Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
DATED: 24.02.2026
CORAM
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE N.ANAND VENKATESH
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
in
Execution Petition No.4 of 2025
A.Nos.304 to 307/2026
1.Jumbo World Holdings Limited,
A company incorporated and existing
in accordance with the laws of British Virgin
Islands, with its registered office at
Sea Meadow House, Blackburne Highway,
Road Town, British Virgin Islands.
Represented by Authorized Signatory
Gourag Arunkumar Shah
2.Dandvati Investments and Trading Company
Private Limited,
A company incorporated and existing in
accordance with the laws of India, with
its registered office at 5th Floor,
‘The International’, 16 New Marine Lines,
Cross Road No.1, Churchgate,
Mumbai – 400 020.
represented by Authorized Signatory
Gourag Arunkumar Shah
.... Applicants in all applns.
Vs.
Embassy Property Developments Private Limited
(Formerly known as M/s.Dynasty Developers
Private Limited),
A company incorporated and existing in
accordance with the laws of India, with its
registered office at No.150, Embassy Point,
Infantry Road, Bangalore – 560 001.
.... Respondent in all applns.
1/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
Applications filed under Order XIV Rule 8 of the Madras High
Court Original Side Rules read with Section 47 and Order XXI Rule 1
and Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, praying to
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
permit the first applicant to withdraw the amount of
Rs.22,09,68,496/- (Rupees Twenty Two Crores Nine Lakhs Sixty
Eight Thousand Four Hundred and Ninety Six only) (along with
accrued interest) deposited to the credit of Execution Petition
No.04 of 2025;
permit the second applicant to withdraw the amount of
Rs.168,89,57,770/- (Rupees One Hundred and Sixty Eight Crores
Eighty Nine Lakhs, Fifty Seven Thousand Seven Hundred and
Seventy only (along with accrued interest) deposited to the credit
of Execution Petition No.04 of 2025;
direct the balance amount of Rs.8,36,99,650/- (Rupees Eight
Crores Thirty Six Lakhs Ninety Nine Thousand Six Hundred and
Fifty only) be kept in Court deposit and paid to second applicant
(along with accrued interest) when the Preference Shares are
dematerialized and transferred to the respondent; and
direct the respondent to deposit an additional sum of
Rs.3,26,21,677/- (Rupees Three Crores Twenty Six Lakhs Twenty
One Thousand Six Hundred and Seventy Seven only) to the credit
of Execution Petition No.04 of 2025.
For Applicants
[in all applns.]
For Respondent
[in all applns.]
:
Mr.H.Karthik Seshadri
:
Mr.Satish Parasaran,
Senior Counsel
A.Nos.580 to 584 of 2026
Embassy Property Developments Private Limited
(Formerly known as M/s.Dynasty Developers
Private Limited),
A company incorporated and existing in
accordance with the laws of India, with its
registered office at No.150, Embassy Point,
Infantry Road, Bangalore – 560 001.
represented by its Authorised Signatory
Mrs.Asha Kumari Alexander
.... Applicant in all applns.
Vs.
2/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
1.Jumbo World Holdings Limited,
A company incorporated and existing
in accordance with the laws of British Virgin
Islands, with its registered office at
Sea Meadow House, Blackburne Highway,
Road Town, British Virgin Islands.
Represented by Authorized Signatory
Gourag Arunkumar Shah
2.Dandvati Investments and Trading Company
Private Limited,
A company incorporated and existing in
accordance with the laws of India, with
its registered office at 5th Floor,
‘The International’, 16 New Marine Lines,
Cross Road No.1, Churchgate, Mumbai – 400 020.
represented by Authorized Signatory
Gourag Arunkumar Shah
.... Respondents in all
applns.
Applications filed under Order XIV Rule 8 of Original Side Rules
read with Order 21, 26 Rule 9, 32 & Section 151 of the Civil Procedure
Code, 1908, praying to
(a) clarify paragraph No.42(e) of the order dated 06.10.2025 passed in
E.P.No.4 of 2025 to the effect that withdrawal of the amount from
the deposited amount i.e., Rs.2,04,00,00,000/- shall be subject to
such deductions towards the tax deductible at source as per the
applicable law and also subject to compliance of all statutory
provisions pertaining to payment of consideration to Jumbo World
Holdings Limited and Dandvati Investments and Trading Company
Pvt. Ltd.;
(b) direct the Judgment Debtors to rectify and cure all deficiencies
enumerated in Annexure-A of this application, including settlement
of outstanding liabilities, completion of statutory filings and
production of all missing documents, as the case may be, to
undertake forthwith all actions necessary to enable completion of
closing (i.e., transfer of the sale shares to the decree holder and
withdrawal of the deposited amount) in compliance with applicable
laws;
(c) appoint an Advocate Commissioner at the cost of the Judgment
Debtors to ensure compliance of the obligations stated in Annexure
3/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
(d)
(e)
A of this Affidavit, as authorised representative of the judgment
Debtors by taking over the affairs of the Company, including the
possession of the assets of the Company, both movable and
immovable, and carry out or cause to be carried out specific
performance of the share transfer obligations within one week from
the date of appointment of the Advocate Commissioner;
to permit the decree holder post transfer of shares to conduct
physical survey of the properties mentioned under Annexure-D of
the SPA; and
direct the Judgment Debtors to provide all necessary assistance and
cooperation to the Advocate Commissioner and/or the Decree
Holder to ensure the completion of the share transfer and further
ensure timely resolution of any issues that may arise post
acquisitions of the shares, including execution of necessary share
transfer forms, filings and instruments on behalf of the Judgment
Debtors and all such future compliances as may be required from
Judgment Debtors post acquisitions of the shares.
For Applicant
[in all applns.]
: Mr.Satish Parasaran, Senior Counsel
for Mr.Rahul Balaji
For Respondents : Mr.H.Karthik Seshadri
[in all applns.]
*****
COMMON ORDER
Application Nos.580 to 584 of 2026 have been filed seeking
clarification of some of the directions issued by this Court while
disposing of E.P.No.4 of 2025 by order dated 06.10.2025 and for certain
directions to effectively work out the order passed in E.P.No.4 of 2025.
2. Application Nos.304 to 307 of 2026 have been filed by the
Judgment Debtors seeking a direction to withdraw amounts and for other
4/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
directions.
3. Heard Mr.H.Karthik Seshadri, learned counsel for judgment
debtors and Mr.Satish Parasaran, learned Senior Counsel appearing for
decree holder.
4. When this Court disposed of E.P.No.4 of 2025 by order dated
06.10.2025, the following directions were issued at paragraph No.42:
“42.In the light of the above discussion, the following
directions are issued by this Court:
a) There shall be a direction to the petitioner to deposit a sum of
Rs.204 Crores to the credit of E.P.No.4 of 2025, within a
period of four weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this
order.
b) There shall be direction to the respondents to provide all the
details and documents as stated in Paragraph No.97 of the
Award, as is required by the petitioner, within a period of two
weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
c) There shall be a direction to the petitioner to conduct due
diligence in order to ensure that all the statutory mandates are
complied with, which will not adversely impact the
acquisition of the shares of GWL. This process shall be
completed by the petitioner, within a period of four weeks
from the date of receipt of all the details and documents from
the respondents.
d) The entire process of providing the details and documents
and conducting due diligence upon the same shall be
completed and necessary steps shall be taken by the
respondents to transfer the share holdings (share and
debentures) held by them with GWL Properties Limited,
within a period of eight weeks from the date of receipt of
copy of this order.
e) On such transfer of shares, the respondents will be entitled to
withdraw the amount deposited by the petitioner to the
5/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
account of the E.P.No.4 of 2025 along with accrued interest.
f) If the respondents failed to comply with the conditions
stipulated supra, the Directors/Principal Officers of the
respondents Company mentioned in Schedule B annexed to
the petition will be liable to be detained in the civil prison,
and
g) There shall be a direction to the respondents to pay a cost of
Rs.2.50 Lakhs to the petitioner, within a period of eight
weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.”
5. The applications filed by the decree holder came up for hearing
and after hearing both sides, this Court directed the learned counsel for
decree holder to submit a memo after discussions with the other side and
specifically point out the clarification required from this Court for the
issue in controversy and also those issues where the parties are ad idem
and consequently, may not require any clarification.
6. Pursuant to the above order, a memo was filed by tabulating the
issues and for proper appreciation, the same is extracted hereunder:
S.
No.
1.
6/16
Pending
Issue
SPA
Clause
Annexure B – 4.1(a)(i)
Sellers
Certificate
Award
EP Order
Dated
dated
31.08.2025 06.10.2025
Paragraph
As discussed on
05.02.2026
Paragraph The Sellers disputed the
42(b)
format of the Certificate.
The Purchaser insists on
retaining the format as
per Annexure B to the
SPA except to the
exclusions of 23.08 acres
land which was given up
during
arbitration
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
S.
No.
Pending
Issue
SPA
Clause
Award
EP Order
Dated
dated
31.08.2025 06.10.2025
As discussed on
05.02.2026
proceedings
subsequent
proceedings.
2.
Physical
Survey
Fencing
3.
Preference
Shares
4.
7/16
and
OP
8 (g) and Paragraph
(d)
and (i)
and (e), 9
(vi) (viii)
Paragraph The Sellers are not
42(b)
allowing the Purchaser to
conduct physical survey
to resultantly fence the
properties along with
identifying the current
state of the immovable
properties.
4.1(a) (ii) Paragraph
and
4.1(a)
(iii)
Paragraph The parties have agreed
42(b)
that necessary approvals
shall be obtained from
the Hon’ble National
Company Law Tribunal,
till then the proportionate
consideration shall be
retained
from
the
deposited amount in the
Court deposit before this
Hon’ble Court.
To
be Paragraph
Annexure
D(B) – Assets delivered
– (Rs.28.07 in terms
of 8.1(a),
Crores)
consisting of (g), 8.1(i)
(b) read
three items:
1. NH Bonds with 9(ii)
of
Rs.9.6
Crores
2.Fixed
Deposit
Accounts with
Banks
of
Rs.17.60
Crores
3.
Current
Account with
Banks
of
Rs.0.87
Crores
Paragraph The
Purchaser
is
42(b)
claiming Rs.33.6 Crores
basis the notional interest
on Rs.28.07 Crores from
the date of the SPA after
deducting the expenses
of the Company for the
period between Dec
2005 – Oct 2025. The
Sellers contend that they
are only liable to a sum
of Rs.18.04 Crores.
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
S.
No.
Pending
Issue
SPA
Clause
Award
EP Order
Dated
dated
31.08.2025 06.10.2025
As discussed on
05.02.2026
5.
Improper
8.1(i)(a)
Paragraph
Litigation – and 8.1(i)
(Rs.5 Crores) (j)
6.
Court
Commisison
(2.2%)
and
Additional
Deposit
Request
(Rs.3.26
Crores)
NA
NA
NA
This claim is not legally
tenable and is disputed
by
the
purchaser.
Assuming it is tenable,
the deposit made by the
purchaser was based on
the direction of this
Hon’ble Court in the EP
order based on the
contentions made by the
sellers.
The
Court
Commission
is
not
envisaged in the EP
Order, and hence it is to
be borne by the sellers.
7.
Annexure E –
Outstanding
dividend on
Pref shares :
Rs.11.32
crores + NQ
NA
NA
NA
With respect to Rs.11.32
crs + NQ of dividend –
the existing shareholders
should provide a waiver
letter/NOC giving up
their rights to receive the
dividends on preference
shares.
8.
Undertaking
all
actions
required for
transfer
of
sale
shares
and hand over
of documents
pertaining to
the company
as part of
closing
actions
4 read
with 5
Paragraph
8/16
Paragraph The purchaser sought
42(b)
details of the litigation
expenses incurred which
the sellers are not willing
to disclose.
Paragraph All actions and steps for
42(b)
the purpose of transfer of
sale shares to the
completed and sellers to
also hand over of all
documents/ information
relating to the company,
to the acquirer, at the
time of closing. An
indicative list of to be
handed over attached.
Final list to circulated
prior to closing.
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
7. Insofar as the direction issued in paragraph No.42(a), the decree
holder has deposited a sum of Rs.204 crores to the credit of E.P.No.4 of
2025. Hence, nothing remains to be clarified on this issue.
8. Insofar as the issue pointed out in Sl.No.2 is concerned, it was
submitted that the decree holder will proceed further to survey the
property and to fence the same considering the current state of the
immovable properties. Hence, no clarity is required on this issue.
9. Insofar as the issue pointed out in Sl.No.3 is concerned, the
parties have reached an agreement and therefore, no further clarification
is required.
10. Insofar as the issue pointed out in Sl.No.5 is concerned, after
submissions were made on either side, this Court pointed out that it will
be impracticable to insist for details of the litigation expenses.
Accordingly, no further clarification is required for this issue also.
11. Insofar as the issue pointed out in Sl.No.6 is concerned, it
pertains to Court commission deducted at the rate of 2.2% from the total
9/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
deposit made by the decree holder which works out to nearly Rs.3.36
crores. The judgment debtors want the decree holder to set off this
amount by making an additional deposit.
12. Per contra, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the decree
holder submitted that the decree holder has already deposited the amount
as directed by this Court at paragraph No.42(a) of the order dated
06.10.2025 and therefore, no further liability can be mulcted against the
decree holder.
13. In the considered view of this Court, pursuant to the judgment
in M/s.Gowpatt Associates vs. The Superintending Engineer National
Highways Salem Circle and others [E.P.Nos.72 and 73 of 2019 dated
12.12.2023], 2.2% commission cannot be deducted from the deposit
made by the decree holder. The relevant portion in the judgment is
extracted hereunder:
“48. Accordingly, in the above discussions narrated above,
this Court directs as follows:
(i)Registry is not entitled to deduct 2% commission and 0.2% as
Audit Fee for each and every deposits made in the Nationalized
Banks as per the orders of this Court.
(ii) Articles 37, 38 and 39 could be invoked only when the
amount has been invested in the Government Securities as
10/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
discussed above.
(iii) In the absence of the amount has been transferred from the
CCD account and invested in Government Securities, the
Registry has no power to deduct 2% commission and 0.2% Audit
Fee.
(iv) And the petitioner is certainly entitled to all the monies
deducted in this regard and the Registry is directed to repay such
amounts to the petitioner.”
14. In view of the above and following the above judgment, this
Court will issue necessary directions to the Registry not to deduct any
commission from the amount deposited by the decree holder to ensure
that the entire amount is kept in tact along with accrued interest.
Accordingly, necessary clarification will be issued.
15. Insofar as the issues pointed out in Sl.Nos.7 & 8 are
concerned, there is an agreement between the parties to work out these
issues and therefore, no further clarification is required in this regard.
16. That leaves this Court to clarify only the issues raised in
Sl.Nos.1 and 4. These issues pertain to the certificate that has to be issued
under Annexure-B to the Share Purchase Agreement dated 21.12.2005.
While dealing with this certificate, Annexure-D also assumes significance
since it touches upon both movable and immovable properties and the
warranties/indemnity to be given by the judgment debtors by issuing this
11/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
certificate.
17. Under Annexure D(B), it consists of three items viz., National
Housing Bonds to the tune of Rs.9.60 crores, Fixed Deposit accounts with
banks to the tune of Rs.17.60 crores and current account with banks to the
tune of Rs.0.87 crores. In total, it works out to Rs.28.07 crores. The
judgment debtors clarified that insofar as National Housing Bonds are
concerned, they have matured and the amount realized has also been
spent towards expenditure in running the company. The judgment debtors
contend that they are liable to pay only a sum of Rs.18.40 crores. After
some deliberations, this Court suggested that the liability of the judgment
debtors can be fixed at Rs.18.40 crores without any further ado.
18. Insofar as immovable properties are concerned, the same has
been described in Annexure D(A). For the property in Sl.No.1 at Zamin
Pallavaram, 23.08 acres of land was given up even during the arbitration
proceedings and therefore, what is available is only Rs.64.03 crores.
There will be no difficulty in handing over the original documents and
making specific reference about the same in the certificate issued in
Annexure-B.
19. Insofar as second item of the property at Rajaji Salai is
12/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
concerned, it stands as a vacant land as on today and the judgment
debtors have taken a stand that they do not possess the original
documents. The decree holder is insisting that the judgment debtors must
incorporate separate indemnity clause for this property if in case any
future claims are made by third parties.
20. In the considered view of this Court, Clause 11 of the Share
Purchase Agreement dated 21.12.2005 makes it very clear that once any
third party claims are made, the judgment debtors will be liable to
compensate and indemnify the decree holder. In view of the same, even in
the absence of making a specific mention in the certificate issued in
Annexure-B, the responsibility of the judgment debtors will automatically
trigger as per the agreement and they will be bound by clause 11 to
compensate/indemnify/defend the decree holder. Hence, in the certificate,
it will suffice if the judgment debtors reiterate their title and state that
they are not in possession of the original documents pertaining to the
property.
21. Insofar as the property mentioned in Sl.Nos.3 to 6 are
concerned, after some deliberations, the parties agreed to resolve the
same on agreed terms. This is in view of the fact that the property in
13/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
Sl.No.4 is not in the name of the judgment debtors, the property in
Sl.No.5 pertains to 99 years lease from Vizag Port, which period has
already come to an end and for the property at Sl.No.6 the judgment
debtors are neither in possession of original documents nor are they in
possession of the property and they are not in a position to even establish
their ownership. Insofar as the property in Sl.No.3 is concerned, the
decree holder can work out their remedy by prosecuting the pending case.
22. In the light of the above clarifications, certificate under
Annexure-B shall be issued by the judgment debtors to the decree holder
accordingly.
23. Insofar as Application Nos.304 to 307 of 2026 are concerned,
except for the sum of Rs.8,36,99,650/-, the entire remaining amount
along with accrued interest shall be permitted to be withdrawn by the
judgment debtors after deducting the tax deducted at source (TDS). The
necessary TDS certificate shall be issued in favour of the judgment
debtors. It is made clear that the Registry shall not deduct any
commission or audit fees in line with the judgment in M/s.Gowpatt
Associates (supra).
24. With regard to the sum of Rs.8,36,99,650/-, the same shall
14/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
continue to remain in deposit and it shall be paid to the second judgment
debtor along with accrued interest after the preference shares are
dematerialized and transferred to the decree holder.
25. The parties have arrived at an agreement in most of the issues
and wherever clarity is required, this Court has also clarified in this order.
Hence, this Court expects both parties to work in tandem and close all the
pending issues as expeditiously as possible.
All these applications are disposed of in the above terms.
24.02.2026
Index:yes/no
Speaking Order/Non-speaking order
NCC:yes/no
gm
15/16
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
N.ANAND VENKATESH, J.
gm
Application Nos.304, 305, 306, 307, 580, 581, 582, 583 & 584 of 2026
24.02.2026
16/16
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review