Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
APHC010313052022
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
[3333]
TUESDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 352/2022
AND
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4/2023
1.
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 352/2022
Between:
1. SHRIRAM
GENERAL
INSURANCE
COMPANY
LIMITED.,
REPRESENTED BY ITS MANAGER, UPSTAIRS C/O GOPAL AUTO
STORES.MARUTHI NAGAR, NEAR RTC BUS STAND, KADAPA
...APPELLANT
AND
1. JUTURU SHARAN KUMAR
CHARAN KUMAR, S/O. MURALI
KRISHNA, AGED 28 YEARS, HINDU, BUSINESS, RESIDENT OF
D.NO.2/110,
AMMAVARISHALA STREET, PEDDA CHEPPALI
VILLAGE, KAMALAPURAM MANDAL, KADAPA DISTRICT-516 289
2. K GANGA SUDHARSHAN REDDY, S/O K.RAMAKRISHNA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS, HINDU, PRESENT OWNER OF THE
LORRY BEARING NO.AP 04 TT 3389, RESIDING AT D.NO.2-127-D9,
MAHESWARA NAGAR,
YERRAGUNTLA TOWN AND MANDAL,
KADAPA DISTRICT
3. R VENKATA KONDA REDDY, S/O R.GOVINDA REDDY, AGE NOT
KNOWN, BUT MAJOR, HINDU, PREVIOUS OWNER OF THE LORRY
BEARING
NO.AP 04 TT 3389,
R/O A-28, ICL COMPANY,
YERRAGUNTLA, KADAPA DISTRICT.
4. KORRAPATI MAHABOOB BASHA, S/O MAHABOOB SAHEB, AGED
ABOUT 41 YEARS, MUSLIM, DRIVER OF THE LORRY BEARING
NO,AP 04 TT 3389,
RESIDING AT DATHAPURAM VILLAGE,
KONDAPURAM
MANDAL,
Y
S.R.KADAPA
DISTRICT.
(RESPONDENT NO.4 IS NOT NECESSARY PARTY)
...RESPONDENT(S):
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
2. MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4/2023
Between:
1. JUTUR SHARAN KUMAR @ CHARAN KUMAR, S/O. MURALI
KRISHNA AGED 32 YEARS, R/O. D.NO. 2/110, AMMAVARISHALA
STRET, PEDDACHEPPALI, VILLAGE, KAMALAPURAM MANDAL,
YSR KADAPA DISTRICT).
...APPELLANT
AND
1. K GANGA SUDHARSHAN REDDY, S/O. K. RAMAKRISHNA REDDY,
AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS, R/O. DO.NO.2/127-D9, MAHESWARA
NAGAR, YERRAGUNTLA TOWN AND MANDAL, YSR KADAPA
DISTRICT.
2. R VENKATA KONDA REDDY, S/O. R. GOVINDA REDDY, DO.NO.A28, ICL COMPANY, YERRAGUNTLA, YSR KADAPA DISTRICT.
3. SHRIRAM GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD, REP. BY ITS
MANAGER LEGAL, BRANCH OFFICE, 2ND FLOOR,
HERO
SHOWROOM COMPLEX, OPP.RTC BUS STAND, KADAPA TOWN,
YSR KADAPA
4. KORRAPTI MAHABOOB BASHA, S/O. MAHABOOB SAHEB, R/O.
DHATHAPURAM VILLAGE, KONDAPURAM MANDAL, YSR KADAPA
DISTRICT.
...RESPONDENT(S):
Counsel for the Appellant in MACMA No.352 of 2022 and Respondent in
MACMA No.4 of 2023:
1. A JAYANTHI
Counsel for the Respondent(S) in MACMA No.352 of 2022 and Appellant
in MACMA No.4 of 2023:
1. DHANUNJAYA REDDY K
The Court made the following:
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 352/2022
AND
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4/2023
COMMON JUDGMENT:
1.
The Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal (for short
MACMA) No.352 of 2022 has been preferred by the Appellant/ Respondent
No.3 – Shriram General Insurance Company Limited., represented by its
Manager (Legal), Branch Office at 2nd floor, Hero Showroom Complex,
opposite to RTC bus Stand, Kadapa Town, YSR Kadapa District, challenging
award passed by the Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (for short
MACT) –cum- Principal District Judge, Kadapa in M.V.O.P.No.456 of 2018
dated 14.02.2022, wherein the Tribunal has awarded an amount of
Rs.14,41,545/- as against the claim of Rs.20,00,000/-.
MACMA No.4 of 2023 has been preferred by the appellant/Petitioner
seeking enhancement
2.
Since both the appeals are preferred challenging the same award
passed by the Chairman, Motor accidents Claims Tribunal –cum- Principal
District Judge, Kadapa in M.V.O.P.No.456 of 2018 dated 14.02.2022, this
Court feels it appropriate to pass a common Judgment in both the appeals.
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
For the sake of convenience and to avoid confusion, the parties hereinafter are referred to as they were arrayed before the Tribunal i.e., Appellant in
MACMA No.352 of 2022 and Respondent No.2 in MACMA No.4 of 2023 as
Respondent No.2; and Respondent No.1 in MACMA No.352 of 2022 and
appellant in MACMA No.4 of 2023 as petitioner; Respondents No.2 to 4 in
MACT No.352 of 2022 and Respondents No.1, 2 and 4 in MACMA No.4 of
2023 as respondents No.1, 2 and 4.
3.
Brief averments of the claim petition in MVOP No.456 of 2018 are
that: on 15.02.2018 evening one K.Nagarjuna and his brother-in-law on one
motorcycle and one K.Sudheer Kumar and the Petitioner herein on another
motorcycle, went to Yerraguntla on their personal work. After completion of
their work at Yerraguntla, they were proceeding to their village on their
respective motorcycles. K.Sudheer Kumar was riding the motorcycle and the
Petitioner was the pillion rider. The said K.Sudheer Kumar was riding the
motorcycle ahead of the motorcycle of K.Nagarjuna. At 6.15 p.m., when they
reached near Surya Lorry Transport parking yard situated in Kadapa road, the
Respondent No.1's lorry bearing No.AP04 TT 3389 (crime vehicle) driven by
Respondent No.4 - driver of the lorry, rashly and negligently, without giving
any signals, without observing the traffic on the road, suddenly took the lorry
in reverse, in a rash and negligent manner, with high speed and dashed
against the motorcycle, on which the Petitioner was a pillion rider. As a result,
the rider of the motorcycle K.Sudheer Kumar sustained serious head injuries
and died on the spot.
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
i.
The Petitioner sustained serious injuries on his left knee as he fell down
from the motorcycle, fractures to his ribs 1 to 6 on the right side, on the right
clavicle and other parts of the body. He was shifted to Government Hospital at
Proddatur. From there, for better treatment, on 16.12.2018 he was shifted to
Gowri Gopal Hospital, Kurnool. He was as in-patient till 21.02.2018 and
shifted to Ward and was finally discharged on 27.02.2018. He underwent
surgeries at the fractured areas. The injuries were not healed. He was again
admitted in M.M Hospital, Kadapa, surgery was conducted. He was there as
an in-patient up-to 07.03.2018. For follow up treatment, the Petitioner visited
M.M Hospital, Kadapa, thrice. He has taken physiotherapy. He has taken
treatment under private Orthopedic Surgeons at Kadapa. Petitioner spent
Rs.3,00,000/-
towards
treatment.
Rs.50,000/-
towards
physiotherapy,
Rs.30,000/- towards transportation charges, follow-up treatment and other
incidental expenditure. A crime was registered against Respondent No.4 by
the Police, Investigated and charge sheet was filed.
ii.
Prior to the accident, the Petitioner was running a general store by
name Juturu General Stores at his village, running a photocopier centre and
Internet cafe also. He got a license to do business in crackers. In all, the
Petitioner was earning Rs.50,000/- per month.
iii.
Due to the accident, he is unable to sit cross legged, facing difficulty to
attend natural calls, he cannot lift even small weights, he lost grip over his
right hand, and he is suffering with breathing problems and not able to attend
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
his work properly. He became permanently disabled. He was unable to sit in
general and the disability affected the marital life of the Petitioner also.
iv.
Respondent No.3 is the Insurer of the Crime vehicle, Respondent No.1
is the owner, Respondent No.2 is previous owner and Respondent No.4 is the
driver of the crime vehicle, for the negligent driving of Respondent No.4, all
the Respondents are jointly and severally liable to pay compensation of
Rs.20,00,000/- to the petitioner.
4.
Respondent No.3 - Insurance Company filed written statement,
denied the manner of accident and also denied that Respondent No.4 was
rash and negligent in his driving and was having a valid and effective driving
license. It admitted that an insurance policy was given on the crime vehicle,
the liability of Respondent No.3 is subject to conditions of Insurance policy
such as breach of obligations under M.V Rules and the insurance policy. It is
the rider of the motorcycle was not having valid driving license who drove the
two-wheeler in a rash and negligent manner but not Respondent No.4. The
rider of the motorcycle dashed against the rear side of the lorry, did not
maintain 15 feet of distance against the lorry. Petitioners foisted a false case
against Respondent No.4. Two vehicles were involved in the accident i.e.,
crime vehicle and two-wheeler. The petition is bad for non-joinder of proper
and necessary parties i.e., owner and insurer of the motor cycle. Respondent
No.3 denied the age and occupation of the Petitioner that he was earning
Rs.50,000/- per month by running General Store, Crackers business,
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
Photocopier center and Internet café as he did not file any documents relating
to Photocopier centre, General stores and Internet café, except Crackers
business. The Petitioner is wrongly claiming income. Respondent No.3 denied
that the Petitioner was suffered with permanent disability. Hence, prayed to
dismiss the petition.
5.
Basing on the above pleadings, the following issues have been
settled for trial by the Tribunal:
1) Whether the Petitioner sustained injuries in a motor vehicle accident
which occurred on 15.02.2018 due to rash and negligent driving of the
driver of the Lorry bearing No.AP04-TT-3389?
2) Whether the Petitioner is entitled for compensation, if so, to what
amount and from whom?
3) To what relief?
6.
To prove the case of the Petitioner P.W.1 to P.W.5 were
examined and got marked Ex.A.1 to Ex.A.18.
On behalf of Respondents R.W.1, R.W.2 were examined and Ex.B.1 –
Insurance policy copy marked.
7.
Upon hearing both counsel, upon perusing the pleadings, oral
and documentary evidence placed on record by both parties, the tribunal
allowed the claim petition partly by awarding Rs.14,41,545/- as compensation
together with proportionate costs and interest at 7.5% p.a from the date of
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
petition till the date of realization, directing respondents No.1 to 4 to deposit
said amount within three (03) months from the date of award.
8.
Being aggrieved by the said Award, the 3rd respondent insurance
company has preferred the present appeal on the ground that the tribunal
erred in granting compensation of Rs.14,41,545/- by taking the income of the
injured as Rs.15,000/- per month, without any proof and evidence, though
injured was doing crackers business which is only seasonal business and also
erred in granting disability at the rate of 30% which is high; that the tribunal
ought to have held that the MVOP is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties
i.e., owner and insurer of the motor cycle, the Tribunal ought to have
considered the evidence of R.W.2 – driver of crime vehicle and ought to have
held that the accident occurred due to negligent riding of the rider of two
wheeler and ought to have apportioned the liability on both the vehicles
equally at-least. Hence, prayed to allow the appeal by setting aside the order
and decree dated 1402.2022 in MVOP No.456 of 2018 passed by the
Chairman, MACT –cum- Principal District Judge, Kadapa and to dismiss the
MVOP No.456 of 2018.
MACMA No.4 of 2023 has been preferred by the appellant/ petitioner on
the grounds that the tribunal ought to have awarded the compensation as
claimed by the appellant in view of the injuries sustained by him, ought to
have considered the total income of the appellant, that the tribunal failed to
consider other income sources of the appellant and award on the basis, the
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
tribunal failed to award for future earning of the appellant and granted less
rate of interest.
Hence, now the appellant prayed to allow the appeal by
awarding Rs.20,00,000/- as claimed in the claim petition.
9.
Heard learned counsel for both parties in both the appeals,
perused the material in record.
10.
Now the point for determination is – Whether the order/award
passed by the Tribunal needs any interference?
11.
POINT: Considering the evidence of P.W.1, coupled with Ex.A.1
F.I.R., Ex.A.3 copy of the Charge sheet, the Tribunal concluded that the
accident had occurred due to rash and negligent driving of respondent No.4.
12.
As per evidence of P.W.1 on 15.02.2018 evening one
K.Nagarjuna and his Brother-in-law were travelling on one motor cycle and
one K.Sudheer Kumar and the claimant on another motor cycle, went to
Yerraguntla on their personal work.
After completion of their work at
Yerraguntla, they were proceeding to their native place on their respective
motorcycles. At 6.15 P.M when they reached near Surya Lorry Transport
parking yard situated in Kadapa road, 1st respondent‟s lorry bearing No.AP04
TT 3389 (crime vehicle) driven by Respondent No.4 – driver of the lorry in a
rash and negligent manner, without giving any signals, without observing the
traffic on the road, suddenly took the lorry in reverse, in a rash and negligent
manner, with high speed and dashed against the motor cycle, on which he
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
petitioner was a pillion rider.
Because of the said accident, the claimant
sustained serious injuries on his left knee as he fell down from the motor
cycle, sustained fractures to his ribs on the right side, fracture on the right
clavicle and other parts of the body.
He was shifted to Government Hospital
at Proddatur, from there, for better treatment, he was shifted to Gowri Gopal
Hospital, Kurnool, on 16.02.2018 he underwent surgeries for all the fractures
sustained in the said accident and he was finally discharged on 27.02.2018,
again he was admitted in M.M. Hospital, Kadapa on 27.02.2018, wherein a
surgery was conducted on him on 28.02.2018 and he was there as inpatient
up-to 07.03.2018.
13.
P.W.2 is the Doctor who is one of the District Medical Board
members, who issued Ex.A.6 – disability certificate. He deposed that the
claimant suffered from old fracture clavicle right side, mal-united old fracture
right side multiple ribs, mal-united with pneumothoraz and old fracture fibula
left side mal-united with soft tissue injury to left knee, resulting in painful
restricted movements, loss of terminal 30%, not able to sit and squat on the
floor and taking turns and climbing up and down.
14.
P.W.3 – who is Orthopedic surgeon deposed that the claimant
was admitted in their hospital on 16.02.2018 for the fracture to the clavicle
right side, multiple rib fractures right side with haemothorax and fracture to
fibula left side with open wound.
conservatively.
He was admitted in ICU and treated
On 20.02.2018 surgery was done on the left knee.
On
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
21.02.2018 he was discharged from ICU and shifted to the general ward.
Daily dressing was done and was discharged on 27.02.2018. However, in
cross examination P.W.3 has categorically deposed that he did not mention
any operation in the discharge summary. External wounds are healed now.
Petitioner will not suffer in future with these injures. As per Ex.A.2 there are
two injuries only.
15.
P.W.4 who is Administrative Officer –cum- Billing Manager of
Gowri Gopal Hospital, Kurnool, also deposed on similar lines and during his
cross examination, he admitted about issuance of Ex.A.14 – medical bills by
his hospital.
16.
P.W.5 is a Consultant Plastic Surgeon and visiting consultant at
M.M Hospital and other hospitals at Kadapa. Though in his chief examination
he has deposed that the claimant was admitted in M.M Hospital on his
reference on 27.02.2018 with complaints of post-traumatic wound on his left
knee sustained in a road traffic accident, surgery was done on 28.02.2018 and
he was discharged on 07.03.2018, in his cross examination he categorically
deposed that in Ex.A.5 – discharge summary issued by M.M Hospital,
Kadapa, the date of surgery column was kept blank. However, the Court
below relying on the evidence of P.W.1 to P.W.5 awarded an amount of
Rs.14,41,545/- for the injuries sustained by the claimant in the said accident.
Admittedly, the accident took place on 15.02.2018 near Surya Lorry
Transport parking yard on Kadapa road from where he was shifted to
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
Government Hospital, Proddature for treatment, on 16.02.2018 again he was
shifted to Gowri Gopal Hospital, Kurnool, on the same day i.e., on 16.02.2018
and he underwent treatment till 27.02.2018.
The claimant got examined
P.W.3 and P.W.4 in support of his case to prove that he was admitted in
Gowri Gopal Hospital at Kurnool and was treated there from 16.02.2018 to
27.02.2018 and also underwent two surgeries in the said hospital. However,
P.W.3 though admitted that the petitioner was admitted in his hospital on
16.02.2018 for the said fracture, during the course of his cross examination he
deposed that he did not mention any operation in the discharge summary and
also that the external wounds were healed and that the claimant will not suffer
in future with these injuries. P.W.4 who is Administrative officer –cum- Billing
Manager of Gowri Gopal Hospital, Kurnool who was examined in support of
Ex.A.14 which is essentiality certificate issued by the said hospital.
Both
P.W.3 and P.W.5 have categorically deposed that they have not mentioned
about conducting any surgery on the claimant on the particular dates
mentioned in their chief examination or as stated by P.W.1 i.e., claimant.
When the claimant was discharged from Gowri Gopal Hospital on 27.02.2018
after recovering from the said injuries, the question of once again admitting
and consulting M.M Hospital on the same day situated at Kadapa i.e.,
27.02.2018 does not arise. When the evidence of P.W.5 is specific that no
surgery was done on the claimant and as per Ex.A.5 the date of surgery
column was kept blank, this court is unable to believe the evidence of P.W.5
who was examined in support of the surgery done on 28.02.2018. As such,
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
Ex.A.17 medical bills to a tune of Rs.37,902/- and Ex.A.18 to a tune of
Rs.36,000/- which were issued by M.M Hospital at Kadapa are created to be
suspicious and are disbelieved.
17.
Now coming to the income of the claimant, his case is that as per
Ex.A.8 he was running crackers business and apart from that he was also
running general store, Xerox center and internet café also but no independent
witnesses were examined to that extent, except Ex.A.8 which is license issued
for running crackers business. Even, as per Ex.A.8 the license is valid up-to
19.10.2017 (during Diwali festival season 2017 only).
18.
In the absence of any documentary evidence to show that the
deceased was earning Rs.15,000/- per month, the Tribunal ought to have
considered the wages applicable as per the Minimum Wages Act of the year
2018, if the same is applied, an unskilled labour would get an amount of
Rs.318/- per day. If the same is considered, the monthly income of the
deceased would come to Rs.9,540/- (Rs.318 X 30). Accordingly, annual
income would come to Rs.1,14,480/- (Rs.9,540 X 12).
19.
As per Ex.A.6 disability certificate issued by the District Medical
Board the claimant sustained 30% disability in the accident, which in fact
supported by the evidence of P.W.2, who is one of the members of the
medical board. Considering the age of the claimant as 24 years as on the date
of the accident, for the age of group of 21-25 years, as per the decision of the
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
Hon‟ble Apex Court in “Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation1”, the
appropriate multiplier is „18‟. After applying the appropriate multiplier, the loss
of earnings would come to Rs.20,60,640/- (Rs.1,14,480 X 18). As the claimant
sustained 30% of disability as per Ex.A.6, he is entitled 30% of arrived income
towards loss of income due to permanent disability, which comes to
Rs.6,18,192/- (Rs.20,60,640 X 30%).
20.
In view of the same, this Court intends to reduce the loss of
income from Rs.9,72,000/- to Rs.6,18,192/-.
21.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the opinion
that Tribunal erred in awarding Rs.90,000/- (Rs.15,000 X 6) towards loss of
income for the period of treatment, therefore, the same is reduced from
Rs.90,000/- to Rs.57,240/- towards loss of income during the period of
treatment for 6 months.
22.
The Tribunal also awarded an amount of Rs.25,000/- towards
expenses relating to hospitalization charges, Rs.10,000/- towards extra
nourishment
charges,
Rs.50,000/-
towards
Transportation
charges,
Rs.10,000/- towards personal attendant charges, Rs.25,000/- towards future
medical expenses, Rs.2,09,545/- towards medical expenditure relying on
Exs.A.7, A.14, A.17 and A.18, Rs.50,000/- towards two grievous injuries and
one simple injury, which needs no interference.
2009 ACJ 1298
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
23.
In all, the claimant is entitled for Rs.10,54,977/- towards
compensation for the injuries sustained by him.
24.
The compensation awarded by the Tribunal under different heads and
the amount awarded by this Court, are as follows:
Sl.
No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
7.
8.
Head of the claim
Expenses relating to hospitalization
charges
Extra nourishment charges
Transportation charges
Personal attendant charges
Loss of Income
Loss of Income during the period of
treatment for six months
Towards future medical expenses
Towards Medical bills
Towards pain and suffering for three
injuries
Total
25.
Compensation
awarded by the
Tribunal in
Rs. Ps.
25,000-00
Amounts now
awarded by
this Court
Rs. Ps.
25,000-00
10,000-00
50,000-00
10,000-00
9,72,000-00
90,000-00
10,000-00
50,000-00
10,000-00
6,18,192-00
57,240-00
25,000-00
2,09,545-00
50,000-00
25,000-00
2,09,545-00
50,000-00
14,41,545-00
10,54,977-00
In the result, the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal vide
MACMA No.352 of 2022 is partly allowed by reducing the compensation
awarded by the Chairman, MACT –cum- Principal District Judge, Kadapa in
M.V.O.P.No.456 of 2018, dated 14.02.2022; and in view of the order passed
in MACMA No.352 of 2022 the Motor Accident Civil Miscellaneous Appeal
vide MACMA No.4 of 2023 is dismissed. No costs.
Consequently, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall stand
closed.
_______________________
SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
KS
Dated 10.03.2026.
MACMA NO’S.352/2022 & 4/2024
VS,J.
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE V.SUJATHA
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 352/2022
AND
MOTOR ACCIDENT CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 4/2023
DATED 10.03.2026
KS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review