Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No. 1/13
GAHC010265402025
2026:GAU-AS:10604
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(THE HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM & ARUNACHAL
PRADESH)
Writ petition [c] no. 7169/2025
Jiarul
Islam,
S/o-
Abdul
Mannan,
Vill.
Barbhita, P.O. Jatradia, P.S. Tarabari, Dist.
Barpeta, Pin - 781305.
………………Petitioner
-VERSUS-
1.
The State of Assam, Represented by the
Commissioner
and
Secretary
to
the
Government of Assam, Land Revenue and
Disaster Management Department, Dispur,
Guwahati - 781006.
2.
The District Commissioner, Barpeta, P.O.
Barpeta, Pin - 781301.
3.
The Revenue Circle Officer, Chenga, Dist.
Barpeta, P.O. Chenga, Pin - 781305.
……………….Respondents
Page No. 2/13
BeFore
Hon’BLe Mr. JUStice MAniSH cHoUDHUrY
Advocates :
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. M.A. Sheikh, Advocate
For the Respondent no. 1
:
Mr.
S.
Dutta,
Counsel,
Standing
Revenue
Department
For the Respondent nos. 2 & 3
:
Mr. H.K. Hazarika, Junior
Government
Advocate,
Assam
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
28.07.2026
:
No
:
Yes
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment ?
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced ?
JUDGMent & orDer
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India
is preferred by the petitioner aggrieved by rejection of his
application for issuance of a ‘Permanent Residential Certificate
[PRC] for Higher Education’ by a Rejection Order dated
04.04.2025 passed by the Designated Public Servant. Assail is
made to the Rejection Order dated 04.04.2025 on the ground
that the same has been passed arbitrarily and without
Page No. 3/13
application of mind. The Rejection Order is also assailed on the
ground that the factors germane for issuance of Permanent
Residential Certificate [PRC] for Higher Education were not
taken into consideration by the Designated Public Servant.
2.
It is stated that the petitioner was born on 01.09.2002. The
name of his grandfather Late Jabed Ali, son of Sadek and the
name of his father is Sri Abdul Mannan. It is stated that the
family of the petitioner has been residing in Village – Barbhita,
Sub-Division – Barpeta, Mouza – Chenga, Police Station –
Tarabari, District – Barpeta, which is within the territorial limits
of Chenga Legislative Assembly Constituency [LAC], since the
time of his grandfather. It is stated that the name of the
petitioner’s
grandfather
appeared
in
the
Electoral
Roll,
published in the years 1970, 1997 and thereafter for Chenga
LAC. It is further mentioned that in the NRC of 1951, the name
of the petitioner’s grandfather was recorded wrongly as Abed
Ali, instead of Jabed Ali. The petitioner has claimed that there
was an annual Kheraj Patta no. 105 issued in favour of the
petitioner’s grandfather on 09.01.1965 in respect of a plot of
land, covered by Dag nos. 208 and 225, Village – Barbhita.
3.
The petitioner has stated that as he has the requisite
qualifications, he appeared in the National Eligibility-cumEntrance Test [NEET] [UG] – 2025 conducted for the Ministry of
Education & Ministry of Health and Family Welfare Department,
Government of India by the National Testing Agency [NTA] on
04.05.2025. In the application submitted for the NEET [UG] –
2025, the petitioner mentioned Assam as the State of eligibility.
The application submitted by the petitioner for NEET [UG] –
2025 was processed and thereafter, a provisional Admit Card
was issued to him to appear in the NEET [UG] – 2025 on
Page No. 4/13
04.05.2025 from a test centre in Guwahati. The petitioner’s Roll
Number, as shown in the provisional Admit Card, was
1402109124. Accordingly, the petitioner appeared in the NEET
[UG-2025] on 04.05.2025. As per the Score Card published by
the National Testing Agency [NTA], the petitioner scored
92.5368790 Percentile, by obtaining 425 marks out of total
marks of 720.
4.
As after publication of the results, the NTA used to conduct
Counselling Sessions for the purpose of admitting students in
the Medical Colleges and it was a requirement to submit a
Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC] to get admission with
Assam as the petitioner’s State of eligibility, the petitioner
applied for a Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC] online in
the designated portal on 12.03.2025. The receipt of the said
application number was acknowledged as Application no.
SSDG/ED/PRC/107708762.
As
per
the
acknowledgement
receipt, the Designated Public Servant for the notified public
service, ‘Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC]’ was the
District Commissioner, Barpeta and fourteen working days from
12.03.2025 was mentioned as proposed delivery date.
5.
When the petitioner did not receive the service within the
prescribed delivery date, the petitioner checked the status of
his application in the designated portal and on such checking,
the petitioner came to learn from the designated portal that the
concerned Circle Officer did not recommend for issuance of the
Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC] for the petitioner. In
the designated portal, the status of the application was shown
simply as ‘Rejected’. Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has
approached this Court by the instant writ petition assailing the
said Rejection Order dated 04.04.2025 and for a direction to
Page No. 5/13
the respondent authorities to issue the Permanent Residential
Certificate [PRC].
6.
I have heard Mr. M.A. Sheikh, learned counsel for the
petitioner; Mr. S. Dutta, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue &
Disaster Management Department, Government of Assam for
the respondent no. 1; and Mr. H.K. Hazarika, learned Junior
Government Advocate, Assam for the respondent nos. 2 & 3.
7.
Mr. Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
submitted that the petitioner had submitted all the supporting
documents along with the application when he submitted the
application online on 12.03.2025. It is submitted by Mr. Sheikh
that there was a minor discrepancy in the name of the
petitioner’s grandfather in the NRC of 1951 in that his name
was wrongly shown as ‘Abed Ali’ instead of ‘Jabed Ali’. To that
effect, an affidavit was submitted stating that the names were
wrongly shown as ‘Abed Ali’ and ‘Sabed’, instead of ‘Jabed Ali’
and ‘Sadek’. He has further contended that the Rejection Order
dated 04.04.2025 was without any reason. He has further
canvassed that the respondent authorities have subsequently
tried to improve their case by showing certain reasons in the
affidavit-in-opposition filed through the respondent no. 3.
According to him, such explanations are not to be taken into
consideration when the question is regarding legality and
validity of the impugned Rejection Order dated 04.04.2025. It is
also contended on behalf of the petitioner that with the
application, the petitioner had submitted a number of other
documents in support of the claim, apart from the NRC of 1951
reflecting the name of the petitioner’s grandfather. It is
contended that the respondent authorities, more particularly,
the Designated Public Servant did not consider any of those
Page No. 6/13
supporting documents prior to rejection of the application by
the cryptic Rejection Order dated 04.04.2025.
8.
In response, Mr. Dutta, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue
Department has submitted that the matter of issuance of
Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC] for Higher Education is
regulated by the procedure laid down in an Office Memorandum
dated 01.04.2013 issued by the Political [B] Department,
Government of Assam. He has drawn attention to the fact that
issue of PRC for Higher Education is a notified public service
under the Assam Right to Public Services [ARTPS] Act, 2012
and therefore, if the petitioner is aggrieved by the Rejection
Order dated 04.04.2025, the petitioner has the remedy of filing
of an appeal instead of approaching this Court by filing a writ
petition under Article 226 of the Constitution directly. Mr. Dutta
has
placed
a copy
of the
Office Memorandum
dated
01.04.2013; a Notification dated 10.04.2013 issued under
Section 4 of the Assam Right to Public Services [ARTPS] Act,
2012, as amended; an Office Memorandum dated 19.01.2022;
and a Circular dated 01.04.2022 of the Political [B] Department,
Government of Assam, which are on the subject of issuance of
PRC for educational purposes.
9.
Mr. Hazarika, learned Junior Government Advocate, Assam
appearing for the respondent nos. 2 & 3 has submitted, by
referring to the statements and averments made in the
affidavit-in-opposition filed through the respondent no. 3, that
the petitioner himself had admitted regarding the discrepancy
in the NRC of 1951, where the name of the applicant’s
grandfather was recorded as ‘Abed Ali’ instead of ‘Jabed Ali’. He
has contended that a self-declared affidavit, which was
submitted by the petitioner could not be treated as a legal
Page No. 7/13
document to remove the discrepancy in the NRC of 1951. He
has submitted that there was a break in linkage and due to
variations in the names, the application for the PRC was
rejected on 04.04.2024 after submission of a field verification
report by the Land Records Assistant.
10. I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel for
the parties and have also gone through the materials brought
on record by the learned counsel for the parties through their
pleadings.
11. As per the Office Memorandum dated 01.04.2013, ‘Issue of
Permanent Residential Certificate [PRC] for Higher Education’ is
a notified public service and a PRC is issued to Indian citizens
only for the purpose of admission to educational institutions
where such certificates are insisted upon by the educational
institutions. Such certificates are issued as per existing
provisions after due examination by the District Commissioners
and Sub-Divisional Officers [Civil] containing a clear provision
that it will be applicable only in respect of the specific
requirement of admission to that specific institution and shall
not be valid for any other purpose.
12. In the Circular dated 01.04.2022 [supra] also, it has been
clarified that the PRC will be issued only for the purpose of
admission
to educational
institutions
with
the
following
conditions : [i] Admission to educational institutions where such
certificates are insisted upon; [ii] PRCs are to be issued as per
existing provisions after due examination by DCs/SDOs; and [iii]
PRCs should contain a clear provision that it will be applicable
only in respect of the specific requirement of admission to that
specific institution and shall not be valid for any other purposes.
Page No. 8/13
13. The procedure to be followed for submitting an application for
PRC and issuance of PRC has been outlined in the Office
Memorandum
dated
01.04.2013. In the
Citizen
Charter
attached to the Office Memorandum, the Standard Guidelines,
Procedure, Timeline, Designated Public Servant, Appellate
Authority, Reviewing Authority and the documents required to
be submitted with the application are specified.
14. It is of relevance to mention that the following three categories
of persons are made eligible for Permanent Residential
Certificate
[PRC]
for
Higher
Education
by
the
Office
Memorandum dated 01.04.2013 :- [1] a person who along with
his parents and forefathers or whose parents and forefathers
has/have continuously resided in Assam for a minimum period
of 50 years; [2] a person who has continuously resided in
Assam for a minimum period of 20 years; and [3] a person who
is a child of any person falling in any of the preceding
categories.
15. In the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the respondent no. 3, it is
averred that the petitioner has himself admitted that there is a
discrepancy in the NRC of 1951 in that there the name of the
petitioner’s grandfather was recorded as ‘Abed Ali’ instead of
‘Jabed Ali’ and therefore, a self-declared affidavit dated
30.10.1993 cannot be treated as a conclusive legal document to
remove the discrepancy in the NRC of 1951. It is further
averred that since there is a break in linkage between the
legacy person [1951] and the subsequent generations resulting
in variation of names ‘Jabed’ and ‘Abed’ and in absence of an
unbroken chain, the Revenue Office could not verify the claim.
It is stated that inclusion in the latest NRC is the primary proof
Page No. 9/13
of citizenship and a PRC requires distinct proof of permanent
domicile.
16. From the stand taken by the respondent no. 3 in the affidavitin-opposition, it appears that the primary ground for rejection
of the application of the petitioner is the discrepancy in the
legacy data recorded in the NRC of 1951 regarding the link of
the petitioner’s grandfather with the petitioner. Having regard
to
the
Circular
dated
01.04.2022
of
the
Political
[B]
Department, Government of Assam, which has been issued as a
clarification in the matter of issuance of PRC, this Court is of the
considered view that such ground as the primary ground for
rejection of the application of the petitioner for PRC is not
tenable. In the Circular dated 01.04.2022, it has been clarified
that for an application of PRC, which is a notified public service
under the provisions of Assam Right to Public Services [ARTPS]
Act, 2012, the Designated Public Servant is not to insist on
submission of a copy of Draft NRC, which was published on
31.08.2019 as a supporting document while applying for PRC
by the applicant. The reason is that the Draft NRC published on
31.08.2019 is yet to be finalised by the competent authority.
17. As per the Citizen Charter annexed to the Office Memorandum
dated 01.04.2013, the stipulated time period for providing the
notified public service is fourteen days and the Designated
Public Servant is the Additional District Commissioner or SubDivisional
Officer
[Sadar],
as
notified
by
the
District
Commissioner in a District and the Sub-Divisional Officer [C] in
the Sub-Division. The Appellate Authority is the District
Commissioner.
Page No. 10/13
18. The Assam Right to Public Services [ARTPS] Act, 2012 has been
enacted by the Assam Legislative Assembly in order to provide
for delivery of notified public services to the people of the State
of Assam within the stipulated time limit and for matters
connected therewith and incidental thereto. As per Section
2[h], ‘Right to Public Service’ means right to obtain the public
services under the ARTPS Act, notified from time to time, within
the stipulated time limit as prescribed under Section 5. Section
5 of the ARTPS Act has laid down that every eligible person
shall have the right to obtain the services in accordance with
the ARTPS Act within the time bound period as notified under
Section 4. It is the liability of the Designated Government
Servant to deliver services, under Section 6 of the ARTPS Act,
within the stipulated period. The stipulated time limit, as per
Section 7[1], starts from the date when the application for
obtaining a required notified service is submitted to the
Designated Public Servant or to a person subordinate to him
authorized to receive the application. As per Section 7[2], the
Designated Public Servant on receipt of an application under
sub-section [1] shall, within the stipulated time limit, provide
the notified service or reject the application and in case of
rejection of application, he shall record the reasons in writing
and communicate to the person making the application, [i] the
reasons for such rejection; [ii] the period within which an
appeal against such rejection may be preferred; and [iii] the
particulars of the Appellate Authority.
19. A reasoned or speaking order is one which expressly states the
reasons for the decision. In other words, a reasoned order
speaks for itself by assigning the reasons behind the
conclusion. If an order is passed without giving a reason by the
concerned authority, more particularly, when the authority is
Page No. 11/13
statutory authority then the order is a non-speaking one. Nonspeaking order is one which does not provide a clear reason for
its decision. The authority exercising the statutory power must
record reasons for its decision, unless such obligation is not
expressly or impliedly dispensed with. It is implicit in the
principles of natural justice and fair play that an authority which
has been vested with the power to decide the matter should
record reasons as it is part of fair procedure, more particularly,
when the decision is likely to affect the person concerned.
When the order is an appealable order, recording of reasons
assumes significance as the reasons would come under
examination of the appellate authority. Without a reasoned
order, the appellant also finds himself handicapped to challenge
the order when the reasons are not disclosed in the order itself.
In the case in hand, the right of the applicant is also traceable
to his right to pursue education. Recording of reasons is also
prima facie suggestive of conscious application of mind on the
part of the authority. The obligation to record reasons is a
possible check against arbitrary action on the part of the
authority invested with the statutory power to take a decision
which is likely to affect the right of the person concerned. When
the statute itself contains a prescription to record reasons in the
decision, absence of reasons in the decision falls short of
prescription and would be in violation of the prescription and
thus, illegal. Against a non-speaking order, even if it is an
appealable order, a writ petition under Article 226 of the
Constitution can be entertained as such an order is in violation
of the principles of natural justice and fairplay.
20. The reason assigned subsequently regarding rejection of the
petitioner’s application for NRC in the affidavit is not found
sustainable in view of the clarification provided in the Circular
Page No. 12/13
dated 01.04.2022. That apart, any reason assigned in the
affidavit-in-opposition is to be discarded considering the
rejection of the application cryptically as ‘Rejected’. The law is
settled that when a statutory functionary makes an order based
on certain ground, its validity must be judged by the reasons so
mentioned and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in the
shape of affidavit or otherwise. Otherwise, an order that in the
beginning may, by the time it comes to court on account of a
challenge, gets validated by additional grounds later brought
out [Mohinder Singh Gill and another vs. the Chief Election
Commissioner, New Delhi and others, [1978] 1 SCC 405].
21. Viewed from the above standpoints, the Rejection Order dated
04.04.2025 cannot be termed as a reasoned order, fulfilling the
prescription under Section 7[2] of the Assam Right to Public
Services [ARTPS] Act, 2012, as amended. Thus, the impugned
Rejection Order is liable to be set aside and quashed. It is
accordingly set aside and quashed.
22. At this stage, Mr. Sheikh, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner has submitted that though the process of admission
through the Counseling Sessions on the basis of the results of
NEET [UG] – 2025 has already been over, the petitioner has, in
the meantime, appeared in the NEET [UG] – 2026. As per the
Score-Card published in the NEET [UG] – 2026, as placed by
Mr. Sheikh, the petitioner has scored 522 marks out of total 720
marks and his percentile score is 96.7910815. Mr. Sheikh has
submitted that there is a fair possibility of the petitioner getting
admission into a Medical College on the basis of such ScoreCard in the Counseling Sessions likely to be held within a month
or two.
Page No. 13/13
23. With the setting aside and quashing of the Rejection Order
dated 04.04.2025, the matter stands reverted back to the
Designated Public Servant for consideration of the application of
the petitioner for issuance of PRC for Higher Education. The
Designated Public Servant shall consider the application afresh
strictly in terms of the Office Memorandum dated 01.04.2013;
the provisions of Assam Right to Public Services [ARTPS] Act,
2012, as amended; the Citizen Charter attached to the Office
Memorandum dated 01.04.2013; and other notifications/office
memoranda/circular, etc. on the subject. As the matter of the
admission of the petitioner for pursuing medical education on
the basis of the results in the NEET [UG] – 2026 is dependent
with the issuance of PRC for Higher Education or otherwise, the
Designated Public Servant shall bring the entire process into its
finality within a period of thirty days from the date of
submission of a certified copy of this order at his office by the
petitioner. If in the processing of the application, any further
document is found necessary from the petitioner, then the
Designated Public Servant is to inform the petitioner in writing
as regards the deficiency, if any, in the application within a time
period of fifteen days from the date of submission of a copy of
this order at his office. In such a situation, the time period of
thirty days is to be calculated from the date of meeting the
deficiency by the petitioner.
24. With the observations made and the directions given above, the
writ petition is allowed to the extent, indicated above. There
shall, however, be no order as to cost.
Ananta Konwar
DN: c=IN, o=Personal, postalCode=782103, l=Nagaon, st=Assam, street=00
Kahiguri, Gandhibari, Raha Assam India 782103 Near Namghar, title=8844,
2.5.4.20=b5a05e1af058b36f4059a90ed7cffd5bb96f7ecd72ef4648d7f09f1773
320e01,
serialNumber=d2d87646b496abfcb916daa92f0cc8a8476a70693ea30fe4d16
a2fc5fbaca1e3, email=anantakonwar88@gmail.com, cn=Ananta Konwar
Date: 2026.08.01 13:57:52 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review