 1/3rd share. The alleged oral partition claimed by the defendant as in-equal in nature is not permissible under law. The averment of the plaintiffs proved that in the joint family properties, each entitled to 1/3rd share total extent of 10 acres. The findings rendered by the courts below is well reasoned and requires no interference. There is no substantial question of law involved in the present second appeal. There is no merit in this appeal and the second appeal is liable to be dismissed. https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis S.A.No.856 of 2025 and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
14. Accordingly, this Second Appeal stands dismissed, confirming the decree and judgment dated 26.08.2025 passed in A.S. No.34 of 2013, on the file of the IV Additional District Court, Udumalapettai, upholding the decree and judgment dated 27.07.2012 passed in O.S.No.40 of 2010, on the file of the Subordinate Court, Udumalapettai. Considering the relationship between the parties, there is no order as to costs. Consequently, connected Civil Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 21.01.2026
CORAM:
THE HONOURABLE MRS.JUSTICE T.V.THAMILSELVI
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P. No.32983 of 2025
K.P.Muthusamy
… Appellant
vs
1.K.M.Sureshkumar
2.K.M.Poorani
... Respondents
Prayer : Second Appeal filed under Section 100 CPC, 1908 against the
decree and judgment dated 26.08.2025 passed in A.S. No.34 of 2013, on
the file of the IV Additional District Court, Udumalapettai, upholding the
decree and judgment dated 27.07.2012 passed in O.S.No.40 of 2010, on
the file of the Subordinate Court, Udumalapettai.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
For Appellant
: Mr.N.Thiagarajan
For Respondents
: Mrs. Hema Sampath
Senior Counsel
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
JUDGMENT
This Second Appeal is filed praying to set aside the judgment and
decree passed in A.S.No.34 of 2013 on the file of the IV Additional
District Court, Udumalapettai, dated 26.08.2025, by which the learned IV
Additional District Judge, confirmed the judgment and decree dated
27.07.2012 passed in O.S.No.40 of 2010 on the file of the Subordinate
Court, Udumalapettai.
2. For the sake of convenience, the parties are addressed as per
their ranking before the trial court. Challenging the concurrent findings
of the Courts below the defendant has preferred this appeal.
3. The respondents herein / the plaintiff filed the suit in
O.S.No.40/2010 on the file of the Subordinate Court, Udumalapettai,
claiming their lawful 1/3rd share each in the suit properties as described
in the plaint schedule stating that it is joint family properties, in which the
plaintiffs and their father each entitled to 1/3rd share but their father
refused to give their share. Therefore, they come forward with the suit for
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
partition. The said suit was contested by the appellant / defendant stating
that due to difference of opinion with the plaintiffs, there was a panchayat
held in the presence of the village elders namely, one Kumarasamy and
Marudhamuthu, wherein orally an arrangement was made in respect of
division of the properties in which 60 cents was allotted to the plaintiffs
as they were living in other places and remaining extent of 9 acres 40
cents was allotted to this defendant since he was suffered with family
needs and other liabilities. Accordingly, possession has also been taken by
all the sharers and subsequently the said family arrangement was reduced
into writing on 19.08.2007 in the presence of Notary Public at Pollachi, in
which the plaintiffs were also signatories, but suppressing the said family
arrangement they have come forward with the present suit, which is not
maintainable and prayed to dismiss the Suit.
4. Before the trial court both the parties adduced evidence. The
learned Trial Judge, on considering the oral and documentary evidence,
finally held that the alleged family arrangement was not been proved by
the defendant in all the signatures found in the document (Ex.B1) is that
of the plaintiffs by comparing the signatures found in their marriage
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
registration certificates (Ex.X1 to Ex.X4) and also held that the alleged
oral partition in the presence of panchayatdhars also not been proved,
thereby held that the family properties are joint family properties in
which the plaintiffs each entitled 1/3rd share, accordingly the suit was
decreed as prayed for.
5. Aggrieved over the said findings, the defendant has preferred an
appeal in A.S.No.34 of 2013 before the IV Additional District Court,
Udumalapettai. The first appellate judge has analysed the entire facts and
evidence and framed separate point for consideration and finally held that
the suit properties are joint family properties in nature. As per the
compromise decree held in OS No.272 of 1994 in which the plaintiffs and
the defendant each entitled to 1/3rd share and the alleged oral partition
pleaded by the defendant not been proved, so also the family arrangement
not been proved as required under law and also held that the signatures
found in the said family arrangement (Ex.B1) also not belongs to the
plaintiffs. Thereby the learned first appellate judge held that the burden
cast upon the defendant in respect of proving oral partition as well as
subsequent family arrangement not been proved. On the other hand, the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
plaintiffs established that the suit properties are joint family properties in
nature and they are entitled to 1/3rd share. As on date no division was
taken place. Accordingly, the findings of the Trial Court was confirmed
and dismissed the appeal. Aggrieved over the concurrent findings of the
Courts below, the defendant has preferred the present second appeal.
6. Heard Mr.N.Thiagarajan, learned counsel for the appellant and
Mrs. Hema Sampath, learned Senior Counsel for the respondents.
7. The learned counsel for the appellant argues that both the courts
below failed to take note of the fact that the plaintiffs have not
specifically denying their signatures found in Ex.B1 and even the second
plaintiff not entered into the witness box to deny the signature in Ex.B1.
Inspite of that, the Courts below erroneously held that Ex.B1 is not a true
and valid document and it is a fabricated one and also without any expert
opinion the comparison of the signatures made by the courts below by
comparing the signatures along with Ex.X1 to Ex.X4, as such is
erroneous and liable to be set aside. The learned counsel for the appellant
further pointed out that the Courts below failed to take note of the fact
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
that one of the witness Maruthamuthu was already died and another
witness DW2 was not permitted to adduce evidence due to the
threatening made by the plaintiffs. Therefore, the best efforts made on the
side of the defendant to prove Ex.B1-family arrangement was failed to be
take note of by the courts below and erroneously held that the burden of
discharge cast upon the defendant was not satisfactorily acted upon, as
such is an erroneous finding and liable to be set aside.
8. The learned counsel for the appellant would also argues that in
respect of oral panchayath partition held among the sharers, one of the
panchayatdhars Maruthamuthu was already died and another witness
Kumarasamy was threatened by the plaintiffs so he was not able to
examine the said witness to that effect. The Courts below erroneously
failed to appreciate those circumstances for non examination of witnesses
and erroneously concluded that Ex.B1 has not been proved and also
invalid under law as such is illegal and liable to be set aside. The learned
counsel also pointed out that the Notary Public was already died and there
is a presumption attached to the validity of the signatures of the Notary
Public, but the Courts below failed to take note of legal proposition and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
erroneously concluded that Ex.B1 is not valid one and gave an erroneous
finding, which is liable to be set aside. The learned counsel also submits
that comparison of the signatures found in Ex.X1 to Ex.X4 which are all
the marriage certificate of the plaintiffs by the courts below along with
signatures found in Ex.B1 without referring to the expert opinion to that
effect and also the applications filed by the plaintiffs was also dismissed
as it was a belated one. Therefore, no scientific opinion was obtained with
regard to the signatures found in Ex.B1, without which the findings
rendered by the courts below that it is an invalid document under law, is
an erroneous finding and the same is liable to be set aside. Further he
argues that as per the oral arrangement, 60 cents given to the plaintiffs are
the lands with minerals. Considering the said potentiality, 60 cents was
allotted to the plaintiffs and the remaining barren land given to the
appellant which was also not taken into consideration by the Courts
below. Therefore, he prayed to admit the appeal by quoting the substantial
question of law with regard to the validity of Ex.B1 family arrangement.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
9. The learned counsel for the respondents also appeared. Before
admitting the appeal, the parties are directed to appear before this Court
to settle the issue amicably, but the defendant is not inclined to settle the
issue. Therefore, arguments were advanced on both sides with regard to
the admissibility of the appeal. The learned counsel for the respondents
also submits that the defendant / appellant, who claim that the property
was already divided based on the oral panchayatdhars as well as family
arrangement (Ex.B1) and the burden is cast upon him to prove the same,
but he failed to prove the same before the Trial Court, which was rightly
appreciated by the courts below, which requires no interference. The
learned counsel for the respondents also pointed out that even a bare
comparison of signatures found in Ex.B1 along with signatures found in
Ex.X1 to Ex.X4, which are contemporaneous documents and the court is
empowered to compare the signatures and such power was exercised by
the courts below and rightly concluded that the signatures differs in
Ex.B1 as well as in the marriage registration document (Ex.X1 to Ex.X4).
Thereby the courts below rightly held that the signatures does not belongs
to plaintiffs and the same was not disputed by the defendant to send those
documents to the Forensic Lab for obtaining opinion. Therefore, the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
findings with regard to Ex.B1 is sustainable one, which requires no
interference.
10. It is admitted fact that the suit properties belongs to the
ancestral joint family properties and as per the decree passed in OS
No.272 of 1994, there was a compromise decree on 23.12.1994, based on
which the plaintiffs and the defendant each entitled to 1/3rd share. So
admittedly it follows from the ancestral properties and the defendant also
not disputed the nature of the property. Therefore, the courts below
rightly concluded that it is a joint family properties. Now the plaintiffs
claiming 1/3rd share in the suit properties stating that their father has
misused to give the share.
11. As discussed above the properties are joint family properties,
primarily established by the plaintiffs. As per the defendant / appellant,
the properties were already orally partitioned in the presence of
panchayatdhars on 19.08.2007 in the presence of Kumarasamy and
Maruthamuthu in which 60 cents was allotted to the plaintiffs share and
remaining 9.40 cents were allotted to the defendant. Thereafter, in
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
furtherance of the sale, the said oral arrangement was reduced into family
arrangement on 18.05.2008 (Ex.B1) in the presence of Notary Public.
The plaintiffs also signed in that document, but suppressing that the suit
was filed by the plaintiffs. Therefore, burden cast upon the defendant to
prove the oral arrangement in the presence of panchayatdhars so also the
family arrangement executed by the Notary Public. To prove the
panchayat held in the family, the defendant has not adduced any evidence,
stating that one of the panchayatdhars Maruthamuthu was died and
another witness was threatened by the plaintiffs, but no contradictory
evidence to that effect. However, it reveals that one of the witness was
available but they were not brought to the court as per the manner known
to law. Therefore, both the courts below rightly held that the panchayat
held by the family not been proved by the defendant. In respect of Ex.B1family arrangement, the defendant examined one Thangavelu as a scribe
of the said document. Admittedly, the said Thangavelu PW2 is not a
attestor of the said Ex.B1. He said to be a scribe. Since he is not a
attestor, his evidence cannot be taken into consideration with regard to
attestation as per his signature affixed by the plaintiffs. Here also the
defendant contended that one attestor died and another attestor was
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
threatened by the plaintiffs. In the absence of any contradict evidence, it
cannot be acceptable one.
12. The defendant has relied on Ex.B2- copy of the FIR dated
24.12.2011 but that alone is not sufficient to conclude that the witnesses
were threatened by the plaintiffs, which requires further evidence.
Admittedly, the alleged Notary Public also died. Even as the evidence of
DW2- scribe, he was unable to identify the plaintiffs. Therefore, his
evidence also not supported by the defendant. But the plaintiffs were
present on the date of the alleged execution of Ex.B1. In all aspects,
Ex.B1 has not been proved to establish the family arrangement as claimed
by the defendant. Furthermore the signatures in Ex.B1 also disputed by
the plaintiffs stating that it does not belongs to them. At the time of the
alleged circumstances they were got married and settled some where else
in Bangalore and Chennai. However, the marriage registration certificate
of both the plaintiffs were produced before the court with the help of
Registrars and the signatures found in Ex.X1 to Ex.X4 was compared
along with the signature found in Ex.B1 wherein the trial judge had
elaborately discussed and stated that the signatures found in Ex.B1 totally
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
differs from the signatures found in Ex.X1 to Ex.X4. The signatures
found in Ex.B1 is a very artificial one, comparing to the alignment of the
said signatures with admitted signatures of Ex.X1 to Ex.X4. Therefore
the findings rendered by the learned Trial judge requires no interference.
In fact, burden is heavily upon the defendant to prove that the signatures
found in Ex.B1 belongs to plaintiffs, but he has not taken any steps to
send the document for comparison. Therefore, Ex.B1 has not been
proved. The Court below has rightly rendered findings which requires no
interference.
13. Admittedly, the suit properties are joint family properties in
which the plaintiffs and the defendant equally entitled to 1/3rd share. The
alleged oral partition claimed by the defendant as in-equal in nature is not
permissible under law. The averment of the plaintiffs proved that in the
joint family properties, each entitled to 1/3rd share total extent of 10 acres.
The findings rendered by the courts below is well reasoned and requires
no interference. There is no substantial question of law involved in the
present second appeal. There is no merit in this appeal and the second
appeal is liable to be dismissed.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
14. Accordingly, this Second Appeal stands dismissed, confirming
the decree and judgment dated 26.08.2025 passed in A.S. No.34 of 2013,
on the file of the IV Additional District Court, Udumalapettai, upholding
the decree and judgment dated 27.07.2012 passed in O.S.No.40 of 2010,
on the file of the Subordinate Court, Udumalapettai. Considering the
relationship between the parties, there is no order as to costs.
Consequently, connected Civil Miscellaneous Petition is closed.
21.01.2026
Index: Yes/No
Internet: Yes/No
Speaking/Non-Speaking order
mtl
To
1. The IV Additional District Court, Udumalapettai.
2. The Subordinate Court, Udumalapettai.
3. The Section Officer, VR Section, High Court, Madras.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P No.32983 of 2025
T.V.THAMILSELVI, J.
mtl
S.A.No.856 of 2025
and C.M.P. No.32983 of 2025
21.01.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review