The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
18. In the present case, the charge sheet was never set aside by the Kerala Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, and the petitioner was asked to submit a reply to the charge sheet WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024 2025:KER:24912 vide notice dated 13.10.2023. The judgment cited by the learned Senior counsel for the petitioner in Satheesan (supra) is not applicable to the facts of the case inasmuch as in the said case, the charge sheet was issued after the petitioner therein, demitted the office on attaining the age of superannuation. In the present case, the charge sheet was issued before the petitioner demitted the office and the Tribunal, as well as the learned Single Judge and the learned Division Bench permitted the respondent society to conduct the enquiry in accordance with law. Therefore, I am of the considered view that the notice issued on 13.10.2023 is not an initiation of a new enquiry inasmuch as the enquiry gets initiated after issuing the charge sheet. The charge sheet was issued before the petitioner demitted the office and therefore, I am of the view that there was no bar for the respondent society to issue him the show cause notice and ask for his response to the charge sheet in view of the liberty granted by the Tribunal which was upheld by the learned Single Judge and the Division Bench. WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024 2025:KER:24912 Thus, I do not find much substance in this writ peti…
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE D. K. SINGH
MONDAY, THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 3RD CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
PETITIONER:
K.M.RAVI
AGED 58 YEARS
S/O.RAGHAVAN NAIR, THALIYACHA HOUSE, NANMINDA, KOZHIKODE,
PIN - 673613
BY ADVS.
M.R.SABU
LAKSHMI RAMADAS
APARNA RAJAN
SREEDHAR RAVINDRAN
RESPONDENTS:
NANMINDA RURAL CO-OPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY LTD NO.D 1988
NANMINDA.P.O., KOZHIKODE REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY, PIN 673613
THE SECRETARY, NANMINDA RURAL CO-OPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY
LTD NO.D 1988
NANMINDA.P.O., KOZHIKODE, PIN - 673613
BY ADV P.C SASIDHARAN
THIS
WRIT
PETITION
(CIVIL)
HAVING
COME
UP
FOR
ADMISSION
24.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
ON
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
JUDGMENT
The petitioner, while working as Senior Clerk under the
1st respondent society, was
proceedings
alleging
various
subjected to disciplinary
acts
of
omission
and
commission. On conclusion of the disciplinary proceedings,
the petitioner was terminated from service vide order dated
03.12.2009. An appeal filed against the said order of
termination before the Board of Directors got rejected, and
thereafter, the petitioner filed a case before the Cooperative Arbitration Court, Kozhikode, invoking Section 69
of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969. The
Arbitration Court vide judgment dated 20.10.2015 passed in
ARC No.139/2011, set aside the punishment order on the
ground that the domestic enquiry conducted against the
petitioner was illegal. The respondent society was directed
to reinstate the petitioner, and the Arbitration Case was
allowed with a cost of Rs.50,000/-.
2. Aggrieved by the said decision of the Arbitration
Court, the respondent society filed Appeal No.110/2015
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
before
the
Kerala
Co-operative
Tribunal,
Thiruvananthapuram. The Tribunal vide judgment dated
12.12.2017 upheld the order passed by the Arbitration
Court and directed the respondent society to conduct
domestic enquiry afresh as per law permitting the petitioner
herein to adduce evidence, if any.
3. The said judgment dated 12.12.2017 passed in Appeal
No.110/2015 by the Kerala Co-operative Tribunal came to
be challenged by the respondent society in W.P.(C.)
No.4698/2018.
The
petitioner
also
filed
W.P.(C.)
No.2118/2019 against the observation of the Tribunal.
While deciding issue No.1, i.e., whether the impugned
award is proper and legal, the Tribunal set aside the award
in ARC No.139/2011. There were discrepancies in the
decision on issue No.1 and issue No.2. In issue No.1, the
award/judgment passed by the Arbitration Court was set
aside, whereas in issue No.2, the judgment of the
Arbitration
dismissed.
Court
was
upheld,
and
the
appeal
was
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
4. This Court, vide judgment dated 18.01.2023 passed
in
W.P.(C.)
No.4698/2018
as
well
as
in
W.P.(C.)
No.2118/2019, filed by the petitioner impugning the order
of the Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, dismissed the writ
petition filed by the respondent society and allowed the writ
petition filed by the petitioner to the limited extent by
clarifying that the Tribunal has not set aside the order of the
Arbitration Court but had confirmed it.
5. The learned single Judge of this Court was of the view
that it would be unnecessary for the Court to enter into the
merits of the enquiry or to decide the credibility or
otherwise of the depositions and evidence adduced therein,
when it is expressly and without reservation, admitted that
the punishment awarded to the petitioner was issued by the
Sub Committee which was then affirmed by an Appellate
Committee with the members of the Sub Committee. It was
also noticed that the Kerala Co-operative Appellate Tribunal
had reserved the right and given full liberty to the Society
to initiate disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner in
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
terms of the law and follow due process in conduct of the
disciplinary proceedings.
6. The said decision of the learned Single Judge came to
be challenged in W.A Nos.1741/2023 & 1742/2023. The
Division Bench vide judgment dated 03.10.2023 dismissed
the appeals and upheld the judgment passed by the learned
Single Judge. The review against the said judgment passed
in the writ appeals also came to be dismissed.
7. After the judgment was passed in the review petition,
the petitioner was issued with a show cause notice with the
memorandum of charges on 13.10.2023. The petitioner
submitted the reply saying that after the petitioner demitted
the
office
on
31.05.2023,
on
attaining
the
age
of
superannuation, there was no relationship between the
master
and
servant
and
therefore,
no
disciplinary
proceedings would be initiated against him in view of Rule
198 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules, 1969. He
also submitted that the petitioner was no longer a member
of the Co-operative Society after he attains the age of
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
superannuation, and therefore, the disciplinary proceedings
would not have been continued against him.
8. Since the Tribunal’s judgment was affirmed by this
Court,
a
three-member
disciplinary
committee
was
constituted. The petitioner was directed to appear before
the Committee on 17.10.2023, but he was not present on
that day. Hence, the sitting was adjourned to 21.10.2023,
and again, a show cause notice was issued to the petitioner.
The petitioner did not appear on 21.10.2023 and the matter
was adjourned to 30.10.2023. On that day also, the
petitioner did not appear, and the matter was adjourned to
03.11.2023.
9. The disciplinary Authority rejected the objection of
the petitioner and held that the disciplinary proceedings
against the petitioner were initiated before he demitted the
office on 31.05.2023 on attaining the age of superannuation.
The Appellate Tribunal also granted liberty to proceed
against the petitioner afresh. The proceedings, by issuing
show cause notice on 30.10.2023, were not a fresh
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
proceeding, but would be deemed to be the proceedings
which continued against him in view of the liberty granted
by the Tribunal. After adverting to the response of the
petitioner to the show cause notice, as the petitioner did not
appear before the disciplinary committee, his services were
terminated vide impugned order dated 05.02.2024 passed
by the 2nd respondent.
10. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that
Rule 198 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules
empowers the competent authority to initiate disciplinary
proceedings against a member of the society. After
demitting the office on 31.05.2023, the petitioner no longer
remained a member of the respondent Co-operative society.
Therefore, the show cause notice dated 13.10.2023, and
thereafter, the impugned order passed terminating the
services of the petitioner with effect from 05.01.2024 are
wholly without jurisdiction. In view of the aforesaid
submissions, it is said that the writ petition be allowed and
the impugned punishment order be set aside and the
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
respondents be directed to grant the petitioner all the
benefits of service including pension etc,. The learned
counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance on the
judgment of this Court in W.P.(C.) No.29957/2019 dated
24.06.2024
in
Satheesan
v.
Kannur
District
Co-
operative Bank [2020(4) KLT 236] in support of his
submissions.
11. Sri.P.C.Sasidharan, learned counsel appearing for
the respondent society, however, submits that initiation of
the fresh enquiry after an employee or the member of the
Co-operative Society demits the office is barred under Rule
198. However, the question which needs to be decided in
this case is whether the show cause notice dated 13.10.2023
would amount to initiation of fresh enquiry or it should be
treated as the continuation of the enquiry which was
permitted by the Kerala Co-operative Tribunal. The said
decision of the Tribunal was upheld by the learned Single
Judge and Division Bench of this Court. According to Sri.P.C
Sasidharan, the notice dated 13.10.2023 is not an initiation
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
of a fresh enquiry inasmuch as no fresh charge sheet was
issued. But the petitioner’s response was asked to the
chargesheet, which was already issued to the petitioner in
view of the liberty granted by the Kerala Co-operative
Appellate Tribunal as well as the decision of the learned
Single Judge and Division Bench of this Court rendered
while challenging the decision passed by the Kerala Cooperative Tribunal. He, therefore, submits that it is not a
fresh enquiry, and Rule 198 does not bar continuation of the
enquiry after a member/employee of the Co-operative
society demits the office.
12. The learned counsel for the respondent society has
placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court in
State Bank of India v. Ram Lal Bhaskar & another
[(2011) 12 SCR 1036] and submits that an employee who is
guilty of serious misconduct should not be allowed to go
scott free because of the trivial violation of procedure and
the High Court should not sit as a Court of appeal against
the findings recorded by the disciplinary authority on
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
evaluation of the evidence as the High Court is not required
to reappreciate the evidence and is only required to see that
whether the rules of natural justice have been followed or
not.
13.I have considered the submission. Relevant portions
of Rule 198 of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Rules,1969
read as under:
“Punishment
198.Disciplinary action :- (1)Any member of the
establishment of a Co-operative Society may, for good
and sufficient reasons, be punished by imposing any of
the following penalties, namely;(a) Censure;
(b) Fine (in the case of employees in the last grade);
(c) Withholding of increments with or without
cumulative effect;
(d) Withholding of promotion.;
(e) Recovery from pay off the whole or part of any
pecuniary loss caused to the society, by negligence or
breach of orders or otherwise
(f) Reduction to a lower rank
(g) Compulsory retirement
(h) Dismissal from service.
Charge sheet (2) No kind of punishment shall be awarded to an
employee unless he has been informed in writing of the
grounds on which it is proposed to take action against
and he has been afforded an opportunity including a
personal hearing to defend himself. Every order
awarding punishment shall be communicated to the
employee concerned in writing stating the grounds on
which the punishment has been awarded.
Disciplinary Sub
Committee
[(2A) The committee of a society shall constitute a
disciplinary sub-committee consisting of not more
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
than three of its members, of whom one shall be
designated as Chairman, but the President of the
Committee of the society shall not be a member in the
disciplinary subcommittee.
Domestic
enquiry
(2B) The Disciplinary Sub-Committee so constituted
shall inquire into the charges against the employee
either by themselves or by engaging an external
agency]
14. From the language of the Rule, it is evident that a
member of the establishment of the Co-operative society can
be
punished
enumerated
by
imposing
therein.
The
any
of
question
the
punishments
which
requires
consideration in this case is whether the show cause notice
dated 13.10.2023 is a fresh enquiry or continuation of the
enquiry from the stage, where from the enquiry got vitiated.
15.The Kerala Co-operative Tribunal in its judgment
dated 12.12.2017 (supra) while deciding issue No. 2 held as
under:
“Hence the finding in the impugned award that the
domestic enquiry was illegal is upheld dismissing the
appeal. The order for reinstatement is upheld and the
appellant is directed to conduct the domestic enquiry
afresh as per law by permitting the respondent to
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
adduce evidence of any to disprove the charges
against him.”
16. Thus, the respondent society was permitted to
conduct the domestic enquiry afresh as per law from the
stage it got viated. The said liberty has been upheld by the
learned Single Judge and Division Bench as stated above.
17. If the enquiry is a new enquiry and a charge memo
is issued after the retirement of the employee/member, the
said enquiry would not be permissible inasmuch as no fresh
departmental
enquiry
can
be
initiated
after
a
member/employee of the Co-operative society has demitted
the office. However, if the enquiry was initiated before the
member/employee of the Co-operative Society has demitted
the office, after his retirement on attaining the age of
superannuation, the enquiry would continue, as there is no
bar for continuation of the domestic enquiry.
18. In the present case, the charge sheet was never set
aside by the Kerala Co-operative Appellate Tribunal, and the
petitioner was asked to submit a reply to the charge sheet
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
vide notice dated 13.10.2023. The judgment cited by the
learned Senior counsel for the petitioner in Satheesan
(supra) is not applicable to the facts of the case inasmuch as
in the said case, the charge sheet was issued after the
petitioner therein, demitted the office on attaining the age
of superannuation. In the present case, the charge sheet
was issued before the petitioner demitted the office and the
Tribunal, as well as the learned Single Judge and the
learned Division Bench permitted the respondent society to
conduct the enquiry in accordance with law. Therefore, I am
of the considered view that the notice issued on 13.10.2023
is not an initiation of a new enquiry inasmuch as the enquiry
gets initiated after issuing the charge sheet. The charge
sheet was issued before the petitioner demitted the office
and therefore, I am of the view that there was no bar for the
respondent society to issue him the show cause notice and
ask for his response to the charge sheet in view of the liberty
granted by the Tribunal which was upheld by the learned
Single Judge and the Division Bench.
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
Thus, I do not find much substance in this writ petition,
which is hereby dismissed.
D.K. SINGH
JUDGE
AP
WP(C) NO. 12793 OF 2024
2025:KER:24912
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 12793/2024
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit-P1
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE ARBITRATION
COURT DATED 20.10.2015 IN ARC NO.139/2011
Exhibit -P2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER OF THE ARBITRATION
TRIBUNAL DATED 12.12.2017 IN APPEAL NO.110/2015
Exhibit-P3
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 18.01.2023 IN
W.P.(C) NO.4698/2018
Exhibit-P4
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE LEARNED SINGLE
JUDGE DISMISSING THE R.P.NO.645/2023 DATED
26.07.2023
Exhibit-P5
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT OF THE DIVISION BENCH
IN W.A.NO. 1741/2023 DATED 03.10.2023
Exhibit-P6
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT DATED 13.10.2023
Exhibit-P7
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT DATED 21.10.2023 NO.049/2023-24
Exhibit-P8
TRUE COPY OF WRITTEN SUBMISSION MADE BY THE
PETITIONER BEFORE THE DISCIPLINARY COMMITTEE
DATED 26.10.2023
Exhibit-P9
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT DATED 05.01.2024
Exhibit -P10
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN CON. CASE (C)
NO.1008/2023 DATED 07.03.2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review