Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 33
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 161 of 2023
Date of Decision: 02.05.2024
Shri. Jamshed Ali
S/o (L) Asmotulla,
Resident of village & P.O. New Bhaitbari,
P.S. Phulbari, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
-Vs1.State of Meghalaya represented by the
Commissioner and Secretary Education,
Government of Meghalaya, Shillong
2.The Director of School Education &
Literacy, Meghalaya, Shillong
3.The Sub-Divisional School Education
Officer, Dadenggre, West Garo Hills
4.The Accountant General (A&E)
Meghalaya, Shillong
5.The Treasury Officer, West Garo Hills,
Tura, Meghalaya
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Applicant(s) : Mr. S.A. Sheikh, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mrs. N.G. Shylla, Sr. GA with
Ms. Z.E. Nongkynrih, GA(For R 1-3,5)
Mr. K. Kharmawphlang, Adv. (For R 4).
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
The brief facts are that the petitioner a retired Government Teacher,
on the demise of his first wife namely one Smti. Saleka Khatun, who was
entered as a nominee in his pension papers had contracted a second
marriage to one Smti. Alima Khatun, and an application was made before
the respondent No. 3, for change of nomination in the pension papers. The
same being rejected vide the impugned letter dated 10.01.2022, the writ
petitioner is before this Court with the instant writ petition.
2.
Mr. S.A. Sheikh, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted
that, the return of the application by the impugned letter dated 10.01.2022,
was on the ground that the Meghalaya Civil Service (Pension) Rules 1983,
particularly Note-2 of Rule 48 of the said Rules, did not recognise family
pension to post retiral spouses of persons who retired before 01.01.2007.
He submits that the ground taken is incorrect, inasmuch as, Rule 48 has
since been amended vide a Notification dated 04.11.2010, wherein at Note2 of the said amended rules, provisions had been made for payment of
family pension to post retiral spouses. It has further been submitted that, in
the event of the petitioner’s death and if the name of the second wife is not
entered as nominee, grave injustice will be caused to her. The learned
counsel has then placed the following decisions in support of his case, and
submits that by virtue of the ratio of the said cases, the instant case is also
covered.
(i)
Smti. Tipmon Lyngdoh vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
(2016) SCC OnLine Megh 260 : 2017 Lab IC 559
(ii)
Smti. Nanji T. Sangma vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.
(2016) SCC OnLine Megh 259: 2017 Lab IC (NOC
74) 25.
3.
Mrs. N.G. Shylla, learned Senior Government Advocate appearing
for the State respondents No. 1-3 and 5 has relied on the affidavit and
submits that as the petitioner had retired on 30.06.2002, before the
amendment including post-retirement spouses came into effect from
01.01.2007, the petitioner will not be covered by the said amendment.
4.
Mr. K. Kharmawphlang, learned counsel for the respondent No. 4
has submitted that due to the stand taken by the State respondents, and by
application of the relevant pension rules and Office Memorandum, the case
cannot be settled by the said respondents, and that acceptance or rejection
of such pension cases, is dependent on the provisions of the Rules and
orders framed and amended by the Government of Meghalaya from time to
time.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties. The only issue it can be
seen is with regard to the applicability of the amendment to Rule 48 of the
Meghalaya Civil Service (Pension) Rules 1983, which allows family
pension to post retiral spouses. The amended Rule 48 for the sake of
convenience is reproduced herein below.
“7. Amendment of Rule 48:- (1) Rule 48 (i) of the Principal
Rule shall be renumbered as “48(1)” and substituted by the
following:“48 (1) For the purpose of this rule, family shall include the
following relatives of the Government servants:“(a) First Category:(i)
Widow or widower, up to the date of death or remarriage, whichever is earlier;
(ii)
Son/daughter including widowed daughter up to
the date of his/her marriage/re-marriage or till
the date he/she starts earning or till the age of
twenty five years, whichever is earlier.
Note 1 : (ii) above will include legally adopted
sons/daughters.
Note 2 : Post-retiral spouses/children born after
retirement:- The family pension is admissible to postretiral spouses and children born/adopted legally after
retirement.”
6.
The amended Rule therefore, has clearly provided for post retiral
spouses to be admissible for payment of family pension. Though the
question has been raised as to applicability, the judgments of this Court, as
cited by the counsel for the petitioner will essentially cover the instant case,
inasmuch as, as quoted in the said judgment, the Supreme Court has held
that, pension is payable and had struck down the part of the rule which
excluded the marriage after retirement from the defination of ‘Family’. In
this context, the judgment of this Court in the case of Smti. Tipmon
Lyngdoh vs. State of Meghalaya & Ors.(supra), at Para – 13, had held as
follows.
“13. The Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of ‘Smt. Bhagawanti’
(supra) dealt with the issue of family pension and struck down the part
of the rule which excluded the marriage after retirement from the
definition of “family”. The Court considered the question whether the
spouse-man or woman, as the case may be-married after the retirement
of the concerned Government servant can be kept out of the definition
so as to deprive him from the benefit of the family pension. It was held
by the Supreme Court as under:“8. Admittedly, the definition of ‘family’ as it stands after
amendment excludes that the scope of the Government servant after
his/her retirement and the children born after retirement also
stands excluded. Petitioners have challenged the stand of the Union
of India and the definition in the Pension Rules as arbitrary and
discriminatory. It has been contented that if family pension is
payable to the widow or the husband as the case may be, of the
Government servant, the category which the definition keeps out,
namely, those who have married after retirement and offsprings of
regular marriage born after retirement, is discriminatory.
9. Pension is payable, as pointed out in several judgments of this
Court, on the consideration of past service rendered by the
Government servant. Payability of the family pension is basically on
the self-same consideration. Since pension is linked with past
service and avowed purpose of the Pension Rules is to provide
sustenance in old age, distinction between marriage during service
and marriage after retirement appears to be indeed arbitrary. There
are instances where a Government servant contracts his first
marriage after retirement. In these two cases before us, retirement
had been at an early age. In the Subedar's case, he has retired after
putting in 18 years of service and the Railway employee had retired
prematurely at the age of 44. Premature or early retirement has
indeed no relevance for deciding the point at issue. It is not the case
of the Union of India and, perhaps there would have been no force
in such contention if raised, that family pension is admissible on the
account of the facts that the spouse contributed to the efficiency of
the Government servant during his service career. In most cases,
marriage after retirement is done to provide protection, secure
companionship and to secure support in old age. The consideration
upon which pension proper is admissible or the benefit of the family
pension has been extended do not justify the distinction envisaged
in the definition ‘family’ by keeping the postretiral spouse out of it.
10. Government Servants' Conduct Rules prohibit marriage during
the life-time of a spouse. Section 494 of the Penal Code, 1860
makes second marriage void and makes it a criminal offence.
Thereafter, both before retirement and even after retirement there is
no scope for a person to have a second wife or a husband, as the
case may be, during the lifetime of an existing spouse.
11. Reliance has been placed on the recommendations of the Third
Pay Commission on the basis of which the amendment in the
Pension Rules is said to have been made. Apart from referring to
the recommendations, no attempt has been made at the hearing by
counsel for the Union of India to drive support from the
recommendations. We really see no justification as to why postretirement marriage should have been kept out of the purview of the
definition.
12. In clause (ii) of the definition son or daughter born after
retirement even out of wedlock prior to retirement have been
excluded from the definition. No plausible explanation has been
placed for our consideration for this exclusion. The purpose for
which family pension is provided, as indicated in Smt. Poonamal's
case (AIR 1985 SC 1196), is frustrated if children born after
retirement are excluded from the benefits of the family pension.
Prospect of children being born at such advanced age (keeping the
age of normal superannuation in view) is minimal but for the few
that may be born after the retirement, family pension would be most
necessary as in the absence thereof, in the event of death of the
Government servant such minor children would go without support.
The social purpose which was noticed in some pension cases by this
court would not justify the stand taken by the Union of India in the
counter-affidavit. It is not the case of the Union Government that as
the matter of public policy to contain the growth of population, the
definition has been so modified. Even if such a contention had been
advanced it would not have stood logical scrutiny on account of the
position that the Government servant may not have any child prior
to retirement and in view of the accepted public policy that a couple
could have children up to two, the only child born after
superaanuation should not be denied family pension.
13. Considered from any angle, we are of the view that the two
limitations incorporated in the definition of ‘family’ suffer from the
vice of arbitrariness and discrimination and cannot be supported by
nexus or reasonable classification. The words ‘provided the
marriage took place before retirement of the Government servant’
in clause (i) and ‘but shall not include son or daughter born after
retirement in clause (ii) are thus ultra vires of Article 14 of the
Constitution and cannot be sustained.”
7.
Accordingly, in line with the judgments of this Court and the
Supreme Court, it is held that the objection raised as to the inclusion of the
petitioner’s second wife name in the pension papers as a nominee is
unsustainable, and the restrictive clause is read down.
8.
The respondents are therefore directed to accept the application of
the writ petitioner for inclusion of the name of his post retiral spouse into
the pension papers as a nominee, for receipt of family pension.
9.
Writ petition as ordered above is allowed and disposed of.
Judge
Meghalaya
02.05.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review