Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3303 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 9638 OF 2023
Between:
Jayanth Sai Vallabltanenr,. S/o. Narayana Rao Vallabhaneni, A Eir' 30 years.
Occ. Pvt [:nrployee, R/o.8 -3 -19111051218, 2nd Floor Flat No t-l Spoortl-ry
Homes, Vengal Rao Nagar, Hyderabad (A-20)
PETITIONER/ACCUSED No.20
AND
1 The State of Telangana,, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor l-ligh Court Suildinqs
High Court, Hyderabad. Through PS, S.R.Nagar, Hyclerabad
Responclcnt No.1
2 tVr.P.V tlarn Prasada Rao,, Addl. lnspector of Police, S R Nagar Polrce
Station, S.R. Nagar, Hyderabad.
..RESPONDENT No.2/DE-FACTO COMPLAINANT
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that rn the crrcumstances
stated in the [/lemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court rnay
be pleased to quash the proceedings against the petitroner/accused No 20
in S.C N.D.P.S.No.273 of 2022 on the file of the I Additional lVetropolitan
Sessions Judge, Hyderabad and pas.
l.A. NO: 2 OF 2023
Petition under Section 482 of Cr.P.C praying that in the circurnstances
stated in the [/lemorandum of Grounds of Criminal Petition, the High Court nray
be pleased to stay all further proceedings against the petitioner/accused No.20
in S.C N.D.P.S. No.273 of 2022 on the file of the I Additional tVetropolitan
Sessions Judge, Hyderabad and pass.
This Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the lVlemorandum of
Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of
Sri Nageshwar Rao Pujari, Advocate forthe Petitioner and Sri l\4. Vivekananada
Reddy, Assistant Public Prosecutor (TG) on behalf of the Respondent No.'1 and
of none appeared for the Respondent No.2.
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
,IHE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE
J.SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PET ITION No.9638 of 2023
t)r.ir-t: ()!).0 I .2U2o
Bctrt't'r'ri
.Jtrtlrnt I Siri Vrr lllrllllilit,.rri
[)cLrt.ioner/i\ccurscrl ],r r .10
1\NT)
'l'[rc St;rt(-' )l illtr nglurrr.
'
r-el)r'(:s('lttcrl ir-r' it.s [)Lirllir. Prosrtr:lrtorI-liqlr (iorrrr Ijlrilclirrlis I Iislr Crrurr. [-r-\'(iorertrac]. through p.S.,
S. R Nzrq;rr, I ii tlcr-rrltrrri. irr-rcl irrrot lrc:r
licsytorrrlt'lr is
qBD-E-B
'l-iris L'i'itttirriri i'cLitiorr Irzrs 1-lr:crr filcri
seeking Lo quasl-r
l,lrc: ;;L'<-,ccctlirr,qs irr S.C. N.D.P.S.No.273 ol 2022 on thc l'ilc:
of thc I A<lclil iorraI Nlc:tropolitr,rn Sr:ssior-rs .,lr-rd.ge, I-[.yder-nlrrrc[,
whercin tht: 1>ctiLit.rner \A/as arr:r},ed a_s accrrsed No_20. li>r
t-hc c,ilcr-r.t' purrrisiralrl<: trircler scr:tion 27 of the Nar.t:oti<:
Druqs arrd l)s.y<;lrolr-opir: Strbstzrr"Lc:cs Act, rggs (for shor-L
'thc IJI)l'}S .\t:t'.
2-
l-Iealrcl Ms. it.Sar-rdhy:r, learned counsel, representing
Mr.Pujari Nageshwar Rao, lcarned cor. nsel for the petitioner
and Mr. M.Vivekananda Reddy, learned Assistant public
Pros,:ctttor
3. '--L6arned counsel for the petitioner surbrnilted tfiat in
rcspcct ol-the ver'-v-. samc pr()ccedings ir'r' S.C. N.D.P-S.No.273
o1".t.O22, a<:c:tISc-:cl No.21 hlrc-l approachcd this Cor-trt aticl l-ilcd
(lrirrrirrzrl ['ctitiorr No.548l] ol 2023 secl<ing Lo qur.islr t.hc:
1>r-6c<:cclirtgs agzrirrst thc
vcry seIITIe arllegaliorrs lt:r'clleci
irqarirrst Irirn err-rd tl]is Cortrt- w]rilc taking ir.rtrt ct;trsiclcri,ttion
tirt:1>rirrciples iairl dou,t-t by Lhc Hon'lrlc A1)c:x Court in
Toofan singh v. State of Tamil Nadul, Noor Aga v. State
of Punjab2, er.lkttvc:cl t-l-rr: said Crirninal Pclitiorl i'rgzlinst ttrc
lrctilioll(:r- tltercitr. ()t-I '22.O8.2023. Hertce, thc pctitiotrr:t- is
:rlso c--rrLitlt:tl ftrr tltt: satnc: Ilcnefit.
4.
I.eerrnr:d Assistant Public Prosecutor hzrs not opp(>scd
Ihr: santt
5.
Hef iltg Consiclerecl thc rival sgbmissions made 1'15' the
rcsltectivc pa.rties and after perusal of the rnateria"l averilable
on r-ecorcl, it rerrcals that the petitioner was implicafed in
this case as aCCuse,C No.2O, upon the confession made by
accused No.6. Especially the petitioner is only a custolrler
and no contrabancl was seized frorn the possession o[ the
petitioner. Accused No.2l in this case had,.approached tLris
cor-rrt ?l$ fitea crirninal Petition No.54B3 of 2023 seeking
tcrl.n.No.l52 of 2013, dated 08.10.2013
2 Crl.A.No.l034 of 2008 (Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No.5597 of 2OO6l
to quas)r the procec:clings ergzrinst the very saITIe allcgations
levellecl agailtst hirr-r ancl this Coutrt nllorxrecl the
saicl
Crirnina-l PcLitron on 2').OiJ.-2O23. 'l'he very same allcgations
uII-c] le\ ollccl it.qirttlst tirr: Pt:titiiril<'t- het-cirl.
6.
'l'rrl<irrg irrLo corrsiclr-:r'irtiott tirc ulb()v(r saticl lacts atncl
circlr rrrstarrc('s o1- 1lt,' ('ils('. tlrrs C)ott I'1 is o[- (hc c;onsiclcrrrcl
vier,r, tltaL lhr: ltctiLiortt:r'is rrls,.r cntitlccl for- t[)() samc relief.
7.
Irr LIr(: r-osL-llt, iirr: ()r'ir.nittitl [)t:titictu is lrl[<>rnrccl and thc
procec:-tings ltgerirtst tlrc 1.rt:lttiortt;t i irct:utsctl No.20 in S.C
N.l).l').S.Ntl..l/.'i
ol
r()..)-). i)r'r ttrt: irit: ol'tlrt;'l
Mctropr>lilarrr Scssi,rns,lLtilgc:,
I{.t'clcrab:t<[,
,\clditiorrirl
aro
hercb.r,
quasht:cl.
Pc-rrcting rnisr;c:llirrrc;ous appiicatiorrs, if any, shall
stand closccl.
SD/. A. JAYASREE
ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY/
SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The lAdditional Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad.
2. The lll Additional t\4etropolitan tMagistrate, Nampally, Hyderabad.
3. The Station House Officer, S.R.Nagar Police Station. Hyderabad
4. Mr.F'.V.Ram Prasada Rao,, Addl lnspectorof Police, S.R Nagar Police
Station, S.R Nagar, Hyderabad.
5. One CC to Sri Nagestrwar Rao Pujari, Advocate IOPUCI
U'{d-
6 lwo ,CC to Public Prosecutor High Court for the Stdte of Telangana
Hyderabad [OUl ]
7 l.r,vo CD CoPtes
Sode: Alpnq vvith a copy of orcler itt Crl P No.5483 of 2023, dated 22'08'2023
i t rr.
STB/PSL "
,
;
\>?,,
i,
HIGH COURT
DATED:tl9/0112026
t rlP. fit
T
ORDER
iI
{-)
CRLP.No.9638 of 2A23
?
t F{|l
11026
*
*
CRIMINAL PETITION
IS ALLOWED.
KS
\
q
*
\,\
THE HONOURABLE SRI ruSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in/hcorders/2023/crlp/crlp-5483_2023.pdf.
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY
CRIMIN
PETITION No.5483 OF 2023
ORDER:
This Criminal Petition is filed under Section 482 of Code of
Criminal Procedure (for
short 'Cr.P.C.') by
the
petitioner/accused No.21 to quash the proceedings in S.CNDPS No.273 of 2022 on the file of the I Additional Metropolitan
Sessions Judge, Hyderabad, for the offence punishable under
Sections 8(c) read with 22(cl and 27 Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (for short 'NDPS Act).
2.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri S.Ganesh,
learned Assistant Public Prosecutor for respondent No.1 - State.
Perused the material available on record.
3.
The brief facts, as culled out from the charge sheet, are
that accused Nos.5 and 6 are addicted to alcohol/weed/drugs
and their income is not sufficient to lead their life lavishly.
Accused No.S is working in a restaurant in Goa and he started
to sell MDMA drug and Ecstasy pills to the needy customers at
higher price, meanwhile accused No.6 along with accused No.S
procured the banned Psychotropic Substance Drug i.e-, MDMA
and Ecstasy Pills from accused No.l to 4, who are the main
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTIC E M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
https /icsis.tshc.gov. in/hcordersi'2023/crlpicrlp_54
:
83_2023.pdf
GAC; J
Crtp_5483_2O23
drug suppliers and sold the same to the customers i.e., accused
Nos.7 to 34. As per the orders of the customers, in the month of
August, accused Nos.5 and 6 went to Goa and procured the
drugs i.e.,2O grams of MDMA and 50 Ecstasy pills from accused
No.1 by paying Rs.75,O00/- and brought the same to
Hyderabad. Further, accused Nos.S and 6 sold 1O grams of
MDM.{ drug and 22 Bcstasy pills to needy customers and
remaining 10 grams of MDMA drug ancl 28 Ecstasy pills were
kept with them in equal share. On 06.09.2022 at about 14:30
hourr;, as per their plan, accused Nos.S and 6 gathered near
Vella.rki Foods, Madhura Nagar, S.R.Nagar, Hyderabad and
were waiting for customers to sell the drug, in the meanwhile,
LW- 1 along with staff of SR Nagar Police Station apprehended
accused Nos.5 and 6, seized and banned Psychotropic
Substance Drug i.e., MDMA drug And Ecstasy Pills from the
possession of accused Nos.S and 6 in the presence of panchas.
Therefore, a case uide FIR No.673 of 2022 on the lile of the
Station House Officer, S.R. Nagar Police Station, Hyderabad was
regis;tered against accused Nos.S and 6 and basing on the
confessional statement of the said accused, other accused
inchrding the petitioner herein were implicated in the case.
2ofll
21912026,3:14 PM
THE HONOLIRABLE SRI ruSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
htps://csis.tshc.gov.in./hcordersl2023/crlplcrlp-54832023.pdI
GAC, J
Crlp-S483-2O23
4.
Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that the
mandatory provisions under NDPS Act are not followed by the
investigating agency; basing on the confession statements of coaccused, the petitioner has been falsely implicated in the case;
the statements under Section 67 of NDPS Act are completely
inadmissible statements and they cannot be used against the
petitioner. It is further contended that the investigating agency
has blatantly violated the Standing Orders I I 1989, dated
13.06.1989, which are legislated by Ministry of Finance under
Section 52A of the NDPS Act, which is mandatory provision for
seizure. The Standing Orders 1/1989 contemplate as follows:
Drqwal of Samples:
2.2. All the packages/ containers shall be seriallg
numbered and kept in lots for sampling. Samples
from the narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances
seized, shall be drawru on the spot of recouery, in
duplicate, in the presence of search witness
(Panchas) and the person from whose possession the
drug is recouered, and a mention to this effect should
inuariablg be made in the panchanama.
Quantitg to be drawn for the sampling:
2.3 The quantitg to be drawn in each sample for
chernical test shall not be less than 5 grams in
respect of all narcotic drugs and psgchotropic
substances saue in cases of opium, gania and charas
(hasish) where a quantitg of 24 grams in each case is
required for chemical test. The same quantities shall
be taken for the duplicate sample also. The seized
drugs in the packages/containers shall be well mixed
to make it homogeneous and representatiue before
the sample (in duplicate) is drawn."
THE HONOURABLE SRI TSTICE M - crlp_5483 2023.pdf
https:/icsis.tshc.gor,.inrhcorders,'2023/crlpicrlp_5483.
2023.pdf
GAC, J
Crlp_5483_2O23
5.
lt is also contended by the learned counsel for the
petitioncr that the petitioner was never in possession of any
contre band; the petitioner is ready to seek medical help and to
go to a rehabilitation center or de-addiction for immunit,y from
proser:ution. It is further contended that if the protection is
accorrled to him, he will be prosecuted for the offence under
Secticrn 27 of the NDPS Act and if the entire version of the
Invesrigating Agency is taken to be absolute truth even then the
petitirner is charged for the offence under Section 27 of NDPS
Act, ,a7[i"h provides mandatory protection under Section 64A of
the I{DPS Act. Therefore, prayed to quash the proceedings
against the petitioner.
6.
To support his contentions, learned counsel for the
petitioner relied upon the following judgments:
(i)
In Toofan Singh a. State of Tamil Nadul, the Madras
Higt. Court has held that it is imperative here to mention that
when the confessional statements are in itself inadmissibie the
enti:e charge sheet and prosecution against the accused is
against the law.
I
4ofll
crl.A.No. ts2 of 2013 dated 09.10.2013
219/2026,3:14 PM
THE HONOLJRABLE SRI ruSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
https://csis.tshc.gov.in/hco rders/2023/ crlp/ crlp
GAC, J
Crlp_5483_2O23
(ii) In Noor Aga a. State of Punjab2, the Honble Supreme
Court has held as follows
*91. The logical corollary of these dlscussions is
that the guidelines such as those present in the Standing
Order cannot be blatantlg flouted and substantial
compltance therewith must be insisted upon for so that
sanctitg of physical euidence in such cases rematns intact.
Clearlg, there has been no substantial compliance of these
guidelines bg the inuestigating authority which leads to
drawing of an aduerse inference against them to the effect
that had such euidence been produced, the same would
haue gone against the prosecLttion."
7.
Learned counsel for the petitioner also relied upon the
judgments of this Court in Criminal Petition Nos.29O2 and 906
of 2023, wherein this Court has quashed the proceedings in the
concerned cases against the accused after getting them
rehabilitated.
8.
On the other hand, learned Assistant Public Prosecutor
contended that he has received written instructions from the
Sub-Inspector of Police, S.R.Nagar Police Station, Hyderabad,
wherein it is stated that on verification, it was disclosed that the
consumers have undergone rehabilitation and found it to be a
genuine one.
Crl.A.No.t034 of 2008 [Arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 5597 of 2006]
-5483
2023.pdf.'
THE I{ONOURABLE SRI JUSTICI: M - crlp- 5483_2023.pdf
https:ii csis.tshc. gor'. inihcorders,' 2023icrlp, crlp_54 8 3_2023.pdf
GAC, J
Crlp_5483_2O23
9.
Eiefore proceeding further, it would be appropriate to refer
to Section 64-A of the Act, which reads as under:'64A. Immunity from prosecution to addicts uolunteerinq
Jor treatnlenL--Any addict, tulto is charged utith an offence
punishable under section 27 or with offences inuoluing
;mall quantity of narcotic drugs or psAchotropic
'-ubsfances, who uoluntailg seeks to undergo medicaL
treatment for de-addiction from a hospital or an institution
maintained or recognized bg the Gouernment or a. local
autlrcritu an.d undergoes such treatment shall not be liable
to proserution under section 27 or under any other sectiort
for offences inuoluing small quantity of narcotic drugs or
psychotropic substances: Prouided that the said immunity
from prosecution may be withdrawn if the addict does not
undergo the complete treatment for de-addiction."
10. In San;riu Bhatnagdr u. States, Madras High Court held
as urrder:-
"11. Giuen the attendant facts and circumstances, the
prosecution in the instant case maA at best be able to
make out an offence under Section 27 of IVDPS Act. The
question that arises for consideration would be whether
the accused should be required to undergo tial towards
his conuiction for offence under Section 27 of NDPS Act
and would he onlg thereafter be entitled to seek the
benefit of Section 64(A) of NDPS AcL Simplg put, Section
64(A) of NDPS Act is one intended to id qn user of drugs
from the euil thereof and towards his rehabilitation, the
end object being to facilitate a life free of drugs. Ihis Court
I crl.lt.c. No.1278 0F 2015 and M.p.Nos. |
6ofll
&2 0f 2015
2/9/2026,3:14 PM
THE HONOURABLE SRI ruSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdt
https ://csis.tshc. gov. in/hco ders/2023 I crlp/crlp_548 3_2023.pdt
GAC, J
Crlp_S483_2023
is of the uiew that Luhen the matertal gathered by the
prosecution itself informs the petitioner to be an user of
drugs and not in too large a quantttg the prouision for
rehabilitation should be giuen effect to at the earliest.
12. Exercising powers under Section 482 Cr.P.C, this
Court presently would pass the follouing order:
(i) Charge in case pending in C.C.No.46 of 2O15 on the file
of learned II Additional Special Judge under NDPS Act,
Chennai, shall be attered to one for offence under Section
27 of the NDPS AcL Further proceedings in the case shall
be stayed pending further orders of this Court.
(it) Petitioner shall be requtred to undergo treatment
toutards de-addiction at T.T.Ranganathan Clinical
Research Foundation F-fK Hospital), Chennat, tuhich is
informed, to be recognized bg Gouernment as a hospital
for treating and rehabilitating persons addicted to alcohol
and other drugs(iii)Upon completion of treatment and related programmes,
T.T.Ranganathan Clinical Research Foundation ITK
Hospttal), Chennai, is required to file a report regarding
the success or otherwise of the treatment afforded to the
petitioner and the state of health (mental and physical) as
on the date of such report. Such report mag be filed before
this Court notlater than on 10.06.2016. Afi.er 22 dags, the
rehabilitation institution submitted a progress report about
the accttsed to Madras High Court stating that, "TIl.e
patient undenttent three weeks of psgchotherapeutic
interuention for treatment of substance dependence. This
included attending re-educattue lecture sessfons, group
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
https://csis.tshc.gor'.inihcorders; 2023/crlpicrlp_54E3 2023.pdf
CAC, J
Crlp_5483_2O23
therapA, AA sharing and counselling sessions. As part of
the family programme his u.tife also attended classes and
counselling. Patient has been uery co- operatiue
,hroughout the term of treatment and has adequate family
support. To ensure qualitatiue sobrietg follou'-up tuith
:ounsellor has been recommended." Recording the
submission and gtuing the attendant facts and
circtLmstances, by ctpplging Section 64(A) of tlrc Act antd
the petttioner therein has gained immunitg from
prosecution, consequentlg proceedings before the II
Addition-al Special Judge under /VDPS Act, Chcnnai, haue
been quashed by the Madras High Court."
11. In the instant case also, nothing has been seized from the
poss€ssion of the petitioner and the petitioner was charged for
the offence under Section 27 of NDPS Act. Further, in Sanjiu
Bhatnagq.r a. State (3 supra), the Madras High Court, after
hearing the matter, quashed the proceedings against the
petitjoner therein, however, the petitioner herein was referred
for srccessful rehabilitation as envisaged under Section 6a(A) of
the NDPS Act. Even in the instant case, according to the
written instructions of the prosecution, the petitioner has
undr:rgone rehabilitation.
L2. Further, the medical report of the petitioner discloses that
the petitioner has undergone rehabilitation and he has no
8 of li
219/2026,3:14 PM
THE HONOTIRABLE Szu ruSTICE M - crlp_5483_2023.pdf
https ://csis.tshc. gov. inlhco rders/ 2023 I crlp/ crlp_5483_2023.pdf.
GAC, J
Crlp_5483_2023
complaints and maintaining well.
He had occasionally
consumed alcohol and no other substances were used and
psycho education is done.
13. A perusal of the said certificate dated 06.11 .2022 filed by
the petitioner would reveal that he has undergone successful
treatment from the government recognized de-addiction centre
i.e., Vicinity Multi Specialty Clinics, Hyderabad and there is no
presence of any Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic substance in
his body and that the petitioner was proactive in the sessions
and responded well to the counseling.
14. In view of the aforesaid discussion and the decisions
rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court and Madras High
Court, which are applicable to the facts and circumstances of
the present case, this Court deems it appropriate to quash the
proceedings against the petitioner.
15. Accordingly, the Criminal Petition is allowed and the
proceedings against the petitioner/accused No.21 in S.C. NDPS
No.273 of 2022 on the file of the I Additional Metropolitan
Sessions Judge, Hyderabad, are hereby quashed.
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE I\,{ -
https:i/csis.tshc.gouiuhcorders 2023/crlp/crlp_5483, 2023.pdf.
5a83 2023.pdf
l0
GAC, J
Crlp_.5483_2O23
miscelianeous applications, if any, shall stand
closed
G.ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY, J
Date: 22.O8
TMK
l0 of ll
219/2026,3:14 PM
]'I{E HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N{ .
5a83 2023.pdf
https:r.'csis.tshc.gor'.in hcorders,'2023lcrlp/crlp_ 5483_tC23.pdf
ll
GAC, J
Crlp_5483_2O23
HON'
SMT. JUSTICE G. ANUPAMA CHAKRAVARTHY
CRIMINAL PETITION No.5483 OF 2023
Date: 22.08.2023
TMK
ll of 11
21912026,3:14 PM
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review