Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC040000572025
2026:GAU-AP:516
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/17/2025
Jitendra Prasad
Son of Shri Shobha Ram Sharma, residence of Quarter No. RNC-21 Type -1,
Itanagar, PO and PS Itanagar, Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh 791111
VERSUS
The State of AP and Anr
represented by Secretary to the Governor, PO and PS Itanagar, Rajbhawan, Papum
Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh.
2:The Deputy Secretary to the Governor
Age: 0
Occupation :
Itanagar
PO and PS Itanagar
Rajbhawan
Papum Pare District
Arunachal Pradesh
Advocate for the Petitioner
: Abhai Kumar Singh, Tsering Nyima,Nabam Kakum,J Lomi,1 P Borah
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
20.05.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
26.05.2026
Page No.# 2/22
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
N/A
:
Yes
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
Judgment & Order (Oral)
Heard Mr. B. Kaushik, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. Y.
Riram, learned Government Advocate for all the respondents.
2.
Challenge in the present writ petition is to the order dated 04.12.2024
passed by the Secretary to the Governor, Itanagar, Arunachal Pradesh, whereby
the petitioner was dismissed from service from the post of Assistant Cook with
disqualification for future employment under the Government.
3.
The case, in brief, is that the petitioner was initially appointed as an
Assistant Cook on officiating basis and his service was subsequently regularized
vide order dated 05.06.2009 as Assistant Cook in the household establishment
of the Governor’s Secretariat, Arunachal Pradesh, with effect from the date of
his joining.
4.
By order dated 23.08.2023, the Secretary to the Governor granted earned
leave to the petitioner for a period of 19 days on domestic grounds, as
recommended by the Assistant House Comptroller, Raj Bhavan, Itanagar. Prior
to the expiry of the said leave period, the petitioner submitted an application
seeking extension of leave from September, 2023 to October, 2023 on account
of serious illness. The petitioner thereafter resumed his duties on 31.10.2023 by
submitting his joining report. However, the request for extension of leave was
not granted.
Page No.# 3/22
5.
Thereafter, vide notice dated 02.11.2023, the Secretary to the Governor
issued a Show Cause Notice to the petitioner directing him to submit his
explanation in respect of his application for commuted leave for 28 days with
effect from 16.09.2023 to 13.10.2023, on the basis of the report of the Medical
Board, wherein serious doubts were raised regarding the authenticity of the
medical documents submitted by the petitioner, allegedly constituting a gross
violation of the provisions of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. In response
thereto, the petitioner submitted his reply on 10.11.2023, furnishing his
explanation and praying for recall of the Show Cause Notice, inter alia
contending that due to his ongoing medical treatment he was unable to furnish
a continuous series of medical certificates regarding his fitness and that the
recurrence of illness at different stages could not be treated as a strange
coincidence.
6.
Thereafter, the Secretary to the Governor issued a Memorandum dated
30.01.2024 proposing an enquiry against the petitioner, which was accompanied
by the Statement of Articles of Charge, a Statement of Imputation of
Misconduct along with supporting documents and a list of witnesses, directing
him to submit his written statement within 10 days. In response thereto, the
petitioner submitted his written statement reiterating the explanation already
furnished in his reply dated 10.11.2023, and contended, inter alia, that the
warning letter referred to in the Memorandum of Charge was not relevant to the
present issue and ought not to be considered. Thereafter, disciplinary
proceedings were initiated and an enquiry report was submitted; the petitioner
was issued a notice dated 04.09.2024 along with a copy of the enquiry report
calling upon him to submit his response within 15 days of receipt thereof, to
which the petitioner submitted his reply on 20.09.2024.
Page No.# 4/22
7.
Consequently, the Secretary to the Governor has passed the impugned
order dated 04.12.2024, whereby, the petitioner is dismissed from service as
Assistant Cook with immediate effect which shall be a disqualification for future
employment under the Government in terms of Rule 11 Sub Rule (ix) of the CCS
(CCA) Rules, 1965.
8.
It is the contention of the petitioner that, notwithstanding his appearance
in the proceedings, he was effectively denied a meaningful opportunity to
present his defence and was instead coerced into accepting the charges,
ostensibly to facilitate imposition of a minor penalty or mere warning on the
ground of it being a first-time offence. The petitioner, an Assistant Cook with
limited proficiency in the English language, is stated to have faced considerable
difficulty in understanding and participating in the enquiry proceedings
conducted by his superior officers. It is further contended that he was not
afforded any opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses, if any, examined
during the course of enquiry and that the hearing was merely a façade intended
to create an impression of procedural compliance, while in reality no effective or
genuine hearing was conducted, thereby violating the principles of natural
justice.
9.
Mr. B. Kaushik, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that
notwithstanding the diligent attendance of the petitioner on each and every
scheduled date before the Enquiry Board, he was inexplicably denied the
opportunity of oral hearing. It is further submitted that the statements of the
petitioner were not duly recorded, thereby causing prejudice to his effective
defence against the Articles of Charge levelled against him. The Enquiry Board is
stated to have solely relied upon the written submissions, without affording prior
notice or granting an opportunity for oral submissions, which, according to the
Page No.# 5/22
learned counsel, clearly violates the principles of natural justice and fair hearing.
10.
Mr. Kaushik, learned counsel, submits that the nature of the charges
levelled against the petitioner and the impugned punishment imposed upon him
are patently disproportionate and are also tainted by preconceived bias, as the
enquiry, in reality, was a mere sham devoid of any intent to inquire the
allegations in a fair and impartial manner. He further submits that the
departmental proceedings initiated against the petitioner, as well as the
consequent impugned punishment, are in flagrant contravention of Rules 14 and
15 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 and Article 311 of the Constitution of India.
11. He submits that the Departmental Enquiry Board, while enquiring into the
matter and the Articles of Charge, neither examined the petitioner nor afforded
him an opportunity to cross-examine the departmental witnesses. It is further
submitted that the documents relied upon were not part of the documents
mentioned in the list of documents or the basis of the Articles of Charge. The
Enquiry Board is stated to have failed to examine and allow cross-examination
of the departmental witnesses, which, according to the learned counsel,
constitutes a gross violation of the principles governing departmental enquiries,
as examination of witnesses is a crucial component of the entire enquiry. It is
therefore contended that the impugned order is vitiated.
12.
In support of his submissions, Mr. Kaushik, learned counsel has placed
reliance on the following authorities:
(i). Union of India & Anr. vs. K G Soni, reported in (2006) 6 SCC
794.
(ii). Krushnakant B. Parmar vs. Union of India & Anr., reported in
(2012) 3 SCC 178.
Page No.# 6/22
(iii).Union of India & Ors. vs. Constable/G. D. Jageshwar Singh,
decided on 20.05.2025, in Civil Appeal No. 7029 of 2025 (Arising out
of SLP (C) No. 18628 of 2019).
13.
Mr. Y. Riram, learned Government Advocate for all the respondents,
submits that the petitioner’s application for extension of leave was not accepted
by the authority as there were serious doubts regarding the veracity of the
medical certificates and the investigation reports submitted by the petitioner.
Despite not being granted leave, the petitioner remained absent from duty,
which necessitated the issuance of a Show Cause Notice. It is further submitted
that, upon being dissatisfied with the petitioner’s reply to the Show Cause
Notice, the respondent authorities initiated departmental proceedings by issuing
a Memorandum of Charges along with the list of documents and witnesses.
14. He submits that the petitioner was afforded full opportunity to present his
defence and was explained in detail the charges framed against him as well as
the entire enquiry proceedings in Hindi, which was understood by him. It is
submitted that there was no question of the petitioner being subjected to any
coercive persuasion to admit the charges levelled against him. Rather, the
petitioner pleaded guilty and accepted all the charges framed against him,
which, according to the respondents, stands corroborated by the documentary
evidence placed on record as exhibits during the departmental enquiry. It is
further submitted that throughout the proceedings, the petitioner was given full
opportunity to defend his case with all documentary evidence in accordance
with the applicable legal provisions governing departmental proceedings. Even
the notice for personal hearing was received by the petitioner on 01.10.2024
and he was heard in person on 03.10.2024. It is, therefore, contended that the
petitioner was afforded ample opportunity to defend himself and having
Page No.# 7/22
accepted the charges, the petitioner cannot simply deny the same and as such,
the writ petition is devoid of merit.
15.
Due consideration has been extended to the submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the parties, and the materials available on record have been
carefully perused.
16.
The petitioner, while serving as Assistant Cook in the Governor’s
Secretariat, was subjected to disciplinary proceedings on the allegation of
unauthorised absence beyond sanctioned leave and submission of doubtful
medical documents for the purpose of seeking extension of leave. Pursuant
thereto, a Memorandum of Charges, dated 30.01.2024 was issued under Rule
14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. In the departmental enquiry, reliance was
placed on various documents including medical reports and statements
contained in the record. The Enquiry Board submitted its report holding the
charges proved, primarily on the basis of admission of guilt by the petitioner as
well as the medical and documentary material on record. The disciplinary
authority, upon consideration of the enquiry report and the reply submitted by
the petitioner to the Notice, passed the impugned order dated 04.12.2024
dismissing
the
petitioner
from
service
with
disqualification
for
future
employment.
17.
The issue which arises for consideration in the present writ petition is
whether the disciplinary proceedings conducted against the petitioner suffer
from procedural infirmities and violation of the principles of natural justice,
including denial of effective opportunity of defence, non-examination and noncross-examination of witnesses and reliance upon materials not supplied to the
petitioner, thereby vitiating the enquiry and the consequential order of dismissal
Page No.# 8/22
and whether the punishment of dismissal is shockingly disproportionate.
18.
The petitioner was proceeded against pursuant to the Memorandum of
Charges, dated 30.01.2024, the contents of which are reproduced herein below
for ready reference:
“GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/6053
Dated 30 January, 2024
MEMORANDUM
The undersigned proposes to hold an inquiry against Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant
Cook, under Rule 14 of the Central Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1965. The Substance of
the imputation of statement of articles of charge (Annexure-1). A statement of the
imputations of misconduct in respect of which the inquiry is proposed to be held is set
out in the enclosed support of each article of charge (Annexure-II). A list of documents
by which and a list of witness by whom, the articles are proposed to be sustained are
also enclosed (Annexure-III & IV).
2. Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, is directed to submit within 10 days of the
receipt/ service of this Memorandum a written statement of his defence and also to
state whether he desired to be heard in person. If no reply is received within
stipulated time, matter will be decided ex-parte.
3 He is informed that an inquiry will be held only in respect of those articles of charge
as are not admitted. He should, therefore, specially admit or deny each article of
charge.
4. Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, is further informed that if he does not submit
his written statement of defence on or before the date specified in para, 2 above, or
does not appear in person before the inquiry authority or otherwise fails or refuse to
comply with the provision of Rules 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, or the orders/
directions issued in pursuance of the said rule, the inquiring authority may hold the
inquiry against him ex-parte.
5. Attention of Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, is invited to Rule 20 of the Central
Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, under which no Government servant shall bring
or attempt to bring any political or outside influence to bear upon any superior
authority to further his interest in respect of matters pertaining to his service under
the Government. If any representation is received on his behalf from another person
in respect of any matter dealt with in these proceedings, it will be presumed that Shri
Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, is aware of such a representation and that it has been
made at his instance and action will be taken against him for violation of Rule 20 of
the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
Page No.# 9/22
6. The receipt of the Memorandum may be acknowledged.
Sd/-Darade Sharad Bhaskar,IPS
Secretary to Governor
Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook,
Governor's Secretariat
Arunachal Pradesh,
Itanagar.
ANNEXURE-1
STATEMENT OF ARTICLES OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST SHRI JITENDRA PRASAD,
ASSISTANT COOK, GOVERNOR'S SECRETARIAT, ITANAGAR.
Article - I
That Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's Secretariat, has violated Rule
25 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 by unauthorizedly overstaying beyond the
sanctioned leave and by his willful absence from duty without any intimation to the
authority and submitting medical documents only to extend leave. Shri Jitendra
Prasad, Assistant Cook has violated Rule 3(1) (i) (ii) (iii) (vi) of CCS (Conduct) Rules,
1964.
Article - II
That Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's Secretariat, frequently fails to
perform his duty as per requirements of the post. He lacks sincerity and dedication to
duty. Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook has violated Rule 3(1) (i) (ii) (iii) (vi) of CCS
(Conduct) Rules, 1964.ANNEXURE-II
STATEMENT OF IMPUTATION OF MISCONDUCT OR MISBEHAVIOR IN SUPPORT OF
THE ARTICLE OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST SHRI JETENDRA PRASAD, ASSISTANT.
Page No.# 10/22
Article-I
Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's Secretariat, was granted
Earned Leave for 19 (nineteen) days w.e.f. 28.08.2023 to 15.09.2023. While approving
the leave of Shri Jitendra Prasad in his personal file, authority directed that "No
extension of leave will be entertained for any reason". The contrary to this direction,
Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook has applied for commuted leave for 28 (twenty
eight) days w.e.f. 16.09.2023 to 13.10.2023 in continuation to the 19(nineteen) days
Earned Leave
A Medical Board was constituted by Senior Medical Officer vide to this office
letter No.GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/3803 dated 13 th Oct, 2023 to scrutinize his case. The
Medical Board submitted its report vide letter No. RBD/3/22-23/75 dated
19.10.2023.
The following points of contention arose based on such scrutiny:
i. That as per the Medical Board Report, his SGPT and SGOT readings in the
biochemistry tests performed on 14.09.2023 i.e two days before he consulted
OPD on 16.09.2023 were abnormally high and they do not correlate with his
symptoms presented at the OPD.
ii. That the Medical Board got his tests conducted on 17.10.2023 in which his
SGPT and SGOT readings are within normal range. The Medical Board has
opined that it would take at least three months for these values to reach such
normal level but in this case they reach normal range within a month.
iii. That under normal circumstances, if a person falls ill, he first consult doctor
and then undergoes various tests as advised by the doctor. But in this case his
biochemistry tests were performed on 14.09.2023 and he consulted doctor in
OPD in Meerut hospital two days later on 16.09.2023.
iv. That he was not hospitalized for the treatment but treated only as an OPD
patient despite such high values of SGPT and SGOT.
V. That as per medical practice 4 weeks medical leave in a single go is not
Page No.# 11/22
prescribed. Repeat medical tests are performed in a week or two and then
decision is taken. No such repeat medical tests are performed in this case.
vi. That there are no serial numbers on medical certificate of leave and fitness.
The format and language on medical certificate of leave is not clear.
vii. That medical certificate of fitness is dated 13.09.2023 which is three days
before he even consulted the OPD!
viii. That there are no bills of medicines purchased as prescribed.
ix. That he fell ill right at the end of his approved earned leave which is a
strange coincidence.
Report from TRIHMS was also called which also confirmed some of the issues.
The aforementioned points of contention raise a serious doubt that Shri
Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook has submitted these medical documents only to
extend his leave which would be gross violation of the provisions of CCS (Conduct)
Rules, 1964.
The act on the part of Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, has violated Rule 25
the CCS (Leave) Rules 1972 by his unauthorized absence beyond the sanctioned leave
and his willful absence from duty. Thus he has violated 3 (1) (i) (ii) & (iii) (vi) of CCS
(Conduct) Rules, 1964.
Article-II
Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's Secretariat was served with a
warning letter vide No. GS/Estt-85/PF/2007 dated 16th August, 2023 for not obeying
instructions given to him by the Hon'ble Governor and the First Lady of the State for
his lackadaisical attitude and poor performance. His lack of concentration and
sincerity has lead to his poor performance and his deliberate mistakes have hampered
the dignity and decorum of the highest office of the State. He was warned verbally
many times to improve his efficiency in cooking healthy and hygienic food by
following proper cooking methods and to improve his cooking skills, but to no avail.
Thus he has violated Rule 3 (1) (ii) (iii) & (vi) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.
Page No.# 12/22
ANNEXURE - III
LIST OF DOCUMENTS BY WHICH THE ARTICLE OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST SHRI
JITENDRA PRASAD, ASSISTANT COOK, ARE PROPOSED TO BE SUSTAINED.
1. Copy of leave application of Shri Jitendra Prasad Assistant Cook, for granting 19
(nineteen) days earned leave w.e.f. 28.08.2023 to 15.09.2023
2. Copy of leave order vides GS/Estt-85/PF/2007 dated 23/08/2023.
3. Copy of Extension leave application of Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, for
granting 28 (twenty eight) days Commuted leave w.e.f 16.09.2023 to 13.10.2023.
4. Copy of Medical Documents.
5. Copy of absent Report from Sub, Chob Singh, House Comptroller.
6. Copy of letter to the Senior Medical Officer, Raj Bhavan Dispensary, formation of
Medical Board vide letter No.GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/3803 dated 13/10/2023.
7. Copy of letter from Dr. J.Tayeng, SMO, I/C Raj Bhavan Dispensary, Itanagar, for
board member letter vide No.RBD/3/73 dated 16/10/2023.
8. Copy of letter for Medical board report of Shri Jitendra Prasad, letter vide
No.RBD/3/75 dated 19/10/2023.
9. Copy of Show Cause Notice vides GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/4212-14 dated 02/11/2023.
10. Copy of reply to Show cause Notice dated 10/11/2023.
11. Copy of letter to the Director of(TRIHMS) Vide NO.GS/Estt-85/2007/4529 dated
22/11/2023.
12. Copy of Medical Report from Dr. Tao Kaki, Dy. Medical Superintendent, TRIHMS,
Page No.# 13/22
Hospiatal Naharlagun, vide letter NO.TRIHMS/DEV-12/83/2019-20/Pt-III/5002-04
11/12/2023.
13. Copy of Warning letter vide No. GS/Estt-85/PF/2007 dated 16 th August, 2023.
ANNEXURE - IV
LIST OF WITNESS BY WHOM THE ARTICLE OF CHARGE FRAMED AGAINST SHRI
JITENDRA PRASAD, ASSISTANT COOK, ARE PROPOSED TO BE SUSTAINED.
1. Sub. Chob Singh, House Comptroller, Raj Bhavan, Itanagar.
2. Dr. (Mrs.) J. Tayeng, Senior Medical Officer, Raj Bhavan Dispensary.
3. Dr. Taso Beyong, Chairman Medical Board, TRIHMS.
4. Shri R.K. Rai, APCS, Under Secretary to Governor.
5. Shri Ajoy Kr. Gupta, Section Officer.”
19. Upon completion of the enquiry, the Departmental Enquiry Board submitted
its report holding that the charges levelled against the petitioner stood proved,
which is reproduced hereinunder:
“…INQUIRY REPORT OF THE DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS AGAINST SHR
JITENDRAPRASAD, ASSISTANT COOK, GOVERNOR'S SECRETARIAT, ITANAGAR.
INTRODUCTION:
Vide order No GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/6426 dated 12 th Feb, 2024 a
Departmental Enquiry Board was constituted by the Secretary to Governor for
inquiry into charges framed against Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook,
Governor's Secretariat, Vide No GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/6053-55 dated 30 th Jan,
2024. The members of the Inquiry Board are as under;
1. Deputy Secretary to Governor
2. Under Secretary (TPT) to Governor
- Chairman.
- Member
Page No.# 14/22
3. Section Officer
- Member
By the said order, the Under Secretary (Establishment) was appointed as
Presenting Officer.
STATEMENT OF CHARGES FRAMED AGAINST SHRI JITENDRA PRASAD, ASSISTANT
COOK, GOVERNOR'S SECRETARIAT, ITANAGAR
Article-I
That Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's secretariat has violated Rule
25 of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 by unauthorisedly overstaying beyond the
sanctioned leave and by his wilful absence from duty without any intimation to the
authority and submitting medical documents only to extend leave, Shri Jitendra
Prasad, Assistant Cook, has violated Rule 3(1)(i)(ii)(iii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules,
1964.
Article-II
That Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook, Governor's secretariat, frequently fails to
perform his duty as per requirements of the post. He lacks sincerity and dedication
to duty. Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook has violated Rule 3(1) (i) (ii) (iii) (vi) of
CCS(Conduct) Rules 1964.
DATE OF HEARING
14.3.2024 at 3 pm in the office chamber of Deputy Secretary to Governor.
28.8.2024 at 11 am in the office chamber of Deputy Secretary to Governor.
LIST OF EXHIBITS
1. Application for leave.
2. Leave sanction order vide No.GS/Estt-85/PF/2007 Dated 23 rdAug, 2023.
3. Leave availing report.
4. Application for extension of leave with medical documents.
5. Absentee report against the Charged Official by the House Comptroller.
Page No.# 15/22
6. Letter to SMO, Raj Bhavan Dispensary for formation of Medical Board vide
No.GS/Estt- 85/PF/2007/3803 Dated 13thOct, 2023.
7. Medical Board formation of Raj Bhavan Dispensary vide No.RBD/3/73 Dated
16/10/2023.
8. Show Cause Notice to the Charged Official vide No.GS/Estt-85/PF/2007/4212-14
Dated 2ndNov, 2023.
9. Reply to Show Cause Notice, dated 10th Nov, 2023.
10. Letter to Director (TRIHMS) seeking opinion on medical documents submitted
by the Charged Official, vide No.GS.Estt-85/2007/4529 Dated 22ndNov, 2023.
11. Report from TRIHMS vide No.TRIHMS/Dev-12/83/2019-20/Pt-III/5002-04
Dated 11th Dec, 2023.
12. Warning letter to the Charged Official in Hindi vide No. No.GS.Estt85/PF/2007/2593-95 Dated 16th Aug, 2023.
13. Findings of the board constituted by the CMO, PL Sharma District Hospital,
Meerut, Uttar Pradesh on medical documents issued by Dr Annu Gupta to the
Charged Official.
FINDINGS OF THE MEDICAL BOARD OF TRIHMS ON QUERIES RELATED TO
MEDICAL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED FOR EXTENSION OF LEAVE BY SHRI
JITENDRA PRASAD, CHARGED OFFICIAL.
Query-That under normal circumstances, if a person falls ill, he first consults
the doctor and then undergoes various tests as advised by the doctor. But in this
case, his biochemistry tests were performed on 14.9.2023 and he consulted the
doctor in OPD in Meerut two days later on 16.9.2023.
Observation of the Medical Board - The present medical board totally agrees
with above observation that under normal circumstances a patient gets tested only
after consulting a doctor. A patient with such severe symptoms and abnormal test
report would normally never consider delaying his own treatment intentionally.
Query - That he was not hospitalised for the treatment but treated only as an
OPD patient despite such high values of SGPT and SGOT.
Observation of the Medical Board - Ideally any such patient with fever, acute
abdomen, nausea and vomiting with severe jaundice and tachycardia should
preferably be admitted, managed and further investigated appropriately in that
health care centre (e.g, repeat LFT, KFT, S. electrolytes, CBC, viral marker and an
ultrasound of abdomen with an emphasis on hepatobiliary system). In absence of
such minimum basic facilities at that health care centre, a referral to the nearest
Page No.# 16/22
higher centre is the usual norm.
Query - That as per medical practice, 4 weeks medical leave in a single go is
not prescribed. Repeat medical tests are performed in a week or two and then
decision is taken. No such repeat medical tests are performed in this case.
Observation of the Medical board - As per the NMC/MCI guidelines the
maximum days of medical leave a treating doctor can prescribe his/her patient is 2
weeks. If need be, re-issuance can be done but only after seeing the patient again.
This medical board also could not appreciate any mention of his repeat
examination findings and investigations before the date of issue of his medical
fitness certificate in the documents provided to it.
Query - That medical certificate of fitness is dated 13.9.2023 which is three
days before he even consulted the OPD.
Observation of the Medical Board - Medical certificate can never be issued by
the Doctor before the date of first consultation for any ongoing disease/ailment.
FINDINGS OF THE MEDICAL BOARD CONSTITUTED BY THE CMO, PL SHARMA
DISTRICT HOSPITAL, MEERUT, UTTAR PRADESH ON MEDICAL DOCUMENTS
ISSUEDBY DR ANNU GUPTA TO SHRI JITENDRA PRASAD, CHARGED OFFICIAL.
1. Medical document issued by Dr Annu Gupta has been issued under some
influence to give undue benefit to the patient.
2. Dr Annu Gupta whose appointment is on contractual basis, is not authorised to
issue medicalcertificates independently and was warned earlier as well to not to
issue medical certificates but in-spite of that she has done it again.
3. The present medical board agrees with all the findings of earlier board
constituted with regards to examination of medical certificate.
4. Contract appointment has been concealed in the seal thereby misleading the
patient.
BRIEF BY THE PRESENTING OFFICER
The gist of brief by the Presenting Officer is as under:
As the Charged Official Shri Jitendra Prasad, Assistant Cook has accepted the
charges framed against him, the charges are proved beyond doubt.
CONCLUSION
The Charged Official has pleaded guilty to the charges framed against him, which
Page No.# 17/22
corroborates with the documental evidence placed as exhibits. The findings of the
Medical Board of TRIHMS placed as exhibit no-11 makes it amply clear that medical
documents were manufactured by the Charged Official solely for extension of his
leave, which is further substantiated by the findings of the board constituted by the
CMO, PL Sharma District Hospital, Meerut, Uttar Pradesh placed as exhibit no-13.
The warning letter to the Charged Official, placed as exhibit.no-12 proves that he
has been failing to perform his duty as per requirement of the post. Therefore, the
charges framed at Article-l and Article-II against Shri Jitendra Prasad, the Charged
Official stands proved.
Under Secretary (TPT)
to Governor (Member-1
of the Departmental Enquiry Board)
Section Officer
(Member-2 of the
Departmental Enquiry Board)
Deputy Secretary to Governor
(Chairman of the Departmental Enquiry Board)
20.
After examination of the enquiry report, the Secretary to the Governor
passed the impugned order, whereby the petitioner was dismissed from service
with immediate effect, which would ordinarily operate as a disqualification for
future employment under the Government.
21. A perusal of the Memorandum of Charges dated 30.01.2024 shows that the
petitioner was proceeded against under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965
on two Articles of Charge, namely, unauthorised absence beyond sanctioned
leave coupled with submission of doubtful medical documents for extension of
leave and alleged lack of sincerity and devotion to duty in discharge of official
functions. The memorandum was accompanied by Annexure-I containing the
Articles of Charge, Annexure-II containing detailed statement of imputations,
Annexure-III listing the documents and Annexure-IV listing the witnesses
Page No.# 18/22
proposed to be relied upon.
22.
Annexure-II to the charge memorandum contains detailed factual
imputations forming the foundation of the disciplinary action. The same refers to
the petitioner having been granted earned leave for 19 days from 28.08.2023 to
15.09.2023 and thereafter having applied for extension of leave on medical
grounds from 16.09.2023 to 13.10.2023. It refers to constitution of a Medical
Board and the scrutiny of medical records, wherein several inconsistencies were
noticed, including timing of medical tests vis-à-vis consultation, variations in
SGPT/SGOT readings, issuance of fitness certificate prior to consultation and
absence of supporting treatment records. On the basis of such observations,
doubt was raised regarding the genuineness of the medical documents
submitted by the petitioner.
23.
The disciplinary proceedings were accordingly initiated and the matter
proceeded to enquiry in terms of Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965.
24.
Upon completion of enquiry, the Enquiry Board submitted its report
holding that the charges stood proved. The report records reliance upon various
documents including the report of TRIHMS dated 11.12.2023, the report of the
Medical Board constituted by PL Sharma District Hospital, Meerut and the
warning letter dated 16.08.2023. The enquiry report shows that the finding of
guilt is primarily founded on two aspects, first, the alleged admission of guilt by
the petitioner during the enquiry proceedings and second, the documentary and
medical evidence forming part of the record. The Enquiry Board considered that
the petitioner had pleaded guilty to the charges and on that basis, directed the
Presenting Officer to submit his brief, leading to the conclusion that the charges
stood proved.
Page No.# 19/22
25.
The reliance placed on the medical reports, particularly the report of
TRIHMS dated 11.12.2023 and the report of the Medical Board constituted by
PL Sharma District Hospital, Meerut, shows that the core allegation pertains to
the genuineness of the medical certificates submitted by the petitioner. The said
reports contain detailed observations regarding inconsistencies in medical
findings, timing of consultation and improbability of recovery, leading to the
conclusion that the documents were not reliable. It is thus evident that the
disciplinary conclusion is based on the alleged acceptance of charges during the
enquiry proceedings as well as the documentary and medical material collected
during the course of enquiry.
26.
The warning letter dated 16.08.2023 has also been taken into
consideration while assessing the overall conduct of the petitioner. However, the
same pertains to alleged past conduct and cannot, by itself, constitute proof of
the specific misconduct alleged in the present Charge Memorandum.
27. The petitioner has contended that the enquiry was vitiated due to violation
of principles of natural justice, particularly on the ground that he was not
afforded effective opportunity to cross-examine witnesses and that the
proceedings were conducted merely as a formality without properly considering
his defence. The record, however, indicates that the petitioner was served with
the Memorandum of Charges along with all documents sought to be relied upon
and was given opportunity to submit his written statement. It further reflects
that the petitioner had participated in the enquiry proceedings and was also
afforded personal hearing. During the enquiry proceedings held on 14.03.2024,
the petitioner was specifically asked whether he admitted the charges, to which
he answered in affirmative.
Page No.# 20/22
28. Once the petitioner has admitted the charges during the course of enquiry
proceedings, the requirement of strict proof through examination or crossexamination of witnesses does not arise in the same manner, particularly where
such admission is voluntary and clear. An admission is the best evidence against
the person making it, unless shown to be involuntary or vitiated by coercion.
The petitioner has not been able to demonstrate that the alleged admission was
obtained under coercion or that he was deprived of understanding the nature of
the proceedings. Mere assertion of procedural irregularity, without supporting
material, is insufficient to vitiate duly conducted disciplinary proceedings.
29.
Even otherwise, the documentary and medical evidence on record
independently supports the findings recorded by the Enquiry Board. The reports
of the medical authorities, duly constituted for verification of disputed
documents, raise serious doubts regarding the authenticity of the medical
certificates submitted by the petitioner, thereby reinforcing the conclusion of
misconduct.
30.
Coming to the case laws relied upon by the petitioner, in K G Soni
(supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has reiterated that judicial review in
disciplinary matters is limited to examining the decision-making process and not
the merits of the findings and interference is permissible only where the
decision suffers from illegality, irrationality, or procedural impropriety. In
Krushnakant B. Parmar (supra), it was held that unauthorised absence does
not automatically amount to wilful absence and must be proved on the basis of
evidence and that findings cannot be based on conjectures or by ignoring
relevant material. In Constable/G.D. Jageshwar Singh (supra), the Hon’ble
Supreme Court reiterated the doctrine of proportionality in disciplinary matters,
holding that interference with punishment is justified only in cases where it is
Page No.# 21/22
shockingly disproportionate or arbitrary. The aforesaid decisions lay down
settled principles governing judicial review in disciplinary proceedings, but the
same do not assist the petitioner in the facts of the present case, as in the
present case the disciplinary findings are based on material on record, due
procedure has been followed, and no case of illegality, perversity, or procedural
infirmity is made out.
31.
In the present case, it is evident from the departmental proceedings that
the petitioner, during the enquiry as well as at the stage of personal hearing,
has accepted the charges levelled against him, which has been duly recorded in
the enquiry proceedings. The said acceptance is not shown to have been
obtained under any coercion or undue influence and, therefore, constitutes a
clear admission on the part of the petitioner. The Enquiry Board has proceeded
on the basis of such admission, which is also corroborated by the documentary
and medical records forming part of the enquiry file. In such circumstances, the
findings recorded cannot be said to be unsupported by material on record. The
record further reflects that the petitioner was supplied with the Memorandum of
Charges along with documents and was afforded adequate opportunity to
participate in the enquiry and submit his defence.
32.
In view of the foregoing discussion and upon careful examination of the
record, this Court is of the considered opinion that the petitioner was afforded
due opportunity of hearing at all stages of the disciplinary proceedings,
including the service of Memorandum of Charges, supply of relied upon
documents, participation in the enquiry and personal hearing. The proceedings,
as reflected from the enquiry record, do not suffer from any procedural
irregularity or violation of the principles of natural justice. The findings recorded
by the Enquiry Board are based on materials available on record, which include
Page No.# 22/22
documentary and medical evidence as well as the petitioner’s admission of the
charges during the enquiry proceedings. In the absence of any demonstrated
illegality, perversity, or procedural lapse, the conclusion arrived at by the
disciplinary authority cannot be faulted nor the punishment imposed is
shockingly
disproportionate.
Consequently,
the
impugned
order
dated
04.12.2024 issued by the Secretary to the Governor, Itanagar, Arunachal
Pradesh, does not warrant interference.
33. Accordingly, the writ petition fails and is dismissed. No order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review