Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.02
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.352/2021
Date of Order: 25.04.2022
Jalesh Kumar & anr
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioners
: Mr. M. Chanda, Adv with
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv
For the Respondents
: Dr. N. Mozika, ASG with
Ms. S. Rumthao, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The matter pertains to the perceived anomaly in the pay-scale
offered to the Assistants, who occupy a civilian post in the Assam Rifles.
There is no dispute that since 2008 all posts in Assam Rifles and other
Central paramilitary organisations have been combatised and the civilian
cadre of Assistants in Assam Rifles will die out in the next few years.
2.
The present writ petition arises out of an order of December
21, 2018 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati
Bench on a petition of several persons who occupied the post of
Assistant in Assam Rifles. The principal case carried out to the Tribunal
was that since the duties and responsibilities of Assistants across the
Central paramilitary forces were equal, there ought not to be any
disparity in the pay and emoluments between persons in the Assistant
cadre in one Central paramilitary organisations and the members in the
similar cadre in another.
3.
This is the second round of litigation between virtually the
same parties, though the Union insists that several of the original
petitioners have abandoned the cause and the matter be confined to only
the two petitioners who are before this Court pursuing the grievance
while the others are deemed to have resigned to their fate and accepted
the order of the Tribunal or the previous rejection of their requests at
various levels. By the order impugned, the Tribunal has held that since
Assistants in Assam Rifles, historically, did not have the same payscales as Assistants in other Central paramilitary forces, parity in pay-
scale could not be sought with the other civilian Assistants in
comparable organisations.
4.
Under the Third Central Pay Commission, while the Assistants
in Central Industrial Security Force, Indo-Tibetan Border Police,
Sashastra Seema Bal and Border Security Force were granted a payscale of Rs.425-800, Assistants in Assam Rifles were granted a payscale of Rs.425-700. Again, the Fourth CPC granted a pay-scale of
Rs.1640-2900 to Assistants in the four other Central paramilitary forces
but granted only Rs.1400-2300 to Assistants in Assam Rifles. The Fifth
CPC continued the distinction as Assistants in the other four paramilitary
forces had their pay-scale revised to Rs.5500 to 9000 while Assistants in
Assam Rifles were recommended to receive Rs.4500-7000.
5.
It does not appear that the duties and obligations of civilian
Assistants in the other four comparable paramilitary forces are any
greater than or different from the duties and responsibilities of the
civilian Assistants in Assam Rifles. Indeed, as would be evident from a
recommendation of July 5, 2004 made by the Director-General of Assam
Rifles to the Union Home Ministry, the same pay-scale as extended to
Assistants in the four other paramilitary forces was demanded to be
made effective for Assistants in Assam Rifles.
6.
Paragraphs 2 and 5 of the recommendatory letter of July 5,
2004 may be noticed:
“2. It appears that our above proposal mixed up with
consolidated proposal submitted subsequently vide our letter
No. A/1-A/2787-86/492 dated 02 Feb 2001 seeking up
gradation of pay scale of Assistant to Rs.5500-9000 at par with
the other CPOs and also for upgradation of pay scale of
Superintendent and AO/AAO/RO/CGO.”
“5. In view of the above it is strongly recommended that
Assistant of this Directorate may please be granted at least the
revised pay scale of Rs.5000-8000/- wef 01-1-96 as per part
‘B’ of the first schedule of CCS(RP) Rules, 1997, pending
finalisation of upgradation of pay scale of Assistant, Supdt and
AO/AAO/RO/CGO at par with other CPOs as mentioned in
para 2 above. This would reduce the financial hardship being
faced by the Assistants to a great extent.”
7.
It is apparent from a plain reading of the relevant letter of July
5, 2004 that the DGAR required the same pay-scale as in respect of other
paramilitary forces to be extended to the Assistants in Assam Rifles.
Such a recommendation could not have been made without the DGAR
acknowledging and accepting that the duties and responsibilities of the
personnel in the four other paramilitary forces and the duties and
responsibilities of Assistants in the civilian cadre in the Assam Rifles
were the same. Indeed, as would be evident from the fifth paragraph of
the letter quoted above, though a stop-gap arrangement was suggested
under which the Assistants in Assam Rifles would, at least, be granted
the pay-scale of Rs.5000-8000, the recommendation or the demand
remained that they should be given the pay-scale of Rs.5500- 9000.
8.
The Ministry of Home in the Union government acceded to the
request made by way of a stop-gap arrangement and, by its letter of
March 30, 2005, agreed that Assistants in Assam Rifles be granted the
pay-scale of Rs.5000-8000 with effect from January 1, 1996, but
notionally. The actual financial benefits of the upgraded pay-scale were
to be received from the date of issuance of the letter. In other words, all
benefits of the upgraded pay-scale could be obtained by persons in the
civilian post of Assistant in Assam Rifles with effect from March 30,
2005.
9.
The recommendation to permanently bring the pay-scale of
Assistants in the civilian post in Assam Rifles cadre at par with the
Assistants in other Central paramilitary forces, was finally rejected by
the Union Home Ministry’s letter of September 26, 2006 on the grounds
that a recent upgradation had been effected in March, 2005 and that the
civilian post of Assistant in Assam Rifles had been declared a dying
cadre. Significantly, it was not indicated in the relevant letter rejecting
the proposal of DGAR that the duties and responsibilities of Assistants
in Assam Rifles were any different from those of the comparable
employees in the other Central paramilitary forces. The letter of rejection
also required Assam Rifles to pursue the case with the Sixth CPC which
had then not finalised its recommendations.
10.
The
petitioners
submit
that
even
though
a
detailed
representation was made before the Sixth CPC, the matter was not
alluded to by such commission and the demand for upgradation of payscale stood rejected without specific reference to the representation made
by the concerned employees.
11.
It was in such circumstances that several of the Assistants
occupying the only civilian post in Assam Rifles carried a challenge to
the Central Administrative Tribunal seeking parity in pay with similar
employees in other Central paramilitary forces. Such petition came to
be, in effect, rejected by an order of Central Administrative Tribunal,
Guwahati Bench of March 4, 2011. The 57 petitioners before the
Tribunal were given liberty by the relevant order to “make appropriate
representation before the anomaly committee for upgradation of the
scale of pay”.
12.
Such order of March 4, 2011 came to be assailed in this Court
by way of a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
petition was allowed by setting aside the order of the Tribunal and by
directing the matter to be considered afresh. The order of this Court of
November 22, 2016, inter alia, noticed a judgment reported at (2008) 1
SCC 586 (Union of India v. Dineshan K. K.) and the principle of equal
pay for equal work that was accepted by the Supreme Court in such
judgment.
13.
It is on the basis of this Court’s order of November 22, 2016
that the matter went back to the Tribunal for its fresh consideration. By
the judgment and order impugned dated December 21, 2018, the
Tribunal has rejected the claim, primarily on the ground that,
historically, there has always been a difference in the pay-scale
pertaining to civilian Assistants in Assam Rifles and the pay-scale
offered to Assistants in the other Central paramilitary forces.
14.
In course of the judgment, the Tribunal noticed the differences
in the pay-scales for Assistants in the other paramilitary forces on the
one hand and Assistants in Assam Rifles on the other, beginning with the
recommendation of the Third CPC. The Tribunal held that it was for the
employer to decide to what extent the pay of an employee should be
increased and, unless the consideration in such regard was shown to be
completely arbitrary and having no nexus with the matter, a Court or
Tribunal would not be minded to interfere therewith. The Tribunal
referred to a Madras High Court judgment of November 24, 2010
pertaining to All India Radio and Doordarshan Technical Personnel. The
Tribunal ruled that the dictum in the relevant judgment was founded on
the fact that there was always a pay parity between the comparable posts
and, it was such pay parity that was restored upon discovering that the
pay-scale in one of the posts had been increased and the similar benefit
not extended to another comparable post.
15.
The Tribunal also referred to the decision in Dineshan K. K.
but found that the ratio decidendi therein would be inapplicable because
of the historical disparity between the pay-scale granted to Assistants in
Assam Rifles and the higher pay-scale for Assistants in the other Central
paramilitary forces as in the present case. The Tribunal referred to the
initial pay-scale of Rs.425-700 under the Third CPC and observed that
since the pay-scale of the comparable employees in the other Central
paramilitary forces was then Rs.425-800, there was no error or anomaly
in the Assistants in Assam Rifles drawing less pay than their
counterparts in the other Central paramilitary forces.
16.
It is necessary in the present context to notice paragraph 27 of
the judgment in Dineshan K. K.:
“27. Thus, the short question requiring our consideration is
whether having admitted in their affidavit referred to
hereinabove, the “apparent disparity” and “anomaly” in the pay
scales of Radio Mechanics, the administrative authorities, the
petitioners herein, could be permitted to perpetuate apparent
discriminatory differentiation in the pay scales because of the
disparity in prerevised and revised scales of the personnel of
Assam Rifles prior to the recommendations of the Fourth Pay
Commission, irrespective of the identity of their powers, duties
and responsibilities with other paramilitary forces. In our
considered opinion, in view of the total absence of any plea on
the part of the Union of India that Radio Mechanics in other
paramilitary forces were performing different or more onerous
duties as compared to the Radio Mechanics in Assam Rifles,
the impugned decision of the Government was clearly
irrational and arbitrary and thus, violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution.”
17.
There is no doubt that the Supreme Court noticed that similar
duties and responsibilities were discharged by persons in comparable
posts across all Central paramilitary forces and found that in case of
Radio Mechanics in Assam Rifles there was no “plea on the part of the
Union of India that Radio Mechanics in other paramilitary forces were
performing different or more onerous duties as compared to the Radio
Mechanics in Assam Rifles ...”.
18.
In the present case, implicit in the recommendation of the
DGAR of July 5, 2004 was the acceptance that the duties and
responsibilities and the work performed by the Assistants in Assam
Rifles were similar to those discharged by the Assistants in the other
Central paramilitary forces. Indeed, that must be seen to be the basis for
the DGAR recommending and demanding the same pay-scale for
Assistants in Assam Rifles as Assistants were granted in the other
paramilitary forces. As noticed earlier in this judgment, the letter of July
5, 2004 required a lower pay-scale of Rs.5000-8000 be extended to
Assistants in Assam Rifles till a final decision in such regard was taken.
The fifth paragraph of the relevant letter quoted above merely required
an ad-hoc enhanced pay-scale to be offered and the letter must be seen in
its entirety wherein the recommendation was for the same pay-scale to
be offered to Assistants in Assam Rifles as granted to the Assistants in
the other Central paramilitary forces.
19.
However, the Union Home Ministry accepted the ad-hoc
enhanced pay-scale suggested and, by its letter of March 30, 2005,
arbitrarily fixed the increased pay-scale of Rs.5000-8000 to apply
notionally from January 1, 1996, but actually from the date of the letter.
Thus, the Assistants in Assam Rifles got a limited benefit prospectively
and were denied the benefit prior to the date of issuance of the letter
without any cogent ground being indicated in such regard or as to why
the increase would operate prospectively for them and not when the
increase had applied in respect of similar posts in the other Central
paramilitary organizations.
20.
It is further evident from the subsequent letter of the Union
Home Ministry of September 26, 2006, by which the recommendation of
the DGAR to upgrade the pay-scale of Assistants in Assam Rifles at par
with the pay-scale of other similar employees of Central paramilitary
forces was rejected, that such rejection was merely on the ground that
the civilian post of Assistant in Assam Rifles was a dying cadre. In
neither the original letter of March 30, 2005 nor in the final rejection of
the recommendation of the DGAR in the subsequent letter of September
26, 2006 did the Union Ministry of Home indicate that the duties and
responsibilities of Assistants in the other paramilitary forces were more
than those of the Assistants in Assam Rifles. To such extent, the fact that
the ground of disparity in work was never cited as the reason for the
lower pay-scale granted to Assistants in Assam Rifles, the plea is not
available any more. The Union cannot now be permitted to urge or
speak of any distinction between the responsibilities and duties
discharged by Assistants in other Central paramilitary forces and those
discharged by Assistants in Assam Rifles.
21.
However, it is submitted on behalf of the Union that the
continuing Assistants in other Central paramilitary forces may not be
engaged in a civilian post and such post may have been combatised.
22.
There is no doubt that no non-combat Assistant could be
recruited in Assam Rifles or in any of the paramilitary forces since 2008
in view of the instructions issued by the Union Home Ministry to the
Central paramilitary forces in the year 2008. However, if prior to such
cut-off date, Assistants have been recruited in the civilian cadre in the
other Central paramilitary forces and such earlier-recruited Assistants
continue in the civilian post, then the civilian Assistants in Assam Rifles
should not suffer by being treated differently. If, however, it is
discovered that there was no civilian Assistant in the four other Central
paramilitary forces who had been recruited since 1986, when the
recommendation of the Third CPC came into effect, there may be a
distinction found between the post of Assistant in Assam Rifles and the
similar post in the other paramilitary forces. But, if Assistants continued
to occupy a civilian post in the four other paramilitary forces after the
recommendation of the Third CPC coming into effect from January 1,
1986, the petitioners and all others who were similarly placed, whether
they have retired now or may even have died will be entitled to the same
benefits directly or through their heirs in accordance with law. Since the
pay-scale enhancement to Assistants in Assam Rifles was extended
notionally from January 1, 1996 by the letter dated March 30, 2005 and
actually from the date of receipt of such letter, the parity among
Assistants across all Central paramilitary forces would be deemed to
have been restored on and with effect from March 30, 2005 at the level
of Rs.5500-9000 with at par subsequent increase such that with effect
from such date there would be no discrimination in the pay-scale
applicable to the Assistants in Assam Rifles and the pay-scales of
civilian Assistants in the other Central paramilitary forces. This is
because of the dictum in Dineshan K. K. and the fact that, as in that case,
in the present case there is no plea taken by the Union that the duties and
responsibilities of Assistants in Assam Rifles are any different from the
duties and responsibilities of Assistants in the other Central paramilitary
forces.
23.
To clarify, it is reiterated that if the post of Assistant in the
other paramilitary forces was not a civilian post with effect from January
1, 1996, Assistants in Assam Rifles as the present petitioners will not be
entitled to any further benefit; however, if the Assistants in the four other
Central paramilitary forces were also civilian employees as at January 1,
1996, the Assistants in Assam Rifles will be entitled to the same payscale as Assistants in the other Central paramilitary forces with effect
from March 30, 2005. As a consequence, the multiplication factor of
1.86 that would operate in a disparate manner between the Assistants in
the other Central paramilitary forces and the Assistants in Assam Rifles
will no longer remain and the present pay to the serving Assistants and
pensionary benefits to the retired Assistants of Assam Rifles will be
determined on the same basis as of serving and retired Assistants,
respectively, in other four Central paramilitary services.
24.
WP(C) No. 352 of 2021 is allowed to the extent indicated
above by setting aside the judgment and order impugned dated
December 21, 2018 and by substituting the same with the above. Since
the benefit to the petitioners and other similarly placed Assistants in
Assam Rifles, whether serving or retired, would be substantial, no order
is made for costs.
25.
As to the Union’s suggestion that since only two of the original
petitioners stayed back to challenge the order of the Tribunal, the benefit
conferred by this order must be confined only to these two petitioners, it
must be said that the same would be impermissible. What has been
noticed here is the entitlement of Assistants in Assam Rifles as a class.
The effect has been directed to be given from March 30, 2005 in view of
the letter of March 30, 2005 granting a limited increase in the pay-scale
which appears to have been accepted by the Assistants in Assam Rifles.
26.
It has been appropriately pointed out on behalf of the Union
that in the previous round of the proceedings before this Court, the order
of November 22, 2016 had confined the issue to the petitioners who
were before this Court. The following paragraph from operative part of
the relevant order is referred to by the Union:
“In view of the above, this writ petition is allowed to the
extent and in the manner that the impugned order dated
04.03.2011 is set aside; and O.A. No. 273 of 2010 is restored
for re-consideration by the CAT qua the present petitioners.”
27.
There is no doubt that the previous order of this Court of
November 22, 2016 confined the reconsideration to the cases of the
petitioners before this Court. However, no reasons were indicated as to
why the decision would apply to some members of a cadre and not to
other members of a cadre when it was a general anomaly covering all
members of the cadre and not restricted to a few of them. It must also be
remembered that the principle that has developed in service
jurisprudence in this country is that when an individual complaint
pertaining to the special circumstances concerning a particular employee
is carried to a Court or a Tribunal and a favourable order is obtained, the
benefits thereunder would be confined to the individual employee; but
when a grievance carried by one member of a cadre consisting of a large
number of personnel is brought before a Court or a Tribunal concerning
the general interest of all members of the same cadre, the final order
passed would be binding on the employer and the employer would be
obliged to extend the benefits to all persons similarly placed. Indeed,
anything contrary would be in derogation of the philosophy embodied in
Article 14 of the Constitution. At any rate, since the civilian post of
Assistant has been phased out, the cost to the Union would be one-time
and not recurring for other batches.
28.
Accordingly, if the Assistants in the other four Central
paramilitary forces are also found to be civilian employees, then all
Assistants in civilian post in Assam Rifles ought to be extended the same
benefit. However, since it appears that by the letter of March 30, 2005,
for some reason or the other, it was determined that the increase would
be effective from the date of such letter, such aspect of the matter is not
interfered with, though the notional benefit will be available to all
Assistants in Assam Rifles with effect from January 1, 1996.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
25.04.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review