Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 20.07.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 20.08.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 20.08.2026
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010448372023
CUSAA 82/2023, CM APPL. 57697/2023
PARVEEN KUMAR JAIN
.....Appellant
Through: Mr Kamal Mehta Senior
Advocate with Dr Sushil
Kumar Gupta and Ms. Anshika
Kumari Advs.
versus
PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT)
ICD, TKD, NEW DELHI
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Vikrant Nilesh Goyal, Mr.
Inderpreet Singh, Mr. Kunal
Dixit, Advs.
Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010448402023
CUSAA 83/2023, CM APPL. 57699/2023, CM APPL.
27569/2026
BIMAL PAPERS PVT. LTD.
.....Appellant
Through: Mr Kamal Mehta Senior
Advocate with Dr Sushil
Kumar Gupta and Ms. Anshika
Kumari Advs.
versus
PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates
#
+
CNR No. DLHC011028232025
CUSAA 177/2025, CM APPL. 79867/2025, CM APPL.
79870/2025, CM APPL. 16640/2026
MS MUKTA ENTERPRISES
.....Appellant
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC, Mr.
Dipak Raj, Mr. Aryaman Singh
Chouhan,
Mr.
Aditya
Chaudhary, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC011028242025
CUSAA 178/2025, CM APPL. 80092/2025, CM APPL.
80096/2025, CM APPL. 16648/2026
M/S RAJA RAM AND COMPANY
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT)
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC011028252025
CUSAA 179/2025, CM APPL. 80160/2025, CM APPL.
80163/2025
RAJINDER KUMAR JAIN
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT .....Respondent
Through: Mr. Anurag Ojha, SSC, Mr.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Dipak Raj, Mr. Aryaman Singh
Chouhan,
Mr.
Aditya
Chaudhary, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC011028262025
CUSAA 180/2025, CM APPL. 80234/2025, CM APPL.
80238/2025
JINENDER KUMAR JAIN
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
PRINCIPAL COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT
.....Respondent
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010552512019
W.P.(C) 12233/2019, CM APPL. 4168/2024, CM APPL.
16717/2026
M/S SUMAT PERSHAD AND SONS AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER CUSTOMS (EXPORT) AND ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010745652025
W.P.(C) 15114/2025, CM APPL. 62118/2025
MS KAPIL PAP MART PVT LTD
.....Petitioner
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Raj Kumar, CGSC With
Ms Vandana Sachdeva and Ms
Vidushi Sah Advocates
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010287422020
W.P.(C) 8248/2020, CM APPL. 26724/2020, CM APPL.
32123/2021, CM APPL. 4160/2024, CM APPL. 16683/2026
MS SUMAT PERSHAD SONS & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Sushil kumar Pandey SPC,
Mr. Aman Kumar Pandey, Mr
Pradip Sharma Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010330042020
W.P.(C) 9868/2020, CM APPL. 31491/2020, CM APPL.
16695/2026
MS RAJA RAM & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Virender Pratap Singh
Charak and Ms. Shubhra
Parashar Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010330062020
W.P.(C) 9869/2020, CM APPL. 31493/2020, CM APPL.
16715/2026
M/S JUNEJA PAPERS PVT. LTD. & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010240232021
W.P.(C) 8039/2021, CM APPL. 25019/2021, CM APPL.
4163/2024, CM APPL. 16707/2026
M/S SUNEJA SONS & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010241442021
W.P.(C) 8122/2021, CM APPL. 25215/2021, CM APPL.
32144/2021, CM APPL. 16716/2026
M/S KRAFTLINE INTERNATIONAL & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harish Kumar Garg &. Ms.
Nisha Advocates
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010022762022
W.P.(C) 232/2022, CM APPL. 4166/2024, CM APPL.
16691/2026
MS JUNEJA TRADE LINKS
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advs.
Mr Nirvikar verma, SPC
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010148662022
W.P.(C) 6209/2022, CM APPL. 4194/2024, CM APPL.
16689/2026
AJAY PAPER CORPORATION
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
Ms. Nidhi Banga, Senior Panel
Counsel for Respondent/UOI
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010149152022
W.P.(C) 6239/2022, CM APPL. 4193/2024, CM APPL.
16706/2026
S D ENTERPRISES
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
#
+
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
CNR No. DLHC010151262022
W.P.(C) 6299/2022, CM APPL. 4157/2024, CM APPL.
16705/2026
KHURANA PAPER HOUSE
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC CBIC,
Ms. Arya Suresh Nair, advs.
Ms. Uma Prasuna Bachu, SPC
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010218272022
W.P.(C) 8763/2022, CM APPL. 26389/2022, CM APPL.
26390/2022, CM APPL. 4284/2024, CM APPL. 16710/2026
M/S SHREE PAPER CO. PVT. LTD.
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (EXPORT) & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
Mr. Farman Ali CGSC, Ms.
Usha jamnal Adv, Ms. Tanya
Advs.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010330622020
W.P.(C) 9903/2020, CM APPL. 4191/2024, CM APPL.
16714/2026
M/S S. D. ENTERPRISES
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Shubhra Parashar and Mr
Virender Pratap Singh Charak
Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010242722023
W.P.(C) 9923/2020, CM APPL. 31611/2020, CM APPL.
4170/2024, CM APPL. 16704/2026
M/S RAJA RAM AND CO & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Virender Pratap Singh
Charak
and
Ms.Shubhra
Parashar Advocates
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010245642023
W.P.(C) 9924/2020, CM APPL. 31613/2020, CM APPL.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
4195/2024, CM APPL. 28570/2026, CM APPL. 43133/2026
M/S KHURANA PAPER HOUSE
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC CBIC,
Ms. Arya Suresh Nair, advs.
Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010331332020
W.P.(C) 9925/2020, CM APPL. 31615/2020,CM APPL.
4278/2024, CM APPL. 28562/2026, CM APPL. 43357/2026
M/S SUMAT PERSHAD AND SONS & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Shubhra Parashar and
Mr.Virender
Pratap
Singh
Charak Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010114762021
W.P.(C) 2850/2021, CM APPL. 8591/2021, CM APPL.
32132/2021, CM APPL. 4182/2024, CM APPL. 28572/2026,
CM APPL. 43137/2026
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
MS KHURANA PAPER HOUSE & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC CBIC,
Ms. Arya Suresh Nair, advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010151402021
W.P.(C) 4386/2021, CM APPL. 13353/2021, CM APPL.
4286/2024, CM APPL. 28563/2026, CM APPL. 43107/2026
MS BIRDHI CHAND GIRDHARI LAL PAPERS PVT LTD &
ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010057342021
W.P.(C) 118/2021, CM APPL. 369/2021, CM APPL.
4285/2024, CM APPL. 16699/2026
MS SUMAT PERSHAD SONS & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Shubhra Parashar and
Mr.Virender
Pratap
Singh
Charak Advocates
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010057632021
W.P.(C) 141/2021, CM APPL. 425/2021, CM APPL.
4177/2024
MS KRAFTILE INTERNATIONAL
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harish Kumar Garg &. Ms.
Nisha Advocates.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010114462021
W.P.(C) 2838/2021, CM APPL. 8529/2021, CM APPL.
32170/2021, CM APPL. 4158/2024, CM APPL. 16701/2026
MS SUMAT PERSHAD SONS & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
#
+
Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates.
Ms. Shubhra Parashar and
Mr.Virender
Pratap
Singh
Charak Advocates
CNR No. DLHC010114602021
W.P.(C) 2842/2021, CM APPL. 8560/2021, CM APPL.
4202/2024, CM APPL. 16697/2026
M/S SUMAT PERSHAD & SONS AND ORS. .....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates
Ms. Shubhra Parashar and
Mr.Virender
Pratap
Singh
Charak Advocates
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010150462021
W.P.(C) 4345/2021, CM APPL. 4199/2024, CM APPL.
13262/2021, CM APPL. 16702/2026
MS BIRDHI CHAND GIRDHARI LAL PAPERS PVT LTD &
ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010150852021
W.P.(C) 4368/2021, CM APPL. 13302/2021, CM APPL.
32125/2021, CM APPL. 4178/2024, CM APPL. 16703/2026
M/S SHITAL PAPER IMPEX
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010151342021
W.P.(C) 4380/2021, CM APPL. 13344/2021, CM APPL.
4283/2024, CM APPL. 16679/2026
M/S KALRA PAPER CONVERTER AND TRADER PVT.
LTD. & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Jitesh Vikram Srivastava,
Ms.
Suramya
Srivastava
Advocates.
Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010151422021
W.P.(C) 4388/2021, CM APPL. 13357/2021, CM APPL.
32169/2021, CM APPL. 4179/2024, CM APPL. 28573/2026,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
CM APPL. 43119/2026
M/S KAPIL PAP MART PVT LTD & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Virender Pratap Singh
Charak
and
Ms.Shubhra
Parashar Advocates
Mr. Harpreet Singh, Senior
Standing Counsel with Mr.
Jatin Kumar Gaur, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010152192021
W.P.(C) 4409/2021, CM APPL. 13497/2021, CM APPL.
4171/2024, CM APPL. 16712/2026
MS KALRA PAPER PRODUCTS PVT LTD & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
1.
#
+
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
CNR No. DLHC010239252021
W.P.(C) 7987/2021, CM APPL. 24822/2021, CM APPL.
4180/2024, CM APPL. 61266/2025, CM APPL. 16709/2026
MS DIAMOND COPY HOUSE & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010239382021
W.P.(C) 8000/2021, CM APPL. 24843/2021, CM APPL.
4174/2024, CM APPL. 16663/2026
M/S SONA PAPERS PVT. LTD. & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (IMPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Ripu Daman Bhardwaj
(CGSC) and Mr. Kushagra
Kumar, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010240322021
W.P.(C) 8047/2021, CM APPL. 25031/2021, CM APPL.
32166/2021, CM APPL. 4165/2024, CM APPL. 28564/2026,
CM APPL. 43143/2026
M/S JUNEJA PAPERS PVT LTD & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
#
+
Mr. Vijay Joshi, CGSC, Mr.
Shubham Chaturvedi, Adv.
CNR No. DLHC010151012022
W.P.(C) 6288/2022, CM APPL. 4203/2024, CM APPL.
28569/2026, CM APPL. 43136/2026
KRAFTILE INTERNATIONAL
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advs.
Mr. Vedansh Anand (SPC), Mr.
Shivam Kumar (GP) & Mr.
kush Garg, Adv.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010151522022
W.P.(C) 6313/2022, CM APPL. 4279/2024, CM APPL.
43039/2026
RAJA RAM CO & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Suraj Shekhar Singh and Mr.
Tushar Bhalla, Advocates
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010151852022
W.P.(C) 6331/2022, CM APPL. 4175/2024, CM APPL.
28565/2026
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
INDIRA OFFSET PRINTERS PVT LTD & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS IMPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Tanveer Ahmed Ansari
Senior Panel Counsel
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010232302022
W.P.(C) 9334/2022, CM APPL. 4164/2024, CM APPL.
16711/2026
M/S ARUN AND CO. & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS (EXPORT) & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Aditya Singla, SSC CBIC,
Ms. Arya Suresh Nair, advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010281632022
W.P.(C) 11146/2022, CM APPL. 32756/2022, CM APPL.
4181/2024, CM APPL. 28566/2026
MS SUNEJA SONS AND ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
#
+
Ms. Anushree Narain, SSC with
Mr. Apurv Yadav & Mr.
Naman Choula, Advocates.
CNR No. DLHC010374232022
W.P.(C) 14138/2022, CM APPL. 43180/2022, CM APPL.
4167/2024, CM APPL. 16676/2026
M/S JAIN ENTERPRISES
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms.Anushree Narain (SCC),
Mr.Apurv Yadav and
Mr.Naman Choula, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010377872022
W.P.(C) 14263/2022, CM APPL. 43555/2022, CM APPL.
4173/2024, CM APPL. 4840/2025, CM APPL. 28571/2026
MS GUNSHIKA MARKETING CO & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates.
Mr. Piyush Beriwal, Advocate.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010271712023
W.P.(C) 9480/2023, CM APPL. 36221/2023, CM APPL.
4172/2024, CM APPL. 28567/2026
JAYSON INTERNATIONAL & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Through:
Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Sh. Atul Tripathi, SSC, CBIC,
Mr. Shubham Mishra and Mr.
Akshay Sagar, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010271942023
W.P.(C) 9500/2023, CM APPL. 36302/2023, CM APPL.
4176/2024, CM APPL. 16713/2026
BRIJBASI ART PRESS LTD & ANR.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Gibran Naushad, SSC with
Mr. Suraj Shekhar Singh and
Mr. Tushar Bhalla, Advocates
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010272132023
W.P.(C) 9506/2023, CM APPL. 36338/2023, CM APPL.
4192/2024, CM APPL. 27910/2026, CM APPL. 43105/2026,
CM APPL. 45432/2026
KALRA PAPER CONVERTOR TRADER PVT LTD & ORS.
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Vivek Goyal, CGSPC with
Mr. Aryan Aggarwal, Advs.
#
+
CNR No. DLHC010332722023
W.P.(C) 11246/2023, CM APPL. 43800/2023, CM APPL.
4159/2024, CM APPL. 16708/2026
JUNEJA TRADE LINKS
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Kamal Mehta, Sr. Counsel
with Dr. Sushil Kumar Gupta,
Ms. Sunita Gupta & Ms.
Anshika Kumari, Advocates.
versus
COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS EXPORT & ANR.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Preet Pal Singh, Mrs.
Tanupreet Kaur, Mr Gaurav
Ms. Pooja and Ms Simran
Advs.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SHAIL JAIN
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.:
A.
INTRODUCTION:
1.
The present batch of 6 Appeals challenges the final Orders of
Customs, Excise and Service Tax Appellate Tribunal1, whereas, in the
batch of 41 Writ Petitions, various Orders-in-Original issued by the
Commissioner of Customs, Inland Container Depot, Tuglakabad, New
Delhi2 have been questioned.
2.
The present batch arises out of a common substratum of facts
hereinafter referred to as „CESTAT‟
hereinafter referred to as ICD
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
concerning large-scale customs duty evasion through forged and
manipulated licenses/duty credit scrips3 by importers4 of paper and
paper articles at the ICD during the period 2011 to 2015. Since the
questions of law and fact are substantially common, the matters were
heard together and are being disposed of by this common judgment.
3.
To maintain brevity and avoid repetition, CUSAA 178/2025 is
being treated as the lead matter for deciding the batch of Customs
Appeals, whereas W.P.(C) 12233/2019 is being treated as the lead
matter, as and when required, for deciding the connected batch of Writ
Petitions.
B.
BRIEF BACKGROUND:
4.
Pithily put, during the relevant period, Appellant imported
paper and paper articles through ICD and discharged applicable
customs duty by utilising transferable scrips issued under various
export promotion schemes formulated under the Foreign Trade Policy
(FTP), including the Duty Free Import Authorisation („DFIA‟), Focus
Product Scheme („FPS‟), Focus Market Scheme („FMS‟), Vishesh
Krishi and Gram Udyog Yojana („VKGUY‟) and Duty Entitlement
Pass Book („DEPB‟) Scheme.
5.
Notably, these scrips, once issued by the Directorate General of
Foreign Trade („DGFT‟), are freely transferable in terms of the
applicable FTP and are capable of being utilized for payment of
customs duty upon registration with the Customs Authorities („CA‟).
hereinafter referred to as scrips
Appellants/Petitioners
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
6.
The present impugned proceedings find their genesis in the
detection of large-scale irregularities in the Electronic Data
Interchange („EDI‟)/Indian Customs EDI System („ICES‟) functioning
at ICD. The investigation undertaken by the CA disclosed the
involvement of M/s Kirti Cargo, a Customs Broker (earlier known as
Customs House Agent), its G-Card holder Mr. Sharafat Hussain, and
Mr. Vinod Kumar Pathror, in a systematic scheme for evasion of
customs duty through the use of forged and manipulated scrips.
Modus Operandi adopted for manipulation/forgery of scrips:
7.
The investigation revealed that Mr. Sharafat Hussain was
engaged in sale/purchase of scrips originally issued by the DGFT in
favour of exporters, through the front-end entities owned and
controlled by him, including M/s Ganpati, M/s Zealous International,
M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd., and M/s Fibre Exim etc.
8.
It further emerged that Mr. Vinod Kumar Pathror, while acting
as an employee of M/s Kirti Cargo, illegally accessed the EDI system
and manipulated the digital records of these scrips, by artificially
enhancing their value (for instance, increasing a scrip of Rs. 100 to Rs.
10,000) or by reusing scrips whose entitlement had already been
exhausted or by using scrips that were non-existent on the DGFT
records.
Role of the Appellant:
9.
The Appellant availed the services of Mr. Sharafat Hussain for
customs clearance and discharged their statutory duty liability by
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
debiting these forged and manipulated scrips, resulting in unlawful
availment of exemption and evasion of legitimate customs duty.
10.
Consequently, a Show Cause Notices (SCN) came to be issued
by the Commissioner, Customs, proposing recovery of customs duty
under Section 28(4) of the Act of 1962, together with interest under
Section 28AA, confiscation of the imported goods under Section
111(d) and 111(o), and imposition of penalties under Sections
112(b)(ii), 114A and 114AA thereof.
11.
Following which, prior to the commencement of adjudication
proceedings, the Appellant by way of multiple communications
sought production of various departmental records, including copies
of the scrips, Bills of Entry (BoE) and other documents relied upon in
the SCN, besides seeking cross-examination of the concerned
Customs officers.
12.
At this stage, it is pertinent to highlight that the issue pertaining
to production of documents has already seen the light of this Court at
the behest of the Petitioner in W.P.(C) 12233/2019, who initially filed
a petition bearing no. W.P.(C) 9680/2019 captioned M/s Sumat
Pershad and Sons and Anr. v. Commissioner of Customs (Export)
and Anr., wherein this Court by way of its Order dated 06.09.2019,
while disposing of the said Petition directed the Respondents to decide
the Petitioner‟s representation dated 30.07.2019, seeking cross
examination of witnesses and production of certain documents.
13.
Thereafter, the Adjudicating Authority proceeded to pass an
OIO dated 11.10.2019, which came to be the subject matter of
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
challenge in W.P.(C) 12233/2019, wherein the Petitioner, raised a
ground that despite earlier directions of this Court, the request for
supply of documents were not conceded. The said Petition, however,
was disposed of by way of judgment dated 27.11.2019.
14.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioner approached the Supreme
Court by way of SLP(C) No. 30509 of 2019 captioned M/s Sumat
Pershad and Sons & Anr. v. Commissioner of Customs (Export) &
Anr., wherein the Court by its Order dated 09.01.2020, granted liberty
to the Petitioner to seek review of the judgment dated 27.11.2019,
with the following observations:
“Learned counsel for the petitioners invited our attention to
paragraph 39 of the Writ Petition to contend that the specific
grievance of the petitioners was that the authority did not furnish
copies of the relevant documents referred to in paragraph 7 of the
communication dated 30.07.2019, despite the direction issued by the
High Court and yet proceeded to pass Order-in-Original No.
06/2019/SUNIL TATED/COMR/EXP/ICD/TKD (DIGIT NO.
20180220161942-903 on 11.10.2019, that too without giving any
opportunity of hearing to the petitioners. That grievance has been
glossed over by the High Court.
In that case, it will be open to the petitioners to resort to remedy of
review before the High Court, which be filed within four weeks from
today.
If the Review Petition is decided against the petitioners, it will be
open to the petitioners to challenge the said decision as well as the
impugned judgment by way of Special Leave petition before this
Court.”
(emphasis supplied)
15.
Pursuant to the liberty granted by the Supreme Court, a Review
Petition was preferred before this Court and by Order dated
30.10.2023 the Review Petition bearing Rev. Pet. No.31/2020 was
allowed, with a finding that the earlier judgment proceeded on an
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
incorrect premise that the representation dated 30.07.2019 had been
adequately dealt with, consequently, W.P.(C) 12233/2019 was
restored to its original number for fresh consideration.
16.
In the interregnum, the Adjudicating Authority while dealing
with the SCN issued against the Appellant, ultimately confirmed the
demands of duty, interest and penalties, which came to be upheld by
the CESTAT. Aggrieved thereby, the Order of the CESTAT along
with connected writ proceedings arising from the same investigation,
are before this Court seeking our indulgence.
C.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
17.
Mr. Kamal Mehta, learned senior counsel representing the
Importers, has made the following submissions:
17.1
At the outset, it has been contended that the Respondents
proceeded in an arbitrary, irrational and premeditated manner
against the importers by initiating these proceedings via issuance of
the impugned SCN. Against this backdrop, it has been argued that
their entire case, alleging forgery and manipulation of scrips, is
based solely upon manipulated entries in the EDI system.
17.2
It is contended that the Respondents have completely
ignored primary evidence, namely, original BoE, scrips, bank
transfer certificates, and endorsements, which were physically
presented, verified, and accepted as genuine by the CA between
2011 and 2015. Therefore, the presumption of forgery without
comparing it against original documents is legally unsustainable, as
a forgery must be proven against an original document, not a
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
subsequent electronic copy.
17.3
Learned senior counsel, has argued that the Respondent‟s
approach is glaringly contradictory to its own established statutory
regulations and procedures, as well as its own RTI replies. It is his
case that the import customs clearance process operates in two
stages. At the first stage, the goods get cleared after physical
verification; following which, at the second stage, the data is
entered into the EDI system, both of which falls exclusive within
the domain of the CA.
17.4
Reference has also been made to the statutory procedure
involving a stringent seven-stage process, namely, (i) registration of
Duty Free Licence on Customs Computer System after verification
of Physical copy of Licence; (ii.) in-line verification of Licence;
(iii) approval of Licence Registration by higher authority; (iv)
debits on physical copy of Licence and on-line debits; (v) approval
of Licence Debits by l:Iigher authority; (vi) Audit of Licence
Debits; and (vii) verification that Customs Duty has been paid
before Customs out of charge, to argue that these steps are carried
out strictly by Customs Officers without any involvement of the
importer. Further reliance has been placed on the RTI replies from
the CA, to argue that the said replies, itself unequivocally confirm
that no outsider can enter the Customs computer room, nor can they
register, debit, audit or tamper with the licenses in the EDI system.
17.5
In regard to the aforestated, reliance has also been placed
on the judgment dated 31.05.2018 passed by this Court in W.P.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
(Crl) 1338 of 2018 captioned Farha Hussain v. Union of India &
Ors., to argue that EDI system is a completely secured system that
can only be accessed by Customs officials through a unique Single
Sign-On Identity (SSOID) and passwords that are mandatorily
changed every 15 days. Therefore, it is practically impossible for an
outsider or importer to hack the system or tamper with the entries
after the goods have already been cleared, as the Petitioner had no
motive or opportunity to do so.
17.6
Reliance is also placed on the Order dated 20.11.2025
passed by this Court in the present batch, to argue that inspection of
the relevant documents was directed by this Court. In compliance
thereof, the Inspection Report dated 18.12.2025 was submitted by
the Department, which itself records that the essential documents,
including the original scrips/licences, Transfer Letters, Debit Sheets
and BoE, are “NOT AVAILABLE”. This non-production of
primary documents is argued to strike at the root of the SCN,
rendering it a case of no evidence and acting as a tell-tale story in
the importers‟ favour.
17.7
Moreover, it is his case that the Respondents have
arbitrarily denied importers an opportunity to cross-examine the
Customs Officers whose signatures and stamps authorized the
clearance of the goods, reducing the adjudication process to an
empty formality.
17.8
Additionally,
it
has
also
been
argued
that
the
Adjudicating Authority has exercised jurisdiction with material
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
irregularity, constituting an error of law under the Wednesbury
principle of unreasonableness. By assuming jurisdiction based on
entirely irrelevant material (the tampered electronic EDI entries)
and totally ignoring the relevant material (the physically verified
original documents), the decision is manifestly erroneous.
17.9.
Relying upon the comparative chart placed on record, it
is contended that material discrepancies exist between the original
BoE and the EDI records, including alterations in dates and
registration numbers. For instance, dates and registration numbers
were mysteriously and maliciously altered only in the electronic
records, such as a license dated “22.02.2010” being manipulated to
“02.02.2010” by simply removing the “2”, while the original
physical documents remained unchanged. Such discrepancies
establish that any manipulation occurred within the Departmentcontrolled EDI system and not in the documents submitted by the
private parties.
17.10
While impugning the Order of the CESTAT, it has been
argued that the reliance upon Munjal Showa Ltd. v. Commissioner
of Customs and Central Excise5, is misplaced, as in that case
forgery of the scrips was independently established, whereas in the
present case the scrips were genuine, verified and accepted by CA
at the time of clearance.
17.11
Lastly, it is contended that the cumulative effect of
issuing the SCN and the subsequent adjudication are founded upon
(2022) 22 GSTR-OL 168
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
unreliable electronic entries, unsupported by primary documents
admittedly unavailable with the Department; the adjudicating
authority proceeded without the necessary jurisdictional facts; the
principles of natural justice have been violated; and the case falls
within the recognised exceptions warranting exercise of writ
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, as laid down in
Godrej Sara Lee Ltd. v. Excise and Taxation Officer-cumAssessing Authority6 and Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of
Trade Marks7.
18.
We deem it appropriate to place on record that, during the
course of hearing, an opportunity was afforded to learned counsels
appearing for the importers to advance any additional submissions, if
so desired. However, no other counsel sought to make any further
submissions, and the arguments on behalf of the importers were
advanced solely by learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Kamal Mehta.
However, at a later stage, on 07.08.2026, learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Appellant in CUSAA 83/2023, placed on record his
submissions, in substance, covering the arguments already advanced
by learned senior counsel.
19.
Per contra, Mr. Harpreet Singh, learned Senior Standing
Counsel representing the Respondents has made the following
submissions:
19.1
It is argued that the original scrips issued by the DGFT
were materially altered before registration in the customs system,
SCC OnLine SC 95
(1998) 8 SCC 1
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
resulting in a difference between the genuine scrips and the
registered scrips. Since the scrips were forged and manipulated,
they were void ab initio and incapable of creating any legal
entitlement. Accordingly, any duty debited through such invalid
instruments cannot be treated as a lawful payment of customs duty
and no statutory benefits can be claimed thereof, making the
importers liable to pay the duty which remained short-paid.
19.2
The contention that the importer was unaware of the
fraud and that liability rests solely on their agent or customs
officials is stated to be legally untenable. In this regard, it is argued
that the adjudicating authority‟s findings establish the importers
negligence, lack of due diligence, and possible complicity.
Although M/s Kirti Cargo was engaged for clearance, the importers
were receiving invoices and making payments to Mr. Sharafat
Hussain‟s front-end entities. Hence, the absence of direct
documentation from M/s Kirti Cargo and billing by unrelated third
parties should have prompted verification of the scrips and licenses
by the importers.
19.3
Learned counsel further relied upon the judgment of
Commissioner of Customs (Preventive) v. M/s. Aafloat Textiles
India Pvt Ltd & Ors.8 and the principle of caveat emptor, applying
the rationale therein to the present matter. He argued that a buyer
purchasing rights or licenses from another is bound in law to take
requisite precautions regarding the title and genuineness of the
purchase and the private parties having failed to undertake any
(2009) 11 SCC 18
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
verification, must face the legal and financial consequences of the
fraud.
19.4
It is contended that under Section 46(4) of the Act of
1962, the importers are statutorily required to subscribe to a
declaration attesting the absolute truth and correctness of the
contents of the BoE. However, by using BoE containing
manipulated scrips the importers clearly misdeclared the facts,
leading to the non-payment of legitimate duty. It is argued that even
if it is presumed for the sake of argument that the importers were
entirely ignorant of the forgery, the fraudulent acts and
misstatements committed by their appointed agent squarely bind
them under the law.
19.5
Reference is also made to Section 28 of the Act of 1962,
to argue that the said provision prescribes a standard limitation
period of five years for issuance of a SCN in cases involving fraud,
collusion, wilful statement or suppression of facts. Hence, the
Adjudicating Authority correctly held that the systematic forgery
of the scrips, coupled with the importers misdeclarations, triggered
this extended period.
19.6
Lastly, with respect to the writ petitions, it has been
argued that the Adjudicating Authority passed a reasoned order
based on undisputed factual findings of forgery. The Petitioners
have bypassed the statutory remedy before CESTAT, the final factfinding authority, and invoked the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of
this Court despite the matter involving only questions of fact and
no substantial question of law and as such interference by this
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Court is unwarranted.
D.
ANALYSIS:
20.
Having heard learned counsel representing the parties at length
and perused the material placed on record, the following issues arise
for consideration:
I.
Whether the Appellant as users/beneficiary of transferrable
scrips (forged/fabricated/manipulated), can avoid liability arising
therefrom, by claiming protection as bona fide purchaser?
II.
Whether the non-availability of the original scrips and allied
documents, coupled with the denial of cross-examination of Customs
Officers, vitiates the impugned proceedings on the ground of violation
of the principles of natural justice?
III.
Whether given the plea that the private parties had no actual
knowledge of forgery, the penalties imposed under Sections 112, and
114A of the Act of 1962 are legally sustainable?
OBSERVATION:
21.
Before proceeding to examine the aforesaid issues, the nature of
the fraud alleged, and the character of material relied upon is
necessary to be noticed. The case set up by the Respondents is not one
of an isolated lapse but of a systemic and continuing arrangement,
spanning several years, whereby scrips genuinely issued by the DGFT
to unrelated exporters were procured from the open market, routed
through entities controlled by Mr. Sharafat Hussain, and thereafter
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
registered in the EDI system either at artificially inflated values or
after their entitlement stood exhausted, or, in certain instances, on the
basis of fictitious instruments.
22.
It is against this factual backdrop, and more particularly in the
light of the statements and admissions recorded under Section 108 of
the Act of 1962, that the issues framed for consideration are required
to be examined. The relevant statements of Mr. Jinender Kumar Jain,
as well as the communication of Mr. Sharafat Hussain received in the
Customs office on 19.07.2016, which forms a part of the analysis is
reproduced hereunder:
“4. And whereas, the assessee was summoned under Section 108 of
Customs Act, 1962 to tender their true and correct statement and
bring all the documents related to their Bills of Entry for import vide
summons dated 19.01.2016 (RUD-I). In response to the said
summons, Sh. Jinender Kumar Jain, Partner in the assessee firm
appeared before the Superintendent (SIIB) on 22.01.2016 and his
statement was recorded under Section 108 of the Act (RUD-II),
wherein, he interalia stated that the other partner in the assessee firm
was his brother Sh. Devinder Kumar Jain and that he himself had
been looking after the major affairs of the firm; that they had been
availing the services of M/s Kirti Cargo for their import clearances;
that Sh. Sharafat Hussain, 'G' card holder of M/s Kirti Cargo was
mainly looking after their import clearance; that Sh. Sharafat Hussain
used to raise his Bills for clearance to them through one of his various
firms viz. M/s Zealous International, D-808, 3rd floor, New Friends
Colony, New Delhi-110065, M/s Zealous Overseas Private Limited,
201, 2nd floor, Tribhuvan Complex, Mathura Road, New Delhi, M/s
Fibertech Impex, M/s Zealous Exim and M/s Zealous Impex. On being
asked as to how they were getting their import consignments cleared,
he stated that they were giving import related documents to Sh.
Sharafat Hussain of M/s Zealous International, who after processing
with the Customs was declaring duty amount along with shipping
company charges etc. After getting those figures, mostly they used to
remit the Customs Import Duty directly to the Customs site. However,
they used to remit the agency charges in respect of the Bills raised by
Sh. Sharafat Hussain through any of his company/ firm in his account
through RTGS or cheques; that they used to contact Sh.. Sharafat
Hussain once the import containers reached Indian ports and
thereafter they used to hand him the required import documents. On
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
being asked as to what instruction or advice Sh. Sharafat Hussain
used to give them in connection with the payment of import duty on
the import consignment, he stated that after they used to hand over the
import documents to Sh. Sharafat Hussain, they used to get an email/telephonic information from his firm giving the details of
Customs duties including the special additional duty and other
charges and thereafter they used to remit the amounts billed to them.
Sh. Jinender Kumar Jain, on being specifically asked as to whether
they ever tried to ascertain from Sh. Sharafat Husssain as to how he
was paying Customs duties on their behalf on their import
consignments, he stated that Sh. Sharafat Hussain used to inform them
the total amount of duty which they had to pay online. This amount
they had been depositing online after verifying it at ICEGATE site. In
respect of the balance amount of the duty, Sh. Sharafat Hussain used
to utilize licenses. Again a specific question was put to Sh. Jinender
Kumar Jain as to whether they ever tried to stop Sh. Sharafat Hussain
from utilizing any license for payment of Customs duty on their behalf
without their permission, to which he categorically stated once or
twice they instructed Sh. Sharafat Hussain verbally not to use licence
but nothing was given in writing. Thereafter, he was asked as to when
Sh. Sharafat Hussain was not listening to their instructions, then why
they still kept on availing his services, Sh. Jinender Kumar Jain stated
that Sh. Sharafat Hussain's services were better to some extent when
compared to other agents; that prompt collection of documents after
receiving out telephonic call, filing of Bill of entry at the earliest, less
demurrage charges etc. were main points in Sh. Sharafat Hussain's
services. On being specifically pointed as to whether defiance of
their instructions by Sh. Sharafat Hussain did not alert them about
Sh. Sharafat Hussain's mischievous activities, Sh. Jinender Kumar
Jain stated that no they never got alerted as they did not doubt Sh.
Sharafat Hussain's activities. On being asked as to whether they
were aware that rest of their Import duties were being paid through
the use of licenses/ scrips/authorization before the goods were
cleared from customs, he stated yes, during the time of payment of
customs duty through ICEGATE, they used to come to know that
license has been used in this bill of entry but actual amount of the
license was informed by Sh. Sharafat Hussain after the clearance of
their consignments. Sh. Sharafat Hussain used to issue them a debit
note informing them the quantum of duty paid through the use of
license/ scrips/ authorization; that Sh. Sharafat Hussain never
sought any permission from them before using any scrip/licence;
that Sh. Sharafat Hussain used to sell the Focus Licenses @ about
98% of the value of the license i.e. 2% less than the value of the
licence; that he exactly did not remember the rates on which DFIAs
were sold to them, however, as far as he remembered, Sh. Sharafat
Hussain used to sell them the DFIA licence at the rate of 15.5% to
16%. Thereafter, Sh. Jinender Kumar Jain stated that sometimes due
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
to use of scrips, their consignments got delayed and they had to pay
demurrage charges. On being specifically pointing out that when
scrips were utilized, they had to incur demurrage charges as per
their statement, then why they did not strongly object to Sh. Sharafat
Hussain's using scrips/licenses for payment of duty on their behalf,
he stated that since Sh. Sharafat Hussain's services were found to be
better, they did not object of usage of scrips. Thereafter, he was
categorically asked as to whether they ever tried to verify the scrips
that were used in payment of customs duties on their behalf, he
stated that they never tried to verify the scrip but relied on the details
in the bill of entry; that they were never in possession of those scrips
which were used by Sh. Sharafat Hussain. However, they had the
copies of the licenses which they had purchased directly from the
open market and handed over to Sh. Sharafat Hussain for use
against their bills of entry. On specifically being asked to explain as
to why they did not verify or saw an instrument which was to be used
for payment of duty on their behalf, in the answer, he stated that
they relied on the particulars mentioned in the Bill of Entry which
bears endorsement from the Customs officials at various stages,
hence they never bothered to have any doubt on the authenticity of
documents involved; that they never possessed the license hence they
never ensured that the particulars filled in the Bill of entry were true
and correct; that they always thought them to be correct since they
were checked by the customs; that they do agree that such scrips are
cash in kind. On being asked as to if at some stage, those scrip's
were found to be tampered or fictitious, could they be utilized for
payment of duty and what they had to say on such scrips, he stated
that these scrips cannot be used for payment of duty; that in his
opinion, it is the importer who is importing goods is responsible for
payment of Customs duties; that CB works for the importer as a
representative; that if CB has done any fraudulent activity after or
before getting full duty amount or scrip premiums as mentioned in
the Bill of Entry which was processed by the Customs, CB should
only be responsible. After explaining the provisions of section 12 of
Customs Act, 1962, he was specifically asked as to who has to ensure
as to correct duty has been paid into government's revenue on imports
made, he stated that when the goods have been received in their
godowns, it means all the duties have been paid and they as importer
have paid the duty; that the duty paid by them at the ICEGATE was
paid by them to the exchequer and balance duty was paid by them to
Sh. Sharafat Hussain. Thereafter he was specifically asked as to
when they never verified the scrips/licences used by Sh. Sharafat
Hussain for payment of customs duty on their behalf, did they ever
try to ensure and verify from Sh. Sharafat Hussain as to the
scrips/licenses intended to be used by him for payment of Customs
duty were indeed genuine, Sh. Jinender Kumar Jain stated that they
never inquired about the genuineness of the scrips intended to be
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
used by Sh. Sharafat Hussain on their behalf since they relied on
the Bill of entry endorsed by the Custom's officer; that it is the
importer who import goods of whose particulars are filled in the Bill
of Entry and not the Customs broker who is working for the
importer. On being asked as to if at some stage after an import, where
goods have moved out of Customs area after Bill of Entry has been
assessed, it is found that proper payment of duty was not made, then
from whom the duty should be charged? Is it the importer or the
Customs broker who is working for the importer? In the answer, he
stated that if any duty has been short paid due to any calculation
mistake or HSN code, it is the importer who will pay the duty short
paid.
5. And whereas, further statement of the assessee was recorded under
Section 108 of the Act on 24.02.2016 (RUD-III) wherein, Sh. Jinender
Kumar Jain, Partner in the assessee firm interalia stated that he
agreed with the contents stated in the statement dated 22.01.2016. On
being asked as to whether they knew any person by the name of Sh.
Ramesh Chadha, he stated that he came to know about one Sh.
Chadhaji, the owner of M/s Kirti Cargo once they started getting M/s
Kirti Cargo's invoices in respect of charges for Customs
documentation, packing repacking, conveyance and agency &
attendance charges; that first invoice received from M/s Kirti Cargo
dated to 28.06.2013; that they never met Sh. Ramesh Chadha in
person neither they had any talk with him; that he met this person
when this investigation commenced. On being asked that before
28.06.2013 who was raising their firms the invoices in respect of the
charges mentioned by him, he stated that before that M/s Zealous
International used to raise them the bills/invoices. He was specifically
asked as to after 28.06.2013, any company/firm of Sh. Sharafat
Hussain raised them any bill/invoice? If yes, then on what account
such documents were raised, he stated that company/firms of Sh.
Sharafat Hussain used to raise their bills/invoices in respect of
Custom entries, examination, transportation, sundry charges, labour
charges agency charges and miscellaneous charges. On being asked
as to whom they had authorized for the services of Custom House
Agent, whether, it was M/s Kirti Cargo or any company/firm of Sh.
Sharafat Hussain, he stated that they had authorized M/s Zealous
International for their Custom Clearance purpose and no
authorization was given to M/s Kirti Cargo; that no written
authorization was given to M/s Zealous International, they were
verbally authorized to act as for their Custom clearance purposes On
being asked as to who was giving them the bills of M/s Kirti Cargo
after 28.06.2013, he stated that it was given by Sh. Sharafat Hussain
or some of his employee. After reminding him that as per his
statement M/s Zealous International was authorized by them
verbally for the purpose of clearance of Custom clearance, he was
specifically asked that did they raise any objection as part of custom
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
clearance was being charged by M/s Kirti Cargo. In the answer, Sh.
Jinender Kumar Jain replied that they had asked bills of M/s Kirti
Cargo from Sh. Sharafat Hussain as on their Bills of Entry, M/s
Kirti Cargo was appearing as the CHA, so as per their Chartered
Accountant's advice, they asked Sh. Sharafat Hussain to give bills of
M/s Kirti Cargo. Thereafter, his attention was brought to the fact
that majority of the charges in respect of the Customs clearance i.e.
75% were raised to them by M/s Zealous International and the rest
of the charges were raised in M/s Kirti Cargo's bills and he was
asked as to did they ever raise this discrepancy with Sh. Sharafat
Hussain as to why charges in respect of services of Custom House
Agent were raised in bills of two different entities, he replied in
negative and further stated that they never asked Sh. Sharafat
Hussain about this discrepancy as they had authorized M/s Zealous
International for Customs clearance purpose and as the imported
goods used to reach them, they never bothered to think on this issue;
that soft copy of the Bill of entry was provided to them by Sh.
Sharafat Hussain during the process of clearance and hard copy
within a span of 3-4 days to two weeks of clearance after they
received the import consignment; that Sh. Sharafat Hussain used to
send them the soft copy and he used to ask them to deposit the duty
amount which used to appear on the screen; that if no duty was to be
paid by utilization of any licence, they used to deposit the full
amount and if some licence was to be used, they used to deposit that
part of duty online that was to be paid in cash. Sh. Jinender Kumar
Jain was then specifically asked as to whether they ever checked the
particulars mentioned in those Bill of entry before making or
releasing payment to Sh. Sharafat Hussain. In the reply, he stated that
they started getting the soft copies only one and half years back and
before that they were not getting the soft copies; that they only
checked the SAD amount in the soft copies as that was to be refunded
to them and that too for their costing purpose. On being asked as to
whether they ever received any bill/invoice/debit note of M/s Kirti
Cargo, he stated that they started receiving bills of M/s Kirti cargo
after 28.06.2013 in respect of the 25% charges of Custom clearance
charges and no debit note was received from M/s Kirti Cargo. After
confronting him with the fact that Kirti Cargo's name always
appeared on their Bills of entry which implies that the CHA was M/s
Kirti Cargo and not any company or firm of Sh. Sharafat Hussain,
he was asked as to whether they ever raised doubt or any query in
this regard with Sh. Sharafat Hussain as to why major clearing
charges were claimed by his company/firm and not the actual CHA
i.e. M/s Kirti Cargo, he again replied in negative and stated that they
never raised any query or doubt with Sh. Sharafat Hussain in this
regard. On being asked as to who was providing them the services of
Custom House Agent? Was it M/s Kirti Cargo or M/s Zealous
Overseas Pvt Ltd/ M/s Zealous International or any other firm of Sh.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Sharafat Hussain, he stated that M/s Zealous International with
proprietor as Sh. Sharafat Hussain was providing them the services
of Custom House Agent; that he did not know as to whether M/s
Zealous International was also holding any Custom House Agent
license. Thereafter on being asked as to when they did not know as to
whether M/s Zealous International was holding any Custom House
agent license or not then did not they try to verify as to on what
authority this firm was engaged in clearing their import consignment,
he stated that as they had been receiving their imported goods after
clearances, they never asked Sh. Sharafat Hussain on this count. He
further stated that they were not registered with Central Excise
department as such they cannot raise cenvatable invoices for their
buyer to avail cenvat on them; that they made payments to their
foreign suppliers through bank on presentation of documents. In some
case, they had sent advance also to the suppliers against sales
confirmation, as the case may be. After inviting his attention to the
provision of section 46 (4) of Customs Act, 1962, Sh. Jinender Kumar
Jain was asked to explain as to declaration in respect of the truth of
contents of Bill of Entry was followed in their Bills of Entry. He
replied that since all their Bills of Entry in question were out of
charge by adopting the proper channel as per the Customs Act, they
do not feel that anything lapsed on their side. He was specifically
asked as to whether particulars of licenses in respect of its number,
date, registration and its date were correctly filled in the Bill of
entries filed by them, he stated that since they did not check these
particulars, he could not say whether those particular were true and
correct. As the goods reached them after custom clearances, he
thought the particulars may be correct and true; that they used to
purchase DFIA licenses between 15.5% to 16.5% of the assessable
value time to time as per the market price. On being asked as to what
percentage this purchase value used to be of the Customs duty
foregone in the DFIA license, he stated that total duty used to be on
paper and board imported by them varies time to time which is
approximately between 20% to 22%, wherein, they are eligible to
claim the SAD mentioned in the BOE, after sales made by them which
comes to between 17 to 17.5% in all. Since the SAD was inclusive in
the total duty foregone under DFIA scheme, they used to get benefit of
1.5 to 2 % on assessable value. In the case of focus licenses and
DEPB books, they were getting the licence at the rate of 98% to 99%
of the value in the licence, however, this is not fixed and it varies as
per the market; that in case the licence was sold on to them on a
taxable invoice, then the purchase value used to be at the rate of 94 to
96% of the value in the licence.
6. And whereas, a statement of Sh. Ramesh Chadha, Proprietor of
Customs broker firm M/s Kirti Cargo, F-110, First floor, Kirti Nagar,
New Delhi-15 was recorded under section 108, of Customs Act, 1962,
on 15/09/15 (RUD- IV), wherein, he interalia stated that he was
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
having CB licence No. R80/98 dated 27/10/98, renewed upto
31/12/2018; that there were 9 (nine) 'G' card holders of his firm; that
Sh. Sharafat Hussain was one of them, holding 'G' Card No.484/99;
that only 5 persons out of the 9 'G' card holders namely Sh. Sharafat
Hussain, Sh. Manmohan, Sh. Roop Tanwar, Sh. Vishal Kohli and Sh.
R.K.Tiwari were coming to ICD, TKD for clearance work; that Sh.
Sharafat Hussain, Sh. Manmohan and Sh. Roop Tanwar were looking
after clearance of paper consignments (Import) and Sh. Vishal Kohli
and Sh. R.K.Tiwari were looking after general cargo. On specifically
being asked, he stated that Sharafat Hussain was looking after the
entire work related to clearance of paper consignments. He further
stated that since last 5 or 6 years, due to old age, sickness and bad
health, he was unable to supervise the whole business of M/s Kirti
Cargo and Sh. Sharafat Hussain was looking after the business for his
firm. On being asked about M/s Zealous International, he stated that
this was may be Sh. Sharafat Hussain's partnership firm and as per
his knowledge, it may be a paper trading firm. He further stated that
Sh. Sharafat Hussain was his authorised 'G' card holder since 1999. A
further statement of Sh. Ramesh Chadha, proprietor M/s Kirti Cargo
was recorded under section 108 of Customs Act, 1962, on 23/01/2016
(RUD-V), wherein, he inter-alia stated that being an old person, he
was not actively involved in the working of the firm and all the work
related to clearance of paper consignments was sub-let to Sh.
Sharafat Hussain and Sh. Sharafat Hussain used to pay him a fixed
amount of Rs.25,000/- per month; that Sh. Sharafat Hussain was
independently involved in the clearance of paper consignments and no
supervision was done by him or instruction was passed to Sh. Sharafat
Hussain in relation to import clearances; that he did not have any
record in relation to the working of M/s Kirti Cargo. On being
specifically asked he stated that he did not have any contact with Sh.
Sharafat Hussain after 15/09/2015.
7. And whereas, in order to ascertain and determine the roles of Sh.
Sharafat Hussain alias Sharafat Ali and Sh. Vinod Kumar Pathror,
both were summoned under Section 108 of Customs Act, 1962 to
tender their true and correct statement. For this purpose, Sh. Sharafat
Hussain was summoned vide summons dated 15.09.15 (addressed at
M/s Kirti Cargo address), 16.09.15 (addressed at M/s Kirti Cargo
address), 21.09.15 (addressed at M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd.),
29.09.15 (addressed at M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd.), 07.10.15
(addressed at M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd.), 15.10.15 (addressed at
M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd.) and 21.10.15 (addressed at M/s
Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd.) (collectively RUD- VI). Sh. Vinod Kumar
Pathror was summoned vide summons dated 17.09.15, 21.09.15,
29.09.15, 07.10.15, 15.10.15 and 21.10.15 addressed at F-632, behind
IGNOU centre, Palam Extension, sector-7, Dwarka, New Delhi
(collectively RUD-VII). Since, Sh. Sharafat Hussain alias Sharafat Ali
and Sh. Vinod Kumar Pathror did not appear in response to the said
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
summons, therefore, complaint under Section 174 & 175 of Indian
Penal Code read with Section 108 of the Customs Act, 1962 were filed
in the Court of Learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate,
Patiala House Courts, New Delhi through Special Public Prosecutor.
Further, Directorate of Revenue Intelligence, New Delhi being the
nodal agency of Central Board of Excise & Customs, Department of
Revenue, Ministry of Finance, Government of India was requested
vide this Commissionerate's letter C. No. VIII/ICD/6/TKD/SIIBExp/Scrip/102/2015/Pt-1/27976 dated 21.12.2015 to get Look Out
Circulars issued from Ministry of Home Affairs in respect of both
these individuals. Further, Assistant Commissioner of Police, Cyber
Crime Cell, New Delhi vide this Commisionerate's letter C.No.
VIII/ICD/6/TKD/SIIB-Exp/Scrip/102/2015/ 3869-3870 dated 05/02/16
was also requested to register First Information Report and to initiate
action under the provisions of Information Technology Act, 2008 read
with applicable provisions of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (as amended).
On the basis of complaint / information shared with EOW, the EOW
has converted the complaint against Sh. Sharafat Hussain and Sh.
Vinod Kumar Pathror into FIR No.0151 dated 19.09.2016.
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
xxxx
10. And whereas, Sh Sharafat Hussain, vide letter dated NIL (RUDXVIII) received in this office on 19.07.2016, inter-alia submitted
that he was doing business of Custom clearing agent under the
license of M/s Kirti Cargo for which he was paying a fixed amount
per month to them; that his major clients were paper importers
besides other importers of paper related products; that he was in
license trade since last 7-8 years and purchasing licenses from
various firms from Delhi, Mumbai and other parts of India; that he
had visited custom house or ICD at rare occasions; that he
purchased license from Sh Vinod Kumar Pathror through his firms
namely HMR International, Mahi International, Mahi Impex and
Rudransh International; that Sh Vinod used to raise debit note / sale
bill for sale of license to his firm; that he was a bonafide purchaser
of licenses purchasing from Mr Vinod Kumar Pathror.
11 To verify the authenticity of facts submitted by Sh Sharafat
Hussain, vide his letter dated 19.07.2016, regarding purchase of
license from various firms which were utilized for payment of
Customs import duty and found to be tampered during the course of
investigation, a statement of Sh Rajesh Kumar Jain, Accountant, of
one exporter namely M/s KS Impex (RUD- XIX) some of whose
licenses were used for imports through M/s Kirti Cargo, was
recorded on 14.09.2016. On being specifically asked regarding
license Nos.0519001934, 0519001935 and 0519001145 issued to M/s
KS Impex by DGFT, he stated that all those 03 licenses were sold to
M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt Ltd, i.e. Sh Sharafat Hussain's company,
and licenses were handed over after receipt of payment. Sh Rajesh
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Kumar Jain submitted the copies of those 03 licenses and sale
invoices.
11.2 On scrutiny, it was observed that license No. 0519001145,
issued by DGFT to M/s K S Impex for value of Rs.5,53,848/-, was
sold by them to M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt Ltd had been fraudulently
registered with Customs EDI System for a value of Rs. 16,53,848/-.
Similarly, license Nos.0519001934 and 0519001935 issued for a
value of Rs.5,85,830/- and Rs.2,34,687/-respectively had been
fraudulently registered with Customs EDI System for a value of
Rs.11,65,830/- and Rs.6,34,687/- respectively. These licenses were
found to be utilized for payment of Customs import duty by various
importers. Hence, it indicated that Sh Sharafat Hussain was
involved in sale and purchase of licenses / scrips and their
subsequent tampering and registration in EDI System.”
(emphasis supplied)
In re: Issue I
23.
The primary contention advanced by the Appellant is that the
scrips were initially issued by the DGFT and were subsequently found
to have been forged or manipulated due to tampering of the EDI
system, without the Appellant having any knowledge or participation
on their part. Accordingly, it is urged that they are entitled to
protection as bona fide purchasers. However, the said submission,
requires the examination by this Court under three distinct questions,
which are as follows:
a.
Whether, the Appellant can avoid liability for the actions
taken by Mr. Sharafat Hussain on its behalf?
b.
Whether the Appellant is entitled to claim an equitable
defence of a bona fide transferee as envisaged under Section 41
of the Transfer of Property Act, 18829?
c.
Whether the Appellant can claim protection under
principle of caveat emptor?
hereinafter referred to as Act of 1882
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
In re: Sub Issue a
24.
The plea of bona fide purchaser raised on account of the
Appellant is to be examined in light of the settled principles governing
the relationship of principal and agent. The attempt of the Appellant to
compartmentalise the acts of Mr. Sharafat Hussain, as those of an
independent intermediary is contrary to both the factual matrix on
record and the settled legal position governing attribution of acts
performed by an authorised representative.
25.
It is an admitted position that Mr. Sharafat Hussain and one of
his front-end entities, namely, M/s Zealous International, was engaged
by the Appellant for handling its customs clearance operations. The
Appellant entrusted him with import documents, authorised him to
process BoE, communicate duty liabilities, coordinate customs
formalities, and arrange utilisation of scrips for discharge of customs
obligations. Accordingly, Mr. Sharafat Hussain was not an unknown
third party facilitating an isolated commercial transaction but was
acting under authority voluntarily conferred upon him by the
Appellant.
26.
Section 182 of the Indian Contract Act, 187210, defines agent as
a person employed to do any act for the principal or to represent the
principal in dealings with third persons. The legal consequence of
such relationship is that acts performed by an agent within the
authority conferred by the principal are legally attributable to the
principal.
hereinafter referred to as „Act of 1872‟
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
27.
Whereas, Sections 186 and 226 of the Act of 1872, when read
together, further recognise that such authority may be express or
implied and the acts performed by an authorised agent bind the
principal in the same manner as if undertaken personally by the
principal.
28.
Similarly, Section 147(a) of the Act of 1962 permits an
importer to transact customs business through an authorised agent.
Whereas Section 147(b), provides that any act done by an agent of the
importer of any goods, shall unless proved to the contrary, be deemed
to have been done with the knowledge and consent of such importer,
making such importer liable as having done such act by themselves.
29.
In the present case, the procurement and utilisation of the scrips,
including reliance upon the inflated values reflected in the EDI
system, were undertaken by Mr. Sharafat Hussain, in the course of the
activities explicitly authorised by the Appellant. As such, the
subsequent discovery of rigged and manipulated EDI entries does not
sever the relationship of agency or transform the acts of an authorised
representation into those of an unrelated third party.
30.
Having authorised Mr. Sharafat Hussain to undertake customs-
related activities and having derived the benefit arising therefrom, the
Appellant cannot selectively disown responsibility for the manner in
which such benefit was obtained. The Appellant cannot be permitted
to accept the advantages flowing from an agency relationship while
avoiding the corresponding legal consequences arising from acts
performed within the scope of such authority.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
31.
The aforesaid interpretation. if accepted, would defeat the very
purpose of Section 147 of the Act of 1862, which permits an importer
to transact business through an authorised representative, but does not
create immunity from the consequences of acts performed by such
representative in the course of the authorised so granted. Accordingly,
in view of the aforesaid statutory provisions, the Appellant cannot
evade liability arising from the acts of Mr. Sharafat Hussain, once it
has expressly authorised him to act on its behalf.
In re: Sub Issue b
32.
Section 41 of the Act of 1882, in its express terms, relates to
transfer by an ostensible owner of immovable property, the principle
underlying the provision is founded upon the doctrine of estoppel and
operates as an exception to the general rule embodies in the maxim
nemo dat quod non habet, namely, that no person can transfer a better
title than that which he himself possesses. However, the protection
provided under the aforesaid provision is not absolute, but conditional
upon the transferee having acted in good faith and taken reasonable
care to ascertain that the transferor possessed the requisite authority.
33.
The Supreme Court in Hardev Singh v Gurmail Singh (D) by
LRs11, while explaining the scope of Section 41 of the Act of 1882,
identified the essential conditions for protection thereunder, which are
as follows:
i.
the transferor is the ostensible owner;
ii. he is so by the consent, express or implied, of the real owner;
(2007) 2 SCC 404
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
iii. the transfer is for consideration; and
iv. the transferee has acted in good faith, taking reasonable care to
ascertain that the transferor had power to transfer.
34.
The rationale behind this provision is that where the real owner
has, by his conduct, allowed another person to represent himself as the
owner, the real owner cannot subsequently defeat the rights of an
innocent purchaser/transferee who relied upon such representation
after exercising reasonable diligence.
35.
Thus, the equitable protection rests upon the concurrence of
two major elements, firstly, an appearance of title or authority
attributable to the conduct of the person entitled to assert the contrary,
and secondly, bona fide reliance upon such appearance by the
transferee who exercises reasonable care. To put it succinctly, the
equitable protection cannot be extended to a person who has failed to
exercise the degree of care or diligence which the relevant
circumstances reasonably required.
36.
It is in this limited sense that the aforesaid principle governs the
surrounding facts and circumstances of the present case. Although
Section 41 of the Act of 1882 does not, in terms, govern the transfer or
utilisation of scrips in question, yet the underlying principle of due
diligence becomes relevant while examining the claim of protection as
a bona fide purchaser, who while acting in good faith and for valuable
consideration, is under an obligation to take reasonable care to
ascertain that the ostensible owner possessed the authority which
she/he purported to exercise. The aforesaid requirement finds further
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
force in the principle of nemo dat quod non habet.
37.
In the present case, what also becomes relevant to highlight is
that the application of nemo dat quod non habet, is not with reference
to the validity of the scrips as instruments simpliciter, but to the extent
of the entitlement that stood represented by them. Notably, the scrips
having been originally issued by the DGFT, to that extent represented
genuine entitlements. However, the enhanced value reflected in the
EDI system, exceeded the entitlement actually granted by the
competent authority, inasmuch as such enhanced entitlement was
never lawfully possessed by the transferor/Mr. Sharafat Hussain, and
consequently, could not have been transferred to or acquired by the
Appellant merely by virtue of the manipulated EDI entries.
38.
In the present case, the investigation revealed one of such
circumstances, wherein, although the scrips had originally been issued
by the DGFT in favour of M/s K S Impex and subsequently
transferred to M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd., the values registered in
the EDI system were found to be substantially higher than the actual
entitlement granted by the competent authority. Thus, the issue which
falls for consideration is whether the enhanced entitlement reflected in
the EDI system was ever validly granted by the competent authority,
the answer to the same is in negative.
39.
The investigation revealed the extent of the aforesaid
manipulation, where it was discovered that Licence No. 0519001145,
issued for Rs.5,53,848/-, was reflected in the EDI system at
Rs.16,53,848/-. Likewise, Licence Nos. 0519001934 and 0519001935,
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
issued for Rs.5,85,830/- and Rs.2,34,687/-, were reflected at inflated
values of Rs.11,65,830/- and Rs.6,34,687/- respectively. Thus, the
inflated value of scrips administered in the EDI system had never been
granted by the CA, consequently, the transfer of such scrips could not
operate to confer upon the Appellant an entitlement greater than what
had lawfully been granted by the DGFT.
40.
The aforesaid position also assumes significance in assessing
whether or not the Appellant had acted as a bona fide purchaser,
thereby satisfying the requirements under Section 41 of the Act of
1882. The Appellant being the importer and ultimate beneficiary of
scrips was required to exercise reasonable care before availing itself of
the entitlement represented thereof. However, despite being aware of
scrips being utilised towards payment of customs duty, the Appellant
did not undertake any verification of their genuineness, validity or the
extent of the entitlement reflected therein. On the contrary, it is an
admitted position of the Appellant that, the particulars and values of
such scrips were communicated to it only after customs clearance, and
it never attempted to verify the genuineness of the scrips or the
correctness of the particulars and values thereof.
41.
Further, in this regard, the conduct of the Appellant in relation
to the customs clearance authority vested upon Mr. Sharafat Hussain
also assumes significance. Admittedly, the Appellant itself authorised
M/s Zealous International, through its proprietor Mr. Sharafat
Hussain, to undertake customs clearance operations on its behalf
without ever verifying whether the said entity possessed a valid
Customs Broker license. By entrusting customs clearance functions to
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Mr. Sharafat Hussain and permitting him to act on its behalf before the
CA, the Appellant clothed him with authority to undertake clearance
activities in connection with its imports. To that extent, Mr. Sharafat
Hussain occupied the position of a person having authority to
undertake customs clearance activities for and on behalf of the
Appellant.
42.
Accordingly, the Appellant cannot escape responsibility for acts
performed by Mr. Sharafat Hussain in the course of such agency, as
discussed in the preceeding paragraphs under Sub-Issue a (Supra).
Since the fraudulent/forged/manipulated scrips were utilised for
clearance of goods imported by the Appellant, the responsibility to
verify the genuineness, validity and lawful entitlement of such scrips
rested upon the Appellant, being the importer and the ultimate
beneficiary of the duty benefit, which it failed to do.
43.
Moreover, the Appellant admitted that, despite agency charges
being raised in the names of two different entities, namely M/s Kirti
Cargo (25%) and M/s Zealous International (75%), and despite the
BoE reflecting the name of M/s Kirti Cargo, it never sought any
clarification regarding these apparent inconsistencies. Likewise, the
Appellant entrusted customs clearance work to M/s Zealous
International without verifying whether it possessed the statutory
licence required to undertake such functions. The aforesaid
circumstances were not extraneous to the transaction, rather, they were
matters directly bearing significance upon the manner in which the
Appellant‟s customs clearance and duty benefits were being dealt
with.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
44.
The aforesaid circumstances, viewed cumulatively, reveal that
the Appellant did not act with the degree of good faith and reasonable
care necessary to claim equitable protection. Additionally, the fact that
the scrips originated from the DGFT cannot, by itself, confer validity
upon an enhanced entitlement that was never granted by the CA.
Equally, the Appellant‟s status as a purchaser cannot create, by
operation of equity, an entitlement which was absent in the transferor.
Therefore, the principle of nemo dat quod non habet remains
applicable to the extent of the excess entitlement reflected in the
manipulated EDI records.
45.
Moreover, the equitable protection granted under Section 41 of
the Act of 1882, intends to protect an innocent transferee who has
reasonably relied upon an appearance of authority created or permitted
by the true owner. It does not intend to enable a transferee, who has
failed to undertake reasonable enquiries, to retain or enforce an
entitlement beyond that which was lawfully granted in the first place.
Thus, the Appellant having failed to make necessary enquiries cannot
invoke estoppel to shift the consequences of its own negligence.
46.
Additionally, the Appellant‟s claim to equitable relief is
undermined by its own statutory defaults under Section 46(4) of the
Act of 1962, which provides the importer to make a true, correct and
complete declaration in the BoE. Having furnished declarations that
have been found to be false or incorrect, the Appellant cannot
simultaneously invoke equitable principles founded upon honesty,
good faith and due diligence to avoid the consequences arising from
those declarations. The statutory obligation to make a truthful
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
declaration is independent of, and reinforces, the requirement of due
diligence that underlies the equitable protection claimed by the
Appellant.
47.
It is a settled principle that equity cannot be invoked by a party
whose conduct is inconsistent with its statutory obligations. The
equitable principle underlying Section 41 of the Act of 1882, or the
doctrine of estoppel, cannot be used to enlarge an entitlement beyond
that lawfully granted by the competent authority. In the present case,
the scrips had a genuine underlying DGFT entitlement; however, the
entitlement reflected in the EDI system had been inflated beyond the
amount actually granted.
48.
To that extent, Mr. Sharafat Hussain possessed no lawful
entitlement capable of being transferred, therefore, the maxim nemo
dat quod non habet operates against the Appellant. Having failed to
exercise reasonable care to ascertain the genuineness and extent of the
scrip entitlement, and having furnished incorrect declarations under
the Act of 1962, the Appellant cannot claim protection as a bona fide
purchaser or avoid the consequences arising from utilisation of the
excess entitlement.
In re: Sub Issue c
49.
The maxim of caveat emptor, which means „let the buyer be
aware‟, places an obligation upon the purchaser to make necessary
enquiries and satisfy itself regarding the genuineness, validity and
authority attached to the rights or instruments being acquired.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
50.
The Supreme Court in Aafloat Textiles (Supra), applied this
principle in the context of forged import license and held that a
purchaser of transferable licences must establish that it had undertaken
necessary enquiries and taken requisite precautions to ascertain their
genuineness. The Court further held that where the purchaser fails to
demonstrate such enquiry, the consequences must follow. The burden
of establishing that reasonable precautions were taken lies upon the
purchaser, as such knowledge and verification exercise are matters
within its special knowledge.
51.
The aforesaid principle squarely applies to the facts of the
present case. The Appellant having been availed the benefit of
transferable scrip cannot merely rely upon their apparent existence or
representation by intermediaries but is required to exercise reasonable
care to verify their authenticity and validity. The mere fact that an
instrument is reflected in official records does not absolve the
beneficiary (Appellant) from undertaking due diligence regarding the
underlying entitlement, particularly when such benefit is being
claimed for discharge of statutory liabilities.
52.
In the present case, as elucidated in the preceeding paragraphs
the Appellant has failed to establish any verification exercise
undertaken by it before relying upon the disputed scrips. There is no
material on record to demonstrate that the Appellant verified the
genuineness of the scrips from the issuing authority, examined the
underlying entitlement granted by the DGFT, or undertook any
independent enquiry before availing the duty benefit.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
53.
The doctrine of caveat emptor does not protect a party that
remains passive in the face of circumstances requiring verification. It
is intended to impose responsibility upon the purchaser to exercise
ordinary prudence and cannot be invoked as a shield against the
consequences of failure to make necessary enquiries.
54.
Accordingly, the Appellant cannot derive any benefit from the
principle of caveat emptor. Rather, the said principle reinforces the
obligation of the Appellant to have exercised due diligence before
relying upon the scrips, and its failure to do so disentitles it from
claiming protection against the consequences arising from such
reliance.
In re: Issue II
55.
The principle of natural justice is intended to secure fairness in
the decision-making process and not to elevate procedural
requirements into ends in themselves. Unless the alleged procedural
lapse demonstrably occasions actual prejudice, the proceedings cannot
be invalidated on that ground alone.
56.
The contention of the Appellant regarding non-production of
the original scrips proceeds on the assumption that the Respondents‟
case rests solely upon proving the physical forgery of the said
instrument. However, as already discussed in the preceeding
paragraphs the foundation of the present controversy lies in the
revelations made during the investigation by CA.
57.
The investigation unequivocally established that the scrips
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
reflected in the EDI system had either been artificially enhanced,
repeatedly utilised beyond the entitlement originally granted by the
DGFT, or did not correspond with any lawful entitlement whatsoever.
Consequently, the evidentiary foundation of the proceedings rests not
merely upon the physical scrips but upon the DGFT entitlement
records, Customs registration data, ICES/EDI transaction trails,
system-generated electronic records and the statements recorded
during investigation.
58.
In these circumstances, the mere non-production of the original
scrips cannot, by itself, undermine the proceedings. The law
pertaining to non-production of documents is governed by the
principles embodied under Section 119 of the Bharatiya Sakshya
Adhiniyam, 2023. The aforesaid provision empowers the Court to
draw appropriate presumptions having regard to the common course
of natural events, human conduct, and the circumstances of a
particular case.
59.
However, such presumptions are discretionary in nature and
cannot be invoked mechanically. An adverse inference can arise only
where the document withheld is shown to be material, is within the
exclusive possession or control of the party concerned, and where the
circumstances reasonably justify an inference that its production
would have operated adversely against such party.
60.
In this regard, the principle of adverse inference as enunciated
by the Supreme Court in Pandurang Jivaji Apte v. Ramchandra
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
Gangadhar Ashtekar (D) by LRs & Ors.12, is required to be noticed.
The Court in the said case held that, an adverse inference for nonproduction of a document is neither automatic nor invariable but
depends upon the nature of the controversy and the availability of
independent evidence. Where the relevant fact otherwise stands
satisfactorily established, no adverse inference is liable to be drawn.
61.
Applying the aforesaid principle, this Court finds that the
Respondents have independently established its case through
contemporaneous
electronic
records,
DGFT
entitlement
data,
investigation into the modus operandi of the fraud, and the statements
recorded under Section 108 of the Act of 1962. Consequently, the
absence of the original scrips is by no means fatal to the adjudication.
62.
Significantly, as already noticed under Issue I (Supra), Mr. Jain
unequivocally admitted that the Appellant was never in possession of
the original scrips, never undertook any independent verification
thereof, and relied exclusively upon the particulars reflected in the
BoE. He further admitted that neither the source, nor the validity, nor
the available balance of the scrips was ever verified by them.
63.
The aforesaid admissions made by Mr. Jain negates the plea of
prejudice being argued by the Appellant, since its case was never
founded upon verification of the original instruments but solely upon
their assumption that every entry processed through the Customs
system was necessarily valid. Consequently, the absence of the
original scrips could not have deprived them of an opportunity to
(1981) 4 SCC 569
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
establish a fact which they admittedly never attempted to verify.
64.
Equally devoid of merit is the grievance regarding denial of
cross-examination of the Customs officers inasmuch as the Appellant
has failed to demonstrate what material fact could have been elicited
through such cross-examination or how the absence thereof has caused
any adverse consequence to their defence. A mere assertion that crossexamination was denied, unaccompanied by any demonstrable
prejudice, is manifestly insufficient to invalidate the proceedings.
65.
Furthermore, it is to be noticed that during the course of
investigation repeated summons under Section 108 of the Act of 1962
were issued to Mr. Sharafat Hussain at the addresses of M/s Kirti
Cargo as well as M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd. requiring him to
tender his statement. Despite repeated opportunities, he deliberately
failed to appear before the investigating authorities. Thereafter,
searches were conducted on more than one occasion at his registered
addresses; however, he could not be traced. Following which, lookout
circulars came to be issued against him culminating into registration
of an FIR.
66.
Thereafter, Mr. Sharafat Hussan, in a written communication
addressed to the CA, claimed to be a bona fide purchaser having
purchased the scrips from Mr. Vinod Kumar Pathror through his
various entities. However, upon further investigation against the
claims made by Sharafat Hussain, the CA approached one of the
original exporters, namely M/s K S Impex, whereupon it was revealed
that scrips purchased by M/s Zealous Overseas Pvt. Ltd. had been
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
fraudulently enhanced and registered in the EDI system for values
substantially exceeding those originally issued by the DGFT.
67.
Further, Mr. Sharafat Hussain, in his voluntary statements dated
15.11.2017 and 16.11.2017, stated that he possessed either the
physical licences or their particulars and had purchased licences
already registered in the EDI system. However, when confronted with
the purchase invoice and utilisation details of Licence No.
0510389153, purchased for Rs.7,18,837/- against a credit value of
Rs.7,29,688/- but utilised for payment of customs duty amounting to
Rs.20,85,111/- in four Bills of Entry, he furnished only evasive
explanations.
68.
Furthermore, his claim that the purchase documents had been
seized during searches was found to be false, as no such documents or
physical licences were recovered. Likewise, although he asserted that
the Customs registration numbers were reflected on the purchase
invoices, invoices obtained from M/s R.S. Enterprises revealed
otherwise.
69.
Additionally,
the
investigation
also
exposed
material
inconsistencies in the explanations furnished by Mr. Sharafat Hussain,
his failure to produce any purchase records despite repeated assertions
to the contrary, his admitted omission to verify the authenticity of the
licences from the DGFT, and the statements of the importers
confirming that the disputed licences had been utilised by him without
their instructions.
70.
Put succinctly, the aforesaid material demonstrates that the CA
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
conducted a comprehensive investigation and collected independent
documentary,
electronic
and
oral
evidence.
The
aforesaid
circumstances when viewed cumulatively, constitute independent and
compelling evidence establishing the fraudulent modus operandi and
the misuse of the scrips.
71.
Consequently, the evidentiary foundation of the proceedings
remains wholly unimpaired, and no adverse inference can be drawn in
favour of the Appellant merely on account of the non-production of
the original scrips or allied documents along with denial of crossexamination being sought by the Appellant.
In re: Issue III
72.
The present issue is borne out of separate questions framed by
this Court in its Order dated 03.09.2024 in CUSAA 82/2023 and
CUSAA 83/2023, concerning penalties under Sections 112(b) and
114A of the Act of 1962. However, since the both the provisions
pertain to imposition of penalty arising from similar transaction, they
are being dealt with together.
73.
Section 114A of the Act of 1962, is attracted where duty has not
been levied or has been short levied by reason of fraud, collusion,
wilful misstatement or suppression of facts with an intention to evade
payment of duty. The last proviso to Section 114A further manifests
the legislative intent that where penalty is imposed under the said
provision, no separate penalty shall be leviable under Section 112 or
Section 114 of the Act of 1962.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
74.
In view thereof, the issue framed with respect to Section 112 of
the Act of 1962, loses its significance and does not survive for
determination by this Court. However, we shall proceed to examine
whether the acts of Appellant, attracts the penalty prescribed under
Section 114A of the Act of 1962.
75.
The plea of absence of direct knowledge regarding the actual
manipulation of the EDI records, at the highest, may have relevant
while examining the degree of culpability. However, penalty under
Section 114A of the Act of 1962 does not require that the importer
must personally execute such fraudulent act. Where the duty benefit
has been obtained by suppression of material facts, wilful
misstatement or fraudulent reliance upon an invalid entitlement, the
statutory consequences necessarily follow.
76.
In the present case, the Appellant consciously sought to
discharge their liability to pay customs duty by filing BoE containing
declarations regarding utilisation of scrips, despite admittedly failing
to verify the existence, validity or availability of such credits.
Therefore, its conduct cannot be characterised as a mere innocent
reliance upon an external fraud. They derived the direct benefit of the
manipulated scrips and, by their own admissions, failed to exercise
even the minimum diligence expected while dealing with instruments
capable of extinguishing substantial statutory liability.
77.
Hence, the penalty imposed under Section 114A of the Act of
1962 sustains, whereas no separate penalty under Section 112(b) is
levy able.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
78.
Before parting, we deem it appropriate to observe that the
findings and conclusions recorded by this Court in the aforesaid batch
of Customs Appeals shall govern present writ petitions as well, since
the Petitions are founded on identical facts and involve substantially
similar questions of law.
79.
It is for the reason that the records pertaining to the present
Petitions have already been placed before this Court, and the issues
arising for consideration stand squarely covered and answered by the
judgment rendered in the aforesaid Appeals. In such circumstances,
we are of the considered view that relegating the Petitioners to the
alternative remedy would serve no meaningful purpose and would
only result in an inefficacious exercise, culminating in the Petitioners
once again approaching this Court in appellate jurisdiction on the very
same issues.
80.
Although such course may ordinarily have been warranted, in
the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present matters, and with a
view to prevent multiplicity of proceedings and ensure expeditious
resolution of the controversy, we dispose of these Writ Petitions in
terms of the judgment rendered in the aforesaid batch of Customs
Appeals.
E.
CONCLUSION:
81.
For all the foregoing reasons, the present Appeals and Writ
Petitions are disposed in the following terms:
a. the Appellant is not a bona fide purchaser in light of Section 41
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
of the Act of 1882 and cannot claim protection under the principle
of caveat emptor;
b.
the
proceedings
rest
upon
overwhelming
independent
documentary, electronic and oral evidence, and the Appellant has
failed to demonstrate any prejudice warranting interference;
c. the Impugned Orders, to the extent they impose penalties under
114A of the Act of 1962, is upheld, while the imposition of penalty
under Section 112 of the Act of 1962 is set-aside; and
d. Since the writ petitions arise from the same investigation and
adjudication proceedings as the connected Customs Appeals, the
findings and directions issued therein shall apply mutatis mutandis
to these proceedings.
82.
All the pending applications also stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
SHAIL JAIN, J.
AUGUST 20, 2026
jai/hr
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
CUSAA 82/2023 and connected matters
14:51:27
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review