Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THURSDAY,THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
CIVIL MISCELLANE OUS APPEAL Nos : 427 438 and 460 OF 2024
C.M.A.No. 427 of 2O24
Appeal Under Order 43 of Rule 1 of CpC aggrieved by the Judgment and
decree dated 23-01-2024 in A.s. No. 1 of 2o1s on the file of the court of the
lll Additional Diskict & sessions Judge at Sanga Reddy prefened against the
Judgment and Decree dated 14-10-2014 in o.s.No. 83 of 2007 on the file of the
Court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Sangareddy
Between:
Jukannagari Narender Reddy,
.S/o Late Ananth Reddy, Aged 84 years, Occ.
Agriculture, R/o Flat No.203, Yogetha_Nandanavanam,
Balaji Hills, Nizampet,
Hyderabad District.
...APPELLANT/ Respondent / Defendant
AND
Jukannagari Ravinder Reddy (died pe_r LRs RR 5 to g), S/o_ Anantha Reddy,
LS"9.51yqqrq, Occ Agriculture and Service, R/o. Teipote (V), Kondapur (tVl"),
Medak District.
Jukkanagari Sylen.de-r Reddy, S/o. Anantha Reddy, Aged 52 years, Occ.
Agriculture and Pvt. Senrice, RJo. Terpole (V), Xondap,'ur (M), Medak District
S_mt Suvarna, Wio. Narsimha Reddy, Occ. Retired Headmaster, R/o_ Kohir
'
Village and Mandal, I\4edak District
Smt- Sharada, Wo. Narsimha Reddy, Occ. Retired Emptoyee, R/o. plot
No 203, Lgtus. Residency, plot No. 275lA,/8, Road No i Z, trlLn Cotony,
Banjara Hills. Hyderabad - 34
Smt Nirmala, W/o. Late J. Ravinder Reddy, Age 59 years, Occ Household,
R/o. Terpole Village, Kondapur Mandal, Iviedak Distiict
9mt Kalpana, D-io. Late J. Ravinder Reddy, Age 47 years, Occ Household,
R/o. Terpole Village, Kondapur Mandal, tviedaf Oistilct
Smt Kavita, D/o. Late J. Ravinder Reddy, Age 4t yearc, Occ Household, R/o.
Terpole Village, Kondapur Mandal, Medak diskict.
I Smt Karuna, D/o. Late J. Ravinder Reddy, Age 43 years, Occ Household,
R/o. Terpole Village, Konctapur Mandal, Med;k Disirict.
6Tiii?rtr",t fi,'"n?'"?iL"r".l" as LRs or the oi.i;1"'g3loEfl"r" c.o. dt
lA NO: 2 oF 2024
petitron under
au",,n1.1:, CpC praying that in
the circumstances stated in
the affrdavir frred in support of
tne petrtion-ih;"d;'ilJl
may be preased to qrant
rnrerm stay of the
Judqment, and decree o"t"i. rid,,-2024
passed bv the Honorabte
in AS No.1/201s
t Addt District anjS"*,on".
lrdge at Sangareddy
Counsel for the Appe ant:
SRt. C. M. R. VELU
Counsel for the Respondents:
SRI p. VENKAT REDDY
CIVIL M ISCEL LANEO US
AP PEA LNO :438O F 2024
Appeal Under Or(sr z
decree dated 23.01.2024 j'^":
X:"i J ffi :TT:T:l;",:"il"I il:
lll Additionar Drstrict & Sessions Judge
Judgment and Decree dated
Court of the principal Junior
at sanga Reddy preferred against
14_10_2014 in O.S.No.
Cjvil Judge, Sangareddy
the
83 of 2OOt on the fite of the
Between:
Reddy,
*llllt^"nr, ttarender
.S/o Late Ananth Reddv Aged 84 years,
Frat
No 2oj,
l9ll9yll9,9
^Fr"
Hyoerabad Distflct
AND
Occ
Yogetha Nandanavana#
Balaji Hills, Nizampet,
...APPELLANT/ nespont ent
/ Defenda nt
3'#a!:,::11,ft :ls"Jf T;-tg:_ati&i"ffi
,effix j,11i,i:.,"0"*
. xespondenuAppeilani/ pt;iniifi"-"-..
fl[#if#$:S:lx#,:lil,S:"f.,S:l[""T"uf.:J"iJ?"iiiLli:f,?ifl,
;li:$'::f n#i: Ir:.JlIS l,?,:lv, occ Retired Headmaster, R/o Kohir
'lflififfii,:#,iff#Jiff ,x,:.i1.?f,.,:fi [!"..,5J?3'i,?f
'
'
R[ : ]Jil: l:,H,:i
":i1""
R[ : f SiB:r
f;51",i
i, I;Jl tiil X,:l#;A?ri e vea rs, occ H o u s e h o,d,
i. I;Jl i, :l [:: fl ldA?"# 7 vea rs, occ H o u se ho, d,
"'-1[.'i1""
7. Smt Kavita, D/o.
Late J. R;
re'p o
r
"
Vr r'a g
el,6;; i, J)ili$".i :,i,:irj -t3 r{,ve a rs, o cc H o s e o d, R/o
u
h
r
i
'Ffl
i-:jliqiiiJ"l.R$[i:J?',::ft:1:,ilSs?3'",,,",&i*?"s["H',",!""
brought
on record as LRs
No.1 of
2025).
oi the oeceaseO ni viou 6.'O. ot Os.oz .2025 in lA
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 2 oF 2024
Petition under Section.151 CpC praying that in
the crrcumstances stated in
the affidavit fited in support of the petition
may be pteased to grant
interim stay of the judgment and decree o^t
"""H€h
a zi^tzoii In AS No.3/2015 passed
by the Hon'ble lll Addl. District and Sessions
.lrOgu ,t-S-angrr"OOy
i;r;i
Counsel for the Appellant: SRI. C. M. R. VELU
Counsel forthe Respondent No.l : K RAGHAVENDRA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 5 to I :
REDDY
SRI p. VENKAT REDDY
CIVIL MISC ELLA NEOUS APP EAL NO:4 60
0F 2024
Appear Under order 43 0f Rure 1 0f cpc aggrieved
decree dated 23-01-2024 in A.S.No. 2 0f 2015
by the Judgment and
0n the flre of the court of the
lll Additionar District & Sessions Judge at sanga Reddy preferred
against the
Judgment and Decree dated 14-10-2014 in o.s.No. g3
0f 2007 0n the fire of the
Court of the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Sangareddy
Between:
Jukannagari Narender Reddy,
.Sio Late. Ananth Reddy, Aged g4 years. Occ.
Asricutture, R/o Ftat No 2oi, V"n"q-i_ry?!'J"ilr"i1?]
Hyderabad
Djstrict.
e"r"ii Hils, Nizamoet
-...AppELlAtiilnEdibnoervT
/pLAtNTIFF.
AND
1. Jukkanagari Surender Redciy, S/o. Late Anantha Reddy,
Agricutture and pvt. Service,'ivo r"ip"l"
Aged 52 years, Occ.
ivf ,'x"i,o:Jri.ir (M), rvledak District
2 Jukannagari Ravinder Reddy_(died per LRs RR 3 to 6), S/o. Late Anantha
[315];fPfi;riir5:',f 'o?.',.";ln'.',"'ii';;; s;it-"lftro r"6;r; ivi,''"-
3. Smt Nirmala, W/o. Late J. Ravinder Reddy, Age 59 years, Occ
R/o. Terpote Vilage, Kondapr lrrinoir, M.jj"'r.-ojJtiItl'
Household,
'R[lf 3l3:8"',,,',i"llp"l.];;lif, il1:lrry;AtiTvears,occHousehord,
' isiS3''}i,,'#
' R[l f
^i,i,l;
j;1iilIfJ: :,fii1 ; -t,:
r1:,lea
rs, c)cc H o u seh o,d, R/o
SI;i ft 9J[ J;:'Ri" [i1jl i,": ft",?:ili:? 3?.,,,."f,: occ H o u se h o,c,
$[^a.!S q ^aj9 brgught on record as LRs of the deceased R2 vide C O
Dt.ue.o/.2025
rn tA No.1 of 2025).
...RESPONDENTS
lA NO: 2 OF 2024
Petition under Section 15'1 cpc praying that in the circumstances
stated in
the affidavrt fired rn support of the petition,'thJ High court may be preased
stay of
the judgment and decree dated 23_01_2024 AS No.2/2'O1s
Uy,tne
iasseo
Hon'ble lll Addl. Drstrrct and Sessrons Judge at Sangareddy and pass
i;
Counsel for the Appellant: SRl. C. M. R. VELU
Counsel for the Respondent No.1 : SRI K. RAGHAVENDRA REDDy
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 5 to g : SRI p. VENKAT
The Court delivered the following COMMON JUDGMENT:
REDDY
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAI)
THE HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE RENUKA YARA
C.M.A Nos. 427 438 and 460 of 2024
22od JANUARY
C.M.A No. 427 of 2o24
Betu,een:
Mr. Jukannagari Narender Reddy, Hyderabad.
Appellant
AND
Mr. Jukannagari Ravinder Reddy, Medak and others
...
Respondents
C.M.A No. 438 of 2024
Between:
Mr. Jukannagari Narender Reddy, Hyderabad.
...Appellant
AND
Mr. Jukkanagari Surender Reddy, Medak and others
Respondents
C.M.A No. 460 of 2024
Between:
Mr. Jukannagari Narender Reddy, Hyderabad.
...Appellant
cMA 427. o* ouo ouo o1!if..
AND
Mr. Jukkanagari Surender Reddy, Medak and others.
Respondents
...
COMMON J UDGMENT
Heard Sri. C.M.R. Velu, learned counsel for the
appellants and Sri. p.Venkat Reddy, learned counsel
for the
respondents. perused the record.
The C.M.A. Nos.427, 43g and 460 of 2024 are preferred
aggrieved b-v the judgments and decrees dated
passed in A.S. Nos. l, 2 and 3 of 2015
23.01.2024
b-y the learned III
Additional District and Sessions Judge at Sanga
Reddy (for
short, 'the First Appellare Court,). The First Appellate
allou'ed A.S. Nos. t, 2 and 3 of 20 15 setting aside
judgments and decrccs in O.S. Nos. 83
201 1 and remanded the O.S. Nos. g3 of
Court
the common
of 2OOZ and 6g of
2OOZ and 6g of 2O1i
to the Trial Court lor fresh disposal on merits. Aggrieved
the same, the present Civil Miscellaneous Appeals
by
have been
preferred.
3.
Both thc learned counsel have dealt with the
case and the merits of their respective
_.
1',
facts of the
case. However. their
,/
RY,J
CMA- 427, 43a artd 460 ol2024
arguments were focused on whether or not the First Appellate
Court was justified in remanding the matters back to the Trial
Court for fresh disposal on merits. In the circumstances, this
Court is not inclined to venture into both the facts as well as
merits of the respective cases. The only point for consideration
is whether or not remanding the matters to the Trial Court for
fresh disposal is justified.
4.
According to the learned counsel for the appellant, the
First Appellate Court has discussed the entire facts as well as
merits of the case and therefore, ought to have pronounced a
judgment on merits. Whereas, by remanding the matter, the
First Appellate Court has given an opportunity to the
respondents to hll in lacuna and thereby causing prejudice to
the interest of the appellant.
5.
Per Contra, learned counsel for the respondents argued
that the First Appellate Court deemed that there is a need for
adducing documentaqz evidence with respect to age of
appellant/ defendant No.2 to prove his claim of purchasing the
suit schedule property. Since there was no evidence with
respect to age of defendant No.2 when he allegedly purchased
the suit schedule property, issue No.2 in O.S. Nos. 83 of 2OO7
)
RY,J
C^'IA 427, 438 and 460 of2024
and 68 of 201 1 is framed and the matter rvas remanded back
lor leading evidence on said issue. It is also the case of the
learned counsr:l for the respondcnts that the First Appellate
Court has discusscd the judgment of the Trial Court only to
the extent of issues n,here additional evidence is required for
just ad.ludication of the case but has not given a finding on
any of the issur:s
6.
In reply, learned counsel for the appellant contended
that the appellzrnr has filed a suit in O.S. No. 6g of 2O1l for
perpetual injunction onlv, rvhereas, respondent No.1 in
C.M.A.
No. 427 of 2024 has filed a suit in O.S. No. g3 of 2007 for
declaration of title and therefore, both the parties ought to
have led evidcnce in support of their. respective cases.
7.
Learned counsel for the appellant contended that in case
there was deficiencv with respect to the evidence led by the
appellan r/ defendan t No.2 in a suit lor declaration of title,
the
same cannot be relied upon bv the respondents herein to
strengthen their case.
8.
Learned coun sel for the appellant submitted that in a
suit for declaration of title, the plaintifl has to stand and fall
on the strength of his own case. Therefore, even in case the
CMA- 427, 438 arld. 460 of 2O2a
evidence is lacking with respect to age of appellant/defendant
No.2 and his claim of purchasing the suit schedule Property
on his own, the evidence with respect to said issue has to be
led by the respondents and the said burden cannot cast upon
the appellanL.
g.
In sum and substance, learned counsel for the appellant
contended that the First Appellate Court ought to have
decided the matter on the basis of evidence that was already
available on record rather than remanding the matter back to
the Trial Court lor adducing additional evidence'
10. In that context, learned counsel for the appellant
referred to the judgments of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the
case of P. Purttshottam Reddg u. M/s' Pratap Steels
Limitedt and J.Balaji Singh u. Diuakar Cole and Others2
to contend that the matter can be remanded back to the Trial
court only in exceptional cases and not otherwise'
I 1. While so, learned counsel for the respondents referred to
the judgment of the Honble Supreme Court in Diuga Exports
a. Shali'rnar Video Company and othersa to contend that
',' 2OO2 AIR (Supreme Court) 77 t
rporz 1a1 ALr (D.N.) (sc)r (D.ts.1
t
120141 16 supreme court cases 194
Ci4,4 427,438
"^d
.f;;f4
the First Appellate court is empo\\:ered to remand the matter
for fresh disposal on mer.its rvhene'er necessarv under Order
XLI Rule 24 ol rlre CpC.
12. In the instant case, there is no issue about whether or
not the First Appellate Court is cmpor.r,ered to remand the
matter rathcr the issue is whether or not remand is proper.
As per the record. the evidence has been led by both
respectir.e parties and the Trial Court has passed the
judgment and decree on merits in both the suits. Further,
u,hen the appeals came up before the First Appeltate Court,
neither of thc parties e r.i.ced an_v interest to rcad additionar
evidence.
13. In the circumslances, the First Appellate Court ideally
ought to have drsposed of the appeals u-ith the evidence that
was alreadv available on record. Even in case, the First
Appellate Court deemed that on cer[ain issues the evidence
is
not sufficient or lacking r'r,hen it is not the case of the either
of
the parties to give an opportunity for leading cvtdence, there
is
no need for remanding the matter and that the First
co;Lld have been disposed of on merits.
Appeals
RY,J
CMA_ 427, a38 and 460 oI2024
14. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the
considered opinion that there were no grounds for remanding
and in fact, the remand ',vould give an additiona,l opportunity
to the respondents to flll in lacuna in evidence to the prejudice
of the appellant. Therefore, the impugned judgments passed
by the First Appellate Court are liable to be set aside
15. Accordingly, these Civil Miscellaneous Appeals are
allowed. The judgments and decrees dated 23.01.2024 passed
in A.S. Nos. 1, 2 and 3 ol-2015 by the learned III Additional
District and Sessions Judge at Sanga Reddy, are set aside
with a direction to dispose of the same on merits with the
evidence that is already available on record by permitting both
the parties to argue on all the issues. There shall be no order
as to costs
Miscellaneous petitions, if any pending, shall stand
closed.
Sd/. T.KRISHNA KUMAR
OINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
CTION OFFICER
To
1. The lll Additional District & Sessions Judge at Sanga Reddy,
Sangareddy District.
2. The Principal Junior Civil Judge, Sangareddy, Sangareddy District.
3. One CC to SRl. C. M. R. VELU, Advocate TOPUCI
tl. One CC to SRl. P. VENKAT REDDY, Advocate [OPUC]
5. Two CD Copies
kul
I
HIGH COURT
DATED:2210112026
COMMON JUDGMENT
THE S fa
(
C.M.A. Nos. 427 4 38 and 460 OF 2024
O
I
t'4Afl 2020
*
sPATC
ALLOWING THE ALL CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEALS
g)
\L
P
z
c)
\
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review