Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
1.
2.
Miscellaneous Appeal No.962 of 2024
======================================================
Jay Prakash Prasad, Son of Late Khudi Ram, Resident of Mirganj Bazar,
Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
Om Prakash Prasad, Son of Late Khudi Ram, Resident of Mirganj Bazar,
Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
... ... Appellant/s
Versus
1.
Bishwanath Gupta @ Vishwanath Prasad, Son of Radha Kishun Prasad,
Resident of Mirganj Bazar, Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
2.
Daya Shankar Prasad, Son of Late Ganesh Ji, Resident of Mirganj Bazar,
Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
3.
Arun Kumar, Son of Late Ganesh Ji, Resident of Mirganj Bazar, Police
Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
4.
Manoj Kumar, Son of Late Ganesh Ji, Resident of Mirganj Bazar, Police
Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
5.
Ajay Kumar, Son of Late Ganesh Ji, Resident of Mirganj Bazar, Police
Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
6.
Sanjay Kumar, Son of Late Ganesh Ji, Resident of Mirganj Bazar, Police
Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
7.
Parshuram Prasad, Son of Late Khudi Ram, Resident of Mirganj Bazar,
Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
8.
Uma Shankar Prasad, Son of Late Khudi Ram, Resident of Mirganj Bazar,
Police Station- Mirganj, District- Gopalganj.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Appellant/s
:
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. Jitendra Prasad Singh, Senior Adv.
Mr. Dhananjay Kumar Upadhyay, Adv.
Mr. Rajesh Kumar Sharma, Adv.
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KHATIM REZA
ORAL ORDER
09-07-2026
Heard Mr. Jitendra Prasad Singh, learned senior
counsel assisted by Mr. Dhananjay Kumar Upadhyay, learned
counsel for the appellants and Mr. Rajesh Kumar Sharma,
learned counsel for the respondents.
2. This appeal has been filed preferred against the
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
2/9
judgment and order dated 28.10.2024 passed by learned
Additional District Judge-XII, Gopalganj in Title Appeal No. 70
of 1997, whereby the learned First Appellate Court has
dismissed the petition filed by the appellants for setting aside
the abatement of appeal after 16 years of the death of appellant
no. 5, namely, Vijay Kumar (in Title Appeal No. 70 of 1997)
and consequently, the whole appeal has become incompetent
due to rejection of setting aside abatement against appellant no.
5.
3. This appeal arises out from Title Suit No. 346 of
1982 filed by respondent 1st set for declaration of title and
recovery of possession and mesne profit against five defendants
which was decreed by the trial court. Defendant nos. 1 , namely,
Parshuram Prasad (respondent no. 7 in the instant case),
defendant no. 2, namely, Jay Prakash Prasad (appellant no. 1 in
the instant case), defendant no. 3, namely, Uma Shankar Prasad
(respondent no. 8 in the instant case), defendant no. 4, namely,
Om Prakash Prasad (appellant no. 2 in the instant case) have
been made party in present appeal except defendant no. 5,
namely Vijay Kumar. All the five defendants challenged the
judgment and decree passed by the trial court in Title Appeal
No. 70 of 1997. During the pendency of the said title appeal,
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
3/9
defendant/ appellant no. 5, Vijay Kumar, died on 28.06.2000 in
an accident leaving behind his widow, three sons and two
daughters, but substitution petition was not filed within time.
The plaintiff/respondent filed a petition on 05.04.2016 for
abatement of the said appeal due to non-substitution of heirs and
legal representatives of deceased, Vijay Prasad (Appellant no. 5
in
Title
Appeal
No.
of
1997).
Thereafter,
the
defendants/appellants filed a petition on 04.06.2016 under Order
1 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure for impleading the
heirs and legal representatives of the deceased as appellants.
4. On objection raised by the plaintiffs/respondent 1st
set by way of rejoinder on 16.08.2016, the learned First
Appellate Court fixed the date on 04.06.2016 for orders on the
application filed by the defendants/appellants. Thereafter, the
defendants/appellants filed an application for setting aside
abatement against appellant no. 5 and limitation petition for
condoning the delay in filing the setting aside abatement against
him. The plaintiffs/respondent 1st set filed its rejoinder
opposing the prayer of the appellants on the ground that the said
appeal has already been abated before filing of substitution
petition and prayer for setting aside abatement.
5. After hearing the parties, learned First Appellate
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
4/9
Court dismissed the petitions for substitution, setting aside
abatement and condonation of delay in filing the setting aside
abatement against deceased Vijay Kumar, vide judgment and
order dated 28.10.2024 passed in Title Appeal No. 70 of 1997
which is under challenged in the instant miscellaneous appeal.
6. The plaintiff/respondent 1st set had filed the suit for
declaration of title and recovery of possession as well as mesne
profit. It is further pleaded that the suit land originally belongs
to Ram Govind Ram and on compromise between two sons in
Partition Suit No. 96 of 1973, the property exclusively allotted
to the share of Mohan Lal, who was coming in peaceful
possession of the aforesaid allotted share. The plaintiffs are
descendants of late Mohal Lal. It is further pleaded that the
house of the defendants is situated over Plot No. 2123, which is
adjacent to the plaintiffs' Plot No. 2124 and in the course of
time, the house of the defendants fell down over the disputed
plot and defendants illgally encroached the same in absence of
plaintiffs. Hence , the plaintiffs filed suit for title and recovery
of possession as well as mesne profit.
7. On summon, all the defendants appeared and filed
their joint written statement and admitted that the disputed plot
originally belonged to Ram Govind Ram, but they have been
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
5/9
dispossessed since 1st January, 1965 and since then, the
plaintiffs are not in possession. The plaintiffs have no title on
the suit land and the defendants have acquired title by adverse
possession. The said suit was decreed on 12.06.1997.
8. Being aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated
12.06.1997 passed in Title Suit No. 346 of 1982 by learned 3rd
Subordinate Judge, Gopalganj, Defendants filed Title Appeal
No. 70 of 1997. It is apparent from the memo of Title Appeal
No. 70 of 1997, five appellants filed the aforesaid title appeal
which was abated for non-substitution of the heirs of appellant
no. 5, namely, Vijay Kumar, which is under challenge.
9. Learned senior counsel submitted that the appeal as
a whole could not be abated as the full brothers of deceased
appellant no. 5 were already on record as appellant nos. 1 to 4,
who represented the estate of deceased. It is further submitted
that the learned trial court failed to consider that if one of the
legal representative of the deceased is on record, the appeal is
not abated for non-substitution of the heirs of the deceased.
Learned senior counsel further submitted that the provision
contained in Order 22 of the C.P.C. are not to be construed as
rigid matter of principle but must ever be viewed as a flexible
tool of convenience in the administration of justice. Laws of
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
6/9
procedure are meant to regulate effectively, assist and aid the
object of doing substantial and real justice and not to foreclose
even an adjudication on merits of the substantial rights of citizen
under personal, property and other laws. Reliance has been
placed in the case of S. Amarjit Singh Kalra (dead) By LRS.
And Others Vs. Promod Gupta (dead) By LRS. and Others
decided on 17.12.2002 by the Apex Court in Appeal (Civil ) No.
1027-1028 of 1992 by the Hon'ble Supreme Court.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for the
plaintiffs/respondents vehemently opposed the prayer for setting
aside abatement. Learned counsel for the plaintiffs/respondent
submitted that the suit was filed by the plaintiffs/respondents for
declaration of title and recovery of possession. The defendants
claimed his title by adverse possession. Therefore, the
defendants
admitted
the
claim
of
the
title
of
the
plaintiffs/respondents. All the five defendants encroached the
land of the plaintiffs/respondent 1st set and the said defendants
filed their joint written statement and all of the defendants
jointly claimed the title by adverse possession.
11. Reliance has been placed in the case of Suresh
Chandra (deceased) through L.Rs. and Ors. Vs. Parasram and
Ors. reported in Manu/SC/0940/2025, wherein the Hon'ble
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
7/9
Apex Court has held that where a decree is joint one and a part
of the decree has become final by reason of abatement , the
entire appeal must be held to be abated. As per the claim of the
appellants, a joint right of the defendants/appellants has proved
by way of adverse possession. Learned counsel submits that the
substitution petition along with setting aside abatement and
limitation petition were filed after 16 years of death of Vijay
Kumar and no sufficient cause or even a reasonable cause has
been shown for condoning the delay of more than 16 years.
Only explanation given in the limitation petition is that the
petitioner had no knowledge about the procedure of law. It is
submitted that since the decree is joint and indivisible, the
appeal against the other appellants also will not proceed and will
have to be dismissed as a result of the abatement of appeal
against the deceased appellant no. 5, Vijay Kumar. Learned First
Appellate Court has rightly dismissed the appeal as incompetent
on the account of abatement against appellant no. 5, Vijay
Kumar.
12. Having considered the submissions of the parties
and materials on record as well as the impugned order, it is
admitted fact that the appellants/defendants accepted the title of
the plaintiffs and claimed that defendants jointly have acquired
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
8/9
title by adverse possession. It is also apparent from the record
that four appellants were alive before the learned First Appellate
Court, but the present appeal has been filed by only two
appellants, namely, Jay Prakash Prasad and Om Prakash Prasad
who were appellant nos. 2 & 4 respectively in Title Appeal No.
70 of 1997. The defendants/appellants jointly claimed adverse
possession. The trial court decreed the suit in favour of
plaintiffs/respondent 1st set which is a joint and inseverable
decree. Since the heirs of deceased Vijay Kumar were not
brought on record for 16 years without any plausible
explanation, the appeal was rightly abated. Since the joint
decree was passed by the trial court and part of the decree has
become final by reason of abatement, the entire appeal must be
held to be abated in view of the pronouncement of the judgment
of the Hon'ble Supreme Court as stated above. Moreover, two
appellants of Title Appeal No. 70 of 1997 have not challenged
the judgment and order of the learned First Appellate Court
which also attained finality against defendant / respondent no. 7
& 8. Therefore, the order passed by the learned First Appellate
Court is not required to be interfered by this Court.
13. Accordingly, this Miscellaneous Appeal is
dismissed having no merit in it.
Patna High Court MA No.962 of 2024(8) dt.09-07-2026
9/9
14. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, shall
stands disposed of.
(Khatim Reza, J)
premchand/U
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review