Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:1:
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE VIJU ABRAHAM
WEDNESDAY, THE 26TH DAY OF MARCH 2025 / 5TH CHAITHRA, 1947
WP(C) NO. 13474 OF 2022
PETITIONER:
JESUS GEORGE,
AGED 56 YEARS
S/O. GEORGE, THAIKKODAM HOUSE, V.P. MARIKKAR ROAD,
EDAPPALLY P.O, KOCHI- 682024
BY ADVS.
JOHNSON MANAYANI
BENHUR JOSEPH MANAYANI
JEEVAN MATHEW MANAYANI
RESPONDENTS:
KALAMASSERY MUNICIPALITY,
MUNICIPAL COMPLEX, KALAMASSERY P.O, ERNAKULAM 683104, REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY
THE SECRETARY,
KALAMASSERY MUNICIPALITY, MUNICIPAL COMPLEX,
KALAMASSERY P.O, ERNAKULAM - 683104
THE TAHSILDAR,
KANAYANNUR TALUK, TALUK OFFICE, ERNAKULAM - 682011
THE TALUK SURVEYOR,
KANAYANNUR TALUK, TALUK OFFICE, ERNAKULAM - 682011
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:2:
STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY TO LOCAL SELF
GOVERNMENT, SECRETARIAT, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM 695001.
*ADDL.R6: STANLY K.J.,AGED 59 YEARS,
S/O.JACOB, KURISINKAL HOUSE, JAWAHAR LANE,
V.P.MARAKKAR ROAD, EDAPPALLY P.O., KOCHI-682 024.
*ADDL. R7:SABITH M.M., AGED 47 YEARS,
S/O.M.M. MOHAMMED ALI, MANAKKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
JAWAHAR LANE, V.P.MARAKKAR ROAD, EDAPPALLY TOLL,
KOPCHI-682 024
*ADDL. R8:ABDUL NAZAR M.M., AGED 58 YEARS,
S/O.M.M. MOHAMMED ALI, MANAKKAPARAMBIL HOUSE,
JAWAHAR LANE, V.P.MARAKKAR ROAD, EDAPPALLY TOLL,
KOPCHI-682 024.
(*ADDL.R6 TO R8 ARE IMPLEADED AS PER ORDER DATED
21-06-2022 IN IA 1/2022)
BY ADVS.
SHRI.M.K.ABOOBACKER,SC KALAMASSERY MUNCIPALITY
C.S.AJITH PRAKASH
T.K.DEVARAJAN
PAUL C THOMAS
FRANKLIN ARACKAL
M.B.SOORI
BABU M.
NIDHIN RAJ VETTIKKADAN
HAARIS MOOSA
ANCY THANKACHAN
OTHER PRESENT:
GP- RIYAL DEVASSY
THIS WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) HAVING BEEN FINALLY HEARD ON
26.03.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:28363
:3:
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
---
VIJU ABRAHAM, J.
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -W.P.(C) No.13474 of 2022
-- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -- -Dated this the 26th day of March, 2025
JUDGMENT
The
above
writ
petition
is
filed
challenging
Ext.P7
proceedings of the 2nd respondent.
2. It is averred in the writ petition that there were series of
writ petitions relating to the subject property, which culminated in
Exts.P1 to P3 judgments. W.P.(C)No.32141 of 2019 is filed by the
petitioner herein alleging encroachment upon the Municipal
puramboke and canal puramboke by respondents 2 to 5 therein.
Thereupon this Court has disposed of the same as per Ext.P1
judgment directing the Tahsildar, Kanayannur Taluk to complete
the survey of the property with notice to the parties and further
directing that if there is any encroachment found in the survey, the
Tahsildar shall communicate the same to the Municipality and
thereafter the Municipality was directed to take further action in
the matter. In W.P.(C)No.28823 of 2019, which was also filed by
the petitioner herein seeking police protection for reconstruction of
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:4:
the boundary wall, the Court found that since there is a dispute
between the parties with regard to the reconstruction of the
boundary wall, it is not appropriate for the Court to issue police
protection and in case there is any dispute between the parties, it
can be resolved only through a civil court and by Ext.P2 judgment
relegated the parties to approach the Civil Court and the request
for police protection was declined. Ext.P3 is the judgment in W.P.
(C)No.33141 of 2019 filed by the additional respondents 6 to 8
herein, in which the petitioner herein is the 7 th respondent. The
said writ petition was filed seeking a direction against the
Municipality to complete the tendering process for the renovation
of the canal passing through Jawahar lane road and this Court has
disposed of the same with a direction to the 6 th respondent
Tahsildar to identify the land belonging to the 7 th respondent(the
petitioner herein) and on the basis of the same take appropriate
action. After the issuance of Exts.P1 to P3 judgments, respondents
3 and 4 made arrangements to measure the petitioner's land and
they inspected the petitioner's property. Though inspection was
conducted, no proper measurement was made or the survey
proceedings were finalised. Since there was no measurement of the
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:5:
property, the petitioner could not repair his damaged boundary
wall.
Thereupon a contempt of court case was filed as COC
No.443/2022. While so Ext.P7 notice dated 17.03.2022 was issued
by the 2nd respondent Municipality stating that the petitioner has
encroached upon the Municipal properties and directed him to
remove the encroachments. The petitioner would contend that after
the issuance of Ext.P7, Ext.P8 notice dated 10.03.2022 was issued
to the petitioner by the 4th respondent for survey and demarcation
of the property. Based on Ext.P8, it is the contention of the
petitioner that when notice of survey was issued to the petitioner
on 10.03.2022, the direction issued in Ext.P7 to demolish the
unauthorised construction on finding that there is encroachment by
the petitioner on Municipal property is absolutely arbitrary and
illegal. Thereupon Ext.P9 request was submitted by the petitioner.
3. A detailed statement has been filed by the 3 rd respondent
Tahsildar wherein it is stated that in obedience to Ext.P1 judgment
issued by this Court in W.P.(C)No.32141 of 2019, the Taluk
Surveyor was directed to measure the land with prior notice to the
parties. Though notice was issued regarding the survey to be
conducted on 08.12.2020, the survey could not take place on that
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:6:
day and the same was postponed to 28.12.2020 with notice to the
petitioner and the affected parties as evident from Ext.R3(a) notice.
After the site inspection and measurement, the Taluk Surveyor
prepared Ext.R3(b) sketch report and submitted it to the 3 rd
respondent and to the Secretary, Kalamassery Municipality which
would reveal that an extent of 0.28 ares of Puramboke land in
Survey No.77/19 part of block 5 in Thrikkakkara North Village is
encroached upon by the petitioner. While so a contempt of court
case No.443/22 was filed by the petitioner and in the said
circumstance copy of the survey sketch was again sent to the
Secretary, Kalamassery Municipality on 28.02.2022 for compliance
of the Court Order and a direction was given to the Taluk Surveyor
to pegmark the alleged property. It is also stated that Ext.P7 notice
was issued by the Municipality based on the survey sketch & report
given by the 3rd respondent and later on 16.03.2022, the Taluk
Surveyor pegmarked the alleged land as directed by the 3 rd
respondent with prior notice to the parties based on the survey
sketch already prepared by him.
4. A detailed counter affidavit has been filed by additional
respondents 6 to 8 wherein based on Exts. R6(a) to R6(d) it is
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:7:
contended that a proper survey was conducted as directed in
Ext.P1 judgment. As there was a delay in completing the
measurement, the respondents submitted a request
before the
Municipality to evict the encroachment on the thodu and to
renovate the canal. Thereafter the 2 nd respondent again issued a
letter to the Taluk Surveyor, Kanayannur with a request to remove
the encroachment as per Ext.R6(i). It is further submitted that it is
on the basis of the sketch and measurement forwarded to the
Kalamassery Municipality that Ext.P7 notice was issued. It is
contended that there is absolutely no merits in the contention
raised by the petitioner and sought for dismissal of the writ
petition.
5. Respondents 1 and 2 have also filed a counter affidavit,
wherein it is stated that pursuant to the direction issued by this
Court as per Ext.P1 judgment, survey was conducted and the
report and sketch was forwarded to the local authority which
reveals that some extent of puramboke land is in the possession of
the petitioner which is marked as 'C' and coloured as pink in the
survey sketch and it is on the basis of the same that the
Municipality
issued Ext.P7 notice. The contention taken in the
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:8:
counter affidavit is that in the Commission report filed by the
Advocate Commissioner appointed by this Court the property is
mentioned as 'Nalithuvazhi' which, in common parlance means a
passage which is being used from time immemorial.
6. This Court has appointed an Advocate Commissioner and
the Advocate Commissioner filed a detailed report, wherein it is
reported that during the inspection the Commissioner has seen a
thodu in the aforesaid 0.49 Ares of land in Sy. No.77/18 and the
said thodu does not find a place in the municipal records. It is
further reported that as intimated by the Surveyor, 0.30 Ares of
land in Sy. No.77/19, which is in the possession of the petitioner is
seen as 'Naalathuvazhi' in the BTR and the Commissioner was also
informed by the Surveyor that 'Naalathuvazhi' is not under the
ownership of anyone including the Municipality, as the same is in
existence from time immemorial and not marked in any records.
The petitioner relies on the finding No.(d) in the Commission
report that as per Annexure C2 sketch of the Taluk Surveyor, there
is no encroachment by the petitioner.
7. I have heard the rival contentions on both sides.
8. Though the petitioner has a specific case that no further
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
:9:
steps were taken pursuant to Ext.P1 to survey and demarcate the
property, it has come out in evidence that the survey was
conducted with notice to the petitioner and report and sketch was
prepared and forwarded to the Municipality for taking appropriate
action. In the reply affidavit filed by the petitioner to the counter
affidavit filed by additional respondents 6 to 8, there is an
admission that originally notice of inspection was given intimating
the date of inspection as 08.12.2020, which was adjourned to
28.12.2020. This makes it clear that the petitioner was issued with
notice of the survey and in the said survey conducted, going by the
statement filed by the learned Government Pleader, an extent of
0.28 Ares of puramboke land comprised in Sy.No.77/19 part of
block 5 in Thrikkakkara North Village is in the custody of the
petitioner. Based on the same that Ext.P7 notice was issued.
9. Another aspect to be noted is the issuance of Ext.P7 notice,
wherein a reference was made to the report of the Tahasidar
Kanayannur dated 28.02.2022, which is the sketch prepared and on
the basis of the same that Ext.P7 notice was issued contending that
the petitioner has encroached upon the road and has constructed
the compound wall encroaching upon the road and directed the
2025:KER:28363
: 10 :
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
petitioner to remove the said encroachment. The statement filed by
the 3rd respondent Tahsildar also reveals that the sketch and report
was prepared much earlier to the notice to the petitioner and other
affected parties. But later a contempt of court case was filed by the
petitioner and in view of the same the copy of the survey sketch
and plan was again sent to the Secretary of the Kalamassery
Municipality
on
28.02.2022
vide
letter
No.H4-9482/2020
in
compliance with the direction in Ext.P1 judgment. But the said
report also reveals that a direction was given to the Taluk Surveyor
to pegmark the alleged property and report it to the Court. In the
counter
affidavit
filed
by
respondents
to
8,
Ext.R6(e)
communication has been produced, which is the communication
issued by the Tahsildar to the Secretary of the Kalamassery
Municipality whereby the survey sketch and report was forwarded
to the Municipality for appropriate action and also intimating that
the Taluk Surveyor has been intimated to pegmark the subject
property so that appropriate action could be taken. Exts.P8 could
be treated only as a notice based on the direction issued to the
Taluk Surveyor to pegmark the subject property. But it is a fact
that Ext.P7 notice has been issued even before the pegmarking was
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
: 11 :
completed as per Ext.P8, inasmuch Ext.P8 notice is dated
10.03.2022 whereas Ext.P7 notice is dated 07.03.2022. The learned
Government Pleader as well as the learned counsel appearing for
the respondents and the learned counsel for the Municipality would
submit that Ext.P7 notice has been issued based on the survey
sketch and report prepared by the Tahsildar as directed in Ext.P1
judgment. Whatever that be Ext.R6(e) communication would reveal
that a direction was issued to the Taluk Surveyor by the Tahsildar
to pegmark so that appropriate action could be taken. It is without
any doubt that Ext.P7 order has been issued before completing the
proceedings for pegmarking pursuant to Ext.P8 notice.
10. Though there is a finding in the Commission report that as
per the Annexure C2 sketch of the Taluk Surveyor there is no
encroachment by the petitioner, the Commissioner has not stated
as to how the Commissioner came to such a conclusion in the
Commission report. Further aspect to be noted is that the property
in
Sy.No.77/19
of
Thrikkakara
North
Village
is
shown
as
'Nalithuvazhi' in the BTR and that the said property is not under
the ownership of anyone including the Municipality and the same
was in existence from time immemorial.
2025:KER:28363
: 12 :
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
11. Therefore, I am of the view that the writ petition could be
disposed of as follows:
i) Ext.P7 order is set aside.
ii) There will be a direction to respondents 1 & 2 to see that
further proceedings in this regard shall be taken only on the
basis of the survey sketch and report submitted and also on
the basis of the pegmarking of the subject property, which is
stated to have been done pursuant to Ext.P8 notice.
Iii) Before proceeding further, the petitioner as well as the
additional respondents 6 to 8 shall also be put to notice and
appropriate
action
shall
be
taken
after
affording
an
opportunity of being heard to the petitioner as well as
additional respondents 6 to 8.
Sd/-
VIJU ABRAHAM
JUDGE
sm/
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
: 13 :
APPENDIX OF WP(C) 13474/2022
PETITIONER EXHIBITS
Exhibit P1
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) NO.
32141/2019 DATED 18.03.2020 OF THE
HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
Exhibit P2
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) NO.
28823/2019 DATED 18.03.2020 OF THE
HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
Exhibit P3
TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT IN WP(C) NO.
33141/2019 DATED 18.03.2020 OF THE
HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA,
Exhibit P4
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
PETITIONER'S COUNSEL DATED 30.11.2020 TO
THEN, TALUK SURVEYOR AND TAHSILDAR.
Exhibit P5
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
PETITIONER'S COUNSEL TO THE 3RD
RESPONDENT DATED 27.01.2022.
Exhibit P6
TRUE COPY OF THE CONTEMPT OF COURT CASES
NO.443/2022 FILED BY THE PETITIONER
WITHOUT THE ANNEXURES DATED 16.02.2022.
Exhibit P7
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 7.3.2022
ISSUED BY THE 2ND RESPONDENT TO THE
PETITIONER.
Exhibit P8
TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE ISSUED BY THE 4TH
RESPONDENT DATED 10.03.2022 TO THE
PETITIONER AND TO THE LOCAL RESIDENTS.
Exhibit P9
TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
PETITIONERS COUNSEL TO THE 2ND RESPONDENT
DATED 17.03.2022.
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
: 14 :
RESPONDENT EXHIBITS
Exhibit R6 A
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED 3/7/2019
ISSUED BY THE TALUK SURVEYOR, TO THE
PETITIONERS AND OTHERS
Exhibit R6 B
A TRUE COPY OF THE NOTICE DATED
21/12/2020 ISSUED BY THE TALUK SURVEYOR,
TO THE PETITIONERS AS WELL AS TO THE
ADDITIONAL RESPONDENTS.
Exhibit R6 C
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPORT DATED 8/12/2020
OF THE SURVEYOR MR.RAJEEV JOSEPH ISSUED
BY THE PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICE OF THE
TALUK OFFICE.
Exhibit R6 D
A TRUE COPY OF THE SKETCH OF THE DISPUTED
PROPERTY ISSUED BY THE TALUK SURVEYOR IS
OBTAINED UNDER THE RTI ACT
Exhibit R6 E
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER BY THE
THAHASILDAR (LR) DATED 28/2/2022
FORWARDED TO THE SECRETARY, KALAMASSERY
MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit R6 F
A TRUE COPY OF THE MASS REPRESENTATION
SUBMITTED BEFORE THE 2ND RESPONDENT
Exhibit R6 G
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY UNDER THE RTI
ACT ISSUED BY THE AE AND PUBLIC
INFORMATION OFFICER OF THE 1ST RESPONDENT
DATED 27/11/2019
Exhibit R6 H
A TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION
SUBMITTED BY THE RESPONDENTS DATED
7/8/2021 BEFORE THE RESPONDENTS DATED
7/8/2021 BEFORE THE SECRETARY,
KALAMASSERY MUNICIPALITY
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
: 15 :
Exhibit R6 I
A TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER ISSUED BY THE
2ND RESPONDENT TO THE TALUK SURVEYOR
DATED 23/12/2021
Exhibit R6 J
A TRUE PHOTOCOPY OF THE SURVEY STONE LAID
BY THE TALUK SURVEYOR AND OVERSEER OF THE
MUNICIPALITY
Exhibit R6 K
A TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPH SHOWING THE
MARKING OF ENCROACHED AREA
Annexure R3(a):
True copy of notice sent to the
petiitioner by registered post.
Annexure R3(b):
A true copy of sketch
Exhibit R8(a)
A TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPH OF THE REAL
SITUATION OF THE CANAL IN QUESTION DATED
26/07/2022.
Exhibit R8(b)
A TRUE COPY OF THE PHOTOGRAPH OF THE REAL
SITUATION OF THE CANAL IN QUESTION DATED
11/07/2022.
Exhibit R8(c)
A TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED
11/07/2022 SUBMITTED BY THIS DEPONENT
ALONG WITH 11 OTHERS BEFORE THE
SECRETARY, KALAMASSERY MUNICIPALITY.
Exhibit R8(d)
A TRUE COPY OF THE RECEIPT ISSUED BY
KALAMASSERY MUNICIPALITY DATED
16/07/2022.
Annexure C1
Original of the sketch dated 31/10/2022
showing the properties of additional
respondents 6 to 8 prepared by the Taluk
Surveyor
2025:KER:28363
W.P.(C). No.13474 of 2022
: 16 :
Annexure C2
Original ofthe sketch dated 31/10/2022
showing the petitioner’s property
prepared by the Taluk Surveyor
Annexure C3
True copy of the survey sketch dated nil
marking the properties of 7th and 8th
additional respondents
Annexure C4
True copy of the survey sketch dated nil
marking the property of 6th additional
respondent
Annexure C5
True copy of Survey Sketch dated
14/06/1982 marking the property of the
petitioner
Annexure C6
Original of the sketch dated 30/01/2023
showing the entire length and width of
the Jawahar lane prepared by the Advocate
Commissioner
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review