Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATE : 07.01.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M.DHANDAPANI
W.P. NO.50627 OF 2025
AND
W.M.P. NOS.56688 & 56689 OF 2025
K.Iswarya
.. Petitioner
- Vs -
1. The State of Tamil Nadu
Rep. By its Secretary
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Fort St. George, Secretariat
Chennai 600 009.
2. The State of Tamil Nadu
Rep. By its Addl. Chief Secretary to Govt.
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Fort St. George, Secretariat
Chennai 600 009.
3. The Commissioner
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Panagal Maligai, Saidapet
Chennai 600 015.
4. The District Collector &
District Level Appointment Committee
Collectorate, Cuddalore District
Cuddalore 607 001.
5. The Assistant Director (Panchayats)
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
Cuddalore District, Cuddalore 607 001.
6. The State of Tamil Nadu
Rep. By its Prl. Secretary to Govt.
School Education Department
Secretariat, Fort St. George
Chennai 600 009.
7. The Director of School Education
DPI Campus, College Road
Nungambakkam, Chennai 600 006.
.. Respondents
Writ petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying
this Court to issue a writ of certiorari and mandamus to call for the records
relating to (i) G.O. Ms. No.198, Rural Development & Panchayat Raj (E5) Dept.,
dated 04.09.2025; and (ii) District Notification No.4209/2025 dated
09.10.2025 issued by the 3rd respondent District Collector, Cuddalore, and
quash the same, consequently direct the respondents to consider my
candidature for the post of Village Panchayat Secretary in Cuddalore District
afresh.
For Petitioner
For Respondents
:
:
Mr. M.Elumalai
Mr. P.Balathandayutham, Spl. GP
ORDER
Assailing the impugned Government Order in G.O. Ms. No.198, Rural
Development & Panchayat Raj (E5) Dept., dated 04.09.2025 and the District
Notification No.4209/2025 dated 09.10.2025 issued by the 3 rd respondent
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
District Collector, Cuddalore in and by which the selection criteria is solely
based on the 10 standard marks to be arbitrary and discriminatory, irrational
and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, the present writ
petition has been filed.
2. Mr.Balathandayutham, learned Special Government Pleader takes
notice for the respondents.
3. It is the case of the petitioner that the Tamil Nadu Village Panchayat
Secretaries (Conditions of Service) Rules, 2023 was published vide the
Government Order in G.O. (Ms.) No.113, Rural Development and Panchayat
Raj (E5) Dept., dated 13.09.2023 wherein Rule 3 provides for the appointment
for Panchayat Secretaries shall be by direct recruitment and that the selection
is to be carried out by means of open competitive recruitment process by a
District Level Committee.
4. It is the further case of the petitioner that G.O. Ms. No.198, Rural
Development and Panchayat Raj (E5) Dept., dated 4.9.2025 was issued
prescribing guidelines for mode of selection and appointment of Village
Panchayat Secretaries in which the prescription has been given as under :3
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
(a) The sole academic criterion for selection shall be the
marks obtained in the 10th standard examination;
(b) 85% weightage shall be given to the 10 standard marks
and 15% weightage shall be given for the interview;
(c) A system-generated merit list shall be prepared purely on
the basis of 10th standard marks (for converted
marks/grades), without any rational normalization
between different Boards, batches, or different schemes
of examination; and
(d) For the COVID-19 batch (2020-2021), in which no marks
were awarded and only a pass certificate was issued, a
uniform score of 66.67% is deemed for all such
candidates.
5. It is the further case of the petitioner that the 4 th respondent issued
the impugned notification inviting online applications for 37 posts of Village
Panchayat Secretary, specifying the qualification, priority categories and
communal rotation and reservation and it further prescribed that the
selection would be based on the aforesaid G.O. Ms. No.198.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
6. It is the further case of the petitioner that she belongs to Most
Backward Class/Denotified Community and had passed 10 th standard in
March, 2008 under the Tamil Nadu State Board and she applied for the said
post. It is the further case of the petitioner that she passed the 10 th standard
examination in March, 2008 under the then existing ‘old system’ of
examination in which the evaluation pattern was predominantly theory-based
for almost all subjects, including Science. She completed her 10 standard
(SSLC) in the year 2008 and Higher Secondary Certificate (12 th Standard – HSC)
in the year 2010 and has scored very good marks and is eligible in all respect
for consideration to the post of Village Panchayat Secretary as per the
applicable rules.
7. It is the further case of the petitioner that on and from the year
2010, the syllabus and method of examination from Standards VI to X were
substantially modified and so also the examination structure and evaluation
pattern were significantly altered and there is a fundamental shift from the
earlier old system of assessment to a more integrated evaluation model.
8. It is the further case of the petitioner that as a consequence of the
changes introduced over the years to the education pattern and pattern of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
evaluation, two types of candidates exists within the State of Tamil Nadu, one
under the old scheme, which is prior to the introduction of the Uniform
System of Education and the one under the Uniform System of Education and
also persons from various Boards such as CBSE, ICSE, State Boards, which all
grade the candidates in different fashion.
9. It is the further case of the petitioner that her candidature was not
shortlisted and that she was not called for the interview purely because under
the unnormalised system of ranking based solely on raw 10 th standard marks,
persons belonging to later batches under the Uniform System of Education
had obtained higher marks due to differing evaluation patterns and had a
march over the other candidates belonging to the old scheme and the persons
belonging to COVID-19 batch who were awarded marks irrespective of their
individual merit and were integrated into the same merit pool.
10. It is the further case of the petitioner that comparing of raw marks
across such different educational systems without any scientific normalization
or standardization and treating them equivalently is wholly arbitrary, irrational
and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. It is the further case of
the petitioner that persons with higher educational accomplishments,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
including higher secondary certificate as well as relevant language proficiency
and local knowledge have not been taken into account, which shows the
perversity and arbitrariness of the selection process. Therefore, left with no
alternative and efÏcacious remedy, the present petition has been filed.
11. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that without
adopting normalization and standardization of marks between the old scheme
and the Uniform System of Education, awarding equivalent marks to persons
under the different streams is nothing but perpetuating inequality between
the persons, who studied in different streams of education, as the persons
from the older stream would not have had the benefit of higher marks, which
the present generation who studied under the Uniform System of Education
would have and who could secure higher marks. Therefore, the system
adopted by the respondents for shortlisting the candidates is grossly perverse,
arbitrary and unreasonable.
12. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that awarding an
artificial score of 66.67% to persons, who had a pass only and belonging to the
2020-2021 batch, which was due to COVID-19 is ex facie arbitrary and
unreasonable and such an award of marks grossly defeats the rights and
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
curtails the chances of the persons, who had studied in previous years and
under the old scheme.
13. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that though
minimum qualification of 10th standard is fixed, however, only using the 10 th
standard marks as the decisive factor for ranking is perverse, as persons with
higher qualifications like HSC or graduation have not been given any
weightage for the said higher qualification and other experience and other
skills, which would have a relevance in the discharge of duties.
14. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that no scientific
and rational basis has been followed in the arriving of the marks and also in
the fixing of the marks for the purpose of fixing the merit list as it is evident
that there are systemic differences in the awarding of marks in various
streams of education and also between the old system and the Uniform new
system. The absence of normalization and standardization hits at the base of
equivalency thereby rendering the whole process illegal and unreasonable.
15. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that when
candidates from multiple Boards and batches, each with different marking
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
schemes are pooled together for a common recruitment process it is
necessary to adopt normalization, standardization or a common examination
to ensure fairness and the adoption of crude system to take the total
percentage of marks and fixing it at 85% is a manifestly erroneous approach,
which hits at the base of the recruitment process.
16. It is the further submission of the learned counsel that the
Government Order fixing the minimum qualification and adopting the marks
obtained in the 10th standard as the sole criterion as a matter of administrative
convenience gravely affects candidates, who have higher qualification and
additional personal and professional experiences, which are required for the
discharge of the work for which recruitment process is being conducted.
17. In fine it is the submission of the learned counsel that the system of
recruitment based on 10th standard marks and interview for selection for the
post of Village Panchayat Secretary is against the constitutional mandate of
equivalence and, therefore, the impugned Government order and the
notification pursuant thereto deserves to be quashed with a further direction
to the respondents to adopt a more rationalized and standardized approach
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
for the filling up of the posts and, therefore, prays for allowing the present
petition.
18. Per contra, learned Special Government Pleader, who accepts
notice on behalf of the respondents submitted that when the rule does not
prescribe any particular method for selection and the selection is by direct
recruitment, it is within the ambit of the appointing authority to prescribe the
manner and the method in which the selection would be made. The issuance
of Government Order on the basis of the same and the consequent
notification issued by the 3 rd respondent are within the bounds of legal
propriety and ratio laid down by the Courts with regard to the manner in
which recruitment is to be carried through for filling the public posts and
there is no infirmity in the manner in which the posts are to be filled up and,
therefore, no interference is warranted with the selection process and,
accordingly, prays for dismissal of the present writ petition.
19. This Court gave its careful consideration to the submissions
advanced by the learned counsel appearing on either side and perused the
materials available on record.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
20. Before venturing into the merits of the issue, the law on the
manner in which the recruitment process is to be taken up, when such
recruitment is by way of direct recruitment, requires consideration.
21. In Chandigarh Administration thro’ The Director, Public
Instructions (Colleges), - Vs – Usha Kheterpal Waie & Ors. (2011 (9) SCC 645)
the Apex Court held that it is within the domain of the rule making authority
or the appointing authority to prescribe the mode of selection and minimum
qualification for retirement. In this context, the Apex Court held thus :“22. It is now well settled that it is for the rule-making
authority or the appointing authority to prescribe the
mode of selection and minimum qualification for any
recruitment. Courts and tribunals can neither prescribe the
qualifications nor entrench upon the power of the
concerned authority so long as the qualifications
prescribed by the employer is reasonably relevant and has
a rational nexus with the functions and duties attached to
the post and are not violative of any provision of
Constitution, statute and Rules. [See J.Rangaswamy vs.
Government of Andhra Pradesh - 1990 (1) SCC 288 and
P.U. Joshi vs. Accountant General - 2003 (2) SCC 632]. In
the absence of any rules, under Article 309 or Statute, the
appellant had the power to appoint under its general
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
power of administration and prescribe such eligibility
criteria as it is considered to be necessary and reasonable.”
22. Similar view has been adumbrated by the Apex Court as early as in
the decision in P.U.Joshi & Ors. – Vs – Accountant General, Ahmedabad &
Ors. (2003 (2) SCC 632), wherein, the Apex Court held thus :“10. We have carefully considered the submissions
made on behalf of both parties. Questions relating to the
constitution, pattern, nomenclature of posts, cadres,
categories,
their
creation/abolition,
prescription
of
qualifications and other conditions of service including
avenues of promotions and criteria to be fulfilled for such
promotions pertain to the field of Policy and within the
exclusive discretion and jurisdiction of the State, subject, of
course, to the limitations or restrictions envisaged in the
Constitution of India and it is not for the Statutory
Tribunals, at any rate, to direct the Government to have a
particular method of recruitment or eligibility criteria or
avenues of promotion or impose itself by substituting its
views for that of the State. Similarly, it is well open and
within the competency of the State to change the rules
relating to a service and alter or amend and vary by
addition/subtraction the qualifications, eligibility criteria
and other conditions of service including avenues of
promotion, from time to time, as the administrative
exigencies may need or necessitate. Likewise, the State by
appropriate rules is entitled to amalgamate departments
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
or bifurcate departments into more and constitute
different categories of posts or cadres by undertaking
further classification, bifurcation or amalgamation as well
as
reconstitute
and
restructure
the
pattern
and
cadres/categories of service, as may be required from time
to time by abolishing existing cadres/posts and creating
new cadres/posts. There is no right in any employee of the
State to claim that rules governing conditions of his service
should be forever the same as the one when he entered
service for all purposes and except for ensuring or
safeguarding rights or benefits already earned, acquired or
accrued at a particular point of time, a Government
servant has no right to challenge the authority of the State
to amend, alter and bring into force new rules relating to
even an existing service.”
23. The scope of judicial review in matters relating review of
Governmental policy has been discussed by the Apex Court in Directorate of
Film Festivals & Ors. – Vs – Gaurav Ashwin Jain & Ors. (2007 (4) SCC 737),
wherein the Supreme Court held thus :“16. The scope of judicial review of governmental
policy is now well defined. Courts do not and cannot act as
Appellate Authorities examining the correctness, suitability
and appropriateness of a policy. Nor are courts Advisors to
the executive on matters of policy which the executive is
entitled to formulate. The scope of judicial review when
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
examining a policy of the government is to check whether
it violates the fundamental rights of the citizens or is
opposed to the provisions of the Constitution, or opposed
to any statutory provision or manifestly arbitrary. Courts
cannot interfere with policy either on the ground that it is
erroneous or on the ground that a better, fairer or wiser
alternative is available. Legality of the policy, and not the
wisdom or soundness of the policy, is the subject of judicial
review.
[vide
:
Asif
Hameed
v.
State
of
J&K
MANU/SC/0036/1989 : [1989]3SCR19 ; Shri Sitaram Sugar
Co. Ltd. v. Union of India
MANU/SC/0249/1990 : -
[1990]1SCR909 ; Khoday Distilleries v. State of Karnataka
MANU/SC/0242/1996 : AIR1996SC911 , Balco Employees
Union
v.
Union
of
India
MANU/SC/0779/2001
:
(2002)ILLJ550SC , State of Orissa v. Gopinath Dash
MANU/SC/2387/2005 : AIR2006SC651 and Akhil Bharat
Goseva
Sangh
v.
State
of
Andhra
Pradesh
MANU/SC/1795/2006 : (2006)4SCC162 ].”
24. Recently, in The State of Maharashtra – Vs – Bhagwan & Ors.
(MANU/SC/0025/2022 :: 2022 Live Law (SC) 28), the right of the employees of
autonomous bodies to claim service benefits on par with Government
employees was dealt with, wherein the Apex Court held thus :“10.2 In the case of T.M. Sampath and Ors. v.
Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources and Ors. (supra),
the employees of National Water Development Agency
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
(NWDA), an autonomous body under the aegis and control
of Ministry of Water Resources claimed the pensionary
benefits on par with the Central Government employees.
Refusing to allow such pensionary benefits to the
employees of NWDA on par with the Central Government
employees, in paragraphs 16 and 17, it was observed and
held as under:
“16. On the issue of parity between the employees of
NWDA and Central Government employees, even if it is
assumed that the 1982 Rules did not exist or were not
applicable on the date of the OM i.e. 1-5-1987, the
relevant date of parity, the principle of parity cannot be
applicable to the employees of NWDA. NWDA cannot be
treated as an instrumentality of the State Under Article 12
of the Constitution merely on the basis that its funds are
granted by the Central Government. In Zee Telefilms Ltd. v.
Union of India [ MANU/SC/0074/2005 : (2005) 4 SCC 649],
it was held by this Court that the autonomous bodies
having some nexus with the Government by itself would
not bring them within the sweep of the expression "State"
and each case must be determined on its own merits. Thus,
the plea of the employees of NWDA to be treated on a par
with their counterparts in the Central Government Under
Sub-rule (6)(iv) of Rule 209 of the General Financial Rules,
merely on the basis of funding is not applicable.””
25. Therefore, from the aforesaid decisions, there could be no quarrel
with the fact that insofar as recruitment is concerned, based on the rules,
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
which is in force, it is within the domain of the rule-making
authority/appointing authority to decide the manner in which the process of
recruitment is to be taken up and the posts filled. Further, the scope of
judicial review in such matters is very limited and unless arbitrariness and
perversity is shown, the Courts shall not enter into the said controversy by
exercising its powers of judicial review.
26. In the present case, there is no quarrel with the fact that the
minimum educational qualification prescribed is 10 th standard pass with which
there is no grievance. The grievance expressed is only with regard to the
manner of rating and the proportion of weightage given to such rating as
according to the petitioner, normalization and standardization has not been
adopted while weighing the marks obtained by the persons in different
streams and also in different years, more particularly the fact that after the
year 2010, the Uniform System of Education has been adopted, which
prejudices the persons, who have underwent education in the old system.
27. It is to be pointed out that normalization under the same Board is
not in vogue time immemorial and only between different Boards, the pattern
of normalization or standardization has been adopted. The award of marks in
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
the CBSE and ICSE Boards, as is generally accepted, are stringent, while in the
State Board, it is not so very stringent.
28. The petitioner has had her education in the State Board and within
State Board merely because the petitioner had completed her education in
the year 2008 and on and from 2010, the Uniform System of Education has
come into force, there could be no normalization or standardization. It is to
be pointed out that such procedure of normalization or standardization could
be only between different Boards, where the manner in which the marks are
awarded is different. The petitioner could not seek for normalization or
standardization of marks within the same Board, merely because she had
taken the exams in the year 2008, while after the year 2010, persons have
taken the exams under the Uniform System of Education pattern.
29. Further, it should not be lost sight of that day-in and day-out,
though the pattern of education changes, the syllabus for the years ahead are
going up and the knowledge level of the later generations would definitely be
more than the present generation as they have to learn more and assimilate
more and, therefore, their merit cannot be brushed aside, merely because of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
the Uniform System of Education on the ground that the syllabus and the
manner of studies were different.
30. Further, insofar as the marks, which is given to the candidates
belonging to COVID-19 batch, which is fixed uniformly at 66.67%, it should not
be lost sight of that candidates with higher merit, who could have obtained
even higher marks in the academics during the said academic year were
robbed of the opportunity to write the examination due to the pandemic.
Though certain persons may be beneficiaries of COVID-19, there are also
losers on account of the pandemic and, therefore, normalization has been
given to such type of persons, which was due to the fact that the pandemic
was not within their control. Therefore, the said fixation of percentage for the
COVID batch cannot be said to be flawed.
31. When the rules do not prescribe a specific method of selection
except spelling out that it should be direct recruitment, it is open to the
appointing authority to decide the method by which the said posts are to be
filled up so long as it is not arbitrary, perverse or unreasonable. When a policy
decision has been taken to fill up the posts by adopting the method as
specified in the notification, which is uniform to all the persons, irrespective of
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
the Board, the said method cannot be said to be erroneous or arbitrary unless
the petitioners are able to show the perversity or the ulterior purpose which is
writ large on the said selection method. To allege is one thing and to establish
the same is another thing.
32. On the whole, a careful perusal of the entire papers placed by the
petitioners coupled with the contentions advanced on behalf of the petitioner,
no substantial ground is made out to hold that the method of selection
adopted by the respondents is perverse, arbitrary or unreasonable and the
mere grievance of the petitioner cannot be a ground to set at naught the
selection process, which is otherwise in order. Therefore, this Court is of the
considered view that the process of selection prescribed in the impugned
Government order, which has been carried on in the impugned notification
issued by the 3rd respondent cannot be said to be flawed, arbitrary or perverse
and, therefore, the same does not require any interference at the hands of
this Court.
33. For the reasons aforesaid, the writ petition fails and the same is
dismissed. However, liberty is granted to the petitioner to challenge the
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
rejection of her candidature, if so advised.
Consequently, connected
miscellaneous petitions are closed. There shall be no order as to costs.
07.01.2026
Index : Yes / No
GLN
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
To
1. The Secretary
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Government of Tamil Nadu
Fort St. George, Secretariat
Chennai 600 009.
2. The SAddl. Chief Secretary
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Government of Tamil Nadu
Fort St. George, Secretariat
Chennai 600 009.
3. The Commissioner
Rural Development & Panchayat Raj Dept.
Panagal Maligai, Saidapet
Chennai 600 015.
4. The District Collector &
District Level Appointment Committee
Collectorate, Cuddalore District
Cuddalore 607 001.
5. The Assistant Director (Panchayats)
Cuddalore District
Cuddalore 607 001.
6. The Prl. Secretary to Government
School Education Department
Government of Tamil Nadu
Secretariat, Fort St. George
Chennai 600 009.
7. The Director of School Education
DPI Campus, College Road
Nungambakkam
Chennai 600 006.
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
____________
W.P. No.50627/2025
M.DHANDAPANI, J.
GLN
W.P. NO.50627 OF 2025
07.01.2026
https://www.mhc.tn.gov.in/judis
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review