Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.Petn. No.69 of 2023
Date of Decision: 14.11.2023
Vs. State of Meghalaya & Anr.
Jindal (India) Limited
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. D. K. Mishra, Sr. Adv.(VC) with
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. And
Mr. S. Banerjee, Adv.
Mr. M. L. Nongpiur, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. N. D. Chullai, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA. (R:- 1).
Mr. A. Bhuyan Adv. (VC) with
Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv. (R:- 2)
i)
ii)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This petition under Section 482 Cr.P.C has been preferred by
the petitioner for quashing of the FIR registered as Jowai Police
Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 under Section 120B/469/34 IPC
which was instituted on the basis of a written information lodged by
the respondent No.2.
2.
A written FIR dated 14-04-2023 was lodged by the respondent
No.2 to the Officer-in-Charge, Jowai Police Station to the effect that
the respondent No.2 was appointed as authorised commission agent by
the petitioner to represent them in the Public Health Engineering
Department, Meghalaya for getting materials cleared at consignee end
and for release of payment against such material and a letter of
authorization to that effect was signed by one Ravi Sugla in the month
of March 2021 on behalf of the petitioner. The respondent No.2 was
also trading in pipes and sheets manufactured by the petitioner on
regular basis up to 2021.
Despite payment of sum of Rs.
1,12,60,393/- to the petitioner for purchase of materials, the petitioner
denied to give the materials and also did not refund the money
following which the respondent No.2 raised this matter with the
NCLT in September, 2022 for realization of Rs. 1,31,39,182/- (with
interest). Following which the petitioner filed an FIR in Howrah,
West Bengal, vide FIR No.1144/2022 alleging that a few
consignments of GI pipes sent to PHE Jowai Division has been
diverted on the instructions of the respondent No.2 and his brother Mr.
Umang Dhanania to other places thereby causing a loss of rupees
16.79 crores to the petitioner. The petitioner took the shield of this
FIR in NCLT case to deny money to the respondent No.2. Upon
perusal of the copy of the FIR along with the supporting documents
which were made available to the respondent No.2, some of the
documents were prima facie contradictory in nature and forged by the
petitioner for benefit of his case vide FIR No. 1144/2022. A letter
dated 20-05-2021 signed by one Shri. Ramesh Bansal as Director
addressed to the Chief Engineer, PHE Meghalaya also appeared to be
false as Shri. Ramesh Bansal became director on 27-08-2021. The
said letter was counter-signed and verified as true copy by another
director Mr. Sudipta Bhowal on behalf of the petitioner was
knowingly submitted before the police and Hon’ble Court in West
Bengal.
In a reply made by PHE, Meghalaya, they have denied
receiving any such letter. Mr. Biplab Sengupta, an employee of the
petitioner, was responsible in the year 2021 for third-party inspection
of goods dispatched from the factory of the petitioner and he is hiding
the fact that the goods were to be of an amount of Rs.16.79 crores preinspected materials has already been delivered to PHE from the said
missing materials and payments has also been received by the
petitioner in the official bank account for many of the alleged missing
consignments.
Despite receiving payment, petitioner has made a
criminal conspiracy to falsely accused respondent No.2 for alleged
theft of Rs.16.79 crores. Since the petitioner was aware of the actual
delivery location of trucks, they have paid many freight bills of the
alleged missing trucks to the transporters even up to the year 2022, yet
petitioner chose to file misleading FIR. The respondent No.2 has
come across three different emails issued to the petitioner by three
transporters which are contradictory in nature. The e-mails stated that
Mr. Ayush Jatia was director whereas Mr. Ayush Jatia has ceased to
be director of the petitioner company since 01-08-18. One of those emails clearly stated that the materials have been directly unloaded by
the truck drivers at different PHE Depots and most of the times the
receipt challan was directly signed and stamped by PHE officers and
only in few cases the respondent No.2 has signed himself. Another email stated that the respondent No.2 used to instruct for the delivery of
materials at different depots and the respondent No.2 used to take the
invoice at the time of vehicle reaching the unloading point and take
responsibility of unloading.
The third e-mail stated that the
respondent No.2 and his brother used to instruct for the delivery of
materials and receiving was also arranged by them. Whereas the fact
is that the material was directly unloaded by the transporters of the
petitioner at PHE Depot as instructed by the petitioner in third party
inspection report of Dr. Amin and most of the times receipts were
given to the truck drivers by PHE officers. The petitioner is trying to
threaten the respondent No.2 and others through their West Bengal
FIR No. 1144/2022 to compel the respondent No.2 to take back NCLT
case against the petitioner otherwise petitioner would falsely implicate
the respondent No.2 in West Bengal FIR. The marriage ceremony of
the respondent No.2 which was scheduled on 01-02-2023 in Kolkata
also got cancelled due to the filing of the untrue case by the petitioner
vide FIR No.1144/2022.
On the basis of the FIR lodged by the
respondent No.2, Jowai PS Case No. 48 (04) of 2023 under Section
120B/469/34 IPC was registered.
3.
The facts averred in the instant criminal petition reveal that the
Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022 was registered for
investigation pursuant to a direction passed by the Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Howrah in terms of Section 156 (3) Cr.P.C upon a
complaint made by the petitioner against the respondent No.2 and
others. The said case was based upon the fact that in the month of
March, 2021 the petitioner company was selected as a successful
bidder for supply, delivery and stacking of ISI marked medium quality
GI pipes by the Public Health Engineering Department (PHED),
Government of Meghalaya and various supply orders were issued to
the petitioner for the supply of pipes to the tune of 17,393 Metric Ton
over a period of 8 – 10 months to various designated depots owned or
controlled by the said department.
The petitioner appointed 11
transporters along with the co-accused transport logistic companies for
the execution of the said job of transportation of consignment from the
Jangalpur factory under Sankrail police station to the designated
depots of the PHED, Meghalaya including the one at Electrical
Division-II, Jowai Division, Meghalaya. The said consignments were
not delivered to the designated depots.
The co-accused transport
company have entered into a criminal conspiracy with the respondent
No.2 herein and his brother to misappropriate the said specific
consignments, forged consignment notes and lorry challans.
The
accused persons have mis-represented themselves as employer of the
petitioner company and have misused office stamps and took
unauthorized action on behalf of the petitioner company. During the
course of investigation of the said Sankrail police station case, the
respondent No.2 and his brother preferred an application under
Section 438 Cr.P.C before the learned Sessions Judge, Howrah, West
Bengal which was registered as Criminal Misc. Case No. 237 of 2023.
Vide an order dated 22-02-2023, the said application was dismissed as
not pressed. Thereafter, the respondent No.2 and his brother filed two
separate applications under Section 438 Cr. P.C. before the learned
Sessions Judge at Howrah, West Bengal which were registered as
Criminal Misc. Case No. 644 of 2023 and Criminal Misc. Case No.
645 of 2023. On 20-03-2023, the aforesaid applications were also
dismissed as not pressed.
In the meanwhile, the brother of the
respondent No.2 preferred an application under Section 482 Cr. P. C.
before the Calcutta High Court for quashing the First Information
Report in Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022.
The said
application was registered as CRR No. 954 of 2023. Vide an order
dated 17-03-2023 the said application was admitted by the Calcutta
High Court with a direction to continue investigation without taking
any coercive steps against the petitioner therein. The respondent No.2
also filed an application for quashing of the same First Information
Report before the Calcutta High Court, which was registered as CRR
No.1181 of 2023.
Vide an order dated 30-03-2023 the said
application was directed to be listed along with CRR No. 954 of 2023.
It was further directed that the investigation to continue without any
coercive steps against the respondent No.2. The petitioner preferred
two separate applications for vacating the aforesaid interim orders
dated 17-03-2023 and 30-03-2023. On 11-04-2023, the applications
filed by the respondent No.2 and his brother were taken up for hearing
and the Calcutta High Court vide two separate orders dated 12-042023 passed in CRR No. 954 of 2023 and CRR No. 1181 of 2023
quashed the First Information Report being Sankrail police station
case No. 1144/2022. The petitioner preferred a Special Leave Petition
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court challenging the orders dated 1204-2023 passed by the Calcutta High Court in CRR No. 954 of 2023
and CRR No. 1181 of 2023 and the Hon’ble Supreme Court was
pleased to set aside the said orders vide an order dated 18-05-2023
passed in Special Leave Petition (Crl.) Nos. 5779-5780/2023.
4.
On the filing of this petition and on the issuance of the notice,
the respondent No.2 has entered appearance and filed his affidavit-inopposition in this matter. The petitioner has also filed an affidavit-inreply to the affidavit-in-opposition of the respondent No.2.
5.
The impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 refers to certain
documents which are annexed with the said FIR and marked as
annexures. However, at the time of the hearing of the matter it is
noticed that the copy of the FIR appended with the present criminal
petition does not have any annexures attached to it. The affidavit-in-
opposition filed by the respondent No.2 also made no specific
disclosure with regard to those annexures. In order to ascertain what
are the actual documents annexed with the FIR, the case diary of the
matter was called for and the same was produced before the Court by
the learned AAG, appearing for the respondent No.1. The case diary
containing certain documents stated to be the documents annexed with
the FIR dated 14-04-2023 was perused by this Court but copy of the
FIR was not available therein.
6.
Mr. D. K. Mishra, learned Senior counsel appearing for the
petitioner submits that the impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 registered
as Jowai Police Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 under Section
120B/469/34 IPC does not disclose about occurrence of any
independent offence and the same is centered around the occurrence
or incident basing on which Sankrail Police Station Case No.
1144/2022 was registered in Howrah, West Bengal at the instance of
the petitioner. He submits that the informant (respondent No.2) in the
Jowai Police Case No. 48(04) of 2023 under Section 120B/469/34 IPC
is a co-accused in the case registered at Sankrail Police Station and his
name appears as accused No.7 in the said case. Referring to the
paragraphs No. 5,6,13,14 and15 of the complaint filed by the
petitioner and the contents of the impugned FIR lodged by the
respondent No.2, he submits that the allegations made by the
respondent No.2 is related to and dependent upon the investigation
launched by the police in the Sankrail Police Station case. He further
submits that the entire text of the impugned FIR questions the
credibility and legitimacy of the complaint filed by the petitioner
which is not permissible in law. He contends that no investigation can
be launched on the basis of the impugned FIR to determine the
validity of the complaint filed by the petitioner which is under
investigation by the police in Sankrail Police Station case No.
1144/2022. Referring to section 120B,34 and 469 IPC under which the
impugned FIR is registered, the learned senior counsel submits that
the filing of the complaint by the petitioner cannot be termed as a
criminal act under the said section of IPC and the allegation made in
para 5 of the impugned FIR also does not constitute any criminal
offence as the contents thereof no way hampers the reputation on any
person. He submits that in the event of filing of any FIR basing on
false or forged document, appropriate action can be initiated by
resorting to the provisions of law under Section 195(1)b and 340
Cr.P.C. read with Section 211 IPC, but no counter FIR can be lodged
seeking investigation into genuineness of the FIR already filed. The
learned Senior counsel further submits that the impugned FIR was
lodged on 14-04-2023 by the respondent No.2 after the Calcutta High
Court quashed the proceedings of the Sankrail Police Station case
No.1144/2022 by order dated 12-04-2023, but after the revival of the
investigation of the said case by the Hon’ble Apex Court by order
dated 18-05-2023, the investigation initiated on the basis of the
impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 cannot continue any further as the
same is an off-shoot of the very incidents basing on which the
investigation of the Sankrail Police Station case No.1144/2022 is
undertaken. He also submits that one Shri. Ravi Sugla, the person
who allegedly authorized the respondent No.2 to be an agent of the
petitioner, has been arrested and detained by the police in connection
with the Sankrail Police Station case No.1144/2022 and is under
investigation now. On this backdrop, he submits that the impugned
FIR cannot be divorced from the facts basing on which Sankrail
Police Station case No.1144/2022 is being investigated and the same
needs to be quashed.
7.
Mr. A. Bhuyan, learned counsel for the respondent No.2
submits that the present criminal petition filed by the petitioner is
based on false and forged documents. The documents enclosed at
Pages 64, 67, 86, 87, 91 & 92 of the criminal petition are non-existent
document in the official record of the PHE department. He submits
that the information with regard to the documents were obtained
through RTI application filed on behalf of the respondent No.2 and the
FIR dated 14-04-2023 was lodged by the respondent No.2 on the
detection of the wrong doings by the petitioner. He further contends
that the RTI information were derived in the State of Meghalaya and
the forgery of documents also took place in the same State which
prompted the respondent No.2 to lodge the FIR in the appropriate
police station of the State. The learned counsel strongly submits that
no proceeding before a court of law can be based on false and forged
documents and the present criminal petition deserves to be dismissed
on this ground alone. He submits that the FIR dated 14-04-2023
clearly discloses about commission of cognizable offence by the
petitioner which is totally distinct and different from what has been
alleged in the Sankrail Police Station case No.1144/2022 by the
petitioner. He further submits that the Sections of law under which
the Jowai PS Case No. 48 (04) of 2023 is registered is not of much
relevance at the stage of investigation of the matter as the same can be
altered depending on the outcome of the investigation. It is also the
submission of the learned counsel that the reference of Section 195
(1)(b), 340 Cr.P.C and Section 211 IPC in the present matter by the
learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner is totally
untenable as the said provisions of law are not applicable at the stage
of investigation.
He submits that the allegations made by the
petitioner against the respondent No.2 in Sankrail Police Station case
No.1144/2022 is totally false as the petitioner has already received the
payment for the supply of materials from the concerned office. By
referring to the order dated 18-05-2023 of the Apex Court by which
the investigation of the Sankrail Police Station case No.1144/2022
was revived, the learned counsel submits that the Apex Court has
granted liberty to the respondent No.2 to approach the appropriate
forum for seeking relief and in that view of the matter, the filing of the
FIR dated 14-04-2023 by the respondent No.2 cannot be faulted with.
He submits that the investigation of the Jowai PS Case No. 48 (04) of
2023 initiated on the basis of the FIR dated 14-04-2023 is at the initial
stage and no interference is called for at present. He further submits
that just because an investigation is undertaken by the police in
connection with the Sankrail Police Station case No.1144/2022 in
relation to certain alleged offence, it does not mean that another FIR
relatable to different offence occurring at different place cannot be
lodged and investigated upon. The learned counsel submits that the
criminal petition is devoid of merit and deserves to be dismissed
forthwith. In support of his submission, the learned counsel places
reliance on the decisions of the Apex Court reported in the following
cases: (2013) 6 SCC 384, Anju Chaudhary Versus State of Uttar
Pradesh and Another (Paras 28 & 29).
(2021) SCC OnLine SC 315, Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt.
Ltd. Versus State of Maharashtra and Others (Para 80).
8.
Mr. N. D. Chullai, learned AAG appearing for the State-
respondent, while supporting the submissions advanced on behalf of
the respondent No.2, submits that subsequent to filing of the FIR
dated 14-04-2023 the investigation of the matter has been taken up
and a number of documents have been seized during the course of
investigation. He further submits that the allegation made in the said
FIR prima facie discloses commission of offence under Sections 467,
469 and 471 IPC. He submits that certain documents relied on by the
petitioner apparently appears to be false. He also contends that inspite
of issuance of notice under Section 41A Cr.P.C, the petitioner is not
responding which in fact is in violation of the interim order passed by
this Court wherein petitioner had undertaken to cooperate with the
investigation of the matter.
The learned AAG submits that the
investigation is in progress and it should not be scuttled at the infant
stage without any lawful cause or reason.
The learned AAG in
support of his submission places reliance on the following decisions: (2003) 6 SCC 175, Superintendent of Police, CBI & Ors.
Versus Tapan Kumar Singh (Para – 20);
(2013) 10 SCC 581, Vinod Raghuvanshi Versus Ajay Arora &
Ors. (Para – 30);
(2021) SCC OnLine SC 315, Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt.
Ltd. Versus State of Maharashtra and Others (Paras 30, 49 – 80)
9.
Mr. D. K. Mishra, learned Senior counsel, in his reply submits
that the impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 does not speak about the
occurrence of any independent offence and is confined to the facts
alleged in the Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022. He submits
that the documents which the respondents are contending to be forged
and false are all parts of police record and judicial proceeding initiated
in connection with the Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022 and
are subject-matter of investigation therein. He further submits that
many of such documents are also counter-signed by the officials of the
PHE department of the Government of Meghalaya and at this stage it
would be wrong to assert that the said documents are false or forged.
Maintaining that the impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 does not make
out a fresh case for initiating a separate investigation under Section
156 Cr.P.C, the learned Senior counsel submits that the impugned FIR
may be quashed. The learned Senior counsel relies on a decision
reported in (2002) 1 SCC 714, Kari Choudhary Versus Mst. Sita Devi
& Ors. (para 11) and submits that there cannot be two FIR in relation
to one occurrence requiring investigation by two different agencies
simultaneously.
10.
The submission advanced by the rival parties have been duly
considered. For the purpose of just and proper decision of the matter
in hand, it is important to take note of the fact basing on which the
investigation in Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022 and Jowai
Police Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 have been set in motion.
11.
A perusal of the complaint filed by the petitioner before the
Chief Judicial Magistrate, Howrah basing on which the Sankrail
police
station
case
No.
1144/2022
under
Section
419/420/467/468/469/471/409/120B IPC was registered, reveals that
the petitioner company was allotted various supply orders for GI pipes
for water supply by the PHE department, Government of Meghalaya
in the month of March, 2021 which were required to be supplied in
terms of the contract over a period of eight to ten months to the
various designated locations.
It was alleged therein that the
respondent No.2 and his brother with fraudulent intention diverted
substantial quantity of GI pipes which were meant for supply to the
PHE department and thereby earned wrongful gain at the cost of the
petitioner. It was also specifically alleged therein that the respondent
No.2 in collusion with others fraudulently represented himself as an
employee/agent of the petitioner-company and also illegally used the
office stamp and took unauthorized action causing immense financial
losses and damages to the petitioner company.
12.
The Jowai Police Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 under
Section 120B/469/34 IPC which was registered on the basis of the
impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 filed by the respondent No.2 is also
founded on the fact of supply of GI pipes consequent upon placement
of supply orders by the PHE department, Government of Meghalaya,
to the petitioner company during the period of March, 2021. In the
said FIR the respondent No.2 alleged wrong doing by the petitioner in
implicating that the respondent No.2 as an accused in the Sankrail
police station case No. 1144/2022. The respondent No.2, inter alia,
alleged that the petitioner has taken support of forged and false
documents despite having full knowledge about the missing materials
and trucks and have received payment for the alleged missing
consignment.
It is also alleged by the respondent No.2 that the
documents furnished on behalf of the petitioner to the respondent
No.2 were contradictory in nature and forged by the petitioner to
benefit his case in Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022. The
respondent No.2 in his FIR further alleged that the petitioner is trying
to threaten the respondent No.2 by filing the Sankrail police station
case No. 1144/2022 in order to compel the respondent No.2 to take
back the NCLT case which was filed by him against the petitioner. It
is further alleged that by the respondent No.2 that his marriage, which
was scheduled to be held on 01-02-2023 in Kolkata got cancelled
because of the filing of untrue case by the petitioner. It is to be taken
note here that in the impugned FIR the respondent No.2 claimed
himself to be an agent of the petitioner company on the basis of an
authorization certificate signed by one Shri. Ravi Sugla, in the month
of March, 2021.
13.
What transpires from the above is that the investigation of both
the Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022 and the Jowai Police
Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 have been initiated on the basis of the
complaint/ FIR lodged in connection with the same incident or
occurrence. While the investigation in the Sankrail police station case
No. 1144/2022 is based on the version of the allegation made by the
petitioner, the investigation in the Jowai Police Station Case No.
48(04) of 2023 is based on the version of allegation made by the
respondent No.2. Even most of the documents, which are subject
matter of controversy between the parties in the present matter, are
also subject matter of investigation by the aforesaid two different
investigating agencies.
14.
The materials on record divulge that prior to the filing of the
impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023, the respondent No.2 challenged the
initiation of investigation under the Sankrail police station case No.
1144/2022 (G.R. Case No. 6348 of 2022) by filing a revision
application under Section 482 Cr.P.C registered as CRR/954/2023
before the Calcutta High Court wherein a prayer was made for
quashing of the said proceeding. The High Court at Calcutta vide
order dated 12-04-2023 quashed the further proceeding of the G.R.
Case No. 6348 of 2022 arising out of Sankrail police station case No.
1144/2022. It is only at that stage the respondent No.2 filed the
impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 when the investigation in Sankrail
police station case No. 1144/2022 was not in existence. However, the
order dated 12-04-2023 of the Calcutta High Court was challenged by
the petitioner before the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Special Leave
Petition (Crl.) Nos. 5779-5780/2023 and the Hon’ble Supreme Court
by order dated 18-05-2023 was pleased to set aside the order of the
Calcutta High Court dated 12-04-2023. Resultantly, the investigation
initiated by the police in connection with the Sankrail police station
case No. 1144/2022 stood revived.
15.
The learned counsel for the respective parties relied on the
certain decisions of the Apex Court during the course of hearing. It
would be appropriate to take note of the propositions of law laid down
therein before coming to the conclusion in the present matter.
16.
The case of Superintendent of Police, CBI & Ors. Vs. Tapan
Kumar Singh (supra) at para 20 lays down that whenever any
information is furnished with regard to the commission of an offence
which the police officer is empowered under Section 156 Cr. P.C to
investigate, the police officer is bound to record the information and
proceed to investigate into the case.
The truthfulness of the
information or any other matter relating to full details of occurrence,
name of the accused, the sufficiency of evidence is alien to the
consideration of the question whether report discloses the commission
of a cognizable offence. The police office is duty bound to investigate
into the case in order to find out the truth.
17.
The case of Vinod Raghuvanshi Vs. Ajay Arora & Ors.
(supra) at para 30 stipulates that while considering the case for
quashing of criminal proceedings the Court should not “kill a stillborn
child”.
Appropriate prosecution should not be stifled and an
investigation should not be shut out at the threshold if there is no
compelling reason to do so. When a prosecution at the initial stage is
to be quashed, the test to be applied by the Court is whether
uncontroverted allegation as made, prima facie, establish the offence
and it would be inappropriate for the Court to embark upon an inquiry
to determine the genuineness of the allegation. More so, the chargesheet filed or charges framed at the initial stage can be
altered/amended subsequently in view of the provisions of Section
216 Cr.P.C..
18.
The decision of Neeharika Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Vs. State of
Maharashtra and Ors. (supra) lays down in detail the principles
basing on which the High Court would be justified in protecting the
accused against arrest or any coercive steps while not entertaining the
criminal quashing proceedings. The propositions of law laid down
therein are based on an analysis of many decisions of the Apex Court
which are akin to the principles to be followed while dealing with the
matters seeking quashing of Complaint/FIR in exercise of power
under Section 482 Cr. P.C. and/or under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India.
19.
The case of Anju Chaudhary Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh &
Anr. (supra) relied on by the respondent No.2 deal with the question
of filing of multiple FIRs and appears to be relevant for the purpose of
adjudication of the present matter. The paragraphs No. 28 & 29 of the
said decisions as referred by the respondent No.2 are reproduced
hereinbelow: “28. First Information Report No. 145 of 2007
lodged by Hazrat, son of Bismillah related to the burning
of a shop prior to holding of a meeting. He categorically
stated that he did not know the persons or names of the
perpetrators who attacked the shop where he was
working. This incident occurred at 6 p.m. as per the
records while the meeting itself, as per Respondent No.2
was held after 8 p.m., though on the same date. His
report clearly states that when he was going back to his
house at about 8.30 p.m., he stopped at the place where
the meeting was being held. The FIR registered by
Hazrat was against unknown persons and related to a
particular event and commission of a particular crime.
There was no question of any provocation, conspiracy or
attempt by the persons premeditatedly committing the
offences which they committed. As per the FIR, it was an
offence committed at random by some unknown persons.
The registration of such FIR was neither intended to be
nor was it in fact in relation to a matter of larger
investigation, or commission of offences, as alleged by
Respondent 2.
29. Even the offences which are stated to have
been committed, and for which the two FIRs were
registered in these respective cases were different and
distinct. In the complaint filed by Parvez Parwaz, which
was registered as a FIR, names of the persons were
mentioned and a general investigation was called for,
while FIR No.145 of 2007 registered by Hazrat, was
against unknown persons for damage of his property,
which was for a specific offence, without any other
complaint or allegation of any communal instigation or
riot. In other words, these were two different FIRs
relatable to different occurrences, investigation of one
was in no way dependent upon the other and they are
neither interlinked nor interdependent. They were lodged
by different persons in relation to occurrences which are
alleged to have occurred at different points of time
against different people and for different offences.
Requirement of proof in both cases was completely
distinct and different. Thus, there was no similarity and
the test of similarity would not be satisfied in the present
case. Thus, we have no hesitation in coming to the
conclusion that lodging of the subsequent FIR was not a
second FIR for the same occurrence as stated in FIR
No.145 of 2007, and thus, could be treated as a first
information report for all purposes including
investigation in terms of the provisions of the Code. It
was not in the form of a statement under Section 162 of
the Code.
20.
The para 11 of the decision of Kari Choudhary Vs. Mst. Sita
Devi & Ors. (supra) relied on by the learned Senior counsel appearing
for the petitioner lays down: “11. Learned counsel adopted an alternative
contention that once the proceedings initiated under FIR
No.135 ended in a final report the police had no
authority to register a second FIR and number it was FIR
No.208. Of course the legal position is that there cannot
be two FIRs against the same accused in respect of the
same case. But when there are rival versions in respect
of the same episode, they would normally take the shape
of two different FIRs and investigation can be carried on
under both of them by the same investigating agency.
Even that apart, the report submitted to the court styling
it as FIR No. 208 of 1998 need be considered as an
information submitted to the court regarding the new
discovery made by the police during investigation that
persons not named in the FIR No.135 are the real
culprits. To quash the said proceedings merely on the
ground that final report had been laid in FIR No.135 is,
to say the least, too technical. The ultimate object of
every investigation is to find out whether the offences
alleged have been committed and, if so, who have
committed it.”
21.
From the reading of the above proposition of law, it emerges
that the Court in order to examine the impact of one or more FIRs has
to rationalize the facts and circumstances of each case and then apply
the test of “sameness” to find out whether both FIRs relate to the same
incident and to the same occurrence, are in regard to incidents which
are two or more parts of the same transactions or relate completely to
two distinct occurrences.
22.
In the present case, as has been observed above, there remains
no doubt that the complaint filed by the petitioner in Sankrail police
station case No. 1144/2022 and the FIR filed by the respondent No.2
in Jowai Police Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 are arising out of one
transaction of the same incident and cannot be regarded as distinct and
different from each other except for different versions alleged by the
rival parties. Moreover, since the documents relied on by the rival
parties in support of their respective allegations are subject-matter of
investigation in both the cases, investigation of the respective police
station cases will be dependent upon the other and will some way be
interlinked and interdependent.
23.
The contention of the rival parties, more particularly the
respondent No.2, with regard to the genuineness of various documents
annexed at Pages 64, 67, 86, 87, 91 & 92 of the criminal petition and
at Pages 15, 30, 33 and 51 of the affidavit-in-opposition cannot be
gone into by this Court in exercise of its inherent power under Section
482 Cr. P.C. Moreover, it is pointed out by the learned Senior counsel
for the petitioner that many of such documents are parts of judicial
proceedings and investigations arising out of the Sankrail police
station case No. 1144/2022.
24.
Since the investigation of the Sankrail police station case No.
1144/2022 is presently underway and has the nod of the Hon’ble Apex
Court for continuation, initiation of counter-investigation in the Jowai
Police Station Case No. 48(04) of 2023 on the basis of the impugned
FIR dated 14-04-2023 lodged by the respondent No.2 would not be
proper at this stage. The separate investigation undertaken in both the
matters, set up on rival versions, by two different investigating
agencies in all probability will have overlapping effect on each other
which may lead to chaos and legal complicacy.
25.
The contents of the impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 discloses a
challenge to the validity of the complaint filed by the petitioner in
Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022 which at present is under
investigation. Initiation of investigation by one agency to determine
the legality and correctness of another investigation initiated and
continued by a different agency is unknown to the procedure
established by law. Hence, allowing the continuation of investigation
initiated on the basis of impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023 filed by the
respondent No.2 would not only be an illegality but also would lead to
creation of unnecessary obstacles and hindrances in the course of the
investigation of the entire matter. In the case of Kari Choudhary
(supra) the Hon’ble Apex Court has held that when there are rival
versions in respect of the same episode, they would normally take the
shape of two different FIRs and investigation can be carried on under
both of them by the same investigating agency. The ultimate object of
every investigation is to find out whether the offences alleged have
been committed and, if so, who have committed it.
26.
Resultantly, further proceeding in the Jowai Police Station Case
No. 48(04) of 2023 arising out of the impugned FIR dated 14-04-2023
filed by the respondent No.2 is quashed. Despite the quashing of the
impugned FIR, it would be open for the respondent No.2 to place his
version of the case along with the supporting documents before the
investigating agency of the Sankrail police station case No. 1144/2022
and the same may be done in the form of a counter-FIR, if so advised.
27.
With the aforesaid direction this Criminal Petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
14.11.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review