Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.296 of 2026
CNR No. BRHC011357222025
======================================================
Jay Kumari, Wife of Ramai Ram, Resident of Village- Saidpur, P.S.- Ara
Muffasil, Post- Barka Dumra, District- Bhojpur (Ara). At present member of
Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Ara Sadar, Ara, Bhojpur.
1.
... ... Petitioner/s
Versus
The State of Bihar through the Chief Secretary, Government of Bihar, Patna.
2.
The Additional Chief Secretary, Panchayati Raj Department, Government of
Bihar, Patna.
3.
The Commissioner, State Election Commission, Bihar, Sone Bhawan,
Veerchand Patel Marg, Patna.
4.
The Joint Election Commissioner, State Election Commission, Bihar, Sone
Bhawan, Veerchand Patel Marg, Patna.
5.
The Secretary, State Election Commission, Bihar, Sone Bhawan, Veerchand
Patel Marg, Patna.
6.
The District Magistrate, Bhojpur.
7.
The Deputy Development Commission -cum- Chief Executive Officer (Zila
Parishad), Bhojpur.
8.
The District Panchayat Raj Officer, Bhojpur.
9.
The Sub-Divisional Officer, Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
10. The Block Development Officer -cum- Executive Officer, Ara Sadar
Panchayat Samiti, Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
11. Minta Devi, W/o not known to the petitioner, at present Pramukh of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti. Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
12. Surya Pratap Singh, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present Up-Pramukh
of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti. Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti,
Block- Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
13. Bhagirath Yadav S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
14. Sony Dubey, W/o not known to the petitioner, at presnet Member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
15. Rajendra Paswan, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
16. Anita Devi, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara Sadar
Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Block- Ara
Sadar, Bhojpur.
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
2/10
17. Rita Devi, W/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of ara Sadar
Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Block- Ara
Sadar, Bhojpur.
18. Anshu Singh, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
19. Juli Devi, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara Sadar
Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Block- Ara
Sadar, Bhojpur.
20. Punam Devi, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
21. Ramji Singh, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
22. Saekhan Khatoon, W/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of
Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti,
Block- Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
23. Birendra Kahar, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
24. Hare Krishna Prasad, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of
Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti,
Block- Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
25. Lal Babu Prasad, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
26. Suman Devi, W/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
27. Surendra Singh, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
28. Balram Ram, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
29. Anand Yadav, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
30. Sushila Devi, W/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
31. Sonajhari Devi, W/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
32. Janardan Gond, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
3/10
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
33. Rajesh Singh, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samitui, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
34. Priyanka Kumari, W/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
35. Anand Sharma, S/o not known to the Petitioner, at present member of ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
36. Satyendra Kumar, S/o not known to the petitioner, at present member of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Members of Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, BlockAra Sadar, Bhojpur.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
:
Mr. Shyam Kishore, Advocate.
For the Respondent/s
:
Mr. Shiv Kumar, AC to GA 3
For the Resp. No. 11
:
Mr. Manoj Kumar, Advocate.
For the SEC
:
Mr. Girish Pandey, Advocate.
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. ABHISHEK REDDY
ORAL ORDER
01-10-2026
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
2. Present writ petition has been filed for the
following relief(s):“(i) For issuance of an
appropriate writ in the nature of
CERTIORARI quashing or setting aside
the minutes of meeting dated 17.07.2025
whereby and where under the Respondent
No. 11 has been elected to be Pramukh of
Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Bhojpur in
pursuance of Letter No. 3023 dated
05.07.2025 issued by the Joint Election
Commissioner,
State
Election
Commission, Bihar (Respondent No. 4) in
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
4/10
spite of the stay order of Hon'ble Supreme
Court on the scheduled elections passed
on 19.12.2024 passed SLP (Civil) Diary
No(s). 47916/2024 (Annexure-P/14-A).
(ii) For issuance of an
appropriate writ in the nature of
CERTIORARI quashing or setting aside
the minutes of meeting dated 11-01-2025
(Annexure-P/9) communicated to the
District Magistrate, Bhojpur by the
Executive
Officer
-cumBlock
Development Officer, Ara Sadar, Bhojpur
(Respondent No. 10) by which second No
Confidence Motion has been passed
against the Petitioner, which is against
the order dated 17.09.2024 passed in SLP
No. 12490 of 2024 (Annexure P/3) and
15.01.2025 passed in SLP (C) Diary
No(s). 672 of 2025 (Annexure - P/10) by
Hon'ble Supreme Court and Memo No.
1376 dated 23.01.2025 communicated to
the entire District Magistrates, Deputy
Development Commissioners cum- Chief
Executive Officers, Zila Parishad and
District Panchayat Raj Officers, Bihar by
the Panchayati Raj Department issued
under signature of Joint Secretary,
Panchayati Raj Department, Government
of Bihar (Annexure – P/13).
(iii) For issuance of an
appropriate writ in the nature of
MANDAMUS commanding and directing
the Respondent Authorities to allow the
Petitioner to perform the duties as an
elected office bearer on the post of
Pramukh, Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti,
Block-Ara Sadar, Bhojpur in pursuance of
order dated 17.09.2024 i.e. AnnexureP/3.
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
5/10
(iv) For issuance of any other
appropriate writ / writs, order/orders,
direction / directions for which the writ
petitioner would be found entitled under
the facts and circumstances of the case.
(v)
For
appropriate
writ
issuance
in
the
of
an
nature
of
MANDAMUS commanding and directing
the Respondent Authorities to hold a fresh
special meeting for consideration of No
Confidence Motion against the Petitioner
in pursuance of order dated 10.02.2026
passed in SLP(C) No. 942 of 2025.
”
3. The prayer sought for by the petitioner in I.A. No.
02 of 2026 is as follows:“(vi)
appropriate
For issuance
writ
of
an
in the nature of
Certiorari quashing or setting aside the
minutes of meeting dated 23.05.2026
whereby No Confidence Motion has been
passed against the petitioner.”
4. The prayer sought for by the petitioner in I.A. No.
03 of 2026 are as follows:“(vii) For issuance of an
appropriate
writ
in
the
nature
of
Certiorari quashing or setting aside the
Memo No. 11140 dated 29.07.2026
(Annexure-P/23)
issued
by
the
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
6/10
Respondent No. 2 whereby he was
pleased to direct the Respondent No. 6 to
appoint the Respondent No. 11 namely
Minta Devi as Pramukh of Ara Sadar
Panchayat Samiti, Ara Sadar, Bhojpur.
(viii)
appropriate
For
writ
issuance
in
the
of
an
nature
of
Certiorari quashing or setting aside the
Memo
No.
(Annexure-P/22)
dated
05.08.2026
issued
by
the
Respondent No. 6 whereby he was
pleased to appoint the Respondent No. 11
namely Minta Devi as Pramukh of Ara
Sadar Panchayat Samiti, Ara Sadar,
Bhojpur in pursuance of Memo No. 11140
dated 29.07.2026.”
5. Bereft of details, it is the case of the petitioner that
the petitioner was elected as Pramukh of Ara Sadar Panchayat
Samit, Block-Ara Sadar, Bhojpur in the year, 2021. That based
on the requisition dated 26.09.2024 (Annexure-P/5) made by
some of the members of the Panchayat, a meeting of No
Confidence was fixed on 11.01.2025. That on 11.01.2025 the
motion of No Confidence was passed against the petitioner and
the petitioner was removed from the post of the Pramukh and
the Respondent No. 11 herein i.e. Minta Devi has being elected
as the Pramukh. That persuant to the directions of this Court in
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
7/10
CWJC No. 296 of 2026 dated 12.05.2026, a special meeting of
No Confidence was fixed on 23.05.2026 vide notice dated
16.05.2026. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that out
of the total 27 members of the Ara Sadar Panchayat Samiti,
Block Ara Sadar, Bhojpur at Ara, only 16 members had attended
the meeting convened on 23.05.2026. That the authority has
manipulated the minutes of the meeting dated 23.05.2026
(Annexure-P/21=Annexure-R/U) and even though in the said
meeting one of the members, namely, Sahkhan Khatoon did not
attend the meeting, her signature was entered subsequently.
6. Learned counsel has drawn the attention of this
Court to the Annexure-P/21 filed along with the I.A. No. 02 of
2026 and submitted that the authorities have initially marked ‘X’
against the name of Sahkhan Khatoon, however, subsequently
signature of the said person is taken. Learned counsel has
submitted that due to the said manipulation, the vote of no
confidence was passed against the petitioner. Learned counsel
submits that out of the total 27 members, only 16 members
attended the meeting and in case, the vote of Sahkhan Khatoon
is not taken into consideration, the 2/3rd majority as mandated
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in interim order dated
17.09.2024 in SLA (C) No(s) 12490/2024 passed by the
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
8/10
Hon’ble Supreme Court (Rashmi Singh Vs. The State of Bihar
& Ors.) will not be met. Learned counsel has, therefore, prayed
this Hon’ble Court to allow the present writ petition and set
aside the minutes of the meeting dated 23.05.2026 and the
removal of the petitioner from the post of Pramukh and also the
subsequent election held by the authority in which Respondent
No. 11 was elected.
7. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf
of the Respondent-State has vehemently opposed the very
maintainability of the present writ petition. Learned counsel has
stated that the petitioner by a majority of 16 votes out of the
total 27 members was removed from the post of Pramukh. That
the petitioner having lost the confidence of majority of the
members should not try to hang on to the said post. Learned
counsel submits that there is absolutely nothing on record to
substantiate the allegation made by the petitioner. Learned
counsel submits that once the said person has signed on the
minutes of the meeting, the validity or otherwise of the said
signature cannot be challenged in the present writ petition.
Further, the learned counsel submits that there is nothing on
record to show that the said person has not signed on the
minutes of the meeting or any affidavit filed by the said person
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
9/10
substantiating the claim of the petitioner. Learned counsel has,
therefore, prayed this Hon’ble Court to dismiss the present writ
petition.
8. The facts in question are not in dispute, the only
issue that remains to be resolved by this Court is as to whether
the signature of Sahkhan Khatoon has been taken subsequently
or not. To substantiate the allegation of the petitioner, that the
signature of one of the Panchayat Samiti Members, namely,
Sahkhan Khatoon was taken subsequently after it was marked as
‘X’, the least that was expected by the petitioner was to file an
affidavit of the said person stating that she had not signed the
minutes of the meeting or her signature was subsequently
obtained after the meeting was concluded. However, in this
case, the petitioner for reasons best known to her has not filed
any affidavit to the said effect. In absence of any statement by
the said person the allegations of the petitioner cannot be gone
into.
9. Having regard to the above, this Court does not find
any merit in the present writ petition which warrants any
interference by this Hon’ble Court. Further, it is to be noted that
the term of the office of the Pramukh will end in the month of
December, 2026 and even for the sake of argument if all the
Patna High Court CWJC No.296 of 2026(12) dt.01-10-2026
10/10
contentions of the petitioner are accepted as correct, no useful
purpose would be achieved if the minutes of the meeting are set
aside except satisfying the ego of the petitioner.
10. Having regard to the above, the present writ
petition stands dismissed, however, without costs.
(A. Abhishek Reddy, J)
shakir/U
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review