Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.41048 of 2023
In the matter of an application under Articles 226 & 227 of the
Constitution of India.
………………
Jitendra Kumar Nayak
….
Petitioner
-versus….
State of Odisha & Ors.
For Petitioner
:
For Opp. Parties :
Opposite Parties
Mr. S.D. Routray, Advocate
Mr. A. Tripathy, Addl. Govt. Advocate
PRESENT:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing: 08.05.2026 and Date of Judgment: 08.05.2026
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Biraja Prasanna Satapathy, J.
1. This matter is taken up through hybrid mode.
2. Heard Mr. S.D. Routray, learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner
and Mr. A. Tripathy, learned Addl. Govt. Advocate appearing for the
Opp. Parties.
// 2 //
3. The present writ petition has been filed inter alia with the following
prayer:“It is therefore, most humbly prayed that this Hon'ble Court
be graciously pleased to:
i) Admit the writ application.
ii) Call for the record.
iii) Issue Rule Nisi calling upon the opposite parties to show
cause as to why the impugned order of rejection dated
07.11.2023 under Annexure:12, the order of disengagement
dated 03.06.2015 under Annexure:2 order dated 05.12.2012
under Annexure:3 and the office order dated 14.03.2018
under Annexure: 13 shall not be quashed.
iv) If the opposite parties do not show cause or show
insufficient cause issue a writ in the nature of certiorari or
any
other
appropriate
writ/writs,
order/orders,
direction/directions quashing the impugned order of rejection
dated 07.11.2023 under Annexure: 12, the order of
disengagement dated 03.06.2015 under Annexure:2, order
dated 05.12.2012 under Annexure:3 and the office order
dated 14.03.2018 under Annexure: 13.
v) Issue a writ in the nature of mandamus or any other
writ/writs direction/directions directing the opposite parties
to re-engage / reinstate the petitioner as a Gram Panchayat
Technical Assistant forthwith and further direction be issued
to extend all the service and financial benefits to the
petitioner from 04.06.2015.
// 3 //
vi) And/or pass such other order/orders, direction/directions
as this Hon'ble Court may deems fit and proper for the ends
of justice.
And for the said act of kindness, the petitioner as in duty
bound shall ever pray.”
4. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that Petitioner
was engaged as a GPTA on contractual basis on being recommended by
the Committee of Chief Engineers vide order dtd.26.03.2010 under
Annexure-1. Pursuant to the said order, Petitioner joined on 26.03.2010
itself. However, because of his implication in a vigilance proceeding in
Berhampur Vigilance P.S. Case No. 3 dtd.22.01.2015, Petitioner was
straight away disengaged from his services vide office order
dtd.03.06.2015 under Annexure-2 w.e.f.22.01.2015.
4.1. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that in the
said vigilance proceeding, Petitioner was honorably acquitted vide
judgment dtd.18.12.2021 under Annexure-5 by the learned Special
Judge, Vigilance, Berhampur, Ganjam in G.R. Case No. 2/2015.
4.2. It is contended that after being acquitted in the vigilance proceeding,
Petitioner seeking his reengagement, moved a detailed representation
before Opp. Party No. 1 on 05.05.2022 under Annexure-6. However,
// 4 //
such claim of the Petitioner when was rejected vide order dtd.17.04.2023
under Annexure-7.
4.3. Petitioner challenging the same, moved this Court by filing W.P.(C)
No. 18191 of 2023. This Court vide order dtd.21.06.2023 under
Annexure-10 while quashing the impugned rejection, directed Opp.
Party No. 2 to consider the matter afresh and take a decision with regard
to claim of the Petitioner to get the benefit of reengagement. But such a
direction of this Court was negatived with rejection of the Petitioner’s
claim to get the benefit of reengagement vide the impugned order
dtd.07.11.2023 under Annexure-12.
4.4. Learned counsel appearing for the Petitioner contended that, since
Petitioner only on the ground of his implication in the vigilance
proceeding was disengaged vide order dtd.03.06.2015 under Annexure-2
w.e.f.22.01.2015, after his acquittal vide judgment dtd.18.12.2021 under
Annexure-5, in view of the decision of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the
case of Ram Lal Vrs. State of Rajasthan and Ors. (Civil Appeal
No.7935 of 2023) so followed in the case of Maharana Pratap Singh
Vs. The State of Bihar and Others (Civil Appeal No.5497 of 2025),
Petitioner is eligible and entitled to get the benefit of reengagement. Not
only that in view of the recent decision of this Court in the case of State
// 5 //
of Odisha & Ors. vs. Banshidhar Barik (W.A. No. 589 of 2025
disposed of on 20.03.2026), Petitioner is also eligible to get the benefit
of reengagement.
4.5. Hon’ble Apex Court in Para-13, 25 and 30 of the decision in the
case of Ram Lal has held as follows:“13. However, if the charges in the departmental
enquiry and the criminal court are identical or
similar, and if the evidence, witnesses and
circumstances are one and the same, then the matter
acquires a different dimension. If the court in
judicial review concludes that the acquittal in the
criminal proceeding was after full consideration of
the prosecution evidence and that the prosecution
miserably failed to prove the charge, the Court in
judicial review can grant redress in certain
circumstances. The court will be entitled to exercise
its discretion and grant relief, if it concludes that
allowing the findings in the disciplinary proceedings
to stand will be unjust, unfair and oppressive. Each
case will turn on its own facts. [See G.M. Tank vs.
State of Gujarat & Others, (2006) 5 SCC 446, State
Bank of Hyderabad vs. P. Kata Rao, (2008) 15 SCC
657 and S. Samuthiram (supra)]
xxx
xxx
xxx
25. Expressions like “benefit of doubt” and
“honorably acquitted”, used in judgments are not to
be understood as magic incantations. A court of law
will not be carried away by the mere use of such
terminology.
xxx
xxx
xxx
30. In view of the above, we declare that the order of
termination dated 31.03.2004; the order of the
Appellate Authority dated 08.10.2004; the orders
dated 29.03.2008 and 25.06.2008 refusing to
reconsider and review the penalty respectively, are
all illegal and untenable.”
// 6 //
4.6. Similarly, following the decision in the case of Ram Lal Hon’ble
Apex Court in Para-47 & 50 of the decision in the case of Maharana
Pratap Singh Vs. The State of Bihar and Others (Civil Appeal
No.5497 of 2025) has held as follows:“47. While an acquittal in a criminal case does not
automatically entitle the accused to have an order of
setting aside of his dismissal from public service
following disciplinary proceedings, it is wellestablished that when the charges, evidence, witnesses,
and circumstances in both the departmental inquiry
and the criminal proceedings are identical or
substantially similar, the situation assumes a different
context. In such cases, upholding the findings in the
disciplinary proceedings would be unjust, unfair, and
oppressive. This is a position settled by the decision
in G. M. Tank (supra), since reinforced by a decision of
recent origin in Ram Lal v. State of Rajasthan31.
xxx
xxx
xxx
50. The judgment acquitting the appellant reveals that
the prosecution "miserably failed to prove its case
beyond reasonable doubt" as both the informant and
PW-2 refused to identify the appellant in court. This
discussion confirms that the appellant's acquittal was
based not on mere technicalities. In Ram Lal (supra),
this Court held that terms like "benefit of doubt" or
"honourably acquitted" should not be treated as
formalities. The Court's duty is to focus on the
substance of the judgment, rather than the terminology
used.”
4.7. Similarly, this Court in Para 20 of the decision in the case of
Banshidhar Barik has held as follows:“To substantiate the aforementioned charge, the inquiry
officer, as has been stated above has examined the same set
// 7 //
of witnesses, whose version has been clearly discarded by a
judicial finding by the Court of Addl. Sessions Judge. The
important aspect of this matter is the plea of alibi taken by
the respondent, which has been established by him by cogent
evidence and believed by the trial court. If the plea of alibi is
believed by the trial Court in the judgment dated 26.11.2018,
which has attained the finality, the entire genesis of the case
is washed away on facts. Therefore, it could be safely
inferred that departmental proceedings and their conclusion
are based on "no evidence". The learned Single Judge has
rightly relied upon numerous judgments to un-justify the
departmental action taken against the respondent. It is no
gain saying that the judgment relied upon by the learned
Single Judge is apt in the fact scenario of the present case.
The eventual conclusion drawn by the learned Single Judge,
setting aside the departmental action against the respondent
cannot be faulted with on law as well as facts. Therefore, this
is clearly not a case for interference by this Court.”
4.8. It is accordingly contended that since Petitioner was only
disengaged because of his implication in the vigilance proceeding and he
has been acquitted honorably vide judgment dtd.18.12.2021, in view of
the decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court as well as of this Court so cited
(supra), the ground on which Petitioner’s claim has been rejected vide
the impugned judgment dtd.07.11.2023 under Annexure-12 requires
interference of this Court, being not sustainable in the eye of law.
5. Mr. A. Tripathy, learned Addl. Govt. Advocate on the other hand
made his submission in support of the impugned order, contending inter
// 8 //
alia that since Petitioner by the time he was disengaged because of his
implication in a vigilance proceeding, was continuing as a contractual
GPTA, even though he was acquitted vide judgment dtd.18.12.2021, but
taking into account his implication in the vigilance proceeding prior to
his regularization, the authorities were not inclined to direct for
reengagement of the Petitioner and accordingly his prayer for
reengagement was rejected vide order dtd.07.11.2023 under Annexure12. Stand taken in Para 6 of the counter affidavit so relied on by the
learned AGA reads as follows:“6. That in reply to the averments made in Para-1 of the Writ
Petition, it is humbly submitted that, the petitioner was engaged
as
GPTA
(Contractual)
vide
Office
Order
No.
dtd.26.03.2010 of Collector, Gajapati on recommendation from
Govt. in PR&DW Deptt., Odisha on contract basis with a
consolidated remuneration of Rs.5000/- per month followed by
executing an agreement abiding by the terms and conditions and
posted as such in Mohana Block for preparation of estimate,
measurement of works and supervision of MGNREGS works and
other developmental works as assigned by the authority as and
when required. Whereas the petitioner was caught red handed on
dtd.22.01.2015 while accepting bribe of Rs. 8000/- on demand
from the complainant Sri Uma Sankar Sahu for passing of bill of
the work "Construction of C.C Road from RD road to KS High
School, Patigovindapur" and arrested by the vigilance team on
22.01.2015 and forwarded to the Court of Special Judge,
Vigilance, Berhampur on 23.01.2015 and had been remanded to
judicial custody till 05.02.2015. Since the petitioner had been
// 9 //
remanded to Jail custody for more than 48 hours and comes
under the definition of misconduct and is a fit case for
disengagement with reference to PR Deptt. Letter No. 17-NREGII-4057-21161/PR, dated 05.12.2012. Further, the law of natural
justice was followed by the Opp. Party No. 03 by giving the
petitioner an opportunity to be heard in person and being
dissatisfactory explanation submitted by the petitioner on
dtd.25.02.2015 and dissatisfactory reply during personal hearing
on dtd.24.03.2015, 21.04.2015 and 12.05.2015, he has been
disengaged from contractual service w.e.f.22.01.2015 vide Office
Order No.2051 dtd.03.06.2015 of Opp. Party No. 03. Basing on
the merit of the facts, instructions and orders of Govt. in GA
(Vig.) Deptt., Odisha vide their letter No. 823 dt.13.04.2015 and
also terms and conditions of services of contractual employees
like GPTAs under MGNREGS Scheme are governed by the terms
and conditions of agreement/contract, and not by OCS(CCA)
Rules, 1962, the Govt. in Panchayati Raj & Drinking Water
Department, Odisha the Opp. Party No. 01 has rejected /
disposed off the representation dated 05.05.2022 of the petitioner
and
communicated
to
him
vide
their
letter
No.8316
dtd17.04.2023. The orders of this Hon'ble Court dated 13.10.2023
in Contempt Petition No. 7516 of 2023 filed by the petitioner
alleging there in non-compliance of the order dated 21.06.2023
passed in WP (C) No. 18191 of 2023 has also been complied by
the Opp. Party No.02 (Director, Panchayati Raj & Drinking
Water Deptt.) rightly in accordance with the law and issued an
order on dated 07.11.2023 which is communicated to all
concerned vide Memo No. 25421/PR&DW, dated 07.11.2023. The
copies of the Office Order No. 1152 dt.26.03.2010, Letter No.
21161 dt.05.12.2012, Office Order No.2051 dtd.03.06.2015,
Disengagement Vide Order No. 823 dt.13.04.2015, Letter No.
8316 dt.17.04.2023 & Order No. 25421 dt.07.11.2023 are
// 10 //
annexed herewith as Annexure-A/4, Annexure-B/4, Annexure-C/4,
Annexure-D/4, Annexure-E/4 & Annexure-F/4 respectively.”
6. Having heard learned counsel appearing for the Parties and
considering the submission made, it is found that Petitioner was engaged
as GPTA on contractual basis vide order dtd.26.03.2010 under
Annexure-1. However, because of his implication in Berhampur
Vigilance P.S. Case No. 3 dtd.22.01.2015, Petitioner was disengaged
vide order dtd.03.06.2015 under Annexure-2 of the Collector, GajapatiOpp. Party No. 3 w.e.f.22.01.2015.
6.1. It is not disputed that in the aforesaid vigilance proceeding,
Petitioner was honorably acquitted vide judgment dtd.18.12.2021 under
Annexure-5. Since Petitioner only on the ground of his implication in the
vigilance proceeding was disengaged vide order dtd.03.06.2015 and he
has been honorably acquitted vide judgment dtd.18.12.2021 and the said
order of acquittal has not been assailed by the State, placing reliance on
the decisions of the Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of the Ram Lal so
followed in Maharana Pratap Singh and the decision of this Court in
the case of Banshidhar Barik so cited supra, this Court is of the view
that, the ground on which Petitioner’s claim has been rejected, so far as
reengagement is concerned, vide the impugned order dtd.07.11.2023
under Annexure-12 is not sustainable in the eye of law.
// 11 //
6.2. Not only that since Petitioner has been acquitted honorably, the
order of disengagement initially passed on 03.06.2015, as per the
considered view of this Court is also no more sustainable. In view of the
aforesaid analysis, this Court is inclined to quash order dtd.03.06.2015
so passed by Opp. Party No. 3 under Annexure-2, and so also order
dtd.07.11.2023 so passed by Opp. Party No. 2 under Annexure-12.
While quashing both the orders, this Court directs Opp. Party Nos. 2 & 3
to reengage the Petitioner in the post of GPTA, with passing of an
appropriate order within a period of four (4) weeks from the date of
receipt of this order.
6.3. Since it is contended that similarly situated GPTAs in the meantime
have been regularized as Asst. Engineer, this Court directs Opp. Party
Nos. 2 & 3 to extend the benefit of regularization by taking the date of
engagement of the Petitioner as 26.03.2010, but only on notional basis
and Petitioner will not be permitted to raise any claim towards receipt of
any financial benefit.
7. The writ petition accordingly stands disposed of.
Signature Not
Verified
Orissa
High Court, Cuttack
(BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY)
JUDGE
Digitally Signed
Dated the 8th May, 2026/Sneha
Signed by: SNEHANJALI PARIDA
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 11-May-2026 13:38:33
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review