Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Date of decision: 07th JANUARY, 2026
IN THE MATTER OF:
+
LPA 1189/2024, CM APPL. 72010/2024
JITENDER YADAV
Through:
.....Appellant
Ms. Esha Mazumdar & Ms. Anushka
Gupta, Advs.
versus
UNION OF INDIA & ORS.
Through:
.....Respondents
Mr. Sandeep Kumar Mahapatra, Ms.
Mrinmayee Sahu and Mr. Tribhuvan,
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE VIMAL KUMAR YADAV
JUDGMENT
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J.
1.
The Appellant has preferred the present Appeal aggrieved by the
Judgement dated 19.09.2024 in Jitender Yadav vs. Union of India and Ors.,
W.P. (C) No. 12014 of 2015 (hereinafter referred to as „Impugned
Judgement‟) wherein this Court dismissed the Writ Petition filed by the
Appellant for quashing of impugned final result dated 06.11.2013 regarding
selection/appointment of the Respondent No. 3 therein under OBC category
as Staff Car Driver (Ordinary Grade) vide Advertisement No. 01/2011, and,
to pass an order in nature of mandamus directing Respondent No. 1 and 2 to
declare the Appellant as selected under OBC category and appoint the
Appellant as Staff Car Driver (Ordinary Grade) with all consequential
benefits including seniority and arrears of pay.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
2.
Shorn of unnecessary details, the facts leading to the filing of the
present appeal are as follows:
a.
Union of India/Respondent No. 1 and Rajya Sabha Recruitment
Cell/Respondent No. 2 (hereinafter referred to as „Official
Respondents’) invited applications for the post of Staff Car
Driver (Ordinary Grade) under Category VI vide Advertisement
No. 01/2011, which included reserved category seats - 01 in SC,
01 in OBC, and 01 in UR category.
b.
The Appellant applied for the post of Staff Car Driver under the
OBC category and appeared for the written examination in
June, 2013.
c.
Respondent No. 2 declared the final result on 06.11.2013. Mr.
Tej Pal/Respondent No. 3 was the top scorer in the OBC
category with 163 marks securing the position in the OBC
quota. The Appellant scored 158.75 marks, securing the spot
below Mr. Tej Pal/Respondent No.3. Another candidate Mr.
Bhim Singh scored 154 marks and was selected under the UR
category.
d.
In November, 2013, the Appellant filed W.P.(C) 7500/2013
before this Court on the ground that Respondent No. 3 should
have been adjusted against the UR category vacancy based on
merit, despite him applying under the OBC category. Hence, the
Appellant sought his own selection and appointment against the
OBC vacancy and asserted that the appointment of Bhim Singh
under the UR vacancy is bad in law.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
e.
The Appellant then filed an application under the Right to
Information Act, 2005 (RTI) seeking the caste certificate of
Respondent No. 3 which was later provided to the Appellant.
On 23.12.2013, the Appellant submitted a representation to the
Respondents requesting recommendation of his name under
OBC category instead of Respondent No. 3 since as per the
Appellant the Respondent No. 3 was ineligible for appointment
against OBC vacancy as he did not possess the requisite OBC
certificate as per the advertisement.
f.
The Appellant filed W.P.(C) No. 5243/2014 before this Court
seeking appointment under OBC category after being apprised
that the Respondent No. 3 did not possess a valid OBC
certificate. The Writ Petition was dismissed as withdrawn vide
an Order dated 20.08.2014 with directions to the official
Respondents to take appropriate steps pursuant to the final
result declared on 06.11.2013.
g.
This Court vide Order dated 24.08.2015 allowed W.P.(C) No.
7500/2013 and held that Respondent No.3, should have been
adjusted against the UR vacancy and not against the OBC
vacancy. The OBC vacancy should have been filled by the
Appellant as the next available OBC candidate. The final result
dated 06.11.2013 was set aside to the extent of the appointment
of Respondent No.3 and Bhim Singh.
h.
This Order dated 24.08.2015 was challenged by the Official
Respondents in ‘Rajya Sabha Recruitment Cell and Anr. vs.
Jitender Yadav and Ors.’, LPA No. 696/2015. On 7.10.2016,
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
this Court allowed the said appeal filed by the Official
Respondents. This Court held that Respondent No. 3 was
eligible for the appointment under OBC category on account of
availing age relaxation. It was held that his appointment was
valid against the OBC vacancy. The judgment dated 24.08.2015
in W.P.(C) No. 7500/2013 was set aside.
i.
The Appellant filed W.P.(C) No. 12014/2015 seeking quashing
of the final result dated 06.11.2013 concerning the selection and
appointment of the Respondent No.3 under OBC category. This
Court dismissed the said writ petition of the Appellant vide
Order dated 19.09.2024, observing that the issue of Respondent
No.3’s appointment under the OBC category had already been
settled by the Division Bench decision in LPA No. 696/2015
which had attained finality. The Court also held that the Reserve
List of Candidates who took the exam cannot be operated and
thus the Appellant cannot claim appointment against the OBC
vacancy as such unfilled vacancies are carried forward to the
next year.
j.
It is this Order dated 19.09.2024 that has been challenged by
the Appellant by way of filing the present appeal.
3.
The Counsel for the Appellant states that it is well settled law that no
ineligible candidate should be considered for selection since they cannot be
appointed to the post even after their selection. He states that that the
appointment of the next eligible candidate is certain. The Counsel tenders
the decision of Apex Court in DSSSB vs. Lokesh Kumar, W.P.(C) No.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
5236/2012 dated 07.03.2013 stating that this case squarely covers the case of
the Appellant.
4.
It is the case of the Appellant that the Learned Single Judge failed to
appreciate that the issue in LPA No. 696/2015 pertained to the shifting of
category from OBC to UR and not the eligibility of Respondent No. 3 under
the OBC category. As per the Counsel for the Appellant, in the said LPA, it
was held that the Respondent No. 3’s appointment under the OBC category
was correct since he had availed age relaxation under the said category.
However, the judgment did not examine or adjudicate upon the validity of
his OBC certificate or his eligibility under the said category.
5.
It is the case of the Appellant that the Learned Single Judge failed to
appreciate the appointment of Respondent No. 3 was void ab initio as the
certificate of Respondent No. 3 itself was not valid. He submits that the
Respondent’s stand that the reserve list cannot be operated, based on the fact
that SSC does not maintain a reserve list for open competitive examinations
is erroneous and contrary to settled law. The Counsel tenders the judgment
in Union of India vs. Shrey Bajaj, W.P.(C) No. 11739/2016 to support its
arguments.
6.
The Counsel further states that the Learned Single Judge did not
consider the Order dated 20.08.2014 in W.P.(C) No. 5243/2014 as well as
the Order dated 07.08.2015 in C.M. No. 21286/2014, wherein this Court
granted liberty to the Appellant to challenge the decisions of Respondent
No. 1 and 2, both in law and on facts, in accordance with law.
7.
It is the case of the Appellant that once the name of the Appellant was
shown in the list of reserve panel, the principle of legitimate expectation is
attracted and so he had a legitimate right of consideration for appointment.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
8.
The Counsel for the Appellant tendered various judgments to support
its case namely Dinesh Kumar Kashyap & Ors. vs. South East Central
Railways & Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 11360-11363/2018, Gagandeep Singh
vs. State of Punjab & Ors. (2019) 11 SCC 771, and Shiv Krishna Garg vs.
High Court of Madhya Pradesh in W.P.(C) 4792/2020.
9.
Per contra, the Counsel for the Union of India contends that the
Appeal is not maintainable and is liable to be dismissed as the Appellant is
seeking to reopen and reagitate the issues which have already attained
finality.
10.
The Counsel for the Official Respondents state that as per the extant
policy, if an offer of appointment made to any recommended candidate is
cancelled either because the candidate is not found eligible for the post in
any respect or for any other reason, the vacancy so caused is not filled by the
results of that examination. It is carried forward to subsequent recruitment
year and, therefore, if the offer made to Respondent No. 3 is cancelled either
because he is ineligible for appointment against a vacancy reserved for OBC
or otherwise, the vacancy so caused shall not be filled on the basis of the
results of 2011 recruitment but would be carried forward to the subsequent
recruitment year.
It is further stated that the post was advertised vide
Advertisement No. 01/2011 and had been frozen till the pendency of LPA
No. 696/2015, hence, the said vacancy was not carried forward for filling up
through next recruitment drive advertised vide Advertisement No. 01/2016.
11.
The candidature of Respondent No.3 was cancelled on 19.05.2017 as
he failed to submit his caste certificate in the required format as directed
vide OM dated 26.10.2016. Pursuant to cancellation of candidature of
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
Respondent No. 3, the vacancy was then carried forward for being filled in
the next recruitment cycle as per the then extant policy.
12.
It is thus the case of the Official Respondents that once the
candidature of Respondent No. 3 was cancelled, the vacancy was carried
forward to next recruitment cycle without filling up the same from any
reserve list. The decision dated 23.01.2015 of the Official Respondents not
to maintain a reserve panel and to carry forward unfilled vacancies for being
filled in the next recruitment year was never challenged by the Appellant in
earlier writ petitions and the said decision is not open to challenge at this
stage of litigation.
13.
The relief sought by the Appellant in the present Appeal cannot be
granted as the same will have the effect of setting aside the judgment of the
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court. The issue regarding appointment of the
Appellant had attained finality and cannot be re-opened in the present round.
14.
Heard the Counsel for both the sides, and perused the material on
record.
15.
In the opinion of this Court, the learned Single Judge has correctly
noted that the challenge to appointment of Respondent No. 3 was
conclusively determined by the Division Bench in LPA 696/2015. The
subject matter, i.e., the eligibility of the Appellant to hold the OBC seat
under the same advertisement stood adjudicated. The earlier round of
litigation was squarely concerned with the validity of selection of
Respondent No. 3 under the OBC category, which is the very issue sought to
be reopened now. Judicial finality attaches not only to what was expressly
decided, but also to what might and ought to have been raised in the earlier
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
proceedings. The Apex Court in Sulthan Said Ibrahim v. Prakasan & Ors,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1218, has held as under:
“53. The High Court, in its impugned order, held the
application of the appellant under Order I Rule 10 to
be barred by res judicata and thus not maintainable on
that ground. We find no infirmity in the said
observation mad by the High Court. This Court
in Bhanu Kumar Jain v. Archana Kumar reported
in (2005) 1 SCC 787 observed that the principles of res
judicata apply not only to two different proceedings but
also to different stages of the same proceeding as well.
The
relevant
observations
are
reproduced
hereinbelow:
“18. It is now well settled that principles of res
judicata apply in different stages of the same
proceedings. (See Satyadhyan Ghosal v. Deorajin
Debi [AIR 1960 SC 941 : (1960) 3 SCR 590]
and Prahlad Singh v. Col. Sukhdev Singh [(1987)
1 SCC 727].)
19. In Y.B. Patil [(1976) 4 SCC 66] it was held :
(SCC p. 68, para 4)
“4. … It is well settled that principles of res
judicata can be invoked not only in separate
subsequent proceedings, they also get
attracted in subsequent stage of the same
proceedings. Once an order made in the
course of a proceeding becomes final, it
would be binding at the subsequent stage of
that proceeding.”
xxx xxx xxx
21. Yet again in Hope Plantations Ltd. [(1999) 5
SCC 590] this Court laid down the law in the
following terms : (SCC p. 604, para 17)
“17. … One important consideration of
public policy is that the decisions
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
pronounced by courts of competent
jurisdiction should be final, unless they are
modified or reversed by appellate
authorities; and the other principle is that no
one should be made to face the same kind of
litigation twice over, because such a process
would be contrary to considerations of fair
play and justice.””
(Emphasis supplied)
54. Thus, as the dictum of the law as extracted
aforesaid indicates, the only manner in which a
decision arrived at by a court of competent jurisdiction
can be interfered with is by modification or reversal by
the appellate authorities. In the present case, the order
for impleadment of the appellant as a legal heir was
made by the Trial Court after due inquiry under Order
XXII, as also observed by the Trial Court in its order
rejecting the application under Order I Rule 10.
Evidently, neither any objection was raised by the
appellant before the Trial Court nor any revision was
preferred subsequently against the said order. Thus, it
could be said that the issue as regards the impleadment
of the appellant as a legal heir of the original
defendant had attained finality between the parties and
thus the subsequent application under Order I Rule 10
seeking to get his name deleted from the array of
parties could be said to be barred by res judicata.
Undoubtedly, the expression “at any stage of the
proceedings” used in Order I Rule 10 allows the court
to exercise its power at any stage, however the same
cannot be construed to mean that the defendant can
keep reagitating the same objection at different stages
of the same proceeding, when the issue has been
determined conclusively at a previous stage. Allowing
the same would run contrary to the considerations of
fair play and justice and would amount to keeping the
parties in a state of limbo as regards the adjudication
of the disputes.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
55. This Court in the case of Satyadhyan
Ghosal v. Deorajin Debi reported in(1960) 3 SCR 590,
has noted that the principle of res judicata is essential
in giving a finality to judicial decisions. The relevant
observations are reproduced hereinbelow:
“The principle of res judicata is based on the
need of giving a finality to judicial decisions.
What it says is that once a res is judicata, it shall
not be adjudged again. Primarily it applies as
between past litigation and future litigation. When
a matter — whether on a question of fact or a
question of law — has been decided between two
parties in one suit or proceeding and the decision
is final, either because no appeal was taken to a
higher court or because the appeal was dismissed,
or no appeal lies, neither party will be allowed in
a future suit or proceeding between the same
parties to canvass the matter again. This principle
of res judicata is embodied in relation to suits in
Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure; but
even where Section 11 does not apply, the
principle of res judicata has been applied by
courts for the purpose of achieving finality in
litigation. The result of this is that the original
court as well as any higher court must in any
future litigation proceed on the basis that the
previous decision was correct. The principle of
res judicata applies also as between two stages in
the same litigation to this extent that a court,
whether the trial court or a higher court having at
an earlier stage decided a matter in one way will
not allow the parties to re-agitate the matter
again at a subsequent stage of the same
proceedings. …”
(Emphasis supplied)
56. This Court in S. Ramachandra Rao v. S.
Nagabhushana Rao reported in 2022 SCC OnLine SC
1460 observed that although a decision may be
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
erroneous, yet it would bind the parties to the same
litigation and concerning the same issue, if it is
rendered by a court of competent jurisdiction. The
observations read thus:
“31. For what has been noticed and discussed in
the preceding paragraphs, it remains hardly a
matter of doubt that the doctrine of res judicata is
fundamental to every well regulated system of
jurisprudence, for being founded on the
consideration of public policy that a judicial
decision must be accepted as correct and that no
person should be vexed twice with the same kind
of litigation. This doctrine of res judicata is
attracted not only in separate subsequent
proceedings but also at the subsequent stage of
the same proceedings. Moreover, a binding
decision cannot lightly be ignored and even an
erroneous decision remains binding on the parties
to the same litigation and concerning the same
issue, if rendered by a Court of competent
jurisdiction. Such a binding decision cannot be
ignored even on the principle of per incuriam
because that principle applies to the precedents
and not to the doctrine of res judicata.”
57. A five-Judge Bench of the Calcutta High Court
in Tarini
Charan
Bhattacharya v. Kedar
Nath
Haldar reported
in 1928
SCC
OnLine
Cal
172 considered the question as regards whether an
erroneous decision on a point of law would operate
as res judicata between the parties or not. The
court inter alia observed that it is not always open to
the party to raise a point of law. It further held that
Section 11 of the CPC makes the decision of the court
conclusive between the parties notwithstanding the
reasoning employed by the court in arriving at the said
decision. The relevant observations are as under:
“(1) The question whether a decision is correct or
erroneous has no bearing upon the question
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
Whether it operates or does not operate as res
judicata. The doctrine is that in certain
circumstances the Court shall not try a suit or
issue but shall deal with the matter on the footing
that it is a matter no longer open to contest by
reason of a previous decision. In these
circumstances it must necessarily be wrong for a
Court to try the suit or issue, come to its own
conclusion thereon, consider whether the previous
decision is right and give effect to it or not
according as it conceives the previous decision to
be right or wrong. To say, as a result of such
disorderly procedure, that the previous decision
was wrong and that it was wrong on a point of
law/or on a pure point of law, and that therefore it
may be disregarded, is an indefensible form of
reasoning. For this purpose, it is not true that a
point of law is always open to a party.
(2) In India, at all events, a party who takes a plea
of res judicata has to show that the matter directly
and substantially in issue has been directly and
substantially in issue in the former suit and also
that it has been heard and finally decided. This
phrase “matter directly and substantially in
issue” has to be given a sensible and businesslike
meaning, particularly in view of Expl. 4 to
sec. 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure which
contains the expression “grounds of defence or
attack.” Sec. 11 of the Code says nothing about
causes of action, a phrase which always requires
careful handling. Nor does the section say
anything about point or points of law, or pure
points of law. As a rule parties do not join issue
upon academic or abstract questions but upon
matters of importance to themselves. The section
requires that the doctrine be restricted to matters
in issue and of these to matters which are directly
as well as substantially in issue.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
(3) Questions of law are of all kinds and cannot
be dealt with as though they were all the same.
Questions of procedure, questions affecting
jurisdiction, questions of limitation, may all be
questions of law. In such questions the rights, of
parties are not the only matter for consideration.
The Court and the public have an interest. When a
plea of res judicata is raised with reference to
such matters, it is at least a question whether
special considerations do not apply.
(4) In any case in which it is found that the matter
directly and substantially in issue has been
directly and substantially in issue in the former
suit and has been heard and finally decided by
such Court, the principle of res judicata is not to
be ignored merely on the ground that the
reasoning, whether in law or otherwise, of the
previous decision can be attacked on a particular
point. On the other hand it is plain from the terms
of sec. 11 of the Code that what is made
conclusive between the parties is the decision of
the Court and that the reasoning of the Court is
not necessarily the same thing as its decision. The
object of the doctrine of res judicata is not to
fasten upon parties special principles of law as
applicable to them inter se, but to ascertain their
rights and the facts upon which these rights
directly and substantially depend; and to prevent
this ascertainment from becoming nugatory by
precluding the parties from re-opening or
recontesting that which has been finally decided.”
(Emphasis supplied)”
16.
Explanation IV to Section 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908,
further strengthens the operation of res judicata, which is as under:
“Section 11. Res judicata.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
No Court shall try any suit or issue in which the matter
directly and substantially in issue has been directly and
substantially in issue in a former suit between the same
parties, or between parties under whom they or any of
them claim, litigating under the same title, in a Court
competent to try such subsequent suit or the suit in
which such issue has been subsequently raised, and
has been heard and finally decided by such Court.
……….
Explanation IV.-- Any matter which might and ought to
have been made ground of defence or attack in such
former suit shall be deemed to have been a matter
directly and substantially in issue in such suit.”
17.
Even otherwise, a candidate in a panel or waitlist does not have a right
to appointment. He merely acquires a right to be considered in accordance
with rules, subject to availability of vacancy and subject to no legal
impediment. Since Respondent No. 3’s selection attained finality, no
vacancy survived for the Appellant to stake claim upon.
18.
The challenge raised by the Appellant is barred by res judicata, and
more importantly, by constructive res judicata. The Appellant had ample
opportunity in earlier proceedings but failed to raise the objections he now
presses. The law does not permit litigants to reopen matters in instalments.
The learned Single Judge rightly refused to disturb the concluded
appointment of Respondent No. 3. We find no infirmity in the impugned
judgment.
19.
The judgments tendered by the Learned Counsel for the Appellant are
not applicable to the present facts of the Appeal due to constructive res
judicata barring the Appellant to reagitate the issues which already stands
adjudicated in LPA 696/2015.
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
20.
The present Appeal is accordingly dismissed, along with pending
application(s), if any.
SUBRAMONIUM PRASAD, J
VIMAL KUMAR YADAV, J
JANUARY 07, 2026
MT
Signed By:RAHUL
SINGH
20:56:09
LPA 1189/2024
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review