Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JAMMU & KASHMIR AND LADAKH
AT JAMMU
WP(C) No.52/2026
Reserved on: 27.01.2026
Pronounced on: 05.02.2026
Uploaded on: 06.02.2026
Johny, age 29 years S/o Sh. Yaqoob,
R/o Ward No.4, Ammunition Morh, Gadi,
Tehsil and District Udhampur
....Petitioner(s)
Through:- Mr. Pawan Kumar Kundal,
Advocate
Versus
1.
Union Territory of Jammu & Kashmir
Through General Administrative Department, Civil Secretariat,
Jammu/Kashmir
2.
J&K Service Selection Board,
Sehkari Bhawan, Rail Head Complex,
Panama Chowk, Jammu/Zum-Zum Building Rambagh,
Srinagar.
...Respondent(s)
Through:- Mr. Raman Sharma, AAG with
Ms. Saliqa Sheikh, Advocate
Coram: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJEEV KUMAR, JUDGE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY PARIHAR, JUDGE
JUDGMENT
Sanjeev Kumar J
1.
This petition by one Mr. Johny, filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, is directed against an order dated
07.11.2025 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal,
WP(C) No.52/2026
Jammu [„the Tribunal”] in TA No.2800/2020 (Jammu) titled
Johny v. UT of J&K and another, whereby the Tribunal has
dismissed the petition of the petitioner.
2.
Before we advert to the grounds of challenge urged by
Mr. Pawan Kumar Kundal, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, it would be appropriate to narrate few facts as are
germane to the disposal of the controversy raised in this
petition.
3.
Vide advertisement notice No.6 of 2015 dated 01.09.2015,
respondent No.2 invited applications for making selection to
various posts including five posts of Patwari for District
Anantnag. Out of the five posts, notified for District Anantnag,
one post was reserved for RBA and one for Scheduled Caste
category. The essential qualification prescribed for the post, as
indicated in the advertisement notification, was “graduation
with knowledge of Urdu”.
4.
The petitioner being eligible and possessing the requisite
qualification, applied for the post of Patwari under scheduled
caste category. The petitioner participated in the written test
conducted by respondent No.2 under Roll No.30052016659. He
was declared successful in the written examination and was
shortlisted for participating in the further process of selection.
WP(C) No.52/2026
As contended, name of the petitioner figured at serial No.8 of
the said shortlist of candidates.
5.
It is further case of the petitioner that on 14.06.2018 i.e. after
almost two months of the declaration of the written
examination, respondent No.2 issued another notification for
conducting examination for testing the “working knowledge of
Urdu”, which exam was introduced vide notice dated
18.11.2017. Said exam was scheduled to be held on 01.07.2018.
The exam was qualifying in nature with the provision of
negative marking for each wrong answer. The qualifying
percentage was fixed at 40% for open merit candidates and 35%
for other category candidates. The petitioner did not question
the notification dated 18.11.2017 and the conduct of exam for
testing the „working knowledge of Urdu” and instead
participated therein. It was only after the final select list was
issued on 26.12.2018, the petitioner found that no candidate
was selected under the Scheduled „Caste Category‟ and the note
appended to the select list stated that “one post under SC
category remained unfilled due to non-availability of eligible
candidate”.
6.
The petitioner having sensed that he could not make it to the
selection for not meeting the benchmark provided for scheduled
caste category, challenged notification dated 18.11.2017 on
WP(C) No.52/2026
various grounds including that the said criteria was not
prescribed at the beginning of the selection process. It seems
that initially the writ petition was filed before this Court and
registered as SWP No.837/2019, which, on transfer to the
Tribunal, was registered as T.A. No.2800/2020 (Jammu). It is
this petition which has been dismissed by the Tribunal in terms
of the order and judgment impugned in this petition.
7.
As is apparent from a reading of the impugned order, the
Tribunal has dismissed the petition on the ground that the
benchmark for SC category in the examination conducted for
testing the working knowledge of Urdu was 35%, whereas the
petitioner had secured less than the said percentage and,
therefore, was rightly held ineligible. It is this order of the
Tribunal, which is called in question by the petitioner on the
following grounds:
i)
The introduction of examination for testing the working
knowledge of Urdu by respondent No.2 vide notification
dated 18.11.2017 was illegal, arbitrary and violative of
Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution.
ii)
The examination for testing the working knowledge of
Urdu was introduced midway after the selection process
had already been set in motion, thereby taking the
petitioner by surprise.
WP(C) No.52/2026
iii)
That the qualification prescribed for the post was
graduation
with
knowledge
examination
conducted
for
of
Urdu,
testing
the
therefore,
working
knowledge of Urdu was contrary to the statutory
prescription and, thus, not permissible.
8.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material on record, we are of the considered opinion that the
petitioner by participating in the examination conducted by
respondent No.2 for testing the working knowledge of Urdu in
terms of notification dated 18.11.2017 is estopped from
challenging the terms and conditions of the said notification
after having failed to achieve the benchmark indicated in the
aforesaid notification.
9.
It is true that in the instant case advertisement notification was
issued on 01.09.2015 for making selection for the posts of
Patwari inter alia for District Ananatnag. Before the selection
process could proceed further, J&K SSB issued notification
No.SSB/Sel/Secy/2017/11832-46 dated 18.11.2017 containing
the scheme of selection and making it clear to all the
candidates, who had submitted their applications that, in the
first, they shall appear in MCQ based test and only the
candidates, who would be shortlisted on the basis of such test,
would be required to appear in the subsequent examination for
WP(C) No.52/2026
testing the working knowledge of Urdu. Notification dated
18.11.2017 is set out below:
“NOTICE
Subject:- Syllabus for the posts of Naib-Tehsildar and Patwari-regarding
1. The syllabus for the multiple choice based written test for the
posts mentioned hereunder is enclosed as Annexure „A‟.
2. The general guidelines for testing the „working knowledge of
Urdu” are enclosed as Annexure „B‟.
3. The candidates will first appear in the MCQ bases test. Only
the candidates shortlisted on the basis of the written test will
be required to appear in the subsequent exam for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu.
4. The exam will conducted in the month of April, 2018 (NaibTehsildar) and February/March, 2018 (Patwari).
5. The written exam will be offline (OMR based) exam. There
shall be negative marking (0.25 for each wrong answer). The
exam for testing working knowledge of Urdu will be
computer based (Reading Section) and descriptive (Writing
Section).
6. The criteria for the overall merit shall be notified
subsequently. However, the Urdu exam will be of qualifying
nature only.”
10.
In the aforesaid notification, it was further made clear that
there shall be negative marking (0.25 for each wrong answer)
and the examination for testing the working knowledge of Urdu
will be computer based (Reading Section) and descriptive
(Writing Section). The general guidelines for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu were also annexed with the
aforesaid notification, which indicated that the examination for
testing the working knowledge of Urdu would be qualifying in
nature and candidate would be required to obtain 40% in the
open merit category and 35% marks in the reserved category
with atleast 33% in each section. This notification was well
WP(C) No.52/2026
within the knowledge of the petitioner since 18.11.2017. The
notification also dealt with the conduct of MCQ based written
test for shortlisting of candidates to be admitted to the
examination for testing the working knowledge of Urdu. The
petitioner sat in the written examination (MCQ based test) on
25.02.2018. The petitioner even qualified the test and was
shortlisted for examination to be conducted for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu. He did not raise any objection or
resentment against the notification dated 18.11.2017 and sat in
the examination conducted by respondent No.2 for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu.
11.
The petitioner, however, could not qualify the aforesaid
examination conducted for testing the knowledge of Urdu, as
the percentage of marks obtained by him was less than the
benchmark fixed in the notification. He was, therefore, not
considered for selection against the post of Patwari. It is only
after the final select list was issued and the petitioner found that
his name was not in the select list, he thought of filing the writ
petition and throw challenge to the notification dated
18.11.2017.
12.
The writ petition was filed after publication of the selection list
in the year 2019. It is this petition which the Tribunal has
dismissed. The Tribunal has though not considered the real
WP(C) No.52/2026
controversy raised by the petitioner, yet the conclusion drawn
by the Tribunal cannot be found fault with. It is well settled that
a person, who participates in the selection process with his eyes
wide open without making any grievance or raising challenge to
the selection criteria adopted in the said selection process,
cannot be permitted to challenge the result of the selection and
selection criteria adopted only after such candidate fails to make
it to the select list.
13.
Recently, Supreme Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh
v. Karunesh Kumar, 2022 SCC Online 1076, reiterated the
settled legal position in this regard. Para 21 of the judgment
surveys the case law on the point and sums up with a
declaration that unsuccessful candidate cannot turn back and
assail the selection process on the ground that the selection
criteria adopted was illegal or arbitrary, particularly, when he
was well aware of the selection criteria and participated in the
selection process without any protest or demur. For facility of
reference, paragraph No.21 of the aforesaid judgment is
reproduced hereunder:
“21. A candidate who has participated in the selection process
adopted under the 2015 Rules is estopped and has acquiesced
himself from questioning it thereafter, as held by this Court in the
case of Anupal Singh (supra):
“55. Having participated in the interview, the private
respondents cannot challenge the Office Memorandum
dated 12-10-2014 and the selection. On behalf of the
appellants, it was contended that after the revised
Notification dated 12-10-2014, the private respondents
WP(C) No.52/2026
participated in the interview without protest and only after
the result was announced and finding that they were not
selected, the private respondents chose to challenge the
revised Notification dated 12-10- 2014 and the private
respondents are estopped from challenging the selection
process. It is a settled law that a person having consciously
participated in the interview cannot turn around and
challenge the selection process.
56. Observing that the result of the interview cannot be
challenged by a candidate who has participated in the
interview and has taken the chance to get selected at the
said interview and ultimately, finds himself to be
unsuccessful, in Madan Lal v. State of J&K [(1995) 3 SCC
486 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 712], it was held as under : (SCC p.
493, para 9)
“9. … The petitioners also appeared at the oral
interview conducted by the Members concerned of
the Commission who interviewed the petitioners as
well as the contesting respondents concerned. Thus
the petitioners took a chance to get themselves
selected at the said oral interview. Only because
they did not find themselves to have emerged
successful as a result of their combined performance
both at written test and oral interview, they have
filed this petition. It is now well settled that if a
candidate takes a calculated chance and appears at
the interview, then, only because the result of the
interview is not palatable to him, he cannot turn
round and subsequently contend that the process of
interview was unfair or the Selection Committee
was not properly constituted.”
57. In K.H. Siraj v. High Court of Kerala [(2006) 6 SCC 395 :
2006 SCC (L&S) 1345], it was held as under : (SCC p. 426, para
73)
“73. The appellant-petitioners having participated in the
interview in this background, it is not open to the appellantpetitioners to turn round thereafter when they failed at the
interview and contend that the provision of a minimum
mark for the interview was not proper.”
58. In Union of India v. S. Vinodh Kumar [(2007) 8 SCC 100 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 792], it was held as under : (SCC p. 107, para
19) “19. In Chandra Prakash Tiwari v. Shakuntala Shukla [(2002)
6 SCC 127 : 2002 SCC (L&S) 830] ….
xxx xxx xxx
It was further observed : (SCC p. 149, para 34)
34. There is thus no doubt that while question of any
estoppel by conduct not arise in the contextual facts but the
law seem to be well settled that in the event a candidate
appears at the interview and participates therein, only
because the result of the interview is not “palatable” to him,
he cannot turn round and subsequently contend that the
WP(C) No.52/2026
process of interview was unfair or there was some lacuna in
the process.”
59. Same principle was reiterated in Sheikh [(2008) 4 SCC 619 :
(2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 9] wherein, it was held as under: (SCC pp.
645-46, para 59)
“59. It is also a settled position that the unsuccessful
candidates cannot back and assail the selection process.
There are of course the exceptions carved out by this Court
to this general rule. This position was reiterated by this
Court in its latest judgment in Union of India v. S. Vinodh
Kumar [(2007) 8 SCC 100 : (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 792]
…. The Court also referred to the judgment in Om Prakash
Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla [1986 Supp SCC 285 :
1986 SCC (L&S) 644], where it has been held specifically
that when a candidate appears in the examination without
protest and subsequently is found to be not successful in the
examination, the question of entertaining the petition
challenging such examination would not arise.”
14.
There are of course exceptions to this general rule but the case
of the petitioner does not fall under any of such exceptions. It is
not the case of the petitioner that notification dated 18.11.2017
is contrary to any statute. The qualification prescribed for the
post as indicated in the advertisement notification is graduation
with knowledge of Urdu and there is nothing wrong in the
respondent No.2 conducting examination for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu. It is because of this reason,
respondent No.2 without proceeding further in the selection
process, issued notification dated 18.11.2017, making it known
to all the candidates, the complete scheme of selection process
to be followed in the matter. It was clearly mentioned that after
conducting the MCQ based test the candidates would be
shortlisted for examination to be conducted for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu. The examination would be a
WP(C) No.52/2026
computer based examination containing two sections i.e reading
section and descriptive section (writing section) and that there
would be different cutoff for open and reserved categories. It
was also made known to the candidates that the examination
would be only of a qualifying nature. This notification was
issued by respondent No.2 on 18.11.2017, much before the date
when the MCQ based written test was conducted. It is
absolutely not a case of change of selection criteria midway. As
a matter of fact the scheme of selection was prescribed for the
first time in the notification dated 18.11.2017. Not only the
petitioner participated in the MCQ based written test but was
even shortlisted for sitting in the examination for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu.
15.
The petitioner voluntarily and without any protest sat in the
examination for testing the working knowledge of Urdu and
raised no issue with regard to the manner in which it was
conducted. It was only after he could not find his name in the
final select list, he chose to throw challenge to the prescription
of written examination for testing the working knowledge of
Urdu in terms of notice dated 18.11.2017.
The Tribunal
examined the merit of the petitioner and found that he had
failed to qualify the examination conducted for testing the
working knowledge of Urdu and, therefore, rightly declared
ineligible by the SSB.
WP(C) No.52/2026
16.
For the foregoing reasons and in view of the settled legal
position, we find no merit in this petition. The same is,
accordingly, dismissed.
(Sanjay Parihar)
Judge
JAMMU
06.02.2026
Vinod, Secy
Vinod Kumar
2026.02.06 10:33
I am the author of this
document
(Sanjeev Kumar)
Judge
Whether the order is speaking : Yes
Whether the order is reportable: Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review