Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH: AMARAVATI
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.3453, 3507 & 3435 OF 2025
% Dated 19.02.2026
CRP No.3453 of 2025 & 2 other CRPS
# Jasti Satyavati,
w/o Srinivasa Rao,
aged about 54 years, occ: Household,
r/o K. Rajupalem village, Ballikuruva Mandal
Prakasam District
….. Petitioner
Versus
Bollepalli Suresh Babu,
s/o Venkata Rao, aged about 42 years,
occ: Business,
R/o Ananthavaram Village, Yaddanapudi Mandal,
Prakasam District & 5 others
…. Respondents
JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED ON: 19.02.2026
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Whether Reporters of Local newspapers
may be allowed to see the Judgments?
Whether the copies of judgment may be marked to
Law Reporters/Journals
Whether Their Ladyship/Lordship wish to see the fair
copy of the Judgment?
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
+ HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.3453, 3507 & 3435 OF 2025
% Dated 19.02.2026
CRP No.3453 of 2025 & 2 other CRPS
# Jasti Satyavati,
w/o Srinivasa Rao,
aged about 54 years, occ: Household,
r/o K. Rajupalem village, Ballikuruva Mandal
Prakasam District
….. Petitioner
Versus
Bollepalli Suresh Babu,
s/o Venkata Rao, aged about 42 years,
occ: Business,
R/o Ananthavaram Village, Yaddanapudi Mandal,
Prakasam District & 5 others
Counsel for the petitioner
Counsel for Respondent
<GIST:
> HEAD NOTE:
? Cases referred
:
:
…. Respondents
Mr. Nalluri Madhava Rao
-
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.3453, 3507 & 3435 OF 2025
COMMON ORDER:
1.
All these three civil revision petitions under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India are filed challenging the orders passed by the
Principal
Junior
Civil
Judge,
Addanki,
Prakasam
District
in
I.A.Nos.179, 177 & 178 of 2025 in O.S.No.133 of 2012 dated
23.07.2025.
2.
O.S.No.133 of 2012 is filed for declaration of passage rights of
plaintiff to reach Z Z1 marked bazaar through X series passage and
for granting consequential permanent injunction in favour of plaintiff,
restraining the defendants and their men, from in anyway interfering
with ‘X’ series passage right of plaintiff to reach Z Z1 marked bazaar
and to award costs of the suit.
3.
The petitioner herein is the plaintiff and the respondents are
defendants in the suit. For the sake of convenience, the parties are
herein referred as arrayed before the Court below.
4.
During hearing, Sri Naga Praveen Vankayalapati, learned
counsel for the petitioners/plaintiff submits that, D.W.1 acquired
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
adjacent property to X series passage under Ex.B-1 basing upon the
VRO Certificate dated 26.05.2011. With malice intention, D.W.1 got
executed sale deed in his favour more than the property what was
held by his vendor and also mentioned different survey number which
was neither acquired nor owned otherwise by the vendor of D.W.1
nor himself and no link document was filed to that effect. It is the case
of D.W.1 in his cross-examination that no certificate was issued by
the Tahsildar in respect of common passage of X to X-3 and further
contended by the plaintiff in his evidence that the alleged certificate
issued by the VRO is not a valid certificate and the same was not
issued by following due procedure as contemplated. He asserts that,
after completion of plaintiff evidence, he got secured the certificate
issued by the Tahsildar dated 01.04.2020 which reveals that the
recitals of Ex.b-1 were drawn with an intention to encroach X series
passage without there being any title or possession held by the
vendor of D.W.1. He argues that the plaintiff also obtained copy of
ROR – Meeseva copy and Adangal to show that the subject X-series
property of D.W.1 is not covered under house property. Therefore,
the ROR – Meeseva copy and Adangal copy in respect of subject
survey number were procured after completion of plaintiff evidence.
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
Therefore, the certificate issued by the Tahsildar, ROR – Meeseva
copy and Adangal issued by the revenue authorities are crucial
documents to prove the case of the plaintiff, as such, filed I.A.No.179
of 2025 under Order VII Rule 14(1) and Section 151 C.P.C praying to
receive the certificate issued by the Tahsildar dated 01.04.2020, ROR
– Meeseva copy and Adangal copy; and filed I.A.No.177 of 2025 and
I.A No.178 of 2025 respectively, to reopen the evidence of P.W.1 and
recall P.W1 for further examination, in order to mark the certificate
issued by the Tahsildar on his behalf.
5.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, if the Hon’ble
Court did not allow these petitions, the petitioner/plaintiff will suffer
irreparable loss and hardship and consciously created right while
drawing the recitals of Ex.B-1 without there being any right
whatsoever conferred upon the vendor of D.W.1.
Therefore, the
reasons assigned by the Court below in dismissing I.A.Nos.179, 177
& 178 of 2025 in O.S.No.133 of 2012 dated 23.07.2025 i.e. to receive
the certificate issued by the Tahisldar office dated 01.04.2020, ROR
Meeseva Certificate, adangal copy; recall and reopen the evidence of
P.W.1 by speaking order without proper reasons and by way of
docket orders respectively, is erroneous and contrary to law.
6.
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
He further submits that, the petitioner/plaintiff is entitled to file a
petition under Order VII Rule 14(1) C.P.C at any point of time,
particularly, even after completion of defendants evidence and the
said documents were procured considering the evidence of D.W.1, as
such, the same should be received and marked by allowing other
petitions. He further submits that, the Court below went on the
premise that the said documents were filed with so much of delay and
when the matter was posted for arguments and filing these petitions
is only to drag on the matter is certainly contrary to the plea of the
plaintiff and also facts on record, as such, the orders passed by the
Court below in I.A.Nos.179, 177 & 178 of 2025 in O.S.No.133 of 2012
dated 23.07.2025 are liable to be set-aside in the interest of justice.
7.
Heard learned counsel for the petitioner and perused the
material available before this Court.
8.
Admittedly, O.S.No.133 of 2012 is filed in the year 2012 and
still the suit was not determined by the Court below, for the reasons
best known to the parties therein. But, the factor to be considered
before this Court is that, more than 13 years has elapsed after filing
the suit and still it is pending for final determination. As per the orders
of the Court below in I.A.No.179 of 2025 in O.S.No.133 of 2012 dated
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
23.07.2025, the matter was posted for arguments on 03.12.2024 after
completion of evidence of both the parties. The entire claim of the
plaintiff in I.A.No.179 of 2025 is that, he has procured a certificate
dated 01.04.2020 issued by Tahsildar concerned and he also
obtained
ROR
Meeseva
certificate
and
adangal
copy
after
completion/adducing his evidence, as such, he is unable to mark the
said documents to prove his case. The fact remains that the matter
was posted for arguments after completion of evidence on both sides
but the plaintiff has been dragging the matter without arguing the
mater on many occasions even though it is coming for arguments and
finally got filed these civil revision petitions after the matter is posted
for arguments on 03.12.2024.
The said action of the plaintiff is
certainly in support of the finding of the Court below that to drag the
matter for one reason or the other.
9.
On perusal of the affidavit and counter affidavit filed by both the
parties as well as arguments canvassed by both the parties before
the Trial Court, it is observed that the contention of the plaintiff that
Ex.B-1 sale deed of D.W.1 was intentionally drawn to encroach X X-3
common passage to reach to Z Z-1 main bazaar/panchayat main
road without there being any rights whatsoever held by his vendor to
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
alienate the subject property appears to be valid in the absence of
link document of D.W-1. The said Ex.B-1 said to have been drawn
basing upon the certificate issued by the VRO dated 26.05.2011,
thereby, the plaintiff extensively canvassed that the defendant/D.W.1
could not get any rights in respect of common passage marked as
X - X-3 series under the guise of certificate of VRO dated 26.05.2011
which is not a valid certificate is valid and sustainable ground for the
reason that the VRO is neither authority nor the custodian of any
record, but he is only an assistant to the competent authority.
10.
Whereas, as per settled Latin legal maxim "nemo dat quod non
habet" means "no one gives what he does not have". It is a
fundamental legal rule, often called the nemo dat rule, which states
that a buyer cannot acquire a better title to the property than the seller
had. In simpler terms, if a person does not legally own something,
they cannot sell it to someone else and give that new person legal
ownership of it. The rule is the basis for the principle of derivative title,
meaning a buyer's ownership right comes from the seller's ownership
right and cannot be more than that.
11.
As contended by the plaintiff, VRO is not the competent
authority to issue any such certificate and he can only assist the
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
competent authority in processing the file and issuance of certificate
by the Tahsildar, therefore, as per law, the certificate issued by the
VRO which is the basis for Ex.B-1 admittedly is not a valid certificate
as per law. Therefore, the same is neither admissible document nor
any inference can be drawn.
12.
In view of the settled proposition of law, D.W.1 neither can get
any title nor any rights in respect of X X-3 common passage, since his
vendor did not possess any rights over the subject property. The
basis of certificate of VRO is not a valid one, therefore, the Court
below certainly will consider these aspects since the same were
argued and urged by the plaintiff and adduced in his evidence.
Therefore, for proving the well said proposition of law, the claim of the
plaintiff to mark the additional documents is not at all necessary, the
Court below should be allowed to proceed further in accordance with
law only. The plaintiff cannot presume that the court below would not
consider the well settled proposition of law as mentioned above, on
perusal of the order of the Court below, the Court below expressly
opined that there is no necessity of marking of documents which were
proposed through these petitions. Once the plaintiff already
canvassed about the legality of issuance of certificate by VRO and
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
also the rights of the vendor of D.W.1, therefore, the Court below
keeping in mind regarding the above well settled principle of law and
rightly dismissed the petitions on the ground that the documents are
not at all necessary for determination of issue before the court which
were already canvassed by both the parties at length.
13.
For the reasons stated above, the orders passed by the
Principal
Junior
Civil
Judge,
Addanki,
Prakasam
District
in
I.A.Nos.179, 177 & 178 of 2025 in O.S.No.133 of 2012 dated
23.07.2025 neither suffers from any perversity nor malice and does
not warrant interference by this Court.
14.
In the result, civil revision petition are dismissed. No costs.
15.
Consequently, miscellaneous applications pending if any, shall
stand closed. No costs.
_____________________________________
JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
Dated: 19.02.2026
Note: LR Copy to be marked
SP
NV,J
CRP_3453_2025 & batch
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE VENKATESWARLU NIMMAGADDA
CIVIL REVISION PETITION Nos.3453, 3507 & 3435 OF 2025
Dated: 19.02.2026
W
Note: LR Copy to be marked
SP
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review