Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3443 l
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY FIRST DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE NARSTNG RAO NANDIKONDA
D
oF 2015
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia, Aggrieved by the
Order dated: 09.11
16 in l.A No.8B2 of 2016 in O.S No.1015 of 2O1O on the fite
of the Principal Seni Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar
Between:
1. K. Anjaiah, S/o
Lrngaiah, age 72 years, occupation: agriculture.
2. K.
3. K. Shankar,
4. K. Haridas,
(died)
Allare R/o
late Lingaiah, age 60 years, occupation: agriculture.
late Lingaiah, age 57 years, occupation: agriculture.
r Village, R.R. District.
...PETITIO NERS/DEFENDANTS
AND
1. M.A. Shankar,
46 years, occupation: Service, FVo
Hyderabad-48
H.No.18-15517,
2. G. Krishna
business. R/o
Chandraiah Yadav, age 50 years, occupation:
, s/o Hyderabad.
, Wo late P.S Devasahayam, age 50 years, occr.rpation:
3.
7-1-455, Ameerpet, Hyderabad,
4. Srikanth, S/o
5. Anjaneyalu,
Narasaiah
(R-4 and 5 not
... RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS
Petition under
the affidavit filed in
all further procedings
Judge, Ranga Reddy
151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
of the petition. the High Court may be pleased to stay
O.S No.1015 of 2010 on the file of Principal Senior Civil
at L.B.Nagar, pending disposal of the CRP.
clV{L REVISION PETITION NO: 5941 OF 2016
Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of lndia, aggrieved by the
Order datecl: 09-11-2016 in l.A.No. 454 of 2016 in O.S.No. tOts oi2O10 on the fite
of the Princrpal senior civil Judge, Rangareddy District"at L.B. Nagar.
Between:
1. K Anjaiah, s/o Late Lingaiah, AgeT2Years, occupation: Agriculture.
2. K. Satyanarayana (Died), 3. K. sl"ankar, s/o Late Lingaiah, Age 60 years, occupation: Agriculture
4- K- Ha ridas, s/o Late Lingaiah, Age 57 years, occupation: Agriculture
All ar,: R/o Ghatkesar Mllage, R.R. District
...PETITIONERS/DEFENDANTS
AND
1. M A shankar, s/o late Narsaiah, Age 46 years, occupation: service, R/o
H No 18-15517, Hanmanpet, Malkajgiri, Hyderabad-sOO04'B
2. G Krishna Yadav, s/o chandraiah yadav, Age 50 years, occupation:
Business, R/o Ameerpet, Hyderabad.
3 P Srlaroopa.Rani, wo fate P.s Devasahayam, Age 50 years, occupation:
Housewife, R/o H.No.7-145S, Ameerpet, Hyderabad
4. Srikalrth, S/o Srinivas
5 Anjaneyulu, S/o Narasaiah
[R-4 zrnd R5 not necessary]
...RESPONDENTS/PLAINTIFFS
CRPMP. NC,: 7766 OF 2016
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
Suspend the r impugned order dt.09. 1 1 .2016 in lA No.45 4 of 2016 in OS No. 1 01 5 of
2010 on the file of Principal Senior Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B.Nagar
pending disprosal of the CRP.
counsel for the Petitioners in both cRp's: sri. B.satish representing
Sri. Thoom Srinivas
counsel for the Respondent No.2 in both cRp's: sri B srinivasutu and
Sri. R- Prasad
Counsel for the Respondent nos.l and 3 in both CRP'S: Sri. Rajan Sri Krishnan
The Court rrrade the following: COMMON ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT T1OR THE STATE OF TEIAITGAI{A
AT ITYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE NARSING RAO NANDIKONDA
CIVIL RTVISION PETITION Nos.5937 and 5941 of 2O16
DATE: 21 .oL.2026
Between:
K. Anjaiah and 3 others
..Petitioners
AND
M. A. Shankar and 4 others
...Respondents
COMMON ORDER
This Civil Revision Petition No.5937 of 2016 is filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India aggrieved by the Order
dated 09.1 1.20L6 in dismissal 0f I.A.No.882 0f 2016 in
O.S.No.1015 of 2010 on the fite of the learned Principal Senior
Civil Judge, Ranga Reddy District at L.B. Nagar.
-t-
NN&I
cRP_5937& 5941:n16
2.
This Civil Revision Petition No.594l of 2016 is liled under
Article 22'7 of the Constitution of India aggrieved by the Order
dated 09.l 1 .2016 in allowing I.A.No.454 of 2016 in O.S.No.10 15
of 2010 o:e the frle of the learned Principal Senior civil Judge,
Ranga Rectdy District at L.B. Nagar, to summon the oflicials i.e.,
Secretar5r, Gram Panchayat of Rampally Village, Keesara
Mandal, Ranga Reddy District to appear with relevant
Grampanchayat records pertaining to Laxminagar Colony
situated i:r Sy.Nos.381, 382, 383, 384 and g8T at Rampally
Village, K€:esara Mandal, Ranga Reddy District and Tahsildar of
Keesara iV,andal, Ranga Reddy District to appear with revenlre
records pr:rtaining to the lands mentioned
"borr"
to produce
evidence.
3.
For the sake of convenience, tlle parties hereinafter
referred to as, as they are arrayed before the Triar court.
4-
The brief facts in c.R.p.No.sggz of 2ot6 are that the
respondents/plaintiffs herein filed a suit for perpetual injunction
against the respondents/defendants therein in respect of the
suit schedule p.op.Ig: During the pendency of the suit, it
NNR,J
CRP-5937 Ex594LA16
appears that the plaintiff relied upon and got marked through
Pwl, as Ex.A-10 was a Xerox copy and it was a created one,
there is a burden of proof on the plaintiff to prove the document
according to the Right to Information Act (RTI Act), 2oos, which
is said to have submitted a report by Tahsildar Keesara to the
District Collector in respect of personal inspection relating to the
land. Being aggrieved by the said markings of the said
documents, the present revision is frled contending that Ex.A- 1o
was a Xerox copy and the sarne is not admissible evidence filed
by the Pwl and the trial court has dismissed the petition under
order XIII Rule 3 r/w section 151 of the civil procedure code
was being illegal and that Xerox copy of the document being
inadmissible in evidence and the finding of the learned trial
court ought to have decided immediately and cannot be
postponed and inadmissible documents can be rejected at any
time. Further, prayed to allow the application i.e., t.A.No.882 of
20t6.
5.
Heard Sri B.Sathish, learned counsel representing
sri rhoom srinivas, learned counsel for the petitioners and
\
-..
/
NNR,I
cRP_5937 & 5941_2016
Sri Rajan Sri Krishnan, Sri B. Srinivasulu and Sri R. Prasad,
learned counsel appearing for respondents. Perused the entire
material ore record.
6.
Admlttedly, the said document which is marked as
Ex.A-10 w'as a Xerox copy, though the learned counsel for the
petitioner contended that the said document can be obtained
under RTI Act and the same cannot be marked. Learned trial
Court ou61ht to have considered that the document which is
rnarked was submitted by the Tahsildar Keesara to the District
Collector in respect of the personal inspection which is
conducted relating to the suit schedule property. Admittedly,
the said <locument being only the Xerox copy and there is a
dispute rerised regarding the contents of the documents which
are created by PWl, is a scribe of the said document. Unless and
until the :;ame in confronted to the concerned, the same cannot
be treated into evidence. Further, in view of the judgment of this
Court in the case of Yeluvolu Blessy Sheeba v/s. Amgoth
Anitha Naryakr, wherein held that:
'c.R.P.No.1769 of 2o23
\
NNR,J
CRP_5937 Ex5941.A16
"The learned counsel for the respondentdefendant placed reliance on the judgment of. the
combined High Court of Andhra Pradesh and
Telangana in Syed Yousuf Ali v. Mohd.Yousuf
and Othersl, wherein also it was contended that
when a document is admifted and marked as
exhibit, it could not be questioned except under
Section 61 in view of interdict contained under
Section 36 of Indian Stamp Act, it was held that:
16. No doubt, Section 36 of the Act created an
interdict to raise an objection about admissibility of
document, once admitted, except under Section 61, it is
the duty of the Court to apply its mind about the
admissibility and determine judicially but the Presiding
Officer failed to look into the admissibility of the
document for want of stamp duty and penalty. Putting
signature on the stamp of marking on the document
cannot be considered as admission of a document in
evidence. When similar issue came up before Division
Bench of this Court in W.P.No.29434 of 2013, dated
12.02.2014, placing reliance on judgment of Apex
Court in RV.E.Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu
Viswesaraswami [AfR 2003 SC 45481 and
V.P.Temple and another and Ram Rattan (dead) by
legal representatives v. Bajranlal and others [AlR
1978 SC 13931 drawn distinction between admitting in
evidence and marking of document. Marking of a
document is only for convenient reference, whereas,
admitting document is taking the document as evidence
after applying judicial mind. In view of principle laid
down in RV.E.Venkatachala Gounders case [AlR
2003 SC 45481and Ram Rattan (dead) by LRs case
[AlR 1978 SC 1393], theparties can raise objection as
to admissibility of document and mere marking of,
document for convenience of reference would not
preclude the parties to raise objection as to the
NN&]
cRP_5937& 5yg,2016
admissibility. In R.V.E.Venkatachala Gounders case
[AIR 2003 SC 4548], the Apex Court is of the view
that mcrcly bccause a documcnt is marked as cxhibit an
objection as to its admissibility is not excluded and is
available to be raised even at a later stage or even in
appeal or revision. Similarly in Ram Rattan's case
[AIR 1978 SC 1393], the Supreme Court is of the view
that when the document was tendered in evidence by
the plaintiff while in witness box, objection has been
raised by the defendants that the document was
inadmissible in evidence as it was not only
insufficiently stamped, but also for want of registration,
it rvas obligatory upon rhe learned trialjudge to apply
his mind to the objection raised and decide the
objection in accordance with lar.v. Tendency sometimes
is to postpone the decision to avoid intemrption in the
process of rercording evidence and therefore, a very
convenient device is resoned to, of marking the
document in evidence subject to objection. However,
would not mean that the objection as to admissibility
on the ground that the insrrument is not duly stamped is
judicially decided; it is merel,v postponed- [n such a
situation at a later stage before the suit is finally
disposed of it would none-the-less be obligatory upon
the Court to decide the objection. The endorsement
made by the learned trial Judge that objected, allowed
subject to objection, clearly indicates that when the
objection was raised, it rvas not judicially determined
and the document was tentatively marked and in such a
situation, Section 36 would not attract. Though facts
are different, the lau, laid dorvn by the Courts time and
again is that to admit a document in evidence the Court
has to appl,v its mind and decide the admissibility of
document in evidence, judicially, mere marking for
convenience of reference itself would not amount to
admitting the document by applying judicial mind and
it is not a.iudicial determination as to the admissibility
of document in evidence. Section 35 created clear
NNR,J
cRP_5937& 594L_n16
embargo against acting upon insufficiently stamped
document for any purpose. Any purpose would include
collateral purpose. Even if both parties gave consent
for marking insufliciently stamped document, it shall
not be act upon, more particularly to enforce the right
of parties under contract of sale, unless it falls under
any clauses of proviso. The present documbnt does not
fall within any of the clauses of proviso to Section 35of
the Act, when document shall not be acted upon
admitting the same by consent would mean that it is the
duty of the Court to decide admissibility of document
in evidence judicially.
17. In such situation, the bar under Section 36
of the Act would not come in the way of the parties to
raise an objection as to the admissibility of the
document. In the present case except affixing stamp
giving numerical nurnber to the possessory contract of
sale as Ex.A.l, signing thereon by officer, nothing
discloses about the judicial determination of
admissibility of possessory contract of sale. The
provisions of Starnp Act are fiscal in nature and such
provisions have to be construed strictly, at the same
time, it is the duty of the office to decide or determine
judicially about adrnissibility of the document,
irrespective of objection to avoid loss of revenue to the
State. In the absence of any judicial determination
about admissibility of the document, the same can be
questioned at a later stage though stamp is affixed
marking the document as exhibit.
The High Court of Andhra Pradesh (United)
in Syed Yousuf Ali's Case (cited supra) also held
that:
21. When the documents were marked as
exhibits in the absence of defendant or his counsel and
without considering the nature of the document by the
NNR,I
cRP_5937 & 5947_2076
Court, assigning exhibit number cannot be said to be
admitted in evidence and interdict contained in Section
36 would not corne to the aid of the party in whose
evidence the document was marked as exhibit without
any judicial determination, totally debarring the
adversary to challenge the admissibility of document in
evidence. In Vemireddy Kota Reddy's Case
[2004(3)ALD 187], single Judge of this Court relied on
Javer Chand and others v. Pukhraj Surana to
conclude that marking of a document is assigning
exhibit number without judicial determination would
not amount to admitting document in evidence and
such objection can be raised at later point of time.
Whereas, leamed counsel for the
respondents placed reliance in T.Nagaratnam's case
12006 (3) ALD 8381, so also M.Narasimhulu's case
[996 Law Suit (AP) 447] and lsra Fatima's case
12002 Law Suit 8321. In all the three judgments, the
single Judges of this Court decided the bar contained
under Section 36 of lndian Stamp Act holding that until
and unless there is a judicial determination it cannot be
said that it has been admitted in evidence though it is
marked. Mere marking of document itself is not
sufficient and there should be judicial determination as
to the nature of document and its admissibility. Further
the words admitted in evidence appearing under
Section 36 of the Act means admitted after judicial
consideration of objections relating to admissibility. tn
the absence of judicial determination marking of
document mechanical[y is an illegalit-v. Even otherwise
at any stage of the suit, the Court may reject any
document which it considers irrelevant or otherwise
inadmissible in view of Order l3 Rule 3 CPC.
24. According to Orderl3 Rule 3 CPC the
Court may at any stage of the suit, reject an\.document
which it considers irrelevant or otheru,ise inadmissible,
NNR,]
cRP_5937& 5941.476
recording the grounds for such rejection. Order 13 Rule
4 CPC prescribes an endorsement to be made on the
document when a document is admitted in evidence.
According to it, there shallbe an endorsement on every
document which has been admitted in evidence
containing number and title of the suit, the name of the
person producing the document, the date on which it
was produced and a statement of its having been so
admitted and the endorsement shall be signed or
initialled by the Judge.
25. Here there is an endorsement on the reverse
possessory
of
contract of sale consisting the details
under Order 13 Rule 4(lXA) to (C), 1(D) is absent.
Therefore, the document cannot be said to be admitted
after judicial determination, in such a case, exercising
power under Order l3 Rule 3 CPC, the Court can reject
any document which it considers irrelevant or inadmissible, record ing reasons.
7.
This Court is of the view that the learned trial Court ought
not to have marked Ex.A- 10- In view of the provisions of the
Order XIII Rule 3 of C.P.C, the Court empowering which is
marked mistakenly or which should not be marked and been
marked can be de-exhibited.
8.
This Court deems it fit and proper that C.R.P.No.5937 of
2016 can be allowed setting aside the order passed by the
learned trial Court by allowing the application i.e., I.A.No.882 of
2016 and thereby de-exhibiting the
- 10.
NNR,I
CRP-5937 E*.594U076
9.
In res,pect of C.R.P.No.5941, on perusal of the order passed
by the leanred trial Court and the reasons cited by the petitioner
in allowing the application i.e., I.A.No.454 of 2016 to surnmon
the officials i.e., Secretary, Gram Panchayat of Rampally Village,
Keesara Miandal, Ranga Reddy District are the appropriate
persons t,f, appear with relevant Grampanchayat records
pertaining to La;rminagar Colony has denied by the trial Court.
However, il, is an admitted fact that the said documents or report
which was submitted by the Tahsildar Keesara to the District
Collector, €rs such he being the one who inspected. as submitted
the report, he is proper person to speak about the documents as
to produce the same and the same can be marked, as he being
the author of the documents, as such this Court could not find
any effof rlorrrritted by the trial Court in summoning the said
oflicials to confront the said document i.e., inspection report of
the Tatisilctar and the layouts which is said to have been existing
in Laxmi Itlagar Colony. Hence, this Court could not Iind any
ground to interfere with the order passed by the learned trial
Court.
+-
--*"
I
NNR,I
cRP_5937& 5947_n16
10. Accordingly, the C.R.P.No.594L of 2016 is dismissed and
C.R.P.No.5937 of 2016 is allowed setting aside the order passed
by the learned trial Court and de-exhibiting Ex.A- 1O and
granting liberty to the petitioner to confront the said document
to the concerned Tahsitdar and get the same marked through
the same Tahsildar. As the suit is pertaining to the year 2OlO,
learned trial Court is directed to dispose the suit as
expeditiously as possible without granting any unnecessary
adjournments not beyond one week and both the parties shall
co-operate with the trial Court in disposal of the same.
Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending in this appeal
shall stand closed.
Sd,. N.SRIHARI
DEPUW REGISTRAR
,/TRUE
SECTION OFFICER
lo
Reddy
1. The Princioal senior civil Judge, Ranga
District at L.B.Nagar
i"
Sri. Thoom Srinivai, ndvocatg [O?pCl
2. One CC
e Srinivasttlu, Advocate tOPUg-l
Sii.
CC
One
3.
4. One cc i; sii. nriJn sri Krishnan, A{v99f9 [oPUc]
5. One CC io Sri. R. Prasad, Advocate IOPUCI
6. Two CD CoPies
Pr/BA
Y{-
HIGH COIJRT
DATED: 2110112026
t
COMMON ORDER
0(.):
cRP.Nos.t5937 AND 5941 0F 2016
a
18 IIARffi
*
*
ALLOWINI3 THE CRP.NO.5937 OF 2016
AND
DlSMlSSlt\tG THE CRP.NO.S941 OF 2016
I ."dd
&*
L\ ?
cyo )
(
v \1-
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review