Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
:1:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 7933 OF 2022
PETITIONER:
JOSEPH JACOB
AGED 87 YEARS
S/O. LATE M. P. JOSEPH, E.H.T.LINE CONTRACTOR,
MUNDACKAL HOUSE, PINIDIMANA P. O., KOTHAMANGALAM 686692.
BY ADVS.
REBIN VINCENT GRALAN
DINESH G WARRIER(K/904/2016)
VIMAL VIJAY(K/000214/2018)
RESPONDENT/S:
THE CHAIRMAN & MANAGING DIRECTOR
KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD, VYDYUTHI BHAVAN,
PATTOM P. O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004.
THE CHIEF ENGINEER
(TRANSMISSION SOUTH), K.S.E.B., VYDYUTHI BHAVAN,
PATTOM P. O., THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695004.
BY ADVS. AJIT JOY
ANEESH JAMES(K/214-D/2008)
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
26.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28197
:2:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
---
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -W.P.(C) No.7933 of 2022
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 26th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The
above
proceedings
and
writ
petition
seeking
a
is
filed
challenging
consequential
direction
Ext.P15
to
the
respondents to release a sum of Rs.45,93,750/- being the revision
of rate with future interest @12% from the date of completion of
the work till recovery.
2. The brief facts necessary for the disposal of the writ
petition are as follows:
The petitioner is a contractor of the K.S.E.B, who has been
issued with Ext.P1 work order for the construction and drawing of
220 KV D.C line from Sabarigiri to Edamon. The said work was
originally awarded to another contractor, but due to the dispute
between the contractor and K.S.E.B., the work was abandoned. The
petitioner submits that the said line passes through the dense
forest of Western Ghats and for drawing of the line, the workers
had to work in extreme adverse conditions. Though clause 28 of
2025:KER:28197
:3:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
Ext.P1 mandates that no revision of rates will be allowed on any
account, the same was not accepted by the petitioner. Thereupon
he addressed to the respondent that without the revision of rates
he is not prepared to take up the work. In response to his letter,
Ext.P2 communication was issued wherein the Board has agreed
that rates will be firm during the contract period of 15 months from
the date of execution of the agreement and if the work is not
completed
within
this
period
solely
due
to
the
omissions
/commissions on the part of the Board, the petitioner is free to open
the issue after the contract period. After completion of the work
with much difficulty, the petitioner submitted the final bill, which
of course exceeded the original estimate. Therefore, some dispute
arose with regard to the fixation of quantum of amount due to the
petitioner. The respondents slept over his final bill for more than 8
years and aggrieved by the same the petitioner has approached
this Court filing W.P.(C)No.12625/2004 and this Court directed the
Board to consider the representation submitted by the petitioner
and thereafter the said representation was disposed of as per
Ext.P4 wherein it is decided as follows:
“The entire matter was placed before the Full Board and as
2025:KER:28197
:4:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
per the direction of the Full Board, negotiation was made
with the contractor by the Chief Engineer (TransmissionSouth) and then by Member (Transmission). An amount of
Rs.13.19
Lakhs
which
includes
retention
is
pending
payment to the contractor. Since the work is entrusted with
rate contract basis, claim of the contractor for revision of
rate is not agreeable. The contractor has refused to come
down from his claims for rate revision and requested to
release the payment for the earth filling at Location. No.5.
Considering the matter in detail, the Board decided to
accept the completion report amounting to Rs.1,83,51,602/(Rupees One Crore Eighty Three Lakhs Fifty One Thousand
Six Hundred and Two only) in favour of Sri.Joseph Jacob
towards the work of construction of 220 KV DC line from
Sabarigiri – Edamon provided the overall claims are limited
to the estimate as per completion report subject to
verification of the measurement(and subject to the condition
that no escalation of rates will be allowed over and above
the agreed rate as per the contract.
The Board further orders that final payment and
retention along with the amount withheld to the contractor,
Sri. Joseph Jacob towards the above work be released. The
actual expenditure incurred by the contractor for filling the
revetment at Location No.5 of the line will be worked out
and released.”
Being not satisfied with Ext.P4, Ext.P5 request was made by the
petitioner, which was disposed of as per Ext.P6 and the relevant
part of which reads as follows:
2025:KER:28197
:5:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
“8. Earlier, Board had entrusted the then Member
(Transmission) to conduct a personal hearing with Sri.
Joseph Jacob for working out a package for settlement of
the claims of the contractor. Accordingly, a meeting was
conducted with the contractor on 17.07.2006. In the
meeting, the contractor has raised a claim of Rs. 5 Lakh for
the subject item among other things.
9. Therefore in a way to settle the matter, further
negotiation was conducted by the Board with the contractor
on 16.02.2011 to explore the possibility of reducing his
claim of Rs.5 Lakh for the item. Accordingly, the contractor
vide
his
letter
dated
18.02.2011
has
expressed
his
willingness to reduce his claim for the items to Rs.4 Lakh.
10. The negotiated amount of Rs.4 lakh is found to be
the lowest when considering the various options. The
estimate amount for the item as per Schedule of Rates 1992
comes to Rs.2,35,703/-.
11. Therefore, in pursuance of the Board Order dated
13.07.2007, sanction is hereby accorded for effecting
payment for the item of filling the revetment at Location
No.5 of the 220 KV DC Sabarigiri-Edamon line as per the
estimate rate of 1992 Schedule of Rates for the executed
quantities
in
addition
to
Rs.1,64,297/-
towards
compensation for the undue delay in effecting the payment
limiting the expenditure to Rs.4 Laks (Rupees Four Lakh
only)
The Chief Engineer (Transmission-South) shall take
further necessary action.”
Since the petitioner has raised a grievance that the Board has not
2025:KER:28197
:6:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
addressed his genuine demand for revision of rates, the petitioner
negotiated with the Board regarding the payment of the amount,
and accepted that the matter could be settled for an amount of
Rs.45,93,750/-. The petitioner would submit that by Ext.P7 order,
the Board has recommended the rate revision of 35%. The
petitioner would also submit that as per Ext.P8 and P9 the
respondents have admitted the delay on their part in the
completion of the work. As the claim was not settled by the Board,
the
petitioner
again
approached
this
Court
filing
W.P.
(C)No.20998/2011, which was disposed of as per Ext.P10 and the
Board without affording an opportunity of hearing and without
considering the crucial question of revision of rates, rejected the
claim of the petitioner by Ext.P11 order. Ext.P11 order was again
challenged before this Court and as per Ext.P12 this Court has set
aside the order under challenge and directed the respondents to
consider the request of the petitioner and pass orders thereon.
Later by Ext.P13 the claim of the petitioner was rejected and
challenging
the
same
the
petitioner
has
filed
W.P.
(C)No.29950/2016 and this Court by Ext.P14 judgment again
quashed Ext.P13 and directed reconsideration. Thereupon the
2025:KER:28197
:7:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
petitioner was called for a meeting and he submitted all the
evidences in support of the rate revision. Later the claim was
rejected by Ext.P15. It is aggrieved by the same that the present
writ petition has been filed.
3. A
detailed counter affidavit has been filed by the
respondents wherein they have challenged the maintainability of
the writ petition contending that it is a purely a civil dispute arising
out of a contractual relationship between the petitioner and the
respondents covered by Ext.P1 award of work and in matters
involving
adjudication
of
disputed
facts,
same
cannot
be
adjudicated in a writ petition and that the petitioner has to avail
other alternate remedies to adjudicate the disputes. In the counter
affidavit it is admitted that though the date fixed for completion of
work as per agreement was March, 1991, due to various reasons it
was commissioned only during May, 1994. Extensions for the work
was granted to the petitioner up to June 1994 on condition that 'no
revision of rates will be allowed over and above the agreed rates
specified in the contract'. Various reasons have been stated in the
counter affidavit for the delay in completing the work. It is further
submitted that on actual execution of the work, the amount of work
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
:8:
done by the petitioner came to Rs. 1,83,51,602/-, which is 313.6%
over and above the quoted PAC. The completion report for the said
amount was accepted by the Board and the amount was paid to the
petitioner. While deciding to accept the completion report for
Rs.1,83,51,602/-, it was specifically stipulated by the Board that 'no
revision of rates will be allowed over and above the agreed rates
specified in the contract. With respect to the additional work
carried out by the petitioner, an amount of Rs. 2,35,703/- was paid
as per the estimate rate of 1992 SOR, in addition to Rs.1,64,207/towards compensation for the undue delay in effecting the
payment, thereby limiting the total expenditure in this regard to
Rs.4 lakhs. The same was also accepted by the petitioner. It is
thereafter that the petitioner has raised a claim for revision of
rates and claimed an amount to the tune of Rs.75 lakhs.
It is
further submitted that after Ext.P14 judgment, the matter was
considered in detail by the Board and on perusal of the relevant
documents it is revealed that more than 94% of the departmentally
issued materials were transported to the site much ahead of
9/1992, ie., the date of the schedule of rates was revised and only
less than 6% materials is seen transported after 9/1992.
The
2025:KER:28197
:9:
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
transportation of 6% of materials after 9/1992 was not due to any
fault on the part of the Board, but due to the delay on the part of
the contractor in transporting material and due to non-utilization of
the available materials in time by the petitioner. It is also
contended that all clearances for the construction of line were
obtained and communicated well in advance and therefore, there is
absolutely no delay on the part of the Board. The Board has also
taken note of the fact that some additional items of work as well as
some excess quantities were necessitated for the successful
completion of work. The rates for the extra items of work were not
decided
in
the
tender
but
were
mutually
agreed
through
negotiation at the time of execution during the period from 1992 to
1994. As a result, the contract amount was increased to
Rs.1,83,51,602/-
against
the
original
contract
amount
of
Rs.44,41,720/-. Supplementary agreements were executed for the
additional works at mutually agreed rates and the entire amount
due as per the agreed rates has also been paid to the petitioner.
Additionally, an amount of Rs.1,64,297/- was also paid to the
petitioner towards compensation for belated payment. In the light
of the above it is contended that whatever amount due to the
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
: 10 :
petitioner has been paid by the Board and taking into consideration
all the above said aspects, the claim of the petitioner was rejected
as per Ext.P15.
4. The petitioner has not filed any reply affidavit refuting any
of the contentions taken in the counter affidavit.
5. I have heard the rival contentions on both sides.
6. It is true that this Court has interfered with the decision
made by the Board on various occasions. Ultimately by Ext.P14
judgment this Court set aside the order holding that the Board has
not taken into consideration the issue as to whether there was
delay on the part of the Board in completing the work awarded to
the petitioner. Having not done so, this Court by Ext.P14 order, set
aside the order impugned therein and directed reconsideration.
Thereafter the matter considered in detail by the Board and on the
basis of the relevant records, by Ext.P15 order the Board entered
into a finding that 94% of the departmentally issued materials were
transported to the site much ahead of 9/92, the date of
implementation of the revised rate and only less than 6% material
is seen transported after 9/92 and it was further found that there
was delay on the part of the contractor in executing the work and
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
: 11 :
the fact that items such as earth work, masonry etc. which require
no departmental materials for its completion were not completed
during the scheduled completion period, which underlines the
delay on the part of the contractor and it is on said basis that the
Board has entered into a finding in Ext.P15 that there in no delay
on their part. A perusal of the counter affidavit would reveal that
though the original award was for an amount of Rs.44,41,720/ ,
based on a completion report submitted by the petitioner the
amount was Rs.1,83,51,602/-, an increase of 313.6% over an above
the quoted PAC was approved by the Board with a specific
condition that no revision of rates will be allowed over and above
the agreed rates specified in the contract and the amount was also
received by the petitioner. It is also revealed from Ext.P13 that an
additional amount of Rs.4 Lakhs was sanctioned towards additional
work and that an amount of Rs.1,64,297/- was additionally paid by
the Board towards compensation for belated payments.
In Ext.P15 there is a specific finding on the basis of materials
on record that the delay cannot be attributed on the part of the
Board and that there was delay on the part of the contractor in
completing the work within the time stipulated. On the other hand
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
: 12 :
the case of the petitioner is that the delay is only attributable on
the part of the Board and therefore, he is entitled for the revised
rates. Such disputed questions of facts cannot be adjudicated in a
writ petition and therefore, I am not inclined to interfere with the
order impugned herein. It is for the petitioner to raise his claim in
appropriate proceedings in accordance with law. Leaving open
such right of the petitioner, the writ petition is dismissed.
Sd/VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
2025:KER:28197
: 13 :
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 7933/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
A TRUE COPY OF THE WORK ORDER DATED
12.10.1989 ISSUED TO THE PETITIONER.
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 15.11.1989
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENTS.
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE CLAIM DATED 17.07.2006
SUBMITTED BY THE PETITIONER.
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 13.07.2007
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER DATED 18.02.2011
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 16.04.2011
ISSUED BY THE RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION CHIEF
ENGINEER (ELECTRICITY TRANSMISSION)
NO.T2(B)637/79/C TO THE K.S.E.BOARD.
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION FROM THE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DATED 23.04.1993.
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE COMMUNICATION FROM THE
EXECUTIVE ENGINEER DATED 30.06.1994.
Exhibit P10
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED 2.8.2011
IN WP(C) NO.20998/2011.
Exhibit P11
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 21.10.2011
ISSUED BY RESPONDENT.
2025:KER:28197
W.P.(C). No.7933 of 2022
: 14 :
Exhibit P12
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT WP(C)
NO.33856/2011 DATED 19.11.2014.
Exhibit P13
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT DATED 17.07.2015.
Exhibit P14
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED
26.07.2019 IN WP(C) NO.29950/2016.
Exhibit P15
TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER ISSUED BY THE 1ST
RESPONDENT DATED 16.05.2020.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review