Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:1822
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
MCRC No. 8750 of 2025
Reserved on : 05.01.2026
Delivered on : 13.01.2026
Jaychand Koshale, aged about 34 years, s/o. Shri Ddinesh Chand
Koshale, r/o. Plot No. A-53, Avinash Smart City, Sejbahar, Raipur,
Chhattisgarh, (curently under Judicial Custody at Central Jail, Raipur
(CG).
... Applicant
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through Economic Offences Wing (EOW)/& Anti
Corruption Bureau (ACB), Head Quarfter, Opposite Jai Jawan Petrol
Pump, Telibandha, Raipur, Chhattisgarh 492001.
--- Respondent
For Applicant
:
Mr. Harshwardhan Parganiha, Advocate.
For State
:
Dr. Sourbh Kumar Pande, Dy. Advocate General.
Hon'ble Shri Justice Narendra Kumar Vyas
CAV ORDER
1.
This is the first bail application filed under Section 483 of the Bharatiya
Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 for grant of regular bail to the
applicant who has been arrested on 21-09-2025 in connection with
Crime No. 03/2024 registered at Police Station- Anti Corruption
Bureau/ Economic Offence Wing Chhattisgarh, Raipur, District- Raipur
(C.G.) for the offence punishable under Sections 420, 120-B and 384
of IPC and Sections 7, 7-A, 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act,
1988.
2.
The case of the prosecution, in brief, is that on 11.01.2024, one Mr.
Sandeep Ahuja, Deputy Director, Directorate of Enforcement, Raipur
through Mr. Farhan Qureshi, Deputy Superintendent of Police lodged a
complaint before the Director General of Police Anti Corruption Bureau
& Economic Offences Wing, Chhattisgarh pertaining to predicate
offence discovered during money laundering in investigation File No.
ECIR/RPZO/09/2022 was done under Section 66(2) of the Prevention
of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (for short “the PMLA”). Thereafter, an
offence bearing FIR No. 03/2024 has been registered on 17.01.2024 at
Police Station ACB/EOW Raipur (C.G.) against 35 accused persons
namely Smt. Saumya Chaurasiya, Sameer Bisnoi, Smt. Ranu Sahu,
Sandeep Kumar Nayak, Shivshankar Nag, Suryakant Tiwari, Manish
Upadhyay, Roshan Kumar Singh, Nikhil Chandrakar, Rahul Singh,
Parekh Kurre, Moinuddin Qureshi, Virendra Jaiswal, Rajnikant Tiwari,
Hemant Jaiswal, Joginder Singh, Nawneet Tiwari, Deepesh Taunk,
Devendra Dadsena, Rahul Mishra, Ramgopal Agrawal, Devendra
Singh Yadav, Shishupal Sori, Rampratap Singh, Vinod Tiwari, Amarjeet
Bhagat, Chandradeo Prasad Rai, Brashpat Singh, Idrish Gandhi,
Gulab
Kamro,
Shri
U.D.
Minj,
Sunil
Kumar
Agrawal,
Jai,
Chandraparakash Jaiswal, Laxmikant Tiwari & others.
3.
Further case of the prosecution is that a syndicate comprised of private
individuals and other State Government functionaries like Smt.
Saumya Chaurasiya, Director, Geology & Mining Department and with
the backing of some political executives, they managed to make
deliberate policy changes. As part of the well-planned conspiracy, the
applicant with the active support of the politicians and some of the
senior State Government functionaries managed to influence the then
Director of Geology & Mining and got issued a Government Order
dated 15.07.2020 which became the fountain head of this extortion
system by converting the online system of issuance of Transport
Permits into a manual system. They started a network of extortion to
collect Rs. 25 per ton of coal transported in the State of Chhattisgarh.
The investigation conducted by the Enforcement Directorate revealed
that other senior bureaucrats viz., Smt. Saumya Chaurasia and Smt.
Ranu Sahu, IAS were also involved in this conspiracy and were
providing assistance to the applicant in running the extortion racket.
Smt. Soumya Chourasiya while working as Deputy Secretary in Chief
Minister Office, had assisted the applicant and his associates in
collecting the extortion money by posting pliable officers of mining
department in the coal mining areas. Smt. Ranu Sahu IAS, who
worked as District Collector in coal rich Districts viz., Korba & Raigarh,
had close association with the applicant and helped his associates in
collecting extortion money from the coal transporters and other
businessmen.
4.
It is also case of the prosecution that in the coal rich areas of the State
like Raigarh, Korba, Surajpur, District Mineral Officers made illegal
recovery of Rs.25/- per tonne from coal transporters on the basis of
the above manual, DO and permit related orders were issued from the
Mineral Directorate. Investigation of the Enforcement Directorate that
information received from sources revealed that illegal levy
approximately Rs.540/- crores have been collected by
of
the above
syndicate between July, 2020 and June 2022. On the basis of the
report received
from the Enforcement Directorate, its confidential
verification and source information in relation to above incident was
done in the Bureau and Crime No.03/2004 for commission of offence
under Sections 420, 120-B, 384 of IPC read with Sections 7, 7A & 12
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 as amended in 2018 (for
short “the PC Act”) was registered against the applicant.
5.
From the case diary and the material so collected by the ACB/EOW,
the role of present applicant is that during investigation, it was found
that the present applicant/accused -Jaichand Koshle was posted as
Assistant Grade-II (Reader) in Municipal Corporation, Raipur, where he
was working directly under accused Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia, the then
Additional Commissioner and later in charge of the General
Administration Department. From that period onwards he became a
person of special trust and confidence for Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia.
When Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia was subsequently posted in December
2018 as Deputy Secretary in the Chief Minister's Secretariat,
Mantralaya, Atal Nagar, Raipur, the applicant requested that he also be
posted in the Secretariat and, at her instance, he was transferred and
posted in her personal establishment in the Chief Minister's Secretariat.
This sequence clearly shows that treating him as a dependable and
loyal subordinate, Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia ensured that the applicant
was brought along with her and placed in a position from where he
could act as her trusted operative in the illegal coal levy collection
network.
6.
On the instructions of Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia, accused Jaichand
Koshle was allotted a Government vehicle despite not being eligible for
such facility as per rules. The said government vehicle was misused for
managing illegal coal levy collections. The accused used this vehicle to
receive illegal coal levy collections from the office of accused
Suryakant Tiwari and to deliver those amounts to accused Mrs.
Saumya Chaurasia. The investigation further revealed that during a
search operation conducted by the Income Tax Department on 30 th
June, 2022, handwritten diaries related to illegal coal levy collection
were seized from the residence and office of accused Suryakant Tiwari
and his associates. All the entries in the diaries marked with the code
"JAI" relates to accused Jaichand Koshle, as confirmed by witnesses in
the case. These handwritten diaries provide crucial evidence of the
misappropriation of approximately Rs. 7 crore by the accused Jaichand
Koshle.
7.
The investigation of the case further reveals that accused Suryakant
Tiwari used to handover accused Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia's share of
the illegal coal levy to accused Jaichand Koshle, who in turn used to
deliver the same to accused Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia. Thus, a wellplanned three-tier arrangement was in operation, in which accused
Suryakant Tiwari functioned as the collector of illegal levy, the present
applicant/accused acted as the cash carrier, and accused Mrs.
Saumya Chaurasia was the primary beneficiary. Despite having full
knowledge that the money he was accepting and transporting
represented proceeds of illegal coal levy collection, accused Jaichand
Koshle continued to participate in the said criminal activity regularly
delivering the money to accused Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia and also
deriving benefit there from.
8.
It is further emerged from the seized digital evidence that the applicant
was not a mere clerical staff but the principal trusted operative of
accused Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia for handling her confidential work.
Numerous WhatsApp chats recovered from the mobile phone of coaccused Anil Tuteja contain
repeated references
to "Jai"
in
conversations between Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia and Anil Tuteja. In
several such chats, Mrs. Saumya Chaurasia specifically records that
she is sending sensitive and confidential files and records of the Chief
Minister's House/Secretariat to Anil Tuteja "through Jai" / "by Jai".
These messages clearly establish that the applicant was regularly used
as a personal courier and conduit for transmission of confidential
documents and instructions between the Chief Minister's Secretariat
and co-accused Anil Tuteja, demonstrating the exceptional degree of
trust reposed in him and his active and conscious participation in the
illegal network.
9.
To substantiate the above facts, the non-applicant/State has filed
copies of the statement recorded under Section 161 of the Cr.P.C. of
Roshan Kumar Singh and the statement recorded under Section 164 of
the Cr.P.C. of Nikhil Chandrakar, which are collectively annexed as
Annexure-NA-1.
10.
Learned counsel for the applicant would submit that the applicant is
innocent and has been falsely implicated in the crime in question. He
would further submit that arrest of the applicant is illegal and malafide
as FIR itself clearly reveals that the main allegations are made against
Suryaknt Tiwari, Sourmya Churasiya, Hemant Jaiswal, Sameer Bishnoi
and other politically influential persons. He would further submit that
the essential ingredients of forgery of documents or valuable security
are completely absent in the case of the applicant. The Investigating
agency has failed to bring on record any complaint from person
alleging that the applicant had intentionally created documents or
electronic records for the purpose of cheating. He would further submit
that the investigating agency has also failed to complete the chain of
evidence to establish that the applicant had ever accepted any
gratification as a motive or reward to show favour or disfavour to any
person or group. No evidence has been produced to connect the
applicant with the alleged offence and his name appears in the final
report merely on the basis of presumption, without any direct or indirect
material.
11.
He would further submit that in order to establish a prima facie case,
the prosecution agency was required to place cogent evidence
showing that someone has been put to wrongful loss solely on account
of the acts of the present applicant. However, no such material has
been brought on record in the final report and in absence of any prima
facie evidence against the applicant, no offence under the provisions of
Bhartiya Nyay Sanhita or the Prevention of Corruption Act is made out
against the applicant. He would further submit that the present FIR No.
03/2024 has been registered at the behest of the ED pursuant to the
sharing of information under Section 66(2) of the Prevention of Money
Laundering Act, 2002 ("PMLA"). The registration of the present FIR is
nothing but an attempt to keep afloat the otherwise patently illegal
investigation being carried out by the Directorate of Enforcement ("ED")
in relation to ECIR No. RPZO/09/2022, in the absence of any live
predicate offence. The investigation of the ED into the alleged coal
levy scam is bereft of any live predicate offence is also a categorical
finding recorded by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the order
dated 17.05.2024 passed in SLP (Crl.) 5890/2024 (Sunil Kumar
Agrawal v. Directorate of Enforcement as well as Order dated
04.10.2024 passed in SLP (Crl.) 11141/2024, Laxmikant Tiwari v.
Directorate of Enforcement).
12.
He would further submit that the present FIR does not attribute any
specific role, overtact, or participation by the applicant in the
commission of the alleged offence. It contains vague and general
allegations
against
multiple
individuals
without
detailing
the
involvement of the applicant. After more than a year and 08 months of
the investigation, the non-applicant has failed to bring on record any
material to substantiate the applicant's alleged involvement in the
alleged offence which is a necessary prerequisite for implicating any
individual.
13.
He would further submit that it is settled law that the statements
recorded under Section 161 & 164 of the Cr.P.C. are not admissible in
law. He would further submit that the statement of co-accused person
is an extremely weak piece of evidence and cannot be treated as
substantive evidence as against the other co-accused persons as held
by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Prem Prakash Vs. ED [SLP
(Crl.) No. 5416 of 2024, decided on 28.08.2024], Haricharan Kurmi
Vs. State of Bihar [AIR 1964 SC 1184], Sanjay Jain Vs. ED [2024
SCC OnLine SC 656]. He would further submit that in the present
case, there is also no evidence showing any physical manifestation of
agreement between the applicant and other co-accused for committing
the alleged crime for making out a case of criminal conspiracy under
Section 120-B of the IPC. It is well settled that there must be cogent
evidence to show that the co-accused are acting as per a common
agreement or a common design. A reference in this regard may be
made to the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in case of Ram Sharan
Chaturvedi v. State of M.P., (2022) 16 SCC 166.
14.
He would further submit that there is no apprehension of violation of the
triple test by the applicant, therefore, the applicant is entitled to be
released on bail as it is well settled law that mere apprehension of
influencing witnesses or tampering with evidence can never be a
ground to decline bail to any accused, unless there is cogent
supporting material as held by Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of P.
Chidambaram Vs. CBI [2020 13 SCC 337], Manish Sisodia Vs. ED
& CBI [(2024) SCC OnLine SC 1920], Manish Sisodia Vs. CBI & ED
[(2023) SCC OnLine SC 1393]. He would further submit that the
applicant has not made any attempt to suborn witnesses, tamper with
the evidence, or in any manner pollute or obstruct the judicial process.
Further, the applicant undertakes that he shall not tamper with the
evidence or/and influence witnesses, nor there is any reasonable or
justifiable apprehension thereof. He would further submit that the entire
evidence relied upon the non-applicant is documentary in nature which
already stands seized and placed on record. There are no ocular
witnesses requiring confrontation with the applicant while in custody,
thereby negating the need for further custodial interrogation.
15.
He would further submit that the co-accused persons namely Ranu
Sahu, Suryakant Tiwarii, Sameer Vishnoi and Saumya Chaurasiya
have already been granted bail by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide
order dated 29-5-2025 passed in SLP
(Cri) No. 15941 of 2024,
therefore, the present applicant may also be enlarged on bail on the
ground of parity. He would further submit that the applicant is ready
and willing to furnish adequate surety and shall abide by all the
directions which may be imposed by this Court. He would further
submit that now the challan of the case has been presented before the
trial Court and no investigation is pending, the accused is in custody
since 21-9-2025 and trial of the case will take sufficient time to be
concluded, therefore, the benefit of bail should be granted to the
present applicant.
16.
On the other hand, Dr. Saurabh Kumar Pande, Deputy Advocate
General for the ACB/EOW opposing the submissions made by learned
counsel for the applicant, referring to the FIR and the case diary would
submit that the applicant is involved in the economical offence which is
not only heinous offence but also against the economy of the nation.
The custodial interrogation of the applicant is required as the applicant
has not disclosed the source of income from where these properties
which have been detailed in the final report and if the accused
remained in the custody, the sources of purchased of property can be
traced out. He would further submit that the learned Special Judge
(Prevention of Corruption Act), Raipur while dismissing the bail
application filed by the applicant has observed that there is
involvement of the applicant in the crime in question, which has not
been rebutted by the applicant while making this submission before
this Court. He would further submit that there is a strong prima facie
case against the present applicant and the matter is under further
investigation with the department and the Police will file the
supplementary charge-sheet after collection of fresh evidences against
other co-accused persons involved in the crime at a later stage and
looking to the conspiracy and crime committed by the applicant in
connivance with the other co-accused, the instant bail application
deserves to be rejected.
17.
He would further submit that the accused has been arrested for the
aforesaid crime after strictly following the legal provisions regarding
arrest. After the allegations were found prima facie substantiated, the
challan was presented before the Hon'ble Court and the accused
continues to be detained in judicial custody. The investigation in
respect of the remaining accused persons in the case is presently in
progress.
18.
In view of the above, it is clear that the present applicant is actively
involved in the aforesaid crime. The investigation in the matter is of a
serious nature, as in the present case a huge amount of public money
is involved and money-laundering has also taken place from the illegal
levy on coal transportation by officials of the State Government in
connivance and conspiracy with other accused persons.
19.
He would further submit that the applicant has not made out any of the
ground in which the instant bail application of the present applicant
under section 483 of the Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sahita, 2023 can be
allowed. Thus, looking to the conspiracy and crime committed by the
applicant in connivance with the other co-accused, the instant
application deserves to be rejected.
20.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the case diary
with utmost circumspection.
21.
The submission of learned counsel for the applicant that the trial will
take longer time for disposal, therefore, the case of the applicant may
be considered for grant of bail, is opposed by learned counsel for the
respondent/State. He would submit that not only the applicant but the
other co-accused have adopted delay tactics by moving various
applications causing delay in conclusion of trial, therefore, it cannot be
said that only the prosecution is contributed in delay disposal of trial.
The submission made by learned counsel for the applicant for
releasing the applicant on bail on the count of delayed trial, deserves to
be rejected as the applicant has not placed any material on record to
demonstrate that the trial has been delayed because of the prosecution
only. It is well settled position of law that delay for completion of trial is
always not a ground to grant bail and the bail can be granted looking to
the gravity and seriousness of the offence. In the present case, there is
serious allegation against the applicant, therefore, merely is no ground
to consider the prayer of the applicant to release him on bail.
22.
The further submission of learned counsel for the applicant that the
applicant was arrested illegally as there is no direct evidence against
the applicant. This submission cannot be considered at this stage as it
is the defence of the accused to declare the arrest as illegal.
It is pertinent to mention here that the applicant has nowhere stated in
the bail petition regarding source of income which has been shown in
the final report which clearly shows that the ACB/EOW has collected
certain material against the applicant. The prosecution has collected
the material against the applicant that he has collected money illegally
form coal transporters. Thus, from perusal of FIR and the material
available in the case diary, involvement of the applicant in commission
of offence under Sections 420, 120-B, 384 of IPC read with Sections 7,
7A & 12 of the PC Act, which is economic offence, is prima facie
reflected. Hon’ble the Supreme Court while considering the gravity of
economic offence in case of P. Chidambaram Vs. Directorate of
Enforcement, [(2019) 9 SCC 24] has held that the economic offence is
a serious offence and need to be visited with different approach in the
matter of bail.
23.
Again Hon’ble the Supreme Court in case of Ramesh Bhavan
Rathod Vs. Vishanbhai Hirabhai Makwana (Koli) & another
[(2021) 6 SCC 230] has held that for declining bail application, the
Court should consider whether whether there is any prima facie or
reasonable ground to believe that the accused had committed the
offence; nature and gravity of the accusation; severity of the
punishment in the event of conviction; danger of the accused
absconding or fleeing, if released on bail or reasonable
apprehension of the witnesses being influenced. From submission
made by the parties, it is quite vivid that prima facie these
conditions are available on record.
24.
The further submission of learned counsel for the applicant is that the
applicant is entitled to claim parity as other accused persons have
been granted bail by Hon’ble the Supreme Court, deserves to be
rejected as other accused who remained in the custody for about two
years and have been granted bail by Hon’ble the Supreme Court
whereas the applicant has been arrested on 21-9-2025. Considering
the FIR and other material placed on record, it prima facie shows
involvement of the applicant in crime in question. As such, I am of the
view that it is not a fit case where the applicant should be granted
regular bail.
25.
Accordingly, the instant bail application filed under Section 483 of the
Bhartiya Nagrik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 is liable to be and is hereby
rejected.
26.
The observation made by this Court is not bearing any effect on the trial
of the case. The learned trial court will decide the criminal trial in
accordance with evidence, material placed on record, without being
influenced by any of the observations made by this Court while
deciding present bail application.
Sd/-
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA
RAJU
RAVVA
SATYANARAYANA RAJU
Date: 2026.01.13
14:41:23 +0530
Raju
(Narendra Kumar Vyas)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review