Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/26
GAHC010216322025
2026:GAU-AS:14268
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5639/2025
JUHISREE HAZARIKA AND ORS
AGE -35
D/O-MR .PRODIP HAZARIKA
VILLAGE- KENDUGURI
PO-SENGELIGAON
PS- JORHAT, DIST-JORHAT
PIN - 785010
TET ROLL NO- 300448
2: HIMASHREE KASHYAP
AGE 26
D/O - PABITRA DEVA SARMAH
VILLAGE- DATALPARA NATUNBASTI
PO- FATASHIL (AMBARI)
PS- FATASHIL (AMBARI)
DIST- KAMRUP METRO
PIN- 781025
3: PRANAB KHATIORA
AGE-30
S/O - GOBINDA KHATIORA
VILL- HATIBANDHIA
PO- BAKARI DOLONI
PS- HELEM
DIST- BISWANATH
PIN- 784172
TET ROLL NO 902048
4: JADUMONI BORAH
AGE- - 28
S/O - - BUPRAM BORAH
VILL- - ABHAYAPURIA GAON
PO- - BHAKATIDUAR
PS- - JENGRAIMUKH
Page No.# 2/26
DIST- - MAJULI
PIN- - 785110
TET ROLL NO - - 301655
5: ELIMA REHAN
.
D/O- MUMREZ ALI
AGE-28
VILLP.O- NAKUCHI PATHAR
DISTRICT - BAJALI
PIN-781352
TET ROLL NO-804724
6: . KHANDAKAR ROKIBUL ISLAM
S/O KHANDAKAR AMJAD ALI
AGE 32
VILL- NAMBERPARA PART 3
P.O- NAMBERPARA
P.S ABHAYAPURI
DISTRICT BONGAIGAON
PIN- 783392
TET ROLL NO- 802274
7: RIMASHREE CHOUDHURY
AGE - 27
D/O - PHANIDHAR CHOUDHURY
VILLAGE - KARAKUCHI
PO - SARTHEBARI
PS - SARTHEBARI
DIST - BARPETA
PIN - 781307
TET ROLL NO- 801429
8: ANOWAR HUSSAIN
AGE-32
S/O - ABDUL HALIM
VILLAGE -TUPAMARI
P.O -TUPAMARI
P.S- NAGARBERA
DIST . KAMRUP R
PIN - 781127
TET ROLL NO - 505207
9: RANJAN KALITA
.
AGE-31
S/O- GIRIDHAR KALITA
VILL- KUHIYAR BARI
Page No.# 3/26
P.O- CHAMAHIYA ATI
P.S- JENGRAIMUKH
DIST- MAJULI
PIN- 785105
TET ROLL NO- 301801
10: ZAKARIA HASSAN BARBHUIYA
AGE -30
S/O-ABDUL KADIR BARBHUIYA
VILLAGE- SERALIPUR
PO- TANTOO
PS- LALA
DIST- HAILAKANDI
PIN- 788163
TET ROLL NO-101984
11: ISMAIL HOQUE CHOWDHURY
AGE- 28
S/O- MOYNUL HOQUE CHOWDHURY
VILLAGE- TAPAR PATHAR
PO- TAPAR PATHAR
PS- GOROIMARI
DIST- KAMRUP
PIN- 781137
TET ROLL NO- 505734
12: ABHISHEK CHANGKAKOTY
AGE- - 29
S/O - - RAMESH CHANGKAKOTY
TOWN- - SIVASAGAR
PO- - SIVASAGAR
PS- - SIVASAGAR
DIST- - SIVASAGAR
PIN- - 785640
TET ROLL NO - - 301481
13: SILPISIKHA SAIKIA
AGE - 29
D/O - ATUL SAIKIA
VILLAGE - BORSUTAR GAON
PO - BARANGABARI
PS - HALEM
DIST - BISWANATH
PIN - 784172
TET ROLL NO- 904291
14: PANKAJ SARMAH
AGE- 35
Page No.# 4/26
S/O- NIPEN SARMAH
VILL- BALIPUKHURI
PO- BURIGANG
PS- GINGIA
DIST- BISWANATH
PIN- 784176
TET ROLL NO. - 904477
15: NAZRIN SULTANA AHMED
AGE - 33
D/O- NAZIMUDDIN AHMED
VILLAGE- BARKUMARPARA
PO- PATHARIGHAT
PS- SIPAJHAR
DIST- DARRANG
PIN- 784144
TET ROLL NO- 400377
16: LUCKY DEVI
AGE- 31
D/O- TARA KANTA NATH
VILL- BAM BESSERIA
PO- BESSERIA
PS- TEZPUR
DIST- SONITPUR
PIN- 784150
TET ROLL NO. - 900687
17: SAMSUN NEHAR BEGUM
.
AGE -30 YRS
D/O- ABDUS SALAM SARKAR
VILL- KISMAT HASDAHA PT 4
P.O- KISMAT HASDAHA
P.S- DHUBRI
DIST -DHUBRI (ASSAM)
PIN - 783334
TET ROLL NO -601634
18: NAJMIN BEGUM
AGE -31
D/O- GIYASUDDIN AHMED
VILLAGE- MELAMORA
PO- MELAMORA
PS- KAMARGAON
DIST- GOLAGHAT
PIN- 785702
TET ROLL NO -300740
Page No.# 5/26
19: MOAZZAM AKRAM MOZUMDER
AGE 37
S/O GIAS UDDIN MAZUMDER
VILLAGE- BOWARGHAT PART 2
P.O BOWARGHAT
P.S HAILAKANDI
DIST HAILKANDI
PIN 788164
TET ROLL NO 101704
20: PRIYANKA HALDAR
AGE- 27
D/O - RABINDRA HALDAR
VILL- BECHAMARI DUBA
P. O- PHALIHAMARI PATHER
P. S- BHURAGAON
DIST- MORIGAON(ASSAM)
PIN- 782127
TET ROLL NO- 503558
21: MAMPI DEB ROY
AGE - - 28 YEARS
D/O - - LT MAKHAN DEB ROY
VILLAGE- - AMRAGHAT
PO- - DARMIKHAL
PS- - KACHUDARAM
DIST- - CACHAR
PIN- - 788116
TET ROLL NO- - 100516
22: KAIDUR RAHMAN LASKAR
AGE 35
S/O - JALAL UDDIN LASKAR
VILLAGE - RONGPUR PART 4
PO - SAHABAD
PS - KATLICHERRA
DIST - HAILAKANDI
PIN - 78163
TET ROLL NO - 101593
23: DIPSIKHA SAIKIA
AGE - 32
W/O - BABAMONI GOGOI
VILLAGE - GHILADHARIMUKH
P.O - TEWARIPAL
P.S - SOOTEA
DIST - BISWANATH
Page No.# 6/26
PIN - 784175
TET ROLL NO - 90034
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT
OF ASSAM, EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (SECONDARY), DISPUR,
GUWAHATI -781006
2:THE SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (SECONDARY) DISPUR
GUWAHATI 781006
3:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI 1
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR S BORTHAKUR, MR. D GOGOI
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, SEC. EDU.,
Linked Case : WP(C)/5370/2025
GAYATRI BORPATRA AND ORS
D/O- AKHIL BORPATRA
VILL/ TOWN- GUWAHATI
BELTOLA
P.O- BELTOLA
P.S.- HATIGAON
DIST- KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
PIN- 781028.
TET ROLL NO 501346
2: SAROJINI BARUAH
AGE- 36
D/O- LATE GAJEN BARUAH
VILL/ TOWN- GUWAHATI
BELTOLA
P.O- BELTOLA
P.S.- HATIGAON
DIST- KAMRUP(M)
Page No.# 7/26
ASSAM
PIN- 781028
TET ROLL NO- 504333.
3: RITIMA BARUAH
AGE-25
D/O- DILIP BARUAH
VILL/ TOWN- GHAGUA
P.O- DIGARU
P.S.- SONAPUR
DIST- KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
PIN- 782401
4: JULIANA AHMED
AGE- 36
D/O- AFTABUDDIN AHMED
VILL/ TOWN- GUWAHATI
P.O- SILPHUKURI
P.S.- CHANDMARI
DIST- KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
PIN- 781003
TET ROLL NO- 507817.
5: BORNALI ROY
AGE-29
D/O- SUSHIL CH. ROY
VILL/ TOWN- PADMABIL
P.O- GOSSAIGAON
P.S.- GOSSAIGAON
DIST- KOKRAJHAR
ASSAM
PIN- 783360
TET ROLL NO- 600356
6: BEGUM TASLIMA YASMIN
AGE- 31
D/O- HAZRAT ALI TALUKDAR
VILL/ TOWN- SINGIMARI PT-I
P.O- TISTARPAR
P.S.- DHUBRI
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783324
TET ROLL NO- 600271
7: SIMANTA GOGOI
Page No.# 8/26
AGE-32
S/O- SUBUDH GOGOI
VILL/ TOWN- BIHUBOR
P.O- BIHUBOR
P.S.- BIHUBOR
DIST- SIVASAGAR
ASSAM
PIN- 785687
TET ROLL NO- 201886
8: PUJA SHARMA
AGE-29
D/O- LATE RUDAL SHARMA
VILL/ TOWN- BARAPUJIA
NIZMIKARGAON
P.O- BARAPUJIA
P.S.- MIKIRBHETA
DIST- MORIGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782103
TET ROLL NO- 503644
9: RUMI GOGOI
AGE- 25
D/O- MR. BIMAL GOGOI
VILL/ TOWN- NO2 PAHUKHUWA
P.O- MACHKHOWA
P.S.- DHEMAJI
DIST- DHEMAJI
ASSAM
PIN- 787057
TET ROLL NO- 202624
10: MD YEAHYEA ALOM
AGE- 26
S/O- MD SIRAJ UDDIN
VILL/ TOWN- UTTAR BADEJAMA
P.O- BARAIGRAM
P.S.- PATHARKANDI
DIST- SRIBHUMI (KARIMGANJ)
ASSAM
PIN- 788723
TET ROLL NO- 103489.
11: HIRAK JYOTI SAIKIA
AGE-26
S/O- MRIDUL KR. SAIKIA
VILL/ TOWN- MAJARATI
Page No.# 9/26
P.O- MAJARATI
P.S.- SADAR
DIST-NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782002
TET ROLL NO- 903373.
12: ARIFUL ISLAM
AGE- 26
S/O- GAMIRUDDIN AHMED
VILL/ TOWN- RANGIA WARD NO.10
P.O- RANGIA
P.S.- RANGIA
DIST-KAMRUP
ASSAM
PIN- 781354
TET ROLL NO- 801922.
13: PINKI BARMAN
AGE- 28
D/O- ARJUN CH. BARMAN
VILL/ TOWN- AMGURI
P.O- NORTH BOITAMARI
P.S.- ABHAYAPURI
DIST-BONGAIGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 783380
TET ROLL NO- 601299
14: SRUTIMA BHARALI
AGE- 28
D/O- DILIP BHARALI
VILL/ TOWN- ISSAPURHATI
BARPETA
P.O- BARPETA
P.S.- BARPETA
DIST-BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 781301
TET ROLL NO- 801695.
15: SUSHMITA GOGOI
AGE- 28
D/O- DILIP KR GOGOI
VILL/ TOWN- LONGPOTIA
P.O- LONGPOTIA
P.S.- SONARI
Page No.# 10/26
DIST-CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
PIN- 785692
TET ROLL NO- 201430.
16: BIKASHITA GOGOI
AGE- 27
D/O- BOLIN GOGOI
VILL/ TOWN- JUTULONI GAON
P.O- LONGPOTIA
P.S.- SONARI
DIST-CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
PIN- 785692
TET ROLL NO- 202019
17: NANDITA DAS
AGE- 28
D/O- KALYAN KR. DAS
VILL/ TOWN- MOUTUPURI
P.O- HOWLY
P.S.- HOWLY
DIST-BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 781316
TET ROLL NO- 801076.
18: MD YASIN ALI
AGE- 35
S/O- HUSSAIN ALI
VILL/ TOWN- LAOGAON
SOLMARI
P.O- SOLMARI
P.S.- SADAR
DIST-NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN- 782002
TET ROLL NO- 903530.
19: MERI DUTTA
AGE- 28
D/O- DHIREN DUTTA
VILL/ TOWN- DAHUDI
P.O- SOLMARA
P.S.- BELSOR
DIST-NALBARI
ASSAM
Page No.# 11/26
PIN- 781338
TET ROLL NO- 803292.
20: MAMPI BASAK
AGE-29
D/O- GANESH BASAK
VILL/ TOWN- DAKUAPARA
P.O- BOKO
P.S.- BOKO
DIST- KAMRUP(R)
ASSAM
PIN- 781123
TET ROLL NO- 400298
21: SAJAHAN ALI
AGE- 28
S/O- MALEK ALI
VILL/ TOWN- TALOWA GAON
P.O- SRINAGAR
P.S.- TAMARHAT
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783332
TET ROLL NO- 605514.
22: TUTUMONI DUWARI
AGE- 27
D/O- JOGASAWER DUWARI
VILL/ TOWN- DICHAW GAON
CHARAIDEO
P.O- DICHAW- BOTUA
P.S.- MORANHAT
DIST- CHARAIDEO
ASSAM
PIN- 785670
TET ROLL NO- 504943.
23: SIMI AKHTARA
AGE- 28
D/O- AZIZUL HAQUE
VILL/ TOWN- MADULIJHAR
P.O- CHAKCHAKA BAZAR
P.S.- SORBHOG
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN- 781317
TET ROLL NO- 504540.
Page No.# 12/26
24: MARUFATUL AZIZ AKAND
AGE- 24
D/O- MD ABDUL AZIZ AKAND
VILL/ TOWN- POKALAGI
P.O- KAMANDANGA
P.S.- TAMARHAT
DIST- DHUBRI
ASSAM
PIN- 783332
TET ROLL NO- 603817.
25: MINAL HUDA
AGE- 29
S/O- EUSOB ALI
VILL/ TOWN- SUTARPARA CHAR
P.O- SUTARPARA
P.S.- MATIA
DIST- GOALPARA
ASSAM
PIN- 783125
TET ROLL NO- 506062.
26: RAJASHREE BORAH
AGED ABOUT 28 YEARS
C/O- SURAJIT SAIKIA
R/O- BAREGHAR BHAKAT GAON
P.O.- BONAI
P.S.- TEOK
DIST- JORHAT
ASSAM
PIN- 785683
TET ROLL NO. 301066
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REP BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION DEPTT SECONDARY DISPUR GUWAHATI 6
2:THE SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT (SECONDARY) DISPUR
GUWAHATI 781006
3:THE DIRECOTR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI 19
-----------Advocate for : MR. D GOGOI
Page No.# 13/26
Advocate for : SC
SEC. EDU. appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
Linked Case : WP(C)/5366/2025
DORATHI PHUKAN AND ORS
W/O NAVAKAMAL SONOWAL VILL KAKODUNGA MUKTINAGAR
RAIDANGJURI PO RAIDANGJURI PS BORHOLLA DIST JORHAT PIN 785631
TET ROLL NO. 302041
2: SIMPI NATH
D/O DIMBESWAR NATH VILL BALICHAPARI NATH GAON PO MADHUPUR
PS GARAMUR DIST MAJULI PIN 785104 TET ROLL NO. 302210
3: RIMJIM BORAH
D/O PROMOD BORAH VILL SOLAGURI PO SOLAGURI PS JAMUGURIHAT
DIST SONITPUR PIN 784180 TET ROLL NO. 902923
4: TRISHNA GOGOI
D/O LT TARUN GOGOI VILL CHANG CHAKI PO DAKHIN CHANGCHAKI PS
KAMRUP DIST NAGAON PIN 782426 TET ROLL NO. 509580
5: PARAG JYOTI GOGOI
S/O BAKUL GOGOI VILL KACHARIGAON KATHIATOLI PO KATHIATOLI PS
KAMRUP DIST NAGAON PIN 782427 TET ROLL NO. 400829
6: NIRMALI GOGOI
D/O BIREN GOGOI VILL WARD NO. 5 BORGOHAIN GAON PO AND PS NORTH
LAKHIMPUR DIST LAKHIMPUR PIN 787001 TET ROLL NO. 701568
7: NIHARIKA CHOUDHURY
D/O SASHADHAR CHOUDHURY VILL ATHGAON PO HINGULEE PS
KAMALPUR DIST KAMRUP RURAL PN 781380 TET ROLL NO. 401231
8: IRIN CHUTIA
D/O LT SARBANANDA CHUTIA VILL AND PO SISSIBORGAON PS
SILAPATHAR DIST DHEMAJI PIN 787110 TET ROLL NO. 202150
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
REP BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
EDUCATION DEPTT SECONDARY DISPUR GUWAHATI 6
2:THE SECRETARY
TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM EDUCATION DEPTT SECONDARY DISPUR
GUWAHATI 781006
Page No.# 14/26
3:THE DIRECTOR OF SECONDARY EDUCATION
KAHILIPARA GUWAHATI 781019
-----------Advocate for : MR S BORTHAKUR
Advocate for : SC
SEC. EDU. appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND ORS
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 24.09.2026
Heard Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners.
Also heard Mr. P P Dutta, Learned Standing Counsel, Dept. of
Elementary Education, Assam.
2.
As the issues arising in the above noted Writ Petitions are
one and the same, although recruitment involved being for different
posts, i.e. Post Graduate Teacher and Graduate Teacher, with the
consent of the Parties, the Writ Petitions were heard analogously and
are being disposed of vide the present common order.
3.
The Petitioners, by way of instituting the above noted Writ
Petitions, have raised a grievance with regard to non-compliance by
the Respondent authorities of the condition set-out in Clause 2(f) of
the advertisement dated 26.12.2023, to the effect that after the
publication of the initial merit list, further vacancies from the same
recruitment process, being available, a further merit list was not
Page No.# 15/26
published.
4.
As projected by the Petitioners in the above noted Writ
Petitions, vide advertisements dated 26.12.2023, the Director of
Secondary Education, Assam, initiated separate recruitment exercise
for filling up of vacant posts of Post-Graduate Teachers, as well as
Graduate Teachers, available in different provincialised Secondary
Schools of the State. In terms of the advertisements so published,
1424 (One Thousand Four Hundred and Twenty-Four) posts of
Post Graduate Teachers was advertised while 7249 (Seven Thousand
Two Hundred and Forty-Nine) posts of Graduate Teachers, came to be
advertised.
4.1
In the advertisements dated 26.12.2023, in Clause 2(f), it
was stipulated that in the event, after publication of the initial merit
list, any post, amongst the advertised posts, remains vacant, the
Respondent authorities shall publish 2 (two) further merit lists, for
recruitment against the posts, so advertised. The manner of
recruitment was again further clarified by way of issuance of
Addendums, both dated 16.10.2024, wherein, it was stated that the
initial merit list would be prepared from a draft merit list, so prepared,
incorporating candidates, twice the number of vacancies advertised,
on the basis of the merit obtained by the candidates in the selection
Page No.# 16/26
process. The final merit list to be published was to be so published by
maintaining the ratio of 1:1, i.e. for 1 (one) post, 1 (one) candidate.
4.2
The Petitioners participated in the selection process,
however, their names were not incorporated in the initial merit list
published.
4.3
The Petitioners, on coming to learn that out of the posts
advertised, vide the advertisements dated 26.12.2023, many posts
remained vacant, the Petitioners approached the authorities for
invoking of the provisions of Clause 2(f) of the advertisements dated
26.12.2023. However, the prayers made by the Petitioners before the
Respondent authorities not being considered, the Petitioners have
instituted the present Writ Petition.
5.
Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners,
in the above noted Writ Petitions, submits that the Petitioners fulfilled
all the requisite eligibility criteria, as mandated in the respective
advertisements, issued towards recruitment of eligible persons as
either Post Graduate Teachers or Graduate Teachers. However, their
names were not incorporated in the initial merit list published, in
pursuance
to
the
selection
process
initiated,
vide
the
said
advertisements dated 26.12.2023. Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioners, submits that in terms of the disclosure
Page No.# 17/26
made by the Director of Secondary Education, Assam, in the affidavit
filed in the matter, out of the 1424 (One Thousand Four Hundred and
Twenty-Four) posts of Post Graduate Teachers advertised, vide the
advertisements dated 26.12.2023, only 1265 (One Thousand Two
Hundred and Sixty-Five) posts were filled up and the remaining posts
are still lying vacant. He further submits that out of the 7249 (Seven
Thousand Two Hundred and Forty-Nine) posts of Graduate Teachers,
so advertised, vide advertisement dated 26.12.2023, the Respondents
have projected that only 6240 (Six Thousand Two Hundred and Forty)
posts were so filled up and the remaining posts continued to remain
vacant.
5.1
Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for the Petitioners
submits that a perusal of the provisions of Clause 2(f) would go to
reveal that the Respondent authorities had undertaken to publish
further merit lists in the event, all the posts advertised, vide the
advertisements dated 26.12.2023, are not filled up from the initial
merit list so published. Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for
the Petitioners submit that in terms of the provisions of Assam Fiscal
Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2005, a select list is to be
published only to the extent of the posts available. He submits that
the earlier system of publication of select list, containing names of
Page No.# 18/26
candidates, double the number of the vacancies, has been done away
with. Accordingly, Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners submits that a recruitment process being initiated for a
determined number of vacancies, the Respondent authorities had in
the provisions of Clause 2(f) of the advertisements in question,
incorporated a stipulation, with regard to the publication of further
merit list in the event, if it is so warranted.
5.2
Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel for the
Petitioners, further submits that the contention of the Petitioners that
all the advertised vacant posts were not filled up, has not been denied
by the Respondent authorities. Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior
Counsel for the Petitioners, by referring to the Addendums issued in
the matter on 16.10.2024, has submitted that the provisions of Clause
5(xi) and Clause 5(xii), as the case may be, thereof, would have no
application, with regard to the publication of further merit list, as setout in Clause 2(f) of the advertisements in question, inasmuch as, the
provisions of Clause 5(xi) and Clause 5(xii), as the case may be, of
the Addendums, only pertains to the manner of preparation of merit
list and in no manner had amended the provisions of Clause 2(f), as
originally contained in the advertisements in question. It is submitted
that in the Addendum, issued in respect of recruitment against posts
Page No.# 19/26
of Graduate Teachers, the prescription, with regard to preparation of
select list, is set out in the provisions of Clause 5(xi), while in the
Addendum issued with regard to the recruitment against the post of
Post Graduate Teachers, the said prescription is set out in the
provisions of Clause 5(xii). However, the context of both the said
clauses are verbatim.
5.3
Accordingly, Mr. S Borthakur, Learned Senior Counsel
for the Petitioners submits that the Respondent authorities are
required to be directed to comply with the provisions of Clause 2(f) of
the advertisements in question and in the event, the Petitioners are
found to be placed within the merit position mandating incorporation
of their names in the merit list, a fresh merit list be published to the
extent of the vacancies available and the Petitioners, if so
incorporated, therein, be appointed against the posts for which they
are so selected.
6.
Mr. P P Dutta, Learned Standing Counsel, Dept. of Secondary
Education, Assam, submits that the stipulations, as made in Clause
2(f) of the advertisements dated 26.12.2023, to the effect that further
merit list would be published in the event, after publication of the
initial merit list, in the event, all the advertised posts are not filled up,
was amended by the provisions of Clause 5(xi) and 5(xii) of the
Page No.# 20/26
Addendums, dated 16.10.2024, as the case may be. He submits that
the Respondent authorities, now having taken recourse to preparation
of a draft merit list, incorporating, therein, candidates, twice the
number of vacancies available and from such draft merit list, the merit
list being prepared by maintaining the ratio of 1:1, with regard to the
number of posts and the candidates concerned, there is no
requirement for publication of a further merit list.
6.1
Mr. P P Dutta, Learned Standing Counsel, Dept. of
Elementary Education, Assam has submitted that, in the event posts
have remained vacant after the publication of the initial merit list and
appointment of the candidates, therefrom, the said vacancies would
now be mandated to be filled up by way of a regular selection
process.
7.
I have heard the Learned Counsel for the Parties and
perused the materials available on record.
8.
The issue arising in the present proceedings, being with
regard to the purport of the provisions of Clause 2(f) of, the
advertisements dated 26.12.2023, the provisions, thereof, being
relevant, the same is extracted, hereinbelow :
“(f) In case, any post remains vacant after publication of the first
Merit List as per the ratio of 1: 1, then maximum 2 (two) more
numbers of Merit List will be published.”
Page No.# 21/26
9.
A perusal of the said provisions would go to reveal that the
authority, issuing the advertisements, had stipulated that in case any
post, amongst the advertised posts, remains vacant after publication
of the initial merit list, by following the ratio of 1:1, then maximum 2
(two) more merit lists would be permissible to be published for the
purpose of filling up all the posts of Post Graduate Teacher and
Graduate Teacher, that were put up for recruitment. This Court finds
that the said provision was so incorporated with a view to ensure that
the selection process so instituted, being for recruitment of teachers
and there being a necessity for having, adequate number of teachers
occupying posts in the Schools concerned and also considering the
cost factor involved in undertaking a process of recruitment, the
Respondent authorities had incorporated the provisions of Clause 2(f)
in the advertisement.
10.
As noticed hereinabove, prior to the coming into force of the
Assam Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act, 2005, select
lists were being published in the State for the posts so advertised,
twice the number of posts available. However, with the coming into
force of the Assam Fiscal Responsibility and Budget Management Act,
2005, the said procedure was given a go bye and select lists were
being published only to the extent of the posts available after
Page No.# 22/26
providing, therein, the reservation mandated for various Reserved
Communities, as well as, for persons with disability etc. Accordingly, in
such a situation, it can be visualized that in the event the selected
candidates does not join against the posts, in question, the
expenditure incurred for the recruitment purpose would go to waste
and accordingly, the Respondent authorities were within their rights to
incorporate the provision as contained in Clause 2(f) in the
advertisements in question.
11.
This Court, further, from the materials brought on record,
more particularly, the affidavit filed by the Respondents, finds that all
the posts advertised, vide the advertisements in question, were not
filled up and there are still posts lying vacant out of the said
recruitment exercise, both in the category of Post Graduate Teacher
as well as Graduate Teacher. The respondents, however, had not
followed the prescription made in Clause 2(f) of the advertisements
and have sought to justify the same by referring to the provisions of
Clause 5(xi) and Clause 5(xii) of the Addendums dated 16.10.2024, as
the case may be, issued in respect of all the advertisements in
question. Provisions of Clause 5(xi) and 5(xii) being relevant, the
same is extracted, hereinbelow :
(For Graduate Teachers)
“5.
Additional Information: -
Page No.# 23/26
…………………..
…………………..
xi. For verification of qualification and other particulars of the
candidates, a draft merit list will be published with a ratio of 2
candidates against one vacancy. Thereafter, after verification, a final
merit list will be prepared from the draft merit list as per the
outcome of the verification report and as per the merit in the draft
merit list in the ratio of 1:1.”
(For Post Graduate Teachers)
“5.
Additional Information: -
…………………..
…………………..
xii. For verification of qualification and other particulars of the
candidates, a draft merit list will be published with a ratio of 2
candidates against one vacancy. Thereafter, after verification, a final
merit list will be prepared from the draft merit list as per the
outcome of the verification report and as per the merit in the draft
merit list in the ratio of 1:1.”
12.
This Court would note that the provisions with regard to
preparation of merit list, in respect of the process of recruitment
initiated for Graduate Teachers, was incorporated in Clause 5(xi) of
the Addendum issued, while for the process of recruitment initiated
for Post Graduate Teacher, similar provision was incorporated in
Clause 5(xii) of the Addendum issued.
13.
A perusal of the provisions of Clause 5(xi) or Clause 5(xii),
as the case may be, would go to reveal that, therein, the manner of
preparation of the merit list is being provided for. The provisions
mandate that the purpose of verification of the qualification and other
particulars of a candidate, a draft merit list would be published in a
ratio of 2:1, i.e. 2 (two) candidates against 1(one) vacant post. In
other words, the draft merit list would be published incorporating,
Page No.# 24/26
therein, candidates, twice the number of vacancies available. It
further stipulates that after verification of the qualification and other
particulars of a candidate, a final merit list would be prepared from
the draft merit list, by applying the ratio of 1:1, i.e. 1 (one) candidate
against 1 (one) post.
14.
This Court on a perusal of the provisions of Clause 5(xi) and
Clause 5(xii) of the Addendums dated 16.10.2024, as the case may
be, does not find the same, in any manner, has superseded the
provisions of Clause 2(f) of the advertisements in question. This court
finds that in the provisions of Clause 5(xii), only the manner of
preparation of a final merit list, has been set-out and the same, in no
manner, amends the provisions of Clause 2(f).
15.
Accordingly, this Court is of the considered view that the
provisions of Clause 2(f), having not been expressly amended and/or
deleted from the provisions of the advertisements in question, the
same continues to hold the field and the Respondents are bound to
comply with the said stipulation, in the event, all the posts so put up,
vide advertisements dated 26.12.2023 are not filled up.
16.
Accordingly, in view of the above conclusions drawn by this
Court, this Court directs the Director of Secondary Education, Assam,
to examine as to whether there are posts, from amongst the
Page No.# 25/26
advertised posts, lying vacant after the appointments were effected
from the initial merit list published in pursuance to the advertisements
in question and in the event it is found that there are vacant posts
available, out of the posts, so advertised, vide the advertisements in
question, the Respondents shall proceed to comply the provisions of
Clause 2(f) of the advertisements in question and prepare a further
merit list, strictly in accordance with the provisions of Clause 5(xi) and
Clause 5(xii) of the Addendums dated 16.10.2024, as the case may
be, issued in pursuance to the said advertisements.
17.
The Petitioners, in the above noted Writ Petitions, by
reckoning the merit position obtained by them in the selection held, if
found eligible to be included, in the further merit lists to be published
against the post of Post Graduate Teacher or Graduate Teacher, as
applied for by them, the Petitioners be appointed against the post
they are so selected.
18.
The Director of Secondary Education, Assam, shall for the
purpose of complying with the directions passed, hereinabove, initiate
the required exercise and conclude the same within the period of 1
(one) month, from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order,
along with individual representations from the Petitioners, in the
above noted Writ Petitions.
Page No.# 26/26
19.
With the above observations and directions, the above noted
Writ
Petitions,
WP(C)/5639/2025,
WP(C)/5366/2025
WP(C)/5370/2025, stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
and
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review