The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
16. In the light of the discussions above, issuance of some directions are called for in the matter. Accordingly, it is ordered that the respondents, particularly the respondent Nos. 2, 3& 4 shall take immediate necessary steps for extension of benefit due upon the petitioners herein consequent to the issuance of sanction order dated 28-06-2016 with regard to their rank structure and pay scale at par with other CPOs by introducing rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 01-01-1986 by taking into consideration their respective dates of entry in the clerical cadre of the Assam Rifles keeping in view the period from 01-01-1986 to 20-102022 mentioned in the sanction order. As there is no disclosure of any individual details of the petitioners in the writ petition with regard to their date of entry and continuance in the service, while conferring the benefits, it would be open for the respondents to take into consideration the individual entitlement of the petitioners for conferment of benefit as per the Government order issued vide Memo No. 27012/1/97 PC Cell/PE.I dated 10-10-1997 for extension of benefits of 5th Pay Commission, on the basis of their respective service record. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order by the respondents with due intimation to…
17. The stand taken in the affidavit-in-opposition dated 01-12-2016 filed by the respondents and rejoinder-affidavit dated 02-05-2017 filed by the petitioner are not taken into consideration as none of the parties have advanced any submission basing on those affidavits. The very fact that this decision has been rendered on the basis of the aforesaid judgment of the Guwahati High Court which has been implemented by the respondent-authorities, the contention raised in those affidavits are also considered of not much relevance.
18. The writ petitions stand disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
19. There will be no order as to costs. Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01 & 2
Supple List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 37 of 2016 with
WP(C) No. 187 of 2016
Date of Decision: 16.08.2023
Vs.
Union of India & Ors.
JC 362256 NB/Clk Nirmal Singh Vs.
Guleria & 34 Ors.
Union of India & Ors.
Paras Nath Gupta & 128 Ors
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance: in WP(C) No. 37 of 2016
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Wanniang, Adv.
Ms. P. Biswakarma. Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC.
Appearance: in WP(C) No. 187 of 2016
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. E. Wanniang, Adv.
Ms. P. Biswakarma. Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. R. Debnath, CGC.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Yes/No
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
On the prayer of both the parties, this set of two writ petitions,
i.e., the WP(C) No. 37 of 2016 and WP(C) No. 187 of 2016 are taken
up together for hearing as the matters involve similar issues arising
out of similar facts, and is filed by similarly situated persons. Both
the writ petitions are disposed of by a common judgment and order.
2.
Heard Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel for the
petitioner assisted by Ms. E. Wanniang, learned counsel. Also heard
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC for the respondent.
3.
By this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioners pray for a direction to the respondents for
bringing parity in respect of rank structure and pay scale of the
similarly situated Assam Rifles personnel at par with the other Central
Paramilitary Forces (in short CPMFs)/ Central Police Forces, CPOs)
by introducing the rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer)
at the entry grade w.e.f 01-01-1986 in the scale of pay of Rs. 13202040 (revised Rs.4000/- to Rs. 6000/- w.e.f 01-01-1996) with all
consequential service benefits as per Ministry of Finance, Department
of Expenditure, Resolution No. 50(1)/IC/97 dated 20-09-1997
communicated through MHA letter bearing No.27012/1/97-PC
Cell/PF.I. The petitioners also pray for grant of all consequential
service benefits and promotion upto the rank of Second-In-Command
(Assistant Director) at par with the other CPMFs/CPOs. It is averred
that the issue raised by the writ petitioners is squarely covered by the
judgment and order dated 23-08-2012 of the Guwahati High Court
delivered in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010, which was subsequently
affirmed by the Division Bench and the Apex Court.
4.
In response to the claim of the writ petitioners, the respondent,
Union of India, filed three affidavits on different dates. The first
affidavit dated 28-07-2016 brought into records the compliance of the
judgment and order dated 23-08-2012 passed by the Guwahati High
Court in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and subsequent sanction made
by the department in compliance with the said judgment. The second
affidavit dated 01-12-2016 has been filed in the form of an affidavitin-opposition wherein a para-wise reply has been made refuting the
various averments made in the writ petition. The third affidavit, the
most recent one, has been filed on 07-07-2023 has been filed in the
form of an additional affidavit bringing into the records the fact of
extension of grant of rank or warrant officer and arrear of pay to the
eligible employees. However, a stand has been taken therein that the
petitioners, who had retired prior to the notification implementing the
5th Central Pay Commission came into force, either on retirement or
voluntary retirement, are not entitled to the benefits under the 5th Pay
Commission. The names of some of the incumbents who retired prior
to 01-10-1997 have also been mentioned therein. The petitioner has
also filed a rejoinder-affidavit on 02-05-2017 against the affidavit-inopposition dated 01-12-2016 filed by the respondents.
5.
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, learned Senior counsel for the petitioner
submits that the writ petitioners and some of the deceased employees
of the widow writ petitioners were appointed as clerk in different
units, formation headquarters and minor units of Assam Rifles, which
is a Central Paramilitary Forces (in short CPMFs)/ Central Police
Forces, CPOs) under the Ministry of Home Affairs and at present they
are holding the post of Havildar Clerks, Naib Subedar Clerks and
Subedar Clearks and Subedar Major Clerks etc. which are cadre posts
in the clerical staffs of the Assam Rifles. In pursuance of the
recommendation of the 4th Pay Commission, The Assam Rifles was
duly placed at par with the other CPOs like BSF, CRPF, ITBP, CISF
etc. The recommendation of the 4th Pay Commission was accepted by
the Government of India vide notification No. GSR 1105 (E) dated
22-09-1986 issued by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
6.
He further submits that when the Assam Rifles was brought
under the CPOs retaining the rank of Lance Naik with scale of Rs.
825-15-900-EB-20-1200 as entry post in Assam Rifles was contrary to
the fundamental intention of the Government of India and thus illegal,
unjust and discriminatory, particularly when the entry cadre in Assam
Rifles is tested with the entry post for other CPOs like BSF, CRPF etc.
was Assistant Sub-Inspector with scale of pay Rs. 1320-30-1560-EB40-2040.
7.
He contends that in view of the order dated 10-10-1997, the
post of Lance Naik and Naik of the Clerical Cadre of the Assam Rifles
were liable to be merged with the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector in
the scale of Rs.4000-6000 to bring parity in the rank structure and pay
of clerical cadre with other CPOs for simple reason, inter alia, that for
the recruitment qualification to the entry grade is 10+2 i.e. Higher
Secondary School for the clerical cadre post in Assam Rifles which is
also similar to the Assistant Sub-Inspector in all other CPOs.
8.
He, however, submits that under the pretext of implementing of
notification 10-10-1997, the respondent No.2 has mechanically redesignated the post of existing Havildar Clerk as Warrant Officer
Clerk which is equivalent to the post of Assistant Sub-Inspector with
the pay scale of Rs. 4000-6000/-, but the benefit of such redesignation has not been granted to the petitioner though, they are all
eligible and entitled for the same.
9.
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner
relies on a Judgment dated 23-08-2012 passed by the Guwahati High
Court in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010, Radha Krishna Nair K.M &
1338 others versus. Union of India and submits that the issue raised
by the present writ petitioners in the instant writ petition has been
already decided and it is squarely covered by the said case. The
Judgment of the Guwahati High Court was upheld by a Division
Bench of this High Court vide Judgment and order dated 30-04-2013
passed in a writ appeal No. (SH) 40 of 2012 and subsequently by the
Hon’ble Apex Court vide Judgment and order dated 17-11-2015
passed in Civil Appeal No. 13445 of 2015 and other connected
Special Leave Petition with certain minor modification.
10.
Learned Senior counsel for the petitioner strongly relies on the
para 3 of the affidavit dated 28-07-2016 filed on behalf of the
respondents herein bringing into the records the compliance of
Judgment and order dated 23-08-2012 passed by the Guwahati High
Court in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) 2010 and the sanction of the Director
General of the Assam Rifles with the approval of Ministry of Home
Affairs dated 28-06-2016 bringing parity in respect of rank structure
of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant rank, Assam Rifles) at the entry
grade w.e.f 01-01-1986 in the scale of pay of Rs. 1320-2040 (revised
rate of Rs.4000-6000 w.e.f 01-01-1996) to all personnel of the clerk
cadre who were in service as on 01-01-1986 and who were enrolled
thereafter upto 28-10-2002. He points out that it has been stated that
the said order dated 28-06-2016 also applies and covers the case of the
petitioner in the instant writ petition. He, however, submits that in
spite of this development, the petitioner herein have not been
conferred with any benefit till date.
11.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC appearing for the respondent
submits that some of the petitioners who have retired prior to the
coming of the Order No. 27012/1/97 OC Cell/PE.I dated 10-10-1997
into force, would not be eligible for the extension of benefits under the
5th Central Pay Commission. He also resists the claim of the writ
petitioner for promotion upto the rank of Second in Command
(Assistant Director) and submits that all the CPOs have their
respective sets of recruitment rules indicating the pattern and
procedure of promotion in the ranks, which are different from each
other. He, however, does not dispute the contention that the relief
claimed in the writ petition is covered by the judgment and order
dated 23-08-2012 passed by the Guwahati High Court in WP(C) No.
277 (SH) of 2010. Referring to the order or sanction dated 28-062016, he submits that the petitioners have already been granted relief
and there remains nothing to be decided in the writ petition and the
matter has become infructuous. However, Mr. R. Debnath, learned
CGC has not brought anything into the record to show that the
benefits of the parity in rank structure and pay scale have indeed been
extended to the petitioners.
12.
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, learned Senior Counsel for the
petitioners, in his reply, fairly submits that the petitioners are not
pressing their claims for promotion upto the rank of Second-inCommand (Assistant Director) at this stage. He contends that none of
the petitioners have received any benefits of parity in rank structure
and payscale at par with the other CPOs even after introduction of the
rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer) at the entry grade
w.e.f. 01-01-1986 in pursuance of issuance of sanction vide order
dated 28-06-2016 till date.
He, therefore, submits that necessary
directions are required to be passed in the matter. He further submits
that the entitlement of the benefits to be conferred on the writ
petitioners would definitely be on the basis of their individual
eligibility.
13.
Considered the arguments advance by the learned counsels
appearing for the respective parties. Also perused the pleadings of the
parties. In the present case, the petitioners have been holding the post
of Havildar clerks, Naib Subedar Clerks, Subedar Clerks and Major
Subedar Clerks which are cadre posts in the clerk cadre in the Assam
Rifles having recruitment qualifications (10+2).
Persons similarly
qualified and situated in other CPOs viz., CRPF, BSF, ITBP etc., are
having entry grade rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector.
Government
order issued vide Memo No. 27012/1/97 PC Cell/PE.I dated 10-101997 provides for rationalization of rank structure and pay in all CPOs
including Assam Rifles. Since, there is no dispute to the fact that the
issue involved in the present writ petition is squarely covered by the
judgment and order dated 23-08-2017 passed by the Guwahati High
Court in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010, the other details are not
required to be gone into. At this stage, it would be gainful to refer to
para 14 of the said judgment, which is reproduced hereinbelow:“14. In the result, this writ petition stands disposed of
with the direction to the respondent No.2, the Director
General of Assam Rifles to take up the matter again with
the respondent No.1, i.e, the Secretary to the Govt. of
India, Ministry of Home Affairs to bring parity in respect
of rank structure and pay of the Assam Rifles clerical
cadre at par with other CPOs by introducing rank of
Assistant Sub-Inspector (Warrant Officer) at the entry
grade w.e.f. 1.1.1986 in the scale of pay of Rs1320-2040
(revised Rs. 4000-6000)w.e.f 1996 or any other date as
the authority deem it fit and proper with all consequential
service benefits in the light of the Government of India,
Ministry of Finance resolution dated 20.09.1997
communicated through MHA letter bearing No. 270102/1/97 Cell/Pef-1 dated 10.10.1997. The whole exercise
would be completed within a period of 6 (six) months
from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this
judgment and order.”
The Judgment of the Guwahati High Court has been upheld
thereafter in writ appeal No. (SH) 40 of 2012 vide order dated 30-042013 and subsequently by the Hon’ble Apex Court vide Judgment and
order dated 17-11-2015 passed in Civil Appeal No. 13445 of 2015 and
other connected Special Leave Petition with certain minor
modification.
14.
The affidavits dated 28-07-2016 and 07-07-2023 filed by the
respondents and sanction order dated 28-06-2016 confirmed
implementation of the judgment of the Guwahati High Court. The
respondent do not deny that the writ petitioners are entitled to the
benefit of rank structure and pay scale at par with other CPOs. There
is also no dispute to the fact that the petitioners are not personnel of
the clerical cadre, who were in service as on 01-01-1986 and who
were enrolled thereafter upto 28-10-2022. The only dispute raised by
the respondent is with regard to the entitlements of some of the
petitioners whose name are mentioned in the affidavit dated 07-072023 with regard to the extension of benefits under the 5th Pay
Commission.
15.
Since the petitioner are similarly situated with the writ
petitioners in WP(C) No. 277 (SH) of 2010 and there is a clear
admission by the respondent that the judgment rendered in the said
case has been implemented and a sanction order has been issued
thereof by order dated 28-06-2016, there remains no iota of doubt why
the petitioners should not be entitled to the same relief.
16.
In the light of the discussions above, issuance of some
directions are called for in the matter. Accordingly, it is ordered that
the respondents, particularly the respondent Nos. 2, 3& 4 shall take
immediate necessary steps for extension of benefit due upon the
petitioners herein consequent to the issuance of sanction order dated
28-06-2016 with regard to their rank structure and pay scale at par
with other CPOs by introducing
rank of Assistant Sub-Inspector
(Warrant Officer) at the entry grade w.e.f. 01-01-1986 by taking into
consideration their respective dates of entry in the clerical cadre of the
Assam Rifles keeping in view the period from 01-01-1986 to 20-102022 mentioned in the sanction order. As there is no disclosure of any
individual details of the petitioners in the writ petition with regard to
their date of entry and continuance in the service, while conferring the
benefits, it would be open for the respondents to take into
consideration the individual entitlement of the petitioners for
conferment of benefit as per the Government order issued vide Memo
No. 27012/1/97 PC Cell/PE.I dated 10-10-1997 for extension of
benefits of 5th Pay Commission, on the basis of their respective service
record. The aforesaid exercise shall be completed within a period of
three months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order
by the respondents with due intimation to the petitioners. Since the
prayer for promotion of the petitioners upto the rank of Second-inCommand (Assistant Director) has not been pressed for, no order has
been made in this regard.
17.
The stand taken in the affidavit-in-opposition dated 01-12-2016
filed by the respondents and rejoinder-affidavit dated 02-05-2017 filed
by the petitioner are not taken into consideration as none of the parties
have advanced any submission basing on those affidavits. The very
fact that this decision has been rendered on the basis of the aforesaid
judgment of the Guwahati High Court which has been implemented
by the respondent-authorities, the contention raised in those affidavits
are also considered of not much relevance.
18.
The writ petitions stand disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
19.
There will be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
16.08.2023
“Biswarup-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review