Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:800
Serial Nos. 01-05
Daily List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Crl.Petn. No. 12 of 2023 with
Crl.Petn. No. 36 of 2023
Crl.Petn. No. 37 of 2023
Crl.Petn. No. 70 of 2023
Crl.Petn. No. 71 of 2023
Date of CAV: 03.09.2025
Date of pronouncement: 04.09.2025
The Central Bureau of Investigation through the Head of Branch, AntiCorruption Branch, Shillong 793001
..….Petitioner
- Versus 1.
2.
3.
Smti M. Ampareen Lyngdoh
Shri J.D. Sangma
Smti Ameka I. Lyngdoh
…Respondents
Mazeal Ampareen Lyngdoh
….…Petitioner
- Versus The Central Bureau of Investigation through the Head of Branch, AntiCorruption Branch, Shillong 793001
….Respondent
Mazeal Ampareen Lyngdoh
….…Petitioner
- Versus 1.
The Central Bureau of Investigation through the Head of Branch,
Anti-Corruption Branch, Shillong 793001
2.
Smti Ameka I. Lyngdoh
….Respondents
2025:MLHC:800
Jeffrey D Sangma
.…Petitioner
- Versus -
1.
The Central Bureau of Investigation through the Head of Branch,
Anti-Corruption Branch, Shillong 793001
2.
Smti Ameka I. Lyngdoh
….Respondents
Jeffrey D Sangma
……Petitioner
- Versus -
The Central Bureau of Investigation, Shillong Branch.
….Respondent
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice I.P. Mukerji, Chief Justice
Appearance in Crl.Petn. No. 12 of 2023:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms K. Chisa, Adv.
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
Mr. S. Khurshid, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. S. Ain, Adv.
Ms. R. Goyal, Adv. [for R1]
Mr K. Paul, Sr Adv. with
Mr S. Panthi, Adv.
Mr B. Snaitang, Adv.
Mr S. Chanda, Adv. [for R2]
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv. [for R3]
Appearance in Crl.Petn. No. 36 of 2023:
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. S. Khurshid, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. S. Ain, Adv.
Ms. R. Goyal, Adv.
For the Respondent
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms K. Chisa, Adv.
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
2025:MLHC:800
Appearance in Crl.Petn. No. 37 of 2023:
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. S. Khurshid, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. S. Ain, Adv.
Ms. R. Goyal, Adv.
For the Respondent
:
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms K. Chisa, Adv.
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv. [for R2]
Appearance in Crl.Petn. No. 70 of 2023:
For the Petitioner
:
For the Respondents :
Mr K. Paul, Sr Adv. with
Mr S. Panthi, Adv.
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms K. Chisa, Adv.
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
Mr. C.C.T. Sangma, Adv. [for R2]
Appearance in Crl.Petn. No. 71 of 2023:
For the Petitioner
:
Mr K. Paul, Sr Adv. with
Mr S. Panthi, Adv.
For the Respondents :
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms K. Chisa, Adv.
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for
reporting in Law journals etc.:
Yes
ii)
Whether approved for publication
No
in press:
Note: For proper public information and transparency, any media
reporting this judgment is directed to mention the composition of
the bench by name of judges, while reporting this
judgment/order.
2025:MLHC:800
JUDGMENT
The accused A1 and A2 have made separate applications under
Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. They also seek
quashing of the order dated 23rd August, 2022 passed by the learned
Special Judge (CBI), East Khasi Hills district, Shillong, in applications
made by them under Section 227 of the said Code. By the said
impugned order, the learned Judge had dismissed the applications of the
accused. Sections 227 and 482 are set out below:
“227. Discharge.– If, upon consideration of the record of the case
and the documents submitted therewith, and after hearing the
submissions of the accused and the prosecution in this behalf, the
Judge considers that there is not sufficient ground for proceeding
against the accused, he shall discharge the accused and record his
reasons for so doing.
482. Saving of inherent power of High Court.– Nothing in this
Code shall be deemed to limit or affect the inherent powers of the
High Court to make such orders as may be necessary to give
effect to any order under this Code, or to prevent abuse of the
process of any Court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice.”
In or about 2008, the State started a recruitment process for
appointment of Assistant Teachers in the Lower Primary Schools. A
part of the selection process became the subject-matter of the complaint.
This part concerned five centres or Sub-Divisions: (1) Shillong,
(2) Jowai, (3) Amlarem, (4) Tura and (5) Dadenggre. The complainant,
2025:MLHC:800
on 18th July, 2011 lodged an FIR with the criminal investigation
Department of the State. It started a criminal case against Smti Mazeal
Ampareen Lyngdoh, the then Education Minister of Meghalaya-A1,
Shri J.D. Sangma, the then Director, Directorate of Elementary and
Mass Education (DEME)-A2 and Smti Ameka I. Lyngdoh, the then
Deputy Director, Directorate of Elementary and Mass Education
(DEME) Shillong-A3.
Very broadly the accusation was that the accused conspired with
one another, collaborated and manipulated the score sheets and other
results of the selection process so that their favoured persons got the
appointments. As a result, many eligible and successful candidates in
the selection process were left out.
This case has a very chequered and long history. Initially in 2011,
the case was registered under Section 408 IPC at Police Station,
Laitumkhrah against A1 based on one complaint.
This Court by its order dated 2nd November, 2017 transferred the
case to the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) which registered a
case on 3rd January, 2018. It took the CBI two and a half years to file a
chargesheet on 25th June, 2020. On the chargesheet, Sections 120-B
read with 420, 467, 468, 471 and 201 were also included. Another
2025:MLHC:800
period of more than two years two months was taken by the court to
frame the chargesheet, on 25th August, 2022 and 31st August, 2022
respectively.
A few hundred witnesses were listed to give evidence for the
prosecution. Considering the period during which this proceeding was
pending and the further time required to examine all the witnesses, in
this application, the investigating agency was requested by this Court to
cut down the list. Ultimately, the list had been reduced to 181. Till date,
only 28 witnesses have been examined.
About 17 years have passed since the selection process was
initiated.
Out of 521, candidature of 246 persons was cancelled on the
ground that their selection was tainted.
The scope of intervention by the Court in the application under
Section 482 of the Code is extremely limited.
Mr Salman Khurshid, learned Senior Advocate appearing for A1
and Mr K. Paul, learned Senior Advocate appearing for A2 cited some
significant decisions of the Supreme Court in the application of Section
227 read with Section 482 of the Code. The relevant ones are briefly
discussed hereunder:
2025:MLHC:800
In Baliya Alias Bal Kishan v. State of Madhya Pradesh reported
in (2012) 9 SCC 696, the Supreme Court held as follows:
“17. The offence of criminal conspiracy has its foundation in an
agreement to commit an offence or to achieve a lawful object
through unlawful means. Such a conspiracy would rarely be
hatched in the open and, therefore, direct evidence to establish
the same may not be always forthcoming. Proof or otherwise of
such conspiracy is a matter of influence and the court in drawing
such an inference must consider whether the basic facts i.e.
circumstances from which the inference is to be drawn have been
proved beyond all reasonable doubt, and thereafter, whether
from such proved and established circumstances, no other
conclusion except that the accused had agreed to commit and
offence can be drawn. Naturally, in evaluating the proved
circumstances for the purposes of drawing any inference adverse
to the accused, the benefit of any doubt that may creep in must go
to the accused.”
In State of Tamil Nadu v. N. Suresh Rajan and Ors reported in
(2014) 11 SCC 709, the same court opined as follows:
“29. We have bestowed our consideration to the rival
submissions and the submissions made by Mr Ranjit Kumar
commend us. True it is that at the time of consideration of the
applications for discharge, the court cannot act as a mouthpiece
of the prosecution or act as a post office and may sift evidence
in order to find out whether or not the allegations made are
groundless so as to pass an order of discharge. It is trite that at
the stage of consideration of an application for discharge, the
court has to proceed with an assumption that the materials
brought on record by the prosecution are true and evaluate the
said materials and documents with a view to find out whether
the facts emerging therefrom taken at their face value disclose
the existence of all the ingredients constituting the alleged
offence. At this stage, probative value of the materials has to be
gone into and the court is not expected to go deep into the matter
2025:MLHC:800
and hold that the materials would not warrant a conviction. In
our opinion, what needs to be considered is whether there is a
ground for presuming that the offence has been committed and
not whether a ground for convicting the accused has been made
out. To put it differently, if the court thinks that the accused
might have committed the offence on the basis of the materials
on record on its probative value, it can frame the charge; though
for conviction, the court has to come to the conclusion that the
accused has committed the offence. The law does not permit a
mini trial at this stage.”
In Dipakbhai Jagdishchandra Patel v. State of Gujarat (2019)
16 SCC 547, the Supreme Court laid down the following law:
“23. At the stage of framing the charge in accordance with the
principles which have been laid down by this Court, what the
court is expected to do is, it does not act as a mere post office.
The Court must indeed sift the material before it. The material to
be sifted would be the material which is produced and relied
upon by the prosecution. The sifting is not to be meticulous in the
sense that the Court dons the mantle of the Trial Judge hearing
arguments after the entire evidence has been adduced after a fullfledged trial and the question is not whether the prosecution has
made out the case for the conviction of the accused. All that is
required is, the Court must be satisfied that with the materials
available, a case is made out for the accused to stand trial. A
strong suspicion suffices. However, a strong suspicion must be
founded on some material. The material must be such as can be
translated into evidence at the stage of trial. The strong suspicion
cannot be the pure subjective satisfaction based on the moral
notions of the Judge that here is a case where it is possible that
accused has committed the offence. Strong suspicion must be the
suspicion which is premised on some material which commends
itself to the court as sufficient to entertain the prima facie view
that the accused has committed the offence.”
2025:MLHC:800
In Vikramjit Kakati v. State of Assam reported in (2022) 17 SCC
249, its dictum was as follows:
“9. Before we proceed to examine the matter on merits any
further, it will be apposite to take note of the legal principles
applicable seeking discharge, for which we may refer to a
judgment of this Court in P. Vijayan v. State of Kerala reported
in (2010)2 SCC 398, which has been further reiterated by this
Court in the recent judgment in M.E. Shivalingamurthy v. CBI
reported in (2020) 2 SCC 768 and discerned the following
principles: (M.E. Shivalingamurthy case, SCC pp. 776-77, para
17)
“17. …. 17.1. if two views are possible and one of them
gives rise to suspicion only as distinguished from grave
suspicion, the trial Judge would be empowered to
discharge the accused.
17.2. The Trial Judge is not a mere post office to frame the
charge at the instance of the prosecution.
17.3. The Judge has merely to sift the evidence in order to
find out whether or not there is sufficient ground for
proceeding. Evidence would consist of the statements
recorded by the police or the documents produced before
the Court.
17.4. If the evidence, which the Prosecution proposes to
adduce to prove the guilt of the accused, even if fully
accepted before it is challenged in cross-examination or
rebutted by the defence evidence, if any, ‘cannot show that
the accused committed offence, then, there will be no
sufficient ground for proceeding with the trial.’
17.5. It is open to the accused to explain away the materials
giving rise to the grave suspicion.
17.6. The court has to consider the broad probabilities, the
total effect of the evidence and the documents produced
before the court, any basic infirmities appearing in the case
and so on. This, however, would not entitle the court to
make a roving inquiry into the pros and cons.
2025:MLHC:800
17.7. At the time of framing of the charges, the probative
value of the material on record cannot be gone into, and the
material brought on record by the prosecution, has to be
accepted as true.
17.8. There must exist some materials for entertaining the
strong suspicion which can form the basis for drawing up a
charge and refusing to discharge the accused.”
This Court has been shown by Mr Khurshid and Mr Paul, learned
Senior Advocates for the petitioners, the score sheets at page 204
onwards of the petition which appear to have been prepared and signed
by five officials, namely, the Director, Elementary and Mass Education;
Member Secretary, DEME; Headmaster; Lecturer, DIET and an official
of SDOIEAC. It was sent to accused No. 2 (A2) for checking and
verification. He approved it. The score sheet at page 204 stated that it
was prepared on the basis of “comparative working sheets.” Then I was
taken to pages 197 onwards which represented the merit list prepared on
the basis of this list. Learned counsel showed me the break-up of marks
obtained by the candidate against Sl. No. 6 at page 197 of the merit list
which matched the computation of scores in the said sheets against Sl.
No. 30 at page 205. Then I was shown the final list of candidates rated
ranking-wise at page 194. The contents of all the three sheets were
identical. All were signed by the same officials.
2025:MLHC:800
Now, the case of the prosecution is that A1, A2 and A3 were in
conspiracy, connivance and collaboration with one another. They had
manipulated the score sheets, thereby, displacing the successful
candidates by candidates of their choice. The original score sheets were
different. White ink was used to erase the marks and substitute them by
higher or lower marks as the case may be to accommodate the preferred
candidates and to remove the undesirable ones.
Futthermore, they had a charge against accused No. 1 that using
her influence as minister she had furnished slips to the officers
preparing the tabulation sheets directing alteration of marks.
First of all, the three documents showing various levels in
tabulation of results were signed by the selfsame five persons.
Secondly, the said slips which had been produced as evidence
could not by themselves suggest any specific direction for alteration of
marks. The originals have not been produced as evidence.
No document showing interpolation or any application of white
ink for erasing the marks are on record. The said slips which have been
produced with some remarks of A1 could be for more than one purpose.
There is no further evidence to link those slips with the charge of
manipulation of results.
2025:MLHC:800
Now, applying the principles laid down in the above Supreme
Court decisions, if the prima facie case sought to be made out by the
prosecution, from the documents, records and other evidence is so weak
that a reasonable suspicion of the accused having committed the crime
does not arise, the Court on consideration of this evidence is
empowered to discharge the accused. In this case, the prosecution has
failed to establish even a prima facie case from where a reasonable
suspicion may arise in the prosecutor or the court of interpolation of the
score sheets by the accused or any of them. The case or charges against
each of them falls to the ground.
Under Section 482, this Court has the power to prevent “abuse of
the process of any court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice.” The
selection process is of 2008. About 17 years have rolled by. The first
FIR was lodged on 18th July, 2011. Nothing has moved significantly in
prosecuting the accused. Only 28 out of 181 witnesses have been
examined.
Such enormous delay in prosecuting a criminal case is also
against the fundamental rights of the accused under Articles 21, 19 and
14 to lead a peaceful life free of mental anxiety caused by pendency of a
criminal proceeding. At the rate it is proceeding examination of all
2025:MLHC:800
witnesses, might take up the entirety of the remaining life of the
accused. Therefore, exercising power under Section 227 of the Code
read with Section 482, especially the part which deals with the power of
the court to prevent abuse of the process of any court or to secure the
ends of justice, I set aside the impugned order dated 23rd August, 2022
passed in Special (CBI) Case No. 2 of 2020 by the learned Special
Judge (CBI), East Khasi Hills district, Shillong. The charges against the
accused A1, A2 and A3 are quashed. The entire criminal proceedings
are hereby quashed.
Each of the accused 1, 2 and 3 are hereby
discharged.
Crl. Petn. Nos. 36 of 2023, 37 of 2023, 70 and 71 of 2023 are
allowed.
Crl. Petn. No. 12 of 2023 is disposed of in terms of this order,
without passing any order.
(I.P. Mukerji)
Chief Justice
LIZ KHARBHIH
Date: 2025.09.04 19:53:37 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review