Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Mr. Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia,
S/o late Sonam Topden Bhutia,
Residing at Children Park,
Tibet Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…..
Petitioner
Versus
1. Miss Aishwarya Rai,
D/o late Gyanson Rai,
Permanent R/o Dokan Dara, Kurseong,
District Darjeeling, West Bengal,
Presently residing at Maskey Villa,
Near Durga Mandir, Lower Sichey,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
General Public.
….. Respondents
Application under Article 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India.
(Petition challenging Order dated 25.09.2021, passed by
learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Title Suit No. 39 of
2014).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Souri Ghosal and Mr.
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Amresh Kumar
Mandal,
Mr. N. B. Khatiwara, Senior Advocate with Ms.
Sarda, Legal Aid Counsel for Respondent No.1.
Navtara
AND
W.P. (C) No. 19 of 2022
Mr. Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia,
S/o late Sonam Topden Bhutia,
Residing at Children Park,
Tibet Road, Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
…..
Petitioner
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
Versus
1.
Miss Aishwarya Rai,
D/o late Gyanson Rai,
Permanent R/o Dokan Dara, Kurseong,
District Darjeeling, West Bengal,
Presently residing at Maskey Villa,
Near Durga Mandir, Lower Sichey,
P.O. Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2.
General Public.
….. Respondents
Application under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
(Petition challenging Order dated 21.03.2022 passed by
learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Title Suit No. 39 of
2014).
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Souri Ghosal and Mr.
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Amresh Kumar
Mandal,
Mr. N. B. Khatiwara, Senior Advocate with Ms.
Sarda, Legal Aid Counsel for Respondent No.1.
Navtara
26.07.2022
J U D G M E N T (ORAL)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
1.
This judgment shall dispose of two petitions filed under
Article 227 of the Constitution of India. W.P. (C) No.38 of
2021 seeks to assails the order dated 25.09.2021 passed by
the learned Civil Judge, East Sikkim at Gangtok in Title Suit
No.39 of 2014. By the Order dated 25.09.2021 the learned
Civil Judge disallowed the application filed by the petitioner
to exempt him from paying the cost imposed for the failure
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
to file written statement to the amended plaint filed by the
respondent no.1. W.P. (C) No. 19 of 2022 assails the order
dated 21.03.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge, East
Sikkim at Gangtok in the same suit by which an application
under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC filed by the respondent no.1
was allowed in toto.
2.
At this juncture it would be relevant to note certain
facts crucial for deciding these petitions. In the year 2014
the respondent no.1 filed a suit for declaration of title. It was
the respondent No.1’s claim that she is the daughter of late
Sonam Topden Bhutia and accordingly a declaration was
sought to the effect. A further declaration was also prayed
that she should be called Aishwarya Bhutia daughter of late
Sonam Topden Bhutia in all her official documents. The suit
was filed against the general public. By a judgment dated
24.07.2015 the learned Civil Judge dismissed the suit. In an
appeal filed by the respondent no.1 on 22.07.2016 the
learned District Judge found that the petitioner was a
necessary party as he would be directly affected by the
outcome of the case and added him as a defendant.
Subsequently on 25.09.2017 the learned District Judge held
that given the nature of the suit and the reliefs prayed for
there could be no doubt that the petitioner, the respondent
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
no.1 and other legal heirs ought to have been arrayed as
parties in the suit as they were necessary parties. The
impugned judgment of the trial court of the learned Civil
Judge rendered in the absence of necessary parties was set
aside and the matter remanded for impleading the legal
heirs of late Sonam Topden Bhutia as defendant in the suit.
The respondent no.1 who was the plaintiff in the suit was
allowed to amend her pleadings to the extent required. On
09.11.2017 the respondent no.1 filed the amended plaint.
On 14.05.2018 the amended plaint filed by the respondent
no.1 was accepted by the Trial Court dismissing the
objection raised by the petitioner that the amended plaint
sought to change the nature and character of the original
suit. The learned Civil Judge held that the suit was
remanded with permission to make all necessary changes
after impleading the necessary parties which meant that the
respondent no.1 could also claim the properties which had
come to their knowledge subsequently lest it is barred by
law. It interpreted the term “extent required” used by the
learned District Judge in the remand order to be a broad
term which would permit such an amendment. Accordingly,
the objection filed by the petitioner was dismissed. The same
order dated 14.05.2018 also referred to an application under
Order 6 Rule 17 and Order 7 Rule 14(3) filed by the
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
petitioner which was decided to be heard subsequently. On
08.06.2018 these applications were considered and allowed.
On 29.03.2019 this court in CRP No. 05 of 2018 examined
the order dated 14.05.2018 passed by the learned Civil
Judge. The respondent no.1 conceded that the procedure
prescribed by law had not been adhered to and therefore, he
had no objection if the order is set aside. Accordingly, the
order dated 14.05.2018 passed by the learned Civil Judge
was set aside. An application for withdrawal of plaint under
Order 23 Rule 1 (3) of the CPC filed on 27.05.2019 by the
respondent no.1 was rejected by the learned Civil Judge on
28.06.2019. Thereafter, on 09.07.2019 the respondent no.1
filed an application under Order 6 Rule 17 for amendment.
By this application various amendments were sought for
including additional facts and additional prayers which,
according to the petitioner, would change the nature and
character of the original suit itself. It included prayers with
regard to various properties which was not the subject
matter of the original suit. On 10.09.2019 this application
under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC was allowed by the learned Civil
Judge. On 23.09.2019 the respondent no.1 filed the
amended plaint and the learned Civil Judge fixed the date
01.10.2019 for filing amended written statement. On
01.10.2019 instead of filing the amended written statement
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
as directed the petitioner chose to file an application under
Order 39 Rule 1 and 2 CPC. The learned Civil Judge granted
the petitioner further time till 14.10.2019 to file the
amended written statement as a final opportunity and
observing that failure to do so would entail a cost of
Rs.10,000/- for trying to delay the matter. Since, the
learned Civil Judge did not preside over the court on
14.10.2019 the matter was taken up on 17.10.2019 on
which date the petitioner filed yet another application under
order 7 Rule 10 (4) CPC challenging the pecuniary
jurisdiction of the learned Civil Judge. The learned Civil
Judge also passed an order on the same date reminding the
learned counsel for the petitioner about the cost imposed
upon them on 01.10.2019 and directed them to either
comply with the order or file an appropriate application on
the next date. On 05.11.2019 the petitioner filed an
application
seeking
exemption
from
paying
the
cost
imposed. On 07.11.2019 the petitioner’s appeal being FAO
No 3 of 2018 against the order dated 25.9.2017 passed by
the learned District Jude, Special Division-I was admitted
and further proceedings in the suit was suspended. On
06.03.2021 this court dismissed the appeal preferred by the
petitioner and the order passed by the learned District
Judge was upheld with the observation that the parties were
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
at liberty to take recourse of law as permissible while
deciding the suit afresh on its restoration. On 03.08.2021
W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021 challenging the order dated
10.09.2019 passed by the learned Civil Judge allowing the
application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC seeking amendment
of the plaint was allowed and the order dated 10.09.2019
was set aside. This court further observed that considering
the judgment of the learned District Judge dated 25.09.2017
which was affirmed by this court on 06.03.2021 in FAO No.
3 of 2018 the legal heirs of late Sonam Topden Bhutia
should be impleaded as defendants in the suit and
amendment for the said purpose to the extend required can
be permitted if prayed by the respondent no.1. With the said
observation this court permitted the respondent no.1 to
amend the plaint afresh. On 06.08.2021 the learned Civil
Judge noted the order passed by this court on 03.08.2021 in
W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021. The learned Civil Judge granted
time to the respondent no.1 to file objection to the
application filed by the petitioner for exemption in paying
the cost imposed. The objection was filed on 25.08.2021,
matter heard on 13.09.2021 and on 25.09.2021 the order
impugned in W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021 was passed. Thereafter,
on 28.12.2021 the respondent no.1 filed an application
under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) read with section 151 CPC
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
praying for various amendments once again not only adding
the legal heirs of late Sonam Topden Bhutia as necessary
parties but also seeking to amend the entire suit with
various pleadings and praying for various reliefs. The
application stated that subsequent to the filing of the suit
certain new facts were revealed to the respondent no.1
which has a direct bearing on the outcome of the case and
as such the respondent no.1 seeks to introduce a new cause
of action which is arisen to the respondent no.1 during the
pendency of the suit. It further averred that the respondent
no.1 came to know that on 18.12.2015 that the properties
belonging to her father late Sonam Topden Bhutia had been
transferred to the names of the petitioner (defendant no.1,
defendant no.2 and defendant no.3) and further that the
Certificate of Identification of the defendant nos. 1 and 2
have been cancelled by the Additional District Magistrate,
East and South Sikkim on the basis of a complaint filed by
the respondent no.1. Thus, the respondent no.1 vide the
application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC sought to change
the cause title of the plaint making the petitioner, Angela
Penzum Bhutia and Elimith Lepcha as necessary parties; to
change the suit from a declaratory suit to a suit for
ejectment, recovery of possession and other reliefs as well. It
also sought to insert various paragraphs in the plaint
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
necessary for grant of the prayers for ejectment, recovery of
possession and other reliefs as well. The respondent no.1
also sought for the following:“ ………..
(xxxii) To redraw the prayers in Paragraph 32
of the Plaint which will read, “PRAYERS
In the facts and circumstances as stated
herein above, the Plaintiff prays for the
following reliefs:(i)
A decree declaring that the Plaintiff is the
daughter of Late Sonam Topden Bhutia.
(ii)
A decree declaring that the Plaintiff shall
henceforth be known and called as
Aishwarya Bhutia daughter of Late
Sonam Topden Bhutia;
(iii)
A decree declaring that the Defendants
No. 1 & 2 Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia and
Angela Penzum are not the son and
daughter of Late Sonam Topden Bhutia.
(iv)
A decree declaring that the Defendant
No.3 is not the daughter in law of the
Plaintiff’s father Late Sonam Topden
Bhutia;
(v)
A decree declaring that the Plaintiff is the
sole inheritor and absolute owner of
Schedule A property by being only
biological child of Late Sonam Topden
Bhutia.
(vi)
A decree declaring that the transfer of
Schedule B and C property unto the
name of Defendant No.1 is null and void
being void ab initio;
A decree declaring that the transfer of
Schedule D property unto the name of
Defendant No.2 is null and void being
void ab initio;
(vii)
(viii)
A decree declaring that the transfer of
Schedule E property unto the name of
Defendant No.3 is null and void being
void ab initio;
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
3.
(ix)
A decree of ejectment against the
Defendant No.1 from Schedule B and C
properties.
(x)
A decree
Defendant
property.
of ejectment against the
No.2 from Schedule D
(xi)
A decree
Defendant
property.
of ejectment against the
No.3 from Schedule E
(xii)
A
decree
transferring
the
khas
possession of Schedule B and C
properties from Defendant No.1 to the
Plaintiff.
(xiii)
A
decree
transferring
the
khas
possession of Schedule D property from
Defendant No.2 to the Plaintiff.
(xiv)
A
decree
transferring
the
khas
possession of Schedule E property from
Defendnat No.3 to the Plaintiff.
(xv)
A decree for mesne profit.
(xvi)
Any order or direction or declaration as
this Hon’ble Court may deem fit and
proper, in the interest of justice and
equity.
……………….”
This application was allowed by the learned Civil Judge
on the ground that the respondent no.1 had rightly filed an
application under Order 1 Rule 10(4) CPC to amend the
plaint upon impleading new defendants to the suit in the
light of the orders passed by the court of the learned District
Judge as well as this Court. The learned Civil Judge not only
allowed the impleadment of the legal heirs of late Sonam
Topden Bhutia but also allowed the respondent no.1 to
amend the plaint from a suit for declaration to a suit of
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
ejectment and recovery of possession of properties changing
the nature and character of the original suit itself.
4.
It would be relevant to consider the two applications
filed by the respondent no.1. One was under Order 6 Rule
17 CPC and the other under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC.
Admittedly, the amendments sought for in both these
applications and the prayers therein were substantially the
same. The first application under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC
which was initially permitted by the learned Civil Judge was
subsequently set aside by this court and therefore, the
amendments sought for in that application were disallowed.
The order dated 03.08.2021 in W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021 was
clear. The order dated 10.09.2019 allowing the application
under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC was set aside. This court not
only did that but made it further clear that the respondent
no.1 shall be permitted to amend the plaint only to the
extent of impleading the legal heirs of late Sonam Topden
Bhutia as defendants in the original suit filed by the
respondent no.1 and amendment to the extent required was
permitted. However, without any deference to the order
passed by this court the respondent no.1 sought to use
Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC to annul the consequence of the
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
application filed by her under Order 6 Rule 17 CPC. Order 1
Rule 10 (4) CPC provides:
“10.(4) Where defendant added, plaint to
be amended.- Where a defendant is added,
the plaint shall, unless the court otherwise
directs, be amended in such manner as may be
necessary, and amended copies of the
summons and of the plaint shall be served on
the new defendant and, if the Court thinks fit,
on the original defendant.”
5.
Order 6 Rule 17 CPC provides:
“17. Amendment of pleadings.- The Court
may at any stage of the proceedings allow
either party to alter or amend his pleadings in
such manner and on such terms as may be
just, and all such amendments shall be made
as may be necessary for the purpose of
determining the real questions in controversy
between the parties:
Provided
that no
application for
amendment shall be allowed after the trial has
commenced, unless the Court comes to the
conclusion that in spite of due diligence, the
party could not have raised the matter before
the commencement of trial”.
6.
In Asian Hotel (North) Ltd. vs. Alok Kumar Lodha1 the
Supreme Court considered the impugned common judgment
and order dated 15.09.2021 passed by the High Court of
Delhi in applications filed in commercial suits under Order 1
Rule 10 and Order 6 Rule 17 CPC, by which, all the
applications submitted on behalf of the original plaintiff was
allowed. The High Court had permitted the original plaintiff
1 2022 SCC OnLine SC 844
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
to amend the respective suits and had also ordered
impleadment of the mortgagees. The Supreme Court held
that. “As per the settled proposition of law, if, by permitting
plaintiffs to amend the plaint including a prayer clause nature
of the suit is likely to be changed, in that case, the court
would not be justified in allowing the amendment. It would
also resulting mis-joinder of causes of action”. The Supreme
Court further held that the High Court had committed
serious error in allowing the application under Order 6 Rule
17 and under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC by permitting the
original plaintiffs to amend the plaint including prayer
clause by which, the plaintiffs have now prayed to declare
the charges/mortgages on the entire premises as void abinitio and permitting the original plaintiff to join/implead the
respective banks/financial institutions as party defendant. It
held that in a suit challenging revocation of respective
licenses, the plaintiffs cannot be permitted to challenge the
respective mortgages/charges created on the entire premises
as void ab-intio. Thus, the impugned orders passed by the
High Court allowing the applications under Order 6 Rule 17
and under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC were quashed and set
aside.
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
7.
Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC enables the court to add any
person as party at any stage of the proceedings if the person
whose presence before the court is necessary in order to
enable the court to effectively and completely adjudicate
upon and settled all the questions involved in the suit. The
Supreme Court in Ramesh Hirachand Kundanmal vs. Municipal
Corporation of Greater Bombay2 held that if addition of parties
means the addition of new cause of action and widening of a
particular issue, the party should not be added in such a
situation. The mere fact that a fresh litigation could be
avoided is also no ground. The addition of a party may be
allowed when it is found by the court that the party sought
to be added is a necessary party or a proper party in whose
absence the suit cannot be decided or no effective decree
can be passed.
8.
Whereas
Order
Rule
10(4)
CPC
relates
to
impleadment of a new defendant it also permits amendment
of the plaint as may be necessary in view of the impleadment
of the new defendant. Order 6 Rule 17 CPC relates to
amendments of pleadings.
The amendment sought for by
the respondent no.1 in her application under Order 6 Rule
17 has already been decided by this court vide order dated
2 (1992) 2 SCC 524
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
03.08.2021 in W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021. The respondent no.1
as well as the learned Civil Judge was required to comply
with the same. Instead the respondent no.1 sought to
reopen and re-agitate the same amendments which had
already been considered by this court and rejected by filing
the application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC.
The
impugned order dated 21.03.2022 decided the application
under
Order
Rule
(4)
CPC
seeking
not
only
impleadment of parties but also various amendments
beyond the scope of the provision. On the touch stone of the
law clearly laid down by the Supreme Court it is quite
evident that the learned Civil Judge has failed to consider
whether the amendment sought for by the respondent no.1
in their application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC would
change the nature and character of the original suit itself
which would have been clear if the orders passed by this
court (supra) would have been carefully considered. Further,
by allowing the application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC of
the respondent no.1 filed after the order dated 03.08.2021 in
W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021 the learned Civil Judge seems to
have brought to naught the order of this court dated
03.08.2021 in W.P. (C) No.26 of 2021 by which identical
prayers of amendment was disallowed. This is simply
impermissible. The application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4)
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
CPC was clearly ill advised. The amendments prayed for in
the application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC beyond what
was permitted by this court on 03.08.2021 could not have
been allowed by the learned Civil Judge. To that extent the
amendment sought for would have changed the nature and
character of the original suit itself which is impermissible.
The prayers as prayed for in paragraph (iii) to (xv) in the
application under Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC which would
change the nature and character of the original suit cannot
be granted in the application.
Accordingly, the impugned
order dated 21.03.2022 passed by the learned Civil Judge,
East Sikkim at Gangtok is set aside.
9.
Insofar as W.P. (C) No.38 of 2021 is concerned
considering the totality of the case and the fact that till date
there is no amended plaint as permitted by this court and
the order dated 10.09.2019 passed by the learned Civil
Judge having been set aside by this court by order dated
03.08.2021 the question of filing written statement even at
this stage would not arise. In such view of the matter the
cost imposed upon the petitioner for not filing the written
statement within the time frame prescribed by the learned
Civil Judge is also set aside.
W.P. (C) No. 38 of 2021
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
AND
W.P. (C ) No. 19 of 2022
Jigmi Phunchok Bhutia vs. Aishwarya Rai & Anr.
10. The respondent no.1 is given a final opportunity to file
an amended plaint only to the extent of impleading the legal
heirs of late Sonam Topden Bhutia as defendants and
making the necessary pleadings to substantiate the same in
the plaint without changing the nature and character of the
original suit. On receipt, after giving an opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner, the learned Civil Judge shall
consider the impleadment and consequential amendments
sought for by examining the original plaint, the order dated
03.08.2021 passed by this court in W.P. (C) No. 26 of 2021
as well as Order 1 Rule 10 (4) CPC and thereafter, implead
them and allow only such amendments as has been directed
by this court. The respondent no.1 shall file the amended
plaint within a period of 20 days from today, failing which
the learned Civil Judge shall proceed further as per law.
Both the petitions are allowed and disposed of.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
to/ Approved for reporting: Yes/No
Internet
:Yes/No
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review