The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
12. For the aforegoing reasons, the order passed by the learned Trial Court in I.A.No.312 of 2025 is set aside and the I.A., stands allowed. In the light of the decisions referred to supra, I.A.No.313 of 2025 is allowed. The learned Trial Court shall take steps to send Ex.A4 for comparison with the signature on contemporaneous documents filed along with the said I.A., by recalling D.W.1.
13. In the result, the Civil Revision Petitions are allowed.
14. Considering the submissions made by the learned counsel for the 1st respondent and as the suit is of the year 2013, the learned Trial Court shall make endeavour to dispose of the suit, as expeditiously as possible, within eight (8) months, from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs. Consequently, all pending applications shall stand closed. Dt. 20.02.2026 THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos: 3707 and 3709 of 2025
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010688292025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3209]
FRIDAY, THE TWE
TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos: 3707 and 3709 of 2025
C.R.P.No.3707 of 2025
Between:
1. K.MALLISWARI, W/o.K.MUNASWAMY NAIDU, AGED 74 YEARS,
HOUSEWIFE, R/O. FLAT No.510, BALAJI EMPIRE APARTMENT,
BACKSIDE OF HYUNDAI SHOWROOM,
RENIGUNTA ROAD,
TIRUPATI CITY, TIRUPATHI DISTRICT, ERSTWHIL
ERSTWHILE CHITTOOR
DISTRICT.
...PETITIONER
AND
1. KILARI SIVASEKHAR NAIDU, S/o.K. MUNASWAMY NAIDU, AGED 46
YEARS, OCC. BUSINESS, R/o.H.No.39/289,
SHIRLEY ROAD,
PAPATOE TOE, AUCKLAND, NEW ZEALAND,
AT PRESENT
TEMPORARILY
RESIDING
AT
ALLIKASIM
VILLAGE,
GAJULAMANYAM POST, RENIGUNTA MANDAL,
TIRUPATHI
DISTRICT, ERSTWHILE CHITTOOR DISTRICT.
2. SURYADEVARA LA
LATHA,
THA, (FORMALLY ADDED) (2ND RESPONDENT
IS NOT NECESSARY PARTY TO THIS CRP AND SINCE NO RELIEF
IS CLAIMED)
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Petitioner:
1. Smt.NIMMAGADDA REVATHI
Counsel for the Respondent(S):
1. Mr.SAI AKASH N
Order Reserved on
: 05.01.2026
Order Pronounced on : 20.02.2026
Order Uploaded on
: 25.02.2026
The Court made the following common order:
The petitioner – 1st defendant in O.S.No.162 of 2013 on the file of the
Court of the X Additional District Judge, Tirpuati, filed the present Revision
Petitions against the Common Order dated 12.11.2025 in I.A.Nos.312 and 313
of 2025 and the same are disposed of by this Common Order.
2.
The 1st respondent – plaintiff filed the above mentioned suit for Specific
Performance of Agreement of Sale dated 15.03.2013 in respect of the plaint
schedule properties. The petitioner / 1st defendant initially filed a written
statement inter alia stating that at the time of registration of the Will dated
17.12.2012 executed by her, the respondent – plaintiff obtained her signatures
on some blank papers and on some stamp papers under the guise of taking
loan from the financial institutions and later she learnt that the respondent /
plaintiff had misused the same and fabricated the suit agreement. In Para
No.10 of the written statement, she also took a plea that the suit agreement
and its endorsement are forged one. In the additional written statement, she
also pleaded that the plaintiff fabricated the suit agreement by utilizing blank
signed stamp papers and that he forged her signature beneath the
endorsement dated 10.07.2013 in the alleged suit agreement of sale and
created the same, that the plaintiff fabricated and created the alleged suit
agreement of sale and approached the Court with unclean hands.
3.
When the suit is posted for the evidence on defendant’s side, she filed
I.A.No.312 of 2025 under Order 18, R.17 & Sec.151 C.P.C., to recall D.W.1
for adducing further evidence and I.A.No.313 of 2025 under Section 45 of the
Evidence Act seeking to send the Ex.A4 containing the signature i.e.,
Payment Endorsement dated 10.07.2013 to the handwriting and finger prints
expert along with the contemporaneous documents containing the admitted
signatures of the petitioner / 1st defendant i..e, (i)Registered Will dated
17.12.2012 executed by her in favour of the respondent / plaintiff (ii)
Cancellation of Will Deed dated 24.12.2012 executed by the petitioner and
Registered Sale Deed dated 28.03.2014 executed by the petitioner in favour
of the 2nd defendant, for opinion. The respondent / plaintiff filed counter,
resisted the said applications, and the same were dismissed vide common
order dated 12.11.2025. Against the said order dismissing I.A.No.312 of 2025
and I.A.No.313 of 2025, C.R.P.No.3709 of 2025 and C.R.P.No.3707 of 2025
respectively are filed.
4.
The learned counsel for the petitioner inter alia submits that the learned
Trial Court went wrong in dismissing the I.As., in question, without considering
the matter in the proper perspective. She submits that the learned Trial Court
erred in rejecting I.A.No.313 of 2025 on the ground that the petitioner took
inconsistent pleas in the written statement and further that the said application
was filed at a belated stage with an intention to protract the litigation. She
contends that there is no bar for the defendant to take inconsistent pleas and
so far as filing of application under Section 45 of the Evidence Act seeking an
expert opinion on a document is concerned, the view taken by the learned
Trial Court is not tenable in the light of the judgment of a Division Bench of the
erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh in Janachaitanya Housing
Corporation Limited v. Divya Financiaries1. The learned counsel contends
that as the petitioner – defendant has specifically pleaded that her signature
on Ex.A4 is forged, the comparison of her signature with her signatures on
contemporaneous documents would assist the Court in arriving at a just
conclusion. She further submits that the order of the learned Trial Court,
without appreciating the relevancy and necessity of the reopening of evidence
of D.W.1 is unsustainable, bereft of cogent reasons and its’ opinion that the
petitioner’s conduct indicates lack of bonafides is misconceived. Contending
that the Common Order dated 12.11.2025 is vitiated by incorrect exercise of
jurisdiction vested in the learned Trial Court, she seeks to allow the Revision
Petitions.
5.
On the other hand, Mr.N.Subbarao, learned Senior Counsel made
submissions to sustain the order of the learned Trial Court. He submits that
the applications in question were filed only with a view to protract the matter,
that too after the witnesses were examined at length, that P.W.1 was recalled
twice, the attestor of Ex.A4-Endorsement was examined as P.W.2 and nothing
was elicited in the cross examination. He submits that when the matter is
posted for the cross-examination of D.W.3, the petitioner / defendant No.1
came up with the above applications with a view to fill up the gaps in the
evidence. He submits that the petitioner / defendant No.1 filed the additional
written statement in the year 2018, but did not take any steps to file any
2008 (3) ALT 409
application under section 45 of the Evidence Act and at the fag-end of the trial,
filed the applications in question. He further submits that as rightly opined by
the learned Trial Court, the applications in question are lacking in bona-fides
and filed only for the purpose of dragging on the proceedings. He submits
that there are no grounds, much less, good grounds warranting the
interference of this Court in the order under challenge and the Revision
Petitions are therefore liable to be dismissed.
6.
On an appreciation of the rival contentions, the point that arises for
consideration is whether the impugned order warrants interference by this
Court, in the facts and circumstances of the case?
7.
Before dealing with the point for consideration, it may be pertinent to
note that in the impugned common order, much attention has been bestowed
on the application for sending the Ex.A4-Payment acknowledgment to the
expert for comparison of the signatures of the petitioner / defendant No.1 with
the contemporaneous documents. There is little discussion with reference to
the other application and conclusion thereon in the impugned order. Be that as
it may. Insofar as the belated stage / delay in filing I.A.No.313 of 2025 which
inter alia is the main factor for dismissal of the said I.A., by the learned Trial
Court, in the light of the judgment in Janachaitanya Housing Corporation
Limited, it cannot be a ground for rejection of an application under Section 45
of the Evidence Act. In the said decision, a Division Bench of the erstwhile
High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad, was dealing with a reference as
to whether an application under Section 45 of the Evidence Act filed for
sending the signatures for comparison and expert opinion, can be entertained
at a later stage, including when the suit was coming up for arguments after
entire trial.
8.
The Division Bench after considering the matter, opined that the Court
cannot lay down any hard and fast rules controlling the discretion of the Court
to send the disputed documents / writings for the opinion of the expert or to
examine him, in support of such opinion. The Division Bench ultimately
answered the reference opining that “no time could be fixed for filing
applications under Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act for sending the
disputed signature or writings to the hand writing expert for comparison and
opinion and same shall be left open to the discretion of the Court, for
exercising such discretion when exigencies so demand, depending upon the
facts and circumstances of each case. The said judgment was considered and
approved by a Full Bench in Bande Siva Shankara Srinivasa Prasad v. Ravi
Surya Prakash Babu and Others2 case.
9.
From a reading of the above judgment while it is clear that an
application can be filed even after trial, but the discretion is vested with the
Court either to accept or reject the said application.
10.
In the present case, one of the contentions advanced by the learned
counsel for the petitioner/ defendant No.1 is that the impugned order was
passed by the learned Trial Court by incorrect exercise of jurisdiction vested in
2016 (2) ALT 248
it. This Court finds merit in the said submission for more than one reason.
Firstly, the petitioner / defendant No.1 in the written statement (original and
additional), took not only a plea that the suit agreement of sale dated
15.03.2013 was fabricated by obtaining her signatures on some blank papers,
but also pleaded specifically that the respondent / plaintiffs forged the
signature beneath the endorsement dated 10.07.2013 in the said agreement
of sale. In the said circumstances, more particularly, in view of the settled
position of Law, that the defendant can take inconsistent / different pleas [See:
Baldev Singh & Others v. Manohar Singh & Others, (2006) 6 SCC 498]
sending of the documents for comparison would aid the Court to arrive at a
just conclusion. In fact, as seen from the cross examination of the petitioner /
defendant (D.W.1), she categorically denied that the signature shown in
Ex.A4-Endorsement does not belong to her. The opinion expressed by the
learned Trial Court that the contention that expert examination is essential
lacks merit, as the petitioner / defendant has unequivocally admitted to have
signed the papers relied upon by the respondent / plaintiff, is not tenable.
11.
Secondly, I.A.No.312 of 2025 was filed to recall D.W.1 for further
evidence. In the affidavit, the reasons for seeking to recall the said witness
were stated. Though advice of the new counsel may not be an acceptable
reason, but to establish that the signature beneath the Ex.A4 Payment
Endorsement is forged, the said document has to be sent for comparison with
the contemporaneous documents, by recalling the D.W.1. The learned Trial
Court has not examined the said I.A., with reference to the plea taken by the
petitioner / defendant and whether recalling of the said witness is justified.
Therefore the dismissal of I.A.No.312 of 2025 is not tenable.
12.
For the aforegoing reasons, the order passed by the learned Trial Court
in I.A.No.312 of 2025 is set aside and the I.A., stands allowed. In the light of
the decisions referred to supra, I.A.No.313 of 2025 is allowed. The learned
Trial Court shall take steps to send Ex.A4 for comparison with the signature
on contemporaneous documents filed along with the said I.A., by recalling
D.W.1.
13.
In the result, the Civil Revision Petitions are allowed.
14.
Considering the submissions made by the learned counsel for the 1st
respondent and as the suit is of the year 2013, the learned Trial Court shall
make endeavour to dispose of the suit, as expeditiously as possible, within
eight (8) months, from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs.
Consequently, all pending applications shall stand closed.
__________________________
JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
Dt. 20.02.2026
BLV
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NINALA JAYASURYA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos: 3707 and 3709 of 2025
Date: 20.02.2026
BLV
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review