Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------W.P. (C) No. 01 of 2018
Shri Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa,
S/o late Dawa Tshering Sherpa,
Resident of Dharey, Jawbari,
P.O. Damthang and P.S.Namchi,
South Sikkim.
…. Petitioner
versus
1. Smt. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa,
Wife of late Lakpa Temba Sherpa,
Resident of Dew Damthang,
P/o Damthang, P.S. Namchi,
South Sikkim.
2. Additional District Collector,
Office of the District Collectorate,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
3. District Collector,
Namchi, South Sikkim.
…. Respondents
--------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 read with Article 227 of the
Constitution of India.
Appearance:
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa and Mr. Jushan Lepcha, Advocates for
the Petitioner.
Mr. William Tamang, Legal Aid Counsel for the Respondent
No.1.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Government Advocate with Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for the StateRespondent nos. 2 and 3.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
JUDGMENT
(16.04.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The present Writ Petition assails the order dated
14.05.2015
passed
by
the
Additional
District
Collector/Magistrate (Respondent No.2) directing the record of
rights for plot no. 233/234 at Damthang Block (the said plots)
to be corrected in the name of the Respondent No.1 after the
expiry of three months from the date of the order. The
Petitioner was granted the said three months to approach the
appropriate forum for relief against the said order. Thereafter,
a notice dated 18.03.2016 was issued to the Petitioner by the
Respondent No.2. The notice stated that the Respondent No.1
had by a petition dated 02.03.2016 requested for mutation of
the said plots in her name. Respondent No.2 issued the notice
to
the
Petitioner
requiring
him
to
submit
order
from
appropriate forum or else it was proposed that mutation
process would be started from 31.03.2016 for the said plots.
This notice dated 18.03.2016 is also impugned. Aggrieved
thereby the Petitioner filed Title Suit No. 1 of 2016 before the
Court of the Civil Judge, South Sikkim at Namchi. A counterclaim praying for declaration that the Respondent No.1 was
the owner of the said plots had also been filed. However, on
31.08.2017 the suit was withdrawn with liberty to the parties
to file afresh. Thereafter the present Writ Petition was filed by
the Petitioner on the ground that question of title has to be
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
decided by Civil Courts and not by Executive Magistrates. The
Petitioner therefore prays for setting aside the impugned order
dated 14.05.2015 and notice dated 18.03.2016. The above
factual matrix is asserted in the Writ Petition.
2.
The Respondent No.2 and the District Collector of the
South District at Namchi (Respondent No.3) have jointly filed a
counter-affidavit. The said
counter-affidavit narrates
the
factual details of the passing of the order dated 14.05.2015
and notice dated 18.03.2016. It is stated that the Respondent
No.1 filed a complaint to the Panchayat President and Member
of 38-Damthang Gram Panchayat Unit (GPU), South Sikkim
stating that the said plots were gifted to her as “Daijo” by one
Norbu Sherpa on 07.05.1980 but the said “Daijo” land was
subsequently registered in the name of the Petitioner. The
Panchayat President and Members of 38 Damthang GPU vide
letter dated 10.09.2013 forwarded the matter to the SubDivisional Magistrate, South Sikkim stating that the dispute
between the parties could not be settled. On 12.09.2013 the
complaint
was
registered
as
Misc
Case
No.5/13.
The
Respondent No.2 thereafter, directed the concerned Revenue
Officer/Supervisor to verify the records of the said plots and
submit a report as to how the said plots were mutated in the
name of the Petitioner. On 25.10.2013 the Respondent No.2
received
a
report
from
the
Revenue
Inspector/Revenue
Supervisor stating that the mutation records/file in favour of
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
the Petitioner was not traceable. On verification it was found
that the mutation of the said plots were carried out from
Norbu Sherpa to Dawa Tshering Sherpa vide O.O. No.
373/AD(S) dated 11.03.1985 and thereafter it was mutated in
favour of the Petitioner from Dawa Tshering Sherpa vide O.O.
No.128/DC(S) dated 05.07.1993. However, the name of the
Respondent No.1 was found recorded in the remarks column
as having got “Daijo” in the computerised land record of the
said plots. The Respondent No.2 thereafter issued summons to
the Petitioner as well as the Respondent No.1 directing them to
appear before him on 21.11.2013. During the proceedings it
was found that the said plots were found mutated in the name
of the Petitioner without the consent of the Respondent No.1.
The counter-affidavit filed by the Respondent Nos.2 and 3
further states that the said plots “belong to Respondent No.1
since the same was received by her as “Daijo” from Norbu
Sherpa in the year 1980 and it was wrongly mutated in the
name of the Petitioner.” It is averred that in order to ascertain
the facts of the case two witnesses viz. Pema Ongchu Sherpa,
resident of Damthang-W1 and Sriman Chettri, resident of
Damthang-W2 were also examined. Pema Ongchu Sherpa
stated on affidavit that in the year 1977 late Norbu Sherpa had
gifted the said plots measuring approximately 5 acres to her
adopted granddaughter i.e. the Respondent No.1. The said
witness also deposed that in the year 1978 Dawa Tshering
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
Sherpa made the Respondent No.1 her sister and gifted the
said plots to her. Thereafter, she had settled in Dew, Namchi,
South Sikkim. Sriman Chettri stated that she knew the
Respondent No.1 who once resided in the land of Norbu
Sherpa (Darey Bajey) and she had left the place twenty years
ago.
3.
The counter-affidavit of the Respondent Nos.2 and 3 also
states that on 14.5.2015 three issues were framed as under:
“(i)
was the land in question i.e. plot no.233/234 under
Damthang block, South Sikkim given as “Daijo” to the
FIRST party?
(ii) whether with the mere abandonment of land the right
of the FIRST party is extinguished?
(iii)
whether FIRST party is entitled to correction in
records of rights of plot no.233/234 under Damthang
block, South Sikkim?”
4.
The counter-affidavit of the Respondent Nos.2 and 3
further avers that with regard to issue no.(iii) it was found that
the mutation order transferring the said plots to the Petitioner
should not have been executed without the No Objection
Certificate from the Respondent No.1 as it was given as “Daijo”
to the Respondent No.1 by late Norbu Sherpa and therefore the
record of rights was liable to be rectified in favour of the
Respondent No.1. It is stated that the Respondent No.2 heard
the matter in the presence of the Petitioner as well as the
Respondent No.1 and the order dated 14.05.2015 was passed
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
after considering the facts, statements and affidavits of the
witnesses. It is also stated that it was only after a lapse of ten
months thereafter that the Respondent No.2 issued the notice
dated 18.03.2016 for mutation of the said plots.
5.
The Petitioner has filed a rejoinder to the counter-affidavit
filed by the Respondent No.2. It is submitted therein that the
order dated 14.05.2015 and notice dated 18.03.2016 are illegal
and without jurisdiction.
6.
The Respondent No.1 has also filed a counter-affidavit. It
is stated that Dawa Tshering Sherpa, father of the Petitioner
left his native place Dharey Jaubari, Damthang, South Sikkim
and started living along with his wife in Nepal where the
Petitioner was born. The Petitioner’ father expired in Nepal.
After the demise of her parents’ Respondent No.1 started living
with late Norbu Sherpa (grandfather of the Petitioner) until his
death in the year 1983. Respondent No.1 took care of Norbu
Sherpa until his demise as she would have her own parents.
She made every effort to keep Norbu Sherpa happy during his
last moments. Due to her untiring love, care and support
Norbu Sherpa gifted the
said plots as “Daijo” to the
Respondent No.1 in the presence of witnesses. The document
granting “Daijo” was submitted at the office of the Respondent
No.2 and 3. She had constructed a “kacha” house on the said
plots. Norbu Sherpa lived there till his demise in the year
1983. However, since the said plots were not suitable for
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
cultivation the Respondent No.1 temporarily shifted her
residence to Dew, Damthang, South Sikkim in the year 1992
where she started working as a labourer at Public Works
Department, Government of Sikkim due to her poverty. Taking
advantage of this the Petitioner in her absence transferred and
mutated the entire landed property of late Norbu Sherpa in his
name without following due procedure. When she came to
learn about the illegal transfer in the year 2013 she made a
complaint before the Respondent Nos.2 and 3. This complaint
was entertained.
7.
The Petitioner filed a rejoinder to the counter-affidavit
filed by the Respondent No.1 in which the assertion that Norbu
Sherpa had given “Daijo” of the said plots to Respondent No.1
has been denied. It is also denied that the Respondent No.1
has constructed the house therein. It is averred by the
Petitioner that the property was duly mutated in the name of
the Petitioner and that the order dated 14.05.2015 and notice
dated 18.03.2016 are wholly without jurisdiction, null and
void.
8.
Heard Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, learned Counsel for the
Petitioner,
Mr.
Karma
Thinley
Namgyal,
learned
Senior
Government Advocate for the Respondent No.2 and 3 and Mr.
William Tamang, learned Legal Aid Counsel for the Respondent
No.1.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
9.
On 25.01.2018 this Court issued notice upon the
Respondents and stayed the order dated 14.05.2015 passed by
the Respondent No.2. On 27.08.2018 this Court directed the
Respondent No.3 to file a detail affidavit pointing out the law
as well as the procedure followed while examining issues
pertaining to issuance of “parcha” or correction/rectification or
cancellation thereof applicable in Sikkim.
10. Pursuant thereto the Respondent No.3 has filed an
affidavit. It is stated that the procedure as envisaged under the
Registration
of
Document
Rule,
are
followed
for
registration of landed property in Sikkim. Once registered
necessary rectification is carried out in the “khasra” (sale from
one individual to another individual) and thereafter a “parcha”
is issued. “Parcha” is issued after registration of the landed
property is complete and mutation is carried out in favour of
the buyer. Prior to such registration a spot verification is
carried out by the concerned amin and a report thereof is
submitted to the revenue section of the District Collector. No
Objection Certificate from the immediate neighbours is also
obtained followed by the No Objection Certificate from the
families of the seller. As far as correction of record of rights is
concerned, no separate law or rules are presently in force
which
authorises
the
Additional
District
Collector/Sub-
Divisional Magistrate to rectify/correct the land records. The
Kotha Purnu or Dru Deb and Attestation Rules, 1951
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
published in the Sikkim Darbar Gazette dated October, 1951
has been repealed by the Sikkim Record Writing and
Attestation Rules, 1988 which came into force on 09.09.1988.
A copy of the said rules has been annexed to the said affidavit.
It is stated that the cadastral survey operation of 1978-82 was
conducted under the Kotha Purnu or Dru Deb and Attestation
Rules, 1951 as the land record has been prepared in
accordance with the provisions contained therein.
11. The Sikkim Agricultural Land Ceiling and Reforms Act,
1977 (14 of 1978) (the said Act) came into force on 22.06.1978
on the issuance of Notification No.3/LR dated 22.06.1978
published in the Sikkim Government Gazette No.86 on the
same date in exercise of the powers conferred by Section 1 (3)
of the said Act.
12. The Sikkim Record Writing and Attestation Rules, 1988
(the said rules) has been made in exercise of the powers
conferred by clauses (1), (j) and (m) of sub-section (2) of
Section 36 of the said Act.
13. The said rules came into force on 09.09.1988. The said
rules deals with preparation and revision of record of rights
(rule 3 (1) to rule 3 (5)); carrying out of survey and
preparation
of
survey
maps
(rule
4(1)
to
rule
4(9));
preparation of “khasra” (rule 5(1) to rule 5(28)); preparation
of “khatian” (rule 6(1) to rule 6(12)); attestation (rule 7(1) to
rule 7(10)); appeal and correction of record of rights (rule 8(1)
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
to rule 8(5)); assessment of land rent (rule 9(1) and rule 9(2));
completion of survey operation and repeal of the Record
Writing or Kotha Purnu or Dru-deb and Attestation Rules,
1951 (rule 11).
14. Under the scheme of the said rules the preparation and
revision of record of rights is undertaken as detailed in rule
3(1) to rule 3(9). The process of preparation of “khasra” (or
index register to the block maps) is undertaken as provided
under rule 5. The “khasra” is required to be prepared in
a
form containing various particulars i.e. the name of the block,
elakha, district, year of survey (in Christian as well as in
Vikrama era), the name of the surveyor, head surveyor, survey
inspector and the date of commencement and completion of
the survey; plot number corresponding to the map; name of
the locality; approximate altitude of the plot in meters;
numbers of terraces or “Garas” comprising the plot; name,
parentage, cast and address of the “Bustiwala”.
15.
While preparing the “khasra” under rule 5 of the said
rules, rule 5(2) provides that “on establishing the ownership of
the claimant, the surveyor shall cause entry in the relevant
column of the khasra”.
16. Rule 5(3) to rule 5(5) deals with disputes at the time of
preparation of the “khasra”. While preparing the “khasra” if
any dispute arises the procedure to be followed is provided in
rule 5 of the said rules.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
17. Rule 5(6) of the said rules provide that “in case of entry of
sale or gift, a valid registered deed shall be demanded and
entry shall be made accordingly and registration number thereof
shall be shown in the remarks column against the plot number
under sale or gift.”
18. Rule 6 of the said rules provide the method for
preparation of the “khatian” (record of rights). Rule 6(1) deals
with the particulars required while preparing the “khatian”.
Rule 6(3) provides that “a parcha in respect of an individual
land holder shall be issued after having checked by the head
surveyor and the inspector respectively.”
19. Rule 6(4) provides that “on completion of preparation of
land record of rights, the surveyor shall issue the parcha to the
concerned Bustiwala in presence of the members of the
Panchayat after duly obtaining the receipt in that behalf from
Bustiwala concerned.”
20. Rule 8 provides for appeal and correction of record of
rights. Under Rule 8(1) of the said rules “if any person is
aggrieved by any decision of the Revenue Officer, he may prefer
an appeal to the tribunal constituted under Section 13 of the Act
within thirty days from the date of such decision.”
21. The order dated 14.05.2015 records that the said plots
were found recorded in the name of the Petitioner in the
“record of rights”. It is further recorded that as per the office
records the said plots were mutated in favour of Dawa
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
Tshering Sherpa from late Norbu Sherpa in the year 1985 and
thereafter in favour of the Petitioner in the year 1993.
22. The Respondent Nos.2 and 3 has also filed copies of the
“parcha khatians” regarding the said plots. The first “parcha
khatian” filed records the name of Norbu Sherpa son of Rinzing
Sherpa in the column of the name of the “Bustiwala”. In the
remarks column there is an entry in Nepali which translated
records “house-Daijo Phurba Lhamu Sherpani wife of Lhakpa
Temba Sherpa”. The said “parcha khatian” bears signature of
the surveyor dated 07.05.1980. It seems that this “parcha
khatian” was prepared under the Kotha Purnu or Dru-deb and
Attestation Rules, 1951 which was in existence till 09.09.1988
when the said rules were enforced.
23. The second “parcha khatian” (computerised record of
rights) records the Petitioner as the owner. Amongst the
various plots shown owned by him against the said plots in the
remarks column the same endorsement showing the house as
“Daijo” to the Respondent No.1 is recorded. The second
“parcha khatian” is dated 22.10.2013. However, it is unclear
as to whether the “parcha khatian” was prepared or the
computerised record of rights was obtained on the said date.
24.
The third “parcha khatian” is in the name of the
Petitioner which relates to plots number 237, 238, 243 and
244. The third “parcha khatian” does not have the plot
numbers 233 and 234 in it. However, against plot number 243
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
once again in the remarks column there is mention of “Daijo”
of the house in favour of the Respondent No.1. There is no
clarification regarding this.
25. The counter-affidavit filed by the Respondent Nos.2 and 3
makes it clear that the complaint by the Respondent No.1 was
entertained by the Respondent No.2 in the year 2013.
The
Respondent No.1 enquired from the Panchayat President as to
how the said plots had been mutated in the name of the
Petitioner although they were gifted to her by her uncle on
07.05.1980. As the Panchayat could not answer this question
it
was
forwarded
to
the
Sub-Divisional
Magistrate
on
10.09.2013 pursuant to which a case was registered and
summons issued to the parties. When the complaint was thus
taken cognizance of by the Respondent No.2 the said rules
were in force. At that time, it is quite clear, the “parcha
khatian” in favour of the Petitioner had already been prepared.
Under the said rules the “parcha khatian” in favour of the
Petitioner had to be prepared under rule 6 on the basis of the
“khasra” prepared under rule 5 thereof. Under the scheme of
the said rules once the record of rights has been prepared and
issued under rule 6(3) and 6(4) if any person is aggrieved by
any decision of the Revenue Officer he may prefer an appeal to
the tribunal constituted under Section 13 of the said Act
within thirty days from the date of such decision under rule 8.
The term “Revenue Officer” has been defined in rule 2(p) to
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
mean any officer appointed by the Government under subsection (3) of Section 19 of the said Act. Section 19 of the said
Act falls under chapter III relating to preparation of record of
rights. In exercise of the powers conferred by sub-section (1)
of Section 13 read with sub-section (2) of Section 13 of the said
Act the State Government issued Notification No.15/LRD (S)
dated 16.08.95 constituting the tribunal for hearing appeals
under section 13 of the said Act and appointed the Joint
Secretary to the Government of Sikkim in the Land Revenue
Department as the sole member of the tribunal. Admittedly
and it is also evident that the Respondent No.1 has not
resorted to rule 8 of the said rules.
26. The Respondent No.1 had however, approached the
Panchayat who endorsed the complaint to the Sub-Divisional
Magistrate which was taken cognizance of by the Respondent
No.2.
27. The Respondent No.2 after taking cognizance of the said
complaint seem to have taken evidence and thereafter come to
the conclusion that the said plots had in fact been gifted to the
Respondent No.1 by one Norbu Sherpa. The Respondent No.2
has recorded in the order that the Respondent No.1 has prayed
to the Court that the land in question be transferred to her as
she has received the same from Norbu Sherpa in the year 1980
and it was wrongly mutated in the name of the Petitioner.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
28. The Respondent No.2 after a detailed examination of the
witnesses decided the first issue in the following manner:“It is clear to me from the statement of both the parties and
witness that the land was indeed gifted to the First Party by
one Norbu Sherpa. The Second party has not denied the
anything in this regard. The second party has stated that it
was gifted but the First Party has abandoned the land in year
1992 and thus due to this act by abandonment, the right of
the First party over the land is extinguished. It is also amply
clear from the records of right that the land was indeed given
a “Daijo”to the First Party by Norbu Sherpa.”
29. The second issue was decided by holding that the
Petitioner having failed to produce the No Objection Certificate
from the first party before the mutation there were few
shortcomings in the office procedure adopted. It was also held
that mutation in favour of the Petitioner could not have been
done without the consent of the Respondent No.1 in view of the
entry “Daijo” in the remarks column of the “parcha khatian”.
30. The third issue related to a pertinent question as to
whether the Respondent No.1 was entitled to correction in the
record of rights of the said plots. The Respondent No.2 decided
the said issue holding:“In deciding Issue No.3, it appears to me that clearly the
mutation order transferring the land to the Second Party with
respect to the above land should not have been executed
without the NOC from the First Party. Since the land was given
as Daijo to the First Party by Late Norbu Sherpa and since
Norbu Sherpa has long expired, the land is to be mutated in
the name of the First Party after his death since it is clear that
the said land was given to the First Party by Norbu Sherpa.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
Therefore records of rights are to be corrected in favour of the
First Party.”
31.
The Respondent No.2 has neither adverted to the said
rules nor drawn power from it or from any other law while
passing the order dated 14.05.2015. Neither the counteraffidavit filed by the Respondent Nos.2 and 3 nor the affidavit
dated 05.03.2019 filed by the Respondent No.3 reveal as to
whether the said rules were at all followed by the Respondent
No.2. The Respondent No.2 has acted as a Court and passed
orders as a Court. The records, however, reveal that the
Respondent No.2 was totally unaware of the source of his
power. If the Respondent No.2 was aware of the said rules he
ought to have known the limitations prescribed therein and
followed the prescribed procedure, if applicable. The counteraffidavit filed by the Respondent No.2 is completely silent on
what procedure was followed.
The Respondent No.2 was
definitely not exercising its limited powers under the provisions
of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Cr.P.C.). The said
rule does not reflect any role of the Respondent No.2 in its
scheme unless he was acting as a Revenue Officer. However,
no notification has been placed by the Respondent No.2 and 3
bringing on record any appointment order by the Government
under the said Act.
The Respondent No.2 and 3 have not
pleaded that the Respondent No.2 was exercising powers of a
Revenue Officer as appointed by the Government under subsection (3) of Section 19 of the said Act.
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
32. Transfer of property is regulated by the Transfer of
Property Act, 1882 which is enforced and applicable in Sikkim.
The preparation of the record of rights is mainly for the
purpose of ascertaining the ownership of the agricultural lands
and quantum of revenue payable by the owner for the
purposes of the said Act. Section 25 (1) of the said Act provides
that every person shall be liable to pay revenue to the State
Government for the lands allowed to be retained by him within
the ceiling limit. While preparing the “khasra” under rule 5 of
the said rules the surveyor is required to establish the
ownership of the claimant. It is only after establishing the
ownership that the surveyor shall cause entry in the relevant
column of the “khasra” as required by rule 5(2).
For the
limited purpose the surveyor can examine the issue of
ownership. The finding of the surveyor or the other authorities
under
the
said
rules
regarding
the
ownership
of
the
agricultural land for the purpose of preparation of the “khasra”
however, cannot be considered the final determination of title
of immovable property. For the determination of title of
immovable property the parties must approach the civil Court
of appropriate jurisdiction.
33. A perusal of the records placed reveal conflicting claims
of title between the Petitioner and the Respondent No.1. The
only document relied upon are the “parcha khatians”. The
Respondent No.1 has claimed that the said plots were gifted to
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
her as “Daijo” and that the said document was submitted at
the office of the Respondent No.2 and 3. However, neither the
copy nor the original was placed before this Court by the
Respondents. Contrary thereto in the remarks column of the
“parcha khatian” there is mention of only a house being given
as “Daijo” to the Respondent No.1. With these uncertain facts
and serious disputes regarding the title of the said plots it was
incumbent upon the Respondent No.2 to have directed the
parties to the civil Court for the determination of the title of the
said plots.
34. The order dated 14.05.2015 passed by the Respondent
No.2 also suffers from non application of mind for not having
even bothered to consider what was the applicable law and
whether he had the power and jurisdiction to decide the issue
before him.
35. The Petitioner as well as the Respondent No.1 is at liberty
to approach the right forum for appropriate relief if advised.
The opinion expressed by this Court regarding the facts and
documents placed before this Court in this judgment is only
for the purposes of determining whether the order dated
14.05.2015 and notice dated 18.03.2016 passed by the
Respondent No.2 were liable to be set aside. This Court makes
it clear that the prima facie opinion so expressed regarding the
materials available shall not in any circumstance be used in
W.P. (C) No 01 of 2018
Jangpu Sherpa @ Jampu Sherpa v. Phurba Lhamu Sherpa & Ors.
any proceeding instituted for determination of the title of the
said plots.
36. The Writ Petition is allowed. The order dated 14.05.2015
as well as the notice dated 18.03.2016 passed by the
Respondent No.2 are therefore set aside. No order as to costs.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
16.04.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review